Actions

Work Header

Beloved Fish With Legs

Summary:

Eddie and Jason are out fishing. Well, Eddie is. Jason is just also there.

Things get a little worse when Eddie accidentally catches a fish that isn't a fish at all, resulting in a consequence he and Jason cannot escape from on their own as the mermaids kidnap them and bring them underwater.

Thankfully the mermaids aren't going to eat them! ... Yet.

Notes:

I was thinking about them again.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Eddie… Actually has no idea what in his 21 years of life he did that ended him up on a boat in the middle of the sea with Jason Carver. He didn’t even like Jason all that much. Enough to be acquaintances but nothing close to being actual friends.

To be fair, in their youth they were… less than stellar towards each other. Jason was always so fun to rile up, and Eddie has gone through too many locker pushes and slung words to count.

Yet here they were, sitting on a boat together. Willingly. It was his uncle Wayne’s friend’s boat they were borrowing, Eddie leaning on the metal railing with a fishing pole in his hand.

Yeah, he was fishing, so what? Eddie’s fished ever since he first came to Wayne’s doorstep all those years ago, Wayne showing him how to keep the worm on the hook, how to tease the fish before cranking the reel as fast as his little hands could go to pull  it up.

Back then they didn’t even have a boat. It was just him and his uncle on a dock, pulling up whatever was dumb enough to linger around.

The line tugs, Eddie jolting into action.

Jason, who was just nearby eating a mayo sandwich, sits up. “You finally got something freak?”

Eddie ignores him, still pulling up the fish. The rod tip was bending in a deep arc. It must be huge, whatever he caught. Once he got it on board he’ll toss it back. He’d feel bad being the end of such a huge fish that managed to even grow that size.

Jason leans over the side of the boat into the waters below.

“I don’t see anything,” He says.

Eddie grunts, straining at the force. “No way Watson, really?” He says sarcastically.

Jason rolls his eyes at him. “Don’t use that tone with me Munson.”

Eddie sticks his tongue out at him.

He still doesn’t see anything come up even after a good ten seconds. Eddie tugs the pole again. “Grab the net, Carver! Grab the net!”

Jason wraps his sandwich, if it could even be called a sandwich, in its paper before grabbing the large net that was propped next to him. He dunks it in the water, prepared to net whatever Eddie managed to pull close to the surface.

“I think I see it!” Eddie shouts, a glimmer of something catching his eyes beneath the normal blue of the ocean. “It looks huge!” He didn’t think he’d catch a huge fish, he wasn’t any kind of professional. The lure he was using was pretty basic as well, just some grey jelly thing with a floppy tail he got at the bait shop.

Eddie pulls back on the line once more, the shining scales under the water twinkling for a second. Jason leans forward more, trying to get the net to go around the catch.

“Uh, Munson?”

“What-” Eddie inquires, but he gets his answer soon enough when the boat began to violently rock back and forth. Jason steadies himself on the boat with a long ‘woah’, gripping the net pole by one hand and the boat rail with the other.

Eddie forces himself to rock with the boat as the tugging was getting worse and he didn’t want to lose the rod. He was borrowing it so losing it would be real bad. He pulls at the rod again, hoping that it was just the water rocking and not something like an orca coming to attack them for fun.

The boat continues to rock forcefully. It gets harder to even stand in place, much less keep ahold of the pole. He caught something too huge.

“Munson just cut your losses!” Jason shouts. “I don’t think you’re pulling it up anytime soon!”

Eddie’s arms were shaking by now. He thinks of his choices in a split second. Eddie releases the rod, watching it sail overboard into the water. The force of the rocking finally knocks him onto his back, Jason still clinging to the rails.

“You alright there?” He asks, Eddie nodding as he shoves an arm behind his head to keep it from smacking against the wall.

The boat eventually quells its rocking after what felt too long for the both of them. Eddie pushes himself up into a sitting position, feeling his head for any damage. He felt fine save for the light throbbing.

Jason drops the net and kneels in front of Eddie, worried. “Maybe we should head back to shore now. The weather must be getting worse or something.”

“I lost the rod…” Eddie mumbles.

“So? It wasn’t like you were pulling it up anyways.” Jason stands up, looking carefully over the edge. “It’s still sunny out, did we catch ourself in some ocean rip?” He questions.

“We’re too far from shore to be in a rip,” Eddie says as he pushes himself up to his feet. “Must have ran over some pod.”

“Pod? Like dolphins? Wouldn’t we have seen them?”

“Or an orca. Whatever it was, we might have caught its pod mate or something and it was retaliating.” Eddie shrugs, making something up. It could be plausible, he wasn’t a marine biologist or anything but he did understand that some sea animals were quite intelligent.

Jason frowns. “Poor orca. We just ran a creature of God over. And now its friend just has a hook in it.” He looks to Eddie. “You’re adding to the pollution to the environment.”

“Wh- You told me to let go!” Eddie exclaims, throwing his hands up in the air.

Jason shrugs, rounding the boat and getting behind the wheel. “Still contributing!” He starts it up and starts driving it back towards the docks.

Eddie rolls his eyes, taking a seat on the bench. “I could call mutiny if I wanted to. Throw you overboard and feed you to the fishes.”

“Yeah?” Jason looks over his shoulder. “Then who’s gonna drive the boat?”

Eddie squints. “I can learn.” Driving a boat couldn’t be too much different than driving a car, right?

Jason scoffs. “I don’t believe you. Besides, do you want to be charged a murderer when I suddenly disappear at sea? It’d sound suspicious, and with your whole… you know.” He waves a hand towards Eddie. “Nobody would prove it different.” Jason says.

Eddie kicks both of Jason’s shin. Jason shoots a glare over his shoulder in return. Eddie grins like a shark.

“Freak.”

“Normie.”

They coast over the water in silence after that, Eddie thinking about what he was going to say to his uncle about the rod. Wayne would forgive him, but Eddie had promised he’d take good care of it.

The boat suddenly rocks again. “What’d we hit this time?” Jason asks. Eddie looks around, but they were still in open waters. There was nothing they could have hit.

“I don’t-”

The boat rocks again, Eddie hearing the sound of something thudding into it from beneath.

Then it settles. The boat resumes gently swaying.

Jason looks around. “Huh, must’ve been a fluke.”

The sun above suddenly disappears, Eddie looking up. He jolts backwards in fear, grabbing onto the metal handles.

“What the hell is that?!” Jason screams, his attention also on the strange silhouette. “Is that a-”

The figure lands on the boat, making it bounce. It looked like a man from the waist up, the lower half covered in rich blue and red scales, the fin of its tail golden with black at the end of it. The fins on its back and sides were a vibrant blue with red splotches on it, a silver ring attached to the dorsal. The tail suddenly dissolves into two thick tanned legs, the man standing up with a wild grin. By pure luck, his hips were covered by shorts.

By sheer misfortune, they were the tightest pair of shorts Eddie has ever seen. He forces his eyes away from the shorts that left nothing to imagination to look up into eyes that were near neon blue.

“Hey.” The strange man greets, still smiling.

Jason is shocked into silence, but he still manages to raise a hand in greeting. Eddie gulps.

The man didn’t seem all that worried on manners, only stepping closer to the two humans. He was still wet, making his skin shiny in the sun. Eddie silently notices that the guy had blue stripes all along his shoulders and down his arm, and red ones on his torso. His legs were a blend of them, making him look almost tiger-like.

“So, you the two idiots that caught a hook in my husband’s back?” His voice goes deep and growly, his eyes narrowing. He’s still grinning despite it, though it felt more predatory.

“Well-” Eddie starts.

Jason, the snitch, immediately points to Eddie. “It was him! He was the one fishing! I had nothing to do with it!”

“Wh-” Eddie twists to stare at Jason, betrayed. “You-”

Jason was pale despite the redness of his cheeks and forehead from the sun, trembling. “So- So whatever you’re doing here do it to him, I had nothing to do with it!”

The man cackles. “Is that so…?” He looks between them, eyes glittering. “Though, I’m pretty sure my starfish told me there were two people hanging out over the side…”

Jason drops his arm. Eddie nervously laughs.

He can’t believe his first ever encounter with a mermaid would end up with being threatened. Didn’t even think they were real. Well, he could imagine them being real, but to actually see them in real life and prove their existence was an entirely different matter.

“Look, it was an accident. Really! So… So can we let bygones be bygones?” Jason clasps his hands together, begging the mermaid who just laughs at him.

“An accident? Hm, I don’t know about that, landie. All I know is that my Stevie was swimming and suddenly he’s gotten a hook to the ass and it’s just yanking him up! You know what that feels like?” He glares at them.

Eddie answers when the mermaid continues to look at them expectantly. “Like being stabbed?”

“And yanked on. You’re lucky it was such a tiny little thing. I’d be a raging barracuda if it tore up his pretty little tail.” He lifts his hair up, and Eddie can see the hook sitting pretty around the part where the ear met the head. The man takes it off, the silver lure still hanging off of it. “Ah, so you recognise this?” He shakes the hook.

“I’m sorry,” Eddie apologises, even though he’s not sure if it would be well received. “But it was an accident- It was! Cross my heart hope to die.”

“Hm, whatever.” The man tosses the hook aside, the lure making it bounce around on the boat. “All I care ‘bout is a little bit of…”

The man suddenly lunges forward, Jason and Eddie scattering in opposite directions. The man stares at them both with a slow turn of his head, laughing lowly. His hands were held like claws, and Eddie’s pretty sure there were sharp nails on them.

“’s just you and me out here, sailor. Open ocean, and the only way out is down. And trust me.” The man sneers. “That isn’t gonna save ya.”

Eddie feels a chill run down his spine. This mermaid meant business, he’s certain of it. He was an okay swimmer, but this was an aquatic creature. It can swim.

He’ll lose the moment he touches the water, he’s certain of it.

The mermaid looks between them again, eyes sharp.

He then lunges for Jason, who screams and sidesteps. The man smashes into the railing, Jason running around the boat and towards Eddie.

The mermaid spins around, licking his teeth and charging once more.

Eddie runs away, Jason right behind him. The man doesn’t seem all that able to take turns easily on the boat. It was their only advantage here.

They keep going back and forth, the mermaid only getting angrier and angrier.

Eddie can’t help but laughs, sticking his tongue out at the mermaid.

He wasn’t watching where he was going though, his foot landing on Jason’s mayo sandwich. Eddie screams as he loses his balance, falling over.

Arms wrap around him, and suddenly he’s airborne again.

Cold water envelops his body as he crashes into the ocean, Eddie sinking downwards. He tries to turn, but the glimpse of something shiny catches his attention.

Something grabs at him. Eddie panics, kicking and flailing desperately to get away from whatever just touched him. It only causes whatever was holding onto him to grip deeper, pain shooting up his arms.

Above him, the water break again with another shadow diving in.

Eddie screams as the swaying lights above him suddenly gets farther away from him much too fast, his head pounding. The other shadow follows after, Eddie getting a glimpse of what could be blond hair.

Bubbles escape past his lips, drifting upwards. Saltwater fills his mouth, Eddie choking on it.

He’s drowning. Eddie wriggles on last desperate time, trying to free himself.

All he hears before it goes dark is amused laughter.


Eddie sits up, panting for breath.

He coughs a few times, wheezing in between.

He felt like he was drowning.

Eddie takes a few more deep breaths, squeezing his eyes shut. It was just a dream, it was just a-

Eddie freezes in place, lifting his head up and looking around.

This was…

This wasn’t his room.

Eddie looks around wildly, looking at the walls that looked like he was staring at the inside of an oyster. It was pearlescent, the wall mostly white with layers of sandy brown and soft blue. The bed he was on was unfamiliar, more a bowl with something spongy in it. He was covered in what looked like seaweed woven together, like this was all some weird ocean themed hotel room. Everything was lit up, but Eddie didn’t see a lightbulb above him at all.

Eddie throws the seaweed aside, wiping his hand on his pants and crawling out of the strange bed. The ground was sand, actual honest to goodness sand.

His shoes were missing, he notices mutely.

Eddie squishes the sand between his toes. It was quite soft. He felt okay to walk along it, looking around the bare room. There was really nothing of note in the room save for the weird bed and the walls, so he goes to what seemed to be the door to leave.

Except there was no knob. Eddie stares at the door, but there was nothing but smooth grain. He runs his hand across the surface, just staring at it.

“I’m dreaming. I’m still dreaming.” Eddie says under his breath. “This is just a weird dream.”

He grabs his side and pinches it hard.

Eddie yelps, letting go. No, this was real.

He was locked in.

Eddie takes a shaky breath in, still petting the door.

“I’m trapped. I’m. Am I dead? Oh I am so definitely dead. I died and my hell is ocean themed.” Eddie takes a couple shaky steps back, grabbing at his hair and tugging. “I’m dead and trapped in ocean purgatory.”

Eddie shakes his head, pacing around the room. “What kind of sick joke is this? Hey, Jesus if you’re listening uh, what the hell man?” He says to the ceiling.

Eddie kicks at the sand. He takes another shaky breath, walking over to the sponge bed and sitting down.

At least hell was soft. That was something.

Eddie groans, folding over and holding his hand in his hands. He knew it, the moment he hit the water he was dead.

They killed him, he’s probably being eaten by them right now. That’s how it went, right? Mermaids dragged their victims down and made a meal out of them. Stories of entire ships disappearing into the waves and hundreds of sailors drowning in the waves below.

And now he was the most recent victim. Him and-

Jason. Was Jason okay? Did he get out alright? He couldn’t tell.

Eddie hopes he did. He didn’t particularly want Jason’s death on his conscience as well.

As he sits there thinking, he hears the sound of sand being pushed.

“Oh, the prisoner’s awake~”

Eddie jerks his head up, looking in the direction of the door. Standing there was a rather short man with freckles littering his body. He was dressed similar to the mermaid Eddie had encountered, though his shorts were a yellow-brown with strange ringed spots on it instead of the vibrant red and blue of the other one.

This must be another mermaid then.

The other mermaid leans against the doorframe, eyes travelling over him. “So, you’re the one that hit Stevie?”

Word travels fast it seems.

The mermaid holds eye contact with him, frowning slightly. “You know, you’re lucky he found you and your friend kind of cute. Otherwise the pod would have been celebrating with fresh dinner.”

Eddie gulps. So it was all true.

His mind soon catches up to him, and Eddie flushes. “Excuse me?”

The man smiles, though it seemed mocking. “You heard me, prisoner. Steve found you cute, so made us put you two in some rooms to recuperate.”

Eddie blinks a few times, mouth hanging open. “So… So I’m not dead?” He asks.

The comment makes the man laugh. “What? I wish you were. But no, you’re just in some underwater cave. Alive. Breathing.” He waves a hand. “You’re like the dolphins and the whales.”

“Underwater?” Eddie repeats. He’s underwater?

The man nods, grinning like a shark. “Yeah. So even if you try to leave, you can’t. Not unless you’re good at ascending from the deep ocean.” The man laughs.

There goes all hope of escape. He’s dead meat either way by the looks of it.

“Oh, don’t look so glum. Steve ain’t mean if he likes you. Bleeding heart, makes him soft sometimes.” The man rolls his eyes. “Don’t know what he sees in you. You’re not particularly pretty to me. But what Stevie says, goes.” The man closer, grabbing Eddie’s hand. “Now come on, the King is waiting.”

Eddie lets out an undignified yelp as he’s suddenly pulled up. Even though the mermaid was shorter than him he still yanked him up with ease, dragging him out of the room. Out of the room it was clear it really was just some cave, Eddie surrounded by rocks. He turns his head to look behind him, balking at the sheer wall covered in rocky outcroppings, shiny white doors plastered at even intervals. It almost looked like a prison of sorts.

His brain again catches up to him. “Hold on, did you say-?”

“Are you deaf? I can’t keep repeating for you forever, prisoner. Now come on, my boy gets cranky if he has to wait any longer.”

Eddie clamps his mouth shut.

They approach the end of the cave, which dips into a large pool of water. Eddie can’t even see into it. He plants his feet into the rough rock.

“Uh-uh, you’re not dragging me down there. No way, no how. No.”

“Ugh, you’re impossible.” The mermaid rolls his eyes. “Fine, if you’re gonna pussyfoot then I’ll ease your fears, ‘kay?” He grabs Eddie’s face.

Suddenly lips smash into his. Eddie freezes, but instead of feeling a kiss he feels warm air suddenly blow into his mouth instead. It tastes heavily of fish. Eddie could gag, but manages to stop himself from throwing up in the other guy’s mouth.

The mermaid pulls away with a sneer, then yanks his arm, Eddie falling forward into the water.

He screams as he hits the freezing cold water, and something grabs at his arm. Something angrily chirps in his ear, Eddie barely able to see in the water before he’s being yanked forward.

Eddie holds his breath as long as he can.

Something smacks the back of his head. He takes a breath in shock. He expects the feeling of drowning again but-

But he’s breathing.

“What?” Eddie says in the water, which sounded like nothing, bubbles rushing out of his mouth and past his face.

There was a rapid clicking noise next to him, like someone was laughing.

Eddie glares into the darkness. He can barely see anything, but he can still make out a silhouette of the mermaid.

Water whips around him, and Eddie just has to trust the mermaid that it wasn’t about to leave him for dead.

In the distance, he sees a strange miracle. It was light, actual light. It looked almost like a castle underwater, lighting up the entire ocean floor. It was surrounded by coral and seaweed that shot up to the sky, Eddie marvelling at the sight.

The closer they got to it, the better Eddie could see his own surroundings. The freckles mermaid was still dragging him along, the spots that Eddie saw on his shorts now covering his shoulders like pads. Up close, the mermaid had orange eyes, vibrant and almost glowing in the darkness.

They soon reach the actual castle , Eddie staring in awe at the size and beauty. He could have never imagined something as grand as this, the castle clearly holding an oceanic theme. There was large bubbles of anemones at the front gate, the mermaid looking at him. He makes another chirping noise that Eddie doesn’t understand before he looks away, mouth just hanging open.

The gate suddenly began drifting down, opening. The mermaid doesn’t even wait for it to open completely, yanking Eddie up and into the gap.

There were so many mermaids. They all gape at the pair, especially at Eddie. Eddie ignores their gazes, the mermaid still dragging him along.

Two mermaids dressed in shell armour nod at him before stepping away from a large double door. For mermaids Eddie’s pretty impressed that everything felt almost human. The mermaid shoves at the door, which swings open and reveals the inside. It led straight into a corridor, but further in Eddie could see a mimicry of stairs, fashioned almost like a mansion on the surface.

Either way, Eddie hasn’t been in something this fancy ever. The mermaid leaves him right at the door, swimming away.

Eddie paddles his way into following. The guards were definitely staring at him funny.

He marvels at the interior. It really was something out of a fairytale, everything an ocean version of what Eddie expected the inside of a real castle would be like.

The mermaid swims to be in front of him, gesturing him to follow. Eddie almost wants to disobey.

Eddie follows the mermaid anyways. He didn’t want to get in trouble. He doesn’t know what the consequence is, and he’d rather not tempt the beasts.

The mermaid guides him through another hall until he stopped in front of another set of doors, pushing it open.

Eddie blinks as he’s shoved into the room, and the water suddenly ceases to exists. Eddie falls over, landing on the ground. Someone laughs, Eddie jerking his head up.

Laying on an absurdly large clam shell was that mermaid who attacked him and Jason, tail draped over the edge.

“Come on, don’t make a fool of yourself in front of the king!” The mermaid shouts, Eddie pushing himself up. He glances behind them, the water cut off like a barrier behind him.

The mermaid that brought him here was floating in mid-air. Eddie is in shock at the sight. He looks at Eddie, smirking.

“Hey, eyes forward, prisoner.” He points his finger back towards the front, Eddie turning around.

The opposite end of the room was set up just like what Eddie expected of a throne room, with a platform raised higher than the floor. There was no stairs nor chairs, the ‘thrones’ replaced by those large clam shells and the platform cut off suddenly at the edge.

There was another mermaid there, staring right at Eddie with a tight expression. His brow was wrapped in gold, shaped like branching coral with shells decorating the right side. His tail was draped over the edge of the shell seat just like the other one.

“Come closer, human.” The king mermaid says, lifting a hand and crooking his finger at him.

Eddie takes a few steps closer. The freckled mermaid follows him, swimming in the air.

The king mermaid leans over the edge of the shell, looking him over. “Seems like you got here fine. Thank you Tommy.”

The freckled mermaid smiles. “You’re welcome Stevie.”

Stevie smiles back at Tommy, which disappears upon looking at Eddie again. “You know why you’re here?”

Eddie shakes his head, though he kind of knows why. Stevie smirks, sitting up more. “Well, I don’t know about you, but my back knows full well why.” He reaches for something in the clam shell before throwing it at Eddie.

It was the fishing rod, the line cut off at the end. Eddie takes a step back before it smacked against his feet.

“Look, uh- Your Highness. It was an accident! Really. I didn’t even think I would hook a mermaid…” Eddie tries to explain it again.

“Well, accident or not, it hurt. You kept tugging that infernal thing.” Stevie crosses his arms, pouting. It was oddly kind of cute, though Eddie says nothing. “Imagine if you had gotten my skin! I would have had you and your companion for dinner.”

Speaking of which- “Where is he?”

Stevie raises an eyebrow. “Where is who?”

“The guy that was with me! Jason.”

“Jason…” Stevie leans on the edge of the shell. “I’ll talk with him later.”

“So he’s alive?”

The king nods. Eddie can’t help but breath a sigh of relief at that.

He looks at the king, not sure whether he should bow or what. Eddie still has one burning question: His fate. “What are you gonna do with me?”

Stevie tilts his head, smiling.

“I think I’m gonna keep you.”

“Wh- What?!” Eddie sputters.

Stevie nods, and he finally comes off the seashell he was laying in, swimming in the air like it was water towards Eddie. His tail was long, like a lung dragon, the thin tail a sunset gold and orange with blue stripes running down closer to his stomach. There were leafy appendages coming off of his body as well, two large ones sprouting from his back.

Eddie is rooted to the ground as the mermaid circles him, one of the appendages tickling his skin.

“You have a cute face when you’re asleep and kind of drowning to death. I think you’d look nice by my side, don’t you think so Tommy?”

Tommy just shrugs in response. “It’s your decision, Stevie.”

“See? So I’m gonna keep you. Your friend too.” Stevie nods to himself, his hands grabbing Eddie’s shoulders. “Besides, it’s payment for hurting me with that nasty hook.”

Eddie is trembling in the mermaid’s grip, the mermaid smiling. “So what do you say, hm? I’ll give you the choice, you want to stay with me?”

Eddie opens his mouth, nervously asking, “What happens if I say no?”

Stevie hums, his hands tightening around Eddie’s shoulder as he leans in. “Then I’ll just eat you right here. Daddy’s awful hungry you know…”

Eddie yanks himself out of the mermaid’s grip, though he near trips himself over Stevie’s tail. “Ea- Then I accept! I’ll stay- Please don’t kill me. I don’t want to be eaten.” He sputters out, pleading for his life. He didn’t want to die by being eaten to death, it wasn’t a pretty thought.

“Mmm, good boy~” Stevie pats at his shoulder, smiling and swimming back towards the shell. “I knew you’d make the right choice. Tommy, take him away. Put him in one of the special rooms. Carol should be around with the other one.” Steve giggles, eyes like crescents. “Let’s hope your little friend says the same. I’d hate to separate friends. I’ll see you later, handsome~” He wiggles his fingers, Tommy grabbing his arms and dragging him backwards.

He’s plunged back into the water, Tommy releasing him just to take his wrist and drag him through.

They pass another mermaid, this one a female. Eddie jolting when he sees Jason being dragged by her. Jason stares back at Eddie in horror, but it was only for a brief moment before they’re separated, Jason disappearing into the strange throne room.

Tommy brings him to the second floor, opening a door. It led upwards, Tommy shoving Eddie in and pointing. Eddie just nods and swims upwards.

He gasps out as he hits open air, pulling himself out of the small pool. Looking around he finds himself in a small room quite similar to the one he woke up in, except there was more things inside. It looked just like a prison cell, now that Eddie looks around, finding a bowl of water that looked to be the toilet system for him in the corner. It was lit up by an unknown source of light as well, Eddie sitting down on the spongy bed.

He takes a shuddering breath in, then lets it all out, crying out.

Eddie was truly and utterly trapped now. He wasn’t getting out.

He already misses his uncle. His friends.

“I-I’m never g-gonna see them again,” Eddie gasps out, curling up.

He sobs some more, until he finally tires himself out.

It wouldn’t hurt to lay down a bit, would it?

Eddie sniffles, laying down on the soft bed.

He stares at the weird pearl walls before his eyes drift shut, unaware of the water entrance being disturbed, someone popping up out of the water.

Chapter 2

Notes:

TW: Cannibalism, Emeto, Non-consensual force feeding, A bit of gore

I went all out oops.

Chapter Text

Steve heaves himself up into the room, shaking off the water from his hair.

The guy was asleep now, Steve slithering over. Why shift into some dumb human legs when he can just slink around? It had its cons of course, but the room was small and the floors smooth, it wasn’t hard to squirm around.

He reaches up, brushing his fingers along the man’s damp hair. Billy had told him his hair puffed up like an anemone when dry. Steve was curious to see it for real. Right now it was still matted against his head, though Steve could see the curls trying to come through.

It was a shame the human was, well, human. If Steve had his way he’d replace those silly human legs with something prettier. Make him a part of the pod. He was no sea witch though.

Steve burbles deep in his chest. Oh, that was a good idea actually.

Steve leans in, pressing a gentle kiss to the man’s lips before turning around, diving back into the water.

Billy was waiting outside the door for him, gnawing at a clam with no success. Billy looks up, smiling as Steve exits the room.

“You know, I don’t have the slightest clue what you see in him, sea star. You know Tommy’s been griping about how we don’t even get to eat him. We specifically went out to go hunting! We got two of them, we might as well have had two of them!”

“I like his face. He’s got a nose just like yours.” Steve boops Billy on the nose, Billy pouting. His nose scrunches up, making Steve laugh softly.

“Does not.”

“Does too! Besides, we can always get more. The surface always has those nasty metal seals full of humans.” Steve swims down to the ground floor, Billy following after. “Carol would love to play siren like we did as fry.”

Billy grunts, swimming ahead of him to look at Steve. “Yeah but they were right there! And-” Billy’s voice gets quieter. “They hurt you.”

Steve is aware of that. His back is still stinging from the hook yanking at his tail plates. Billy had gotten pissed, ramming the boat over and over again. He only stopped because Steve needed help wrenching it out.

Steve didn’t stop his love from taking the humans down into the depths after that. Call it overreacting, but Steve was mad. His father always told him to take whatever he wanted. Don’t let others push you around. Steve took it to heart, taking whatever he pleased. He wasn’t like his father entirely of course, he understood the responsibilities of consent.

Didn’t mean he had to make the choice fair.

It’s what got him the title of king after all.

Seeing the face of the fisherman, Steve had decided that’s what he wanted. He’s done it before, taking pretty humans and keeping them. Steve was a simple mer, when he saw something pretty he wanted it all for himself.

The humans he’s taken before never lived long, not until Steve and his court had gotten a handle on what kept them alive. It was always a shame when Steve visited his latest conquest only to find them drowned or starved in their rooms.

Tommy liked to eat those the best. Said it tasted better when he got to wait for his meals when there was no chance of escape for it. Especially the ones Steve personally liked. Made it special.

Steve didn’t want the waste, so of course he fed his court. His pod came first after all, and Steve wasn’t about to keep a dead body floating about like a maniac.

He reaches out, patting Billy on his arm. “Come on, Billy. Look at them now! One of them is kept safe in his own little spot, and the other is… Well.”

Billy licks at his lips, Steve curling his tail around Billy’s. “Do you think the human will like his first meal with us?”

Billy grins, the tip of his tongue sticking out from between his sharp teeth. “I hope so. We went through all that trouble preparing it.”

“Yes. We went through all that trouble…” Steve glances upstairs.

“So he better love it.”


Nothing has changed.

Eddie sits on the bed, staring at the pool of water.

And staring and staring.

They’ve left him alone, yeah.

But he’s also very much trapped.

Eddie had tried to swim back down, but whatever Tommy had done to him had expired by now. His lung still burned from the attempts.

Eddie kicks at the ground, cursing under his breath. He was wholly trapped here at the whims of what, a king mermaid? He’s trapped because of a royal mermaid. Just his luck. Of course the one time he goes out fishing he ends up pissing off some mythical creature and gets kidnapped with no genuine method of escape.

Just his luck.

And it was so humid in here, too! There was no air conditioner or even a window. Just an enclosed shiny prison with a watering hole, no circulation.

He’s going to die in here, he’s sure of it. Whether or not that king Stevie or whatever said he gets to live, he’s absolutely dying in here.

Eddie flops down, limbs spread out on the ground. He was already getting bored. Wet, hot, and bored.

Eddie snickers to himself. It sounded like the title of a really bad porno.

“What’re you thinking about?”

Eddie screams, pushing himself back with his hands as he sits up.

Poking out of the hole was a girl, hair a strawberry blond. There was a strip of seaweed tying her hair back in a bow, bangs plastered to her forehead and two strands framing her face on either side. She had a sweet face, open and smiling.

“Ah- Uh- Hello?”

The girl waves, supporting herself on the edge. “You must be Steve’s new friend. I’m Chrissy, nice to meet you.” She juts a hand out. Her wrists were wrapped in pearls, her nails pointed.

Despite her claws, her demeanour seemed nice enough. Eddie takes her hand and gives it a firm shake. He’d kiss it like he used to playfully do when he was younger, but he wasn’t sure if he should even do that to her. He wasn’t about to flirt with a mermaid. Once she lets go Eddie speaks up again.

“New friend?” He asks her.

Chrissy tilts her head, lips held in a curious smile. “Are you not? Well, no matter. Steve sent me to fetch you!” She pushes her upper body out of the water, her torso wrapped in more seaweed.

The jacket around her shoulders surprised Eddie more than the mermaid suddenly appearing in the first place. Chrissy seemed to have noticed him staring, tugging her jacket up closer to her body.

“Is something wrong?”

Eddie clamps his mouth shut, shaking his head. “Uh! No, nothing at all!”

Chrissy titters, still holding onto the edge of her jacket. “You must be curious about this.” She pulls at it gently. “It fell in the water. Isn’t it cute?”

Eddie nods.  It actually was kind of cute on her. Eddie gives her the okay sign, Chrissy covering her mouth with another giggle falling out.

“Thank you!” She says. Chrissy grabs at his ankle, tugging lightly. “Now come on, the king is waiting for you to join him for dinner!”

Eddie pulls his foot out of her hand, Chrissy letting it slip out without much fuss. “As much as I would… love to. I can’t breathe down there,” He says, hands together.

Chrissy blinks, her mouth dropping into an O. Chrissy laughs, shaking her head. “Oh! Right, silly me!” She beckons him closer.

Eddie doesn’t kneel down for her immediately. He knows what she’s about to do.

Eddie’s not sure if he can do it again. He’s not against a girl kissing, far from it. It just wasn’t really a kiss. More like conscious CPR.

Well, she is asking him this time. Sort of. He might as well get it over with, Eddie was not spending his time cooped up here because he was afraid of a kiss.

Chrissy makes it quick, at least. She also tastes horribly of fish, Eddie holding back yet another gag. He’d never live it down if he threw up in a girl’s mouth.

She pulls back. “There we go! You should be good!” Chrissy waves her hand at him again before diving down below, Eddie taking a deep breath and diving right after her.

Chrissy is waiting for him outside the room when he finally squeezes himself out. Eddie thinks he likes her better, as she swims and pauses for him to catch up instead of dragging him around like Tommy. Her gold and white tail with those black stripes at the fin sways back and forth as she leads him through the castle and to an open doorframe, the room eerily similar to a dining hall. In the centre was a large flat rock, and coral was hung up above like some chandelier. Steve was ‘sitting’ at the head of the table, Billy at his right.

Like the throne room, it seems this room also ignored all physics. Chrissy swam right by him, settling down by a brown haired mermaid while Eddie stood alone at the entrance. Billy notices him first, waving him over with a smirk.

“Don’t be shy, landie. Take a seat right by the king. Look, we pulled out all the stops.” He points a claw at a smaller stone across from him, apparently the chair Eddie was to use. There was no other stone set down. Where was Jason supposed to sit? Maybe it was on the other side.

Eddie walks closer, gingerly sitting down. Steve smiles at him, Billy nodding in approval before he goes back to knocking the hell out of a clamshell on the rock.

“Nice of you to join us, ‘nemone. Are you hungry?”

In all honesty, he was. He didn’t know how much time had passed, and he was feeling a bit peckish by now. Still, what would a mermaid even serve him? Raw fish? Eddie shakes his head, not really wanting to take a bite out of whatever seafood cuisine the mermaid was about to try to make him eat.

Steve only laughs. “Nonsense. You’re eating.” His face goes serious at the end, Eddie flinching back. Steve puts on a friendly smile right after, patting him on the shoulder. “You’ll like it, I promise. We harnessed the power of the hot spots in the ocean to make the food consumable for humankind! So do not worry your pretty little head.” Steve pats his cheek next, Eddie swatting at him. He was still swatting at the air when Steve grabs his wrist, Eddie freezing up. Steve tuts, shaking his finger.

“Don’t you have respect? Hitting other people, especially me.” Steve shakes his head, muttering, “The disrespect.”

Billy snickers behind the clam that he was now gnawing on. “You should’ve seen him up above, Steve. He’s no fighter, I’ll tell you that.”

“Oh, don’t worry about that Billy. I have enough people fighting for me. Isn’t that right killy?”

Billy beams, slamming the clam on the rock again. “Hell yeah!” The clam finally splits open, Billy shoving his face in and going to town on the innards.

Steve dopily smiles at him, Eddie looking between them with eyes wide.

Well then.

Eddie fidgets in place, his hand still trapped in Steve’s. Billy tosses the empty clam aside, licking the corner of his mouth with a self-satisfied grin. Steve turns back to Eddie, letting go of his wrist.

“Ah, now that I think about it, I don’t know your name. Tell me,” Steve says.

Eddie says nothing, Steve continuing to look at him patiently. Billy glances at him as well, eyes sharp.

Eddie keeps his mouth firmly shut.

After a while Steve shakes his head. “Don’t be shy. I just want to know what your name is. You’re gonna live here, so I deserve to know what to call you.” Steve drifts closer to him, coming up behind him. He points the tip of his tail to Billy. “Here, I’ll introduce everyone else! That’s Billy, my husband.”

“Oh, we’ve met,” Eddie mumbles darkly. Billy winks back at him.

Steve nudges Eddie’s head to look beside him. At the other end of the table was Tommy and the other female mermaid, the mermaid whispering into Tommy’s ear about something that made him laugh. “And you’ve also met Tommy. He’s my best friend since we were fry. Now he heads my own security and hunting party. Next to him is Carol, also a close childhood friend of mine.” Steve turns his head a few degrees, nails digging slightly into his temples. “Chrissy is another friend of mine, but she comes to visit Robin most of the time. They’re close.”

At the sound of her name, the one with the short haircut looks over. She gives a two fingered salute at Chrissy and the brunette before swimming over the table to Steve and Eddie. “You talking about me, Steve?”

“I was just about to actually. Eddie, this is my bester friend. My twin from the clutch, my otter buddy, my-”

“Yeah yeah, think he gets it Steve-o.” She drifts a little closer to Eddie, looking him over with furrowed brows. She smooths it back out a second later and looks back to Steve, pursing her lips together. “You sure you’re keeping this one?”

Eddie’s brow ticks slightly at the tone.

Steve’s hand tighten around Eddie’s head. “Uhh, yeah?” He lets go, Eddie massaging at his sore temples. “He’s pretty to me!”

Robin hums, shrugging her shoulders. “Whatever you say, Steve. He’s alright I guess.”

Steve chuckles a little meanly. “Says you. You prefer ones like Chrissy~” He teases.

Robin sputters, slapping Steve on the shoulder. Peeks over her shoulder several times, cheeks flushing.

Eddie is surrounded by gays.

He is so surrounded by gays.

Eddie keeps silent as the pair bicker over him and ignore his presence entirely. Robin’s tail flicks back and forth in the air, her scales the colour of a goldfish. Eddie thinks she might actually be a goldfish, but the long spike on her back and purple stripes on her cheeks makes him think otherwise.

“Robin! C’mere, Chrissy wants to tell you something!”

Robin spins around so fast her fin nearly smacks Eddie across the face. He’s pulled back by Steve who just squeezes his shoulders gently as Robin swims back to Chrissy and the other mermaid.

“That’s Heather. She’s Billy’s best friend more than she is mine but she’s got her good points.” Steve points to the last female mermaid, tucked between Robin and Chrissy.

“Now,” Steve coils himself around Eddie, tucking two fingers beneath his chin. “Tell me your name, human.”

Eddie swallows, Steve leaning in closer.

“Come on, it’s just a name. I want to know. Tell me.” Steve sticks a nail in the corner of Eddie’s lips. He pulls at it. “Tell me.”

Eddie can’t get away.

Steve’s nail scrapes against his throat. Raises an eyebrow at him.

“E-Eddie. My name’s Eddie,” He croaks out.

Steve smiles, patting his cheek. “Good boy. See, was that so hard?” He pulls away, settling back in his original spot. Billy was staring at Eddie, head resting on his fist. His mouth move silently, as if sounding out Eddie’s name as well.

“Now that introductions are settled, may we have dinner?” Steve claps his hands together.

Tommy grins. “Oh finally! I’ve been starving.”

Steve smiles.

Eddie has a bad feeling.

“Where’s Jason?”

“He’s coming,” Steve says.

Eddie glances at the door behind him.

He looks at Steve again.

“Can I ask what dinner is?” He asks nervously, gripping the edge of the stone table.

“Oh, you’ll see very soon…” Billy purrs.

Eddie definitely has a bad feeling.

Steve looks up, grinning gently. “And here it comes.”

Eddie can’t help but look up as well.

His heart picks up when he sees what the mermaids have brought.

The servers set down the meal on the stone slab, Eddie letting out a whimper.

“J-Jason?”

There on the table, chest split open and filled with clams and beheaded fish nestled amongst organs laid pretty, was Jason Carver. His clothes were missing, his skin flayed open like a demented flower. There were skewers stabbed in his deflated eyes, his mouth hanging open and filled with more skewers with chunks of meat and fish stabbed one after the other. His limbs were cut into slabs, laid out and cooked brown. His hands and feet were missing, but Eddie can see his fingers all wrapped up together next to some whole shrimps that hung near the end of his ripped open stomach. There was cooked fish amongst it, though it mingles with the raw fish.

Eddie feels sick.

He stands up, stumbling back. He needs to get out of here.

The mermaids all stare at him, Tommy and Billy grinning like hyenas.

“What, aren’t you hungry?” Tommy jeers. Yanks out a red, bloody liver and shakes it around. “Come on, Stevie’s made sure to make some of it cooked so you don’t get all sick. Don’t be rude to him. Eat up!” He tears into the liver with his teeth, and it’s like it activates something in everyone at that table.

Eddie falls to the ground in horror as the mermaids all descend on Jason. Even Chrissy, with her sweet face, bites into what Eddie knows is the heart without a second thought. Steve stares right at him with a smile.

That kind of smile does not fit what is happening right in front of him.

“You’re missing out, Eddie… I know you must be hungry.” Steve swims over to him.

Eddie scrambles away on his hands and feet. “No, no no no no-” He pleads. “Don’t- That’s- I’m not gonna eat him-!” He needs to run, but every time Eddie tries to get his feet underneath him he collapses back down.

Steve rolls his eyes, and grabs at Eddie despite his protests. Pulls him closer and forces him to sit down again.

“Stop complaining. I had him all prepared so you can join in too.” Steve prods at his lips. Eddie jerks his head to the side, chest rising and falling rapidly. “Don’t you want to say goodbye to your friend?”

“You’re insane! You’re all insane!” Eddie screams.

Tommy laughs. “Insane?”

“We’re merfolk, Eddie.” Carol licks her lips, clutching onto a shrimp and waving it at Eddie. “And our diet includes humans. You’re just one of the lucky ones.” She bites the head off of the shrimp, sucking out its insides.

“I’m really sorry you had to say goodbye this way,” Chrissy says. “But Jason said no to staying with us! Poor guy…” She swims closer to Eddie, holding out a clam. “But you really do need to eat. If you don’t want to eat him, you can have a clam instead! I hear clams are safe raw for humans.”

Eddie heaves, his stomach retaliating. Steve pets at his hair, holding him against his chest.

“Oh, I think he’s not having it Chris,” Steve says. “But she’s right. You need to eat.”

“I’m not-” Eddie wheezes. “I’m not eating him. I’m not eating anything.” He wants to cry so badly. Jason didn’t deserve this. He wasn’t his favourite person in the world, sure but.

Anything was better than this.

Jason deserves better than being eaten at the bottom of the sea by mermaids.

Billy rolls his eyes. “I told you he’d be against it, Steve. Humans don’t eat their own kind.”

Steve juts his bottom lip out. “But I even got it cooked for him.”

“Either way.” Billy swims closer, grabbing a piece of Jason’s arm. Chrissy moves out of the way for Billy. “It is rude to reject a host’s meal, yeah? And you’ll starve otherwise Eddie.”

“Then I’ll starve!” Eddie shouts. He won’t be eating Jason, end of story. “You’re not feeding me Jason!”

“Hm.” Billy grins, eyes twinkling. “Well, too bad you don’t get that choice. Steve likes ya, you know. And he’s dead set on keeping you alive. We went through all that trouble preparing this meal…”

Suddenly, Steve wrenches a thumb in his mouth, forcing his jaw open. Eddie squirms wildly, trying to get free, but Steve has wrapped himself around Eddie entirely, barring his freedom.

“So you’re gonna eat it.”

The taste of meat hits his tongue, and Eddie’s body finally had enough.

His stomach kicks, and he spews all over Steve’s finger. The mermaid jolts back with a hiss, the meat falling out of his mouth. It floats downward much too slow, Eddie choking on a sob that doesn’t fill his eyes as he stares at him.

“Please…” He says weakly. “Stop it…”

Billy stares at him in disappointment.

“Ew,” Billy spits, nose wrinkled as he backs away.

Chrissy looks at him pitifully, Tommy rolling his eyes. Carol laughs at him, Heather and Robin both looking a blend of concerned and disgusted.

Steve sighs behind him, and Eddie feels himself being dragged backwards.

“Now did you have to do that?” Steve says, pulling him away from his own sick. “Billy, darling ocean, bring some cooked food up to the room. Robin, make sure to save me some?”

“Aye aye, captain,” Robin says.

Steve continues to pull at him by his armpits until he reaches the water, Eddie limp in Steve’s grasp. Steve makes some clicking noises at him, almost in disappointment, before he drags him some more with one hand to the room designated as his.

Eddie’s pushed through first, followed by Steve. He tries to get away from the mermaid, but Steve was faster, grabbing Eddie and tugging him towards the sponge bed. The mermaid still had his tail, which coils up like a snake beneath him as he lifts Eddie up onto the bed.

“Are you alright?” He asks, frowning.

Eddie weakly kicks at him, Steve grabbing his foot. “Stop.”

Eddie tries to kick him again. Steve doesn’t let go. “Eddie, stop that.”

“F off.”

“What?” Steve questions, then shakes his head. “Never mind that. Did you not like the food? Did it taste that bad?”

Eddie glares at him. His eyes were finally watery, tears rageful.

Steve frowns, still clutching Eddie’s foot. “I suppose humans aren’t used to our kind of diet. That’s fine. I’m sure you can survive on fish and shellfish. I just wanted you to join us, but I must have aimed too high up for you.” Steve shakes his head in disappointment.

Billy shows up right then, heaving himself out and clutching a bag. His striped tail shifts into human legs, Billy walking over and dumping the plastic bag at the edge of the bed.

Eddie can smell the fish and clams even from here. Billy digs into it, pulling out a fish that certainly did looked cooked.

“Here. Will you eat this?” Billy holds the fish up to Eddie’s face.

Eddie jerks his head away, still queasy.

Steve moves his head back. “Now you’re just being immature. Eat, Eddie. You’re not starving here.”

Eddie shakes his head. He doesn’t care, he’ll just starve. Die right here right now. It’d be the only apology he can give to Jason.

Billy rolls his eyes, nudging the fish against his lips. It was wet, but really warm. “Eat.”

Eddie keeps his mouth shut.

His stomach rumbles.

Billy nudges him again with the hot fish. “You’re hungry. You need to eat.”

Eddie refuses.

Billy sighs loudly. “Fine, you want to be a baby? Babies don’t get to breathe until he open his mouth.”

A hand clamps over his throat, squeezing. Eddie jerks, kicking out. Steve just grabs onto him, preventing him from hitting Billy.

Billy raises an eyebrow, waving the fish in front of Eddie’s mouth. “Come ooooon, open up~” He squeezes tighter.

Eddie grabs at Billy’s arms, trying to get him to let go. Tears bud at the corner of his eyes.

Billy just leans into his throat.

Eddie needs to breathe.

He needs to-

Fish floods his tastebuds. Eddie screams, muffled. Billy lets go of his neck, Eddie sucking in air desperately into his nostrils. The fish remains in his mouth.

Eddie can’t do anything but bite down. It’s good, weirdly enough.

Eddie doesn’t understand why.

He doesn’t want to, actually.

Billy smiles, pats his cheek gently as if that same hand didn’t press down on his trachea. “See, now was that so hard, Eddie.”

“It’s good, isn’t it?” Steve asks. He was smiling.

Eddie just lets the tears run down his face. Billy wipes them away.

“Oh, don’t cry. Don’t cry landie. Here, have some more. We had it all prepared for you.”

Billy holds the fish up to his mouth again, the other hand resting gently on his collarbone.

Eddie opens his mouth.


“Where’s Eddie?”

Steve looks up, Chrissy hovering nearby. He smiles at her.

“Oh, he’s resting. We managed to get some food in him at least.”

“That’s good.” Chrissy swims closer to him. “Do you think we scared him?”

“I think so. Hm, we went too fast I guess?” Steve taps his chin. “We’ll keep him on a sea diet until he’s ready for meat again. Did you manage to collect fresh water? Humans are bad at getting their water from their food. Remember Linda?”

Chrissy giggles. “How can I forget! She was really cute.” She shakes her head. “And then she died with a bloated stomach. Carol popped her and then there was all that water!” Chrissy wriggles her fingers around her.

“It was a shame. Linda was nice. But no matter! We won’t mess up this time!” Steve says.

“Whatever you say Steve. By the way Robin’s looking for you. She got you what you asked for.”

“She did? Great!” Steve swims off, Chrissy following after him.

Robin was hanging around still in the dining area, a pile of meat in front of her. “There you are! Your food is getting cold!” She says.

Steve swims over, plucking the human’s head up.

“Oh, you saved me his face!”

“As best as I could. Sorry about the eyes.”

“That’s not a problem, Robs. Not a problem at all,” Steve says, and bites down on the lips in a mockery of a kiss.

Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

There’s no calendars in the mermaid realm, so Eddie doesn’t know what day it is today. He scratches at his arm, which felt both damp and flaky all at the same time. After the whole dining experience the mermaids don’t let him out anymore to do anything. They don’t even show him around. It was getting boring, mind-numbingly so. Eddie hums a tune to himself, though it fizzles out quickly.

Chrissy would occasionally appear with a large shell full of wet, cooked fish and a bag of clean water for him. Sometimes it was Steve, who would sit there and watch him eat everything. Praised him like he was some dog or something.

Steve would also come with gifts. Eddie knew what courting looked like. He accepted the many shiny pearls, trinkets, and accessories Steve gave him if only because he couldn’t refuse the king.

He can’t refuse the king. The consequence is still seared behind his eyelids. The taste of his flesh still stung as a bitter memory.

Eddie wasn’t stupid enough to make himself fish chow. So he sits there all pretty getting lavished in gifts that end up sitting all pretty in the corner of the room. They leave him alone most of the time at least. Eddie spends it singing to himself when he wasn’t sleeping the hours away, pretending to hold his precious guitar.

He misses his guitar. Eddie misses a lot of things. He hopes Wayne accepted he wasn’t coming home any time soon. Wayne was getting up there in age, and his heart wasn’t as good as it could be. Eddie hopes he isn’t worrying too much about him. He’s already been enough on the old man’s heart just by being there, his absence must be twice as bad.

Eddie scratches at his skin again. He stretches out his arm muscles, wincing at how tense they were. His legs fare similarly. Eddie has been walking around the room, but it hasn’t been helping.

The water ripples, Eddie staring at his pale and cracked feet.

“You look rough.”

Eddie barely even manages a cynical laugh, his cracked lip twitching. “You think?”

Heather slides out of the water, her deep red and white striped tail shifting into legs wrapped in a thin translucent skirt. “Really, you look rough.” She walks over, sitting down beside him. “All the males are out on a hunt, so it’s just us females on the grounds. Chrissy and Robin are busy with each other, and Carol went out for a little so I’ve come to bother the only thing that can’t leave.”

Eddie lets her talk. She chatters on about what the mermaids had been up to, from how Tommy had swam right into a sea column and Billy had laughed at him, to how a bunch of fry merfolk had taken Steve out to hang out with him and didn’t return him until much later. Eddie doesn’t join in the conversation, but Heather didn’t seem to mind at all. She even talked about how poorly he looked, which didn’t help matters much. He knew he looked terrible even without a mirror to stare at himself. Perhaps he should ask Steve for one.

Then Heather grabs his hand firmly, standing up. “I know what’ll cheer you up.” Heather yanks, sending a spike of pain up his arm. Heather gives a small apologetic smile, but her grasp on him doesn’t let up. Eddie pushes himself up to his feet slowly.

“You need a day out. And maybe something to do with all… this. Steve’s never had one alive this long. Between you and me?” Heather leans in to his ear, raising a hand up near her mouth. “I think he’s too awestruck to notice you’re like. Deteriorating. Chrissy’s been worried about you you know? She’s been wondering if you need some extra help. If you die Steve’s not gonna be a happy mer.”

Of course it is. Doesn’t matter about him, does it? Just Steve’s feelings.

Still, Heather’s offering to let him out. Eddie would be a fool if he didn’t take the opportunity.

So he lets Heather breathe in his mouth and toss him underwater.

She keeps her hand on his arm as she guides him, though it’s more like she drags him along. Eddie was much too tired to help swim through the water. Heather appears to have noticed as she glances back at him with concern a few times. She doesn’t go too fast, thank goodness.

Heather brings him outside, taking him around the castle to a cave just behind the massive building. For a second, Eddie thinks that he made a mistake coming with Heather. This felt like he was being sent to some evil den where evil witches live.

The inside of the cave did not exactly help his thoughts, Eddie staring at all the bottles in the cave, held down by seaweed nets and wooden shelves that looked like they have seen better days. A few bottles seem to sit above the water in a small air pocket.

Heather lets Eddie go, raising a finger and swimming around a cartoonishly witchy cauldron that had barnacles growing all over it. The cauldron was empty from what Eddie could see, Heather shoving random knickknacks aside in what looked to be an old steel serving trolley that was rusted in a few places.

Heather makes a bubbling noise, swimming right back to Eddie. She gestures to where her ears should be then points to him before she grabs his head and pushes it to the left. Eddie barely has time to question her when something is shoved in his ear. Heather tilts his head and shoves something in the other ear before backing up with a nod. It made his ears feel weird, like there were earplugs jammed in them.

She clears her throat. “Test! Test! Eddie, can you hear me!” She says like she was announcing something in a microphone. Eddie’s mouth drops open, right before he shuts it and tries to spit out the saltwater back out. Heather laughs, though it just sounds muted and bubbly to him.

“Good, you understand me! I made those for you. Made from the same stuff that makes up the double rooms. It’s pretty one way though so if you need something you’re just going to have to motion for it.” Heather swims around the cauldron again, digging around some more. “Ah, by the way, I don’t think Steve told you, but I’m the kingdom’s official sea witch. I’m in charge of anything that requires a little extra magic to make it all work. You’ve heard those stories, right? Like the one where a boy comes down on a turtle and leaves with a box he’s not supposed to open, or the reason why you’re able to walk around in the throne room while everyone else is swimming around you?” She points to herself. “All my responsibility. Took over the last one who used to do this. He was a weird one, let me tell you.”

Heather digs in a box, pulling out a pair of diving flippers. “Tommy took these off of a funny little human once. They’re supposed to help you human swim without a tail I hear. Here, you can have them until we figure out a better solution.” She hands them over.

Eddie takes the flippers. It’s a nice gesture, he supposes, even if Eddie couldn’t breathe without the help of the mermaids. Heather nods at him and settles on top of the cauldron.

“You still look terrible by the way. Absolutely ghastly. You are eating your food and drinking your freshwater, right?”

He has. The food was okay. Always wet, but okay. Eddie gives her a small nods, Heather copying him with a larger one.

“Huh.” Heather tilts her head. “Then what’s got you all tired-looking, landie?” She reaches forth, pinching his cheek between her fingers. Her nails dig into Eddie’s skin near his eye, Eddie hissing and leaning away. Heather lets go of him and frowns.

“Maybe you need more freshwater in you. I’ll tell Steve about getting you more to drink.”

Eddie doesn’t think that’s the reason he looks so terrible. Not that he can tell Heather that. The mermaid floats around some more, organising bottles and items. She occasionally glances back at Eddie, pointedly looking at the flippers in his hands.

Eddie looks down at them. They’re maybe his size. He’s not sure. It was always worth a try. He takes on and tries to pull it on over his feet.

It was kind of hard to put it on when there was nothing supporting his weight except for the water. Eddie grunts, Heather giggling at his pitiful attempts. She doesn’t try to help him.

Eddie scoots closer to the wall, finally getting his heel on in the rubber. He gets the other one on without much issue.

“Wow, they really do look funny,” Heather says. She chuckles, a clicking noise behind her laugh. Eddie glares at her lightly, but Heather just waves her hand at him. “Well go on then! Go swim. It’s your day out. Just stay within the area. I’ll come collect you when the boys are back.”

“Are you sure?” Eddie asks her. His words still remain near incomprehensible in the water. Heather makes a confused yet amused face at him, and waves her hand at him again.

Eddie will take that as a yes. He turns and swims away from the cave.

He doesn’t know how long the mermaid’s breath lasts.

Eddie looks up at the dark ocean sky past the glow of the castle. He might as well make the most of it.


“I saw Eddie swim past. He was going upwards. Did you let him out?” Chrissy asks as she ducks into the cave where Heather was.

“He’s already trying to escape? Wow he’s fast.”

Chrissy nods her head, swimming over to Heather. It seems like she was trying to make a concoction, Chrissy peering into the magical liquid. “What’re you making?”

“I was hoping to make something new. Experimenting with it.” Heather pokes at the liquid with the bottom of a bottle full of crab shells.

Chrissy claps her hands, making a happy clicking sound. “Sounds good. Now, about Eddie.”

“What about Eddie?”

“Do you think he’s going to make it far?”

Heather snorts, gills fluttering. She uncorks her bottle, letting the cork float to the ceiling and dumping shell pieces into the cauldron before retrieving the cork. “No. Reaching the surface will take him longer than the breaths he’s gotten from me. And that’s not counting the hunting party finding him first. He’ll get spotted, no sweat.” Heather stirs the cauldron with a long thin rod. “Don’t you feel bad that he’s always cooped up Chrissy?”

“I do,” Chrissy says. “But what do you think Steve will say when he finds out you let him outside? You know how Steve gets about his things…”

“Then that’s a problem between me and the king, now won’t it? And besides, Billy loves a good chase.” Heather dumps a handful of sand into the cauldron. “It’ll make him a happy mer. If he’s happy, Steve’s happy. Eddie gets his exercise in. Win win.”

“That’ll work!” Chrissy watches Heather stir some more. “But what if Eddie doesn’t get found?”

“I trust he will. Eddie’s been looking quite frail, don’t you think? If anything it’d be easier to hunt him down. He’d get tired before he wins. Going from stationary to swimming all that distance.”

“That’s true,” Chrissy says.

Heather reaches over, patting her on the shoulder. “Eddie is one man. The party will be outnumbering him and bring him back safely. If he manages to escape all of them then I’ll applaud him.”

“I hope he will be alright out there.”

“What, you afraid he’ll get caught by some shark?”

“Or a Billy.”

Heather cackles. She tries to stop, but more erupt past her lips in hiccups. “Oh, you’re right, Chris. But Billy’s nice when he wants to be.”


Eddie tastes freedom for what only felt like seconds.

Maybe he should have listened to Heather and stayed within the light of the kingdom. His muscles felt like they were on fire, and he felt far too lightheaded. He doesn’t get it. Eddie descended with Tommy fine, what made ascending so much harder?

He continues paddling upwards, no end in sight. He couldn’t see anything now that he’s left the strange light of the mermaid’s kingdom, but it couldn’t be too hard. All Eddie had to do was go up.

Up. That was his only objective. Eddie just needed to go up and then he’ll regroup. Find a way to return back to civilisation. Never step foot in the ocean ever again. He’ll go inland, even. Back to Indiana. Just away from the ocean.

It’s so dark. And cold. Eddie didn’t realise just how cold it was until he left the kingdom. Everything was aching. He didn’t know how long he’s been swimming. It was a temporary ache. He hasn’t died yet. He thinks he might at this rate.

A loud pinging noise in his ear startles him. It’s quickly followed by faint shouting.

Oh no.

Eddie swims faster, hoping and praying he’ll get somewhere safe. What was he kidding himself for, he can’t see his own hand and he’s just hoping he’s still going upwards. If he wanted to hide he would have to be insanely lucky to find himself a hiding spot.

Eddie could give up now.

No, what is he thinking? Maybe he can evade them.

In the dark.

Against mermaids.

Eddie shakes his head, kicking his feet and pushing onwards. That’s ridiculous, he’s definitely losing.

Maybe they’ll just think he’s some random seal or something that decidedly wasn’t an Eddie Munson escaping when he should have been holed up. There was no way they would assume he’s escaped.

He screams when something tackles him from the side, laughing raucously. His left ear rushes with water, making that side sound dull.

“Gotcha, you rascal.” Billy squeezes him tight. Eddie feels his nose prodding at his neck, teeth grazing his skin and sending a sensation down his arm. His voice was hard to hear, a blend of garbled words and a rapid shuttering dolphin noise. “Well now, I thought I was dreaming!”

“Did you catch them?” Steve’s voice comes from farther away.

“Steeeeve, guess what I caught~” Eddie feels himself get turned around, Billy’s hand squeezing at his arm like a stress toy.

“Is that Eddie?” Steve’s voice is so much closer now, and a finger brushes against his cheek. “Now what are you doing out, handsome? Did the girls let you roam?”

“Hey look Stevie. He’s wearing those silly slippers.” Eddie feels Tommy tugging at his ankle and the flippers. “I think he thought he could get away with it. Tried to escape you Stevie!” Tommy cackles.

“Oh Eddie,” Steve says in pity, stroking his cheek. “You can’t leave!”

Eddie pulls away from his finger, Billy yet to release him. He kicks his feet, Tommy’s nails digging into his calves and preventing him from doing anything.

He hears muttering in his right ear, but it sounded like it should be surrounding him instead.

Eddie is so cold.

Hands grab his face.

“Come on Eddie. That’s enough for today,” Steve sweetly purrs.

He feels his body get spun upside down, and all he can do is hold on.

Eddie sees the kingdom’s light within minutes. Billy doesn’t loosen his hold the entire dive back down, Heather and Chrissy reappearing from the cave and joining them.

“There he is!” Chrissy says. “Oh you look even worse than before. Billy, stop squeezing him so hard! You’ll crush his bones!” She swats at Billy’s hand, the mermaid loosening his grip on Eddie. Eddie clings on to Billy’s arm. He felt so tired. If Billy let go he’ll drop, he’s certain of it.

“He needs a break. Heather, do you mind if…?”

“I’ll get right on it, Your Majesty.” Heather swims away back to the cave.

“You want to do it now?” Billy questions, Steve nodding. It looked smeared, from Eddie’s point of view.

Eddie’s vision was going blurry. Fingers grip at his chin.

“I don’t want to lose him. Do you?”


Eddie wakes up again in his room. Eddie coughs, his nose stinging sharply. He grabs his nose, hissing and trying to will his head to stop exploding on him.

“Oh good you’re awake.”

He rolls his head over, opening his eyes. Even his eyes burned.

Billy was sitting a little aways from him,  chewing on what seemed to be a pink conical sponge. He lets go of the sponge and waves it at him. “Hungry?”

Eddie shakes his head. Billy takes back the sponge and resumes chewing on it.

Eddie tries to sit up, but he collapses back down with a grunt.

“Easy there sailor.” Billy scoots closer. “ You’re gonna be a bit weak for a while. Overexerted yourself out there. You’re not as healthy as you were when you passed by it the first few times.” Billy taps his arm. “But a bit of rest, some medicine, and you’ll be good to come join the rest of us.”

Eddie’s throat feels dry. Billy stares at him silently, eyes tracing his entire body.

It’s a little creepy.

Billy taps his arm again after a while. “Steve was worried when you didn’t wake up after so long. He thought you went and gotten yourself killed swimming out there by yourself,” Billy says. “Course you were still breathing. Chrissy and Heather’s been diligent in making sure you’ve been healing well since you were alive and all. Your skin is looking better than ever. Your pretty little guts? Getting there.”

Billy prattles on about Eddie’s condition. He keeps on chewing messily in between sentences, barely even looking at Eddie as he spoke.

Eddie’s head was still pounding throughout it all. He barely could understand most of what Billy was saying.

“So anyways, Heather chewed us both a new hole about your condition.” Billy waves the sponge at him again, the end chewed up like a well-used dog toy. “She said we needed to let you out more. Get you movin’.” Billy shrugs, putting it back in his mouth. He slaps his thighs and stands up. “Right, that’s all. Back to sleep with you, Eddie. See you after.”

Eddie makes an incoherent noise, eyes slipping shut without much more of a fight.

When he came to again, Billy was gone. He feels less tired, though still sore. Eddie sits up slow. His limbs still burned when he moved. He pushes it past it with a groan.

He check himself over. His skin was soft again, unblemished. His clothes are missing, replaced instead with a simple pair of swim trunks. The flippers are gone as well, though by this point Eddie was more used to not having shoes anymore.

Eddie thinks he should be more concerned about his sudden nudity, but his mind was still foggy.

He sits there, staring at the pearl walls. Nothing has changed in the room. His pile of trinkets still sat in the corner. He tries to clear his throat, but it didn’t feel like there was much improvement.

The water splashes, and Steve appears out of the hole. He shakes his hair, flinging saltwater everywhere before dragging himself up.

“Hello Eddie. How did you sleep?”

It was dreamless. He was less tired.

That meant it was okay, right.

Steve smiles even though Eddie doesn’t say anything, slithering closer to him. He pulls himself up onto the bed, draping his tail across Eddie’s lap. Steve wraps his arms around Eddie’s shoulders, leaning his head on his arm. “You worried me darling. Swimming off like that, what if you had gotten yourself lost? You looked piteous out there, swimming in the dark. Almost ran right into a wall. If Billy hadn’t caught you…” Steve turns his head, his chin leaning on Eddie. “You’re too nice looking to lose. You do still look cute asleep. But you were asleep way too long for my taste.” Steve pouts.

Eddie scratches at his throat. It still felt sore. Steve lets go of him.

“Here you go Eddie. Drink up.” Steve pulls off a pouch and hands it to him. Eddie takes it and pulls open the watertight seal, chugging down the fresh water contained inside.

“Thank you,” Eddie whispers. His voice sounded hoarse despite the water. Still, he felt slightly better now.

Steve smiles and nods, still draped over Eddie. He didn’t have the energy to push him off. Steve was an oddly comforting weight.

The mermaid doesn’t say anything, eyes trained on Eddie’s face. He was smiling contently, his tail wrapping around one of Eddie’s legs. The end of it brushes against the sole of his foot, making his leg twitch every so often.

Eventually he lets go, tugging on his fingers. “Come with me. Will you?”

Eddie let Steve drag him up. His legs tremble when he stands and give out on him, Steve grabbing ahold of his torso.

“Come on, I’ll carry you there,” Steve says softly, dragging him towards the water.

Eddie taps on Steve’s arm when his foot breaches the surface. “What about…”

“Hm?” Steve continues to lower him down, Eddie weakly kicking his legs once he was waist deep.

“The… kiss…” He whispers.

Eddie raises his head, eyes sliding shut. He’s willing, he doesn’t really feel like drowning. He’s already hurting, why hurt more at this point.

Only, Steve laughs in his ear.

“Oh baby, don’t you worry about that.”

A whine erupts from Eddie’s throat. Doesn’t he need it?

“Oh, alright. One to soothe your nerves.”

Lips press against his own. Eddie’s mouth opens automatically, waiting for the feeling of the mermaid breathing down his throat.

There is none. Steve pulls away and lets him drop into the water.

The water is weirdly warm today.

Regardless, the water wakes him up, Eddie trying to swim back up despite his muscles screaming at him to stop moving so much. Steve jumps right in, blocking the pathway. He laughs, pushing him back down.

Eddie holds his breath all the way down, coming out of the door. Steve swims out after him, smiling and grabbing him again. Steve makes a laughing noise, gently pushing on his chest.

“Breathe, Eddie. Breathe. You’re okay, sweet boy.”

Eddie shakes his head. He doesn’t trust him. He’ll drown. He’s going to drown.

Steve pushes on his chest again, rougher than last time. “Come on. Breathe. I promise it won’t hurt you. You won’t drown. We made you all better.”

It was like he read his mind. Eddie still holds his breath despite it. The mermaid could be lying.

Steve wouldn’t lie.

He wants him alive.

Eddie leans back against Steve, looking up at him nervously.

Steve smiles. “Here, let me help you.”

Two fingers prod at his lip. Steve traces them outwards to the corners of his lip.

Eddie’s lip splits open, and he takes a hurried, stuttered breath.

He breathes in, and he breathes out. Steve’s eyes crinkle happily.

“There we go, good boy Eddie.” Steve cups his chin, rumbling deep in his chest. “Come on.” Steve grabs his wrists, going over Eddie and tugging him along gently.

Eddie lets himself get pulled. Steve was swimming backwards, facing him. He turns without looking, soon bringing him into a rather large room. It was decorated finely, nothing like the bare room Eddie has been in. There was actual art on the walls, shells and items Eddie recognises as human decoration embedded into the wall. One wall has thick curtains hanging from it, grey with spots speckled over it. There was no window through it, the curtains hanging on either side of a mass of rocks decorated along the wall. The sandy floor had grooves in it like a mandala, more rocks decorating it at even intervals around the circle.

Steve floats right over it, settling him and Eddie down on the bed. Eddie lays down, letting his body rest once more. His body was faintly pounding like a faint steady drum.

“This is my room.” Steve curls his tail over Eddie’s waist. “Nice, right?”

Eddie doesn’t answer him. It was nicer than the room he just left, but Eddie’s taste in decor was far different than how Steve had everything so his opinion didn’t matter.

The tip of Steve’s tail strokes his arm. “I have a question, though I’m sure I already know the answer.” The two appendages on his back flutters eagerly. “But I’ll let you choose since I know you humans like choices.”

Eddie turns his head to face the eager king mermaid.

“I want you in my pod. Officially. I want you by my side. You are way too handsome to keep as a human. And with that scare you gave me…” Steve clicks his tongue. “Well, I’ve decided that’s enough. I’d rather keep a human I wouldn’t mind watching suffer a little longer. You though? I want to keep you forever. You can stay with me and Billy here. The bed is big enough for all of us.”

Eddie is silent. He didn’t want to, in all reality. He’d rather go, return to his old life.

That was no longer a reality for Eddie Munson. Going back wasn’t an option.

Steve rolls over, his body hovering above Eddie. “So what do you say, Eddie darling? Do you want to join us? Your choice.”

Eddie takes a deep breath.

He has no choice.

“Can… I at least say goodbye?”

Steve tilts his head.

“To whom?”


Wayne sits alone on the boat he rented, staring out into the sea wistfully.

It’s been a whole year and counting since he’s seen his nephew. He had asked him to borrow the boat to go fishing, promising to return with ‘the biggest fish ever, Wayne!’ so they could cook it together.

Then he never came back home.

He knew there was no use when the coast guard came back with his friend’s boat, empty of life. The only thing they found on it was small dents on the side.

“An orca might have gotten ahold of the people on board.”

That is what they told him. Wayne didn’t believe them, but there was news of orcas attacking boats for fun.

There was no other evidence as to what really happened.

Wayne taps the ashes of his cigarette into a mason jar sitting besides him.

He needed to be getting home. It was getting late.

Wayne stands up slowly.

Something dark catches the corner of his eyes. It almost looked like…

Wayne turns towards it, eyes widening. Searching even if he knew in the back of his mind it was impossible.

The only thing he sees is a black tail diving back underwater.

Notes:

Thanks for reading. :D

Notes:

Fish types to note!

Billy: Bluefin Nocto Killifish

Tommy: Spotted Mandarin

Steve: Weedy Seadragon

Robin: Sea Goldie

Chrissy: Swallowtail Angelfish

Heather: Banded Morwong