Actions

Work Header

I'm Your Boyfriend Now, Nancy

Summary:

It's prom night and the legend of Billy Hargrove is alive and well.

Notes:

My Tumblr for my stories if you want to say Hi Edith-Moonshadow

Un-betaed so please excuse all my mistakes.

Work Text:

"I'm your boyfriend now Nancy."

Nancy gave a tight smile while Tommy cackled and slapped Steve's shoulder.

"It's too late Stevie by midnight she'll be Billy's new bride."

Steve rolled his eyes as he wrapped his arm around her shoulder.

"I wouldn't be so sure Tommy."

Wolf whistles and catcalls erupted from the small group gathered and despite herself, she felt her cheeks growing warm. She glanced at Steve and desperately wanted to slap the smug look off his face.

In a few hours, they'd be at prom. Nancy had secretly always dreamed about her prom night. It wasn't as important as her grades or getting into her dream college but it felt like one last magical night to be a teenager before responsibility finally came along. She'd dreamed about it but never would she have believed that she'd be going with Steve Harrington. They'd only been together a short while but it would be cemented forever tonight as she stood by him in the beautiful dress she'd picked out in a picture that would one day line the halls of Hawkins High.

The previous famous attendees smiled at them from behind glass. Steve's parents had attended prom together and were frozen in time. The moment they won prom king and queen. She knew it was important to him to be remembered and adored. There were previous sports heroes, club members who excelled in their chosen fields and some tragedy.

Billy Hargrove was a legend at Hawkins High. He had once held the king title that Steve now wore with pride. He'd been smart, good-looking and captain of the basketball team. Billy had also been a little dangerous. He was known for being into hot rods and drag racing. He had a gleam in his eye that could still send chills through every girl at Hawkins High even through a faded photograph. Billy hadn't just been king on the court he had also won prom king. There was a picture of him standing beside Betty Ross with two sparkling crowns placed on their heads. Betty was radiant, tears shining in her eyes and a huge smile on her face. Billy was stoic with his eyes staring down the lens of the camera. Now it had a haunting quality. Something happened that night. Betty had been abandoned at the school after some kind of disagreement. Billy took off at high speed in his car never to be seen again. A fiery wreckage with a melted crown on top of charred bones was all that remained.

The town mourned. Time moved on. Betty moved away. Slowly a legend was born. If you become prom queen you better not be a virgin by midnight or Billy Hargrove will take you as his bride. Nancy hated the legend. Not only did she feel it was disrespectful towards a teenager who died but his memory was being used to pressure other girls into sex.

She wanted Steve to tell the others to knock it off. That their relationship had nothing to do with them but he didn't. He maintained a smug silence because although she knew deep down he was better than this he needed the attention more. He'd act like a clown in public and make it up to her later. She knew from Carol's sly remarks and the way she looked at her that she knew. Sometimes she wondered if you looked different or acted different once you'd had sex. Or did Steve just tell them everything?

She could feel his frustration growing when she'd slow them down when things got too heavy. His sighs grew a little more strained. His hands lingered a little too long. She'd almost given in a few times. She didn't place too much value on virginity but at the same time, she didn't want to reward Steve's bad behaviour.

Barb was the angel on her shoulder telling her to ignore Carol's sharp tongue. Steve was well known for his girlfriends. He wasn't great at monogamy and she'd be the one with the reputation. Barb's eyes would narrow on Steve especially when Billy was brought up because she could see right through him. He didn't believe in the legend but saw it as a golden ticket to get what he wanted.

Nancy appreciated her concern but she wanted to make her own decision. She felt as though either one was wrong. Carol would never respect or congratulate her. She would probably encourage Steve to move on once he'd got what he wanted. Barb on the other hand was fighting a fight on her behalf that she didn't want to win. Steve was everything she'd ever dreamed of. He could be frustrating but she knew he felt pressure to be the persona that everyone expected of him.

Prom night and being crowned king was the only thing Steve had talked about in the past week. She had no desire to be queen nor Billy's bride but she'd decided especially after Tommy's comments that she would not give in tonight no matter what happened.

 

Steve arrived at her house and her mom took enough photographs to fill a book with tears in her eyes. Her dad watched on with mild disinterest. Her mom had told her about her prom for years. She'd attended with her steady boyfriend at the time, she wore a peach-coloured dress and danced until her feet hurt. She didn't even know if her dad had attended his prom but he generally remained quiet on things like that. The drive to the school she'd remember in retrospect was a highlight of the evening. Steve's smile made her heart flutter like a moth getting too close to a flame. There was a rosy hue to his cheeks and he was that sweet unassuming boy she couldn't help falling in love with even if she wasn't fully there yet. Things changed once they arrived and found Tommy and Carol at the entrance.

They talked mostly to Steve barely acknowledging her. She found they could be civil to her on occasion but generally acted as though she were already Steve's ex-girlfriend. Steve seemed oblivious and she calmed slightly when she felt his thumb stroke the back of her hand. They joined a small group of people waiting to walk up onto a small platform that had been dressed up to look like a romantic scene on a bridge with soft lighting and paper flowers. Couples were posing together while Jonathan Byers dressed in a jacket that was a little too big took photographs.

When it was their turn she stood beside Steve trying to feel good about his hand on her waist but there was something in Jonathan's eyes. Something that made her feel like a ghost who was watching everything transpire from the shadows and was screaming that it was all wrong. A longing for something she didn't yet understand but someday it would all snap into place.

The rest of the night felt like her dream but with even less substance. She danced, laughed and drank as though nothing were real. Soon they were announcing the king and queen and everyone around her seemed to hold their breath collectively. She could feel her heart racing as Steve squeezed her hand.

"The king and queen are…Steve Harrington and Nancy Wheeler…"

The gentle music and people clapping and congratulating them as they walked to the stage almost drowned out her heartbeat. Steve took the whole thing in stride. He looked picture perfect with his crown perched on top of his perfectly styled hair with his sweet smile for her. She smiled back as her crown was placed on her head. A flash made her look round to see Jonathan taking pictures of them and she suddenly felt that same strange feeling again. Steve pulled her close and the prom picture of Billy and Betty flashed through her mind as she was blinded by Jonathan's camera.

The night had seemed so short after that. They danced for everyone as was tradition. Steve disappeared for a few moments to talk to Tommy. The clock struck eleven fifteen and Steve grabbed her hand and pulled her out into the parking lot. Into his car where he sped off to the quarry. She told him to slow down thinking about the past but he only laughed. He pulled the car to an abrupt stop and turned to her. His crown reflected the moonlight dazzling her eyes.

"Why are we here?"

Steve moved closer.

"I didn't want you to become Billy's bride so I thought I'd give you a chance."

She shook her head watching the little beams of light play across his face from her crown.

"You can just take me home."

Steve's smile grew.

"C'mon Nance, it's prom night. We should be enjoying ourselves."

"We can enjoy ourselves just fine without having sex in your car at the quarry."

She could hear her mom's disapproval in her tone and could feel her resolve crumble slightly. Did it matter? Steve was every girl at Hawkins dream and she had his attention but was that enough? Would she look back at this time with fondness like her mom did? Would she roll her eyes at how stupid she'd been? Or would it barely register in her life just like it seemed with her dad?

Steve pulled her closer and kissed her sweetly. His arms wrapped around her and she slowly lost herself in the kiss. She'd spent so much of her time working hard at school and had never really allowed herself to let go like this. She'd had crushes and a few dates but nobody like Steve. She pulled back and tried to catch her breath.

"I'm serious, take me home."

Steve's mouth turned down into a frown as his eyes grew big and sad. It was a terrible impression of a sad puppy but Steve's big brown eyes sold it. She pushed at his shoulder but she couldn't help the smile on her face.

"You're being a jerk."

"A jerk? Just for trying to be a good boyfriend."

"How are you being a good boyfriend?"

"I'm protecting you from Billy Hargrove."

She rolled her eyes.

"That's just a stupid legend. He was only our age when he died and you've all turned him into a monster."

"I never said he was a monster."

"You claim he steals virgins on prom night."

Steve held his hands up.

"I didn't create it."

"But you push it."

Steve smiled then pulled her close to whisper in her ear.

"I'm your boyfriend now Nancy."

She shivered at his hot breath against her ear but pushed him back.

"No, you're a jerk."

"Let me make it up to you."

He pulled her close again and even though she wanted to push him away she didn't. Her stomach twisted when she felt him smile into the kiss. It felt so special like only she could make him smile like that because despite all the posturing he was serious about them.

Soon the windows in Steve's car had fogged up obscuring their view of the outside world. When Steve's hands began to wander she didn't push back. She could feel herself growing warm. Her lips were tingling and her heart was racing. Steve undid the top few buttons on the back of her dress and she moaned into his mouth.

Suddenly there was a roar from an engine and bright lights shining in through the window. Steve stopped and moved back. They both looked through the window but the lights were too bright.

"Is that Tommy?"

He was the only person she could imagine who would think it was funny to interrupt them like this. The engine outside roared louder. It sounded like a demon there to raise hell.

"Stay here. I'll find out who it is."

She grabbed his arm. Something was wrong.

"No, maybe we should leave."

Steve placed a soft kiss on her cheek.

"Don't worry I'll be right back."

Steve opened his door and stepped out into the blinding white light. His door closed with a strange finality. She listened but couldn't hear anything but the lights and the roaring didn't cease. She checked the time it was three minutes past midnight. Soon she couldn't sit still and opened her door and stepped out. She walked out of the bright light and saw a dark blue car with its engine running. She moved closer wondering where Steve had gone. She walked up to the window and looked through. Her heart stopped.

Steve was pressed up against the other door. His eyes were closed and he was being kissed by the person who had their back to her but she could tell it was a man by their build. She felt as though she'd swallowed her tongue. Why would Steve do this? Suddenly burning hot anger spread through her and she tapped loudly on the window. The man with his back to her slowly pulled away from Steve who looked blissfully dazed. The window wound down and he leaned into the light. She gasped as she came face to face with Billy Hargrove.

He looked just like his picture with piercing blue eyes and sandy blonde hair. He looked like he'd just stepped out of the picture of him at prom with all the intensity he seemed to carry. He smiled at her before pressing his foot hard on the gas and disappearing with Steve into the night. He only said one thing leaving Nancy so stunned she swore she was dreaming.

"Your Boyfriend's mine now Nancy."

Series this work belongs to: