Actions

Work Header

read between the lines

Summary:

“What is her name?” Billy demanded, staring right at Steve as if he had any right to know. They weren’t even friends, so why did he care?

Whatever Dustin expected Steve to do, it definitely wasn’t for him to just blurt out, “Brenda.”

Seriously? Not even Dustin had managed to get her name yet and now here Steve was, just giving it to Billy without even putting up an argument. Though, Dustin figured as he looked around the room filled with their friends who were watching the situation unfold with rapt attention, the cat - or rather Steve's secret girlfriend - was already out of the bag.

“Brenda?” Billy said, making such a profoundly disgusted face that Dustin couldn’t help but jump in to defend her.

“Yeah, Brenda,” Dustin said. “And she’s awesome.”

Or, the one in which Steve has a secret girlfriend and Dustin is just trying to be a supportive best friend

Work Text:

“Okay, that’s enough,” Dustin said, glaring at a dreamy eyed Steve who’d sighed for the hundredth time that afternoon, clearly not absorbing a single word that Dustin had said to him since he arrived to his house for their weekend hangout. “What’s her name?”

Steve blinked at him in surprise, as if he’d just realized that he was no longer alone. Dustin would be insulted if he didn’t know that his clever and scathing quips would be lost on Steve in his current love struck condition.

“What are you even talking about, man?” Steve asked, frowning as if Dustin was the one who was being weird here.

“Your girlfriend, Steve,” Dustin said slowly. “What is her name?”

Steve had the balls to roll his eyes at him. “I don’t have a girlfriend, Henderson.”

Dustin put his hands on his hips, mirroring Steve’s usual mom pose when he was done being ignored and was about to lay down the law. “How stupid do you think I am, Steve? You don’t think I can tell when my best friend is head over heels in love- like,” he was quick to correct when Steve’s eyes widened so quickly he was worried they might pop straight out of his head. Steve’s been a bit touchy when it came to the world ‘love’ ever since the whole Nancy fiasco. Wait. “Is it Nancy again? Did her and Jonathan finally break up and you managed to win her back?”

Now, don’t get him wrong, Dustin liked Jonathan. He was a great big brother to Will and he seemed like a decent guy overall. But Steve was awesome and if he loved Nancy, then of course Dustin would be rooting for him no matter how cute Nancy and Jonathan looked together. It was what best friends did for each other. Even if he had some very private opinions that maybe Nancy wasn’t the best choice for Steve. Dustin also liked and respected the hell out of Nancy but, again, Steve was his favorite. Anyone who broke Steve’s heart deserved a side eye or two in his completely unbiased opinion.

“What? No,” Steve was quick to deny. “It’s definitely not Nancy. I’m over her.”

If Steve had said that just a few weeks ago, Dustin wouldn’t have believed him. But now, after Steve had spent the entirety of their spring break sighing and pining and generally acting like a devastated wife yearning after her deployed husband, well. Maybe Steve wasn’t still stuck in denial. Maybe instead, he was stuck on someone else.

“A-ha!” Dustin pointed a finger at Steve. “So you admit that there is someone.”

Steve opened and closed his mouth, visibly annoyed at himself for being so easily tricked before he finally gave in with a sigh. “Fine. I am seeing someone new. Are you happy now?”

Dustin scoffed. As if. Steve should really know him better than that by now. “What’s her name? What does she look like? Are you in the same grade? When can I meet her?” And, most importantly, “Does she have a cute younger sister you can set me up with?”

Instead of responding to any of Dustin’s perfectly reasonable questions, Steve instead looked like he regretted all the life choices he’d made that led to this exact conversation. “No.”

“No to what?”

“All of the above.”

Dustin frowned. “She doesn’t have a name?” His eyes widened in horror. “Steve, please tell me you don’t have some creepy monster girl from the Upside Down currently tied up in your basement.”

He didn’t want to think that Steve was capable of something like that, but if Dustin was curious enough to bring home a demodog, who was to say that Steve wouldn’t do the same if given the opportunity? Considering their lives, it wasn’t that far fetched of a theory.

“She has a name, dipshit,” Steve snapped. “It’s just none of your business. Do I really look like some creepy serial killer to you? I don’t even have a basement!”

Dustin gave a slow nod. Yeah, Steve was making some really good points here, even though he was getting a bit too worked up by the whole basement thing. His house was even fancier than the Wheeler one and they had a huge basement where El, who wasn’t directly from the Upside Down but might as well have been, was kept hidden. It was a perfectly reasonable assumption to make, really.

“So it’s a secret girlfriend, then,” Dustin concluded, since that was his next guess. “Got it.”

Steve didn’t give him a concrete yes or a no, but with the way he dropped his head into his hands and gave a long groan, Dustin decided to take that as a yes.

“You know, I’m pretty great at keeping secrets,” Dustin reminded Steve when he made no attempts to offer any further information about his new girlfriend. “If you want to, you can invite her to join us for our sleepover. I don’t mind, as long as we compensate it with some alone time in the future and you don’t turn into an asshole who completely abandons his friends just because he’s dating someone.”

Looking at you, Mike and El. And Lucas, which also unfortunately meant Max, too. At least Will was still just as painfully single as Dustin was, even though DnD was way more fun when they played it as a group rather than just one on one.

Steve, who’d heard that particular rant more than once this weekend alone, simply rolled his eyes. “No offence, but do you really think I’d be spending my entire spring break hanging out with you if I could see her?”

“None taken,” Dustin assured him. He had been wondering why Steve was all of a sudden inviting him to do things on a near daily basis. They’ve been hanging out outside of life and death situations since November, but daily hangouts? That was definitely not in their realm of normal. It was fun, don’t get him wrong, but he was starting to worry about Steve and his lack of friends within his own age group.

When Steve didn’t elaborate further, Dustin figured that was all he was going to get out of Steve, at least for now. So even though it pained him, he dropped the topic and focused back on his previous task, which was making a list of movies and snacks they’d have to get for the long weekend ahead of them. If Steve needed him to be a distraction for whatever love troubles he and his girlfriend had found themselves in, Dustin was more than happy to be one.

“Listen, Dustin,” Steve told him later that evening, two of them laid out on the floor of Steve’s living room and stuffed to the brim with pizza and unhealthy sodas that even his mom wouldn’t allow him to have outside of special occasions. “You can’t tell anyone about me having a girlfriend, okay? I know friends don’t lie or whatever, but this is serious, you hear me? No one can know. Not Mike, not Lucas and not even Will.”

Oh. So Steve wasn’t only missing her in that typical lovesick way that Dustin had gotten used to seeing on Mike and Lucas ever since they got girlfriends. He was actually worried.

“Is she okay?” Dustin asked, already planning ways he could help if the answer was no. He knew Steve still kept his bat in the trunk of his car and while Dustin wasn’t much help in a physical fight, he did have Hopper just a press of a button away on his walkie.

Steve looked like he was thinking the exact same thing, but then he let out a breath and gave a reluctant nod. “Yeah. I think she’s okay. Her dad is a major asshole,” he explained before Dustin could ask. “He would lose his shit if he ever found out she has a boyfriend. And I know you guys all mean well, but I don’t want to take any risks that could get her in trouble.”

“Don’t worry, Steve,” Dustin said and mimed zipping his lips. “Your secret is safe with me.”

*

Over the next few weeks, Dustin easily kept the promise he’d made and his mouth had remained firmly shut when it came to Steve and his dating life. At least when they were in public. In private, it was a whole other story, and Dustin had managed to find out quite a few details about this mystery girlfriend of his along the way.

In his defense, he never had to pry very hard. It seemed that Steve was just as eager to gush about her as Dustin was to hear about it and he gave in under very little pressure.

As a result, Dustin now knew that she had curly blonde hair and the prettiest blue eyes that Steve had ever seen in his life. She was very into metal music and was the rebel type, basically the complete opposite of Nancy but just as smart and badass according to Steve, which Dustin had a hard time believing. No one could be that perfect, but he also had no evidence to prove otherwise.

She smelled fantastic, like the warm ocean breeze, and she liked jewelry. Steve had agonized for days over which earrings to get her for her birthday. Well, earring. Apparently, wearing only one was all the rage these days even though Dustin had never seen any other girl walk around with only one singular earring. Though Billy Hargrove followed the same fashion trend and he also wasn’t originally from Hawkins, same as Steve’s new girlfriend, so maybe Hawkins was behind on that as well as pretty much everything else.

Steve’s girlfriend lived to mock him about his taste, from music and movies to his clothes, but she also wouldn’t stand for anyone else doing the same. She attended all his games, helped him study and finally finish his college application and had an asshole dad that Steve hated with a passion he usually only reserved for the creatures from the Upside Down and shady government people.

And most importantly, she made Steve happy and he was so in love with her, it wasn’t even funny. Not that he’d admit it.

“It’s too soon for that,” he kept insisting every time Dustin teased him about it, but by the way his face erupted into flames every single time, they were both well aware that he was lying.  

*

People figured it out, because of course they did. Steve was a lot of things, but subtle was not one of them. Dustin wasn’t even sure if he knew the definition of the word.

Spending even more time fixing his hair and wearing a dark blue scrunchie around his wrist like a trophy was more than enough to tip off the rest of The Party of this new development in his life and they were far less understanding than Dustin was about the importance of secrecy. Probably because Steve couldn’t get a word out with all of the questions being flung at him.

Steve was just standing there in the middle of his living room, shaking his head and dodging questions left and right but not denying anything when a new voice suddenly asked, “Harrington’s got a girlfriend?”

All of the smugness at being the only one in the know evaporated out of Dustin when he saw no one other than Billy Hargrove standing in Steve’s doorway, looking genuinely shocked at what he’d just overheard. Shit. So much for keeping it a secret. Dustin trusted his friends to keep quiet, but Billy? The guy was probably itching for an excuse to start some trouble with Steve again.

Billy had left them mostly alone after that night in the Byers house, had even apologized for trying to hurt Lucas but no one really bought it. Dustin didn’t know why he still insisted on coming in whenever he dropped Max off when his presence clearly wasn’t welcome. Sure, Billy said that he just wanted to make sure that there was nothing weird going on inside that could get him and Max in trouble, but Dustin was pretty sure that was just an excuse to bother Steve.

Steve, who for some odd reason kept insisting that Billy wasn’t that bad and that they should all give him another chance.

Yeah, right. Dustin could be a bit naive, but he wasn’t stupid. Dart, his pet demodog, was more harmless than Billy Hargrove on his best day. He’d rather risk sharing a bedroom with him again than extend an olive branch to Billy.

Steve sputtered, clearly not expecting that he’d have to deal with Billy of all people knowing his most treasured secret, but Billy paid no mind to his clear discomfort. Because, again, he was a major asshole that no one wanted to be around aside from Max, but Dustin wasn’t about to get in the middle of their weird love-hate sibling relationship. Unlike what Steve claimed, he actually did have some self preservation skills.  

“What is her name?” Billy demanded, staring right at Steve as if he had any right to know. They weren’t even friends, so why did he care?

Whatever Dustin expected Steve to do, it definitely wasn’t for him to just blurt out, “Brenda.”

Seriously? Not even Dustin had managed to get her name yet and now here Steve was, just giving it to Billy without even putting up an argument. Though, Dustin figured as he looked around the room filled with their friends who were watching the situation unfold with rapt attention, the cat - or rather Steve's secret girlfriend - was already out of the bag.

“Brenda?” Billy said, making such a profoundly disgusted face that Dustin couldn’t help but jump in to defend her.

“Yeah, Brenda,” Dustin said. “And she’s awesome.”

Billy’s scowl was now aimed solely at Dustin. “You met her?”

“I don’t need to. Steve wouldn’t date someone who wasn’t just as awesome as he is.”

Billy rolled his eyes. “She’s a fucking airhead, that’s what she is.”

“She’s actually really smart? Got a full scholarship to some super fancy college in Cali,” Dustin said proudly, because of course Billy didn’t know that. He’d have to look away from her boobs first to notice anything else about her, like the mouth breather that he was. “And she’s hot, too. Blond curls and what did you say her eyes were like, Steve?”

“Um,” was all Steve managed, acting all flustered and weird and Dustin rolled his eyes. Did he really have to do everything around here?

“That’s right. A blue that’s brighter than the sky and the ocean combined,” Dustin repeated some of Steve’s ramblings, then scoffed as he gestured vaguely at Billy’s stupid face. “Unlike whatever bland shade of blue you’ve got going on.”  

“Brenda,” Billy repeated slowly, back to staring intently at Steve.

Steve nodded. “With a capital B.”

Dustin shot him a frown of his own. Her name was Brenda; what other capital letter could it possibly be? But he’d let it slide this once. The situation was intense enough without Dustin schooling him on basic grammar.

Billy and Steve engaged in an uncomfortably long stare down before finally, Billy’s lips turned up into a smirk and he turned to Dustin, looking far too amused for comfort. “You’re right, Henderson. She does sound pretty damn awesome.”

And even though his point was successful proven, Dustin wasn’t sure how he felt about Billy Hargrove agreeing with him on anything. Or the fact that for the first time, he’d referred to him by his actual name.

*

On an above average hot day in the late spring, the Party and friends found themselves in Harrington’s backyard. Steve was throwing his one last pool party apparently, because he’d just dropped the bomb on Dustin that he was moving out straight after graduation.

“You’re leaving?” Dustin said through the lump that immediately formed in his throat at the mere thought.

Logically, Dustin knew that Steve leaving was inevitable. He was a high school senior after all, and he’d just gotten his acceptance letter for the same college his girlfriend Brenda was attending, though Dustin was pretty sure that Steve’s dad was footing the bill in his case. The point was, Steve was always going to leave. But Dustin had just assumed that Steve would spend one last summer here in Hawkins with them all. With Dustin. He didn’t think he’d skip town as soon as he had a diploma in his hands.

“Not straight away,” Steve quickly explained, immediately picking up on Dustin’s emotions like he could see straight through him. He probably could. When it came to feelings, Dustin was as transparent as they came. “I’m spending the summer right here in Hawkins, I promise. I’ve already got a job lined up and everything.”

“But then why are you moving out?”

Steve lifted himself up from the pool and joined Dustin where he was sitting on the ledge of it, running a hand through his now wet hair to get it out of his face. “You remember how Brenda’s dad is an asshole?” he asked in a voice low enough so they wouldn’t be overheard and Dustin nodded. “Well, she’s a bit short on cash so she got a summer job, too. And since she’s sticking around and has no other choice but to move out, I figured I might as well move in with her. Help her with rent and the bills and things like that. It’ll also give us a chance to figure out if we can manage to share a space without strangling each other before we leave for Cali.”

That was sweet and all, but. “Aren’t you rich?” Dustin asked. As far as he was aware, Steve hadn’t been disowned by his parents yet and he never took any money their parents offered him for babysitting. Surely, he’d be more than happy to cover any expenses for their trip to California without issues.

Steve gave him a ‘don’t you think I’ve tried?’ look, full of fond exasperation. “Brenda is very independent,” he said, probably not even realizing that he was smiling. Just like he always did whenever he mentioned her name. “I could help, but this is something she wants – no, needs – to do on her own, you know? And I’ve gotta respect that.”

Despite his sadness, Dustin grinned and nudged Steve’s shoulder with his own. “Look at you, being all mature. When did that happen?”

Steve nudged him right back, hard enough that he was nearly knocked straight into the pool. “Probably around the time I was put in charge of a bunch of little twerps who have no regards for their own safety.”

Dustin laughed. “Yeah, that’ll do it.”

It was a nice moment for him and Steve, and Dustin was doing his best to commit every single second of it to memory while he still could, which was why Billy Hargrove just had to make his presence known and ruin it yet again. This time it was a wolf whistle, followed up with a, “Damn, Harrington. Your girlfriend is an animal.”

As Steve quickly turned to face him, just as startled, Dustin got a good look at his back and unfortunately, he couldn’t not agree with Billy’s assessment.

Steve’s entire back was scratched up like he’d just lost a battle with a feral cat, and there was more than one bruise that accompanied them on the length of his body. Dustin grimaced. This was way more than he ever wanted to know about Steve’s apparently rather wild sex life, and that was after he was already forced to sit through a rather uncomfortable birds and the bees talk Dustin’s mom had probably guilted Steve into giving him.

Not because she wasn’t happy to do it on her own, mind you. But rather because whenever she tried, Dustin was too horrified to absorb a single word she said through the ringing in his ears. His mom was awesome, but some things a guy was better off learning from another guy. Just ask Will. The poor bastard had been so mortified after it happened that Dustin feared he’d never recover.

“Jealous, Hargrove?” Steve asked, casually leaning back on his hands and staring up at Billy with a smirk of his own.

Billy scoffed. “Keep on dreaming, pretty boy.” He looked Steve up and down, far too thoroughly than was appropriate in public if you asked Dustin, and shook his head. “I really don’t know what she sees in you.”

Steve lifted an amused eyebrow. “I’ll have you know that I’m quite a catch. Besides, who else is she supposed to date instead? You?” Steve returned the favor and now he was the one who was looking Billy over from top to bottom, no inch of him left unjudged by Steve’s sharp eyes. “No offence, man, but I don’t think you’re her type.”

“I’m everyone’s type,” Billy said and Dustin couldn’t help but roll his eyes. There was being confident, and then there was being unbearably arrogant. Guess which category Billy Hargrove filed under?

Steve only hummed, looking completely unbothered by Billy’s presence and his unsolicited opinions. “If you say so. But I think Brenda would agree with me. Not a day goes by without her showing me just how into me she is and how much she appreciates me. It’s very sweet. She’s very sweet.”

Dustin felt like he was missing half of the conversation even though it had his full attention, but Billy seemed to understand exactly what Steve was saying and he wasn’t impressed.

Billy had been bringing up Brenda like a relentless bloodhound from the moment he’d found out about her and Steve, was endlessly amused when his teasing, sharp comments only made Steve blush and turn into a blubbering mess and Dustin had to be the one to jump in and defend her, even though he’d never even met her. Something that never failed to make Billy even more delighted by the whole thing. By now, he’d deemed Dustin as Brenda’s and Steve’s yappy yet loyal little guard dog.

But this time, something was different. He could hear it in Billy’s voice and see it in his sneer as he said, “Sweet? I don’t think so.” He gestured at Steve’s back. “She likes marking her territory, huh? Kind of reeks of insecurity, don’t you think?”

Dustin bristled at his tone and was ready to jump into her defense yet again, but for the first time, Steve jumped in before he could. “Don’t talk about her like that.”

Billy let out a dark laugh, clearly not buying Steve’s thinly veiled threat and that was his second mistake of the day. Steve was so easy going most of the time but piss him off, or even worse, insult someone he cared about? King Steve that they’ve all heard so much about came out and put you right back in your place.

As he watched Steve’s mouth tighten and eyes narrow, Dustin fought the urge to go make himself some popcorn to enjoy the show that was about to unfold right in front of him even more than he already was. 

“I’m serious, Billy,” Steve said, not an ounce of humor to be found. The sudden change of his tone had even Billy standing at attention. Dustin almost felt bad for him. Almost being the key word here. “Brenda is the best thing that’s ever happened to me and I don’t want to hear a single bad word about her coming out of your mouth, got it?”

It was Dustin’s mouth that dropped open at Steve’s words. Not because he was surprised, because even a blind man could see how protective Steve was of his girlfriend. No, what shocked him was the way that just like that, Billy backed off. He didn’t argue, didn’t puff out his chest and doubled down on his mockery. Instead, all of the tension in him seemed to just melt away and he gave Steve a tiny, but genuine smile that Dustin didn’t even know he was capable of forming with his stupid, forever smirking mouth.

“Got it,” Billy said softly, and if Dustin didn’t know better, he looked almost pleased by being told off by Steve. Just when Dustin thought he had him figured out, Billy did something that was so unexpected it completely threw him for a loop. 

But that didn’t stop him from calling out, “Yeah, that’s right!” at Billy’s retreating back. “Suck on that, Hargrove!”

“Oh, I will,” was Billy’s reply, accompanied by another one of those smirks and a flip of his middle finger, because the guy never let anyone get the last word, even if whatever he said made no sense at all.

Steve made a choking noise from beside him and Dustin patted him on the back. “You good?”

“Yeah,” Steve said, swallowing hard, face completely red. For someone who always pestered everyone about the importance of sunscreen use, he really should start using it himself. “Everything’s great.”

*

Steve’s new place was tiny. A cramped one bedroom apartment in not the worst, but also not the best neighborhood of Hawkins, and Dustin was trying so hard to be polite about it when he walked through the front door, but Steve only snorted and ruffled his hair as he let him inside.

“It’s kind of a shithole, I know,” he said, instructing him on where to place the box that Dustin had so kindly taken from the moving truck parked in front of the building and carried on his way up. The truck was basically empty already, so he didn’t know why Steve insisted he come before everyone else to help with the move. “But hey, the rent is cheap and we’ll only be here for a few months.”

Dustin immediately perked up, looking around the small space for a certain someone. “Speaking of we, is she here?” he asked, so excited he had to fight the urge to bounce on the spot. “Can I finally meet her?”

Before Steve could respond, the door of what Dustin assumed was the bedroom opened and Billy Hargrove himself walked out, looking all gross without his shirt on and covered in sweat.

“Hey, did you see my- Oh,” he paused, blinking at Dustin. “What’s he doing here?”

Dustin crossed his arms over his chest and glared at him. “I was invited. What are you doing here?”

Billy mirrored Dustin’s defensive stance and stared him down, looking entirely unimpressed with his presence while Steve simply sighed. “What does it look like I’m doing?”

“Helping Steve move?” Dustin guessed. It would be a far more productive way to put all of his ridiculous muscles to use instead of beating someone’s face in, but with all the evidence supporting this theory, it still made no sense at all. Steve and Billy weren’t the kind of friends that helped each other move. Hell, they weren’t friends at all as far as Dustin was aware and as Steve’s best friend, if anyone would know, it was him. 

Or so he’d thought, but then Billy snorted and turned to Steve and asked, “You still didn’t tell him?”

“I was getting around to it, before you interrupted.”

“Tell me what?” Dustin asked, raising his voice to be heard over their bickering. He didn’t like feeling left out of things, and he definitely didn’t like being ignored.  

“It’s about Brenda,” Steve said, hesitant. “She, uh. She’s not actually real?”

“What?” Dustin demanded, in a voice so shrill it made his own ears hurt. “So this entire time you haven’t been seeing anyone?”

“No, I was,” Steve was quick to correct him. “Just not Brenda. Because I made her up.” He paused, cocking his head to the side in thought. “I mean, there is a Brenda in school who is also blonde and blue eyed, but I have definitely not been dating her. And I guess that the Brenda I have been describing does exist, but not in the way you think she does. Does that makes sense?”

“It really doesn’t,” Dustin told him bluntly.

“Oh, for fucks sake,” Billy said, rolling his eyes at them both. He grabbed Steve by the collar of his shirt and pulled him into a kiss that was rated at least PG-13 if not higher and that Dustin immediately wished he could erase from his memory.

And then it all finally clicked into place. Blonde hair, blue eyes, new in Hawkins and a troublemaker, had an asshole dad who would definitely not approve of the relationship. Even the earring that Billy was wearing right now, Dustin realized upon closer look, was the one he’d helped Steve pick out for Brenda’s birthday.

Because Brenda had been Billy all along. Steve’s lovely and sweet and perfect Brenda was Billy Hargrove.

What in the fresh hell was going on here?  

Dustin desperately didn’t want to believe this was true, but the kiss was doing a great job of proving him wrong. That was not how you kissed a random guy who wasn’t even your friend. This was how you kissed your boyfriend who you’ve done a lot nastier things with in the past. Ugh.

“Do you get it now?” Billy asked after he pulled away from the kiss, leaving Steve swaying on his feet in his absence, all dazed like he’d just been hit on the head and gotten another concussion.

“You’re dating Billy,” Dustin said numbly, still struggling to process the last minute of his life. The Upside Down made more sense than Steve dating Billy fucking Hargrove. Sorry mom, but this situation definitely called for some cruse word use.

Steve nodded. “With a capital B.”

Billy rolled his eyes at both of their awkwardness. “I’ll go grab the rest of our things before your pack of brats invades.”

Instead of a kiss this time, Billy chose to slap Steve’s ass as his parting gift, the sound of it echoing in the small room and leaving both Steve and Dustin more than a little horrified in his wake.

“Him, Steve?” Dustin asked, incredulous. “Really?”

Steve shrugged. “The heart wants what it wants. And he’s really not that bad once you get to know him. I mean, he’s still an asshole, but he grows on you.”

“But all you do is argue!” Dustin exploded, waving his arms around in indignation. Billy lived to wind Steve up any chance he got, Dustin had seen it first hand. And okay, maybe Billy teasing him so much about his girlfriend made sense now, but he also gave him grief about everything else, too. How could Steve love someone who made it his life’s mission to get on his very last nerve?

“Would we call that arguing, though?” Steve asked, running a hand through his hair, visibly embarrassed. “Or would we call it flirting?”

Suddenly, Dustin remembered the scratches he’d seen on Steve’s back during the pool party and shuddered in horror. Billy had said that Steve’s girlfriend was an animal – and he was. Oh, god. This whole thing just kept on getting worse and worse. Because no, Dustin wouldn’t call what Steve and Billy were doing flirting. He’d call it foreplay.

Dustin only knew what foreplay was because Steve told him all about it during their little talk, and he’d been serious enough that Dustin had taken literal notes so he wouldn’t forget the importance of it when the time came to put all of that information to good use. But he didn’t remember any notes which said that it was okay to do any of that shit in public.

Dustin wanted to argue that Billy was corrupting him, that this was a horrible idea and that Billy would only drag Steve down with him. But that would be a lie, too. Sure, Billy might have corrupted Steve in some ways that Dustin would rather not know about, but he’d also helped improve his life, too.

Without Billy’s influence, Dustin doubted that Steve would have even applied to college, let alone agreed to go. He’d have probably stuck around to keep an eye on all of them instead of living his own life like the worried mother hen that he often was. Not to mention how much happier and lighter he’d been over the past few months.

As much as Dustin hated to admit it, apparently Billy was a good influence on Steve. But that didn’t mean he had to like it, because he didn’t.

“I don’t like this,” Dustin said as much now, and regretted it just a bit when Steve’s face fell as if the lack of Dustin’s approval actually stung. “But if everything you told me about him is true, and he makes you happy, I guess I can let it slide just this once.” He pointed a threatening finger at Steve. “But don’t let it happen again, okay? Friends don’t lie, or date crazy psychopaths behind each other’s backs.”

“Billy’s not crazy or a psychopath,” Steve said, even as he grinned and pulled Dustin into a brief hug, clearly relieved by his acceptance. Sometimes Dustin forgot that their friendship went both ways and that Steve cared as much about his opinion as he did about Steve’s. “He doesn’t have a basement either, and even if he did, the only person he’d keep tied up there is me. And that’s only if I asked.”

“Ew, Steve” Dustin whined, doing his best to wriggle out of Steve’s hold and mostly failing. Stupid jocks and their stupid muscles. “TMI!”

Finally, after a bit more playful tousling, Steve released him and they settled down on the ratty old couch that probably came with the place. The already small coffee table was piled high with all of their favorite snacks and the first movie was already set to play as soon as everyone arrived. He’d assume that it was all Steve’s doing, but as much as he liked Steve, he’d never pick Star Wars for any of the movie nights. Trust him, Dustin had tried. Many, many times, all of them unsuccessful.

The movie choice combined with some of Dustin’s favorite books he’d spied on the shelf shoved in one corner of the living room that definitely didn’t belong to Steve, meant that Dustin found himself involuntarily warming up to Billy. Goddamnit. He liked it a lot more when he had nothing but reasons to hate him. They weren’t supposed to have anything in common!

Steve must have misread Dustin’s sudden grumpiness as something more than just him being annoyed at himself because after some nervous fidgeting, he said, “I’m sorry.”

Dustin frowned. “Why?”

“For not telling you the truth sooner,” Steve explained.

“It’s okay, I get it,” Dustin assured him. It stung a bit at first, he wasn’t going to lie. But, having met Neil Hargrove one time when Max’s mom had the bright idea of having everyone at their house so she could meet Max’s new friends and their parents, well. It was the understatement of the century to say that the guy was more than a little crazy.

The looks Neil had given Lucas and his family throughout the entire event still made him shudder. And if a guy like that acted like such a dick to random strangers while he was supposedly doing his best to be civil, he could only imagine what he’d do to his own kids if they stepped out of line. He’d seen the bruises and split lips on Billy that, in retrospect, were pretty damn telling of his home life. No wonder Steve was so worried about him whenever they were kept apart by his strict rules.

He didn’t like that Steve needed to keep his relationship a secret, not just because of Neil but from everyone outside of their friend group, too. But he understood. He couldn’t be mad at Steve for trying to keep his boyfriend safe from harm. Well, he could. But he liked to think he’d outgrown that particular brand of pettiness by now.

“Billy said that I could tell you sooner,” Steve said, which was another surprise. “He knew I hated having to lie to you, but…. I don’t know.” He shrugged, laughing a little under his breath. “I guess I was kind of scared of how you’d react, which is stupid, I know. But, like, Billy’s got friends back home who know about him, but you’re the first person I’ve ever come out to aside from him.”

Considering Dustin’s initial reaction, he couldn’t even blame Steve for being hesitant. But he liked to think he was handling this whole thing a lot better than he would have if he hadn’t seen first hand just how well of an effect this relationship had on Steve. And Billy, he reluctantly had to admit to himself. Sure, he was still kind of a dick to everyone, but it was more playful rather than outright mean like it used to be.

It wasn’t just that Billy was good for Steve; they were good for each other. And Dustin was feeling more than a little warm and fuzzy about being given the honor to find out about it first.

“Come on, Steve,” Dustin said, nudging Steve’s shoulder with his own. “I know I’m a pretty badass guy, but I’m not that scary. So what if you like guys now? We’ve saved the world together. Everything else pales in comparison.”

Steve thought about it for a second and then grinned. “You know what, Henderson? You’re right.”

“I always am,” Dustin preened, dodging another hair ruffle that Steve seemed to be so very fond of. Probably because he knew just how much Dustin hated it.

Was this what it was like to have a sibling? The way Mike and Nancy acted around each other, as well as Max and Billy, suddenly made a lot more sense. They’d kill for each other, but they also had the ability to drive each other crazy unlike anyone else. Will and Jonathan were the only outliers here, but they were a special case to begin with.

“No, you’re not,” Steve corrected him proudly, just like he always did whenever he felt that Dustin was getting a bit too full of himself. Said that knocking him down a few pegs every once in a while helped build character. “I don’t just like guys, now. I like both equally.”

“That’s a thing?” Why wasn’t Dustin informed of this before? He always knew that their school education was lacking, which was why his mom had signed him up for a fun science camp for this upcoming summer, but still. He made a mental note to research the topic when he had the chance. He didn’t like not knowing things and if it was important to Steve, then it was important to him, too.

“It’s called bisexuality,” Steve told him matter of factly.

“Noted,” Dustin said with a nod, then punched Steve in the shoulder.

“Hey!” Steve rubbed at his shoulder, shooting him an annoyed look. “What was that for?”

“That was for making me have to give the shovel talk to Billy Hargrove,” Dustin hissed at him. “If I die, it’ll be all your fault. Couldn’t you have found someone with less muscle?”

“You don’t have to him the shovel talk.”

“Don’t be stupid, Steve,” Dustin said, indignant. “Of course someone needs to make sure he knows exactly what will happen to him if he ever hurts you.”

“I am perfectly capable of taking care of myself, you know that, right?” Steve said, amused. “I’m not some kind of damsel that needs protecting.”

“Neither am I, but when has that ever stopped you before?”

Steve was nice enough not to point out all the times he had to jump to his rescue and only smiled. “Thanks, Dustin.”

“Don’t thank me yet,” Dustin said. “I’ll give him a chance, but that doesn’t mean that we’ll suddenly become friends or something because we won’t. I still don’t like him, but I’m willing to try and tolerate him for you.”

“Of course,” Steve agreed with surprising ease. “I’m not delusional enough to think that’s possible, at least not yet. I’m just asking for you to give him a second chance, that’s all. I promise he’s not as bad as he likes to pretend he is.”

“I’ll take your word for it,” Dustin said skeptically. “But, if he ever hurts you in any way, I’ll have El open the gates again so I can sic my demodog at him.”

“What’s a demodog?”

“Jesus Christ!” Dustin exclaimed, nearly jumping out of his skin. He turned to find Billy standing in the doorway of the apartment, frowning at him and Steve with obvious confusion. This guy seriously had the worst timing known to man and he was as sneaky and silent as his mom’s new cat. They should seriously consider putting a bell on him if he was going to be sticking around.

“Language,” Steve warned, back to acting like his mom rather than his overly protective and slightly annoying big brother. Then, he turned to Dustin and asked, “Do you wanna do the honors?”

Dustin considered it for a long moment. Was finally telling Billy all about the Upside Down the best idea? Probably not. But if he was going to be a part of their group, he was bound to get thrown in the middle of it when it all inevitably fell apart yet again. They could use some more competent fighters on their team, anyway.

And if knowing that Dustin had access to some truly dangerous creatures and wouldn’t hesitate to use them on him if he ever hurt Steve, well. That was just another plus in his book.

Mind made up, Dustin aimed a slightly manic grin Billy’s way and asked, “What do you know about Will Byer’s disappearance?”