Actions

Work Header

all i have to do is suffer, 'cause i can't put up a fight

Summary:

Billy survives Starcourt and emerges with fresh scars and a pain that won't leave. Around him, people pretend that nothing's changed, that he hadn't been possessed, hadn't almost died, hasn't re-evaluated everything he'd ever done.

Max pretends his apology hadn't happened, Harrington won't give him the time of day, and his dad doesn't appreciate having a useless cripple for a son.

But then there's a knock on the door.

Notes:

title of the fic and this chapter is from 'Robbing Banks' by Autoheart, which is the song on the FM for harringrove week, day 1 :)

anyway,

the prompts i chose for this were:

Molly Ringwald’s Wish: Mom Returns
Lesley Gore Passing the Crown: Unrequited Love

tw are in the tags

happy birthday billy, i'm sure this is exactly what you wanted

enjoy :)

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: i am not a monument to what i used to be

Chapter Text

When Billy got out of the hospital, things went back to normal. Or it tried to.

Max and her gaggle of friends avoided him like his almost death meant nothing because he lived. And his dad didn't seem to care that Billy was in constant pain most days. Billy was now an 'invalid' mooching off 'his hard-earned funds' so he was to be punished.

Most days, Billy cleaned the house and drove Max around like it was their first week in Hawkins, and nothing happened at Starcourt. Like Billy's torso wasn't a raised terrain, and his throat wasn't damaged from all the chemicals he'd been drinking.

But Billy had lived, and that was all that mattered to people.

No one explained to him what happened that day. He'd woken up in the hospital alone, gone through physical therapy alone and about his day alone. Sometimes his hands would tremble whenever he drove the Camaro.

Sometimes he dreamt that he died in the factory, mall, or even the Byer's house that November. Sometimes the monster consumed him, tore him apart, and left only bones. Sometimes the people Billy killed came back for him. Sometimes Billy didn't know what was real.

Had the mall actually been on fire? Was the monster real? Had Billy just killed those people?

When El/Jane/Eleven/Whatever was still around, she and Billy would sit in the kitchen, quiet and knowing. Her hands were soft when they held his, veins a stark blue. "Not black," she would say, eyes boring into his. "Never black."

She would make him tea sometimes, sweet and fruity, and they would sit and watch the rain. She asked about California, and he told her about the beach. They never spoke about what she saw, and they barely spoke about what happened. But she kept Billy sane; in turn, he kept her safe. Then she moved to Cali, smile soft and unsure, the promise to call left at his feet, broken.

He missed El. But he didn't have her number. He knew she called Mike sometimes, but the boy had never passed anything on to Billy, and Billy never asked.

So yeah, Billy often thought that whatever happened at Starcourt had been a hallucination. And he tried to make peace with that, with his aching body, raspy voice, and nightmares.


"Pretty boy!" Billy called as the door slammed behind him. The store was empty, and the shelves were neat and orderly. At the counter, Harrington rolled his eyes and deliberately turned away. Billy smiled.

He and Harrington weren't friends, but they were friendlier than before. Harrington and El were the only reasons Billy knew Starcourt hadn't been a dream. El because she was El, and Harrington because he had visited Billy in the hospital and told Billy he was happy that he wasn't dead.

And Billy did what he always did and got attached.

Steve Harrington didn't even like him. They were at the nod-in-acknowledgement stage in their relationship, and Billy constantly tried not to kiss him. Sure, it hurt at times. Especially when Harrington rolled his eyes and muttered something to Buckley or scoffed too loudly when Billy dropped Max off with his shirt unbuttoned for the first time since the hospital.

Steve Harrington turned to face him, grin plastered on, seams obvious. "What’s up, Hargrove?”

Billy meandered his way over, pretending his hands weren’t shaking as he shoved the box. “Need to return it.”

“Hmm.” Harrington scrutinised the tape in a way that Billy knew was special for him before nodding and putting it away. “Alright. You getting another one?”

“Nah.” Billy shoved his hands into his jeans pocket, suddenly shy. Should he leave? He didn’t want to. “Dad says that Max isn’t allowed to watch any more films because school starts next week, and she hasn’t done any of the preparation work because, you know….” Billy awkwardly gestured.

Harrington was quiet, and when Billy looked up, he realised the other boy was staring out the window. Something humiliating, angry and red welled up inside him, the old fire licking his throat like a dragon awoken from a deep sleep.

But Billy swallowed it down because he wasn’t that person anymore (no matter how much everyone thought he was). Billy shuffled and backed away, noting that Harrington hadn’t even noticed.

He needed to leave before he cried.

The bell tinkled again, and, “Harrington!”

Billy turned. Eddie Munson came bounding in like an overexcited puppy, curls flapping wildly and chains clinking. He paused when he saw Billy, his grin souring slightly.

“Don’t worry, he was just leaving.” Billy caught Harrington’s pointed look, and he could take a hint. Munson glanced between them warily, and Billy rolled his eyes, suddenly tired.

“Whatever,” he mumbled and nodded to Munson, who was now wide-eyed like a weird chihuahua Billy had seen on the beach once. When he reached the door, he could hear Harrington and Munson talking, excited about something. Neither looked up when Billy left.

Whatever.

But when Billy looked through the window, the grin on Harrington’s face was blinding. He had never seen Pretty Boy smile like that before. Something burned in Billy’s chest.

He got in the car and drove away before seeing something like Harrington patting Munson’s back. Billy wondered if he could crash the car again.


The next day, Billy woke up in pain. His scars seemed tight, and he had scratched them during the night if the angry red marks were any indication. Beneath his nails, the blood had crusted over and stained his sheets, and Billy sat and stared at them.

The lock on his door was always in use; whenever Billy came home, it was straight to his prison until dinner. He had to wait for Neil to wake up before he could shower or take any medicine the hospital gave him, kept under lock and key by Warden Hargrove.

As he waited for the sun and his father, Billy leant against the cool wall, feeling the uneven plaster dig into his back. Opposite him, his reflection stared back, looking sallow and empty like a little china doll that had been found in the attic. The angry red marks stood out like fresh wounds, almost as if he had been trying to tear his skin off.

Bird song filtered through the curtains, followed by a loud popping noise, like a motorbike. Billy frowned and leant over, moving the blanket he used as a curtain outta the way. No one in this neighbourhood owned a motorbike.

He couldn’t see the person, but the bike was parked on the sidewalk below his window. He shrugged and let the blanket darken the room again, leaning against the wall and staring at his reflection.

There was a knock on the door.

The hall light flicked on. Neil’s heavy footsteps thudded down the hallway. Billy tensed as they reached his room, but his dad didn’t stop. He listened cautiously as the stairs creaked and the front door opened.

“What are you doing here?” Neil’s voice was harsh and thunderous.

Whoever it was replied quietly. There was a muffled argument and resounding slam. But the motorbike didn’t leave, and Billy could hear Neil’s harsh breathing as he came back up the stairs. Whoever was at the door was still there.

Then the lock of Billy’s door slid open, and Billy scrambled to cover his chest. Neil hated looking at Billy’s scars. It made him remember that his son was actually in pain for a reason. The man was red-faced and huffing, almost like he was about to breathe fire.

“Get out here, son,” he snarled before stomping downstairs.

Shaking, Billy pulled himself up, groaning low in his throat as pain rippled through him. Blinking back tears, he debated risking going to the bathroom for his meds but decided against it. Neil was already angry early, and Billy didn’t want to take a beating so early in the morning.

After the mall ‘incident’, Max asked Billy why he was still living in the house in one of the only conversations they've had. “You’re eighteen now,” she had said, “You don’t have to stay here anymore.” Billy hadn’t taken the obvious annoyance to heart, instead explaining that he didn’t have any money anymore (Neil had taken all his summer earnings as payment) and that his pain meant he couldn’t work now.

That was the biggest issue. The nightmares could be dealt with, but the pain? The pain was the worst. There were some days when Billy could go and actually do physically taxing tasks without an ounce of pain. Still, other days had Billy bedridden and wishing for death. It was unpredictable and life-altering. No jobs were willing to accommodate his condition, and even if he left, he could barely drive the car without throwing up.

No. Billy had to stay here. Where he had food and a roof over his head. A few beatings were worth that.

Panting, Billy finally hauled himself down the stairs. Neil was waiting at the bottom, arms crossed and sneering. Before Billy could ask, ‘what the fuck?’ Neil pushed him against the wall. Pain laced through his body, and Billy bit his lip to keep from crying out because that would not help.

Neil got close to his face, and Billy could smell cigarette smoke on his breath as he hissed, “When you go in there, you are going to be a good son for once in your life, understand? Say nothing.” He squeezed his shoulder tight before thrusting him towards the living room.

With shaking hands, Billy pushed the door and…

“Mama?”


*

Rosé Marín nee Hargrove missed her son. The sandy beaches of California weren’t the same without him, his laughter and wet, poodle curls. Sometimes, when she sat by the waves, book in hand, she would see him, hear him, but she could never touch him.

The night she left, it had been the easiest and hardest thing she’d done. People often sneered at her when she revealed she had a son, calling her a terrible mother for leaving. They were right, of course, but in the months after she left, Rosé lived on her sister’s couch in a dingy flat in Los Angeles. That was no place for a child.

She told herself that she would go back for him. Still, the fear and nightmares and drinking had pulled her under. Rosé surfaced four years later, alcohol addiction under her belt and a hollowness in her chest. She was homeless, an alcoholic and could not be Billy’s mother like this.

On Billy’s twelfth birthday was when it really hit her. That was when she realised that she would never see Billy again if she didn’t pull herself together. So, on March 29th, 1981, Rosé Marín nee Hargrove got a job as a waitress, bought her own flat and went to get her son.

Only to find that the Hargroves had moved.

The people who bought the house couldn’t tell her where they had moved, and Neil had no family to contact. Humiliatingly, Rosé almost lost everything in the aftermath and drank herself into oblivion because her son was gone.

But she couldn’t take the plunge. Every time she stood on that ledge, she could see her son, and his sweet face, calling to her. She stepped away every time.

In 1982, she got an office job and moved to Lenora Hills, away from the beach and LA and Santa Monica, away from Billy. Her son was always with her, in the locket over her heart, in the pictures on the walls, in the laughter the wind carried, but Lola told her she couldn’t carry him with her. That it was time she lived for herself.

It was hard. It was regret filled and guilty and sinful. She had abandoned her son with a monster and was in a picturesque town pretending she hadn’t. But guilt was heavy, and she had to put it down at some point, drop some of it just to lessen the weight.

She threw herself into her work and spent the nights with her dogs, Shelly and Sandy (dog names that Billy had solemnly handed to her all those years ago), with a book or TV. She never forgot, and she never forgave herself, but she learnt to live. And that was enough.

Four years passed in a semblance of normalcy. No upheaval, no fresh guilt, just days of sunshine.

Then she got new neighbours, and everything came crashing down.

Joyce Byers was a little bit insane. She had a manic energy, a twitch that kept her company and soul-piercing eyes that lay everything bare before her. The Byers arrived by themselves, no father with them, which Rosé didn’t bother asking about (the twitchiness was familiar after all), and three children, wide-eyed and shadowed.

Rosé offered to help them unpack, which Joyce agreed to, letting the two younger children (“Will and Jane,” Joyce said with a smile) play with the dogs as the eldest helped.

The Byers were lovely once you looked past the initial mid-western energy, and Rosé and Joyce became fast friends. Especially once they realised, they had similar husband experiences.

Then one day, during the last week of August, Rosé found herself alone with Jane for the first time. The girl always had an air of wonder about her, like she was experiencing everything for the first time. But now she was scrutinising Rosé with knowing eyes.

Awkwardly, she sat down opposite her with a mug of coffee. “Is everything okay?” she asked softly. Jane was just as jumpy as her mum at times.

Jane stared at her, then said slowly, like she had to think about each word before speaking them. “You look familiar.”

“Yeah? How? I don’t think we’ve met.”

Jane scrutinised her again. “Hair. Eyes. Spots.” She gestured at each in turn. Spots meant freckles, apparently. “A boy I know. The same.”

Rosé pressed a smile down. Was this a little crush? “Oh yeah? What else about this boy?” She didn’t want to tease her that much. “Is he who you call on Friday nights?”

Jane frowned. “No. That’s Mike. Boyfriend.” Rosé’s eyebrows rose. “This boy. Billy. Looks like you.”

What.

“Billy?” Rosé said slowly, hand creeping up to clutch at her necklace.

“Yes.” Jane’s stare was penetrating now. “Billy Hargrove.”

The mug shattered.


Rosé left the next day, leaving the dogs with the Byers. Her motorbike was sturdy, and she could go for hours without stopping. She spent three nights on the road, determined to get to Hawkins fucking, Indiana and her son.

Her son. Billy.

Who could’ve died without Rosé knowing.

Her beloved child could’ve died in a mall fire and been buried in midwestern soil. No sea. No beach. No mother.

According to Joyce, he hadn’t got out unscathed.

“Prepare yourself,” she had warned, “It’s both worse and better than it looks.”

She arrived early in the morning, the sun barely cresting the horizon. Joyce’s handwritten note was crushed in her pocket. She smoothed it out with her thumb, the address stark against the white. 4819 Cherry Lane.

The bike was loud against the suburban quiet, but Rosé didn’t care. She would wake the entire town if she had to. Gently, she pulled down Cherry Lane, slowly reading the house numbers. When she arrived at 4819, the engine popped like a gunshot, and she winced.

Too late now. She knocked on the door and stepped back. Inhaling, Rosé realised that this would be the first time she’s seen Neil since she left in 1975. She could almost hear him stomping down the stairs.

The door swung open, and she was face-to-face with her ex-husband.

“Hello, Neil.”

“What are you doing here?” His face slowly turned red, a familiar vein popping in his forehead. His knuckle went white on the door handle. She wasn’t scared of him anymore, but the fact he looked as if he would punch her out in the open made her cautious.

“I’m here to see my son,” she said, trying to stay calm. She kept her hands in her jacket pockets so he couldn’t see them shake. “And I’ve come to bring him home.”

Neil stared at her momentarily, teeth-baring, before gesturing her in. Rosé kept an eye on him as she entered, holding in a flinch as the door slammed behind her. She turned to the man, taking him and the house in with a disdainful look. The house was lovely, but the rot that clung to Neil ruined it.

“In there.” He pointed to the living room like she was a dog. “I’ll go get him. You know he’s a cripple, right? He can’t work. There are days were he goes mute like an imbecile. Fucking retarded now.”

Rosé winced at the language but didn’t say anything. She shouldn’t agitate the man anymore. Who knows what he would be willing to do. He left her there with a scoff.

Each heavy footstep made her wince, and she could hear a door slamming open, muffled voices following. She sat with her hands in her lap. The sun was coming up in warm orange rays, and birds started dotting the skyline. One of her nails was chipping, red polish flaking whenever she ran her fingers over it.

It was a lovely house.

On the mantel, there were framed photos of Neil with another woman. A redhead and a little red-haired girl, who was probably her daughter. No pictures of Billy.

She twisted the ring on her middle finger. Neil returned downstairs, snorting like a bull about to charge. He didn’t come in, instead leaning against the wall like a cat waiting for a mouse. “Slower than a fucking baby.”

She could hear him now. Her son. Making his way slowly downstairs. Each step creaked, and then a pause seemed to get longer each time. But she was patient. She would be patient.

He reached the bottom of the stairs, but she couldn’t get a good look at him before Neil pushed him against the wall, keeping him from view. Sharp nails bit into her fist, and Rosé knew that no matter what, Billy couldn’t stay here.

Then Neil moved, and Billy limped forward. She knew the exact moment he recognised her.

“Mama?”

“Baby.” Rosé stood, arms coming up to pull him into a hug. But he flinched back. Neil hovered by the door, and she could see his little smirk. “Billy.”

He stood there, silent. As much as she wanted to smother him, hug him and keep him near, she knew she’d been gone for ten years. So much had happened at the time. Best let him come to her.

But the silence stretched on. Rosé bounced from foot to foot, desperate for her son to say something. Neil moved, just his arms, but it seemed to wake Billy from his shock.

He didn’t seem happy to see her, which was understandable, but it hurt. To him, she disappeared and left him behind. She didn’t even know where to begin.

“Billy, I –”

“How did you get here?” His voice was low and raspy like he’d swallowed gravel. It was undetermined whether it was puberty or the aftermath of the mall, and Rosé didn’t think it was her place to ask.

After a moment, she understood what he was asking. “I didn’t know you were here until three days ago.” Billy eyed her warily but didn’t say anything. “About a week ago, I got some, uh, new neighbours. The Byers.” A flicker of recognition. “And, the girl, Jane. She was talking about this boy she knew and said his name was Billy. Hargrove.”

Billy straightened, eyes wide and lips parted as if to say something. But something held him back. Neil. She nodded slightly, and he relaxed, flicking another anxious look at his father.

“Come sit down,” she said. Billy looked tired. If what Neil was (sorta) saying was true, then Billy must be in a lot of pain. He stumbled over like he couldn’t quite get his legs to move naturally before slumping down on the couch with a huff.

Gently, she reached for his hand, and he let her take it. It was warm and calloused, the knuckled patchy and scarred. His nails were bitten down to the finger, and there was peeling skin between his fingers.

“I know I left you with him, Billy, and I am so sorry.” Neil scoffed, and Billy flinched. In response, Rosé tightened her grip on his hands. “I need you to know that I thought about you every day. But” here she swallowed. She didn’t really want to say this in front of Neil. “But something bad happened to me, and by the time I had fixed it, you were gone.”

Billy’s were wide, wide, baby blue, and she wanted to pull him close like she did when he was younger. She had feared that she wouldn’t recognise him when she saw him, but she did.

“You came back?” His voice was small and shaky.

“Oh, baby. Of course, I did.” Her hand came up to cup his cheek. Billy swallowed, leaning into her touch for just a moment. But Neil was hovering behind her, and Billy kept looking back at him.

Straightening her back, Rosé took the plunge. “If you want, you can come live with me.”

Silence.

She bit her lip and let go of Billy’s hands as he stared at her. Behind, she could hear Neil protesting, but she didn’t care.

“Really?” Her son asked.

“Nothing would make me happier.” She promised. Billy looked so much like her, she realised with a small. There was barely any Neil in him.

“But what about…?” Billy gestured at himself, his torso where she could see the spread of scars and his leg that sat at an angle.

“That doesn’t matter,” she told him firmly. “I want you to live with me.”

Neil scoffed behind her. Rosé turned to face him. His teeth were bared, but before she could start shouting, he spat out, “Good riddance, cripple.”

There was silence. There was a glass on the table. Neil didn’t duck.

It was satisfying to see his eyes go wide with fear and watch him stumble as the glass shatters just above his head. But when she turned to Billy, his face was blank and emotionless and…

“Billy?” A voice came from upstairs.

Rosé stepped before her son as the two redheads from the mantel came down. The woman stopped and stared at the shattered glass in muted horror as the little girl squinted at them. Rosé looked at Neil’s new wife, at how she hunched in on herself and kept the girl behind her.

But she honestly couldn’t bring herself to care.

“Who are you?” The New Wife asked.

“Billy’s mother.”

They both flinched in shock. The girl looked between Rosé and Billy before nodding to herself. Billy didn’t move, eyes flickering between the others in the room in a panicked way.

“Why are you here?”

“I came to bring my son home.”

Both of them made noises of protest, although it seemed more like an obligation than a genuine complaint.

“Billy!” The girl complained. “You won’t go, will you?”

“Why not, Maxine?” Billy asked.

Maxine’s nose scrunched in protest. “Because!”

Billy rolled his eyes. “You don’t even like me.”

“I do!”

“Don’t!”

“Do!”

“Don’t!”

“Enough!” Maxine’s mum barked, but it seemed directed at Billy, who quieted down immediately. “Billy is over eighteen, so if he wants to leave, he can.”

Neil finally moved, coming to stand next to her and Maxine. He took in Rosé and Billy before turning to his son. “I want you out of my house by this evening. Let this bitch take care of you.”

“Fine,” Billy said. But he was still looking at Maxine.

“I’ll help you pack,” the girl said. Billy nodded.


*

Billy struggled up the stairs, leaving his mama with Neil and Susan. The tension was so thick that he felt like he would choke. Max was waiting at the top of the stairs, bratty face pinched as he slowly made his way up.

“Did you know she was coming?” She whispered loudly.

“No.”

She shot him an unimpressed look before opening the door to his room. He stepped forward, so they both stood in the door frame, taking it all in. Swallowing, Billy made the first step, Max trailing behind him.

“Where are the boxes?”

“Back of the wardrobe,” he replied, opening the drawers. His body ached, and whenever he bent down, he blinked back tears.

“Billy?” Max said cautiously. “You need your medicine?”

“Please,” he choked out.

She scurried out of the room, and further down the hall, the bathroom door opened. Billy took deep breaths as he waited, the pain lapping at his spine like waves, ebbing and flowing. Max returned, rattling the pill bottle, and Billy swallowed two dry before slumping onto his bed.

He rubbed at his chest and his leg, trying to mitigate some of the pain as Max hovered over him. “What?” he spat.

“Are you sure you want to leave? You’re still hurt.”

Billy regarded her through his wet eyelashes. Max looked genuinely concerned, but the last few weeks had been hard, and Billy didn’t care anymore. Max wanted to pretend the mall hadn’t happened when Billy actually needed help. Still, now that someone else was willing to take on the burden, she suddenly cared? Bullshit.

“Max,” Billy said firmly, “You didn’t care when I got out of the hospital, so I don’t need you to care now.”

“I did care!”

“Then tell me what happened.”

She bit her lip.

“Help me pack,” he said when seconds passed with no reply, “and you won’t have to see me again. You can pretend I died like you so obviously wanted me to.”

Max flinched violently, and her eyes filled with tears. “I didn’t.”

Rolling his eyes, Billy hauled himself up and shoved things into the boxes. Books and cologne and spare pieces of jewellery. “Doesn’t matter anymore anyway. I tried to be better after I almost died, but I guess I was too much of a piece of shit to acknowledge.”

“That’s not true!” Max protested, fists tightening in his red shirt. “I was so scared for you, Billy. I just needed time and space.”

Billy went quiet, letting the last photo frame fall into the box with a clatter. “And I needed to know that I wasn’t insane.”

“Bil–”

“Max.” He turned and dumped the box on the bed, yanking his shirt from her hands. “Look, I was a terrible brother to you, okay? I know that. But these last few weeks have made me realise that you’re not that great of a sister either. I’ve been in pain every day, still driven you and your shitty friends around, and all I got was you telling my dad whenever I picked you up late. I’m still hurt and in pain, because I got impaled by a monster, and then my dad still beat the shit outta me. So sorry if I’m done trying to play nice, Max. I almost died, and I don’t know what for.”

Max didn’t say anything, but she nodded. Her red hair fell like a sheet over her face, which meant she was probably crying, but Billy didn’t care anymore. He and Max weren’t family, weren’t siblings, just two kids forced together like two ends of the same magnetic force. Always being repelled.

Everything would be better when he left with his mama.

His mama. Who had come back after ten years. With her golden curls and blue eyes, and freckles. Billy had taken one look at her and forgiven her for everything.

Because she was taking him home. To the sun and the beach and the waves. To California. And that’s all Billy ever wanted.


His dad wouldn’t look at him as the boxes were loaded into the Camaro. They had shoved down the seats in the back, laid down some of the old newspaper from the rubbish bins and forced his mama’s motorbike in the back. She and Max were now trying to force the boxes of Billy’s shit around it, wedging them comfortably.

Susan was standing in the living room window. He wouldn’t miss her. Maybe with Billy gone, she’d finally take responsibility for her daughter. Neil hadn’t hit Max before, but Billy wouldn’t be there to take the hits anymore. Hopefully, Susan wouldn’t turn away when it came to Max.

But…

Max shoved another box full of books between his legs, where he was sitting in the passenger seat. There was no way he’d make it to Cali if he drove. The pills dulled the pain, but any shifting in his legs still sent splinters of pain up his spine.

Billy grabbed her wrist gently this time. Max looked at him, curious, not scared. He beckoned her closer. She rolled her eyes and obliged.

“If he hits you,” Billy whispered, “call El. She’ll tell me, and I’ll come get you.”

Max eyed him but jerked a nod. He didn’t know if she would, but he would come if she called. Always. “Or go to Harrington.”

Harrington. Billy hadn’t thought about him, which was probably good. Now that he was leaving, Billy let himself acknowledge that he liked Steve Harrington, sexually, romantically, whatever. But he also knew the other hated him.

Even if Max was glad Billy survived, Steve Harrington was not. And Billy was tired of loving people who didn’t love him back. Steve Harrington was one boy, pretty and rich. But Billy didn’t need him to be happy.

Mama got in the car. The engine purred as it woke, and she smiled at him. “Ready to go home, baby?”

“Yeah.”

He was so happy.

Chapter 2: little bit better than i used to be

Notes:

title from 'Live Wire' by Mötley Crüe

harringroveweek, day 3 prompts:

Molly Ringwald’s Wish: Second Chances/to Rewind Time
Gift Wrapped: A Real Big Knife (implied)
How Many Candles on the Birthday Cake: 18 years old
Cake Slice: Microwave Dinner

yay! second chapter!

everyone who wanted rosexjoyce, you are very welcome

but sorry for the steddie content, i just needed it for steve :( also, hopper's fully dead cuz I'm not dealing with that rn

tw: unhealthy relationships (steddie), steddie (lol), drug use that borders on abuse, ableist slurs (directed at El)

enjoy :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Since Starcourt mall, Steve has had nightmares. They were different from the ones before, which had been demodogs and the Mind Flayer and things that seemed so unreal that he could pretend they weren’t. But the nightmares that plagued him after the mall were different, so much more real.

Because they were people. Billy. Heather. Killing. Dying. Possessed and predatorial and real. Steve dreamt about Billy Hargrove dying every night until he moved away. After that, Steve pretended he was dead after all.

But the nightmares left him hollow, mean. He yelled at Robin, at Dustin, jumping at shadows and unable to sleep. Eddie introduced him to weed, and that became Steve’s lifeline.

Maybe that’s why he couldn’t stand to look at Billy Hargrove when he got out of the hospital, why he turned his back and refused to interact because seeing Billy Hargrove and the scars and the pain made the nightmares real. And Steve really couldn’t handle that right now.

Had it been wrong to take it out on Billy when the other was struggling just as much? Probably. But Steve didn’t care that much.

Then Billy moved away. Max told them all later that his mum came back, eyes rimmed red. She had come back, and Billy hadn’t even hesitated to agree to go.

“Good riddance,” Dustin muttered too loudly. Max didn’t speak to him for the rest of the week.

Now that the party was in high school, Steve filled his days at the video store with Robin and his nights smoking weed with Eddie in the other van. He felt himself drift through the days and told himself he was recovering.

(it wasn’t)

Eddie Munson had been a surprise. They never got along when Steve was in school. Eddie was loud and annoying, constantly standing on tables and yelling and shit. They fought like cats and dogs, so it shocked Steve when Eddie offered him a blunt (for free!) three days after the mall fire.

“You look like you need it,” Eddie said.

Steve sucked on it gratefully. “Thanks.”

Eddie’s eyes crinkled, and that had been it. Steve went back over and over, paying copious amounts of money to get high with Eddie Munson. There had been moments when Steve wanted to try something harder, but Eddie said he wouldn’t do it with him then.

As September turned to October, Steve felt Eddie pull away. “This year is going to be my year,” he kept saying, and well… Steve didn’t like being alone.

The first time Steve and Eddie kissed, Steve thought of Billy Hargrove.

Thought out Billy Hargrove when he ran his hands through Eddie’s hair. Thought about Billy Hargrove when they were naked in bed. When they listened to music, when they ate, showered, and worked. Billy, Billy, Billy.

Steve really hated Billy.


Billy hadn’t expected to get along with Jonathan Byers this much. The other had always been slightly creepy, but he had alright taste in music and was willing to drive Billy when he needed out the house.

The month in California was better than the past two years in Hawkins. Getting out the car had been like awakening from a nightmare. The air, although not exactly like San Diego, still had a faint salty tang, and the sun shone down on him as if welcoming him home.

He would never admit it, but alone in his new room, with his mama singing in the kitchen downstairs, Billy Hargrove cried.

Of course, things weren’t all better. He still had days where the slightest movement made him want to throw himself off a cliff, nights where all he saw was the monster and the people he killed, and moments where he felt nothing he did mattered. But, here in Cali, with his mama and the Byers, those days were easier to get through.

Living with his mama was great. She seemed to understand what he needed and when he needed it. His door was always open unless he decided to close it, they alternated chores, and Billy never got in trouble when he couldn’t manage them. There was no alcohol in the house, but Billy found he didn’t need it. They had a garden, where they spent afternoons reading in the sun together with the sound of twittering birds in their ears.

One weekend, she drove him to the beach. After three hours on the road, Billy bawled in the soft, white sand as soon as he stepped onto the beach. He couldn’t enter the water; his body felt too weak. But they collected seashells and sunbathed.

They lay the shells on the pathway to the door, amongst the flowers and the little porcelain cat Joyce had bought them. To help Jane with her coordination, they spent weekends making wind chimes and painting pottery, like everything was finally okay.

*

Jonathan stuck close to Billy at school, eyes sharp on Billy’s every move. Whenever Billy looked remotely tired, Jonathan was there to carry his books and help him in and out of the car. After the first week, Billy couldn’t find it in himself to be embarrassed. He had almost fallen down three flights of stairs the first time he refused, and if it hadn’t been for Jonathan’s new friend Argyle, Billy could’ve been seriously hurt.

Will and Jane (or El) had started high school as well. Billy often saw them in the corridors together, like two baby deer lost in the woods. Jane loved high school, so when the bullying started, it hit her hard.

These were the moments when Billy wished his body was whole. People weren’t that scared of him anymore. Intimidated? Sure, he had survived a ‘fire’ after all. But they were not scared.

“I don’t get it,” Jane told him sadly, staring at her backpack. Someone had written ‘retard’ in permanent marker. Will painted over it with flowers, but Jane wore a black backpack for the rest of the semester anyway.

As October slipped into November, everything seemed to settle into something softer. Jane’s bullies left her alone after Billy (and Jonathan) cornered them one day after school. It had been a good day, body-wise, so Billy pulled out the big knife that belonged to his grandfather and pointed it directly at them. It seemed to work quite well.

One day in November, Joyce invited Rosé around for dinner. This wasn’t unusual, they were around most nights, but it seemed very formal.

“Just the two of us?” she asked, hands twisting her baggy jumper.

Rosé’s face went red, and she nodded shakily. Joyce beamed and turned to Billy. “Is it okay for mine to come over here? You can order pizza or something?” She held out a ten-dollar bill.

Billy glanced between them, took stock of their flushed faces and immediately knew what was happening. “Sure.” He slipped the note into his jean pocket. “Have fun.”

Watching his mama prepare for her date with Joyce Byers made Billy smile. He sat on her bed as she held two shirts against her chest. “Red or blue?” she asked.

“Red. We look good in red.”

She smiled. “We do, don’t we?” She put on a red shirt.

Jonathan, Will and Jane arrived at seven, all grinning and giggling.

“Mum’s so nervous,” Jonathan said, removing his shoes. “She kept freaking out about her hair. Especially compared to your mum’s ‘bouncing curls’”

Billy laughed and closed the door, smiling at his mama being let into the house next door. “I actually can’t believe it. Mama was nervous as well.”

Jane giggled before she frowned. Will patted her on the shoulder.

“What’s wrong?”

“Mike,” she muttered, crossing her arms.

Will looked uncomfortable. “Mike finally replied to her letter.”

Both Jonathan and Billy looked unimpressed. Neither of them liked little Wheeler that much. “What did he say?” Jonathan asked as they walked into the lounge.

As Jane removed the crinkled letter from her pocket, Will immediately started looking through the movies in the cupboard. It was actually two letters, and when Billy looked closer, he realised one was Jane’s.

“Wait.” Jonathan leant close. “Did he fucking correct your spelling?”

Jane nodded sadly. “I tried really hard.”

“I know you did,” Billy told her. She had written the letter at his kitchen table, after all.

She tucked the letter away again, looking forlorn. “Why don’t you help Will choose a movie whilst me and Jonathan order pizza, okay? And we can ignore your stupid, condescending boyfriend.”

“Con-de-scen-ding?”

“It means that he’s treating you like a child, and it’s incredibly rude.”

“He’s trying to help?” she sounded unsure.

Billy scoffed. “Anyone who thinks that’s helping needs to be dumped immediately.”

Jane smiled. “You and Max are more similar than you think.”

“Never say that again.” But he was smiling as he left the room.

Jonathan was already looking at the menu when Billy joined him. “Fuck Mike Wheeler,” he whispered.

“Fuck him,” Billy agreed. “How many should we get?”

“Four.”

They ordered the pizza and waited. Jane came through to tell them that they would be watching Never-ending Story and The Karate Kid.

When the pizza arrived, they spread out on the couches, turned off the overhead lights, and settled to watch her movies. Billy wondered how mama and Joyce were getting on and whether they had kissed yet.

After the pizza, they switched to the karate movie, and Billy fell asleep halfway through.

*

The next morning, he woke up to giggling. As he forced his eyes open, he came face-to-face with Will and Jane leaning over him. “Mornin’”

“Morning!” Jane giggled. “Your mama finally came home.”

“What?”

Will was grinning as well. “We think she stayed overnight with mum. It’s ten now, and she only just walked through the door.”

Billy paused, heard his mama upstairs and burst into laughter. His body shook, and his scars twinged, but it didn’t matter. Billy didn’t think he’d laughed this much, ever.

The Byers went home just before lunch to interrogate Joyce, leaving Billy and his mama in the kitchen. As soon as the front door clicked shut, Billy turned to her with a grin.

“So?”

She went red and sipped her coffee.

“How’d it go?”

“Good.” He could see the red spreading across her shoulders.

“Did you kiss?”

“Billy!” She paused. “Yes.”

Lucky for his mama, Joyce loved it as well. It was kinda gross how wrapped up in each other they were. None of them had ever witnessed a relationship with all smiles and giggles, only smiles and giggles. With their dads, there had been the sinister undertone of pretending everything was okay. Hence, the budding relationship between their mothers was an experience for them all.

November turned to December and then Christmas. It would be Billy’s first Christmas since mama left. Neil was never a massive fan of it, Susan and Max were the only ones who ever really did anything, and Billy never got presents since he was eight.

But the Byers were already there on Christmas morning when he made his way downstairs. Jane enthusiastically shoved her present into his hands before dragging him to the lounge. His mama made pancakes, and they opened presents, and Billy felt loved. Truly loved.

He called Max after lunch.

“Merry Christmas. How’ya doing, shitbird?”

“Merry Christmas and fine.” He could feel her shrug. “Got some new mixtapes and shit. Mum got me another dress.”

“Gross,” Billy replied. She laughed. “You could probably give it to Jane for her birthday.”

“Maybe.”

“You still planning on visiting during spring break?”

“Yeah.” There was a pause, and then she whispered, “I can hear Neil coming down. Gotta go.”

“Be careful, yeah?”

“Always.” She hung up.

Billy put the phone back on the hook and returned to the kitchen. While Jonathan listened to his new mixtape, Will and Jane were doing their new colouring books at the table. Joyce and Rosé were in the garden.

“That Max?” Jane asked, handing him a blue colouring pencil.

“Yeah. She’s okay. Still planning on visiting during spring.”

“Good,” she smiled. “Mike said something came up in his last letter. But it might’ve been because I told him you were mad about him spell-checking me.”

“He deserved it.”

She shrugged. “Being away from him has made me realise that I don’t want a relationship right now.”

Billy and Will exchanged grins. “Good for you.”


Steve asked Max how she felt about Eddie. The boys had joined his club and seemed to worship the ground he walked on, but Steve wasn’t sure anymore. He liked Eddie well enough, how carefree he was, how oblivious he truly was to the horrors of the world.

She shrugged. “He’s okay. I think Mike and Dustin are kinda weird around him like they keep trying to impress him. Why?”

Steve shrugged and handed her the tape she came for. He and Eddie didn’t hang out as much anymore, with Eddie playing in a band and genuinely trying in school now. It annoyed Steve when Eddie blew him off to be tutored by Chrissy Cunningham, but he was trying to improve with that. They weren’t dating.

“He kinda reminds me of Billy,” he said suddenly.

Max shot him a weird look. “What?”

“Doesn’t he seem like a nicer version of Billy? They both like the same music and shit.”

Max slid him the money and pulled a face. “Billy is nice in his own way. He’s getting better.”

“He is? Didn’t he break up El and Mike?”

“Jane, and no, he didn’t. She told me that Mike had been saying certain things in his letters that neither Jonathan nor Billy liked.”

“Right.”

That was the other problem. Whenever Steve was around Eddie, he still thought about Billy. It was distracting now. He dreamt about him sometimes, blond hair instead of brown, blue eyes blinking up at him, red, parted lips.

“Bye, Steve.” Max rolled her eyes and walked away.

Robin tapped him on the shoulder. When he looked over, she raised an eyebrow. “Why are you comparing Eddie to Billy?”

“Eddie just seems like a nicer version of Billy.”

“You’ve never had an actual conversation with Eddie Munson.”

Steve felt his cheeks heat up. Robin gasped and slapped his shoulder. “What the fuck, Steve? You and Eddie Munson?”

He shrugged. “We’re not dating or anything. It’s just a distraction.”

She frowned, squinted her eyes and then nodded. They tidied up in silence, and then she asked, “So, why are you comparing him to Hargrove?”

Steve paused. “I don’t know. I just… I think of Billy when I’m with Eddie.”

“Kinda weird. I’d be insulted if the girl I’m making out with was thinking of someone else as she does it.”

“It’s not like that!”

She grimaced and patted him on the back. “Kinda seems like it is.”

*

That night, Steve lit a blunt, sat by his pool and thought about Billy. About the first day he saw him, in all his Californian glory. The days on the basketball court with Billy pressed on and around him, in the showers, when they made eye contact across the room. The Halloween party and the fight at the Byers, where Steve’s hand had touched Billy’s warm chest before the other smashed a plate over his head.

But he also thought about that summer and the pool and the possession. How they were all so willing to let Billy Hargrove die. Then the aftermath, where Billy’s mangled body lay in the hospital, and all Steve could think about was that girls wouldn’t be into him anymore. The confusing relationship between El (Jane!) and Billy because she’d barely spoken to Steve. Max told them that Billy was asking questions she didn’t want to answer.

Steve remembered the first time he saw Billy’s scars. He couldn’t bare to look at them. How did Billy feel then? Did Steve make him feel ashamed? He hadn’t meant to.

Steve didn’t like Billy Hargrove. But he really, really wanted to.

The next day, after school, the party came to visit him. Mike was still a little shit, even more so without Will and Jane to soften him. Dustin wouldn’t stop talking about Eddie, and Lucas seemed pissed at them again (something about a basketball game?). Max looked like she didn’t want to be there.

As the boys wandered off amongst the shelves, Steve bit his lip and turned to Max. She caught his eye, crossed her arms and scowled. “What?”

“Do you think I can come with you over the break?”

She raised an eyebrow. “Why?”

Steve sighed and mumbled, “I want to see Billy.”

“Billy? Why?”

“I – I just need to talk to him, okay?”

“Is this about when you kept asking about Eddie?”

“Kinda.”

She looked him up and down. “I’ll ask.”

“Who?”

“Billy.”

“What?” He leaned forward. “You can’t tell Billy.”

“I can and will. He’ll hate it if you visit unannounced.”

“Okay,” Steve muttered as she walked away. “Okay.”

He’ll probably regret it.


Will’s birthday was spent to themselves. He didn’t have many friends and didn’t want a party, so the two families (almost one) spent the day at an art gallery. They ate cake and watched movies, Will got a call from his friends in Hawkins, who Jane refused to speak to.

“Max wants to talk to you,” Will said, holding the phone. His cheeks were slightly red from talking to Mike, which Billy was still against. He took the phone.

“What’s up, shitbird?”

“Steve Harrington wants to visit for your birthday.”

“What the fuck.”

He could hear her shrug again. “I don’t know. He keeps asking, so I said I would ask you.”

Billy was silent. He hadn’t thought about Steve Harrington since he left. He didn’t want to think about him. It hurt too much.

He bit his lip. he had no idea why Harrington wanted to visit, but there must be an important reason.

Maybe…

Don’t get your hopes up.

“Billy?”

“Sure,” Billy told her. Maybe it would bring him closure, if nothing else. “See you soon, shitbird.”

“Bye, Billy. Tell your mum that Steve’s coming then.”

He hung up and pressed his forehead to the wall. Dishes clink in the kitchen, and faint laughter echoed. Billy took a deep breath.

As he entered the kitchen, his mama was hovering near the door, eyes concerned.

“You okay, baby?”

“Um, someone else wants to visit for my birthday.”

“Oh,” she raised an eyebrow, “who?”

“Um.” He could feel himself go red. “Steve. Harrington.”

“You’ve never spoken about him before.”

Billy shrugged uncomfortably. He’s never spoken about his feelings for Steve out loud. “It’s… complicated.”

“Maybe this visit will uncomplicate it.”

“Maybe.”

*

The day before his birthday, Max and Steve Harrington flew in. Billy and Rosé went to pick them up at the airport. They didn’t talk in the car; Billy woke up with the worst pain that morning. He had his sunglasses on to block out the worst of the light, the car was playing soft classical music, so his headache didn’t get worse, and he’d taken four pills that morning.

They pulled into the parking lot. “The plane lands in an hour. Do you want to wait inside or here?”

“Here,” he muttered. “Quieter.”

“Of course, baby.” She passed him a water bottle, and he gratefully took a sip. “You excited to see Max and Steve?”

“Sure.”

Rosé was excited to finally meet Max and Steve properly. She’d made up the two spare rooms with Joyce’s help whilst Will and Jane set out to decorate. Jonathan had been more unsure about Steve than Billy, but there was an excited air in the house that morning.

Sooner than expected, his mama corralled him out of the car. The artificial lights of the airport were too bright, so Billy put on his glasses again. He slumped into a seat near the arrival gate and drank more water.

“You okay?” Mama whispered.

“Yeah.”

Around them, people moved to and fro. The noise level was manageable, so Billy allowed himself to relax. He blinked slowly, rested his head on his mama’s shoulder, and let her steady breathing centre him.

He blinked and heard the announcement of the Indianapolis plane landing. He sat bolt upright before clutching his head when the pain spiked. Rosé patted his shoulder gently, “You can stay seated, baby. Max’s red hair will make it obvious.”

“Okay.”

They didn’t have to wait long. Max’s red hair was obvious amongst the crowd, and Harrington was taller than most passengers. Rosé stood and waved, calling to them. Max lit up when she saw them, grabbing Steve’s arm and weaving through the crowd.

“Hi!” She seemed excited and awkward, staring at Rosé with awe. Behind her, Steve just seemed awkward.

“Hi, Max.” Mama hugged her before pulling back and looking at her face closely. “Are you okay?”

“Yeah,” Max said quietly like no one had asked her that. She turned to Billy, still slumped over, palms rubbing his forehead. “Hi, Billy.”

“Hey.”

She sat on the seat next to him, close enough that he could feel her body heat, but she didn’t touch him. “You okay?” She whispered.

“Bad day.”

“Hello, Mrs uh….” Harrington was saying.

“I still use Hargrove, but you can call me Rosé.” She held out her hand. When he took it, she pulled him into a hug. “And you must be Steve. We were surprised when you asked to come, but I’m delighted.”

“Oh. Thanks.”

They pulled apart, and Steve turned to Billy. “Hi, Billy,” he said cautiously.

“S’up, Harrington.” He squinted behind his sunglasses before letting out a lone moan and breathing heavily through the pain. “Fuck,” he hissed.

“Okay,” Mama said gently, “Let’s get in the car.”

Max helped Billy stand up, and they shuffled towards the exit as Steve and Rosé carried the bags. He could feel Steve’s penetrating stare, and his headache worsened.


Steve didn’t know what to expect from Billy and his mum. Truthfully, he didn’t actually know why he was here in the first place. It had been a shock when Billy agreed for Steve to come. But he went through with it because he was many things, but he was not a quitter.

The plane was fine. Max seemed nervous because it was her first time, but she calmed down after vehemently denying taking Steve’s hand.

When they landed, Max had spotted them before Steve had and pulled him through the crowd, grinning wildly.

Steve first noticed that Billy’s mum looked so much like her son. They both had the same blond curls and blue eyes; her freckles were more prominent, and they had the same facial shape. She was standing to greet them, pulling Max into a hug immediately.

As they talked, Steve turned his attention to Billy Hargrove. He was slumped over, wearing sunglasses indoors and rubbing his forehead as if in pain. Hung-over?

Didn’t seem like it. Max said that Billy didn’t drink anymore.

Max and Billy’s mum separated, and then Steve was subject to her knowing blue gaze. She told him to call her Rosé and hugged him. As she did so, Steve wondered if this was how Billy’s hugged. He wanted to find out.

“Bad day,” he heard Billy say as Rosé pulled away.

Steve turned to Billy. “Hi, Billy.”

“S’up, Harrington.” His voice sounded gravelly. Steve vaguely remembered Max telling them that Billy had been drinking chemicals when he was possessed and that his voice had been impacted by it. “Fuck!” Billy hissed, leaning forward.

Rosé nervously gestured them out, casting a worried eye at Billy as he and Max stumbled to the car. “Is he okay?” Steve asked.

“Some days are better than others.” Rosé shot him a weak smile. “The fire took a lot from him.”

Steve flinched at the mention of the mall. He didn’t want to admit his role in the aftermath, and how he thought Billy would get better. Because watching him now, Steve felt something like guilt well in his chest.

“I’m glad you’re here,” Billy’s mother said. “He was so nervous.”

Wonder why, Steve thought bitterly.

They arrived at the car. It was Billy’s Camaro, but he didn’t seem to be driving it.

Billy didn’t talk during the journey. The music played softly. Steve stayed quiet as the landscape floated by.

*

Finding out that Billy and Jonathan were neighbours was a shock. Neither seemed impressed with him as Billy downed two pills. Jonathan just seemed uncomfortable around him. They never really got along, not even after the ‘incident’ and subsequent apology.

However, Will and Jane seemed happy to see him, so that was nice.

Joyce hugged him when she saw him as well, happy that he’d come to visit. Steve didn’t have the heart to tell her he didn’t know she was here.

They stayed for dinner, seven people around the small Hargrove table. Steve didn’t feel uncomfortable, but it had been a long time since he’d eaten dinner with other people. He let himself sink into the noise but found himself watching Billy throughout.

Max explained the chronic pain to him, which did not help Steve’s guilt pit.

The Byers left at eight, leaving Steve alone in a house with people he didn’t really know. Before he could break the silence, Billy asked to go upstairs.

“Of course you can, baby,” Rosé replied.

Billy struggled to get up the stairs. His door shut quietly.

“Steve?” Rosé asked kindly, “Is there anything you want to watch?”

*

Late that night, as the rest of the household slept, Steve went downstairs for a glass of water. Oddly, the light was on in the kitchen, but as Steve peered through the doorway, he realised it was just Billy.

“Hey,” he greeted quietly.

Billy was slumped at the table, book in front of him, bags dark beneath his eyes. “Hi.”

“Um, where are the glasses?”

Billy pointed at a cupboard. As Steve poured himself a glass of water, he noticed the microwave was on. “You hungry?”

“Yes.”

“Oh.” Steve awkwardly sat down beside him. “Are you okay?”

Sighing, Billy closed the book and stared. “What do you think? I was possessed by a monster, my body was destroyed, and the aftermath was the worst. Do I look okay?”

“No.” The microwave beeped. Unsteadily, Billy stood. “I can get that.”

Billy waved his hand. “No. I can do it.” As he puttered around the kitchen, getting cutlery and a bowl, Steve watched as his hands trembled, saw the scars wrapped around his ribs.

“Billy,” he said, “I’m sorry.”

Billy paused in eating, staring. “For what?”

“Everything. Not trying to save you during the mall, taking my trauma out in you afterwards, everything else.”

“It’s okay.”

“It’s not.” Steve reached out and took his hand. “I’ve done a lot of thinking.” Billy looked unsure and exhausted, but Steve pushed through. “And I think I messed up.”

Billy snorted. “Billy,” Steve said seriously. “I really want to like you. I just need you to give me a chance.”

Silence. Billy stared at their hands. Then, “Okay.”

“Yeah?”

“Yes.”

“Okay.” Steve squeezed his hand. “I’m going to kiss you now.”

Billy nodded shakily. And they kissed. It was soft and unsure, everything that Steve knew Billy Hargrove was and was not. He wanted to crawl into this boy, pull him close and never let go.

They parted. Steve glanced at the clock. “Happy birthday.”

Billy smiled.

Notes:

thank you sm for reading. comments, kudos, bookmarks, and anything you're willing to give is very much appreciated.

i don't know is steddie was actually unhealthy but i don't think it is so that's why i tagged that.

do you think billy and steve will be okay? idk *shrugs*

anyway, follow me! tumblr

Notes:

thank you sm for reading :D

comments, kudos, bookmarks etc etc are very much appreciated

yea this is outta 2 because i'm using another prompt for this, so stick around ig

ALSO, i was kinda considering rosé x joyce??? what do you guys think??

anyway

follow me! tumblr

Series this work belongs to: