Actions

Work Header

room for (mis)understandings

Summary:

in which hobbits have some concerning practices when it comes to consent and the dwarves don't take to that knowledge very well

Notes:

PLEASE SEE THE END NOTES FOR spoilers about the consent issues, dub con, non-con mentions if this is a concern to you. there is no actual non-con, and it's very clear from bilbo that there is no non-con (or even dub-con), but he says something that makes the dwarves genuinely and extremely concerned about his relationship with thorin.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

“Well, I could hardly say no, could I?” Bilbo tells the company with a little nervous laugh when they casually ask about his… ‘encounters’ with Thorin.

They do not laugh with him, though, and it makes Bilbo even more anxious. He’s not sure why they’re asking to begin with, but he cannot imagine it being anything else than making sure he’s pleasing to their king.

But then, very softly, Bofur asks, “what do you mean ‘you could hardly say no,’ Bilbo?”

Bilbo looks up, realizing that they’re all looking at him with very serious frowns. He’s gone and done something wrong again and he’s not even sure what it was this time. He was so sure he had been doing alright; Thorin hadn’t even complained, not once!

“Well. He’s the king. I mean, there cannot be any higher position than that, surely,” Bilbo says, trying for levity and probably failing by a mile. “Maybe the wizard, of course, but of course that’s the reason Gandalf never propositions hobbits, you know,” he jokes, but of course it falls flat and it only seems to make them more upset. Of course.

“Bilbo,” Fíli says very seriously. “What do you mean you couldn’t have said ‘no’ to uncle Thorin?”

Bilbo frowns. “Well, I mean. You know. When someone from a more influential family propositions you, of course you couldn’t say no.” Fíli makes a noise of distress and when Bilbo looks at him, it almost looks like he’ll cry, and that’s the last thing the hobbit needs, to make the prince cry, after he’s been so nice to Bilbo. “I mean,” Bilbo isn’t sure if it’d be better to keep his mouth shut now, but he finds himself incapable of it regardless. “Of course I’m from a high family, so there’s hardly anyone in the Shire who would ask me, as it is. I’m expected to ask myself, obviously, but I could hardly ever do it, you know? It just didn’t feel right.”

The dwarves all seem to make urgent sounds of agreement. “It’s just… I didn’t want to be wanted for my status or my family ties or what have you,” Bilbo tugs at his little ruined coat. “And well, I’m not the most attractive or entertaining of hobbits, of course, no matter how respectable,” here Bilbo laughs. “Though I can hardly be called respectable anymore so I’d hardly have anyone come asking now, I suppose.”

To this, the dwarves gasp and Fíli goes to walk away, muttering something about bringing justice down on his uncle’s head.

“So you’ve been disgraced,” Ori says, very softly. The dwarves know, from all the years walking through human settlements, that some creatures out there subscribe to  such practices, of shaming their members from their pre-marital relations, even when or if they weren’t exactly welcomed.

“Well, I say!” Bilbo splutters, “I’d hardly call myself that, Ori. It really doesn’t matter, you understand. Of course, it’s not like Thorin was ever going to ask me for marriage or some such silly thing. Obviously. I know some of the more respected fellows just like. You know. A bedmate, for a while. Before they chose a spouse,” Bilbo blushes. They all must know this, so he thinks it’s hardly fair that they’re questioning him on this now, when it’s been so many months and so much distance.

“But so you don’t even like uncle Thorin then!” Kíli cries out, startling Bilbo and causing Balin to slap him on the shoulder with a chastising frown.

Kíli puts his head on his hands and sobs, making Bilbo panic. He’s gone and made the prince cry after all. He really thought he’d been doing alright. Bollocks.

“Well, I mean,” and Bilbo really didn’t think he could blush harder. “I mean. I didn’t have to keep going back, of course,” he says and really hopes they can leave it at that. He hardly thinks the boys would want to hear all about what their uncle has been getting into with the silly hobbit. Hardly thinks it matters if he’s, you know, fallen in love or whatever other silly thing at all. “I just figured, since most of you are related and all, of course he wouldn’t ask one of you. And then he would just send me away and none of you would have to deal with me being there once Thorin does choose a spouse. It’s just… more convenient, I understand.” Kíli just sobs harder, and now Bilbo really is at a loss. What could he have possibly done to offend the prince this badly. He was sure they all already knew about him and Thorin. “Oh bother. Don’t cry, Kíli. I really don’t know what I’ve done this time that’s upset you. Just. Just tell me and I’ll apologize properly. Truly, I’m really sorry, whatever it is that I’ve done. I don’t,” he swallows, because it’ll hurt to say the next part but he knew it’d hurt regardless of when he had to follow through, be it now or at the end of the journey, “I don’t have to. I mean. I’ll just leave your uncle alone, if it really bothers you this much. You are his family so I understand. If you had said something, I wouldn’t. I mean I wouldn’t have. That is to say, of course you don’t approve but I just thought. If there are rules against it, I’m very sorry,” though his voice is very small by then, so he clears his throat and tries again. “I’m sorry. For upsetting you all. You are my friends,” Bilbo nods, then smiles sadly when he thinks about it again. “For my part,” because him considering himself their friend does not mean they must reciprocate, and surely after all this they won’t be seeing him as a friend at all, considering their reaction. “And I hope you’ll forgive me the offense. And that you’ll explain it also, if you don’t mind, so that I can apologize properly.”

“He is the one who should be leaving you alone,” Bilbo hears Bofur mutter darkly.

“You do not need to apologize for anything, master Baggins,” Fíli says, having returned from wherever it is he went to fetch his uncle who was supposed to be fishing and appears to have returned with no fish at all, and is looking like he’s lost all of his color, his wide eyes firmly in Bilbo. Rats, Bilbo was really looking forward to that fish. “It is Thorin who has brought shame upon our name.”

Bilbo feels affinity with Thorin then, suddenly all his color leaving his body. “Shame?” He says faintly. “Thorin,” he walks toward the dwarf, the bottom of his stomach dropping all the way to his feet when the dwarf flinches at the hobbit’s tentative approach. “Thorin. Thorin, I didn’t mean to tell them. I—they asked me, so I assumed they already knew. You didn’t say—I wouldn’t—I wouldn’t have told them. Please.” Bilbo puts his head on his hands, trying not to tremble, unable to look at any of them. Had he known the dwarves were the kind to find shame on getting involved with a lower class (and of course it’d be the only person Bilbo would want, who could consider him of all people to be lower class), he wouldn’t have opened his dumb mouth. He would have denied it until the day he died. Of course it was a test. Of course they would ask him when Thorin wasn’t present so they could get him to admit to something Thorin may have denied already. Bilbo takes a shuddering breath and tries again. “Please. I won’t say anything again. Nobody else has to know,” he pleads a little desperately. “We can just finish the journey and get your mountain back and then I’ll be on my way and you won’t even need to tell the rest of the dwarves that there was ever a hobbit at all,” he looks up and tries to smile, reassure them there’s no need to blame Thorin for an indiscretion nobody even needs to know about; but by the way Dwalin’s face has gone angry and stony, Bilbo thinks he’s probably not doing a very good job. His own face crumbles when Fíli comes closer and holds his little hands between his own. “I’m so sorry, Fíli. I’m so sorry.”

Thorin is like a father to the boy; never before has Bilbo seen such admiration as the one Fíli has shown for Thorin. Of all the dwarves to have to witness his uncle being shamed, Fíli would be the worse. Bilbo will never forgive himself for it. ‘Not everybody needs to know your business, Bilbo,’ he tells himself, ‘no matter how exciting it may have seemed to you. It should have stayed between you and Thorin.’

 

“Master Baggins,” Fíli says, very softly and with a very kind, small, smile, still holding Bilbo’s little hands. He is so brave, and so strong; they often forget now, that he can also be so very soft and vulnerable. “You needn’t apologize at all. To me or any other dwarf. We owe you a debt, higher than we could ever pay, whether we recover the mountain or not, and we shall escort you home, whenever it is you wish to return, be it today or a whole season later. We were not privy to such practices amongst hobbits, which does not excuse what has been done to you,” Fíli is trying not to cry. Kíli can cry for both of them. It’s not as if Thorin is alone in his shame, when none of them paid enough attention to see. “You’ve said to my brother that, as his family, we could have intervened. And we did not. And so, even if it’s Thorin who has brought upon us this shame, it is all of us who must carry it.”

Bilbo looks up at him, and whatever he sees just makes his face fall further along with tears, like he doesn’t mean to cry but can hardly stop it. “Won’t you call me ‘Bilbo’ again? Before you send me away?” He says, with a heartbroken twist to his mouth.

They haven’t called him ‘Master Baggins’ in a long time, Fíli knows, but. “I hardly think we have the right anymore. After what we’ve done.”

“What are you talking about,” Bilbo cries. “What you’ve done? You haven’t done anything, my boy. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. I should know better than to give my heart away, I’m old enough.”

Fíli can hear his uncle make a wounded noise and, with a fast, sharp move, walk closer until he’s at Bilbo’s feet. Every dwarf has pulled a weapon upon seeing him approach the hobbit, and if Fíli didn’t feel like the entire world would end if he lets go of Bilbo’s hands, he would also pull out all of his knives and demand Thorin paid in blood for the audacity. As it is, he tries to keep his body between the hobbit and his uncle, to keep him from approaching any further.

Mahal loves all his children, Fíli knows, but there is one crime not even He would forgive them for, and it is this. There will be no Remaking of the World for the company of Thorin Oakenshield.

“I would rip every hair out of my head, one by one, and then cut my head from my shoulders with my own sword. I won’t approach you again, though I no longer have anything to swear it by. There is no honor in any of my actions,” Thorin says, and though Fíli wants to feel pride on his uncle’s words, the same way he always has, he can’t help the loop in his head saying ‘why did you do it, then? If you knew it was shameful and horrible, why did you do it? Surely you knew. Surely, Bilbo didn’t need to spell it out for you to know you were forcing your unwanted attention on him.’

“But you say you’ve given your heart away,” Thorin continues and Fíli gasps, freeing a hand to pull a knife after all and point it at his uncle, for surely he’s not trying to talk to the hobbit about love, after what he’s done. But Thorin ignores him and the knife at his throat. "And I won't have it," Bilbo's hands are cold, and he closes his eyes and lets out a sob. "I should have known, that your willingness did not mean yes just because you hadn't said no. That if it was I who sought you out every time, I shouldn't have confused your reluctance to approach me for shyness. I thought you happy," it's as if Thorin's voice wants to give up at the end but he doesn't stop, and Fíli isn't sure now if he wants him to or if he wants to know where he's going, why he feels like he should keep trying. "I wanted to make you my husband," Fíli hears Bilbo gasp, trying to pull his hands away from Fíli's hold. "And you'd have said yes."

Fíli's never seen his uncle cry before, for all the tragedies that have befallen them, but he does now, his eyes firmly on Bilbo while the hobbit still tries to free himself, where Fíli's still unwilling to let him approach the one who wronged him, when he didn't even know he could say no.

"I would have," cries Bilbo, still trying to pull away. "Of course I would have! I love you, Thorin. I do love you, even if you don't want me."

There is something wrong, Fíli thinks; something evil about making a hobbit cry. If he could vow the rest of his life to keep them happy and unbothered, Fíli would.

"You cannot love one you cannot refuse," Thorin denies. Fíli wants to believe his uncle wasn't aware that was the case; that none of them knew, really, that Bilbo believed he couldn't say no to the king. He feels the need to justify their actions, their neglect. But it is unforgivable, even in ignorance. Even if Bilbo would find it within himself to forgive them; even if Bilbo felt like there was nothing to forgive. Fíli really cannot see how they could move past it.

"Bilbo," Fíli startles when he feels Ori's hand on his shoulder, very softly. He didn't hear him approach. Ori takes Bilbo's hands from Fíli, and the prince can't help but feel adrift. "I think there has been a misunderstanding," Ori says. Fíli can hear Dori about to go off on Ori, but for once, Ori doesn't shrink away at the rage of his brother. He is so very gentle when he pulls on Bilbo's hands to make him look at him instead of Thorin. "When you say you couldn't say no, to us it means you could not have then said yes either."

Bilbo frowns at Ori, turning back to Thorin and then back to Ori again, like he's trying to make sense of words he's not really paying attention to. Thorin's on his knees, a severe expression on his face, and won't get any closer to Bilbo.

"What?" Bilbo asks, finally looking directly into Ori's eyes.

"If you cannot say no, Bilbo," Ori says again, "then you cannot say yes either. And if you cannot say yes, then it means that anything that has been done to you has been against your will." Bilbo's eyes go very wide. "To take away someone's agency is an unforgivable crime. One not even our Maker would absolve us of."

"No," the hobbit shakes his head. "No. Thorin didn't do anything I didn't want," his face crumbles again, and Ori mirrors him almost by reflex. "I do love him, Ori. I do love him. I didn't know he wanted to marry me; he's said he'd—he's said he'd m-make me his h-husband. Can we really be wed?"

He whispers the last part, and Fíli feels a deep ache in his heart when he looks at Thorin. He wants there to be hope so badly.

"You have nothing to apologize for, Bilbo," Ori says, because none of them have addressed his earlier apologies yet, and Kíli remains silent and still, having taken out his bow but unable to point it at Thorin. "Because you have done nothing wrong," Bilbo nods slowly, like he's trying very hard to Believe Ori. "But even if you don't believe Thorin has violated your person, he has still wronged you by not learning of your customs before he tried to engage you romantically. And so have all of us, for not realizing."

Bilbo starts crying harder, moving forward to hide his face on Ori's chest. "I don't want Thorin to be beheaded," he says. "I want to marry him. I want to finish the journey and take back your mountain and stay with you and I want to marry him. I don't want you to escort me back to the Shire like some stranger. I don't want you to feel ashamed every time you think of me."

Fíli can hear all of the dwarves inhale sharply. That is not what they were trying to imply to Bilbo when they were talking about the shame upon their name, but he knows it to be true. They would never think of Bilbo again without thinking of how they've shamed him, and to Bilbo it would very much mean the same: that those he considers his friends would forever be ashamed of having ever even come to his smial.

So, Ori brings Bilbo back closer to the fire to sit down, so they can all ask him more about hobbits, and so that Bilbo can ask them about dwarves. Fíli puts his knife back in its sheath and extends a hand out to his uncle, to help him to his feet. There may be hope yet, Fíli thinks when Thorin decides to accept his hand. There may yet be room for clarity.

Notes:

so. i got sick and my brain was like, you know what would make you feel better? waking up at six am and writing some angsty fic after months of not writing anything at all. yay brain, i guess. i'm apparently a big fan of making bilbo sad. i wanted this to have a happy ending but, given the topic, i didn't feel like it could have a proper one.

OK. CLARIFICATIONS ABOUT THE TAGS:
-hobbits appear to practice some type of system in which those of 'lower class' are 'unable' to say no if someone of a 'higher class' tries any romantic/sexual advances with them. Bilbo, being of a higher class, has never actually had to deal with this in any other way than people expecting him to be the one to request such interactions. Bilbo was never interested in having people say yes to him just because of his social standing, but he still doesn't necessarily think anything's wrong with that system.
-this does NOT mean that hobbits are inherently or legally incapable of saying no to someone if their advances aren't welcomed. they've just created a society in which they simply wouldn't say no to those advances, even if they don't lead to marriage. i always think of hobbits as being very sexually liberated, and so they rarely say no to a tumble anyway. and i guess in this universe it kinda translated to "can't say no" in language if nothing else.
-to clarify: no, this is not good or right even if they've made it "normal." it also does not necessarily mean they've normalized rape. rape is not very common with them either, though it's real enough that bilbo is able to understand what's the dwarves' concern eventually. is just that hobbits wouldn't ask someone if they were really in a position to not be able to say 'no', so they've fallen into thinking that there's no need to clarify.
-i don't know if i'm making sense but like, for example: bilbo (hella high class) would not ask someone like hamfast (clearly lower class than bilbo) to engage in anything romantic when it's clear that hamfast is 1. married and 2. may feel obligated to say yes to bilbo considering he's not only wealthy but also his employer.
-there's also still some hobbit that think it's frowned upon to get involved with a lower class; not because of the potential consent issues but because of the status issues. those hobbits are dicks if you ask me.
-i think the language the hobbits are using may be the biggest concern, since they don't seem to understand how it totally leads to consent issues, like bilbo here. as you can see, everything he was trying to say so the dwarves wouldn't be upset was just making things worse.
-dwarves, on the other hand, consider any violations to someone's ability to consent to be absolutely unforgivable. that's my headcanon anyway.
--also, i LOVE fíli being protective of bilbo. i love fíli at large, but him being fond of bilbo to the point he would literally stab his own blood on bilbo's behalf if genuinely justified gives me life. also, him having to cope with his uncle, whom he loves so dearly, doing something so horrible... i live for that tbh
-i feel like it may not be very clear what i mean, which i apologize for, but i'd need a way longer fic to fit in all this hobbit lore and i'm not gonna write a longer one, ngl. feel free to borrow the concept? though i don't think it's a very good one, but i had to write this down, you know?

i tried my best to be respectful with the language and the situation, but if i missed something, please please let me know. i've done my research and i do not take sexual abuse or coercion lightly, but i'm also not perfect and i could have missed or misinterpreted something, for which i apologize in advance, and i'd be very grateful if you could let me know so i can either edit it or delete it or add tags if needed.
remember, no means no. no does not mean yes. silence does not mean yes. going along with something does not always mean yes. talk to your sexual or romantic partners, make sure you're all in the same page, pay attention to how they react to your advances. thorin really couldn't have know this is how bilbo was thinking, but i do think it's true that he still shouldn't just have always assumed it was all good; same way bilbo shouldn't have assumed thorin didn't want anything serious. communication is your best friend.
drink water, take care, be safe out there.

Series this work belongs to: