Actions

Work Header

I'm Too Much

Summary:

When Max needs someone to fill in a role for her school musical that they're putting on for Christmas, her stepfather immediately offers up Billy, if only to humiliate him more than he already does. Billy is reluctant to take the role, but he figures it's easier than to try and go against his father. And anyway, it's for a bunch of kids and old people, he can do that, can't he?
But things get complicated when he finds out that his co-star is none other than Steve Harrington, and the guy directing the show is Eddie Munson. Will this be the worst thing that ever happened to Billy, or will he somehow end up enjoying himself, even dressed in such a ridiculous costume?

Or: Steve, Billy and Eddie are all working together on the school play, and after a little bit of chaos and hilarity, they end up spending the best Christmas of their lives together.

Notes:

I saw a piece of fanart on Tumbr done by @miramelindamusings of Steve and Billy dressed as Snow Miser and Heat Miser from The Year Without A Santa Claus, and my mind took it and ran. So, please enjoy the product of that. Also, if you haven't seen the movie before (or even if you have) I highly recommend it, and I recommend looking up a clip of the song I mention in this story on YouTube just so you can hear it as the boys are singing it. I try to do a special story for Christmas each year, and this is the one for 2022, so please enjoy, and a Merry Christmas to all of you who celebrate it. Love you all, and thanks for reading!

Work Text:

This was the most humiliating thing Billy had ever done, which is certainly saying something. He’d done a lot of embarrassing things in his day, most of which he’d been forced into, and this was no different. But all those other things were mostly done back in Cali, where the population was more than, like, 500 people, and he could brush it off without everyone knowing who he was by the end of it. This wasn’t like that. He knew that he’d be the laughingstock of the entire tiny-ass town of Hawkins by the end of this, but it wasn’t like he had much of a choice. So, with one last long drag of his cigarette and a heavy exhale through his nose, he turned off his car and followed Max through the doors of the school and down the halls to the drama room.

As soon as he saw who was already in there, he was about ready to strangle Max. The rest of her nerdy friends were there, as well as a few other middle schoolers, but there were also a few high schoolers, too, which she had failed to mention the other night when she brought this up at dinner. She’d been complaining about how her friends were putting on a play for the elementary school and the local nursing home for the holidays, but there were still some roles that needed to be filled. They were doing “The Year Without a Santa Claus” , and while they’d gotten most of the major roles filled between herself and her friends, there were still three roles that needed to be casted. 

Obviously, Neil offered Billy up as soon as he could, even though if Billy had asked him to do it out of his own free will, he knew damn well he would’ve beat him and told him only queers got into theater. Still, for precious little Max, Neil would put aside any of his beliefs. Or maybe he was just looking for another excuse to harp on Billy when it wasn’t even his choice. Either way, he’d been offered up for one of the roles, and apparently, he’d gotten it without even needing an audition. They must be pretty fuckin’ desperate.

But as soon as he walked into the drama room, he was ready to turn around and go home, tail between his legs and just deal with whatever punishment Neil would dish out for him. There was no way he was ever going to be able to live this down in general, but to have to make a fool of himself in front of everyone else in the room, that was just too much. But unfortunately, before he could wrench his hand out of Max’s iron grip and run out of the room, someone looked up and saw them. And that someone was Eddie Munson.

“Hey, Red!” He called, waving wildly as he bounded over to them, his shaggy hair bouncing around his shoulders.

“Hey, Eddie!” Max replied, waving back. “You know my brother Billy, right?”

“I’ve seen him around, but we haven’t been properly introduced,” Eddie said, looking up at Billy and holding out a hand. “I’m Eddie, I’m the student director for this little production of ours.”

Billy looked at the hand Eddie held out to him and rolled his eyes, crossing his own arms over his chest and making a face.

“Let’s just get this over with,” he said, brushing past Eddie and slumping in a seat around the table that was set up in the middle of the room. He could already feel the headache forming between his eyes, and it was only made worse when Eddie called the rest of the people in the room to join him around the table. Max and her nerd friends all sat on one side, and Eddie was seated in some sort of throne at the head of the table, ever the dramatic bitch. The high schoolers sat on the same side of the table as Billy, and as soon as he scanned over their faces, he wished one of the sandbags hanging from the rafters would either break and hit him on the head or the ropes holding them up would tangle around his neck and hang him. Not only was Eddie Munson the one running this show, but apparently, along with some of his little groupies, he’d gotten Robin Buckley, Nancy Wheeler, and of all people, Steve Harrington, to join this ragtag group of idiots as well. 

“Alright, settle down, kiddies, let’s get started,” Eddie said, shuffling some papers as everyone quieted down. “So, I’ve got your scripts here, your names are on them, so just find yours and pass the rest down. I was bored last night, so I took the time to highlight your lines for you, along with any stage cues and songs you’ll be singing. Robbie has the score, since she’s the music pit consultant for us, as well as our accompanist when we practice. Anyway, just for today, we’re gonna do a table read, and just try to get to know your characters and who you’ll be interacting with the most. If we get through enough of it, we can see about maybe starting to practice on the stage. But for now, just focus on reading with the rest of us and taking any notes you feel you need. Comprende?”

Everyone mumbled an agreement and Eddie grinned, passing out pens as the scripts were passed around the table. Billy was the last to get his, and he idly flipped through it, not finding a single highlight until at least ten pages in, which he was glad about. At least his part wasn’t going to be that big. But then he saw what the part was, and he wished he was literally anywhere but here. He was playing Heat Miser, which wouldn’t have been that bad a role, but Billy had seen the movie when it was released as a TV special in 1974, and he happened to know that Heat Miser had a whole damn song he had to sing as a duet with Snow Miser. Billy could handle acting, he could handle putting on some makeup and a ridiculous costume and running around like an idiot to make some little kids and some elderly people smile, but he drew the line at singing.

But by the time he’d been able to plot out just exactly where he would bury Max’s body for getting him roped into this, it was nearing time for him to start paying attention, so he just shoved down his pride and tried to pay attention.

The table read went well, Max and her friends were really getting into their characters and finally, it was nearing time for the duet to start. Max and a few of the other kids were the only ones in this scene other than himself and whoever was playing Snow Miser, and they were all trying not to giggle as they delivered their lines.

“Here he comes now, the big ham!” Max read. It was her final line before the song started, and Robin began to hum the intro and tap the beat on the table in front of her, until the part where Snow Miser would start singing.

“Alright, so then Snowy would come dancing his way in with the ensemble behind him and go into the song, Eddie and I will help you learn it probably tomorrow after practice, as long as you can stay a little later to work on it. Since it’s a duet with Heat Miser, you’ll stay after to learn it, too. Is that okay with you both?” Robin asked, looking at whoever was on her left and then over to Billy. He shrugged in response, and Robin seemed satisfied with that, so she leaned back in her chair to mark her score, and Billy’s heart nearly stopped when he saw who was on her left. Steve Harrington. 

Of fucking course.

Billy tuned out for most of the rest of the rehearsal time, only zoning back in when he had a line to deliver, and even then, it wasn’t with much more than a monotone voice and an added eye roll to cap it off. He was the first out the door as soon as it was over, and he considered making Max find another way home so that he could go and smoke at the quarry or something, but she was too fast, and she managed to jump into the passenger's seat just before he pulled out of his parking spot and sped down the street.

“Jesus Christ! Can’t you wait until I’ve got my seatbelt on?! Or at least until I have the door closed!” Max said, making a face at him. 

“Fuck you, shitbird! This is all your goddamn fault, I’ll drive as fast as I fuckin’ want!” Billy seethed back, his foot becoming even heavier on the pedal as he said it. He was pushing 70 on a 35 mph road, and he only kept it below that so that he wouldn’t actually wreck his baby. And besides, even if he did get them in a horrible accident, it wouldn’t get him out of this stupid play. His father would make sure of that.

“I’m not the one who forced you to take the part! I didn’t even want you to do it! One of Eddie’s friends was just about to take the role, but Neil offered you up, and you didn’t say no, so there was nothing I could do!” Max argued, finally getting her belt buckled.

“If one of those nerds was going to do it, then why’d you bring it up in front of Neil in the first place?!” Billy asked, easing off the gas a little. He knew she was right, but it wasn’t like he was going to admit that.

“Because my mom asked me how the play was coming along and I answered her honestly? It’s not my fault Neil jumped down your throat!” Max said, rolling her eyes.

Billy knew he couldn’t argue with that. Instead, he just tightened his grip on the steering wheel and tried to ease himself off the gas a little more. They were getting closer to the town square, and he didn’t need to run someone over or get slapped with a speeding ticket on top of all of this. He let himself get a little lost in thought as he drove through the town, only snapping out of it when he saw Max waving to someone.

“Who’re you waving to?” He asked, going for intimidating, but he didn’t have it in him right now.

“The old ladies over at the nursing home. They always wave whenever they see us passing by since they know me. Dustin’s grandma lives there and sometimes we all go over to visit her. She gives us cookies and we play cards, and she calls us her unofficial grandkids. She’s the one who helped Will make his Will the Wise costume for when they play D&D, and the reason we’re even doing this play in the first place. She told us how lonely the old folks get around the holidays, especially those who don’t have kids or grandkids, and we decided to try and brighten up their holiday. And then Mrs. Wheeler heard about it, and she got to talking with some of the other elementary school moms, and that’s how it got extended to the performance at the elementary school, too. According to Holly, her entire class is counting down the days until the show,” Max explained, picking at her jacket’s zipper as a moment of silence passed between the two. Finally, she sighed and added, “Look, Billy, I know that you’re not happy about this, and I don’t blame you. But without you, the show can’t go on. Eddie’s friend backed out once he found out you’d gotten the role, and we don’t have time to try and find someone else to do it. So as much as it sucks, I’m asking you for just this one favor. And if you don’t want to do it for me, that’s fine, but at least do it for the old folks and the kids. I know you’re always a Grinch when it comes to Christmas, but even the Grinch became nice in the end, and I know you can, too.”

Billy didn’t say anything as Max finished her speech, just sighed through his nose and bit his fingernails as he drove. He once again hated to admit it, but she was right. All he had to do to get through this was swallow his pride and remember that it was for the old folks and the kids.

He could do that, right?

It ended up being a lot easier than he thought it would be. The next day, when they stayed after school to start rehearsing for real, Billy didn’t have much that he had to do. They mostly focused on scenes with the Sinclair boy, who was playing Santa Claus, and Max, who was playing Mrs. Claus. For the majority of the rehearsal, Billy sat in the back of the drama room working on his book report for English, only getting up once or twice when they needed his help to move a set piece or hang on to one of the props. Right now, though, he was just relaxing and reading his book, jotting down a few notes and not even noticing when Steve came up and sat beside him.

“Whatcha reading?” He asked, making Billy jump in surprise. He looked up and saw Steve and was about to tell him to fuck off, but he looked genuinely interested, so Billy only sighed.

“Take a look at the cover and you’ll find out, pretty boy,” he replied, marking his page with a notecard and holding the book out to Harrington.

“ Gone With the Wind , huh?” Steve read the cover, then handed it back to Billy with a small smile. “Funny, never pegged you as a romantic drama type of guy.”

“Yeah, well, what type of guy did you think I was?” Billy asked, closing his notebook and capping his pen before shoving all of it into his backpack.

“To be honest, I didn’t even think you could read,” Steve joked, nudging Billy lightly. Billy rolled his eyes and zipped up his bag, turning then to look at Harrington right in his pretty eyes. The other boy stiffened up for a moment under the glare, but he pretended that he didn’t as he added, “No, but seriously, dude, I just thought you weren’t into all this academic stuff. Not many guys our age would be reading Gone With the Wind and look so enraptured by it the way you did. Besides, most of the time the way it works out in Hawkins is you’re either a really good student or a really good athlete, and since you’re a good athlete, I figured you were probably just a shitty student.”

“Well, that’s awfully presumptuous of you, Harrington,” Billy replied, enjoying making Steve squirm under his gaze probably a little too much. “But if you must know, I enjoy reading almost everything. The only thing I can never really get into is non-fiction. And I had to pick something from a specific list the teacher gave for my book report, so I just wrote down whatever. It’s not like it’s hard work, anyway.”

“Billy Hargrove, you never cease to amaze me,” Harrington said, shaking his head, but that smile was still there. 

“What do you mean?” Billy asked, narrowing his eyes again.

“It’s just… It seems like you’re just good at everything you do. You’re the best player on all the sports teams, you’re the life of every party you’re at, you’re handsome, you’re good at talking to people, you’re charismatic, and, apparently, you’re good at academic stuff, too. And you’re willing to help people, too, we probably wouldn’t be sitting here having this conversation right now if it weren’t for you volunteering to be in the show and take on the only role that still needed to be filled. It means a lot to these kids, they were all so disappointed when they found out they might not be able to do it, and then you swooped in and saved it,” Steve looked at him shyly, a little bit of pink dusting across his usually pale cheeks. “I don’t know, man, I just… I never thought I’d respect you as much as I do, but here we are.”

“I’m really not all that…” Billy said, suddenly feeling shy himself, but it wasn’t in the cute way like Steve. Embarrassment and shame twisted in his gut like a bad stomach cramp, making him want to hurl all over himself. Steve had this romanticized version of Billy in his head, but he didn’t know the truth about him. He didn’t know that he excelled at sports and academics because he was afraid of the consequences that would come if he didn’t. He didn’t know that he’d only learned to be charismatic and confident and handsome because he knew he wouldn’t be able to live this long if he didn’t. He didn’t know that he tried to be the life of the party because it shielded him from making a mistake and revealing his darkest secrets. And he especially didn’t know that he was only here and doing this because he was forced into it. If he did, he wouldn’t see him as someone to be admired, but rather someone to be mocked, worth less than gum stuck to the bottom of his shoe.

“I think you are,” Steve said, shrugging, the blush on his cheeks growing just the slightest bit brighter.

“Yeah, well, then stop thinkin’ it, cuz it’s not right,” Billy said, his tone harsher than he intended for it to be. He regretted it, a little, but it got Harrington to shut his trap long enough for Eddie to wrap up the scene he was working on with the kids and turn to address everyone in the room.

“Alright, gang, that’s enough for today. Tomorrow we’ll work on some of the Southland scenes with Will and Lucas, and then if we have time, we’ll start work on the scene with Nancy, Steve and Billy. Speaking of, don’t forget that you two have to stay after so we can work on your song a little bit,” Eddie said, taking a pencil from somewhere in his hair and writing something down, then biting the end of it. He must’ve come to some sort of decision, because he nodded and stuck the pencil back in his locks, then looked up. “The rest of you, I’ll see you tomorrow.”

Everyone grabbed their bags and shouted goodbyes to each other as they left the drama room, heading for the parking lots. Max was hitching a ride with Nancy and the rest of the kids today, so she left with them, and before long, the drama room was empty except for Eddie, Robin, Steve and Billy. Robin was shuffling some papers around as Steve and Billy approached the front of the room, where she and Eddie were sitting.

“Shit! I left my music in my locker, I’ll be right back,” Robin said, jogging to the door and leaving to go get her music.

“Meet us in the auditorium!” Eddie called after her, grabbing some papers of his own and walking to the door at the back of the drama room.

“What are we going in there for?” Steve asked him, following behind with Billy trailing after him.

“There’s better acoustics in there, and the piano in here is horrifically out of tune, so it’s better if we go in there,” Eddie shrugged, leading them to the auditorium doors. He pushed them open and led them down one of the aisles to the stage, leading them up the stairs on the side of it. Once they were standing in the center of the stage, Eddie jumped off, telling the other two to stay there.

“So, I assume you’ve both been looking over your parts so that you know the basic idea, or have at least seen the movie before, right?” Eddie asked, dropping his papers on top of the piano and pulling out his pencil again.

“Yeah,” they both said at the same time, and Eddie smiled.

“Perfect. So you know that you two are supposed to be the comedy relief, so I want you to really ham it up. Be as over the top about it as I am in everyday life. Think you can do that?” He asked, turning and facing them. They both shrugged, looking a little nervous, and Eddie sighed. 

“Look, I’m gonna be honest with you, you’re going to feel like absolute idiots while you’re performing, that’s just how it is when you act. But that’s also what makes it fun. And I wouldn’t have put you two in these parts if I didn’t think you could play them well. I was desperate, yes, but once the kids told me that you two had volunteered, I scrapped my idea to bump up two of the ensemble kids and let whoever they got take those parts, because I knew that these roles would literally be perfect for you. Steve, you’re cool, you’re a little egotistical, and from what Dustin told me, you love the snow, so all that coupled with the fact that you’re tall and thin and will look the part when we get costumes figured out makes you absolutely perfect. Billy, you’re a hothead, you’re a bit full of yourself sometimes, and you’re literally always complaining about how cold it is in Hawkins because you’re used to warm weather. Add that to your look, tanned skin and a slightly shorter, stockier build, and you two are literally the embodiment of these two characters. So being over the top about it is going to come easier than you think, trust me, you just have to put forth the effort. Can you do that,” Eddie asked, his eyes big and imploring.

“After that little speech of yours, you’re lucky I’m still standing here!” Billy grumbled, crossing his arms and glaring at the older boy, “You don’t know shit about me, you have no right to call me full of myself or a hothead or anything else, Munson!”

“Uh, Billy,” Steve said, trying not to laugh at the look on Eddie’s face, “You’re kinda proving his point by getting angry at that.”

“Shut the fuck up, Harrington!” Billy growled, “You don’t know shit about me, either!”

“Yeah, well I do,” Robin’s voice came from the back of the auditorium, a slightly annoyed expression on her face as she walked over and put her music on the piano, “I’m a people watcher, and I’ve had my eyes on you for a while. You’re just like Eddie said, a hothead, full of yourself, and disagreeable at the best of times. But that’s exactly what we’re looking for, and the fact that you’re able to still put that aside and compromise to help us out is also a big part of the character, we just aren’t working on that scene yet today. So, go get a drink of water, sit down, and cool yourself down a little while we work with Stevie. Once we finish up with him, we’ll work with you. You think you can do that?”

Billy was shocked at the look the girl was giving him, as well as the sharp honesty in her words. She continued to stare at him until he gave in and followed her directions, still a little shaken at how easily she had been able to see beneath his empty rage and get to him. He wasn’t sure if he liked it, exactly, but he did respect her for it. She could be really tough when she wanted to be.

It didn’t take long for Steve to get his part down, the words easy enough to remember and the notes not too difficult, either. He had to work on remembering when he was and wasn’t supposed to sing and following the cues Robin was giving him as she played the piano along with him, but it wasn’t a hard song, and he was well on his way to getting it perfect. 

“Okay, Stevie, go ahead and take a little break,” Robin said as she flipped the pages of her music. “Billy, it’s your turn.”

Billy was looking forward to this about as much as he looked forward to getting his wisdom teeth taken out when he was twelve, but he stepped up to the piano anyway, waiting as Robin played the intro and gave him his starting note. Billy sang through the song, his lack of enthusiasm doing nothing to hinder his performance. Not a whole lot of people knew this, but Billy had perfect pitch, so every note was spot on and he made almost no mistakes as he sang through the song. When it ended, Robin and Eddie were both looking at him with impressed expressions, and Billy felt almost proud of himself.

“That was good,” Robin said as she shuffled her music around. “As soon as you memorize the words and we get you to put some energy into it, we can start the choreography.”

“Yeah, I’ve got no complaints or criticisms here. Who knew that Big Bad Billy Hargrove had such a pretty voice?” Eddie grinned, holding Billy’s gaze as he blushed. Eddie didn’t even look away when Robin grabbed his wrist to check his watch, nearly falling off the piano bench when she saw the time.

“Shit! My mom’s probably been waiting forever for me, I gotta go! Eddie, do you mind cleaning up without me? I swear I’ll owe you one,” she said, getting back up and grabbing all of her stuff.

“No problem, Robbie. See you tomorrow,” Eddie said, waving as she ran out of the auditorium. Eddie smiled and shook his head, but began getting his own things in order. There wasn’t a whole lot to clean up today, just a few props and things to put away in the drama room and he had to cover the piano and shove it back in the corner by the stage, but that was about it. It really wouldn’t take him too long.

“Is there anything we can help you with?” Steve asked, walking over with his backpack thrown over his shoulder. 

“Uh, yeah, sure,” Eddie said, zipping his own bag shut and leaving it on the floor. “I have to shove the piano over into the corner and then just straighten up in the drama room, but that’s about it.”

“Which corner?” Billy asked, surprising the other two. They honestly thought he would’ve left as soon as he could, especially after he bolted yesterday, but he was still standing there, backpack tossed to the side and sleeves pushed up to his elbows.

“Just over there,” Eddie replied, pointing to the lower left corner of the room. Billy nodded and grabbed one end of the instrument, Eddie grabbing the other end and Steve picking up the bench to bring with them. They got the piano into the position Mrs. Jackson had told Eddie to return it to, then covered it up with the protective cloth and tucked the bench underneath it. 

They grabbed their bags once that was done and moved to the drama room, working together once they got there to clean up trash, put away the props and arrange the set pieces so they wouldn’t be in the way. By the time they’d gotten everything in order, they’d worked up just a little bit of a sweat and were all ready to just sit down and relax.

“Hey, uh, thanks for helping out and, y’know, good job today,” Eddie said as they gathered their stuff up again.

“Anytime, Munson,” Steve said, stretching a little and running his hand through his hair.

“Yeah,” Billy said, turning his head to each side to crack his neck. 

“Jesus, how did you not just snap your brain stem?” Eddie said, making a face.

Billy just shrugged and threw his backpack over his shoulder. He watched as the other two did the same and then they all just waited, though none of them really knew what they were waiting for. It just felt like there was something more to be said.

“Anyway,” Eddie said, then paused. He bit his lip like he was trying to think of what to add to that, and finally he looked up. “I guess I’ll… see you guys tomorrow, then?” 

“Yeah, see you then,” Billy rushed out in one breath, Steve nodding in agreement. They all walked out together in silence, which was a little awkward, considering they’d already said goodbye. Billy had hardly noticed the tension, though, he was too busy getting lost in his head again. 

Despite the fact that he felt kind of stupid all afternoon, rehearsal today was almost… fun. It’d been a while since Billy had gotten to show off his singing talents, and even though he didn’t show them often, he missed it. And even though he still felt weird about the way Steve had described him earlier, he liked being able to talk to him just casually, like they were friends. Even Munson’s insults-that-were-supposed-to-be-compliments were nice to hear in some backwards kind of way, and Billy found that he liked being appreciated for just being himself. It was weird, kind of insane, and a little unnerving to say the least, but he found that he was enjoying himself with this little play thing, especially when he was in the company of the other two boys, and it was only the second day of practice. Maybe this thing wasn’t going to be so bad after all.

The next few weeks during rehearsals, the show was finally starting to come together. Everyone was memorizing their lines and music and cues and putting the scenes together, and before they knew it, it was two weeks before dress rehearsal. Eddie had enlisted Nancy’s help to find most of the costumes either at thrift stores or make them, and after they made a few alterations, they were ready to go. They weren’t too fancy or over the top, but the rest of the show would certainly make up for that. 

By the time dress rehearsal rolled around, two nights before the first show, everything seemed to be going perfectly. Everyone was dressed up in their costumes and working on getting makeup on, and soon enough, they were waiting backstage in the auditorium for their cues. Eddie’s friend Jeff was working the lights and sound, and they began to do a run through of the whole show in their costumes. 

Billy would never admit to how excited he was waiting backstage for his cue. The stage went dark as the scenery changed, and Max ran backstage to start her narration as the stage crew moved the set pieces around in the dark. 

“The Miser brothers, what a pair!” Max said in her Mrs. Claus voice. The lights came on once the set was finished, and she continued, “Snow Miser, who controls the Northern part of the world trying to turn everything to icicles…”

As she spoke, Steve ran out onto the stage with a flourish, taking some tiny paper balls from his pocket and tossing them over his head to look like snow. Two of the young ensemble members, dressed similarly in blue shirts and white pants, as well as blue winter hats with white pom poms on top, ran out with him, pretending to be his little henchmen. Steve’s hair was spray dyed to be white, and his face was painted with a blue tint that was probably Robin’s eyeshadow to make him look even colder. He had a blue blazer on and white pants, a blue scarf wound around his neck and the cuffs of his jacket and pants had been sewn with blue felt to look like icicles. He was wearing pointy elf shoes from when the drama club put on The Wizard of Oz a few years ago, and they’d been spray painted blue to match the rest of the outfit. Billy couldn’t help but think that the blue tint suited his pale skin, accentuated the pink of his lips and made his warm eyes even more intense.

“...And his nasty brother trying to keep the South so hot with nary a snowflake a year!” Max continued, and Billy was so caught up in looking at Steve, he almost missed his cue. He ran out as soon as he realized, just a second later than he was supposed to. Still, he was able to get out on stage just in time, and he did his actions as he was supposed to. He was wearing a tan sweater and rust colored pants, along with another pair of elf shoes, though these were painted orange. His sleeves and pants cuffs were sewn with orange felt to look like flames, and it had been sewn around his neck, too. He had his hair sprayed with a few streaks of red and orange and he had more of Robin’s makeup smeared on his face to give him a warm tint to his already tan skin. He also had two ensemble kids following behind him, carrying their own props and wearing orange shirts with brown pants, and they had sunglasses propped on their heads to top off the look. 

“Thanks to me,” Max continued, “Vixen and Jingle and Jangle were headed right between the two.”

Max’s friends Dustin, Mike and El went on stage in their costumes, the two boys dressed as elves and the little girl dressed up like a reindeer. She was pulling on a rope that was attached to a sled with wheels, and the two boys were sitting on the sled, but there was a trapdoor in the middle of it that they were able to stick their legs through to help her move it with. 

“Where are we? Where are we heading?” Dustin asked, looking at Mike.

“What do you see?” Mike asked, pretending to try and look around. They screamed as they looked in different directions, Mike at Billy and Dustin at Steve, and El didn’t scream, but she looked scared.

“Don’t just stand there, you fools!” Billy shouted to his little henchmen, pointing at the three in the center of the stage, “They’re part of that Santy-Claus gang of goody-goodies! Oh! They must be on their way to start everybody dreaming about white Christmas again! Don’t let them get through! Singe their britches for ‘em!”

Steve began to giggle and laugh on the other side of the stage, pretending to double over in hysterical laughter as he watched Billy throw his tantrum. Billy looked over and pretended to get even more angry, continuing to point at the other three.

“Get them! Get them!” He shouted. 

“I never dreamed that little Vixen would make the mistake of flying right smack into Heat Miser’s territory!” Max said from off stage. Billy’s little henchmen pulled out flashlights and shone them on the other three, and they pretended to get burned by it. The two boys pretended to fall off the sled as El ran forward, and as she got to the end of the stage, she stopped, pretending to notice only then that the boys had fallen off. She made a loop around and picked them up, and they ran off stage again, as Billy pretended to get even angrier. 

“They got away! They got away!” He shouted, stomping around and waving his arms. Steve took another paper ball, much bigger this time, and threw it at him, hitting him square in the gut. This time, it was Billy who pretended to be burned, howling a little and holding his gut right where the ‘snowball’ hit him. Steve laughed and turned around, doubling over and exposing his backside. Billy snatched one of the flashlights from one of his henchmen, and he turned it on and aimed its beam right at Steve’s ass. Steve jumped and rubbed at his behind, howling like he’d been burned this time, and he turned back like he was going to start fighting with Billy, but the stage went dark again. They ran off and helped to move the set pieces on the way, and they waited as the run through continued. Billy wasn’t going on again for a little while, so he waited in the drama room with the rest of the cast that wasn’t needed right now, mostly just the ensemble and a few others. Steve came in a few minutes after him, talking to Nancy for a minute before walking over to Billy with two bottles of water. 

“It’s nice to see you getting so into your part,” he said, sitting next to him on one of the chairs and holding one of the bottles out to him. Billy took it and drank, finishing half the bottle before he said anything.

“Thanks for the water, Steve. All that yelling dries me out,” he said, “But yeah, it’s for a bunch of kids and old people, so I figured I might as well. Besides, Eddie was right, it’s a whole lot more enjoyable when you go over the top with it.”

“Yeah, it is. I’m glad you’re having fun with it, I know Max probably dragged you into it against your will,” Steve said, making Billy (ironically) freeze.

“What are you talking about? I thought-” He tried, but Steve cut him off.

“That I thought you volunteered yourself? Hell no. I know Max dragged you into it, the same way Dustin and Mike had to beg me and Nancy to do it, too. But still, we’re pretty much soft touches when it comes to those kids, so we did it pretty much as soon as they asked, but I know it probably took some more convincing to get you to do it, so I still think that you saved the show,” Steve said, and Billy was glad for the makeup on his face, because it would make the red blush coming to his features less noticeable. 

“I’m still not a savior, Harrington,” he said, looking away and fiddling with his water bottle cap. “I don’t know why you and Munson think I’m some kind of second coming, but I’m not.”

“So we’re back to last names now? What happened to Steve and Eddie?” Steve asked, his joking tone lost now. 

“I don’t know, man, I just…” Billy paused, biting his lip. “I just feel like you guys are giving me credit that I don’t deserve. Max didn’t even ask me to do this, she just said something about it at dinner one night and my dad volunteered me and… I didn’t know how to say no to him. Every time I’ve tried in the past, it hasn’t ended well, so I just did what he said, but I wasn’t happy about it. I was forced into it by him, and now that I’m actually enjoying myself, I’m afraid that if people start seeing me as some sort of hero for it or whatever, it’s all gonna blow up in my face. Good things just don’t tend to last for me, so I’m trying to hold onto it for as long as I can, but every time you or Munson or one of those damn kids says how grateful they are to me for making it all possible, it’s like a knife twisting in my gut, because I know that somehow, something is gonna happen and my dad’s gonna catch wind of how happy I am and how much fun I’m having and how proud I am of this role and it’s gonna come falling down on my head, and I’ll be powerless to stop it.”

The words were tumbling out of his mouth before Billy could stop them, and as soon as he said them, he wished he hadn’t. He’d struck up something like friendship with Steve and Eddie throughout the past few weeks, after long nights of practicing and cleaning up and more often than not sharing a joint in the back of Eddie’s van before parting ways and heading home. He cared about them both, they were smart and funny and cute and he enjoyed spending time with them, and he didn’t want that to end. And he knew that if they knew about his home life, about what he was really like under all that bravado and confidence he’d taken years to learn how to give off effortlessly, they’d run away screaming. He wished he could just press a button and rewind time and stop himself from saying anything, but he knew he couldn’t, so he just sat there and hoped like hell that Steve would’ve gotten distracted or not heard him or something.

“I’m sorry that your dad is like that,” Steve said finally, reaching out and putting his hand on Billy’s shoulder. “My dad’s kinda similar. If he knew I was doing this, I’m sure he’d have a heart attack. He’d yank me out of it the first chance he got. He says that only queers get into theater. I know that’s a crock of shit, but that’s just how he sees it and no one can ever change his mind once he’s made it up about something. But he’s never around during the holidays, so I don’t have anything to worry about, I guess. And if your dad starts giving you shit about this, just let me know and I’ll do something about it. Having a shitty father is no fun, and I’m not about to let one of my best friends suffer for their father’s stupidity.”

Billy hadn’t noticed he’d started crying a bit until Steve took his hand off of his shoulder and used it to wipe a tear away. He was being so gentle about it, clearing away the smudged makeup and using the end of the scarf draped around his neck to wipe at Billy’s running nose. He stuck his tongue out a little as he concentrated, and Billy couldn’t help but think of how cute it was. He wanted to kiss those pretty little lips and tangle that soft pink tongue with his own, to see if the shine it always looked like he was wearing was actually strawberry flavored gloss or if it was just the way his lips always looked.

But he didn’t do any of that. Instead, he just smiled and made himself stop crying, fixing his sweater as he stood up and swiping at his eyes one more time.

“I suppose I should go see Robin about getting my makeup redone,” he said, wiping the smudges on his fingers on his pants. 

“Yeah, I guess so. We’ve got our big duet coming up in fifteen minutes, wouldn’t want it to look like you’re actually melting,” Steve said, tossing him a wink as he stood up himself. Billy rolled his eyes with a fond smile and shook his head, turning to go find Robin and get back in the makeup chair. He only made it a few steps before he turned back, picking at the felt sewn around the neckline of his sweater. It was suddenly beginning to feel uncomfortably warm.

“Hey, Steve?” He said, “Thanks for talking to me and, y’know, not getting pissed off. Shitty fathers suck, but… it’s kinda nice to know that I’m not the only one who has to deal with it. It’s like… solidarity or some shit like that. So thanks.”

Steve probably said something afterwards, but Billy didn’t stick around to hear it. He’d already cried in front of him once today, and he wasn’t going to do it again. Besides, if his makeup got anymore messed up, Robin was going to absolutely murder him.

After another ten minutes in the makeup chair, with Robin grumbling and griping the whole time and nearly poking him in the eye with her mascara brush, Billy had just enough time to straighten his sweater and grab the hat he was supposed to wear during the scene before he had to scurry off backstage. He watched as Max, Dustin, Mike and their other friend, Will, who was playing Iggy Thistlewhite, the main little boy in the show, walked onto the set stage, pretending to shiver. There was an ensemble kid waiting on the other side of the stage, and he raised his prop horn up to his face just as Jeff played the fanfare sound. Billy had to suppress a smile as Max said her next line, both because it was just a silly line and because he knew what came after it.

“Here he comes now, the big ham!” She said, pointing over to a set of prop doors that Steve was hiding behind as the music started up. Steve burst through the doors with a cane and a boater hat similar to the one Billy was going to wear, though his had a blue ribbon around it rather than an orange one. He danced onto the stage as the intro played, being as dramatic about it as possible, and Billy had to pinch himself to keep from breaking down in laughter. He’d seen him do this what felt like a hundred times before, but this was the first time that he’d done it in full costume and makeup.

“I’m Mr. White Christmas, I’m Mr. Snow,” Steve began to sing on cue, hitting every note perfectly. He’d clearly been practicing to make sure he got this perfect. 

“I’m Mr. Icicle, I’m Mr. Ten Below,” he continued, “Friends call me Snow Miser, whatever I touch, turns to snow in my clutch, ha ha! I’m too much!”

He tossed his hat in the air, catching it again as he continued to dance around. He spun around in a circle like a ballerina as the ensemble came out, all of them dressed in blue shirts and hats, dancing around Steve as he made an overexaggerated shivering sound, and he continued to dance around and tap his foot to the beat of the song as they repeated the same words of the verse back to him. He danced over to a large prop of a thermostat as the bridge started, and he continued to bounce a little as he continued to sing.

“I never want to know a day that’s over forty degrees! I’d rather have it thirty, twenty, ten, five, then let it freeze!” He pointed at the numbers as he sang them, then went into the laugh again as he said the word ‘freeze’. He spun around again as the ensemble sang their part, only stopping for a moment as they paused in the middle of the verse to add a quick, “That’s right!”

“Friends call me Snow Miser, whatever I touch, turns to snow in my clutch, ha ha!” The music stopped abruptly, and Steve said more than he sang, “Too much!” 

The ending notes rang out and Steve and the ensemble all said one last “too much” before they struck a pose and waited for the cue to move again. The ensemble filed off stage and Steve slumped down in the throne they’d set up on the set, the usual red cushions covered with blue felt to match the rest of the scene as it continued. Max and her friends did their bit and so did Steve, being as over the top about it as he could. The scene went on and Billy watched as Eddie grinned up at Steve from where he was sitting in the front row of auditorium seats, chewing on the eraser of his pencil with a look of pride on his face as the scene finally began to wrap up. Max and her friends turned to walk back towards the curtain, only stopping as Steve called out to them from his throne, waving excitedly with a grin on his face.

“Stop by with your hubby sometime and we’ll have a blizzard!” He called to Max, laughing like a maniac again as they finally got to standing just in front of the curtains. The lights on the other side of the stage dimmed and Steve got up to move backstage once they did, the focus going over to the four kids.

“Where to now?” Dustin asked Max as they stopped again, just short of leaving the stage.

“You heard the man, we’ve got to see Heat Miser,” Max replied, adjusting the prop glasses on her nose.

“I was afraid you’d say that!” Dustin said, and the rest of the stage lights dimmed as the music interlude played and the kids ran off stage. 

It wasn’t hard to change the set around, the stage crew only had to turn the set pieces around and move them to the other side of the stage, and Billy went to take his spot on the throne once the blue cloth was removed, Max and her friends running behind the curtains and waiting for their cue to come out from the other side of the stage as the lights were turned on again. The music started up again, the same song, but maybe just a little bit slower. Billy started dancing around, twirling his hat around and starting to sing on cue.

“I’m Mr. Green Christmas, I’m Mr. Sun. I’m Mr. Heat Blister, I’m Mr. Hundred-And-One. They call me Heat Miser, whatever I touch, starts to melt in my clutch, ha ha ha!” Billy sang, then added a wink as he sang, “I’m too much!”

Max and her friends had walked onto the stage, pretending to fan themselves as did, and the ensemble came to surround Billy from the other side of the stage, wearing their orange shirts and sunglasses, and singing their part of the song. Billy danced around with them, tapping his foot to the beat and dancing over to the thermostat prop like Steve had, and coming back in on cue.

“I never want to know a day that’s under sixty degrees! I’d rather have it eighty, ninety, one hundred’s a breeze!” Billy sang, and having danced to his spot in front of Max and her friends, he with a laugh, “Oh, some like it hot, but I like it really hot!”

The ensemble started up again and during a pause in the song, Billy shouted out, “Sing it!” He tossed his hat up as he said it, and caught it just as he was supposed to come back in. 

“They call me Heat Miser, whatever I touch, starts to melt in my clutch. I’m too much!” He sang, finishing off with his final pose as the ensemble added an extra “Too much!” as the music stopped and they posed, too. 

Billy was a little out of breath as he continued the scene with Max and her friends, but he didn’t mind it, he was having fun. He looked out at Eddie for a second and couldn’t help but (again, ironically) feel even warmer than before. If he’d been smiling when Steve did his scene, he was positively beaming now, looking more than proud as they went on with the scene. Billy went back to the throne and sat down, tossing the hat to the side and pretending to be unimpressed with Max and her friend’s characters as they begged him for help, obviously refusing their pleas. 

The scene went on and there was a tiny shift in the curtains as they opened just slightly behind the door prop, Steve waiting behind it with a snowy backdrop hung up behind him.  Billy was excited for the next part, where he and Steve got to interact again, and he tried not to let it show on his face, instead keeping his expression neutral and unimpressed.

“Hmmm, unless… Unless there were, well… Something in it for me?” He said, looking at the group of kids. 

“Like what?” Max asked, pushing the fake glasses up again.

“Ooh, like for instance, if a… A little bit of Northern territory were turned over to me? Shall we say… The North Pole?” Billy said, gripping both arms of his throne and leaning forward, looking Max dead in the eyes with a raised eyebrow and a smirk on his face.

“Well heavens, I don’t know!” She said, “That would be up to your brother, not me!”

“Well, heh, why don’t you give the tutti-frutti snow-cone a buzz on the hotline? See what he says,” Billy said, gesturing to his left, where a prop telephone stood on a table. Max walked over and picked it up, turning with it to look in the direction of the door.

“Hello?” She said into it, just as the door began to open, revealing Steve standing with his own prop phone. “Snowy, this is Mrs. Claus.”

“Hi there, sugarplum! How’d you make out with the hot-head?” Steve asked, smiling with all his teeth as he looked at Max, but stayed behind the door, as if talking through a TV screen and not with her directly.

“I heard that, you snowball!” Billy said, jumping up from his chair and making an angry face at Steve.

“Oh my goodness, speak of the Devil!” Steve continued, his expression turning even more amused than before as Billy turned back to look at Max.

“Madam, kindly state your business with that drippy snowman and get him outta here!” He said, walking over to stand next to his sister and crossing his arms, still glaring at Steve.

“Mind your blood pressure, hotcakes! Mother warned you about that low boiling point of yours!” Steve piped up, shaking his finger like Billy was a petulant child. Billy began to grumble and stomp around, pretending to throw another tantrum, making himself practically shake with false rage.

“You think you’re hot stuff just cuz mother likes you best!” He argued, making a face.

“Boys, boys, now please! Don’t fight,” Max implored, looking between the two.

“Well, if I can’t have a little fun I might as well leave!” Steve said, pretending to examine his nails.

“Your brother agreed to let it snow in the South!” Max said, gesturing to Billy.

“He did?!” Steve gasped, bouncing on his toes.

“Of course, there has to be a small concession on your part,” Max continued, pinching her fingers together to emphasize the words.

“Oh really?” The enthusiasm slipped from Steve’s voice as he put a hand on his hip, glaring over Max’s shoulder at Billy. “Well what does the flaming fool want this time, the North Pole?”

“Uh,” Max said, looking at Billy before going back to Steve, “Uh, yes, as a matter of fact.”

“What?!” Steve shouted, looking around and biting his nails as if he was nervous, even making little whimpering noises to make it look convincing.

“I told you he wouldn’t cooperate!” Billy said.

“Cooperate?!” Steve continued, almost frantic as he said, “Surrender the North Pole is what you call cooperate?! I’ve a good mind to chill your embers for you!”

“Oh yeah?!” Billy asked, turning and getting into a fighting stance as he faced Steve.

“Alright, enough of this!” Max cut in, stepping between the two. “I hate to do this to you, boys, but you leave me no choice! I’m going over your heads.”

“You’re kidding!” Steve said, looking shocked.

“You wouldn’t dare!” Billy added, letting a little bit of a quiver slip into his voice as he got into Max’s face.

“I would, and I will!” She said, turning her nose up at him and walking back to the other three she’d come in with as Billy pretended to get more and more nervous.

“M-Mrs. Claus!” He whined, but she’d already gotten to the other side of the stage, so he turned back to Steve. “See what you did, you old blizzard! She’s gonna tell mother!”

“What I did? You hot dog, it was all your fault!” Steve replied, jabbing his finger at Billy with an angry expression.

“Come along!” Max called to the other three kids as Billy and Steve continued to quietly bicker.

“We’re not really going to do it, are we, Mrs. Claus?” Dustin asked as he and the other two ran over, grabbing her arm to stop her. “I mean, we’re not actually going to disturb… her ?”

“Oh, she’s not serious!” Mike said, looking just as frightened as Dustin as Max continued to walk away. “I-I mean, w-w-we’re not really g-gonna d-d-d-... A-a-are we actually g-going to see…”

“Yes!” Dustin said.

“No!” Mike said back. 

“Who? Where are we going?” Will asked, his character just as confused as the audience would be after all that stuttering. “Who are we going to see?”

“We’re going right to the top, Iggy my boy,” Dustin said, turning to Will.

“Mrs. C is through foolin’ around!” Mike said, looking around nervously, “We’re going to see none other than…”

“Mother Nature!” He and Dustin said together, turning to follow Max off stage.

“Gosh!” Will said, turning to the audience, and as he ran after them, the lights went off. 

Another interlude played as Billy, Steve and a few stage crew helpers changed the set, hurrying to get the back curtain closed again and get all the set pieces taken away and replaced with new ones. They took and put away any props they’d used, and they rushed backstage to wait until their cues. Billy had to run behind the curtain to get to the other side of the stage for the next scene, and he was just about to do that as Nancy and the rest of the relevant characters took their places on stage and the lights went on, but it seemed his sweater got snagged on something. When he turned around to get it loose, he saw that Steve had grabbed onto him, his dopey grin just barely visible in the dark of the curtains.

“What the- What are you doing?” Billy whispered as Steve let him go, looking to the other side of the stage as he heard Max start with her next line. He didn’t want to miss his cue.

“I just wanted to say that you’re doing great,” Steve whispered back, grabbing Billy’s hand and giving it a little squeeze before he added, “Break a leg.”

“You too, Steve, for both things,” Billy said, smiling at him and squeezing back before running across the stage just in time. Nancy, who was playing Mother Nature, was just getting ready to call them to her, and Billy knew he only had one shot to get this take right.

“Oh, yoohoo! Children!” Nancy called, throwing her arms above her head. She lowered her right arm and the stage went dark as a lightning bolt sound played, and when the lights were back on, Steve was standing on her right. She lowered her other arm and the same thing happened, and Billy ran out onto the dark stage, getting into position just as the lights went back on after the sound effect.

“What is it, mother dear?” He and Steve asked at the same time, mirroring each other’s movements as they tipped and bowed on either side of Nancy. They stayed like that for a moment until they seemed to catch each other’s eye, and then set about trying to outdo the other in sucking up to Nancy.

“Now, Mrs. Claus made a very simple request,” she said, smiling as she turned to Billy. “Now, you let a little snow fall in Southland,” she said, placing her hand on his arm and not even seeming to notice the horrified look Billy gave her or the smug look Steve was giving him, “And you allow just one nice spring day at the North Pole,” she continued, putting her other hand on Steve’s arm and again failing to notice as their expressions shifted and they shot daggers at each other. “All you have to do is compromise. At this time of the year especially! Santa needs some examples of the Christmas spirit, and we must set a good example for the people down there to follow, so boys, please! ” She finally finished, planting her hands on the table and standing up, looking between the two. 

“I won’t do it!” Billy declared, crossing his arms and turning up his nose.

“Me, neither!” Steve replied, doing the same.

“Oh, stop it! Stop it!” Nancy said firmly, throwing her arms up and bringing them down again, causing Jeff to flash the lights and play the lightning sound again. Billy and Steve both looked over their shoulders at each other with looks of fear on their faces before sighing and turning back to Nancy. 

They each put a hand on her shoulder and said in the sweetest tones they could muster, “Yes, mother dear.”

“Hm,” Nancy hummed in contentment, leaning forward and picking up the teacup prop she’d been using earlier, “They’re really nice boys, Mrs. Claus. Oh, sometimes they bicker, but you’ll have no further trouble with them. I do hope Santa enjoys his holiday.”

As she said it, Steve and Billy continued to make faces at each other behind her back, which they hoped would make the audience laugh. Apparently, they were doing good with it, because as they watched Max and her friends try to suppress some laughter of their own, they heard Eddie giggling a little from the front row, too. 

They finished the scene and headed backstage once it was over, none of them needing to go back onstage until the final bows, so since it was just dress rehearsal, they had the all clear to go and get changed and out of makeup. They did just that, heading to the drama room to grab their clothes and then going to the locker room, taking off their costumes and hanging them by the door before walking into where the showers were.

“I meant what I said earlier about you being great,” Steve said as they stepped under the hot sprays of water from their respective showerheads. They were no strangers to talking while in here like this, they’d done it all the time during basketball season in the fall. They’d be doing it again during baseball season in the spring, too, so doing it now wasn’t anything they weren’t used to. Still, it felt different somehow. Maybe it was the fact that it was a friendly conversation and not one of them trying to antagonize the other just to get a reaction out of them.

“Thanks, man. I meant it, too. I was struggling not to laugh the entire time you were onstage,” Billy said, tilting his head back under the water to wash the dye from his hair. He glanced over to see Steve trying to do the same, but with the amount of white that’d been sprayed all throughout his thick locks, it was going to take a lot longer to get it all out than it was taking Billy. He’d already rinsed it three times and lathered it up with shampoo twice, and still a few white streaks remained. 

“You’re never going to get all that out on your own,” Billy giggled, rinsing his own locks clear of soap and stepping over to his friend. “Let me,” he said.

He could’ve sworn he’d heard Steve’s breath hitch for a split second as he said it, but Billy was nothing if not persistent, so he just swallowed and set his sights on Steve’s wild hair. He squeezed some more shampoo into his hands and concentrated on scrubbing the dye out of Steve’s hair, taking his time to make sure he got it all. 

“There, all done,” he said as he finished, lowering his eyes and accidentally meeting Steve’s. He felt his own breath hitch as he lowered his hands as well, slipping them out of his hair slowly and searching Steve’s face for any kind of… anything.

Steve wasn’t giving him anything, though, his face remained as blank as if he were just a photograph and not a living, breathing human being. Billy was terrified for a moment as he realized this, and he was just about to back away and apologize, but then he looked at his eyes again, and he realized that Steve was trying to search him, too. Billy knew he wouldn’t find anything, he’d learned a long time ago how to hide even his strongest emotions, so instead, he decided, ‘fuck it’ . 

And he took a chance. 

He scrunched his eyes shut, grabbed Steve by his pretty face, and kissed him with everything he had.

It didn’t last long, Billy was afraid to let it, and after just a few seconds, it was over. Billy pushed himself away just as forcefully as he’d pulled himself in, but his hands remained on the sides of Steve’s face as he once again searched for something, anything , on Steve’s face. This time he found it easily, but his heart and stomach both dropped upon seeing it, a look of shock settling over Steve’s features. 

“Fuck, shit, I’m so sorry!” He said, yanking his hands away and immediately backing up, suddenly very aware that they were both still naked. “Jesus Christ, I’m sorry! I don’t know what I was doing! Please, just don’t kill me, I’ll leave and you can finish cleaning up and we’ll just pretend this never happened, okay? Just, please, don’t tell anyone! I’m so fucking sorry!”

And with that, he ran. He ignored Steve’s calls for him in favor of yanking on his jeans over his still wet legs and shoving his feet into his sneakers, not wanting to waste time with socks, underwear or shoelaces. Or a shirt, for that matter, and instead just grabbed the rest of his stuff, his costume, and biting his lip hard enough for it to bleed as he ran with it all back to the drama room, leaving his costume on its rack and running straight to his car. He didn't even bother to tell anyone why he was soaking wet and running around like a lunatic before he left, and he booked it to the Camaro and sped away before anyone had the chance to ask. He should’ve known it was too good to be true.

He found himself parked on the outskirts of town, on an old dirt road that had been overgrown with vegetation, so he figured it’d been a while since anyone had been out that way. He drove until the road ended in a circle of trees, a decaying structure that probably used to be a cabin just beyond it. The sky was pitch black and spotted with stars, the glowing moon peeking down at him from between the trees. 

He turned off his car and immediately curled in on himself, panic and fear setting in now that the fight-or-flight response had calmed down. How could he have been so stupid? He was already risking enough by letting himself enjoy being in that stupid play, and now he’d gone and kissed his best (and one of his only) friends, in the showers of all places, while they were both buck naked and he’d just washed his hair for him. God, how desperate could a person be?

Billy couldn’t even look at himself in the rearview mirror as he sat there. He felt more than pathetic. He felt deplorable, like everything his father had ever said about him had been true. He’d always known that some of them were, like when he’d called him things like ‘queer’ and ‘faggot’ and ‘fairy’, but now even more of his dad’s words were ringing true, like ‘failure’, ‘loser’, ‘sissy’, ‘scumbag’. He’d always taken these words at face value, tried to let them slide off of him like he didn’t care, but deep down, they’d always hurt. And now, it was like they were a searing pain that started on the tips of his toes and went all the way to the roots of his hair, scorching him hotter and hotter until the air inside the car felt more like sludge when he tried to breathe it in. 

Billy clambered out of the car as fast as he could, choking on cries and sobs as he tripped and landed in a heap next to it. He felt like his lungs were being squeezed like water balloons, some kind of phantom hand continuing to grip tighter and tighter, testing the limits to see how long it would take before they popped. And still somehow, it felt like they were expanding too much, like if they had any more air in them, they’d pick Billy up and carry him away on the wind. Maybe that wouldn’t be such a bad thing. But even if it wasn’t it just wasn’t quite feasible, so Billy wracked his overworked, barely-functioning-anymore brain for what to do to get rid of all that pressure.

He settled on screaming. As loud as he could, into the night air, he let out all of those pent up emotions and fears and worries in screams that would spook even the most avid horror fans. He sounded like he was dying, being killed in the most gruesome of ways, and maybe he was. Dying from the inside is worse than anything else a person can feel; its only real competition is love. And so Billy screamed and screamed and screamed, the chill of the night air ineffective in cooling him down even a little bit, even though he still wasn’t wearing more than his jeans and a thin, unzipped jacket. The blood rushing around in his veins faster than a freight train was keeping him as warm as he needed to be, and it was turning his skin as red as a tomato in the process. 

Billy didn’t know how long he’d been out there for when he saw a pair of dim headlights coming towards him. It could’ve been ten minutes, it could’ve been ten hours, he wouldn’t have known the difference. All he knew was that there was someone coming towards him, and they were blocking his only exit. 

He knew he didn’t have anywhere to go, so he just trudged back to his car and sat down on the seat as whoever it was got closer, too exhausted to even wipe away his tears. The car stopped and the headlights turned off as whoever it was turned off their car, and as they removed the key and opened their door, Billy saw that it was none other than Eddie Munson. 

Fuck.

“Billy?” Eddie asked as he got out of his van and tentatively stepped forward. “Billy, are you okay?”

“How’d you know I was here?” Billy asked in response, his voice raw and hoarse from screaming so much. It was cracking and barely a whisper, but he couldn’t bring himself to care.

“I didn’t. I was on my way home, but I heard screaming, so I came to see what was happening. But seriously, are you alright? It sounded like you were hurt or dying or something,” Eddie said, walking a little bit closer, but standing far enough away that he wouldn’t scare Billy.

“How did you hear me from the road?” He asked, and Eddie gave him a sympathetic smile.

“This road’s kinda confusing. It seems like you’re way out deep in the woods, right? But it really just goes in a big, windy circle and we’re really not far from the start of it. I lived in Hawkins my whole life and I only figured this out, like, a year ago, myself. But that’s besides the point, dude. You’re kinda, like, avoiding the question here, and it’s making me a little nervous. For real, are you okay?” Eddie asked, leaning on the car next to Billy. He leaned down to try and get a look at his friend, but Billy turned his head.

“I’m fine, it’s… It’s a personal thing,” Billy answered, staring at his shoes as if they’d give him the answers to the secrets of the universe.

“Is it about the whole ‘kissing Steve’ thing?” Eddie asked, hopping up to sit on the hood of the car as casually as if they were discussing last week’s Lakers game. Billy, on the other hand, was having a goddamn heart attack.

“H-how do you know about that?!” He asked, his head snapping to look at Eddie with watery, worried eyes. He never remembered wanting to throw up more than he did right now.

“Steve told me about it,” Eddie said, shrugging his shoulders as if it were no big deal.

“Did he tell everyone, or just you? Fuck, he told everyone, didn’t he? Holy shit, holy shit, holy shit! I begged him not to tell anyone, I-” Billy choked on his own words, getting so worked up, he was sure his heart would give out on him. He’d probably be happier if it did.

“Whoa, whoa, hey, chill out, man!” Eddie said, moving to kneel in front of Billy so he’d have to look at him. “I’m the only person he told,” Eddie assured him, “He said he wasn’t going to tell anyone else, it wasn’t there business, but he wanted me to know because-”

“Because he’s not gonna be comfortable around me anymore, I know. Shit, is he backing out of the show?! Opening night is the day after tomorrow! Or was it that he asked you to kick me out?! Either way, the point still stands, there’s no time to find replacements and if this whole thing is fucking cancelled because I was a stupid fucking idiot, I’m gonna jump in front of a goddamn bus!” Billy rambled, breathing heavily and gripping his hair. Eddie was afraid he’d yank it out of his scalp, so he reached up and took them in his own instead, holding them gently but firmly.

“Billy, hey, calm down a little and just listen,” Eddie said, speaking as softly and calmly as he could. “Steve told me and not anybody else because he’s my boyfriend. He-”

“Wh-What?” Billy asked, his eyes going wide and shocked yet again. For the first time since he’d left the school, he felt cold, the icy hands of terror grabbing him by the spine and shaking him like a baby’s rattle. “Oh my God, Eddie, I’m so fucking sorry! I-I didn’t know you guys were… If I did, I never would’ve done that, never in a million years! But I didn’t know and I’m just so fucking sorry!”

“You’ve got a real problem with interrupting people, you know that?” Eddie said, but he wasn’t being mean about it. In fact, it sounded like he was trying to make light of it. Leave it to Eddie Munson to try and make a joke at a time like this. 

“I-I know,” Billy swallowed, “I’m s-”

“You’re sorry, I know,” Eddie smiled, “But believe me, it’s okay. Nobody knew we were dating, not even Robin, and she and Steve have literally no secrets. We didn’t want to tell anyone yet because it’s still a fairly new thing and we don’t know how everyone will take it, so the only people we want to know for right now is us and my Uncle Wayne, since we spend a lot of time at my place and he was gonna figure it out soon anyway. And we talked a little about it while we cleaned up after tonight once everyone left, and he said he wanted to tell you, too, because he was worried about you. I said we could just tell you tomorrow, but then I heard the screams and well, here we are. But that’s the reason he froze up after you kissed him. He was just shocked and he didn’t know what to do about it. But he’s not mad at you, and I’m not either, okay? He was just a little surprised, that’s all.”

Billy searched Eddie’s face, his voice, everything about him for any hint of a lie in his statement, but there was nothing there. There was nothing but concern and earnestness in his big chocolate eyes, and Billy could barely take it looking at them. He didn’t deserve concern or care, especially from someone as sweet and kind as Eddie. He didn’t deserve anything right now except maybe to get socked in the jaw.

“Well, as much as I agree with the sweet and kind part of it, the rest of that statement was a crock of shit, if I’m being honest with you,” Eddie said, shrugging. Shit, had he said that out loud? He hadn’t meant to. Fuck.

“Look, Bill, I’m still really worried about you. Why don’t you come back to my place and we can talk it out where it’s not quite so cold? Wayne’s probably left for work already, he usually heads out around now, and we can just relax and work this out between us, okay? I’ll even make you some tea so your throat doesn’t hurt as much. What do you say?” Eddie asked, squeezing Billy’s hands and ducking a little to make sure they were still looking at each other. Billy didn’t have it in him to speak, his throat was killing him and he was exhausted, so he just nodded.

When they finally made it back to the Munson trailer, the only lights still on were the single strand of yellowed ones lining the door for the holidays, meaning Wayne had already left for work. Eddie opened the door and ushered Billy inside, flicking on some more lights and telling him to make himself at home. Billy didn’t know exactly how to do that, since he’d never really felt ‘at home’ anywhere, but he made an effort anyway, sitting down on the couch and ignoring the little voice in the back of his mind telling him that he was going to wreck up the pillows if he did. That was Neil talking, and he was the last person Billy needed to hear from right now.

“I’m gonna go get you some pajamas so you can relax and then I’ll make you that tea, and we’ll talk after that, okay?” Eddie said, waiting for Billy to nod before he actually left for a room at the back of the trailer, presumably his room. It only took a few moments for Eddie to return, but by the time he did and tossed the clothes next to Billy, the other boy was already lost in thought again. He didn’t even notice the pile of cloth bouncing off the couch next to him and onto the floor, at least not until Eddie mentioned them when he walked over with two steaming mugs.

“Why didn’t you get changed? The bathroom’s just over there,” Eddie said, pointing to a door down the hall.

“Oh, uh, yeah,” Billy said, biting his lip, “About that… When I kissed him… We were, uh, trying to clean off all the makeup and hair dye and stuff and we were in the showers, so we weren’t exactly… clothed. And then I was in such a rush to get out of there that I just yanked on my jeans and shoes and nothing else, so… you probably don’t want me wearing your clothes.”

“Dude, I know. Steve told me,” Eddie said, that sympathetic smile returning as he gathered up his clothes and shoved them at Billy, “But I really don’t care. Hell, that’s why they invented washing machines. As long as you don’t have cooties, I think it’ll be fine. Do you want to borrow a pair of underwear, too? I can lend you some if you’d be more comfortable.”

“That’s okay, but thanks,” Billy said, finally taking the clothes from Eddie and standing.

“Of course, man, anytime,” Eddie said, smiling nicely, “Just hurry back! Wouldn’t want your tea to get cold!”

Billy went into the bathroom and locked the door behind him, setting the clothes on the closed lid of the toilet and avoiding the mirror altogether as he began to strip. He’d been able to get cleaned up in the showers earlier before he’d gone to help Steve with his hair, so he didn’t waste any time pulling on the clothes, the fabric soft from being worn and washed so many times before. Eddie’d gotten him a pair of old blue sweatpants that were snug on his hips but pooled a bit around his ankles, a KISS shirt that was so old that the graphic was significantly worn off the front, and a pair of black fuzzy socks that had little green marijuana leaves printed on them. Billy found a hair tie in the pocket of the sweatpants and wondered if Eddie had put it there for him on purpose or not, but he didn’t care either way as he used it to keep his almost completely dry hair out of his face. It was frizzy after everything that’d happened, but he couldn’t have cared less at that moment. 

He walked back out to join Eddie in the living room, sitting next to him on the couch again, and now that he was in comfy clothes and Eddie was wrapping a blanket around him and shoving a mug shaped like Garfield in his hands, he was fighting the urge to just fall asleep. Instead though, he just sipped the still hot tea from out of Garfield’s head. It was chamomile, which wasn’t his favorite, but it was good for sore throats, and Eddie didn’t even have to make it for him in the first place, so he didn’t complain.

“I put some honey in there for you, too. Can’t have you losing your voice two days before opening night, right?” Eddie said, nudging Billy’s arm, but the other boy stayed quiet. “C’mon dude, I’m trying to make you laugh, here. Or at least not look like someone just killed your puppy. What can I do to make that happen?”

“I don’t know,” Billy said, staring at his tea. Garfield was staring right back at him, so he turned the mug around in his hands. “I still just feel… really weird about all this. I feel like you shouldn’t be being this nice to me. I mean, if I found out that some random asshole had just up and kissed my boyfriend while they were alone in the showers, I’d have beaten their face in, not helped them through a panic attack and leant them my clothes to wear while I made them tea. I just feel like you should be more upset at me or something.”

“Well, it’s like I said earlier, you didn’t know any better. And besides, you’re not just some random asshole. You’re my friend, and Steve’s friend, and he feels awful that he couldn’t have caught up to you before you left, because he was worried about you, and he wanted to explain himself. But I gave him a quick call while you were getting changed, and he said I could give you a choice,” Eddie said, “Either I explain everything to you right now, cards on the table and all that jazz, and you can take your time to process it and talk to him later, or I can put on a movie, and we’ll just relax until Steve can come over, and he can explain it all himself. Then we can figure out where to go from there. He’s waiting for me to call him back, so you can take your time, but just let me know which one you want to do and that’ll be that.”

Billy thought for a minute, hating the feeling of Eddie’s eyes on him. He didn’t want to see Steve, not really, he felt like a dick for everything that’d happened in the past few hours, but he also didn’t know if he wanted to hear all about Steve’s secrets and his reasoning from Eddie. He trusted Eddie, knew he was honest, but the fact that he could change any bit of the story around that he wanted was ringing like a bell in the back of Billy’s mind, and he just wanted to know the truth. He wanted to, for once in his life, face his problems like a grown up, and hopefully he wouldn’t end up punching his way out of it.

“Call him,” Billy said, “Tell him to come over. We need to talk.”

“Okay,” Eddie replied, picking up the phone, “The TV remote’s on top of the set, you can put on anything you like.”

Billy had heard him, but he made no move to get the remote or turn on the TV, instead he just stayed where he was and continued to sip on his tea. He needed some time to get his thoughts in order, and he didn’t want to have any distractions. 

He tuned Eddie out as he spoke on the phone, and he closed his eyes so he could try to think more clearly. What was he even gonna say to him when he got here? What was he gonna do? Steve probably wouldn’t react any worse than Eddie did, but then again, he wasn’t just an innocent bystander, he was the one who’d been kissed without consent, and Eddie had only been told about it after the fact. What if Steve never wanted to talk to him again? What if he was too weirded out to be his friend anymore? What if he outed Billy to someone, either by accident or on purpose? What if he told Neil? All these thoughts and more made Billy’s heart race and his head hurt, and he felt on the verge of another panic attack, when suddenly, the trailer’s screen door slamming shut brought him out of it.

“Hey, Stevie,” Eddie said, standing from his spot on the couch and moving to take his hand. “I’m gonna go make you some tea, okay? You two just try and talk until I get back, okay?”

Eddie gave Steve’s hand a little squeeze before he left for the kitchen, leaving him and Billy in silence. Billy hadn’t moved a muscle since Steve walked in, just held the stupid Garfield mug in his hands and stared into it as he waited for Steve to hopefully speak first. He didn’t say anything yet, though, just walked to the armchair next to the couch and sat down, taking off his shoes and leaving them beside it. He leaned forward with his elbows resting on his knees and twiddled his thumbs, and after what felt like forever, he finally ran a hand through his hair and looked up at Billy.

“So…” he said, playing with his ear as he tried to find the words, “Eddie said you wanted to talk.”

“Mm,” Billy replied, biting his thumb nail. Steve waited for him to say something else, but he didn’t, so he tried again.

“I’m sorry I freaked you out earlier,” he said, “I was just…”

“Shocked,” Billy finished for him, the word tasting bitter on his tongue.

“Yeah,” Steve said. “It’s not that I don’t like you, Billy, it’s just that I didn’t know what to do because I’m with Eds now, and I know you didn’t know that, so it’s not your fault, but I just wasn’t sure… how to go on… after that.”

Billy nodded and there was a beat of quiet before he spoke again. 

“How long have you and Eddie been…?” he asked, still not looking up at Steve as he continued to bite his nails.

“Almost a month,” Steve replied, “When we would stay after practice, after everyone went home, we would just sit and talk and one day he just asked me out. This was back when you would leave as soon as you could get out, so it was just the two of us and I said yes, so it’s been almost a month now. And then about a week after that was when you started sticking around a little more, which was fine, we liked hanging out with you, but that’s when it started.”

“Jesus Christ, so not only did I kiss a guy that was already in a relationship, but I was third-wheeling that relationship pretty much the whole time? Fuck,” Billy said, scrubbing a hand down his face as he tried not to smash his head into the coffee table.

“You weren’t third-wheeling, like I said, we liked hanging out with you, it was fun. And Eddie and I hadn’t even kissed yet at that point, so it wasn’t like we were trying to be alone together or anything. It was just like a group of friends hanging out, there’s nothing wrong with that,” Steve said. He wanted to reach over and touch Billy, to let him know that it was truly okay, but he could tell that he didn’t want to be touched right now. Still, he’d always been better at showing comfort through actions rather than words, and he wished he could just do that instead of having to sit here and watch his friend suffer because of him.

“Even if that’s true, though, I still feel shitty about it, and I want you to know I’m sorry for… everything. And I understand if you, like, never want to talk to me again or whatever. I know I don’t deserve to be your friend after all that,” Billy said, feeling the lump in his throat getting larger at the thought. 

“Dude, what are you talking about?” Steve asked, sounding genuinely confused. He moved to sit down next to Billy and put his hand on his shoulder, trying to get him to look at him, but Billy wouldn’t budge. “Why would you think that you don’t deserve to be my friend? Especially when I don’t even think you need to be sorry about anything, so you’re already forgiven. I’ll be damned if I let you stop being my friend over something as silly as this, especially when I was adding fuel to the fire that whole time we were hanging out together.”

Those were the words that finally got Billy to look at him, even if it was only a glance over his shoulder. There was confusion in his pretty blue eyes, and doubt, and Steve didn’t know whether he was confused about him not wanting to end their friendship or if he was confused about the implications of his last statement. He couldn’t be that oblivious, though, could he?

“What are you talking about, ‘adding fuel to the fire’?” He asked. Steve’s hand felt like a vice that had hot coals stuck between it and his shoulder.

“Did you seriously not notice me flirting with you the entire time we’ve been hanging out together? Like, half of our conversations were just me trying to figure out what makes you tick so I could try and work up the courage to ask you out. And I feel like I was not subtle in the slightest when it came to the physical stuff, either,” Steve said.

“No, I mean, I noticed, of course I noticed, but… I thought I was reading it wrong, y’know? But, wait, why were you flirting with me if you were already starting to see Munson? And please don’t tell me it’s because you realized you didn’t like him as much as you thought or you just wanted something different, because I already feel like I’ve driven a wedge between you two and I really won’t be able to take it if I find out that you were cheating on your boyfriend with me,” Billy rambled, the words coming out almost too fast for his brain to process.

“No, no! Nothing like that, it’s just…” Steve took a deep breath, sighing it out before he continued, “When he asked me out, Eddie told me that he felt he could tell me anything, and then he told me that I wasn’t the only person he wanted to date. He told me that he’s open to trying anything when it comes to relationships, and he said that he liked me, but he also liked you just as much. So he told me that he wanted to ask you out too at some point, but that I seemed like the easier nut to crack so he decided to talk to me about it first. I told him that I wasn’t quite sure how it was going to work, but I wouldn’t exactly be opposed to it, either. So we did some research and we figured out that when you’re in a relationship with more than one person at once, it’s called polyamory. And once I knew a little bit more about it, I realized that as long as you were both okay with it, I wanted that with you and Eds. I’d been crushing pretty hard on you both for a while and when I found out that there was a way for me to have both of you at the same time, I was over the moon about it. So I tried to get the ball rolling by flirting with you a little bit and testing the waters, and Eddie and I had this whole plan for asking you out after we cleaned up like always after the first show, and when you kissed me today, I just blanked because I hadn’t gotten the chance to talk to you about anything yet and I didn’t know if our plan would work out or if you would get upset if I told you about it or anything like that and I just panicked.”

Billy had wanted to interrupt Steve at least twelve times throughout that speech he gave, and yet every single time, he found he was too baffled to even try. Steve wasn’t mad at him. He still wanted to be his friend. He wanted to be more than friends, and he wanted the exact same thing Billy had been wanting for weeks now. He had only been shocked earlier because he wanted to do something special to show him that, but Billy had messed it up for him, and even then, he wasn’t mad about it. He was only upset because he hadn’t gotten to talk to Billy about it first, and just the fact that he’d thought to do that meant a lot to Billy. So often the people who’d wanted to ask him out would just do so without seeing if he was okay with everything they wanted from him, and it had always made him feel like shit, so the fact that he not only didn’t fuck up everything with Steve, but he’d only thought he did because Steve was waiting to ask for his consent first made his heart swell up in his chest. Now if only he could take back everything that’d happened in the last few hours and do it right this time.

“So… you’re saying that I didn’t fuck everything up beyond repair?” Billy asked, feeling more bashful than he ever remembered feeling. He hadn't even felt this shy when his friend dared him to ask out the most popular girl in their class back in the second grade.

“Of course not, silly,” Steve said, smiling as he reached out and tucked a stray curl behind his ear. “If anything, you did the exact opposite.”

“And you both still want to date me, even though I’m a complete fucking trainwreck?” Billy asked, looking into Steve’s eyes as he chewed on the inside of his cheek.

“Well, I can’t speak for Eds, but I for one definitely still want to date you, trainwreck or not,” Steve said, before leaning forward and closing his eyes. 

This kiss was nothing like the first one the two had shared. It wasn’t rough, it wasn’t tense, it wasn’t over too soon. It was perfect, soft enough to strip the tension from the moment and replace it with warm, fuzzy sweetness, and long enough to say every word that needed to be said, but was too fragile to be spoken aloud. It was the type of kiss a movie would spend an hour leading up to, the kind that takes 16,079 words to lead up to in a story, the kind that every romantic dreams about sharing with someone in the middle of a rainstorm. And the only person that Billy ever hoped would share a kiss like this with him, other than Steve, of course, had just walked back into the room to witness the end of it. 

“So, I take it you guys finally worked everything out?” Eddie asked as he stood in front of the two of them, his hands clasped behind his back.

“Yeah, we did,” Steve said, smiling up at his boyfriend. One of his boyfriends , Billy thought, and he couldn’t keep from smiling a little himself.

“Good, cuz I have something I want to say to you both,” Eddie said, moving his hands from behind his back and taking one of theirs in each before kneeling down in front of them. “Billy Hargrove, Steve Harrington, will you both do me the honor of going on a date with me?”

Billy had to laugh at the display Eddie was putting on, he was ridiculous sometimes. Still, he squeezed his hand and rolled his eyes as he said, “You are the most dramatic person I have ever met in my life, but yes, I will go on a date with you.”

“I second both of those statements,” Steve added.

“Woohoo! Finally! Now it’s time for cuddles!” Eddie cheered as he bounced up, getting a little mischievous twinkle in his eye. “Hey, Stevie, what do you say we make a sandwich out of this big hunk of man-meat?”

“I say that idea has me as keen as mustard,” Steve grinned even wider, both him and Eddie wrapping their arms around Billy as he groaned loudly and scrubbed his hand over his face again.

“We’ve been officially dating for less then two minutes and I already want to break up with both of you,” he said, but his smile gave away just how happy he really was to be smushed between the other two. 

“Oh, be quiet, you love us,” Eddie said, planting a kiss on his cheek, “Now don’t talk for the rest of the night. Your voice is still scratchy and you need to let it rest, so I don’t want to hear anymore out of you unless you’re asking for tea, water, a cough drop, or to take a piss, comprende?”

“Fine, I’ll shut up, but not because you told me to, only because I wouldn’t be able to avoid the wrath of my sister if I ruined the show,” Billy said, but then he kept his promise and kept his mouth shut for the rest of the night. Eventually, the trio moved from cuddled together watching something on TV to cuddled together in Eddie’s bed, which was barely big enough for two of them, let alone all three. Still, they didn’t mind being on top of each other as they drifted off to sleep, happier now than they could ever remember being.

When Billy woke up the next morning, it took him a moment to figure out what, exactly, was happening. One of his arms was propped under a pillow in a bed that was not his and the other was being pinned down by someone else’s, keeping him in place. That someone was snoring louder than the shouts of cavalry to the charge, obviously still out cold, and his hair was splayed out all over the place, including a large chunk of it resting in Billy’s mouth. 

“Morning, Billy,” Steve said as he walked back into the room. He had another one of the Munson’s ridiculous mugs in his hand, and the strong smell of cheap coffee wafted into the room with him. 

“Sthebe! Halph meh!” Billy said, trying to speak around the hair in his mouth, but not doing it very well, and it made Steve giggle a little bit. Still, he walked over and set his coffee down on the cluttered nightstand before he leaned down and brushed all the hair out Billy’s mouth. When he was done, he leaned down even further, placing a soft, chaste kiss to Billy’s lips before he sat back up and helped him untangle his arm from under Eddie’s so he could hold his hand.

“How’s your throat feelin’, baby?” Steve asked, smiling sweetly down at Billy. From the way the light was hitting him, he looked like an angel or something.

“Better,” Billy replied. “Do that again.”

“Do what again?” Steve asked, squeezing his hand.

“Call me baby. I like the way it sounds when you say it,” Billy said, his face feeling a little bit warmer than before. But Steve just laughed a little, kissed his nose, and obliged his request.

“Baby,” he said, then kissed his cheeks. “Baby,” he kissed his forehead. “Baby” he finally kissed his lips again, and Billy’s entire body was flooded with a thrill that he only used to get when he was surfing. 

“Will you two be quiet?! I’m trying to sleep here! And I want my teddy bear back,” Eddie grumbled, yanking Billy’s arm back to him and cuddling it closer than before. Billy couldn’t help but laugh at that, turning to plant a kiss on Eddie’s forehead and letting him go back to sleep, and letting himself drift with him. He was being held captive, after all, but he wouldn’t have it any other way.

As soon as they finally got up for the day, Billy was back to drinking tea to try and soothe the dull ache still in his throat, but he didn’t mind it. They never left their pajamas that day as they cuddled on the Munson’s couch watching silly little Christmas movies, only moving to switch positions, change the movie, use the bathroom, or get something from the kitchen. Other than that, they stayed put, even when Wayne came home and saw the three of them. Billy had frozen up for a second as he saw the man, but Wayne just smirked, shook his head and said he was going to bed. Billy relaxed after that, glad that Mr. Munson hadn’t been upset or weird about the three of them on the couch together. He’d never expected that reaction, especially from a man like him, but he couldn’t say that he wasn’t happy about it. 

They stayed over at Eddie’s again that night, all three of them barely able to fall asleep with how excited they were for opening night tomorrow. Still, they somehow managed to settle down, and when they woke up the next morning, they couldn’t keep the grins off their faces as they got ready to go.

It was Monday, the last day of school for the elementary schoolers before winter break, and the entire second half of their day was reserved for watching the show that the junior and senior highs were putting on for them. They had the morning to get the high school’s auditorium ready, get into costume, and work out any of the last little kinks in their performance, and before they knew it, it was time for Robin to work her magic in the makeup chair before going out and helping the band tune their instruments as the kids began to show up. The auditorium was full of noise as the kids settled down, and Billy, Steve and Eddie could hear it from the drama room as they waited for Mrs. Jackson to come and get Eddie for his opening remarks.

“Eddie, it’s go time,” she said as she walked over to the three of them, and Eddie took a deep breath as he straightened his shirt and smoothed back his hair.

“Do I look presentable?” Eddie asked as he gathered his papers.

“They’re kids, Eds, I don’t think they care what you look like. But yes, you look fine,” Steve said, fiddling with his shoes as he did.

“Okay, good. I’ll see you two later, then. And if I don’t see you before you go onstage, break a leg, both of you,” he said, squeezing both of their hands before he left to follow Mrs. Jackson to the stage. Billy and Steve followed behind, wanting to see Eddie’s only real moments on the stage. They couldn’t help but giggle a little as he borrowed the Santa hat from Lucas’s costume and pulled it on before walking to the stage, the kids all clapping politely for him as he did.

“Hi guys!” Eddie said into a microphone, a huge smile on his face as the kids all said hello back to him.

“Oh, come on, you can do better than that! Let’s try again. Hi guys!” Eddie repeated, louder this time, and when the kids screamed back another hello, he pretended to be blown back by the sound, making some of the kids laugh.

“That’s more like it!” He said, smiling, “Now, before we get started, I need to talk to you for a moment. My name’s Eddie, I’m the director of the show you’re about to see, and I’m super excited about it, so I want to ask you guys for just a few favors. Everyone in the show today is just as pumped as I am to be doing this show for you, so I want you guys to be respectful of them and do your best to not interrupt the performance. I’m gonna ask you to please stay as quiet and still as you can while the show is going on, and please try to only get up during the intermission about halfway through the show. If you brought any snacks or drinks, please try to eat them as quietly as you can, and please throw away any trash you end up with at the end. If you need to use the bathroom you can, but ask your teachers quietly first and leave the auditorium as quickly and quietly as you can. And it’s going to be dark in here, so please make sure you watch where you’re walking so you don’t get hurt. Our performers are just about ready to get started, so do you guys think you can do that for me?”

A loud chorus of ‘yes’ came through the auditorium, and Eddie beamed. 

“Alrighty, then. Without further ado, please sit back, relax, and enjoy Hawkins’ Junior and Senior high school’s production of The Year Without a Santa Claus !” The kids all cheered and clapped again as Eddie took a bow and walked off stage, but they quieted down as the lights went off and the band began to play the opening song. As the song played, the crew made sure everything was in place and that all the props had been handed out, and Max, Lucas and the rest of the performers in the opening scene scrambled to get into place. 

The curtains opened and the show began, the stage lights coming on as the kids clapped frantically. Billy and Steve gave Eddie a quick hug as he ran off the stage, then went back to the drama room to wait until it was time for them to come on stage. When it finally was, they played their characters with as much pizazz as they could muster up, and the kids seemed to be loving it, if their laughter was anything to go by. They had them splitting their sides the entire time they were on stage, and by intermission, it was getting hard to stay in character from the smiles that were threatening to break through on their faces.

When they returned from intermission and did the rest of the show, they once again had the kids rolling in the aisles as they went through the acts, and when they finished the show and came out one last time to do the final bows, the applause they received sounded more like thunder. When Billy and Steve went out with Nancy to take their final bow, the kids all cheered, laughing even more as they continued to act like goons with each other. They were finally done with bows after the rest of the cast took theirs, and they waited until the lights went off and the final song notes rang out before they went backstage and to the drama room. Mrs. Jackson was waiting for them there, with baskets full of candy canes on the table behind her, and she nodded at Eddie before he stood up on one of the tables and clapped his hands to get everyone’s attention.

“Alright gang, Mrs. Jackson has one last request for us,” he said as he stood there, “The principal of Hawkins Elementary asked if we would do a meet and greet with the kids and take some pictures with the classes. The pictures shouldn’t take long, as long as the kids cooperate, but that shouldn’t be too hard to get them to do. And then we’re gonna hand out candy canes for them as they board the buses to leave. We’ve paired you up and you’ll each take a class after the pictures, so here’s your candy cane partners, listen up! Mother Nature and Iggy Thistlewhite, you’ll take the fifth graders. Vixen and Mayor Sinclair, the fourth graders. Jingle and Jangle, you’ll take the third graders. Mr. and Mrs. Claus, the second graders, and you’ll do the kindergarteners, too, since you were the stars of the show. And that leaves Snowy and the Hot-head to take the first graders. Everyone know where they’re going?” 

Everyone nodded and touched up their costumes before waiting for further directions, and after taking pictures with all the classes, they partnered up to go and wait by the door for the classes to be dismissed to the buses. Max and Lucas went first, taking turns giving high fives and candy canes to the kids as they left, thanking them for coming. Once the kindergarteners had all left, it was Steve and Billy’s turn, and they did the same, slipping back into character as they gave out high fives and fist bumps and candy canes, and they pretended to bicker as one little girl told Billy that he was her favorite character in the whole show. After that, they went backstage as Max and Lucas went back out, and began to wipe their makeup off as Dustin and Mike went out to give candy canes to the third graders. Erica and El went out for the fourth graders, and Nancy and Will followed to send off the fifth graders. After the kids had all left, everyone took off their costumes and hung them up for the show they’d be putting on for the residents of the nursing home tomorrow. 

And when they did put on that show, they were blown away by the audience’s reaction. If the kids had loved them, then the old folks had absolutely adored them, and when they went out to do a meet and greet with them after the show had ended, Billy had received more cheek pinches and nose tweaks than he had ever thought he’d be able to stand. And when Mrs. Henderson, Dustin’s grandmother, had bought everyone in the show a bouquet of flowers and gave Billy his, he almost started crying as he thanked her. 

Once the old folks had left and the cast had gotten changed to head home, Billy, Steve and Eddie had all stayed after like always to clean up. Their bouquets from Mrs. Henderson were set carefully on the table as they put away props and costumes and set pieces, and by the time they were ready to leave for the night, it was almost pitch black outside.

“So, do you guys have any plans for Christmas Eve tomorrow?” Eddie asked as they walked out, almost reminiscent of the first time they’d walked out together after the second day of practice.

“Nah, my folks are out of town, so I was just going to order a pizza and stay in tomorrow,” Steve replied, shrugging.

“My old man hasn’t told me of any plans that we have, but he usually ignores me during the holidays so he and Susan can dote on Max, so I was planning on just going to bed and then sneaking out early on Christmas morning. Why?” Billy asked, careful not to jostle his flowers around as he pulled his jacket on.

“Because Wayne said I could invite you over if I wanted. He’s making a big Christmas dinner and we’re gonna play some games and just chill out. And he said you could spend the night, too, so we can exchange gifts in the morning and eat a big breakfast like we always do. What do you guys say?” Eddie asked, pushing open the doors to the parking lot and holding it open for the other two.

“I say that sounds awesome. I’m down,” Steve replied, he and Eddie looking at Billy.

“I say that I will definitely be there. What time should we be there?” He asked, grinning wider than he’s sure he ever had before.

“Whenever. Like I said, it’s just gonna be a chill night, nothing fancy, just bring yourselves and your holiday spirit and it’ll be the best Christmas ever!” Eddie cheered, pumping his fist in the air. The other two rolled their eyes, but they smiled, saying they’d see him tomorrow and kissing him on either of his cheeks before doing the same to each other and heading for their cars.

When Billy parked the Camaro outside of the Munson’s trailer the next night around 6 o’clock, he couldn’t help but feel a little bit nervous. The wine-red sweater he was wearing started to feel like it was strangling him as he opened his door and went to his trunk to get the presents he’d bought for everyone, cringing a little when he saw his mediocre wrap job. Still, he took a deep breath of the freezing air and shut his trunk, walking up to the door and knocking. Within seconds, Eddie was flinging it open and letting him inside, only stopping him for a second as he pointed up at the mistletoe hung in the doorway. Billy rolled his eyes with a fond smile but kissed him anyway, and waved to Wayne as he stuck his gifts under the tree glowing in the corner of the living room. He smiled as he remembered Eddie saying something about Wayne wearing one of his ‘good flannels’ since it was a special occasion, and he had to smile at the fuzzy blue monstrosity of a sweater that Eddie himself was wearing. He looked like Cookie Monster in that thing.

“I hope you’re hungry, kid,” Wayne said as Billy went to join him and Eddie in the kitchenette. “I made enough for an army.”

“I’m starving, actually. Thank you for dinner, sir,” Billy said, smiling as Wayne gave him a look.

“I told you to quit callin’ me ‘sir’, kid. You’re makin’ me feel like an old man!” Wayne chuckled, stirring something around in a big pot as he shook his head. “Now, go put your overnight bag in Eddie’s room and then come here and help me mash up these potatoes. As soon as Steve gets here, we’re gonna eat.”

Billy did as he was told and helped Wayne with the potatoes as Eddie set the table, bolting over to the door as soon as he heard a knock. He stopped Steve in the doorway the same way he had with Billy, and once Steve had put his bag in Eddie’s room and his presents under the tree, he joined them all in the kitchen. 

“Hi, Wayne, hey Billy,” he said, holding a red tin with a little gold reindeer on it. “I brought cookies for dessert, where should I put them?”

“Dang it, I told you kids not to bring anything! You never like to listen, do you?” Wayne said, shaking his head with that same fondly annoyed look he’d given to Billy. “Just put ‘em on the coffee table, we’ll eat ‘em later. Then I want you boys to sit down and relax, Eds and I will serve dinner.”

Billy followed Steve as he put the cookies on the table, then sat down opposite him at the Munson’s small kitchen table. Eddie took their plates and returned a few minutes later with them piled high with food. Mashed potatoes, green beans, shrimp, mac and cheese, corn and chicken were placed in front of them in a feast fit for kings, as well as glasses of sparkling juice and water, and there was a gravy boat on the table, too. Wayne and Eddie came in with their own plates a few moments later, and they all dug in as they chatted idly about holiday traditions or how old they were when they stopped believing in Santa Claus. Apparently, Wayne used to stay with Eddie and his family before Eddie had moved in with him when he was eleven, and he was so good at playing Santa Claus for him every year that Eddie didn’t figure out the truth until he was 13. 

“That’s so cute,” Billy laughed around his mouthful, delighting in the way Eddie’s face went as red as his sweater. 

“Okay, let’s change the subject. Wayne, this shrimp is fantastic. What’s your secret, how do you always make it so good?” Eddie asked, popping one of the little pink treats in his mouth.

“It’s on the back of the Old Bay can, kid,” Wayne laughed, using his fork to point at the seasoning on the kitchen counter.

“You’re kidding me. All these years I thought you were a gourmet chef and here the recipe is on the back of the seasoning box?! My entire life is a lie!” Eddie groaned, making everyone laugh even harder at him. Steve almost choked on his green beans, he was so hysterical.

“Oh, so I see it’s gang-up-on-Eddie-and-make-him-feel-stupid day, too, huh?” Eddie said, pulling his hair in front of his face.

“Aw, come on, kid, we’re just yankin’ your chain. And anyway, as your legal guardian and official father figure, it’s my job to embarrass you in front of your boyfriends when they come over, so don’t be sore, or else Santy Claus might skip us when he’s makin’ his rounds tonight,” Wayne teased, winking at Eddie as he took a big bite of chicken.

“You are the literal worst, Wayne,” Eddie groaned, “But you are one hell of a cook. So everyone stop picking on me and eat the fantastic meal my uncle made, okay? Okay!”

Everyone laughed a little as Eddie shoved a huge forkful in his mouth and nearly choked on it, but once his airways were clear and he’d gotten himself under control, they went on eating. 

When they were finished, Wayne sent the boys to the living room to relax while he cleaned up, and they put on Wayne’s old ‘Christmas Favorites’  album on the record player, just relaxing and sometimes singing along to the tunes as they waited for Wayne to join them. When he did, he brought them each a mug of cocoa with marshmallows and they broke open the tin of cookies Steve brought. They laughed and talked as they enjoyed them until they finally moved back to the dining room and played Parcheesi, which, according to Eddie, was a Munson Christmas tradition. 

The game took almost 2 hours to finish, mostly because everyone playing it was so damn competitive, and once it was over, they retired to the living room once more to relax until bedtime. No matter how old Eddie got, Wayne insisted on bedtime at 10:30 on Christmas Eve, if for no other reason than making sure Eddie would wake up early to open his gifts.

Once 10:30 rolled around, Wayne herded the boys off to bed, making sure they were fast asleep before he put the plan he and Eddie had come up with into action. It was almost midnight by then, but he didn’t care. He loved Eddie, and he loved anyone Eddie loved, as long as they loved him back. And he’d always had a soft spot in his heart for anyone who needed a little extra love, especially around the holidays, so he was almost as excited as Eddie had been when he set to work. He didn’t get to bed until almost midnight, but he went with a smile on his face, and he could hardly wait until the boys woke up tomorrow morning.

“Wake up, wake up, wake up! C’mon guys, it’s Christmas!” Eddie cheered as he ran through the trailer, ringing a bell that had seemingly appeared out of thin air and banging on walls and doors to create as much noise as he could. “C’mon boys, up and at ‘em! Santa came! Get up, get up, get up! ” 

“Fuck off, Munson, it’s not even 8 AM yet,” Billy groaned as he threw a pillow at him. 

“Not for another two minutes, sure, but you’re not hearing me! Santa Claus has stopped and shoved his fat ass through the tiny little vents of this trailer so that we could open presents with each other and have fun! Just come and see the living room! I swear it’ll be worth it!” Eddie said as he climbed on top of the bed and began to jump on it. Steve and Billy groaned and kicked him away, but after elbowing each other in the ribs and being shaken up by Eddie’s jumping, they finally decided it was easier to just get up. 

“Merry Christmas, boys!” Wayne said as they walked into the room after Eddie, rubbing their eyes and mumbling good morning as Eddie continued to bounce around. “There’s coffee in the pot if you want some. I even sprung for the good stuff for once.”

“Thanks, Wayne,” Steve said, pouring himself and Billy each a cup before they headed to the living room. As they got past the kitchen doorway, they both stopped short, their eyes nearly popping out of their heads as they saw the tree. Or rather, what was beneath it. 

There were presents of every shape and size underneath it, as well as four stockings hanging on the hooks that normally held Wayne’s hat collection, and Wayne was sitting on the couch with a Santa hat on as if everything was normal.

“What the hell?” Billy asked as he walked over to the stockings, puzzled to see his own name on one of them.

“I told you, Santa Claus came!” Eddie cheered, bounding up behind him and nearly tackling him by accident as he took the stockings and handed them out to everyone. 

Billy and Steve were still in disbelief as Eddie shoved them down on the couch on either side of him, Wayne grinning at them from his armchair and reaching beside him to grab an old camera.

“Hold your stockings up and smile, boys!” He said, grinning as the flash went off, capturing Eddie with a huge smile and the other two with their jaws on the ground. He couldn’t wait to get a copy of this printed for the fridge. 

“Well, go on! A lot of the stuff in there is the same as everyone else’s, but that doesn’t mean you can’t start opening! The sooner you get started, the sooner I can start breakfast,” Wayne said, pulling something small out of his own stocking and beginning to unwrap it. Eddie did the same with something in his stocking, and once Steve and Billy recovered from the initial shock of it all, they began to unwrap, too. 

Wayne had gotten them all the same little trinkets and treats just like he said, mostly just a few hygiene products and little things that everyone needed, especially if the other two boys were going to start spending more and more time here. The only thing he’d gotten Eddie that he hadn’t gotten for the other two was a box of condoms, which he hid at the bottom of the stocking. After all, playing a little joke on Eddie on Christmas morning had almost become a tradition between the two of them. He snapped a picture of Eddie opening it, laughing so hard, the picture came out a little blurry. Eddie’s face was as red as his Santa hat as he saw what the tiny box was, and Steve and Billy were laughing just as hard as Wayne had been when he snapped the picture.

After that, they moved on to the presents beneath the tree, Wayne having gotten as many as he and Eddie could afford for the three boys. Eddie had gotten a few small things and some clothes as well as a new amp and a new set of D&D dice, Steve had gotten some of that hairspray that he liked and a new sweater along with a few other little things, and Billy had gotten some little trinkets, a few new books that he’d been wanting to read and a new pair of earrings shaped like little skeletons. The three of them thanked Wayne up and down as they opened their gifts, and Steve and Billy nearly cried almost four times each as they opened everything up. They had no idea how he and Eddie had gotten this all together with the tiny amount of time they had, but they couldn’t have been more happy or grateful about it.

“There’s only a few gifts left, I think they’re the ones you boys brought last night,” Wayne said as he put his camera down on the coffee table. He’d been snapping pictures the entire time, but now it was Eddie’s turn to pick up the camera as he shared a look with Billy and Steve.

“Yep, they sure are. Here, Wayne, this is for you,” Eddie said, grabbing the horrendously wrapped gift he’d gotten for his uncle and handed it to him. Wayne smiled and tore the paper off, finding a new hat for his collection with the words “Best Father Ever” sewn on it, but Eddie had taken some embroidery thread and crossed out ‘father’, stitching the word ‘Uncle’ underneath instead.

“Aw, Eds, you damn sap,” Wayne grinned, replacing the Santa hat on his head with the new cap. “C’mere, kid.”

Wayne hugged his nephew close and kissed his head, smiling as he settled back on the floor and Steve got up to hand him a neatly wrapped box.

“Kid, you didn’t have to get me nothin’,” Wayne said, taking the box. “But thank you.”

He tore off the paper as Steve stood there, nervously chewing his lips, unsure whether Wayne would like it or not. Wayne opened the clothing box to find three warm fleece flannels, one white, one green and one red.

“Eds helped me pick them out, he said you’d like something simple, so I hope you like them. I put the receipt in there, too, just in case we got the wrong size or something,” Steve said, fiddling with his hands. Wayne just smiled and pulled the boy into a warm hug, and as he watched this, Billy suddenly felt self-conscious about the present he’d bought for Wayne. He figured it would make him laugh, at least, and that would be okay, but he also knew that Eddie had gotten him something personal and semi-handmade, and Steve had gotten him something nice and expensive that he already knew he liked. Billy had gotten him something that he found at a secondhand store for five dollars and fifteen cents, there was no way it was going to measure up to the gifts he had already received. Still, he took the bag it was hidden in and handed it to Wayne, biting at his nails as he pulled out the paper. And then he busted out laughing.

“Holy shit, kid! Where in the world did you find this?” Wayne asked as he looked into the bag, a giddy smile on his face and a twinkle in his eyes.

“What is it?” Eddie and Steve asked at the same time, and when Wayne pulled it out of the bag, they started to laugh, too. It was a mug to add to his collection, shaped like Odie from the Garfield comics to match the one he had of Garfield. Billy had seen it when he was out shopping the day before, and he snatched it up as soon as he did, remembering the mug Eddie had given him on that night a few days ago. He’d been nervous about it ever since he bought it, but now that he saw the way it was making Wayne light up like the Christmas tree, a wave of satisfied relief washed over him.

“Kid, this is one of the best gifts I’ve gotten in a long time. I don’t know how or where you found it, but thank you. You just made my Christmas,” Wayne said, putting the mug down on the table and wrapping Billy in the tightest hug he could. Billy practically melted into the embrace, and he could’ve sworn he heard the sound of the camera shutter going off, but he wasn’t sure. Either way, he was grinning wider than he’d ever thought possible, as this was the first Christmas he’d had in a very long time that he actually spent with a family that loved him.

“Alright, alright, that’s enough, now,” Wayne said as he gave Billy one last squeeze and broke the embrace. “I’m gonna go start breakfast, you three give each other your gifts and then we’ll eat.”

Wayne left them for the kitchen and the boys all grabbed their presents for each other, sitting on the floor in a circle and bouncing happily as they passed them around. Steve had gotten Eddie a little wooden treasure chest that he’d painted to keep his dice in so he wouldn’t lose them as often as he normally did. He’d gotten Billy a copy of the Gone with the Wind VHS tape, since he’d enjoyed the book so much and wanted to see the movie anyway, but hadn’t had a chance to rent it yet. 

Billy gave them his gifts next, having gotten Eddie the one Black Sabbath record he didn’t already have, and it even came with a free poster on the inside of it. He’d gotten Steve a new digital watch, since Steve complained all the time about how hard it was to read his analog one anymore (the truth is, Steve just needed glasses, but he was going to fight that tooth and nail until the day his vision gets so bad, he can’t even see two feet in front of him).

Finally, it was time for Eddie to give them their gifts, which were identical in shape and size, but you almost couldn’t tell that from the crude way he’d wrapped them. Still, Eddie was nearly bouncing as he readied the camera, telling them they had to open them at the exact same time. He counted down from three and the other two tore off the wrapping, erupting into fits of giggles as soon as the paper was off. Eddie had gotten them each a little figurine he’d found at some toy store, Billy’s being a miniature figure of Heat Miser, and Steve’s being a miniature figure of Snow Miser. 

“Do you like them? It took me almost two days of scouring toy store after toy store to find them,” Eddie asked, smiling widely and scrunching up his nose in delight.

“Like ‘em? Eds, we love ‘em!” Steve said, leaning in and kissing Eddie on his nose.

“Although your uncle is right, you are a damn sap,” Billy said, following Steve’s example and kissing Eddie on his nose before adding, “Merry Christmas, guys.”

“Merry Christmas, baby,” they both answered him back, making him feel all warm and fuzzy again.