Actions

Work Header

Trust in the Time Warp

Summary:

After Steve loses both of his boyfriends in the span of a year, he's not sure how to recover. Luckily, the Upside Down seems to have other plans for him because suddenly, he's waking up on November 4, 1984...for the second time.

Harringroveson Bingo 2022 Fill: A3 Time Travel

Notes:

Hello everyone! Despite the tags, there will be some fluff and humor throughout I promise this is not 10k of straight angst. That being said, if anyone is worried about the "Choose Not To Use Archive Warnings", this is related to the "temporary character death" tag and I will explain in a note at the end so you can make the decision on whether or not you would like to read this. To make it clear, no other major archive warnings apply.

Check me out on Tumblr at writer-in-theory

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

JULY 4, 1986

Last year, while Steve Harrington had been trapped underground being tortured by Russians, there had been a fair. Nearly the whole town had shown up, the night sky full of fireworks while they’d lit up Starcourt with the very same. Apart from a ragtag group of kids who couldn’t seem to stay out of trouble and a couple of ice cream shop employees, the night had been filled with joy.

This year, there was no trace of that joy. There was no fair, there weren’t even any backyard barbeques to celebrate the nation’s day. There wasn’t much celebration of anything in Hawkins these days, not since the ground had opened up in a “rouge earthquake” that destroyed the entire town. 

If Steve closed his eyes, he could pretend the town was mourning with him. They were missing those blue eyes and denim jacket, singing their grief for curly dark hair and a Hellfire Club shirt. All of this was for them and the time Steve never got to have with either of them. He never even got the chance to introduce the two, never got to see all three of them in the same room. Billy would have liked Eddie, if only they had more time . 

But they didn’t have more time and the two people he loved more than anything were dead and buried, and Steve didn’t know how he was ever meant to move on from it all. Because he’d already done it once, had barely started to feel like maybe there was hope for him after all when he’d met Eddie. That sure, he loved Billy and would always love Billy, but he loved Eddie too and Billy would have wanted him to be happy. But both of them sacrificed themselves for a town that never even bat an eyelash at their deaths, and Steve was left attending two far too-empty funerals, crying for the two heroes this town would never actually know existed.

So maybe Steve would never be okay again, in the same way that Hawkins would never quite be free from the horrors of the Upside Down. People had fled in droves and never looked back, dropping the population from its already small number to minuscule. Steve’s parents were selling the house in Loch Nora—had told him to pack up whatever he wanted to keep with him because the house wasn’t a sound investment anymore. He’d spent all week tossing memories into boxes, including a well-worn basketball sweatshirt with Billy’s number and last name on it, and a denim vest that Steve had never gotten around to returning to Eddie. He boxed up pictures of his childhood spent running through the streets with Tommy and Carol, held onto the little stuffed lion he thought he’d lost years before. He emptied out the house And just like that, the Harrington line was ending its stay in Hawkins after generations of raising their kids there. Steve would escape Hawkins the way both of his boyfriends had longed to do, leaving them behind in the town that was far too small for either of them.

Robin tried to help him through it, she really did. She threw herself into volunteering at the shelter long after she wanted to stop because Steve needed to keep busy. And when the shelter was finally reverted back to the high school, she would spend nights in the house that was far too big for just him, both of them tangled up in his bed because he would never get used to sleeping without someone there beside him ever again. But she had her own parents who were actually around and who worried for their kid who never stopped having nightmares after the Russian interrogation, so Steve told her he was fine and she didn’t push because he asked her not to. The kids tried to help too, but Max was in the hospital and El had another bucket of trauma to unpack after Dr. Brenner somehow returned, and Steve couldn’t take adding to any of their worries.

Maybe that was why, on Steve’s final night in Hawkins, he found himself walking himself back to Lover’s Lake, sitting himself in the dirt beside one of the deep grooves in the ground. The eerie red light had long since faded from the splits, but Steve found himself wishing it would come back if only for a moment. Because they’d left Eddie in there, and there was a chance Billy was in there too, after spending so much time invaded by the Mind Flayer. And if he could just get another chance to talk to them , maybe everything would start to feel okay again.

“I don’t know why I’m here,” Steve finally sighed, running a hand through the hair he hadn’t bothered styling in days, weeks . “Both of you would hate this. You’d really hate it, and you’d never let me hear the end of it. God, and I’d let you. So come on, do it. Tell me I’m being a sappy shit and tell me to shove off, tell me you didn’t know King Steve had such a mushy heart. I know you want to.”

Only the crickets answered, chirping just loud enough that Steve couldn’t tense at every rustle of the leaves and sound from a nearby animal shuffling along. He sighed and hung his head low between his raised knees, hair falling forward into his vision. “Yeah, guess I should’ve expected that.”

“I’m getting out of here tomorrow,” Steve continued after a few minutes of pained silence. He’d found a little twig on the ground nearby and began idly digging in the dirt with it, prodding at the fissure in the ground as if he might dig his way to the Upside Down. “Mom and Dad want me to come with them to Chicago, but I think I need to go to California. Pack up the Beemer and just...drive, like we said we would. And Eddie, Wayne made me promise to go check out the music scene in Seattle, said you’d been talking about it since last October.

I don’t really know what I’ll do out there anymore, but maybe it’ll be good to get out of Hawkins. Robin keeps telling me this is a good thing , as if I don’t— Fuck this is stupid, I’m stupid,” Steve interrupted himself, stabbing the stick harshly into the ground as the crushing weight of losing both people he’d loved to the same fucking thing smacked into his chest. “I hate it! I hate it, I hate it!” he shouted, voice rough as it tore from his throat. His arm continued moving, smashing the stick down into the ground until the wood was shattered into too many splinters to be used as an outlet for all the anger, frustration, grief he’d been trying so hard to hold back for so long.

And as the stick snapped in half, so too did Steve’s body, curling forward so his forehead was pressed to the dirt that Eddie and Billy now called home, wishing only briefly that he might return home to them soon. “ Please ,” he pleaded with the ground, fingers digging in so harshly he felt his nails bend and strain with the pressure. “I’d do anything to have them back.”

Maybe Steve just wanted a miracle, or maybe he’d finally cracked under the grief of the anniversary of the worst year of his life, but the ground seemed to listen to him . It shook a little, the fissure widening only a little around the snapped-off end of the stick still pointing up from the dirt. The ground cracked and splintered around it, crumbling away to reveal not the glowing red Steve had come to associate with the Upside Down but an odd blue . Then, all at once, the ground stopped shaking, and the cracks stopped until the blue was just about the size of a dartboard. 

“This is stupid,” Steve huffed out again, head lifted to stare at the glowing blue that appeared because he’d asked it to . He knew he should walk back to the house and call someone. Dustin, probably, maybe Robin if he didn’t want to explain what he was doing out here in the first place. Eventually, the news that Steve had cracked open the thinly veiled peace would make it to the entire group, so it didn’t really matter who he told first. 

None of them had quite believed it was over. Sure they’d launched Vecna out a window but they hadn’t seen the body , and then Hawkins was split into quadrants just like the clock chimes warned, so they’d missed something. The Upside Down wasn’t done with them yet, but for once they had no idea what to expect next. So they’d all waited, watching as the fissures seemed to heal away and no Demogorgons popped out from the ground to steal away more children. It was almost like losing had given them the very thing they’d all been fighting for for years—an end, a chance to try and salvage what they could from the wreckage and move on.

No, Steve couldn’t ruin whatever sense of normalcy those kids found between March and now, he wouldn’t be the reason El risked everything again and another kid got hurt on his watch. Billy and Eddie had both died saving those kids, Steve couldn’t be the one to ruin that. 

So he reached out his hand, fingers shaking as they hovered over the glowing blue membrane in the ground. More likely than not, this was a trap and Steve would end up caught back in the Upside Down where those ashes seemed to cling to the inside of his throat for days after. It’s not like anyone would know either since he said he was planning on taking off early in the morning so he could avoid his parents coming back for the last check-through of the house. There would be no rescue mission, no desperate attempts to get him back as soon as possible. They’d all assume he was relaxing on a California beach and Steve couldn’t fault any of them for it.

That didn’t stop him from reaching forward, pressing fingers against the oddly fleshy membrane until his hand broke through the other side. The membrane burst with enough force that it broke Steve’s balance, sending him crashing forward into the hole the blue film had left behind.

It felt like he was falling for years. Steve opened his mouth to scream but no sound came out like someone had snapped a rubber band around his throat and pulled it tight. This was nothing like the Upside Down, where they’d immediately crashed through to the other side in a scary reminder that the dimension was far closer to their own world than Steve wanted to think about.

Where was he going?

Steve’s back smacked against the pavement so harshly he knew his bones should’ve shattered. Instead, all it did was rip his breath away like any time he was shoved over in a basketball match. He still gasped for air, relief rushing through him that it was clean, free of any Upside Down ash. Hands come up to clutch at his chest, feeling around for any kind of injury, any wetness to evidence the blood that was supposed to be locked away inside him. He kept his eyes shut, desperate not to see what this fall did to him.

“What, you try to walk and chew gum again, Harrington?”

Oh, God. 

It had been exactly one year since he’d heard that voice, longer since he’d heard it without the cruel edge of the Mind Flayer. It sent another wave of hurt flashing through Steve’s chest that he’d nearly forgotten what the other boy had sounded like already.

This wasn’t real. This was a trick by Vecna, the same way he’d made Nancy see the end of Hawkins and Max see, well, whatever it was that had given her such a haunted look after visiting Billy’s grave. Max said Vecna showed people their worst memories, the ones that made them feel the guiltiest. If that were true, it only made sense that he would show him Billy Hargrove, one of two people he couldn’t save no matter how hard he tried.

Steve’s eyes refused to open. He just laid there, hands coming up to press the base of his palms against his eyelids as if that might somehow convince his brain to wake up from whatever trance Vecna had him in. Because he couldn’t do this, he couldn’t hear that voice not on this day, not when he’d spent all morning wishing he could’ve done anything differently last year to let him and Billy watch the fireworks at the fair together . He hadn’t had enough time with either of them, and hadn’t really realized how much he wanted a chance with them until they were laying dead in front of him. He couldn’t take this reminder that once again he let down someone he loved, that in a few months’ time he’d do it again because apparently that was all Steve Harrington could do an—

“Seriously, if you’re dead I’m leaving you here for someone else to deal with.” A toe of a hard boot nudged into Steve’s ribs, just on the other side of too much force. “ Harrington. ”

Steve’s eyes shot open at the huff of breath followed by the annoyed snap of his name that he’d come to know so well. When they’d grown closer, eventually that snap was preceded by a roll of the eyes and a little smile, like Billy couldn’t quite hide his affection for Steve no matter how badly he wanted to. Now though, it was the same as those odd months after November, when harsh tones met something strangely soft in the eyes. It had confused Steve before but when brown met blue he understood now what he should have a year ago—that softness was affection, a deep affection that they hadn’t uncovered until the summer.

“Billy,” Steve gasped, rocketing to his feet and ignoring the twinge in his back that told him the fall wasn’t quite as free from damage as he thought. He watched confusion cross Billy’s features only momentarily before they were schooled into that same neutral smirk that used to infuriate Steve. Now it only made him want to cry in relief—because how many times had he laid in bed wishing for any chance to see that smirk again? “You’re here.”

Before he could stop himself, Steve was launching toward Billy, wrapping his arms around the other boy’s body as tightly as he could. Within seconds Billy was sliding his hands between their chests and shoving as hard as he could, sending Steve stumbling back a few steps. 

“What the fuck, Harrington? You got some more brain damage I don’t know about?”

“I just-” Steve started, glancing around to see who was around. They were in the Hawkins High parking lot which, sure fine he supposed that made sense, but instead of seeing anyone else around, he caught sight of Billy’s Camaro . The Camaro which had been completely totaled outside of Starcourt mall one year ago, the car which Steve had desperately wanted to keep and repair but had been told was just too far gone, left to be abandoned just like its owner had been. “You got your car back. How’d you get it back? How are you here ?”

Billy just watched him for a moment, expression equal parts confusion and frustration. Then he rolled his eyes like he hadn’t just risen from the dead , and said, “Whatever, man. Next time you wanna get high before school, stay the hell away from me.”

“I—what? Wait, wait, Billy!” Steve yelled, sprinting and grabbing a fistful of denim jacket to keep him from walking away. “You’re not weirded out by this?”

“I’m weirded out by you ,” Billy returned, “what the fuck did Munson sell you?”

“Eddie?” Steve balked, eyes widening at the mention of the other man. How was it possible? This clearly wasn’t a vision created by Vecna to torture him, so what other explanation could there be for seeing Billy and hearing about Eddie now? “Am I dead? Did I die? I’m dead, aren’t I?”

Billy stared at him for a full second before he was grabbing onto Steve’s arm, tugging him harshly to the passenger side of the Camaro. Steve allowed himself to be manhandled into the seat, Billy reaching over and harshly snapping the seatbelt into place. All Steve could do was watch with wide eyes, head turning to track him as Billy rounded the car and climbed into the driver’s seat.

“What are you doing?” Steve finally asked. He’d dreamed of a reunion like this before, of finding out Billy hadn’t actually died but had rather been trapped in the Upside Down by some miracle. When he’d been pulled into the gate under Lover’s Lake, Steve had allowed himself to feel the hope that when he opened his eyes, he’d see Billy standing over him. He’d imagined a million ways he’d see Billy again, but never this. 

“I’m taking you home, you’re fucked up as shit, Harrington,” Billy answered simply, eyes never leaving the road as he sped along in the direction of Loch Nora.

“I don’t live there anymore,” Steve croaked out, “we’re moving.”

“No, you’re not.” 

“Am too! How would you know anyway, you’ve been de—” The words died off in Steve’s throat as they crossed through the center of town. The center of town, which, for the past few months, had been well and completely destroyed by the fissures Vecna had torn through their world. Steve scrubbed his hand over his face, wondering when his current line of thinking had ever become a possibility. But they’d traveled to another dimension and fought monsters from said other world, so, could time travel really be out of the realm of possibility in Hawkins? “Billy, what’s today?”

“Sunday.”

“No, I mean, the date?”

“November 4th.”

“What year ?”

“What the fuck did you take, Harrington?”

“I’m not fucking high, okay?” Steve exclaimed, heart racing faster than it ever had before. How was this possible? What had the Upside Down done to him? If he really was in the past, could he get back to where he was before? “Just, please , tell me what year it is.”

Billy stopped the car in the middle of the road. Normally Steve would be concerned, but on a Sunday morning, the majority of the town was tucked away at church and not on the road. Billy looked at him, blue eyes sharp as he tried to figure out what was going on with Steve. He wished he could tell Billy, too, but he’s pretty sure time travel wasn’t on the list of things a regular person would believe, not when Billy hadn’t even encountered the Upsi—

“1984. It’s 1984, Harrington. That help you out?”

November 4th, 1984. It was one of the few dates Steve had engrained in his memory along with the birthdays of all the kiddos, and the dates he’d lost too many people. This was the day that Steve Harrington’s life flipped on a dime because later that day one Dustin Henderson would rope him into searching for an escaped demodog. Later that night, he’d protect the Party from a whole pack of them and it would be the first time he truly thought he would die protecting them. Even later that night, he’d get into a fight with Billy Hargrove at the Byers house. 

“Yeah, yeah it does,” Steve returned. Because why else would the Upside Down send him here after begging for it to give him another chance with Billy and Eddie? This was his chance to save everything, to save every one . It would’ve made sense to go back to the night at Starcourt, or even to whenever Billy had been taken over by the Mind Flayer in the first place, but he supposed going back to where it all began made sense too.

Because, at the end of the day, Billy died because he hadn’t known . Even when he and Steve had grown closer, when friendship began to feel like a little more, Steve still hadn’t let him into this dark secret that haunted Hawkins. He’d told himself it was to protect Billy, but maybe it was partly because he didn’t want to explain it. How could he possibly talk about all the times he’d nearly died when he’d willingly thrown himself into death’s arms simply because the other option was a middle schooler dying in his place? Billy had asked about the scars once, the ones decorating his left bicep and the back of his shoulder from sets of claws that had dug in too deep, but how could Steve possibly explain it?

Except now, maybe he didn’t have to explain at all. Maybe now he wouldn’t have to be the only one protecting those kids, either. Maybe now he could have someone by his side from the beginning , and Billy would survive and help him save Eddie too.

Steve could do this.

“Do you trust me?” he asked then, chest full of the same determination he’d felt all those times the Party had come up with a game plan to win the war against the Upside Down.

“Not a chance in Hell, Harrington.”

Well, fuck.

“What d’you mean ‘no’?” Steve exclaimed, shifting in his seat so he could face Billy better, back leaning against the door of the Camaro. “I can totally be trusted!”

“ Totally ?” Billy teased, that devilish smirk that always used to irritate Steve now making him want to sob with relief. Because it had been a year since he’d seen it, hadn’t realized how much he’d miss it until it was long gone. 

“Totally and completely,” Steve answered. “C’mon, what’s the worst that can happen?”

“Oh yeah, what could go wrong with following someone blasted out of their mind wherever he wants to fuckin’ go? I don’t see the problem with that at all.”

“I’m not high, Hargrove! This is really fucking important, okay? You have to trust me.”

That smirk widened, allowing Billy’s tongue to slip out and run over his lip in a way that had Steve staring . “Say please.”

“What?”

“I want King Steve to say please. You do know what the word is, right?”

Oh, fuck Billy Hargrove. Steve groaned, wondering if there might be another way to solve this after all. Could he really deal with this version of Billy again, the one who was desperate to prove himself at the top of the school? The one who, for whatever reason, had a vendetta against Steve?

He would have to because there was no other option. Steve couldn’t go back to how things were, couldn’t go back to leaving Hawkins alone. 

So he took a deep breath, then another, then closed his eyes and pinched the bridge of his nose and didn’t open his mouth to speak again until his heart rate returned to something reasonable. “ Please, Billy , trust me.”

Billy just stared at him. Steve stared back, taking in blue eyes and an expression that had always been good at hiding from him. It had been too long since he’d had to piece together the little clues hidden there—Steve had no idea what Billy was thinking and that irritated him to no end.

Then just as quickly as he’d shoved Steve into the car, Billy was shrugging and restarting the engine. “Sure, pretty boy. Where’re we going?”

“Just...just like that?” Steve asked, feeling heat rise to his cheeks as Billy gave him a side glance and absolutely grinned .

“Well, you did say please.”

“Okay, fine, whatever,” Steve returned, rolling his eyes and trying to cover up the smile he could feel tugging on his lips. He’d missed the banter, the easy way of talking to Billy that made everything in Hawkins so much more interesting. “But this is gonna be crazy. I didn’t believe it at first until Henderson showed me the t—”

“Harrington.”

“Right, okay, but you can’t ask any questions. You know where the junkyard is?”

“Why are we going to the junkyard?”

“What happened to no questions?” Steve exclaimed though he noticed Billy still turned down the right road to get to the junkyard.

“I didn’t agree to shit, Harrington!”

“Okay fine, you can ask questions! Jesus, you’re annoying,” Steve groaned, sure his hair was a mess with how many times he’s run his hands through it since starting this conversation.

“Why’re we going to the junkyard, dipshit?” Billy asked then, a little smirk on his face like he was proud of himself for the comment.

“If I tried to explain it now you’ll laugh.” There was no way to explain rough demodogs and middle schoolers who can move things with her mind and policemen that were somehow on their side of all this. “Just—”

“Trust you. Yeah, I got that part.”

The car lapsed into silence then. It wasn’t uncomfortable necessarily, or at least not like it could’ve been. It certainly wasn’t like it used to be, though, or rather maybe what it would be in a few months when Steve and Billy call a truce. When they start smoking together at the Quarry to get away from all of their troubles, when Steve can’t sleep and Billy can’t be in his own home. They’d grow comfortable together, talking and laughing and sharing stories until Steve wondered how they ever thought they were supposed to be enemies. 

“So why hang out in the Hawkins parking lot?” Steve asked, glancing over at Billy as the other drove. He noticed the way Billy’s hands clenched around the wheel though his face remained impassive, forever carrying that cool smirk.

“There’s nowhere better to waste my time.” That was the voice Billy used to use when he was hiding shit. Steve had grown used to picking it out and had learned that when that slightly hardened edge came out he shouldn’t keep pushing, not unless it was one of those rare days he itched for a fight.

“There’s plenty of better spots,” Steve contested lightly, “I’d rather not spend more time there than I have to.”

“King Steve really hates his kingdom that much?”

“Why do you call me that? No one uses it anymore,” Steve groaned, tugging a little at his hair as his hand passed through it. Now that he was a year removed from high school the whole thing felt ridiculous—cliques and gossip and kings —in the face of everything much darker he’d seen. At first, he’d been hurt to lose the crown, to see how quickly everyone deserted him the second he stopped pushing others around. But now? Now he couldn’t imagine spending his days lounging at his private pool with Tommy and Carol, shotgunning beers and laughing over whatever embarrassing thing someone with less influence in the school had done. 

“What? Hit a nerve, pretty boy?” Billy teased, “Remembering good times hurts?”

“Nah, it’s just annoying,” Steve countered, thankful when the junkyard finally came into view. “Okay, okay, so I’m supposed to be meeting up with this kid named Hen—”

“Steve! Steve, what are you doing? Is that Max’s brother? Why’d you bring him here?”

“Hey, I’m right here, you little shithead!” Billy barked out as Dustin sprinted up to the Camaro, screaming as Steve pulled himself out of the passenger seat.

“How could you bring him here?” Dustin pointedly ignored Billy, focusing instead on Steve.

“He’s helping,” Steve supplied, shrugging like it wasn’t a big deal. 

“I don’t know if you know this or not, but he tried to run us over with his car! His car, Steve!”

Steve turned to look at Billy then, one eyebrow raised curiously. He’d never known about this, either because Billy asked them to keep it quiet or because they’d all moved on from it naturally he wasn’t sure. “You tried to hit them with your car?”

“No,” Billy laughed, giving Dustin that smirk, patting the top of the Camaro, and adding, “I wouldn’t hurt my baby like that.”

“We can not work with him,” Dustin protested.

“Yeah, and you said that about me too, so grab the bait and let’s get going. We need to be back here by sundown,” Steve answered instead, grabbing Dustin’s hat long enough to mess up his hair before replacing the hat back on his head. 

“What’re you baiting, Harrington?” Billy asked, jogging to catch up to Steve and Dustin, who at least had grabbed the bucket of meat he’d gotten and began walking toward the old railroad tracks. “All the bitches you still can’t land?”

Steve rolled his eyes, moving so he walked in the middle between Dustin and Billy. “You wanna take this one, Henderson? Don’t leave anything out.”

“A few days ago, I found something in my driveway. It was scavenging in the trashcan, so I brought it inside to do more research on it.”

“We’re baiting a fucking raccoon?” Billy deadpanned, and Steve had to hide his smile behind gloved hands as Dustin shot him the most shocked and horrified look Steve had ever seen on him.

“No, it’s not a raccoon ,” Dustin clarified, “I found an entirely new species, one that I think could be—”

Dustin gave Steve a look, and immediately Steve knew what it was about. How much do they tell Billy? How much can be shared? Steve didn’t want to scare him off right away, and he was sure going into detailed explanations of interdimensional monsters and powers might just do that. So instead, Steve sighed and added, “—like last year.”

“Last year?” Billy predictably pressed, to which Steve only shrugged and said, “I’ll explain later?”

“Why’d you keep it then, if it was like last year?” Steve asked, turning his head back to face Dustin as they tossed meat scraps along their path.

“It wasn’t exactly like last year. It was smaller, I thought it was a new species of slug or snail at first, and I wanted to—” Dustin’s cheeks burned red then, head dipping lower as he finished, “I wanted to show this girl .”

“You kept that thing for some girl? You couldn’t find anything else to get her attention?”

“No, Steve, I couldn’t! She’s been around the Party more and I—”

“The Party? That some D&D shit?” Billy piped up, leaning his head forward so he could look at Dustin around Steve.

“How’d you know it was D&D shit, Hargrove?” Dustin snapped back, and Steve couldn’t help the howl of laughter that followed as Billy seemed stunned some middle schooler dared talk to him like that. 

“He has a point, Hargrove,” Steve laughed, nudging his elbow into Billy’s arm and grinning at the scowl he got in return.

“Return to your freaky nerd crush, please,” Billy huffed, and well, at least he had a point. 

“Yeah, Henderson, let me get this straight. You kept something you knew was probably dangerous in order to impress a girl...who you just met?”

“All right, that's grossly oversimplifying things,” Dustin protested.

“I mean, why would a girl like some nasty slug anyway?”

“A slug like last year? Because it’s freaking awesome.”

“Shithead has a point,” Billy piped up, earning two glares this time.

“I don't know. I just feel like you're trying way too hard,” Steve shrugged, trying to remember how this had gone down with Dustin last time. He didn’t want to change too much in the past. After all, he’d watched Back to the Future—albeit high on whatever experimental drugs the Russians had given him at the time—and knew far better than to change everything all at once. “Keep it simple.”

“Well, not everyone can have your perfect hair, alright?” Dustin snapped, looking more than a little embarrassed about the situation.

“It’s not about the hair, man,” Steve tried.

“It’s a little about the hair,” Billy added unhelpfully.

“It’s not. The key with girls is just...just acting like you don’t care.”

“So that’s why King Steve can’t get any girls!”

“What are you talking about, Hargrove? I’ve slept with nearly half the popu—”

“Guys? Can we reign in the cockfight?” Dustin asked, stopping walking immediately, crossing his arms over his chest and staring at them. “I need advice. Resume that.”

“You just pretend you don’t care, okay? It’s worked every time,” Steve continued, shooting a quick look of triumph to Billy before adding, “Then you wait until...you feel it.”

“Feel what?”

“It's like before it's gonna storm, you know? You can't see it, but you can feel it, like this, uh...electricity, you know?” Try as he might, Steve couldn’t help looking at Billy at that, remembering that first kiss pressed against the Camaro. It had been the middle of the night in early March when the air still bit harshly into his skin even as Billy’s touch sent fire through him. He hadn’t understood passion until that kiss when he was sure he’d burn up from the intensity of it. 

“Oh, like in the electromagnetic field when the clouds in the atmosphere—”

“No, no, no, no,” Steve interrupted quickly, “it has nothing to do with science, okay?”

“Oh.”

“Yeah, oh . You feel that electricity, then you make your move.”

“So that’s when you kiss her?”

“Henderson!” Billy laughed, clapping his hands a couple of times in amusement right as Steve yelled, “No! Whoa, whoa, slow down, Romeo.”

“You said to make a move!” Dustin protested, which yeah Steve supposed he had.

“Sure, okay, I did. And some people, yeah, they want you to be aggressive. You know, strong, hot and heavy, like a...” Steve began, waving his hand around as he searched for the right answer.

“Like a lion,” Billy piped up, giving Steve a look he was sure Billy had never once given him before now. He didn’t know what to make of it, how to decipher all of these changes, and if they would be enough to save Billy in the end. 

“Yeah, like a lion,” Steve confirmed, eyes meeting Billy’s blue ones and staring . He thought of the little stuffed lion he’d given Billy when they graduated, the one that Max had grabbed for him after everything was over and Neil started selling his son’s things. 

“Okay, be a lion,” Dustin repeated, shocking Steve right out of his thoughts and finally breaking the eye contact between them. 

“Yeah, but others, you know, you gotta be slow. You gotta be stealthy like a...like a ninja,” Steve supplied, smiling softly as he remembered climbing into Billy’s window in the middle of the night, and even earlier when he’d snuck into...

“What type is Nancy?”

“Huh?” Steve asked,  head whipping around to face Dustin. “Nancy?”

“Your girlfriend ? It’s not a secret, everyone knows you’re dating her.”

“She’s not my girlfriend,” Steve corrected quickly, eyes burning as he fought the urge to look at Billy again. It would be too obvious, too much, even though he desperately needed to know what the other guy’s response to that was. 

“Hargrove,” Dustin piped up then, braving asking the loaded question, “how’d you get girls?”

Billy scoffed then, eyes turned to look at his boots as they continued walking. “Not like Harrington over here, I’ll tell ya that.”

“ Okayyy , if Steve’s plan doesn’t work, what do I do?”

“I say don’t worry about it,” Billy answered instead. “Whoever she is, isn’t worth the heartbreak of dating in middle school. Wait ‘til you’re outta town and you can find someone more interesting.”

“She is interesting. She’s special. It’s just, like, something about her.”

“No one’s that special, kid,” Billy corrected, rolling his eyes at the affection. “You’ll find someone new next week.”

“I won’t,” Dustin protested immediately, “I can’t forget about her. She’s not like anyone I’ve ever met before.”

“Hold up,” Steve interrupted then, “you’re not falling in love with this girl, are you?” He remembered this was about Max and knew that Dustin had a crush on the girl before she found Lucas. He also knew that Max and Lucas would end up together, so continuing to promote Dustin’s crush would only hurt him in the end. 

“No, no I’m not.”

“Okay, good,” Steve answered, hoping that was true. “Don’t.”

“I won’t.”

“I just don’t want you hurt, okay?” Steve added.

“I get it, I get it! You two are such pessimists.”

“Just telling it like it is, Shithead,” Billy returned, that cool suaveness back in place on his features. 

When the trio collapsed into silence, Steve knew what had to come next. He closed his eyes, taking a deep breath as he prepared to admit this in front of Billy. It was needed though, it was what had cemented his and Dustin’s friendship and he couldn’t risk losing that for anything. “Fabergé.”

“What?” Dustin predictably asked.

“It's Fabergé Organics,” Steve sighed. “Use the shampoo and conditioner, and when your hair’s damp...not wet, okay? When it’s damp...you do four puffs of the Farrah Fawcett spray.”

“Farrah Fawcett spray?” Dustin and Billy asked at the same time, both looking at Steve with wide eyes. Where Dustin was surprised, though, Billy looked downright amused. 

“Yeah, Farrah Fawcett. You tell anyone I just told you that and your ass is grass. You’re dead, Henderson, you understand?”

“Yep.”

Just as Billy opened his mouth no doubt meaning to say something incredibly irritating, Steve whipped around and poked Billy in the chest and said, “You too, Hargrove. You tell that to anyone and your ass is mine.”

It looked like Billy was trying to make his eyebrows disappear into his hairline, blue eyes wide and lips slightly parted. Steve smirked then, proud of himself for stunning him into silence. Steve kept walking then, grinning as Dustin kept up with him.

When Billy recovered, he shook himself off and jogged to catch up with Steve. Surprisingly, there was no harsh word on his tongue or aggressive shove. Instead, Billy nudged Steve’s arm with his elbow not unlike how Steve had done earlier, and asked, “So, Farrah Fawcett?”

Steve could feel the flush heat up his cheeks then, rolling his eyes and defending, “she’s hot, alright?”

“Eh,” Billy shrugged, winking and saying with a smirk, “not my type.”

And fuck, if Billy was already flirting with him then he was in for a long night. Steve groaned a little, trying to quicken the pace so Billy couldn’t see the pink spread across his cheeks. “Let’s just get this over with so we can get back to the junkyard, alright?”

Steve grinned at the sound of Billy’s laughter.


Considering the high potential for disaster, everything was going strangely well.

Even when Lucas and Max had strode up to the junkyard, when Billy and Max immediately shouted at each other for daring to be there, Steve had been able to split them up before anything got out of hand. Direct and divert attention away from the signs of tension , one of the few aspects of his father’s business training that still came in handy. 

They’d made it to sundown relatively easily, with the kids setting up the bus while Steve and Billy walked around setting the traps. 

“So what are we trapping, Harrington? You gotta give me somethin’,” Billy asked once they’d all piled into the bus to wait, Lucas and Max having disappeared to the top of the bus a while ago and Dustin scouting out for Dart.

Steve knew what was coming, he would never forget this night—he had a set of claw marks scarred deep across his shoulder blade from when the demodogs had cornered him the first time around. His heart rate began to pick up the second the sun dipped below the horizon, already preparing for the first fight of many that night. It was the second time in his life he ever thought he would die; when he had a fleeting thought of how he’d be remembered and shuddered at the answer because there hadn’t been enough time to do anything yet .

They could leave Billy in the dark. He didn’t need to know what he was fighting to be able to survive. Steve had proved that himself that night at the Byers's house when he’d picked up the nail bat and immediately swung at the nine-foot-tall thing chasing after his then-girlfriend simply because his body recognized the danger it posed to them. Robin had proved that too, when she’d run headfirst into the final fight against the Mind Flayer running on minimal explanations from him, both of them coming off of the worst drug trip he’d ever felt. But Steve had asked Billy to trust him and he had , with seemingly no good reason to, other than because Steve had requested it of him. There was no building friendship before this, no lingering stares and pressing touches, simply a rivalry over a crown neither of them really wanted or needed.

Steve sighed, nodding a little before beginning, “It’s crazy, you gotta know that.”

“This whole day’s been crazy.”

“Right, okay,” Steve said, a breath laugh on his lips. “Has anyone told you about Will Byers?”

“Sure, Zombie Boy,” Billy supplied, to which Dustin immediately called out, “We don’t call him that, you asshole,” and Steve groaned because he was really hoping they’d get along at least a little in this timeline.

“Yeah, well. Turns out when he went missing he went to this, uh, this other world? It’s under us and things are all flipped around in there so the little shits started calling it the Upside Down,” Steve explained quickly, not stopping for a breath so Billy wouldn’t have time to interrupt him. “There’s these monsters that come from there, they’re called, uh, they’re called demogorgons. Henderson found a little one that’s now not that little, so we have to trap it before it kills anyone.”

Billy didn’t react for a long moment, simply stared at Steve as if trying to determine if this was all some big elaborate prank or not. Then, he blinked, nodded, and said, “I’ve heard crazier.”

“You have?”

“Hell no,” Billy barked out, “that’s batshit. But it explains why you’ve been weird all day.”

“You believe me?” Steve pressed, raising an eyebrow. He hadn’t expected this to be so easy. He’s sure had he not had an actual run-in with a demogorgon first, he would have never believed anything Nancy or Jonathan told him. 

“Chasing monsters sounds a lot better than anything else I could do tonight, so sure. I believe you, Harrington,” Billy offered, simple as that. 

“Steve!” Dustin called out, seemingly in competition with himself to see how long he could pronounce the vowels in Steve’s name. “Dart’s not taking the bait. What do we do now?”

He knew what they did now. He knew because it was the same choice he made the first time, the only thing that could be done when he was the only near-adult in the group. There was Billy, of course, but this was new territory. Steve couldn’t risk losing Billy even sooner than before, lost to demodogs the way Joyce had mentioned the Radio Shack guy had gone out. 

No, this had to be him, and him alone.

“I got it,” Steve reassured him, picking himself up off the ground and readjusting his grip on the bat. “Stay on the bus.”

“What are you doing? Steve, where’re you going?” Dustin called out, “Those things are out there!”

“That’s kinda the point, Henderson,” Steve offered up, “they want live bait? They’ve got it.”

But then Billy was standing, grabbing the tire iron he’d kept stowed away in the Camaro for emergency use. “Hey, wait no, stay,” Steve protested, hand flying out to press against Billy’s chest to stop him.

“You want to have all the fun without me? C’mon, it’s rude not to share, pretty boy,” Billy answered, holding up his tire iron like proof of something.

No, no he couldn’t do this. He couldn’t send Billy out there with all those demodogs, surely that’s not what the universe meant to have happen when it sent him back to th—

—Except it hadn’t been the universe at all. It had been the Upside Down, the fissures that Vecna himself had created in their world, to send him here. What if all of this was an attempt to get in their heads more? What if this was Vecna’s next plan, to force them all to experience new horrors and Steve just happened to be the idiot to fall for it first?

What if Vecna sent him here to watch Billy die on a night Steve already still had nightmares about?

“Which one of us is the baseball varsity captain, Hargrove?” Steve tried to tease, hoping Billy somehow wouldn’t notice the way his voice wavered. “I need someone in here to protect the kids, or I won’t be in my right mind out there. Trust me, I can handle this.”

Trust me. Trust me even though he’d willingly crawled back through the Upside Down portal and risked everything. Trust me , even when he might have made Billy experience death twice with this one move, all because he couldn’t handle being alone. Trust me , even though the last time Billy trusted anyone it resulted in the Mind Flayer’s sharpened appendages spearing harshly through him. 

Billy stared at Steve like the world was on fire and this was their final chance at a goodbye. He stared like that last look he’d given Steve at Starcourt, a quick thing that had only been a second long. A haphazard glance over his shoulder before he’d charged the Mind Flayer, blue eyes shining as he shrugged, seemed to say, ‘what can you do?’, before sacrificing himself. He stared like he knew Steve cared about him in ways that he shouldn’t yet, and he stared like Billy might just feel the same, eventually.

“I’ll keep the Shitheads outta trouble,” Billy conceded, waving Steve off the bus like he was shooing him away.

Steve knew how this worked. Though other moments were fuzzy, this night was clear as day in his brain. His mind replayed it over and over again in his dreams, just one more near-death experience to play on a loop each night. He whistled as he did before, calling out for Dart to show up even knowing that it would attract more attention than he really wanted. And when Lucas screamed out the warning for the other demodogs sneaking up on him, Steve still swung the bat, rolling over the hood of a car to escape death, feeling those same claw marks dig in where he carried those scars once healed across his back.

“Steve!” Dustin screamed, opening the bus door to allow him the chance to barrel in.

But this wasn’t a dream, or a memory, because he distinctly remembered being able to make it to the bus. Steve didn’t remember being slightly too slow, out of practice after months of working at the Family Video rather than at basketball practice. He didn’t remember tumbling to the ground, face smacking harshly against it and sending blood pouring out of his nose. He didn’t remember turning onto his back and being met with the toothy maw of a demodog inches from his face, the slimy drool slipping and coating his shirt as the thing growled at him.

Steve reached his hand out for the bat but when he’d fallen, it had tumbled just out of reach. Fuck. Fuck this was bad, and there was no way out of it because he didn’t know how this new version was supposed to go . And now he would die, without having ever gotten close enough to the Party for them to remember him, without ever repairing and building a friendship with Nancy, without having even met Robin . 

But then the thing was tumbling off of him, flying off to the side with a pained whimper. Then there he was: Billy Hargrove standing over him, arms flexed as he held up the tire iron he’d just swung at the demodog, eyes alight with fire as he looked down at Steve. “You’re really takin’ the live bait thing to heart, aren’t ya?”

“Fuck off,” Steve gasped out, still grabbing Billy’s offered hand to allow the other man to pull him up. It was officially a worthy contender for the primetime spot in his nightmares, being so close to the jaw of a demodog that he could smell its moldy breath. 

Billy smacked him on the shoulder, the good one that hadn’t been clawed to shit by a demodog, and said, “Oh, I don’t think so, the party’s just gettin’ started.”

Steve laughed, shaking out his arms and picking up the bat so it would be a little less obvious that his entire body was shaking. “Hey, Hargrove, what’d you say w—”

“Steve! Billy! Look out!” Lucas and Max screamed from the top of the bus, just in time for Steve to swing his trust nail bat to the left of Billy where a demodog was trying to pounce at him from behind. 

“Shit,” Billy breathed out, looking at the spot the thing had been a moment ago. “Think that makes us even?”

“Are you really making jokes right now?” Steve yelled back as the two of them raised their makeshift weapons at the demodogs that were beginning to surround them. He ended up with his back pressing to Billy’s, both of them covering each others’ blind spots. The demodogs were ready to fight, pouncing and slashing, trying to snap a bite of one of them when their guard was down. Steve and Billy made a good team though, swinging their weapons and keeping the things held back long enough to survive, both panting from the exertion.

“What? Not into jokes, Harrington?” Billy laughed after he hit a demodog hard enough to send it sprawling to the ground and not get back up.

“Are you ever serious about anything?” Steve gasped out, trying not to think about the goop that covered the nail spikes of his bat. “We’re fighting—” Another swing, another crunch. “—fucking monsters from Hell and you’re talking about being even?” At least this, winning a fight against these things, made him feel powerful in a way hiding in the bus hadn’t.

The bus.

Steve looked over to the bus as one of the demodogs they’d knocked away seemed to remember it too. “Guys! Watch out!” he shouted, starting to sprint forward but knowing he wouldn’t get there in time. Billy seemed to realize it too, stood stock still as he watched the thing climb to the top of the bus where his sister was.

“Max!” he shouted out, sounding more distressed than Steve ever remembered him being. 

It wasn’t supposed to happen like this. Steve would rather he take every hit sent their way if it meant those kids were protected, if they never had to feel the fear of a demodog stalking them down and h—

Lucas fired off a rock from his slingshot straight into the head of the thing, stunning it enough for Max and him to drop down inside the bus and shut the hatch. The thing recovered quickly, letting out a scratchy noise that sent a chill down Steve’s spine and began to dig at the metal roof of the bus. But Lucas had saved Max’s life and given him and Billy enough time to make it to the bus, to climb to the top and fight the thing away from their ragtag group of kids.

And just like they had the first time, all of a sudden the demodogs stopped fighting. They grew calm, slinking away and taking off all in one direction away from the junkyard.

“Where the hell’re they going?” Billy asked from beside Steve.

Steve shrugged, knowing this had only been the first of many fights to come that night, swiping the back of his hand over his forehead to wipe away the sweat gathered there before saying, “they’re going home.”


Steve had to say, he wished they would’ve included Billy from the start. It was far easier to navigate the underground hub of vines when he wasn’t seeing double, and it was far more useful to have Billy’s punches thrown in defense of him rather than at his face.

They set fire to the vines in no time, leaving them with nothing to do but sit at the Byers’s house and wait for the sign that everything was well and truly over.

Well, until the Russians would decide to undo all of their hard work in a few short months. 

He let Billy shower first, instead choosing to stand over the kids to make sure they really called home to let their parents know where they were. He helped Max out even, making it clear that Billy had come by but that Mrs. Byers really appreciated having the kids over to support Will while he was in the hospital. That seemed to do the trick for the woman named Susan who’d picked up the phone, who asked him to wish Will well before she hung up. 

He let the kids all shower next, each one disappearing into Will’s bedroom the moment they were done. Soon enough it was just him and Billy in the living room, both of them picking up the papers that Will had drawn on and arranged around the room in silence.

What was there to say after saving the world? It wasn’t Steve’s first go at this, nor was he sure it would be his last, but Billy had never seen any of this shit before. He’d gone from just trust me, okay? to fighting back-to-back for his life in a few short hours, and sure he didn’t know how Billy would react but he knew how he’d reacted , after that night with Nancy and Jonathan against the demogorgon. 

“How often does this shit happen?” Billy was the first to break the silence, asking the question as the two dropped the last of the papers onto the kitchen table.

Steve shrugged then, considering it for only a moment before he answered, “Once a year? Hell of a Senior Year, right?”

“Yeah,” Billy scoffed, muttering what sounded like a “you could say that,” before he looked at Steve and pointed out, “You should clean that up.”

“Huh?” Steve asked, following Billy’s finger to look over his shoulder at the slowly bleeding gashes on the back of that shoulder. “Oh, it’s fine.” He hadn’t cleaned them up last time, his head had been swimming too heavily to do it himself. No one else had offered that night either, mostly because he’d excused himself and driven home the second Hopper and Joyce had come back, not wanting to be in anyone’s way while they cared over Will. He’d passed out and cleaned up the blood-printed sheets in the morning, making it through a half-day of school before Joyce Byers was dragging him to the hospital for a concussion evaluation.

“What the fuck? Get over here,” Billy demanded then, patting the back of one of the kitchen chairs before slipping out of the room. Though confused, Steve still sat backward in the chair, straddling it and crossing his arms over the top of the back of it. 

Billy returned several minutes later with a rather hefty first aid kit in hand, dropping it onto the table and picking out what supplies he’d need. “Shirt. Off,” Billy demanded again.

“This an excuse to see me shirtless?” Steve teased, forgetting for a moment that this wasn’t his Billy and jokes like that could be dangerous, if not spoken to the right person. Steve shook his head in what he meant to be an apology before slipping off his shirt and letting it drop over the back of the chair to the ground. He thinks he might have heard a ‘the fuck, Harrington?’ under Billy’s breath, but chose not to comment on it as Billy swiped an alcohol pad over the gashes.

In those few short months they had together, Steve had learned that Billy knew first aid well. Part of it was from his lifeguard job—having been trained in the basics even though the worst he’d ever seen was a scrape on the knee of some kid who was running around the community pool. Most of it, though, was from something far more sinister. Something Billy never outright said to him, but something Steve had been able to put together after one too many nights of Billy coming over with clean knuckles and a split lip.

“We could use more of this on the team, you know,” Steve offered when they’d lapsed into silence for a few moments.

“What’re you talking about now, pretty boy?”

“This,” Steve repeated, “the first aid. None of us know shit about anything.”

“Yeah, I can tell,” Billy bit back, rubbing his hand over the sticky pad on Steve’s shoulder blade before beginning to wrap gauze around his shoulder. “You were gonna leave this shit be? That’d be a worse idea than dating Wheeler.”

“Hey, if you’re gonna join the Party, you can’t be saying that stuff. You have to play nice,” Steve countered, turning his head and smirking playfully at Billy, who looked stunned, eyebrow raised as he began to focus on cleaning up the bandage scraps and bloody gauze he’d left behind.

“Who said anything about me joining the Party?”

“You’re still here, aren’t you?”

“Only ‘cause you’d probably get yourself killed if I left,” Billy countered, and Steve tried to ignore the way his eyes obviously flicked down to Steve’s lips as he stood close, with barely any space between them. And Hell, maybe they should’ve brought Billy into the loop simply for the fact that saving the world with him in one night made Steve feel what months of careful tiptoeing around each other had. Maybe this is how it should’ve gone all along, if Steve hadn’t been so concerned with a girl who never loved him back and Billy hadn’t been kept in the dark about the secrets Hawkins held.

“So you are staying then,” Steve grinned victoriously, patting Billy’s arm when the other guy didn’t protest. “You can take the couch, I’ll crash on Jonathan’s floor.” 

Steve crossed the house to the hallway leading to the bedrooms, stopping only once to toss over his shoulder, “Welcome to the team, Hargrove, thanks for saving my ass tonight.”

And as he laid down for sleep that night, despite the ache in his back he knew he’d feel from laying on the floor, he smiled because he knew he’d finally done it right. He didn’t know how this would change everything yet, but he did know the Upside Down didn’t send him back for no reason. Somehow, this would help him save Billy and Eddie. He just had to take the second chance.

Notes:

Trigger Warnings (SPOILERS AHEAD): In chapter one, it begins post-season 4 so Steve is mourning Eddie and Billy who have both died. They will come back. In chapter two, Steve dies but again, will be brought back. There will be a happy ending.

Series this work belongs to: