Actions

Work Header

High Tide

Summary:

The Harringrove H2O just add water AU that I'm sure everyone has been waiting for.

Chapter 1: No ordinary girl

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Billy Hargrove and Steve Harrington had basically hated each other on sight. Since Billy moved to Hawkins they had been locked in a battle of wills, circling each other, poking, each trying to prove himself better than the other. 'A ridiculous display of pointless machismo' is what Nancy called it, which Steve could never quite argue with. It's not like he even wants to be King of Hawkins High anymore, but to let Billy take the role just seemed a step too far.

On this particular evening, Billy was pushing at Steve by showing up to his house party, and Steve was pushing back by pretending he didn't exist. He kept an eye on him though, in case he tried anything, but so far Billy had just spent the evening doing keg stands and showing off his abs.

The party was winding down when Steve wandered out to the pool to find Billy smoking on a lounger and staring at the water with something like longing in his eyes.

"Cute garden party, Harrington." He calls, words dripping with disdain. "Bit light on the cucumber sandwiches though."

Steve rolls his eyes and does not dignify this with a response. Instead he kicks off his shoes and sits on the edge of the pool, dangling his feet in the water and sipping on his final beer for the night.

They sit in silence, drinking and smoking and ignoring each other, until Steve decides he's going swimming. He gets up and strips, which causes Billy some mild alarm before he realizes what's going on. Steve dives in, forming a graceful arc through the air despite the alcohol running through him.

"Shit form." Billy remarks as he surfaces, earning himself a glare.

"Think you can do better?" Steve demands and Billy growls but doesn't reply. "What's the matter Hargrove, can't swim?"

"I could outswim you in my sleep, asshole."

"Oh yeah? Prove it then."

Billy hesitates and Steve sneers at him. "What's the matter? Scared you'll ruin your perm?"

Steve splashes some water in his direction and suddenly the night takes a turn for the weird. Billy freezes as the droplets hit across his face and chest. Steve takes a step back, eyes fixed on the spectacle, as his form is obscured by swirling, shining, particles that spiral closer and closer around him. When the air clears, Billy's lower half is no longer clad in tight denim.

"What the fuck?" Steve mutters as he takes in the other boy's changed form. A tail. Billy Hargrove has a tail. It's a green-blue colour, reminiscent of the ocean, and where the low lights from the house hit it the scales sparkle with a shade remarkably similar to his eyes.

Billy seems frozen still and the boys stare at each other in surprise and horror for a moment.

"Shit." Billy is the first to break the silence.

"What the FUCK?" Steve repeats his earlier question.

"Shut up. Throw me your shirt."

Steve blinks at him. "You've never willingly worn a shirt in your fucking life. You grew a TAIL and now you want a SHIRT?"

Billy throws up his hands in exasperation. "I have to dry off to turn back moron."

Steve blinks in surprise but figures this makes as much sense as anything so he heaves himself out of the pool and pads over to his pile of clothes to toss over the shirt. Billy catches it and starts swiping at his chest angrily. Steve watches the other boy as he mops up every drop, and eventually the sparkles return, shortly followed by his legs.

"Want to explain what the hell that was?" Demands Steve as Billy gets up and lights another cigarette.

"Not really." The blonde turns and starts to saunter off while Steve gapes at him.

"Wait, you don't just get to leave after that!"
Steve moves to chase him but Billy whirls round and the look of rage and desperation in his eyes gives Steve pause. Billy just snarls and then takes off again, rounding the house and vanishing before Steve can decide what to do.

Notes:

Check out wrecked-fuse on Tumblr for the mermaid Billy art that inspired this. All of their Harringrove art is incredible.

Chapter 2: Two can keep a secret

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

When Billy heads to the parking lot after class on Monday he finds Steve leaning against the Camaro, a declaration of war that is being observed by half the student body. He plans to ignore him like he had been all day but Steve pushes off the hood when he gets close and blocks the drivers side door.

"Move, asshole."

"Nope. We're going to talk." Steve folds his arms stubbornly.

"Like hell we are." Billy tries to shoulder past but Steve stands firm, raising an eyebrow and planting his feet. Billy glances round at the many curious looks they're getting and sighs in frustration.

"Jesus. Fine. But not here."

Steve narrows his eyes but agrees to meet back at his place.

"If you don't show I'll be back here tomorrow afternoon." He warns as he takes a step away. Billy shoves past him and the Camaro screeches off into the afternoon sunshine.

He clearly spends a while driving around angrily because Steve beats him home and waits long enough that he begins to think Billy isn't coming. The roar of the Camaro approaching is a relief for the first time ever.

Billy is clearly wary and irritated, refusing to take a seat and just looming in the Harrington's kitchen. He's obviously not going to be the one to start this so Steve does.

"So you're, what? A mermaid?"

"You breathe a word of it, you die." Snarls Billy, immediately on the defensive.

Steve sighs. "Look, I just need to know if it's dangerous."

"Yeah? Who died and made you sheriff?" Billy snorts a bit but Steve fixes him with a serious look.

"There's some serious shit out there man. Monsters and stuff. If you're connected in any way, you're a threat. I need to know."

"Monsters." Billy raises a brow. "You're an idiot, Harrington."

"What, you're a mermaid but you don't believe in monsters?"

Billy is almost chuckling now, expression mocking, and it pisses Steve right off. He steps forward into Billy's space, voice firm and serious. "I'm not letting you walk around town if it puts everyone in danger."

The depth of his anger must show through, or maybe he's crossed over into crazed, because Billy actually answers properly.
"Jesus, no, alright? It's not dangerous to anyone - except me if anyone finds out and drags me off to experiment on me."

Steve sizes him up and Billy pushes even further forward, angling for some intimidation of his own. "You gonna sell me out Harrington?"

There's a tense moment as they stare each other down but eventually Steve shrugs and steps back casually. "Not if you don't hurt anyone."

"When the fuck you did become protector of the peace." Billy's quickly returning to his usual guarded, cool persona now that the stand off is over and he knocks shoulders with Steve as he moves to go. "Bye sheriff."

Steve still has a thousand questions about the mermaid thing and he's not quite sure if he should just let him leave. He doesn't want to pick a fight right now if he doesn't have to though. He resolves to keep an eye on Billy and to keep his bat nearby. Just in case.

Notes:

Your kudos and comments keep me buoyant, thank you ❤️

Chapter 3: A first dip

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It's a random Wednesday evening a few weeks later when Steve glances out to the patio and sees a shadowy figure standing by the far end of the pool. He startles badly, body moving of its own accord to duck behind a counter and mind sizing up the objects within reach for something he can use as a weapon. He's planning a run for his walkie when he risks another look. The figure is sitting now, hunched over almost sadly. It looks human.

Steve leans right up to the window and is able to make out the tanned skin and curly hair of Billy Hargrove. He watches while he lets his racing heart settle but Billy just sits there, unmoving, staring at the pool.

Panic mostly under control, Steve slides the door open and saunters out, calling out to Billy with false bravado. "That's called trespassing, you know."

He gets no response and when he moves closer he can see the other boy's distressed expression. "Dude. You good?"

Billy tilts his head vaguely towards Steve when he's a few feet away, but his eyes remain fixed on the water. Steve crouches down and softens his voice a bit. "You're freaking me out, Hargrove. Do I need to call someone?"

When Billy speaks it's barely a whisper. "I miss the ocean."

Steve sits with this for a moment, considering. "You can use the pool if you need. I know it's probably not the same, but..." This finally gets Billy to look at him properly, brow still furrowed. Steve finds himself rambling under his gaze. "It's private, neighbors can't see over the fence, my parents are barely ever home. If you need time in the water for whatever the fuck mermaid reason, you can use it."

Billy tilts his head. "Why?"

"Well you can hardly go to the public pool, can you? And the lake is risky too."

"No, idiot, why would you help me?"

Steve blinks as he realizes he should be asking himself the same question. In the end he just sort of shrugs a little helplessly and pushes past the answer. "Do you want to or not?"

Billy battles with himself internally. He wants to be in the water of course, sometimes it's all he can think about, but accepting help from Steve? It's practically unthinkable. The water wins out eventually though as it was always going to and he nods slowly.

"Yeah. I do. Um..." He's so close to saying thank you but loses his nerve at the last second. "Yeah."

Steve nods and gestures at the pool vaguely. "Help yourself. I'll grab you a towel."

He goes to return to the house but pauses, kind of curious to see the transformation again. Billy is in the middle of taking his shirt off but still notices him looking and manages a smirk. "See something you like, Harrington?"

Steve flushes. "Fuck off. It's the magic I'm interested in, not your overly waxed Ken doll chest."

Billy maintains challenging eye contact as he peels out of his jeans and saunters over to the pool's edge. His dive is needlessly showy and Steve rolls his eyes, but fixes his gaze on Billy's legs as he enters the water. The transformation is less dramatic this time, obscured by the rippling water as it is, but no less fascinating.

When Billy surfaces he does a dramatic hair flip that any supermodel would be proud of and grins up at Steve. The grin is barely even mocking. It may be the happiest Steve has ever seen him and he's not quite sure what to do about it. He settles on a half smile and then hurries back into the house for a towel.

He doesn't stick around to watch, no matter how curious he is to watch Billy swim. He just drops the towel within grabbing range by one side and gives a lazy salute as he heads back inside. Billy knocks surprisingly gently on the door to hand it back when he's ready to leave and while he still can't manage a thank you his smile is totally sincere.

Notes:

Lucky for Billy, Steve's good in a crisis. Even an emotional one.

Chapter 4: Call me maybe

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The first time Billy called the house Steve just about dropped the receiver in shock. It does make sense when he thinks about it ("I don't wanna trek all the damn way across town just to find out your parents are home" points out Billy) but it's just so weird to have his enemy call and ask to come over. Like a fucking playdate or something.

Steve isn't really sure how he's meant to act when he does arrive, but thankfully Billy just lets himself in the side gate, no greetings necessary. After what he gauges to be a safe length of time Steve heads to the kitchen to sneak a look, under the guise of grabbing a drink.

He watches Billy do an impressive number of laps without having to come up for air and it makes him insanely curious about how it all works. Does he grow gills? It hadn't looked like it that night, but then again Steve had mostly focused on the tail. Had he always been a mermaid? Were his parents this way too? He has to resign himself to not knowing. It's not like the two of them talk. In fact since Steve had made the offer they were interacting less than they ever had. Billy had kept up his general disdain for Steve at school and was still always ready to challenge him at basketball practice, but was no longer going out of his way to antagonize him in the halls. Other than the briefest of phone calls to check the coast is clear they don't talk when Billy comes over either. At least they don't until the day Billy forgets to bring a towel.

He doesn't realize it until he's already been for his swim. Pulling himself up onto the edge of the pool he looks around desperately but there's definitely no towel in sight and he left his clothes on a lounger too far away to reach. He curses himself out loud. He had left the house in a hurry after an encounter with Neil and left without grabbing anything. He'd called the Harrington's from a payphone across town - shocked to find he actually knew Steve Harrington's phone number by heart. 'Shit, what the hell happened to me' he wonders. It's about to get worse as he realizes he's going to have to do something Billy Hargrove never does. Ask for help.

Taking a deep breath (and a last desperate look around for options) Billy goes for it. "Harrington?" He calls out, much too quiet the first time and he grits his teeth before repeating it louder.

He's about to yell again when Steve pops his head out of an upstairs window. "Fucking, what?"

Billy looks up at him. "I need a towel." When Steve raises an eyebrow he sighs. "Please."

Steve closes the window and Billy worries he'll have to air dry until the kitchen slider opens and Steve emerges brandishing a striped towel. He hands it over and eyes the other boy as he starts to dry off. "You forget yours today?"

Billy sighs. "Left the house in a rush to get away from my old man."

"God I feel that." Steve nods sympathetically and Billy eyes him in surprise before scoffing lightly and trying to steer the conversation back to comforting animosity.

"What, you get bored of talking to daddy about all your money?"

"Hah. I don't think we've talked in years, he just shouts at me about how I'm a disappointment."

His voice has gone kind of faraway and sad and Billy isn't quite sure what the social norm is vis-à-vis comforting your mortal enemy, so he stays quiet and focuses on towelling off. The sight of the transformation seems to shake Steve out of it and he smiles hesitantly at Billy as he stands.

"You want a beer or something before you go?"

Another pause from Billy as he considers how weird it would be to hang out with Steve. Shit though, he really does want a beer, especially if he has to face Neil in a bit. So he nods and he throws his clothes back on and he follows Steve into the kitchen.

Steve grabs two bottles from the fridge and pops the tops off, handing one to Billy then gesturing him through to the living room. He flips the tv on to a football game and collapses into a plush chair. Billy takes a hesitant seat on the adjacent sofa and side eyes him as he takes a swig of his drink.

"You got a team?" Asks Steve casually as if this isn't the weirdest afternoon ever.

"49ers. You?"

"Go Bengals." Steve pauses then gestures to the screen with his bottle. "Though I got a soft spot for the Giants."

Billy hums something like an agreement and then doesn't speak again for the duration of the game. He just watches Steve out of the corner of his eye as he gets really into it, muttering encouragements and cheering or groaning as things play out. It's kind of endearing actually, a thought that Billy shoves away violently before it can take hold.

As the game finishes (with some whooping from Steve to celebrate the Giants' win) Billy stands and clears his throat. "I gotta go."

Steve stands too and shoves his hands into his pockets as he vaguely walks Billy to the door. "Cool. See you next time?"

Billy pauses as he steps outside and without looking around mumbles "thanks Harrington" before hurrying away as if being chased by the ghost of good manners. He doesn't look back at all as he gets into his car and speeds away. If he had he would have seen Steve smiling after him.

Notes:

Please don't come for me about football. I googled some teams. I'm not American. I'm sorry if it's nonsense 🏈

Chapter 5: Captain Harrington rides again

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The next time Billy comes over to swim Steve decides to take a risk and sit out on the patio to keep him company. Billy hides his surprise well and tries to just get on with it. He can't help but show off a little though, taking his laps a little faster than normal and turning a few backflips. The showy speed doesn't really have the intended effect on Steve who watches him swim and realises the pool is much too small for Billy to properly stretch his metaphorical legs.

When Billy takes a break to just float and soak up the sun with his eyes closed he decides to broach the subject.

"You're quick."

Billy grunts a vague acknowledgement, though he's secretly a bit pleased.

"Pool looks a little small. Like it's holding you back."

Billy cracks an eye open now to look at him. "It is what it is. Better'n nothing."

Steve considers this and has an idea. "You know..." He begins, hesitantly. "My dad has a boat."

Billy is taken aback a little at the reminder of how rich the Harrington's really are. "Fuckin' rich people" is all he can muster up in response, which Steve politely ignores.

"We could try going out on the lake. I could keep watch for you, you'd be able to dry off in private in the boat..." He's overthinking it as soon as the words leave his mouth. "Sorry, stupid idea."

Billy isn't listening to the apologetic rambling as he wrestles with himself internally. He wants to go so badly. A big open area where he can swim properly? Heaven. Even with a lookout though it's a risk, plus it involves relying on and trusting Harrington even more than the current set up, which is of course Billy's kryptonite.

"... Hargrove?"

"What?" Billy snaps back to the present where Steve has apparently been trying to get his attention.

"You good?"

"Yes. I want to do it. The lake." He thinks that Steve looks bizarrely pleased that he likes the idea.

They end up going on a Tuesday in the early evening. Steve has the night off from work and they figure they'll avoid most of the fair weather lake-goers by going around dinner time. The lake is mercifully empty-looking when Billy pulls up. He nearly turns back around when he sees Steve mucking around with the boat in a light blue polo and little matching boat shoes. It's just so twee and domestic, he's not sure he can bear it. He can't help the mocking greeting that slips out.

"You're kidding me with this outfit, right pretty boy?"

Steve looks up and takes in the jeans and boots Billy's gone for.

"Dude, boots? You're lucky you have magic water powers or you'd absolutely drown if there was an accident."

Billy snorts. "Oh now you're the coast guard as well as the sheriff?"

Despite the questionable start they manage to get along for long enough to get the boat out. Steve proves to be a decent captain and soon they're safely moored on the quietest side of the lake. Steve has worked up some kind of sinker-with-yellow-flag contraption to help mark the boat and he has another with a red flag that he can lower to warn Billy in case other people show up. Billy's kind of impressed. He promises to keep the swim short but Steve waves him off and shows him the cooler he's brought and the chunky tome of a book Dustin has insisted he needs to read.

"Take all the time you need, I'm good here." He insists.

Billy strips out of his impractical jeans and boots and takes a second to look around at the lake with excitement. He's avoided the area as much as possible since moving to Hawkins, figuring it wasn't going to help to look at what he can't have. Now it's beyond exciting, every inch glimmering with potential. He takes a deep breath. Then he dives in.

Steve tries to watch but as soon as the transformation is complete Billy basically vanishes in a flurry of bubbles. He smiles to himself as he settles in to wait.

Billy returns as the sun is getting low on the horizon, not sure how Steve would feel about boating in the dark. He hoists himself up onto the boarding platform and curses when he realises there's no easy way for him to make his way up to the bench seats. Before he can start trying to awkwardly scoot along the ground though Steve is swooping in and lifting him with surprising ease. Billy is flushed bright red when Steve deposits him on a seat. Not even this perceived emasculation can bring him down for long though, not when he's just spent the best part of two hours feeling free for the first time in a long time. It shows on his face, the usual tension around his eyes wiped clean.

Steve hands him both a towel and a beer then cracks open his own drink, which earns him some ribbing about maritime safety. It's good natured though and Steve is put at ease by Billy's relaxed face and easy laugh.

"So good swim then?" He asks. The answering smile is dazzling.

"It's incredible down there. Different to the ocean, but... so good." Billy leans back and flicks his tail idly to get the worst of the droplets off and Steve can't help but stare as the late sunlight glimmers off the scales. He almost reaches to touch it without thinking but stops himself just in time. Billy still catches him looking.

"Go on. Ask." Steve jumps slightly at being caught but Billy presses onward before he can stutter an answer. "I can see you want to. I probably owe you some answers at this point anyway."

He takes a sip of his drink while Steve tries to organize his many questions into an orderly queue.

"Were you um, born like this?"

"No. I stumbled into the wrong place at the wrong time and got caught in some kind of moon magic thing."

"How does it work?"

"You've seen it. Get wet, transform." Billy sighs a little. "There's other stuff that I'm figuring out as I go."

"Can you breathe underwater?"

Billy tilts his head to one side. "Weirdly, I'm not sure? It's hard to convince yourself to try. I can hold my breath for ages though."

Steve nods thoughtfully. "Makes sense I guess. Can you do anything else?"

"Anything else?" Billy huffs. "What, shape shifting not good enough for ya?"

He's about to apologize when Billy says "think fast" and suddenly he's spluttering as he's splashed in the face with cold lake water while Billy cackles.

"What the hell was that?"

Billy smirks and holds out his hand palm up to show Steve a floating glob of water. As Steve watches it moves in little circles across Billy's palm. This time he ducks when it suddenly shoots towards his face.

"Just a little trick." Billy shrugs nonchalantly but he can't hide the proud grin on his face. Steve grins back and they share something akin to a nice moment before deciding they had better get back to shore before it's fully dark out.

Notes:

Ah, Lover's Lake. What a convenient setting for me specifically to use.

What book do you think Steve is being forced to read? Drop your chunky tome recs in the comments.

Chapter 6: Imagine me and you

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It causes whispers at school when Billy Hargrove smiles at Steve Harrington in the hall. Is it some kind of trick? Has he knocked his head and lost his memory? Does he need glasses? The theories stay at whisper level though, everyone too afraid of Billy to say anything. Nancy does ask Steve about it but he just shrugs and claims he didn't notice a thing.

The occasional swim session becomes a weekly swim which becomes an almost daily event and soon Billy is at the Harrington house more often than Steve's parents are. It's kind of nice to have company he thinks, even if it is his magical former rival.

Steve has taken to hanging out on the patio as Billy swims, occasionally asking questions or requesting he do hydrokinesis tricks (a term he learned via a very roundabout conversation with a very confused Dustin). Billy huffs every time he asks but never actually tells him to piss off and Steve's noticed him trying to hide a smile whenever he claps or looks particularly impressed.

Across many visits Steve learns a lot about Billy. He learns that the 'moon spell' incident happened just before Billy's sixteenth birthday. He laughs when Billy describes his disastrous first shower after the change. He regrets asking if Billy's family know.
Billy had barked out a harsh laugh and looked away as he answered. "You kidding? My old man would be selling me to the highest bidder in two minutes flat if he knew."

Steve considers his questions more carefully after that.

It's a particularly nice Saturday when Billy flicks some chilly droplets his way and tells him to get in the water.

"What, why?"

"I'm bored. Get in. Race me." Billy raises an eyebrow in challenge when Steve hesitates. "What, co-captain of the swim team can't handle a couple laps?"

"I just think you may have an unfair advantage here." Steve rolls his eyes but he's pulling his shirt off anyway. They take their starting places at the edge and Steve tries, he really does, but Billy laps him easily. Steve sticks his tongue out at him when he surfaces at the end of the lap and Billy laughs, though not meanly.

They spend the afternoon setting challenges for each other and showing off. Steve does flashy flips off the diving board. Billy holds his breath for so long that Steve actually gets a bit concerned for his safety. They try to do handstands but Billy overbalances every time, pulled over by the weight of his tail.

When Steve laughs at his flailing tail Billy is surprised to find that his first reaction isn't defensive anger like it normally is when someone laughs at him. He actually kind of... likes it? Does he enjoy making Steve laugh? He tries to push the thought away, but it simmers in the back of his mind all afternoon.

It resurfaces when he tries to go to sleep, brain conjuring the image of Steve's head thrown back in mirth every time he closes his eyes. When he can't get it out of his head he gets up and goes to smoke on the porch. He does not have a restful night.

Notes:

Just short n sweet as Billy realizes

Chapter 7: Taking the plunge

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

"Could we.. go out on the lake again?"

Steve's surprised to hear Billy ask. Billy has never actually asked anything of him he realises, it's always been Steve offering. Being described as a 'we' with Billy Hargrove is also confronting in a way that he doesn't exactly hate.

A bottle cap bounces off his temple while he's mid-realisation. "Hello? Earth to Harrington?"

"Shit. Yes. Yes we can." Steve fumbles for the cap and throws it back at Billy to cover for his slip in attention.

"You sure? You can say no." A few months ago Steve would have been fooled by the facade but now he can tell Billy's nervous, trying to backtrack and brush off his own request like it doesn't matter to him.

"Yeah, for sure, I just need to check my schedule. I can't remember what days I'm on." Steve plays it off lightly, doing his very best to keep Billy from feeling like a burden. Besides, he had enjoyed the trip last time, he likes the peace out on the water.

-

Billy manages to hold back from commenting on Steve's outfit when he arrives this time, though it's as cutesy and coordinated as the last one, and they make it out on the water without incident.

Steve watches with a smile as Billy dives in. The difference between on-land Billy and in-water Billy is night and day and now that Steve is used to the tail he watches that transformation instead. If Billy could be like this all the time - relaxed, comfortable, genuine - maybe they could have been friends from the start.

"Come with me." Billy gestures to him impatiently when he surfaces.

Steve tries to wave him off. "Nah, I'll only slow you down."

"Get in. Or do I have to throw you in?" Billy's grinning but Steve gets the sense that he absolutely would do it if it came down to it so he gets ready to swim while Billy does impatient laps around the boat.

Practically as soon as he jumps in Billy is at his elbow, taking his arm firmly. "Tap me if you need to breathe."

Steve barely has time for a deep breath before Billy tugs him under the surface and takes off at a frankly insane speed. He can't even see where they're going, the bubbles surrounding them too thick to see through. Billy seems to know where they're going just fine though and Steve only has to tap out once before they reach their destination. It's practically the middle of the lake and Steve looks around with confusion, treading water steadily.

"Okay..? What are we doing out here?"

Billy just smiles and points down. When Steve ducks under the surface all he can see is dark shapes around the bottom of the lake.

"Nope, can't see shit dude."

"What are you, blind?"

With a roll of his eyes Billy grabs Steve's elbow again and pulls him down. As they get closer, one of the shapes resolves itself into the rusted body of a car. Billy steers them in a loop around it and then back up to the surface to let Steve gulp some air.

"Woah!" He says once they're up. "How the hell does a car get to the middle of the lake?"

"I can only assume some kind of mafia shit." Billy says this so entirely straight-faced that Steve can't tell if he's being fucked with.

"You think? In Hawkins?"

Billy nods solemnly but cracks a smile halfway through. "Dude, I have no idea. Come back down though, and stick your head in the window. There's tons of teeny fish living in it, it's like a fishy castle."

He pulls them down again and they lean in through the open windows where Steve is delighted to see the shimmer and shine of dozens of multicolored fish going about their business. More emerge out of various nooks and crannies as he watches. They avoid Steve and rush away if he moves but when Billy sticks his hand into the interior they gather round it, bumping against his fingers as if giving him tiny kisses. The gentleness of his movements and his quiet smile makes Steve's chest feel tight. He holds out as long as he possibly can before nudging Billy and indicating that he needs to surface.

"Okay, I need to stay up here a second and give my lungs a break." Steve expects Billy to dive back down without him and leave him sucking in air but he just nods and treads water alongside Steve. The thought of his little smile back there has Steve fumbling for conversation. "So, you found this last time?"

"Yeah. Thought it was kinda neat." The smile that Billy offers him now is almost shy and suddenly it hits Steve just how much it took for Billy to actually reach out like this to try and connect with someone.

"It is. Thanks for sharing it with me."

Steve tries to return the smile but Billy is looking away and down, where his gaze hits on the hand he still has holding onto Steve's arm. He seems surprised to see it there and Steve watches his brow furrow a little. Then, quicker than Steve can process, Billy tugs him a little closer and presses their lips together.

He pulls away just as quickly, eyes wide, appearing frozen on the edge of running for his life as they stare at each other for a moment.

"Well damn." Says Steve finally, making Billy wince. "You got a lot of secrets Billy Hargrove."

"Guess so." Mumbles Billy.

Steve shrugs. "Suppose I owe you a secret of my own at this point."

Then he leans in to kiss Billy again.

Billy laughs with relief (and more than a touch of mania) when they pull apart and presses their foreheads together. "Jesus Christ. I thought I was going to have to drown you or something."

"Alright drama queen." Steve teases, but he's laughing too.

They float in the moment together for a second until Steve is startled by Billy's tail thumping against his legs and he pulls away from the embrace.

"I don't know about you but I can't tread water forever. Let's head back." Billy looks a bit disappointed at this so he nudges him lightly. "You can drop me off and keep swimming if you want."

So that's what they do, Billy leaves Steve at the boat and waits for him to be safely aboard before waving and vanishing into the depths.

Steve cracks a beer, kind of glad to have this time on his own to process. He's never actually acted on his attraction to men before. Who would have thought the first time would be with Billy Hargrove? Then again, he wouldn't have expected it to be with a merperson either. 'Dang my life got real weird lately' he muses. It's good though, he decides. Billy challenges him and he's always been drawn to that in a potential partner. Plus, not that he's shallow or anything, Billy is super easy on the eyes.

By the time Billy returns Steve is feeling good about the situation (and maybe dreaming about visiting the ocean with Billy, but he won't admit to that bit just yet). He wonders how much of the lake Billy manages to see in the half hour he spends on his own out there. He hopes he's found more cool secrets to share.

This time when he returns and Steve picks him up to carry him to a seat to dry he pretends to swoon in Steve's arms.

"Oh my hero. So strong and manly."

Steve stops in place suddenly and fakes a turn back. "Wait, this was a mistake, I'm throwing you back in the lake."

Billy's cackling as Steve places him carefully on the bench seat until he's quieted by a towel thrown at his face. They dry off in companionable silence, each sneaking glances when they think the other isn't looking.

Once they're safely back on shore, Steve braves a question that's been in the back of his mind. "Would you really have drowned me?"

Billy tilts his head to the side as he considers. "If you reacted badly? Maybe. Being into dudes is almost as dangerous as being a freak of nature." Seeing the look on Steve's face he tries to lighten the mood a little. "I would've like, felt bad about it though. Depriving the world of your hair."

"Fuck you dude." Steve shoves him lightly and then again when Billy waggles his eyebrows suggestively.

"Maybe later, if you play your cards right."

-

While Billy smiling at Steve at school had caused whispers, the two arriving together and chatting about basketball like old friends was met with total, shocked, silence.

"Guess I just won him over." Steve shrugs when interrogated. "I'm very likable, Nance."

Nancy regards Steve with suspicion. She knows better than most how good Steve is at winning people over, but this? He maintains his 'just a dumb jock' face though, which frankly makes her more suspicious. It's a trick he pulled regularly when they were dating. She just knows he fakes that look when it suits him but she's never been able to prove it.

"Anyway." Steve glances up at the hallway clock. "I've gotta go. Billy and I are going to Benny's."

He slips past her smoothly and shoots her a grin before dashing down the hallway, laughing when he hears her shout "you've got to be kidding me?!" after him.

Notes:

Steve is such a hopeless romantic...

Anyway, thank you for reading and enjoying. The Harringrove community are honestly the sweetest.