Work Text:
Halloween was a special tradition for the Indiana idiots. It was a Halloween party that brought them together, it bonded them in a way, and every year they decided to treat the celebration just as seriously as Christmas or Easter.
With Halloween, it was all about style. After they would go trick or treating with the younger kids, they'd head down to Tina's where they would have a huge Halloween party, and the last thing you wanna do at a party is look like a fucking idiot. There were only a few times where the gang had gone out in group costumes and it was usually Steve who was put in charge of choosing, with Steve having an eye for style and all. This year, however, things would be a little different.
"Okay, is this some kind of joke?" Billy asks baffled by what he's hearing, "because if it is, I'm not laughing."
"Look in my defense, I didn't expect it to backfire so badly," Steve explained. At some point in the day, during his and Robin's shift at family video, Steve came up with the idea of placing a bet, and if Robin won she would get to choose ALL of their Halloween costumes. He lost. Now here they all were, arguing about it in the living room of Steve's house.
"I'm confused, what exactly did you bet on?" Chrissy asks.
"Tina asked if I could help get the word out on her party so we made a bet to see how many people we could invite?"
"How many people did Robin get?"
"One." Robin inputted, she was sitting on the windowsill playing with Heather's hair while she sat just below her, "she probably thought I was inviting her as a friend but y'know...still counts."
"So what, the great king Steve can't even get one person to go to a stupid party?!" Billy wasn't too shocked at this revelation but he would be lying if he said wasn't slightly embarrassed for him.
"he didn't even ask. He was doing that thing where you're kinda flirting because he thought it'd be more persuasive, but really it's just small talk, and not once did he mention Tina's party."
"I CAN'T HELP IT ALRIGHT! That "flirting" comes naturally but you gotta have a good connection with the person! Besides some of those people are probably considering it right now."
"Can't consider what you don't know."
Steve felt like he was on trial having to justify not bringing his A-game. "Anyway, what's wrong with Robin picking the costumes this year?"
"Because I know Robin she'll go out of her way to make us look like idiots. She'll take any chance she gets to embarrass us and you've just given her the perfect opportunity."
"Well, I'm okay with it. I mean Halloween is meant to be a night where you're allowed to look stupid, right." Chrissy chimes in.
"Not when you're going to party with people you see every day you'll hang that shit over your until you're on your deathbed!"
"I still can't believe Steve lost at flirting to a lesbian." Heather chuckled as she looked up to Robin who was smiling down at her and planted a kiss on her forehead. After a few seconds, Billy composed himself and noticed Jonathan, lying on the couch watching the TV completely, disassociated with the conversation happening before them, "well what about Jonathan? He's gonna have to watch the kids as well, are you gonna pick out his outfit?"
All eyes turned to Jonathan who finally looked up from the television, "Oh. Uhh...yeah that's fine." Billy thought his brain was going to melt faster than ice cream in Californian heat. Before he could get himself going again Eddie, who had quietly been observing the conversation like a silent witness, got up from his chair to make his final judgment.
"I agree with Jonathan. Halloween is a night where chaos reigns and rules can be broken. So what if Robin wants to dress us up like dumbasses? Parents dress their babies up like food, men dress up as their heroes in the hopes of reaching goals they'll never achieve and women think dressing up in cat Spandex is somehow sexy. If all that crap is considered normal, why shouldn't we go out the way we want?"
Everyone's eyes all darted to Billy. The young blonde man to in a long deep breath, "*sigh* Okay, let's do it."
Robin smiled at him with an expression that blurred between devious and sincere, "thanks Billy, trust me, you won't regret it."
*****
Billy couldn't believe what he was seeing. Just before the end of school, Robin handed out bags containing each other's costumes. Maybe Billy should've taken a look at it before he got home? But it was too late. it was hard to tell at first what it actually was, all Billy could see was a white long sleeve shirt, a golden tie, a pair of school shoes, and a straw hat with a yellow and pink ribbon around it. It was only when he discovered the rest of the content inside the bag did the true horror of the costume reveal itself.
The rest of the bag contained: a black school skirt, a strawberry blonde wig with two untied ribbons, and black tights. When Billy laid it all out on his bed the room started spinning. He felt nauseous. His breathing increased as he began to hyperventilate, Neil was still at work, but that didn't stop Billy's paranoia from consuming him. The things his father would do to him if he saw him in those tights let alone a whole schoolgirl outfit! Billy started fixating on the punishments he would receive if Neil found out he'd be wearing that.
So acting like a whore wasn't good enough for you, you had to start dressing like one too?!
How could Robin do this to him? How could she expect him to go out in public wearing that? And with his father on patrol tomorrow night?! He wasted no time in scrambling everything back into the bag before Max or Susan could see. He hoped back into his Camaro. He knew Robin would be hanging out with Steve that afternoon so he knew exactly where to go.
The second Billy pulls up into Steve's driveway, he promises to himself he wouldn't get out of his car until he calms down a little. He was pissed as all hell, sure, but he knew how bad he could get when was angry and he didn't want to release all that anger out on Robin. He got out of the Camaro and made his way to the door where he came face-to-face with Robin.
"you think this is funny?" He snarls, holding up the bag that was being tightly squeezed by his fist.
"so I take it you didn't like the outfit?" He barged past Robin and threw the bag to the ground with brutal force. Steve was sitting on the couch when Billy came storming in like he was about to wreck the damn place. He could see that look in Billy's eyes and knew something bad must've happened for him to get to that point.
"what the hell is wrong with you Billy?" Robin asked.
"what's wrong with me?" He reached into the bag and pulled out the skirt and wig, "what the hell is wrong with you? What the fuck is it supposed to be?!"
"it's Queen."
"Queen?"
"y'know...the band."
"Yeah, I know who Queen is, Rob. But because Queen did it that makes it okay then, huh? Goddammit Robin, what were you thinking? You know what my dad would do if he saw me in that shit!! Why would I--"
"okay y'know what," Steve manages to get in front of Billy, preventing him from doing anything he might regret in the future, "Billy, go upstairs to my room. You calm yourself down. NOW."
Billy was motionless glancing at Steve. He hated being talked down to...but he was right. He stormed off into Steve's bedroom, Steve turns round to check on Robin, she was looking down at the floor slightly ashamed and full of guilt. "I'm sorry. I didn't think he'd take it so badly." She mumbles.
"you got nothing to apologize for," he picked up the abandoned bag of clothes, "give him a minute to cool off, I'll go talk to him. "Steve had been with Billy for quite a while now. He knows how bad Billy can get it, especially when it came to his father, he should've known when he saw his own costume that this would be quite personal for Billy.
A couple of minutes later, Steve enters his bedroom where Billy is pacing up and down the room like a raging wolf in a tight cage. "Babe, will you calm down?"
"SHE KNOWS HOW THAT SHIT MAKES ME FEEL STEVE! AND SHE DID IT ANYWAYS!"
"OKAY!! But you know Robin would never do that to you intentionally. She thought you'd laugh at it or something, but even so, you shouldn't be yelling at her like that...or me."
"I know, I know I'm sorry," he fell back onto Steve's bed. The anger in his eyes died out quickly, "but Neil could've seen it, Steve, he could've walked in at any moment and seen all of it."
Steve joins his boyfriend on his bed, leaning in close to Billy, pressing his knees close to his chest as he caresses his left hand against Billy's broad shoulder. Steve understands why Billy is acting this way; for the last few years Billy had been coming to terms with his sexuality but it was kinda hard to do that with the wrathful eyes of Neil Hargrove watching his every move. Steve knows that deep down Billy didn't have that much of a problem with the outfit but for the last few weeks, the pressure of keeping his relationship with Steve a secret from Neil was finally getting to him. Steve move his arm to wrap around Billy's shoulder as the younger man fell into his embrace.
They sat there for a little while taking in the silence of their warm embrace before Steve pulled up the bag containing Billy's costume. He asked if he could have a look inside and Billy simply nodded yes. After scrambling through the bag Steve gets up from the bed and picks up his identical plastic bag and pulls out the contents of his outfit:
He pulls out a padded pink sleeveless turtleneck sweater, a leather mini skirt, black thigh-high socks, black high heels, pink nail polish, a 1950s bob wig, and a fake mustache.
Billy is speechless, but he's not sure if it's because Steve would be wearing...that
"you got Roger. I got Freddie. I can only imagine what Jonathan and Eddie will like." Billy gave a light chuckle to Steve's comment but it doesn't last.
"my dad's gonna be on patrol tomorrow. He has to keep an eye out on misbehaving teens."
"Where's he being stationed."
"Uptown. On the richer side of Hawkins where all the other hundreds of kids will be."
"Then we won't go uptown."
"But what about Tina's party?"
"we can think about that later, for now, let's just focus on trick or treating." Steve was right, the worst was yet to come, but if Billy could get through one night of walking around town in a schoolgirl outfit then it would be enough.
Robin appeared in the doorway. She is still a bit unsure if right now is a good time to speak to Billy. When Billy notices her, he suddenly feels a large wave of shame and regret wash over him. "Robin, I-I'm sorry I was being a dick before, you didn't deserve to be yelled at like that."
"Thanks. I'm sorry too, I shouldn't have sprung that on you, you don't have to wear it if it makes you feel uncomfortable."
"Actually I was thinking about wearing it when we go trick or treating and see how the night goes." Robin gave Billy a shy smirk. She knows this won't be easy for him, but at least he's putting in the effort to try.
*****
The evening came quicker than usual. Billy had been feeling tense all day-like that feeling you get when you're going up the hill of a large rollercoaster and you're just waiting for the impending drop-the only people who have seen Billy in his costume were Steve, Robin, and Max.
Max didn't taunt Billy as much as thought she would, considering he spent his entire life mocking her anytime she wore or did something "girly".
He made plans to get changed at the Byers where they'd all meet up. The others were already in costume. Billy couldn't take his eyes off of Steve, he never thought he'd see the day where he'd be turned on by his boyfriend in a leather skirt with a fake mustache, maybe he should grow a real one? Eddie arrived with the boys, he was dressed as Brian May sporting a pink floral nightgown and bunny slippers. He had about ten to fifteen rollers in his hair that he had to keep adjusting.
When they reached the Byers' house they were met with Jonathan dressed as Deacy: his face was slightly pale which brought out the red lipstick, he wore a grey wig and wore a matching black hat and coat complete with a faux fur shawl. He looked less like John Deacon and more like the Queen of England.
Max and her nerd friends had a lot of fun mocking the three of them. But Steve most of all, referred to him as that hot mom every senior has a boner for, but Steve took in stride and paid no mind.
Max's friends had decided their theme would be horror movie serial killers: Max was dressed as Bubba Sawyer from Texas chainsaw, Dustin was dressed as Chucky, Will was Freddie Kruger, Mike was Jack Torrance, Lucas was Jason Voorhees, and even El came dressed up as Carrie White.
Around 6 pm the girls showed up. Since the boy's costumes were limited to four, Robin had picked out outfits from the movie Heathers. Robin was Veronica, Heather was Heather Chandler, Nancy was Heather Duke, and Chrissy was Heather McNamara.
Billy hoped the kids had used up all their insults on the others. It was one thing to be mocked by teens his age another when it's kids younger than him, and ones he can't exactly beat if he's meant to look after them.
He'd modified his outfit slightly; he no longer had the hat, he'd used Max's hairbands instead of ribbons, combat boots instead of school shoes, he wore some black shorts underneath the skirt and replace the tights with knee-length white socks. He was in the bathroom with Heather as she was applying the make-up he had reluctantly asked for.
"you're gonna make all the girls soooo jealous." She comments with a slightly valley girl-like tone.
"piss off. I feel so stupid."
"welcome to womanhood, Billy, everyone feels stupid."
"even you?" He asks as Heather finished applying the last of the makeup.
"yeah, all the time, but then I tell myself that it's better to feel stupid than to feel nothing at all so I just...embrace it. AND WE'RE DONE!"
Billy held his breath as he turned towards the mirror, Heather did an impressive job. The makeup wasn't too heavy that it made him look like a hag but it wasn't so light that there was barely anything there. Hopefully, if he went to the party people would be drunk enough to think he was just a muscular girl. "Not bad Holloway." He smiles.
"I'll let the others know you're ready." Billy can feel the anticipation coursing through his veins. He takes a few small steps out to where he's greeted by astonished glances. Lucas and Mike trying to hold back their snickering with Max slapping against the biceps with a shut the fuck up! Look on her face. Jonathan, Dustin, and Will were are speeches-completely taken aback. Eddie had that shit-eating grin across his face, completely overjoyed at the sight before him. "If it isn't the prettiest girl at Hawkins high! Well...second prettiest"
"fuck off Eddie, you look like my aunt carol on a good day."
"oh you're just jealous because you could never be on my level."
"PLEASE! Between you and me, I make this look good!" Billy and Eddie were focused on their playful banter they didn't realize everyone was laughing at their bickering. Steve was enjoying it most out of everyone there, he was so glad to see Billy wasn't taking this seriously and just having fun with it. Maybe it was because they were in a more private location, but it was a good way to start the night off.
*****
They left the Byers' residence at around 7 pm. The kids complained about going not going uptown where all the "good candy" was but Steve didn't want Billy to feel paranoid the whole time and constantly looking over his shoulder to see if his dad was there.
Billy walks a few feet behind the gang, Max had offered to join him so he wasn't lonely but he didn't want to hold her back the whole time. Instead, Steve stays with Billy to keep him company (and also keep an eye an eye out on the kids).
When they approached the first house, Billy kept his distance so he wouldn't be seen. This carried on with the next couple of houses. Max would always run up to him, showing Billy all the candy she'd get and offering him his favorites so he wouldn't get hungry.
"I'm really proud of you." Steve complimented. "I how hard this was for you."
"to be honest, it's not as bad as I thought it would be. Just thought I'd embrace the stupidity." Steve smiles warmly at him as the two lock hands before Billy slid them into his jacket pocket.
As the evening carries on, Billy became more confident in his costume. With each house he got closer and closer to the group, allowing himself to be seen by the homeowners. He lent Steve his jacket as the night started to get colder and Steve replaced his high heels with converse.
By 9 pm they had reached the final house, "oh! Well, what have we here?" The homeowner says in an overly cheery tone.
"TRICK OR TREAT!"
"a bunch of serial killers, huh, and I see you have Queen joining you tonight. Love the costumes, boys." She handed out the last pieces of candy and the gang had completed their tour of the downtown area.
Nancy had taken Mike, El, Dustin, and Lucas home early while the others made a stop at Benny's burgers.
"Guys I need to get Will home before ten or else mom is gonna kill me," Jonathan says, "I gotta get going."
"That makes two of us." Eddie yawns stretching his arms over his head after falling asleep on the diner table, "I already spend seven hours of my life a day with the imbeciles at our school, I ain't planning on wasting more of it." He and Chrissy begin to get up from the booth.
"Hey Chrissy, you don't mind taking Max home, do you? I think I'm gonna go to Tina's party."
"Umm...yeah sure, c'mon Max."
"Later, Billy." Max mumbles tiredly. Billy watches the four of them leave the diner. He keeps an eye on them to make sure Max has crossed the street safely. He feels Steve lean against him, looking at him worriedly, "You sure you want to do this?"
"No. But I might as well rip the bandaid off."
*****
Tina was the first person to greet them-She was dressed as Cyndi Lauper-her attention was immediately drawn to Steve and Billy. "OMG, BILLY! LOOK AT YOU!"
"Uh, what about me?" Steve asked sarcastically.
"oh you two look fabulous! Well, don't just stand there come in!"
The four of them entered Tina's house. She had thrown many parties there over the years, and this was by far the most...lively. Robin observes the craziness before her, "wow T, you really outdid yourself this year."
"I KNOW RIGHT!!! YOU GUYS GO, HAVE FUN, I'LL SEE YOU AROUND YEAH?!!"
Steve had never seen Billy this nervous before, he promised to stay by his side the entire time if he needed to but Billy assured him it wouldn't be necessary. As Billy interacted with others at the party, he felt kind of relieved that they weren't taking him seriously, that may have been because they had the hots for him or they were just kissing his ass so they could get his recognition.
The jocks and basketball team, however, were the ones giving him a bit of a stink eye but Billy had stopped giving a shit about their opinion ages ago. With any luck, they'd end up blackout drunk and mistake him for some other hot chick.
To Billy's surprise, this was the first night in a long while that he actually felt free. As the party raged on he grew more comfortable in his outfit, he was having conversations with his peers, and not once did he think about the fact that he was wearing a literal schoolgirl get-up. Eventually, the jocks had managed to drink themselves into oblivion and started making comments on Billy that were more playful than hurtful.
Steve had taken a step back from Billy, not wanting to coddle him the entire night, he had never done it before why should he do it now? Billy's behavior had not altered because of the outfit; he was still as reckless as ever. Steve wandered towards the pool. He'd become less infatuated with these types of parties over the years-the only real enjoyment he got from them was when he was hanging out with his friends. But like usual, Robin and Heather would end up doing their own thing and Billy would sometimes get so drunk he couldn't form coherent sentences, so Steve found his own pleasure by sitting around the pool left with his own thoughts.
Maybe Billy was enjoying himself too much. He was unaware that Steve had gone to the poolside and with so many people coming in it was hard to distinguish him from the crowd. He searched throughout the whole house before reaching the kitchen. Suddenly the air around him begins to change, the smell of cheap cologne, sweat, and self-indulgence fills his nostrils. Tommy Hagan.
"Hellooo sexy" Billy balls his fist. He's dealt with Tommy before, he wasn't going to let that limp dick asshole get in the way of his fun. He slowly turns around to face him, Tommy is wearing the same cobra Kai karate costume he's worn three years in a row.
"I didn't know Hawkins was opening up a Catholic school." Billy remains silent. He can tell Tommy is drunk because he reeks of alcohol and a thousand other things. His friends had warned him of his temper, Billy would just have to take it like Steve would.
"I don't think pretty little thing like you should be a party like this. Who knows what could happen?"
Again. Billy remains silent.
"I heard Harrington was sporting something a little sexy too. Someone should really go talk to him, a piece of ass like that shouldn't go to waste."
Billy sees flashes of red but he can't let that break him. Tommy doesn't know about his and Steve's relationship but he's aware of their relationship, and how important it is to Billy. "I've had my eye on you all night, Hargrove, you think putting on makeup and skirt still makes you hot shit? That it makes you look good?" And with that one rhetorical question, Billy had found it, he had found Tommy's Achilles heel.
"well it must, clearly," he finally responds to Tommy's attempted insults, "if you've been staring at me all night. Look, I know Carol dumping you shattered your precious ego, but don't expect any sex tonight in that outfit. Hell, I could get more pussy in this outfit than you ever could. But hey don't feel too bad because since you've been so focused on me all night you've now got this image burned into your brain. So how about when you go home tonight you make good use of it?"
Before Tommy could even get a word in, he left the kitchen and made his way to the pool. Maybe he was just a little drunk or this is how he always gets at parties but Billy felt like he was on top of the world. He could honestly remove all of his clothes and skinny dip if he wanted to right now. But his attention was drawn to a lonely figure sitting by the poolside, his feet in the water and Billy's jacket wrapped around him.
"Mind if I join you?" Billy asked. Steve's neutral expression turned into a pleasant smile as he shifted to give Billy room. "Sorry I ditched you."
"I'll let this one slide. You deserve it." The two of them sat in one of those comfortable silent periods they had grown accustomed to. Where they didn't need to use words to fill an empty void that wasn't there.
Billy finally broke the silence after locking their arms together, "You think it's okay if I stayed over tonight? I can't exactly go home to my dad looking like this."
"Yeah, of course. So did embracing stupidity help?"
"It did actually," he understated, "but don't think you're getting off so easily, next year I'm picking the costume I'm going make you suffer, Harrington." Steve began to laugh causing Billy to follow in his infectious laughter. Despite the fears that had plagued Billy, this year's Halloween was quite the success.
