Chapter Text
The first time Steve Harrington saw Billy Hargrove was in the school parking 2 days before Halloween. He was a burst of scorching heat and blazing bright lights that made Steve want to turn his head away because he was getting a sunburn. He couldn’t though.
There was no way in hell he could turn his head away from those golden curls or pretty blue eyes. And what was worse, Billy Hargrove was in his history class. He sat all the way across the classroom from Steve, but that didn’t stop him.
His real name was William, but he told everyone to call him Billy. “No one calls me William other than my dad.” He said and Steve wanted to say, “wow, that’s so interesting.” But it’s not interesting, it’s actually the opposite of interesting. It was a boring, plain old fact about some dude’s name, but Steve couldn’t get enough of it. He wanted to learn everything about the new kid.
Steve first started thinking about boys in an ‘unnatural’ way when he entered his freshman year. It was some random kid. Steve didn’t even remember his name now, didn’t want to. But he was gorgeous. It made Steve question himself, but that was wrong. Steve knew who he was, who he wanted to be. So next year when he met Nancy Wheeler, he started that destiny of his.
Steve had a good relationship with Nancy, yeah they had a little rough patch during his junior year, but they were up and going again and everything seemed fine. And then a loud car engine erupted in Steve’s ear and his attention was pulled away from his girlfriend and to the new ‘bad boy’ of Hawkins. California tan with golden hair and eyes that looked like the ocean. Well, Steve had never seen the ocean, but he was sure they were the same color as Billy’s eyes. The air was taken from Steve’s lungs, but that was probably because it was cold. It was October anyway. Soon December would come and covering their entire town with a blanket of snow. He was just cold.
And now he was cold again. The wind was stinging his face and freezing the tears that were welling in his eyes. He was digging his nails into his arms and repeating in his mind to not cry because this was a stupid thing to cry over. King Steve Harrington was not one to cry over some stupid girl, especially if that girl was Nancy Wheeler.
Look, he was messed up about Barb’s death too - he was messed up about a lot of this shit that he had dragged himself into. It wasn’t his fault that he was dealing with it differently than Nancy, he would be more than happy to forget about everything that happened and continue on with his life, but no he wasn’t allowed to do that because it was selfish of him. Because he had ‘killed’ Barb - he hadn’t killed anyone! If anything, he had killed himself… his old self. Maybe that was a good thing, letting go of all his old friends, but it still stung like a motherfucker. Like this stupid Indiana wind.
Steve bet that Billy Hargrove never had to deal with shit like this. He bet that he never had to deal with the wind biting at his face, or girlfriends breaking up with him at a Halloween party, or petal faced monsters with rows and rows of teeth that plagued his nightmares. Steve bet that Billy never had to deal with any of that shit because his life was just so perfect because… he was perfect… He was really perfect.
That wasn’t what Steve’s mind should’ve been on, though. Steve should be focused on fixing whatever happened between him and Nancy, fixing himself so he wouldn’t be so fucked up, fixing himself so his dad wouldn’t be so disappointed in him, fixing himself so-
Steve’s senses became clogged with the smell of tobacco, and he got thrown into a coughing fit, waving away the smoke that now clouded his face. He took a few steps back to get out of the cloud of smoke. Steve wasn’t even thinking of who it could be. He had been all alone, leaning against the right wall of Tina’s house because the backyard was way too crowded. But now his solitude was being ruined by some jerk who also wanted to get away from the crowd.
“Hey asshole, do you-” Steve’s anger faltered when the smoke cleared from Steve’s eyes and he saw who was smoking right beside him. Billy fucking Hargrove. Oh, how great for Steve.
“Aw,” Billy pouted, the lit cigarette hanging between his two fingers, “has the King Steve cut off smoking just like he’s cut off his popularity.”
Steve scoffed, brushing him off and going back to lean against the prickly brick wall and sulking. Steve didn’t like that Billy’s assumption of him was right. Once Nancy and him had gotten back together, she mentioned how she never liked it when he smoked. He tried stopping since that day and now fought down the feeling to deeply inhale the smoke pouring from Billy.
The deep frown on Steve’s face didn’t stop Billy from trying to initiate a conversation with the older boy (by one year).
“I don’t see your little pet with you anymore.” He commented. “What’s her name? Nancy Whiner? Wheeler? Oh, right, Tommy told me it’s Nancy The Whore so-”
“Don’t fucking talk about her like that.” Steve snapped, giving Billy dangerous eyes, he didn’t seem intimidated at all.
Billy’s smile made him look like he was a shark, sharp and dangerous and never genuine. He took a drag of his cigarette, smoke pouring over both of the boys. “Whatever her name is, she isn’t by your side anymore? Kinda bitchy of her to break up with you on Halloween, don’t ‘cha think?” Billy was trying to get another reaction out of Steve - practically begging, but Steve wasn’t going to give it to him. So he tightened the grip he had on his arms and stared deeper into the forest surrounding Tina’s house. “It’s also kind of shitty of her to stumble out of this house with Jonathan Byers’ arms wrapped around her tight.”
Of course she fucking would. God- Steve was trying not to be mad at her right now. She was probably going through a lot, but god did he predict it. Nancy had said they were only friends, friends, only friends, always just ‘only friends’, but it was so obvious she had feelings for him. She was probably pushing Steve away so she wouldn’t feel as guilty when she ended up in Johnathan’s arms. Steve wanted to cry even more now, but if he did, Billy wouldn’t let him hear the end of it.
“I just can’t fathom the fact that she would ever leave a pretty boy like you.”
Steve’s heart stopped, he heard that right? Billy just called Steve pretty - called him pretty boy, somehow that was worse. The smug look on Billy’s face made Steve’s heart want to explode. He didn’t know how to take it. He didn’t know how to handle those blue eyes keeping on him. It almost felt like he was a prey to Billy’s predator, and it made Steve feel hot all over. Maybe he was getting frostbite and the freezing cold was feeling hot to him, but whatever it was, Steve wanted it to stop.
“You know, I know a lot more about you than you think?” Steve didn’t respond. “I know about your famous make out spots…. I wonder what else you did there?”
“What is your fucking damage?” He finally snapped, facing the asshole. The burning in Steve’s stomach was getting too much to bear, and he had to say something to settle it down, to turn it freezing cold again. But the way Billy was looking at him and the way the smoke was curling around him made Steve burn up again. He was definitely suffering from frostbite. “What do you get in harassing me like this? No one is around, no one is here to see you doing this- this pointless teasing!” Steve was getting too worked up about this, the way Billy was looking at him and Nancy storming off on him was way too much to deal with.
Billy shrugged. “Maybe you’re cute when you’re frustrated?”
Steve’s heart stopped again. He had to be having some auditory hallucinations. Steve’s eyes darted up and down Billy’s body and god was he jealous. There was another thought in Steve’s head, but he pushed that deep down within his subconscious and hoped it wouldn’t resurface. There was a shiny sheet of sweat covering Billy’s abs. Steve didn’t know how Billy was sweating in freezing weather like this.
It was like the boy standing in front of Steve was the physical embodiment of the sun, shining brightly with this scorching heat radiating off him. And while Steve couldn’t look away (part of him didn’t want to), he was starting to feel sick. An empty feeling in his stomach left him with the urge to vomit. It was probably the alcohol talking. Or maybe… Steve didn’t want to think about that, but it was slowly crawling out of his heart and into his nervous system. In Steve’s mind, the night was turning into day. The moon was being taken over by the sun. The moon’s life had been ruined by the sky and they ran away with the stars, leaving the sun to fill in its place.
Steve really wanted to vomit.
Billy raised an eyebrow. “Do you not get what I’m trying to tell you?” He whispered softly, like he was trying to be sweet to Steve. He didn’t buy it-
“I don’t…” Steve whispered. He probably looked pathetic right now. “Wh- What do you mean?”
Billy’s dangerously sharp smile appeared on his face again, and he took another drag. “I can simple it down for you.” He settled himself against the wall, but facing Harrington. Steve hadn’t stopped facing Billy. “Tommy Hagan, and I’m sure every other guy in there, only likes vanilla ice cream. They will only eat vanilla ice cream.” Steve had a suspicion he knew where this was going, and he really didn’t want it to go in that direction. “Nancy Wheeler, though, she likes… What’s your favorite ice cream flavor.”
“Raspberry.” Steve had no excuse for why he answered so fast.
Billy’s smile curled even further. “Interesting.” He said in response to him. “Nancy Wheeler likes raspberry ice cream, well- I thought she did. I guess she’s going for whatever flavor creepo Byers is.” What? “Besides that,” He leaned in closer to Steve, the smoke from his cigarette covering both of them. “Talking to you has made me realize I might like raspberry as well.” Billy’s two fingers tapped the underside of Steve’s chin. That area of his chin was now red with a sunburn.
“Do you get what I’m trying to tell you now?” His voice was low, secretive. This was a secret, a boiling and burning secret that Steve had to keep behind lock and key or his entire life could be ruined. He had been keeping it under lock and key for so long. That stupid closet door had been bolted shut, but Billy was using all his tools to unlock and loosen that door. He must’ve been trying to burn the door down because all Steve could feel right now was heat.
Billy’s hand was still on Steve’s chin, his thumb right below his lip. Steve was becoming all too aware of how close Billy’s face was to his. And Steve wasn’t sure who moved first, but in the blink of an eye, their lips were touching and Steve’s face was on fire. No, his body was on fire. It started with sparks flying from his lips, spikes of burning pain hitting his face like getting too close to a firecracker. His chin was next, still being held by Billy. Maybe so Steve wouldn’t run. Steve wouldn’t want to run, anyway. His skin was boiling under Billy’s touch, bubbling and falling off like some grotesque horror movie. It made him unbelievably sick. But he didn’t stop - Steve didn’t know if he could stop. His fingertips were then burned, tiny fires starting as soon as Steve’s hands grazed the sides of Billy. The black leather jacket might’ve been some ignitor because now Steve’s fingers were burning to the bone.
Steve couldn’t feel his face anymore, but, if he was honest, he didn’t care. There was such a satisfying pain in his body, like a sting that felt so good he wanted more. Steve was sick, deranged, messed up in the head, but he couldn’t stop his lips from working against Billy’s. And they weren’t working together, far from it. They were both seconds away from biting each other’s faces off to win - the prize they had no idea of.
Maybe Billy knew what the prize was, that’s why he was doing this, to get ahead of Steve. But why? Why was Billy doing this? Why was Billy making Steve’s head spin with insanity?
Wait… shit, where were they right now? The thought of Billy trying to one-up him and the heat radiating off his body had knocked Steve back into reality. He was outside Tina’s Halloween party - Tina’s Halloween party that practically everyone in his school had been invited to.
Billy’s free hand wrapped around Steve’s waist and suddenly the pain of Steve’s sunburn turned deadly. He was actually starting to hurt now.
He pushed Billy off of him, a small string of spit breaking off between them. The taste of alcohol and tobacco lingered on Steve’s tongue, nothing like what Nancy or any of his past hookups. Billy wasn’t a hookup though, he was no one. He was an asshole that Steve was supposed to hate.
Steve was reminded they he fucking hated the sun, hated summer, hated sweating, he hated all of it. He was meant to be with the moon. Someone cold and soft. Someone like Nancy Wheeler.
Steve was breathing fast, his heart beating so loud he could feel his ears pulsating. Billy was just staring at him, lips parted and a sheet of spit covering them. He had this fire in his eyes that made Steve feel utterly sick.
The sun was spikey and cruel. You could never get away from the sun’s horrendous glare. Yeah, the moon had some craters in it that made it difficult to traverse, but it was so much better than whatever the fuck the sun had going on.
He stumbled back away from Billy, swallowing as much spit as he could to wash away Billy’s taste, but it just wouldn’t go away.
And while Steve was storming to his car, biting back the feeling of tears in his eyes, Billy was leaning against Tina’s brick wall.
He swiped his finger against his tongue before taking a drag of his cigarette. “Raspberry.” He whispered, watching Steve storm away from him. Billy turned on his heels and went back to the party to get with whatever girl could get on her knees faster. Pushing down the icy feeling he had in his stomach. God, he hated night time.
Steve was walking to his car. He probably shouldn’t be driving, it was whatever. There was still a burning feeling on his fingertips and lips. The feeling of Billy wouldn’t go away and it was getting frustrating.
God, what would his dad think of what he did? What would his mom think? The woman who never cursed or put on excessive amounts of makeup. The woman who carried rosaries everywhere and always wore a cross somewhere on her body. The man who chain-smoked cigars and was the star of the basketball team in his high school days. Steve had chosen to swim and never heard the end of it from his dad. That’s why his dad forced him to at least try basketball this year. He hated it.
What would Mr. and Mrs. Harrington think of Steve’s disgusting actions? His sins against humanity? What would the primary donors of Hawkin’s church think of what Steve just did? The things he was thinking? God fucking- what would the owners of Hawkin’s leading realestate company think?
Steve was going to puke.
He slammed his car door shut and, in the solitude of his own car, he let the tears flow. They hurt and burned his face, but he didn’t want to stop them. They gave Steve the pleasurable pain that Billy had given him a minute ago.
The shame that flowed through his body was unmeasurable, the pleasure that washed through his body was the same. His steering wheel was pressing into his forehead, where he had set his head down. Maybe if he pressed hard enough, he could make the steering wheel go through his brain.
Why did he have to be so fucked up? Steve didn’t even think God was real, but if he was, why? Why would he do this to him? Steve had messed up, and he apologized to the people he hurt, so why was he getting punished?
Why, after all this time, were these disgusting thoughts coming back? And why was it only Billy?
Steve took a deep breath, collecting himself in his silent car. He turned on the ignition and his radio sprung to life, playing the song “Beautiful Boy (Darling Boy)” By John Lennon. He went home biting his lips, trying to bite off the skin that Billy had burnt.
Notes:
sup losers <3 I'm back again with more Harringrove. Also is ship taking me away from my main story that I'm writing? Ofc it is, who do you think I am man. I'm just trying to get all my ideas out before going back to mcd because I really like writing for Harringrove okay
Chapter 2: The Second Kiss.
Notes:
hi guys! We're back with a ch.2 and we have sm-sm-sm-smuuuuutttt so yeah... just be wary of that.
There is some ussage of the slur 'fag' here, but as a gay person I'm legally allowed to use it so akldfjlajsd;fj
This is also the chapter where we get some violence! Blood! Woo!!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
For the two days after Halloween, Steve had done a lot of thinking. And by a lot of thinking, that really meant a shit ton of crying, praying, and hating himself. It also meant one time while jacking off, Billy kissing him during Halloween flashed in his mind and he finished earlier than usual.
Steve didn’t really know why he was jacking off in the first place. He was getting really frustrated and his hand was absent-mindedly crawling under his jeans. What did he think was going to happen, anyway? Steve had been thinking about what Billy was doing to him, got frustrated with what was happening to himself. Did he think he was going to see pretty girls and not the guy that had gotten him so riled up in the first place?
For the past two days, Steve had been crossing his legs whenever Billy sat down in Human Geography, when he walked through the school’s parking lot, when he sat down with Tommy H. and Carol for lunch. Steve had to tell his pulsating body to calm down every time they were in the locker room, and Billy was letting the cold water spray over him after a particularly sweaty gym session. Steve had to act like he wasn’t using all his strength to stop his boner when Billy glared at him in the showers and called him ‘pretty boy’. While they were naked!
Now, Steve wouldn’t be that mad at God smiting him down every other time Steve got a boner when thinking about Billy, but that? No one could blame Steve for having to hunch down in his car and rub the palm of his hand against the seam of his jeans after Billy called him pretty boy in the showers while they were both naked. No one.
Steve had jacked off twice in the past two days, and both times he thought about Billy. And both times, he had knelt by the side of his bed and cried while asking God to not hate him for it. He didn’t know what was wrong with him, what type of weird disease Billy had gotten him, because now he was all Steve could think about.
His mom had interrupted him during one of his cry sessions with a knock on his door and a, “Honey, dinner’s ready.” His parents were home for 2 weeks from their constant ‘business’ trips. Steve was sure that they were just trying to find a place to move so they could leave Steve alone in this big ass house.
He quickly wiped his eyes and got off his knees, sniffing deep and opening his door with a smile. His mother seemed shocked by the suddenness of his actions. Steve was changing in ways he didn’t like.
“Mom.” He said, and she raised her eyebrows, waiting for him to speak. “Do you have a rosary I could borrow?”
His mother smiled, soft and sweet. There was no ounce of cruelty behind it, no past sins. Which was funny, because she’s a recovery addict. “Of course, darling.” She said, her voice smooth like melted candy. “What do you need it for?”
Steve couldn’t tell her, couldn’t tell his darling mother what was going on. If he told her what was going on, she’d grab the nearest cross on the wall and impale it through his heart. “I just want to carry one. It would make me feel better.”
She sighed beautifully. “Well, if you feel like that then,” she put her hand in her pocket and carefully picked something out of it. “Hold out your hand.” Steve did as told and Sherrie Harrington gently dropped the rosary in his cupped hands. It was beautiful, pearl beads with gold chains connecting them together and a gold disk with the Mother Mary on it that connected the necklace to a string of pearls with a golden crucified Jesus hanging on it. It was beautiful, but the disk of Mother Mary had a small crack in it, and when Steve looked back at his mother, he could see that crack.
A crack in her pureness, her kindness. A memory of Sherrie Harrington flashed in Steve’s head, a memory of her hands around his neck after little 5-year-old Steve Harrington couldn’t take care of his 6-month-old sister properly. An event that sadly led to his sister’s death. And the crack in his recovery addict of a mother made him hold the rosary tightly in his hand.
God hated him, so this was probably why he was forcing these kinds of thoughts into Steve’s head.
Everyone hated him. That’s why he couldn’t sleep that night and images of Billy were plaguing his mind. Fantasies of Billy’s face clouded his brain, and he couldn’t go to bed. His eyes were blurry with tears and his head was pounding like someone was taking an ax to a door.
He wondered if Billy liked The Shining.
Jesus Christ.
Even while his blinds were closed and it was 3 in the morning, Steve could feel the sun on him. The gentle grab of Steve’s waist as Billy pulled him in closer, like he wanted more of Steve. Part of him wondered what would happen if he didn’t push away, if he had continued deeper and deeper until he was inside Billy. Not like that… maybe like that.
More tears fell from his eyes as he tightened his thighs together, and he felt empty. The thought of Billy filling him up making him even more sad. Could the small chains on the cracking rosary his mother given him hold together as he hung from it?
In a second, the rosary in his hands turned into the keys of his BMW and he was outside his door. He stared at his car in the night; the moon shining so softly on the red paint. He started wondering what it would look like in the sun - what it would look like with the sun inside of it.
Steve pushed through the ice covering his legs and went to his car, parked in the driveway. Steve never parked in the garage in case he needed to sneak out like this. He ignited the engine, the adrenaline in his body ignoring the fact that his parents could wake up from the roar of his car.
“So, where do you live, Billy Hargrove?” Some girl had purred in Steve’s Human Geography class.
“Oh, I don’t live anywhere nice.”
“Why not?”
“I’m not as rich as the King over there.” He had tilted his head towards Steve, who wasn’t at all paying attention… totally not.
The girls around him giggled.
“My friend said that she saw your Camaro parked outside Cherry Lane.”
“Well, your friend is a stalker.”
And the girls laughed.
Steve’s car was now parked behind a blue Camaro with a California license plate, on Cherry Lane. 4819 Cherry Lane. Steve wouldn’t be able to forget that. The numbers were now burned into his brain, as well as the certain roads he took to get into this part of Hawkins. Cherry Lane was on the complete other side of where Steve lived, but he didn’t care.
The rosary his mother had gifted him wrapped around his hands, the beads rolling between his fingers. Everything felt too cold. Steve usually liked the cold, but now it just felt wrong. It was empty, nothing.
He looked back up at the house. It was 3:30 am. If anyone was up in that house, Steve felt bad for them. Steve felt bad for himself. At least it was Saturday tomorrow… today.
Steve had half the mind to start his car again and drive back to his house, try to force himself to fall asleep. But he didn’t want to pussy out on this. He continued to mess with the rosary, twisting and pulling it around his hand as he continued staring at the house. Steve didn’t know what room Billy was in, and he knew God hated him, but maybe he could just give Steve a direction on where to go? Where to find the man making him restless?
In the blink of an eye, he heard a soft crack and then beads with tiny little golden chains were flying all over his car. Steve looked down at his lap. The rosary had broken. He had been using it as a stress reliever, that he wasn’t realizing how much stress he was putting on it. The small golden crucifixion was on the floor, settled between his feet.
Steve looked back at the house. The front window on the rightmost side of the house caught his eye. God was giving him his sign.
Steve took one more deep breath before ducking out of his car, leaving the comfortable warmth and entering the crude winds of Indiana. He hated this goddamn town. He wondered what California was like. Was it as beautiful as Billy?
That was… Steve didn’t have an excuse for that. He dashed the Hargrove’s lawn, silently apologizing as he stepped into their flower bush, and gently knocked on the front window of their house. Once again, Steve was well aware that God hated him, but he still prayed that this was Billy’s room and not his parents’.
There was a beat of silence and he knocked again, barely flicking his wrist and using the knuckle of his pointer finger. His heart was beating in his ears and he thought his head was going to explode until the blinds of the window cracked open and Billy Hargrove was staring at him. Furrow eyebrows and a snarl on his lips. Steve wanted to run and hide like some scared animal, but no, he had a plan, while not incredibly foolproof, and he was going to finish that plan.
“What. The. Fuck.” Billy mouthed, staring daggers at Steve.
“I need to talk to you.” Steve mouthed back, kinda whispering under his breath even though he knew Billy wouldn’t hear him.
“What. The. Fuck.” He repeated. Steve didn’t know if he was just really angry or he couldn’t understand what Steve was mouthing to him.
“I need to talk to you.” Steve repeated, using added hand gestures to make his statement more concise and clear.
“About what?”
Steve didn’t mean to look so pathetic, but his heart took over when Billy asked him that and he couldn’t stop his brows from furrowing in worry and a frown appearing on his lips. Billy made an ‘o’ with his mouth, eyebrows still knit together and his eyes burning with a fire beneath them. And then the blinds shut and Steve took a couple steps back from the window, stepping out of the flower bush he had kinda ruined.
There was a heartbeat in his pants and he hoped it was just the adrenaline and not some weird sexual thing about the look of pure anger Billy had given to him. Steve’s hands were shoved into the pockets of his jacket and he rocked back and forth on his feet. There was a thought in his mind that Billy closing the blinds was him saying goodbye and he wasn’t actually-
The front door of the Hargrove household opened and Billy carefully walked out, silently closing the door. Steve couldn’t help the small smile on his face. Billy turned towards Steve, and Steve’s eyes widened in fear. Billy was definitely going to beat his ass. The thing is, he had on boots, sweatpants, a random Metallica shirt, and a brown denim jacket. He didn’t look like he was coming out just to beat Steve’s ass and call him a faggot… which he wasn’t…
Billy stormed over him and before Steve could react and get out of the way, he grabbed onto Steve’s shirt collar.
“If you ever do that again, I will fucking kill you.” He growled in Steve’s face and the heart beat started again.
“I’m sorry.” Steve breathlessly said. “I just needed to talk to you.”
Billy pushed the senior off of him. “Why could this just wait till it was a reasonably fucking time?”
Steve didn’t know how to answer. He doubted it was right to say that Billy had been keeping him up and not letting him sleep. “I couldn’t sleep.” He said simply, hoping that would be enough.
Billy stared at him before blowing hard out his nostrils and running a hand through his hair. He had a small gold earring in his right ear. He looked kind of pretty. Fucking hell, Steve was going insane. Billy Hargrove was definitely the type of guy to make people go insane. They could use him for government torture and get all the answers they needed in 10 seconds flat.
“Well, c’mon.” Billy said, annoyed as all hell, and pushed past Steve over to his BMW. Steve stood still for a second, trying to process that Billy was actually going with him before his feet moved quickly back to his car.
The two ducked in the car, and the air was thick. Steve could barely breathe.
“What’s with the pearls?” Billy asked, kicking some of the rosary beads around on the floor underneath his feet.
Steve started the car. “I killed the last girl that was in here. She had on pearls.”
Billy snorted. His smile was gorgeous.
Steve was insane.
It was 4 am when they got to the Sattler Quarry, a 20 minute drive with 10 minutes of silence pouring between them. They were sitting on the hood of Steve’s car, looking over the quarry. Billy was smoking a cigarette while Steve was wondering if he jumped off the quarry’s edge would the water kill him. He hoped it would.
Steve couldn’t believe he was doing this, that he was alone with Billy Hargrove at Sattler Quarry. One of 3 big makeout spots in Hawkins, the only makeout spot Steve didn’t make. He was trying to figure out the right words to say. It had been 10 minutes and every way of saying ‘I think I like you’ fizzled in his brain because it didn’t feel right.
Smoke flowed from Billy’s mouth. His chest was falling slowly, and he was watching the gray stream pour from his mouth. “I’m getting tired.” He spoke slowly. “Are you going to get on with whatever the fuck you have to say, or did you just take me all the way out here to kill me?”
Steve wanted to say yes to the latter part, but the words were caught in his throat. He couldn’t speak at all, not to Billy. It felt wrong, really fucking wrong. It was wrong, because Nancy had never made Steve feel like this. He loved Nancy, to the moon and back, but never in their relationship had she ever made him feel tongue tied like this. Steve was always quick on his feet, winking at the right girls, flirting at the right time, letting his teeth graze the right parts, but now… now he was a fumbling mess. Maybe he couldn’t think because he was tired. The sun wasn’t out.
His eyes darted over to Billy’s lit cigarette, an orange glow radiating from it. Steve’s eyes traveled to Billy’s lips. The sun was definitely here with Steve.
Billy lolled his head over to look at the senior. “Look-”
“Can you just-” Steve snapped his head back to look at the quarry. “I’m trying to figure out what to say.” Steve was trying to keep his calm, fist scrunching around the random khaki pants he had thrown on along with a random cropped shirt. Probably wasn’t the best idea of October weather, but his mind wasn’t all there.
From the corner of his eye, Steve saw Billy lick his teeth. “What’s so difficult about saying that you’re obsessed with me?”
Steve’s face turned a bright red, head snapped to face Billy. “What?” He said breathlessly.
Billy’s parted mouth curled in a smile. He looked kind of drunk. He took his cigarette holding hand and placed it ever so gently on Steve’s thigh. There were sparks flying from Steve’s skin.
“I’m not obsessed with you.” Steve continued, god that was such a lie. Ever since Halloween, all of Steve’s thoughts had trailed back to Billy. They were reading Jane Austen in English, was Billy also reading Jane Austen? What about Angie’s hair? It looked kind of weird today. Billy’s hair never looked weird. It was infuriating. Steve just wanted to live his life without having to think of this fucking asshole every ten seconds.
“Right.” Billy drawled out, not believing Steve for a second. “‘Cause you definitely don’t like me,” his hand crawled up, “and you don’t need me,” his fingertips were barely grazing the edge of Steve’s bulge which was cursed with his fucking heartbeat, “and I can tell from the raging boner in your pants you don’t want me.” His lips were so close to Steve’s, they were so soft and smooth, he had to use chapstick or some shit to get them so pretty. Steve could smell the tobacco smoke with whatever mint toothpaste Billy had used to brush his teeth before going to bed. And Billy’s eyes… holy shit. Steve had never seen such pretty eyes in his entire life, full lashes that Billy’s ocean blue eyes were staring at him through. Billy could stop his heart with one bat of his eyelashes, and he was.
It was taking everything in Steve to not close the inch small gap between them, lean into his sinful desires, say ‘fuck you’ to every good principle he had ever known and pull Billy closer to him, the problem was Billy Hargrove was a fucking asshole. And it wasn’t just because he was taking Steve’s ‘crown’ or whatever, he was a total jerk. Teasing him ever since Halloween, it was driving him insane. And now he was acting like he knew all about Steve? Getting all in his business and making him feel all weird and question himself? He was a total asshole.
An asshole who looked really pretty up close. Steve was too angry to appreciate that now, too busy getting mad at Billy for acting like a fucking know it all.
“What the fuck is your problem!?” Steve snapped, pushing Billy a little too hard and sliding himself off the hood of the car. He almost smacked his face against the metal, but he slammed the car down with his hands to stop himself. Pieces of sharp gravel dug into his knees, his pants doing no good to stop the pain.
“What’s my problem?” Billy laughed like this was all a joke to him, probably was and that’s what made all of this more frustrating. Steve got up to his feet as Billy circled around the front of the car to get back into Steve’s space. “What’s yours?”
“You!” Steve screamed, echoing through the quarry. “You’re fucking driving me insane, dude!”
“Then why are you so obsessed with me?”
“I’m not!” Steve was not only trying to convince Billy, but himself. “You’re obsessed with me, if anything!”
“Yeah, and?” Billy asked. Steve frowned slightly. His argument didn’t work as well as he had hoped. “You’re hot as shit, dude. How can I not?” Steve’s frown deepened. “What? You’ve never had a guy like you before?” Billy tilted his head. “Or maybe you’ve never liked someone as much as you’ve liked me.”
“I fucking hate you.” Steve said as a rebuttal. Steve wished that was the entire truth, but the hot feeling in his abdomen was something far from hate.
“Oh, I bet you do. I bet you fucked hated jacking off to me.”
“Fuck off!”
“Why’d you want to talk in the first place if you were just going to tell me you didn’t like boys?”
“Stop!”
“Just come clean with yourself and admit that you want me to fuck you.”
“Holy shit, dude!” Steve screamed, and Billy shut up. He didn’t shut up because he was scared, but because he was intrigued by what Steve could possibly say next. And Steve didn’t want to say this, it just kind of poured out of him like Billy had been messing with the handle of a hose and the water had finally started running. “I’m not a fucking fag like you!”
And everything went silent. Steve’s heart was shaking, and he really wished he hadn’t said that. All his frustration towards Billy turned into words he seriously regretted and now no apology could take them back.
Billy’s face had fallen, his eyes had gone wide, and his brows were knitted together in obvious anger. Steve dug his nails into his palm, balling his hands up in tight fists. Billy’s lip twitched, and that was the last thing Steve was able to fully process before the Junior took a step forward and slammed his fist in Steve’s cheek bone. There was a sharp jolt that spread all over Steve’s fast as Billy’s knuckles contacted with, what felt like, his bones.
Steve got flung back, but he didn’t fall. He was able to stay on his feet while his legs tripped over themselves. He put his hands on his knees and let himself breathe for a moment. His eyes were watering and his face felt like it was cracking from where Billy had punched it. Steve had been in a couple of fights before, fights that left him worse for wear and bleeding all over. Steve was no virgin to getting punched, he was just a little shocked. Billy had hit him, punched him real fucking bad. He was expecting some yelling, and Billy looked like the kind of guy who got into fights a lot, but Steve wasn’t expecting Billy to punch him. Especially not with what was going on.
There was a part of Steve that told himself he deserved it, just like when he called Johnathan a queer, Steve had crossed a line. But then there was the douchebag side of himself that made him turn around and look at Billy, who was still holding his hands in tight fists, ready to throw another punch.
Steve blew air out of his nose like he was smoking before running and tackling Billy. In an effort to get Steve off of him, Billy pushed him to the side, but that just made both of them run into the BMW and ricochet off onto the floor.
He planted a punched square on Billy’s nose. He heard a crack beneath his fist and the shock of the sound gave Billy enough time to fist his hands into Steve’s collar and headbutt him, pushing him off to his right.
They were breathless and bloody, blood trailing down from Billy’s nose and Steve’s mouth. The gravel was poking at the skin that was exposed from their jackets and pants. Steve sat up and turned over, sitting on his knees as he curled into himself. Like a sitting fetal position. He let the mixture of spit and blood pool from his mouth while Billy held the bridge of his nose together. There was definitely a fracture there or some shit.
“You can punch.” Billy said breathlessly.
“Yeah.” Steve answered, spitting out some of the blood. His mouth and teeth stung with pain. He fucking hated himself right now. He wanted to rip all his hair out and drown in his own blood. “You can punch, too.”
Billy, on the other hand, was very impressed with not only himself, but Steve as well. He touched the blood trailing down the sides of his face. He was bleeding a shit ton just from one punch. Billy propped himself up on his elbow, leaning towards Steve. “Thanks.” He finally said.
Steve uncurled himself and looked out at the horizon. Everything was still pretty dark. The moon was still up in the sky and only the very bottom of the horizon was turning a soft orange color. His eyes were watering and everything was blurry beneath the filter of tears.
“How do you do it?” He asked quietly, turning his head to look at Billy. He looked really pretty in the dark purple-orange lighting. Steve wondered what Billy looked like back in California, where the sky always looked gorgeous (according to magazines and some friends who had visited the golden state.) Steve hated the heat, but right now, he’d be willing to sacrifice everything to see Billy in his home state, where everything was beautiful.
Billy raised an eyebrow. There was blood still trailing from his nose and now down the right side of his face where he was leaning. It was dripping softly on the gray rocks, and Steve wanted to cry harder. “Do what?”
“Be you.” His voice broke when he said it. He hated himself, hated the way he was feeling. He hated the fact that Billy was making him feel something so much… brighter than any one girl had. “Not hate yourself for liking me. Not be scared about liking me.”
“Oh, don’t worry pretty boy, I am.” He gave a pathetic smile. There was some blood on his teeth, nowhere near the amount of blood on Steve’s. “I’m fucking terrified.” Steve wanted to laugh at that, a loud, boisterous laugh that would echo off the quarry, but he couldn’t find the energy to do so. “I’m fucking terrified that I’m a disappointing fag, but honestly, I am who I am and I’m not gonna stop being who I am because some half-wit asshole tells me to.”
Steve knew he was crying now. There was no change in the way he sat, no change in his face, but there were tears no rolling down his cheeks and off his chin. They were landing in the small puddle of his and Billy’s blood.
Billy moved his body so he could sit on his ass. “But I know when I don’t have to be scared.” He gently held Steve’s bloody chin. “Like right now. There is nothing and no one to be scared of right now.”
Steve could’ve said no - finally come to his senses and pushed Billy away. He could’ve apologized for bringing Billy all the way out here with no plans to satisfy him, but that’s not what happened. Billy brought his face close to Steve’s lips, parted in a way to tell him ‘finish it’. And Steve opened his mouth, let his jaw hang slightly open because he wasn’t all that sure about what he was doing. Would kissing a guy be different from kissing a girl? They were lips. Why would it be any different?
The two leaned in and Steve had never felt so warm in his entire life. He wasn’t sweating; he was freezing, he just felt warm. Warm and soft, like a blanket. It was stupid to compare something so fundamental to Steve’s life to a blanket, but he couldn’t think properly. His mind was melting and so was his body as Billy’s lips met his over and over again - they were making out. Steve had done this so many times before, so many countless girls. Why did everything feel so different now?
And it didn’t feel perfect. There was a coppery taste in his mouth, mixed with tobacco and the lingering hints of mint. His face was hurting, and he knew Billy’s was too, but Steve couldn’t bring himself to pull away.
But Billy could. He pulled away, placing a hand so gently on Steve’s chest - their eyes met. Billy didn’t have to say anything. Steve knew the question he was asking. ‘Do you still want this?’ he was asking with his ocean blue eyes. Steve swore he saw waves.
A hot breath tickled Steve’s face and before the pause between them could go any longer, Steve brought his lips to Billy’s in a moment of sporadic confidence. He kissed Billy like he wanted to bite him, and if Billy could speak right now, he’d probably want to be bitten. Steve didn’t know what Billy liked with romance, but he seemed like the guy to like it rough in all aspects of the game. So Steve went rougher. He moved his body with the kiss, arched his back like some horny girl, moved all his weight to his legs so he could grab Billy’s face and make the kiss even deeper. Steve was expecting Billy to press against him, tell him he was going too hard, but he didn’t. Billy grabbed onto Steve’s waist while the other found its way in Steve’s not-so-perfect hair.
Billy must’ve known how much Steve wanted him, how he was lying back then on the hood of the car, because when Steve’s thighs opened and he straddled Billy, the only noise he made was a moan of approval. It drove Steve insane. He had never heard a man moan before. When he moaned, or groaned, or grunted, or whatever noise he made during sex, he wasn’t paying attention to it. He was paying attention to the whining, the whimpers, the cries the girls were making during sex. So when Billy made a noise in his throat the same time Steve straddled him, he completely knocked him back to reality, where Steve remembered he had never had sex with a guy before.
And Steve still hated Billy, so he absolutely hated the way the man could read him so well. Billy knew Steve had never been with a guy before - could probably tell too. His hands were settled on where Steve’s hips met his thighs and he pulled away. Steve hadn’t been paying much attention to the kiss, focusing on the warmth and softness, but now that Billy was pulling away, he had never wanted a kiss to go on longer in his life.
This time, Billy spoke out loud. “Do you want this?” He whispered against Steve’s face, the two breathless and incredibly horny in their loose-fitting pants.
Steve didn’t answer, not verbally, at least. He took the anxiety that was deep within his heart and used it as confidence to slowly grind against Billy’s groin.
Billy smiled, dangerously, viciously. And they were back to kissing. His hand placed itself so tenderly on Steve’s face while the other pressed down on the area between Steve’s hip and thigh, encouraging him to continue. And to continue, Steve did.
There was a fire burning in his abdomen as he continued grinding down on Billy, their clothes becoming thinner and Steve’s mind and he didn’t have to think hard about what Billy looked like naked. Frightened eyes had brought him to Billy’s entire body one too many times in the shower. It wasn’t normal, but he couldn’t help himself. Steve had to brace himself, grabbing onto Billy’s shoulders as he grinded and kissed against Billy - never with.
If he kept going, he was going to cum right there in his khaki pants and hope that Billy came too, but Billy stopped him before any of that happened. Held his body tightly and pulled away again, looking up at him through his thick lashes.
“Do you want to do this?” He whispered, a mirror of his earlier question. And Steve knew what this question meant, the real implications. There was no grinding or clothes with this question. There was only lust and passion underneath this question, and Steve wanted it all.
In all honesty, Steve wanted Billy to punch him, to punch him, kick the shit out of him. Because whatever they had going on now was not real, and Steve wanted to get back to real life. His rope tether into the unknown had snapped, and he was stuck in this weird fantasy land he had landed in.
But he still nodded.
“Words, princess.”
He was definitely in a fantasy land, a sick, twisted dream where he knew he was sleeping, but couldn’t wake up.
“I want this.” He whispered against Billy’s skin. “Please.” He didn’t care if this was pathetic. He wanted Billy under his skin like some kind of parasite. He wanted Billy to give him such a sunburn that he’d be writhing in the pain afterwards. He probably was.
Billy’s hands traveled down Steve’s body, his eyes keeping on his. His hands, they felt worn out and used, calloused on his palms where his hands ever so gently traversed Steve’s burning skin. He kept his eyes locked on Steve’s, a predator keeping eyes on his prey, as he unbuttoned and unzipped Steve’s khaki pants. There was no belt to fumble with since Steve hadn’t thought to put on a belt, he wasn’t thinking a lot tonight.
The cold air hit Steve, and he let out a soft hiss. His eyes darted away from Billy’s and he could’ve gasped at the sight. Billy’s hands looked so… out of place. One hand was wrapped around him while the other was on his thigh, trailing up and down, soft and gently - calming Steve down. His hand was so rough and had obviously been through a lot and Steve looked so soft… well, not soft, but he shaved himself. He was neat, not insanely veiny or anything like that. Billy’s hands just looked strange wrapped around him.
His thumb swiped itself over Steve and he let out a soft gasp, grip tightening on Billy’s shoulder.
“God, you virgin.” Billy teased. Steve wasn’t a virgin, far from it, actually. Losing his virginity in sophomore year, his body count had increased ever since. Everything just felt so new to him, every kiss, every look, every swipe of thumb. It felt all new to Steve, all because a boy was doing it.
He pushed himself up with one hand and brought his sweats and boxers down just so his dick could pop out and take all the air out of Steve’s lungs. God, it looked a lot better erect and closer than when Steve had seen it in the shower. They were quick glances and blurry with water, but he was still impressed, embarrassingly so. Steve understood why his King title had been swept under his feet so quickly, it was obvious that an inch made a big difference when it came to girls… and now guys.
Steve was being lifted up slightly by his thighs. Billy was looking down while Steve was pressing his head against Billy’s shoulder. He didn’t want to look; he didn’t want to visualize any of it. It scared him too much.
Then, there was this burst of color, this flash of bright light, this explosion of color that made Steve open his mouth in pain while no sound came out. It made Steve fist Billy’s shirt, graze his teeth onto his shoulder before biting down. The smell of Billy’s cologne and laundry detergent smell brought him out of the slow stinging for only a second.
Steve wondered if this is what California felt like. A hot, scorching sun burns the outermost layer of skin while the salty ocean tries to fix its friend’s damages. Maybe that’s why being with Billy felt so much more… complete than Steve ever felt being with Nancy. Steve could say this with confidence, Nancy was like the moon. And Steve used to love the moon, the night sky, the twinkling stars. That was a big reason why he loved her so much. She reminded him so much of the moon. Her eyes twinkled with curiosity, her skin was cold like the night and on the paler side, like the moon.
Once again, Steve could say this with confidence, Billy Hargrove was the sun. He was bright and shining and took up everyone’s attention. He was a fucking pain in Steve’s ass (literally now) and drove him insane. Made him sweat like crazy and gave him headaches. But the sun was also really pretty at times. It gave way to some of the prettiest things on planet earth. It made earth what it was. Trees and animals wouldn’t be without the sun, people wouldn’t be without the sun. Steve was now figuring out that he couldn’t be without the sun. It was hard to process, a little terrifying, but now that he was actually in the middle of fucking the sun, he knew he couldn’t go on without it.
There is a cooling sensation on his body. He’s not really sure if it’s the sweat drying on his body or he just came. Then, a pause, long and silent. Steve moves himself off of Billy’s shoulder and looks down at him. His mouth is open, he’s breathing - panting, almost like an animal. It made Steve want him more.
Billy notices the tears in Steve’s eyes, and he uses his thumbs to wipe them away. Steve feels pathetic, but Billy washes all that away in seconds.
“It feels weird, right?”
Steve grimaces. He wants to move to maybe make himself feel more comfortable, but he’s scared. “Like… a good-weird?” he’s unsure of his own answer. Because this does feel good, but it’s foreign to him and he’s not sure if the good feeling he has is actually ‘good’ or not.
Billy breathes out a smile, not sharp or dangerous, but something Steve would jump around in his bedroom later for being ‘super cute’. “You okay? You think I can move?”
Steve eases his hips in a slow rolling motion, and then he cuts short. He can’t. “If you move, I’ll cum.”
“That’d be even better?”
“Really?” Steve’s kind of shocked. “You think if I cum before we’ve even begun, that’ll be hot?”
“Are you kidding me?” Billy asks, handing rubbing into Steve’s hips in a gesture that feels almost domestic. But they can’t be domestic. They’re two teenage boys fucking on a cliff towards Sattler’s Quarry. “If just this can make you blow a load, that’ll be the hottest thing ever. It’ll also be a major ego boost.”
Steve smiles at this, smiles at the fact he could lift Billy’s already massive ego in something so humiliating. It was never cool to finish fast, in any setting.
“So you think I can move?” Billy asks again. Steve takes his courage, makes sure his hands are on Billy’s shoulders, and nods. Billy tightens his grip on Steve’s hips and slowly brings him up before bringing him back down just as slow.
They go through this motion a couple of times before Steve moves on his own, bringing his hips up and down with an added roll to make things feel more. Steve doesn’t even know how his brain is working right now, how he’s not a complete rag doll, because that’s how he wants to feel. He hates feeling inferior, but in this moment, he just wanted Billy to take control, to roll him over and use him. God, that was so dirty, but it was so true. He had never wanted something more in his life. It was disgusting, but he started to like being disgusting. Because Billy was leaning up against him and licking a stripe up his throat, and Steve had never seen so many colors in his life.
He was being knocked into what was real life, not what his parents told him real life was, or teachers, or books, or whatever the fuck, this is what real real life was. It was colorful and loud and so fucking bright!
And suddenly the star that was in his abdomen was growing older and older and suddenly-
Confetti was everywhere, fireworks were going off, paint was being thrown at a canvas. There was an explosion of colors Steve had never seen before, bright and loud, smelling like cigarettes and pine wood, feeling like oil and tough skin. He was sick, disgustingly twisted in the head. The sun was burning into his flesh, bubbling his smooth and pretty skin and making him utterly horrendous. Steve hated being perfect, and he was glad Billy was making sure his perfect image was being burned to hell.
Notes:
I hoped you guys liked this chapter! I don't know how to write sex so I just write it very arty wise, took way too much inspiration from cmbyn..... yeesh...
Chapter 3: An Aftermath.
Notes:
heeeyyy we're on the finale chapter wooooo. It's really short tho sooo... and the second part is kinda sad because it's like before the big fight/breakup between these two losers.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Forbidden fruit had been bitten into - climaxed into… and on, actually, and now Steve and Billy were sitting in Steve’s red BMW. It’s weird having Billy in him still. He had cleaned up the best he could with a flushing red face while Billy told him what to do exactly because he had experience. But he could still feel it, clinging on to Steve. It was disgusting, but also… exhilarating to a point. The blood on both of their faces was smudged and only slightly washed away with spit and the cotton of their t-shirts.
They were sitting in Steve’s car now, driving though. It was still super early, they had hung out for a while until the car’s clock read 4:30 and Steve said he wanted to get something to eat. He suggested his own house, because he knew Billy probably wouldn’t be able to suggest his.
And now they were driving to the Harrington House. Steve’s parents were still going to be asleep, but they could sneak into the backyard and Steve could quickly steal something from the pantry or fridge for the 2 of them to eat. The music in Steve’s car is loud, loud enough for it to fill Steve’s ears completely and make him forget that he’s been hating himself for the past 2 days, because now Steve feels great. Steve’s never felt so amazing in his entire life - never felt more alive. He’s so happy and he doesn’t care if his smile makes him look like a nerd. He’s fucking ecstatic. Steve doesn’t want to use the word love, because that’s way too soon and even though it took him quicker to figure out he was in love with Nancy, this is different, it’s all different.
Steve doesn’t really know what he’s doing. He’s trying out a lot of personality changes right now and figuring out which ones best fit who he is at the moment. He even steals the cigarette between Billy’s fingers and presses it between his lips, letting the tobacco painfully sting his lungs.
He isn’t dating Nancy anymore.
They get to a split in the road and Billy stops them, holding onto Steve’s arm.
“Can we stop at 7-11 and get slushies before getting food at your house?”
And how can Steve say no to those eyes - those lips. Those cherry red lips that drive him insane. Jesus- he was sick.
So they stopped at 7-11, for their slushies, Steve blue and Billy’s red. Somehow that matched them. And now they were sneaking into the Harrington’s backyard. Billy grabbed two pool chairs and sat them on the stairs in Steve’s pool while Steve snuck inside to steal some food. He made sure to never lock up the back door for moments like this. Who cared if someone broke in? They had enough money to replace everything in this house twice.
He pulled some leftover potato latkes, Jewish food he had never cared enough to listen about from his dad. His mom was Christian, very Christian, but his dad was Jewish and because his mom was such a ‘loving wife’, she made sure to make some Jewish foods now and then. His dad didn’t really give a shit though, rather digging deeper into the stereotype that was Jewish people love money, naming their real estate agency ‘Gold Home Property’.
Steve just saw their Jewish-ness as an advantage rather than a disadvantage. His dad selling it with the stereotypes got them a really prominent place in the Hawkins matriarch, and he got to eat some good food now and then because of it too.
He grabbed some applesauce from the pantry and made his way outside, kicking off his shoes and socks before going into the pool to sit down in the chairs. The water only went up to his ankles.
“What the fuck is this?” Billy asks, taking a latke from the plate. They’re best served hot, but Steve wasn’t turning on the microwave.
“Potato latkes.” Steve opened the applesauce and dipped one into it.
“Huh?” Billy says with a mouth full.
“Jewish food.”
“You’re Jewish?” Billy took another from the cold plate.
“Dad is, we don’t really bother with it though. My mom is Christian, so we go with that most of the time. We just get a lot of money and good food from being Jewish.”
“You get paid for being Jewish?”
Steve laughs. “No, it’s this whole stupid thing where people think Jewish people are super greedy.” He says. He likes talking with Billy. “My dad just uses it to his advantage when people get mad at him for his high prices on houses.”
Billy snorted. It’s ugly and obnoxious, but Steve’s already repeating it in his head. “Sorry, man, gotta raise your taxes. I’m Jewish.”
Steve giggled. He felt high. “Exactly!”
And the two continued like this, eating cold potato latkes in Steve’s pool, Billy tried them with the applesauce once asked Steve how insane he really was because ‘who the fuck would like that!?’ They talked about random things, conversation starters with no plan on how to continue or end the conversation. But Steve was okay with that. He’d usually have a big spreadsheet of how to end and start a conversation, how to keep it going, how to make it stop, but he didn’t need any of that now. All he needed to do was talk about the things on his mind, speak endlessly, start a new topic in the middle of one they had been on for a while, diverge into a side story that got them talking even more.
When the sun started peaking up above the trees and everything looked golden, Billy told Steve he had to go home.
“What time do you think it is?” He asked, messing with the straw in his empty slushie cup.
Steve drew in a breath and turned his head over to look at Billy. God, he was gorgeous. “It’s gotta be around five or five thirty.”
Billy tsked. “I gotta get going then.” he stood up and Steve whined.
“No, why?”
“My dad will murder me if he finds out a snuck out.” Billy said while stepping out of the pool, taking the chair with him.
Steve let out a groan while standing up and following Billy, taking his chair out of the pool as well. “All parents say that. Why can’t we just hang out more?” Steve didn’t care if he sounded pathetic. He was having the time of his life talking with Billy.
“Because, the only thing the police will be able to find will be my teeth.” He looked at Steve after putting his shoes on. “I need to go.”
Steve sighed and set down the empty plate of latkes. “If you say so.” He rolled his eyes and Billy cackled behind him.
The car ride was quiet, the music wasn’t so loud, and they weren’t so hyped with the adrenaline of having sex. It was calm and smooth; it was nice. A layer of brick had been ripped away from Steve and now he was just… himself.
It was just about to turn 6 when Steve parked two houses away from Billy’s (his instructions).
“Will I be able to… see you again?” Steve asked, quietly and nervously, as Billy unbuckled himself.
“Damn, pretty boy.” Billy teased. “You really love me, don’t you?”
Steve’s face went hot. He didn’t know if it was love he was feeling for Billy or something else. He just felt really happy when he was with the boy. Complete. “It’s not- I just… I like hanging out with you.” There was a beat of silence and Steve got self-conscious. “We don’t have to- We can forget-”
“No, no, I’ll budge.” Billy turned slightly in his seat to face Steve. “What do you wanna do?”
Steve shrugged. Hookups weren’t really his thing, he was a romantic. Flowers and candles and all that fun stuff. “I don’t know… I want something more formal between us since…” They’re dating… right?”
Billy gave him a look of uncertainty. “You do know we can’t really go out and be boyfriend and girlfriend, right?”
“No, yeah, I know… I know.” Steve stuttered. He was well aware. “I meant like… a formal dinner. Like we can make something at my house. My parents are going to be leaving Sunday morning, so you could come over later that night for dinner?”
“So tomorrow?”
“Yeah.” Steve had been up for so long he forgot it was Saturday.
Billy went quiet for a minute, knots twisted in Steve’s stomach. “I don’t think I’ll be able to see you at a reasonable dinnertime, but I can definitely sneak out for around ten? Maybe eleven?”
Steve nodded, a smile pulling at his lips. “That’s fine, my parents will be long gone by then… hopefully… could I get your number?”
Billy gave him a deadpanned look. “I’m not giving you my number.”
“Well, what if I need to cancel, asshole?” Steve poked his shoulder. “I can’t have you knocking at my door with my parents home.”
Billy squinted at Steve before giving Steve his phone number. No paper, just pure word of mouth. Steve planned to write it down as soon as he got home.
“‘Kay I gotta go now.” Billy leaned in and gave Steve a chaste kiss, but Steve wanted it to go on forever. “I’m so glad that Nancy bitch broke up with you.” He whispered against Steve’s lips before getting out of his BMW with a cheeky smile.
And shit- Steve had forgotten all about Nancy. Now that she was invading his mind again, he needed to do something. He couldn’t tarnish the only real friendship that he had in that fucked up highschool. Yeah… it was a friendship now, and Steve was okay with that, but he wasn’t okay with Nancy hating him. He could go get dressed into something more presentable, grab some forgiveness flowers, and head over to the Wheelers in the afternoon.
Everything would be fine. He had a boyfriend, he was going to apologize to Nancy, and he was going to graduate with a smile on his face. Nothing would go wrong.
There was so much going on Steve hadn’t even thought about the time - it hadn’t even crossed his mind. All he knew was that he spent the day and half with Dustin fighting demodogs (his words, not Steve’s). So when Steve entered the Byers’ house with everyone else and he got to see a clock for the first time, his stomach dropped. It was 11… not the girl… the time.
The only thing that was going through his head was panic. Billy was probably pissed at him, and Steve didn’t blame him.
“Shit.” He hissed and ran back outside, ignoring Dustin’s confused calls. He quickly opened his car and searched around in his glove box for a minute before finding a flooded piece of ripped paper he had torn from one of his school notebooks. Steve quickly ran back inside and waited patiently until Chief Hopper was done with the phone. Thankfully, it didn’t take him long to finish his call and as soon as he was. Steve dialing the scribbled number on the piece of paper he had.
“Who are you calling?” Dustin asked.
“None of your business.” Steve responded while putting in the last 4 digits.
“Is it a new girlfriend?”
“Stop asking, Dustin.” New girlfriend - new boyfriend, same thing really. In the corner of Steve’s eye, he could see Nancy looked at him with furrowed brows and a confused look on her face. Deserved.
Steve waited impatiently as the phone rang in his ear. There was a knot in his stomach and it was only getting tighter. He thought he was going to throw up.
“Hello…” Billy’s eyes were red and wet with tears and he looked out of it, his confidence was kicked in the balls.
Steve let out a sigh of relief. Thank god. “Hey.” He responded. He still smiled, even though Billy wouldn’t be able to see it. “I feel terrible about this, but um… I won’t be able to make it tonight.” He explained. “Some… shit came up.”
“Yeah… I don’t think I’d be able to make it either.”
“Oh, what’s up on your end?”
Billy shrugged. “Some shit came up.” He wiped his nose and looked out his half-cracked open door.
“Oh, no… well, I’m still super sorry about not being able to make it.” Steve twirled the phone line in his fingers, he felt terrible about this. Hopefully, they’d be able to have dinner another time.
“Steve!” Max hissed, and he turned around to face her.
“What!?” he hissed back. This little ginger was getting on his nerves. So annoying, but she was tough.
“We’re mourning! Get off the phone!”
“I didn’t even know the dude!”
“I didn’t know him either, but I’m still being nice about it!”
Max was only a little right. Mrs. Byers was off somewhere in the house crying over Bob Newby, her boyfriend that had just gotten eaten by demodogs. The entire house was quiet and Steve was trying to be as quiet as he could, but he was still talking.
Billy was holding the phone away from his face. There was a feeling of almost… betrayal in his stomach. Because Billy knew that voice, he had been living with that voice for the past 5 years.
“I’m sorry.” Steve’s voice came back on the phone. “Some things are going on right now, but I’ll be sure to make this up to you, okay?” And then Mike started talking about how Bob Newby was the founder of Hawkins AV club and Steve had to pretend like he really cared.
“What’s going on?” Billy asked.
“Oh, I’m just babysitting at the Wheeler’s and the kids are being annoying.”
“Wheeler?”
“Yeah, Nancy’s little brother. Weird, I know” Steve gave a little nervous laugh and his eyes darted back over to the kitchen table where the kids were all talking in hushed tones. That couldn’t be good. “Hey, I gotta go, but I promise I will make this up to you, okay?”
Billy was thinking, Wheeler, like Mike Wheeler, frog-faced loser. He had been in Hawkins for little under 2 months now, he knew where the Wheeler’s lived. The question on his mind was, why the fuck would Max sneak out to go to that loser’s house? It was fucking weird.
“Okay?” Steve repeated.
“Yeah… okay.”
Steve smiled softly. “Well, um… I see you at school, bye.”
Billy only hummed before hanging up the phone. He had to go visit the Wheeler’s.
Notes:
I hope you guys liked this small fic! I adore established relationships, but I really did like writing the start of their relationship <3 I just think they're lovely.
