Actions

Work Header

your will to follow through

Summary:

After that night at the Byers, Steve feels like his days are all blurring together; drowned in a monotonous rhythm he can't seem to break out of. Desperate for some kind of change, he decides to join the amateur lacrosse league advertised in the rec center. It's just his own brand of shitty luck that Billy happens to be on the team, too.

or, the lacrosse au that absolutely no one wanted but i still wrote anyway

Notes:

title comes from "fork and knife" by brand new!

Chapter Text

The feeling begins gradually.

It seems like it starts about a week after the most recent round with the Upside Down; it’s almost like everyone is just content to accept that it’s over, that there’s apparently no chance of the dogs from actual Hell running around and terrorizing them again. Steve kind of feels like he’s going crazy. He’s halfway sure he is, from the consistent lack of sleep. Most of the time when the kids talk about that night, it’s with an exhilarated breath. Like they had honest-to-God fun. Like it wasn’t one of the scariest moments of his life.

The feeling itself isn’t anything really insidious. Just an off feeling. Like it’s hard to care about anything at all, especially when it’s boiled down to comparing the mundane activities of life with everything he’s seen for the last two years. It was as if the veil was finally lifting, and he couldn’t pretend anymore; whether it was the fact that his relationship had probably been failing for the better half of a year or the fact that everything really wasn’t okay. And suddenly it was like he was getting left behind in the dust; while everyone was starting to adjust and get over it, it was like he was going through it for the first time again.

It was kind of startling how much of a difference it was compared to how he’d been living the past year, practically submerging himself so deep into the fantasy of a “normal life,” that he hadn’t even been able to realize exactly when his relationship started crumbling. That maybe the increasing sleepless nights and fidgeting during the days weren’t signs of school-related stress, but something different. Coupled with the realization that maybe he was more avoidant than he thought—and with hindsight delivered by Nancy in his back pocket—and suddenly he was starting to register that maybe things weren’t all okay. And that they hadn’t been okay for a while, no matter how much he wanted to paste a smile over the problem.

It felt shitty to bring it up to any of the kids, because even if he thought they were over it, he was too afraid to make a misstep somewhere and actually make it worse just in case they weren’t. He didn’t want to bring it up with Jonathan or Nancy either, even if they were the only people he was really hanging out with these days—feeling like most of the time he was just the random add-on that neither of them seemed capable of shaking for good, mostly tolerating him out of pity. Joyce and Hopper were there, sure, but he’d never really talked to them before. It’d just be weird to show up on either of their doorsteps, a couple of weeks too late trying to rehash old stressors.

School was difficult to focus on before any of this, but after November it felt downright impossible to keep his head screwed on in class. By the first week of December he’s already given up hope on his exams. He can barely get through the daily worksheets, let alone any test that’ll take him longer than half an hour. None of the information seems to stick anyway, just rolls right off him at the end of every class period.

So a week passes by like that, and then another week, and then another, and then suddenly it’s the end of winter break and he feels like he’s just blinked through the second half of his semester. Like he’s just been going through the motions and sleepwalking through his day. For the first time in a while, he decides to get a grip, and tries to get back into the land of the living. Funnily enough, it’s Dustin that starts the whole thing, over fries at the diner a week or so into the new school year.

“A new hobby?” he’d asked, wrinkling his nose and playing with the idea Dustin just broached. “And what would that do?”

Dustin rolled his eyes. “C’mon, Steve. When’s the last time you did something you wanted to do for fun? Something that wasn’t just laying around your house all day or watching movies every night.”

“You basically do the exact same thing,” he narrowed his eyes. It didn’t exactly feel good being judged by a thirteen-year-old, especially when it was in response to his social life.

“But I do it with friends,” Dustin responded, not unkindly, reaching over to pat the top of Steve’s hand consolingly. “You need to get out, talk to people, get your blood pumping or something.”

“Hm.” He chewed on that for a second, ignoring the sting of the comment and drumming his fingers on the linoleum as Dustin watched him patiently. The kid wasn’t exactly wrong, which was kind of the worst thing about the situation. “I guess you could be right,” he admitted ruefully.

“I’m always right,” he scoffed, “Why don’t you join a club or something? Maybe a sport? Didn’t basketball season end already?”

“No way,” Steve denied immediately, “I’m not going anywhere near another Hawkins’ High team.” And that was something he wasn’t budging on. Tommy and the other guys gave him enough shit since the whole Nancy thing, and there was no way he was gonna willingly put himself directly in the line of fire for those meatheads. Another anxious thought popped up: the sudden, visceral memory of Hargrove slapping his naked back in the showers. He repressed a shiver. “No fucking way.”

Dustin gave him one of his patented Steve, really? looks. “You don’t have to do a sport with the high school. Why don’t you sign up for one of the amateur leagues at the rec center? Or maybe there’s a bigger one a couple of towns over. You just gotta look for it.”

It was actually a surprisingly promising idea. “Okay,” he said, testing it out loud, “But what sport would I do?”

“Do I have to do everything for you, Steve?” he got in response, “Pass the ketchup, you’re hogging it.”

He’d waited until the weekend to check out the rec center. He hadn’t been there in years, not since his parents had signed him and Tommy up for racquetball lessons in the sixth grade (just as horrible of an experience as it sounded), but from what he remembered it hadn’t changed much. Still looked just as dinky then as it did now, which was both comforting and slightly concerning.

And sure enough, his concerns weren’t unfounded. There wasn’t much that the rec center was offering directly in Hawkins, unless he wanted to suddenly start Senior Sunday water aerobics, but further down on the cork boards he found something slightly promising. A flyer, still bright and fresh enough that he knew it couldn’t have been pinned there for too long, advertising an amateur teen lacrosse league.

He’d heard of lacrosse in passing a couple of times: some from the guys at the rival high schools talking about their own teams, and a good handful of times from Billy Hargrove himself. He’d waxed on and on about it to some of the guys after practice a couple of times; Steve had made it a habit to automatically tune Hargrove out, but he couldn’t help regretting that a little bit as he stood in front of the poster. At least he would’ve had a little bit more to go off of. He knew there was, like, a stick, and you shot shit into goals. Seemed pretty straightforward, although knowing Steve he'd find some way to complicate it.

The team meeting itself wasn’t in Hawkins, was actually a town over, but it invited everyone that was in the county. There was a bit of a cover fee, but that wasn’t any issue for him, especially if it meant that the practice equipment was already supplied. All it would take was one long distance call to his mom and he’d have a check within the week. Usually he resented the whole “throw money at Steve so he’ll forget how shitty parents we are” thing, but this time it would at least work in his favor.

So, without a second thought, he tore a scrap of paper off one of the older flyers (darting a look around to make sure no one had seen) before writing down the time and place. The meeting was set for about two weeks from now, and he made sure to stick the scrap in his wallet so he could remember to write it on his calendar when he got home.

Later, when he was driving back, his mind began to pick away at all the reasons why it wouldn’t work. First, and probably most important, he’d never even played lacrosse before. While he’d been confident before that he’d be able to ace it, he was beginning to have doubts. What if he totally sucked and it was a waste of time? Or, like, he broke his face or something? It probably wasn’t likely—breaking his face—but you could never be sure. Secondly, it was around a half hour drive. Kind of out of the way, especially since the practices were in the evening. It didn’t matter that his dad paid for his gas, it was still a drive. Third, he wouldn’t know anyone there, and that was seriously gonna suck. When he told this all to Dustin a couple of nights later, he was immediately shot down.

“You’re joking, right?” Dustin gave him a flat look, “Why are you trying to wimp out?”

“I’m not trying to wimp out!” he protested, “I’m just… y’know, trying to—”

“Hinder yourself?” he raised his eyebrows, making them disappear under his curly hair, “Completely and totally back out because you don’t wanna step outside of your comfort zone?”

“I don’t even know how to play!” Steve said desperately, a last hail Mary, “They’re all probably gonna have experience, and I’m just gonna be the loser who doesn’t know how to hold a stick—”

“Hey! You know it’s called a stick!” Dustin cut in brightly. Steve shot him a look. “Steve, come on. It’s only open to highschoolers, right? There’s no one there who’s gonna be a, like, lacrosse legend. Or they’d be on an actual lacrosse team. Listen, you’ve gotta give some to get some, right? Just give it a try, at least.”

He had a point. “Well, I guess I can’t fault your logic there,” he admitted, nervously tightening his grip on the steering wheel. He really had no excuse, and he’d only be proving Dustin correct if he kept fighting it.

“Just do it, Steve, you’ll probably have a lot of fun!”

Famous last words.

And so now here he was, pulling up to the rec center over in Bedford a little over 20 minutes out of Hawkins. He’d only ever been to their high school for the basketball away games and had distinctly remembered their gym was way better than the Hawkins’ High one.

Their rec center was nothing to play about, as well. The whole thing was about twice as big as the one back home and was lit up brightly from the outside and the inside. It took a couple seconds for him to swallow away all his apprehension, before deciding to just say fuck it and threw the car door open. He pretended like he was King Steve again and slipped on that second easy skin; sure in his gait and not like he was actually quaking with every step that took him closer to the building.

It was even brighter on the inside, and pretty packed comparatively. Luckily, there were flyers attached to the big bulletin board on the wall, and within a couple seconds he was able to see the directions for the lacrosse meeting and shoulder past enough people that he could get to the fluorescent lit hallway alone.

The meeting room itself wasn’t really a room, but actually the field out back. It was almost seven o’clock, so it was starting to get just a little bit dusky, but the spring day was still making it bright enough that he could see the handful of people already gathered on the wooden bleachers on the side of the field. Heart in his throat, he ignored the sweating in his palms and just made his way over to them; glancing down at what they were wearing and relieved to see they had all come dressed in the same loose, casual sportswear that he had chosen. It was still too brisk outside to be wearing anything other than a long-sleeved shirt, but he figured if they were moving around a lot the athletic shorts would be okay.

As he got closer, he was able to recognize a couple of the other guys; some of them were guys from the other high schools they’d played in basketball before, and a couple of others were ones that he recognized from the country club his parents dragged him to reluctantly every so often. He could see them recognize him, and he returned their greeting nods with only a little bit of a grimace on his face, wondering if this was who he was going to have to be friends with the next couple of weeks, before he looked past them and nearly tripped over his feet.

In the back row, arms resting on his spread legs and looking like the cat that got the canary, was Billy Hargrove.

Dressed like the rest of them, in loose sports clothes. For some reason, his mind was unhelpfully stuck on that part. Like even though he’d seen him in basketball practice, it was still weird to see Billy Hargrove in anything other than his boots and tight jeans and denim jacket. His eyes were pinned on Steve, no surprises there, and an overconfident grin was already resting on his lips. Steve felt himself heave an inward sigh as he began inching forward again, now hunching in on himself as if that would somehow make Billy forget he’d just seen him.

At least things between them weren’t as bad as they’d been before. Not that they were about to make each other friendship bracelets, or anything, but at least it was way less hostile than it had been whenever Hargrove had first rolled into town. After that night at the Byers, Billy had done a complete 180 and stopped talking to Steve completely, not acknowledging him on the court, in the locker rooms, or even the hallways. There were no more shoves, no more plant your feet, Harrington’s, and no more weirdly loaded interactions that kind of made his head spin the more he thought about them. He’d seen Hargrove at a couple of house parties over the break, but any time they had caught each other’s eye it had been fleeting and broken off by Billy looking away almost immediately.

It had kind of thrown Steve through a loop; the way he went from apparently hating his guts one day to suddenly acting like Steve was invisible the next. He wasn’t complaining, though; not when it meant that he no longer had to worry about any right hooks or stray dinner plates. Although it looked like all of that was coming to an end, now, since Hargrove was evidently willing to look him in the eye again. At least Steve knew he had to tread with caution this time.

It felt like a march of death, just walking closer and closer even though he knew there was danger in front of him. Someone dangerous. But Hargrove didn’t look like he was fiending for a fight right now, and Steve figured even he wouldn’t be bloodthirsty enough to start something out here in the middle of a group of people. Instead of turning back around, like a big part of him wanted to, he decided to just brace himself and stick it out.

“Steve Harrington,” Hargrove drawled when he was within earshot, “Just what are you doing here?”

“Playing lacrosse, dipshit,” he muttered, still loud enough for Billy to hear, wavering a little bit before reluctantly veering off towards where Billy was slouched. The guys from the country club were major dicks, and at least there was only one Billy compared to their little posse. Better the devil you knew, even if a part of him wanted to make sure there was at least a foot between them at all times. “Why else would I be here?”

Hargrove raised his brows, shifting down only half an inch for Steve to sit. He snickered and scooted down a little further when Steve made an exasperated face. “Didn’t peg you for a lax rat.”

“A what?” he furrowed his brow, only getting more confused when Billy’s grin just got wider. “Whatever, man. Speak in riddles, I guess.”

“Jeez, amigo, take a pill. Was just messing with you,” Billy rolled his eyes. “Seriously, though, didn’t know you played lacrosse.”

“Well,” he scratched the back of his neck sheepishly, going a little warm. “I don’t really. Play it, I mean.”

That earned him an incredulous look. “So why’re you here?”

It sounded stupid to say I don’t know, or I figured I should try something new, or I needed something to wake me up; so instead he settled on shrugging and saying, “I didn’t wanna join the baseball team.”

Which wasn’t entirely false. Hawkins’ baseball team was notorious for their cursed losing streak. It would’ve been even further social suicide. He didn’t even know why he was telling Hargrove in the first place, could’ve just as easily told him to fuck off or something. But it didn’t seem like Billy was really trying to rile him up, even if he was being kind of a dick.

Billy took it with a snort, at least, and didn’t seem to feel the need to press him further. That was just fine in his book, because Steve didn’t want to try to justify his newfound interest in a sport he didn’t really understand. At this point, he wasn’t even sure if he’d come back after this first meeting. It seemed like it would be bad luck to willingly subject himself to anything that Billy Hargrove was even remotely interested in. He was thankful for the resulting blanket of silence that had enveloped them after that weird exchange.

When the guy who was supposed to be leading the team showed up—after he’d barked at them to call him “Coach Turner and nothing else, unless you want an ass kicking for dinner,”—he sat up a little higher in his seat. It took nearly all of his concentration to focus on what he was saying; half his mind trying to desperately grasp onto the basics of lacrosse and what the training would be like, while the other half was constantly aware of Hargrove’s incessant twitching at his side. The guy just couldn’t stay still, and it was enough to break Steve’s own concentration a couple of times. When they were finally let onto the field to run through some plays, he was relieved to actually begin and try to see if he could get a handle on it that way. He’d always been able to understand things if he just tried it out at first: instructions given verbally or in writing seemed to give him a headache.

Coach Turner had them begin with some simple stretches and lunges for warm up. It was easy to sink into the monotony of following orders and going through the motions of stretching and getting ready for practice, and it was a pleasant change from just lying on his couch or walking through the empty hallways in his house. It’d been so long since he’d done something physical, gotten the blood really pumping, and he was trying to discreetly pant through his mouth. Steve mostly kept his chin up and his eyes straight ahead—no need to look at anyone else and acknowledge just how awkward they all looked.

It was hard to care about that, though, when Coach had them begin some actual lacrosse warmups. Suddenly the lunges were deeper, longer, and he could feel the telling pull in his hamstrings from the effort. He didn’t complain, however, just gritted his teeth and blew a puff of air up the front of his face so the stray sweaty locks of hair wouldn’t fall into his eyes. He kept taking big breaths; ignoring, and ignoring, and ignoring the strain in his muscles.

They began all the “basic” exercises that were apparently the norm for lacrosse; exercises he had never even heard of but were consistently a thousand times worse than how they sounded. On one of the drills he’d nearly twisted his ankle like three times—only able to stop himself at the last minute every time with a quick save. Steve was still doing better than some of the others in the group, though, which was at least a little comforting to know he wasn’t the most out of shape out of the bunch.

Almost everyone was pouring sweat by the time Coach Turner called for a water break, and Steve was thankful for the time to take a couple of stabilizing breaths while he rested his palms on his knees. Suddenly, out of the corner of his eye, he saw a water bottle appear. When his vision traveled up the sweaty arm attached to it, he was surprised to find Hargrove on the other end.

The water dangled in front of him, Hargrove shaking it a little after a couple of seconds. He eyed the bottle distrustfully for a moment before the sandpaper feeling in his throat won out and he accepted what seemed like a peace offering. The first swig was like ambrosia; sweet, cold relief sluicing down the back of his throat. A couple of gulps later and he felt like a functioning human again.

“Thanks,” he panted a little, manners practically ingrained in him, some of the exhaustion and aches catching up with him now that he was no longer moving.

“No problem,” Hargrove said easily, like he’d offered water over a dozen times to Steve in the past, pausing to guzzle from his own bottle. He wasn’t nearly as sweaty as everyone else, Steve noticed, and he’d been at the front of the pack for most of the practice.

“How are you not, like, dying right now?” Steve asked, right as someone gave a retching noise—like it was on cue.

They both looked in the direction of the retcher—one of the lanky guys in the back who looked like he was only about sixteen—pulling twin looks of mild disgust, before Billy turned back to him and shrugged. “Lacrosse is big back in Cali. Practically bigger than football if you’re in NorCal. Was surprised there was any sort of league out here, to be honest.”

“Well, to be fair, this doesn’t really look like much of a league,” Steve admitted, casting a gaze around the field at the rest of the guys.

The country club guys were still doing pretty okay, and so were the guys from the rival high school he’d seen. The rest were so-so, with a large group of what looked like Sophomores huffing and puffing their way through the water break. Not really the most cohesive bunch, that was for sure. When he looked back at Hargrove, he only gave a snort in reply. Before he could say anything else, Coach was blowing his whistle and then it was time to start again.

At the end of practice he felt good and thoroughly exhausted, almost every muscle screaming out in pain from sudden use after basically not working out for months. It took him a while to hear anything over the sounds of his own panting. It didn’t sound like anything too important, just Coach explaining how and why they needed the warmups. They were supposed to meet again on Thursday, just two days from now. When they all got the go-ahead to leave, Steve gave a final stretch before loping his way across the field and back to the parking lot. A couple of the guys stayed back to shower off at the rec center, but Steve didn’t want to stick around for too much longer, especially when it was showering with a bunch of strangers he’d just met. After walking a couple of paces, he heard the sound of footsteps in the grass thundering closer.

“Hey, Harrington,” Hargrove appeared suddenly at his side. Steve used all of the willpower he had left to suppress the instinct to flinch back. Billy seemed to have noticed, at least a little bit, because he faltered for a split-second before backing off marginally. “Um, good game.”

“Thanks,” Steve said, even though they technically hadn’t even played yet. But it felt unwise to ignore Billy Hargrove, especially when he was paying him what seemed to be a sincere compliment. “Uh, you too,” he said, and meant it. There was no pretending that Billy wasn’t good.

Billy just nodded, before looking like he was bracing himself for something. “You coming back on Thursday?”

Steve shrugged. “Maybe. I dunno,” he offered, non-committal. He had appreciated the workout, that was for sure, but he was still having a tough time picturing himself actually playing lacrosse, let alone enjoying it. He also didn’t want to voice all these concerns aloud to Hargrove, so he just left it there and hoped the other boy would take the hint.

“You should. Come back, I mean,” Hargrove surprised him by saying. When Steve turned to look at him, eyebrows raised, he almost looked kind of embarrassed—a look that Steve had a hard time reconciling with his image of Billy Hargrove, someone who seemed like they never second-guessed any move they made. “You were pretty good out there with the footwork. And I know your hand-eye ain’t half-bad either. Just think about it.”

And with that, he jogged away. Like he hadn’t just thrown Steve through a loop. Hargrove complimenting him? On his athletic ability? Surely it was some kind of a joke. Surely Hell was about to open up and freeze over.

But Billy didn’t sneer over his shoulder, or anything like that. And some massive crater-portal to the Upside Down never showed up either—so he figured it was probably just the fluke of the century in the form of Billy Hargrove being nice. Steve tried to shake off the whole incident, even as he warily eyed Billy’s retreating figure get smaller in the distance ahead.

By the time he’d driven back home, showered, and changed he was feeling well and truly tired. Where usually he’d have to mess with all the lights in his house, turn on his white noise machine, and obsessively fluff all the pillows, he diverted from his usual routine; instead, he shuffled over to his bed and collapsed on it face-first, only moving to half-heartedly tug the quilt over his bottom half. Before he knew it, his eyes were slipping shut.

When his eyes cracked open again the next morning, he was surprised to see actual light filtering in through the window. So, he hadn’t woken up in the middle of the night like he usually did. When he glanced at his bedside clock next, his eyes nearly bugged out at the time flashing in red numbers.

“Shit,” he cursed, throwing the blanket back hurriedly. “Shit, shit, shit.” He only had about five minutes before he was supposed to leave for Dustin’s, and that entire five minutes was used in some kind of speed-race version of getting dressed and running a toothbrush over his teeth quickly. Even though he had to rush, though, he still felt substantially better than he had any morning the whole week before. There was kind of an ache in his arms and legs as he tugged his backpack on while going down the stairs, but he figured it was due after a workout like the one he’d had last night.

He made it there just in time, pulling up to the curb where Dustin was standing expectantly, both hands fastened onto his backpack straps. When he crawled into the Beamer, he gave Steve an appraising look. “Your hair… is…”

“Yeah, I know,” he ran a hand through it, tugging the bangs back and trying to get it back under control, “I overslept and didn’t have any time to fix it this morning.”

“Overslept?” Dustin raised his eyebrows, reaching over to elbow Steve, “Hey, good job! That’s awesome!”

Steve cheeks went warm. “It’s whatever,” he mumbled, not looking back and dodging Dustin’s elbow, “It’s not that big of a deal.”

“Of course it is! You haven’t had a good nights’ sleep in, like, forever!”

“Not forever, but yeah, it has been a while,” he admitted. “I hit my bed pretty hard last night after practice.”

“Practice! I almost forgot!” Dustin nearly broke the sound barrier with his excitement, “How’d it go?”

“It was alright,” he hemmed and hawed, “I don’t know if I’ll do it again, I’m still kind of debating.”

“Why not?”

Steve shrugged away Dustin’s demand. “I dunno. The warm-up was fine, but I don’t know if I could actually see myself doing that every week.”

He was met with silence. When a couple minutes passed, he looked over to Dustin, who was chewing his lip while he looked on contemplatively. “What?” he asked, guarded.

Dustin still seemed to chew on his thoughts for a couple seconds before finally deciding to speak. “I think you should give it another chance. You never know, you could end up liking it a lot. Besides, if it wears you out and helps you go to sleep at night at least a couple of nights a week, don’t you think it’s worth it?”

“I—I guess,” he accepted. He wisely left the part out about Billy Hargrove being in the group, afraid that if Dustin heard he might have a conniption. “I’ll try it out again,” he promised when he got the full force of Dustin’s puppy dog eyes, smiling only a little bit when Dustin let out a whoop! afterwards.

~

True to his word, Steve went back to the next practice the following Thursday. It was just as exhausting as the first one, but this time the Coach at least let them hold the sticks—crosse’s—to get a feel for them. The weight of the wooden base felt eerily familiar to that of his nail bat, and the first time he picked one up he kind of lost concentration for a second, thrown back into November and its terrifying memories. But the moment passed just as quickly as it’d come, and he twirled the crosse in his hands a couple times to understand how to work it, and it felt marginally better.

It was way different in dimension than the nail bait, that was for sure. It was longer, and thinner, and took more hand-eye coordination than he thought to swing it and get a good arc going, one that would be powerful enough to throw or catch the balls in the little net attached at the end. After a couple goes with it, though, he found it wasn’t that difficult to maneuver. In fact, it almost felt a little more natural with that light weight in his hands than it ever did swinging that damn bat in the Byers’ house and the junkyard.

It took them a couple more weeks of practices before everyone got the swing of things and began to rotate positions. The guys from the country club Steve had met briefly before—Carter, Coyne, and Brooks—were pretty decent, enough that he could tell they’d definitely played once or twice. The random high schoolers that looked to be about a grade or two under him—Nelson, Cameron, and Manning—weren’t as decent, and he could see the twist on Coach Turner’s mouth every time one of them stumbled out onto the field. Manning had nearly brained himself with the stick twice in one afternoon.

It was the guys from the rival high school that were the most aggressive, and that seemed to apply to on and off the field. The guys—Johnson, Stone, and Edwards—seemed to be at the same skill level as him, except, like, a thousand times more hostile than how he played. He found himself tightening his grip and planting his feet every time he had to face off against one of them, and it seemed like they all had some kind of vendetta against him from the way they frequently shoulder checked him through practice. He shook it off every time, though, and just focused on running his drills and trying to keep up. Overall, he felt like he was doing a fairly decent job; Coach had given him a couple of positive comments during practices about his form.

It was nothing compared to Billy, though. Any skill any of them had, combined—and doubled, honestly—probably still fell short when compared to Hargrove. He was good at every position interchangeably, was always at the front of the pack during exercises and drills, and was relentless in practice from beginning to end. He could tell that Hargrove actually enjoyed this game—more like lived and breathed it—just by the intensity on his face every time he got the ball into the pocket of the mesh. It wasn’t anything like what he’d seen in basketball; the cocky showboating and flashy moves. No, instead it was the single-minded focus and tunnel vision that he hadn’t ever seen on Hargrove before, a tenacity that was honestly pretty impressive when he saw how well he wielded it on the field.

He was a surprisingly good team player most of the time, too, which also came as a shock to Steve. It was night and day from the Hargrove who would hoard the basketball all game, and Steve had nearly gaped when Billy had actually corrected his grip on the stick without sounding like a condescending asshole. Reluctantly, Steve was beginning to not hate Hargrove as much. Sure, the guy still annoyed the shit out of him sometimes, but he really wasn’t all that bad at the end of the day. He was pretty much a breath of fresh air when it came to Edwards—the guy who seemed to have an intense dislike the most for Steve.

They’d probably played each other in basketball, forever ago, and Hawkins had probably won a game that Steve honestly had no recollection of playing. It was the only thing that explained Edwards’ hostility towards him, although Steve didn’t know how being a sore loser could really make someone that much of a douchebag. He constantly had something to say about Steve’s form, his weak spots, even the fucking shoes on his feet every time he showed up for practice.

Steve just took it in stride, barely paying him any attention—even though it was really starting to rankle his nerves. Not even Hargrove had been this antagonistic towards him in basketball, and most of the time he found himself biting his tongue or schooling his face so it wouldn’t escalate. He never thought he’d wish for the day that Billy Hargrove was his biggest problem again, but Edwards was pushing him towards his limit.

Edwards pulled a lot of cheap shots too—always rougher on Steve during the drills, shoulder-checks that were barely legal constantly on the field, and one time Steve swore he saw the guy try to trip him as he ran by. It was just immature, grade-school bullying. But it still got to him. This was supposed to be a way to let go; maybe not relax, per se, but something to take his mind off… well, everything. And having Edwards and his shenanigans to look forward to twice a week definitely wasn’t helping.

Today was especially bad. Edwards had stomped onto the field, clearly in a mood, and without any second thought had roughly shoved by Steve to get to the sticks. Steve just went with the hit—per usual—but he was stupefied when Hargrove suddenly appeared at his side.

“The fuck’s his problem?” Billy groused, glaring after the other boy stalking away. “Guy always seems to have it in for you.”

Steve shrugged. He was honestly kind of surprised Hargrove had even noticed. He was even more surprised Hargrove was talking to him about it. “Don’t know. I think we beat him in a basketball game, or something.”

Billy snorted, turning to him. “So he’s acting like a little bitch about it? Cry me a river.”

He couldn’t help but let out a little puff of air through his nose, amused. “Yeah, well. Can’t win ‘em all.”

“Apparently not.” Billy rolled his eyes. “Basketball team must’ve sucked ass if Hawkins’ was able to beat them.”

“Guess so,” Steve remarked drily, watching Edwards look up and make eye contact—receiving a snotty look in return. “Whatever, he can have all the attitude he wants.” And Steve would let him. He figured there was no point raising a fuss over something that was so insignificant—especially when he knew that saying something in this case would only make it worse.

Billy just hummed and narrowed his eyes, still watching after Edwards.

That day in practice, when Coach had them split off to work on drills, Steve was trying to keep his head in the game as much as possible, but he kept getting distracted by the rough shoves and little hits that Edwards got in without Coach Turner seeing. It was enough to make Steve almost grind through his back molars, suppressing the urge to snap at the guy, but he just stuck to his usual routine: ignore, ignore, ignore.

Only, Edwards was really starting to make it difficult. It was during one of the exercises, practicing passing and defense, that Edwards had “accidentally” smacked the back of Steve’s head with the hard net end of his stick, a surprising force that temporarily had him seeing stars and stumbling forward a couple of steps in the grass. The back of his head ached like a bitch, but that feeling was nothing in comparison to seeing Edwards’ smug grin when he clearly thought he had gotten away with something. The next play started, and Steve begrudgingly readied himself for another blindside.

Only, it didn’t happen to him.

He watched in a kind of sick glee as Edwards attempted to catch and pass one of the balls—tongue poking out in concentration—when Billy absolutely slammed into him from the side, knocking him into one of his buddies before they both fell down in an ungraceful heap.

“Fuck, sorry man,” Billy sounded anything but, bouncing his crosse on his knee with a mean smile, closer to a sneer, “Didn’t realize I was coming at you that hard.”

“Sure, whatever,” Edwards muttered; looking like he didn’t believe it at all, but way too afraid to call Billy out on his shit. “No problem.”

The next round, when Edwards had the ball again, Billy slammed into him just as hard. And the round after that. And the round after that. Steve could only watch in poorly contained amusement, unable to keep the grin off his face. Finally, after the fourth time of eating grass, Edwards got the courage to say something.

“What the fuck, man?” he fumed, shoving himself up after another forceful topple from Billy, “You’re doing that shit on purpose, I should—”

“What?” Billy asked frankly, stopping in his tracks and looming over him. His eyebrows were raised, and he looked almost tickled. “You should what, Edwards? Go ahead and finish that sentence for me.”

Edwards went red in the face, eyes darting around the little group that was beginning to gather around them, eager to see some bloodshed. “I should—”

“What you should be doing is focusing on your own shitty form instead of trying to mow down Harrington,” Billy said. Steve felt a ripple of shock at his name, mouth opening a little before he could stop it and watching the exchange with wide eyes. “Keep pulling that over-defensive shit and I’m just gonna dish it right back. Don’t fucking try me. I can get real unsportsmanlike.”

There was a prolonged silence, with Billy raising his eyebrows expectantly, before Edwards just answered by reluctantly nodding after a moment. Stunned, Steve just watched as the rest of the guys walked off to the bleachers, disappointed that the show was over and no one even fought. Steve was still reeling over the fact that Billy Hargrove had come to his defense, both physically and metaphorically.

“Hey,” Billy’s voice came at his side, startling him out of the shock he was still experiencing. “You good?”

“Um, yeah,” Steve finally unstuck his voice from his throat, nodding quickly. “Thanks—for that. I really appreciate it.” It felt lame to say, but he was grateful that someone had done something. It had been so long since he felt like someone was on his side—combine that with the double shock of it being Billy Hargrove, of all people, and he was still kind of reeling over it.

This time Billy looked a little unsure, giving a one shouldered shrug. “It’s cool. Guy’s a douche, anyways.” He seemed to hesitate for a moment, like he was carefully picking his words, before he told Steve, “You do need to plant your feet more, though. There’s guys twice his size who’ll send you flying across the field if you don’t dig your feet in right.”

“Right,” Steve deflated, thinking of the amount of times Edwards had knocked him off his feet. A couple of weeks into training and he still wasn’t the most confident about his lacrosse-playing abilities. The looming thought of this was all a mistake, what a waste of time lingered over his head dangerously.

Like Billy could tell what he was thinking, he was quick to rush in. “Harrington, you’re better than at least half the guys here, don’t get it twisted. All you need is a little work, just tightening your form and feeling more confident. Half of it is your attitude on the field.”

“And the other half is skill, though,” Steve rubbed a palm on the back of his neck bashfully, feeling kind of overwhelmed with the surprising amount of praise. “I still can’t shoot for shit.”

Silence. Steve expected a snarky quip, or maybe something teasing, but instead he got Hargrove acting all nervous again, shifting from foot to foot. “I could… help you. Um, practice. I’m a pretty good shot.”

He didn’t know what to say, didn’t even know what to do other than stare at Hargrove like he was the crazy one. Hargrove—Billy Hargrove—was offering to help him practice? Willingly? Like, actually offering to do something… nice for him? He hadn’t realized how long he was stood there, gaping like a fish, before Billy turned red and cleared his throat.

“Forget I offered,” he bit out, shoulder hunched and turning away.

“Wait!” before he could think about what he was doing, he was grabbing Hargrove’s sleeve and saying, “Yeah, I mean, if you want to. I need all the help I can get.”

It looked like Hargrove hadn’t expected him to accept, even if he had made the offer. He seemed to stutter over his words just as much as Steve did. “Oh, uh, okay.” He seemed to shake himself out of whatever funk he had momentarily been suspended in, because the expression he wore was closer to how he usually looked. “How about Saturday? The football field at the high school should be free.”

“Okay, sounds good.” Steve agreed, abruptly letting go of Billy’s sleeve like it had burned him. He was kind of still processing the fact that he was about to voluntarily spend more time with Billy Hargrove. It sounded like some kind of a sick joke. But he still agreed.

He thought about it on the entire drive back. Why had he agreed? Hargrove had been right; he was better than like half the guys on the team. Yes, he definitely needed to fine-tune his skills, but he wasn’t abysmal. Last semester there was no way he would’ve gone near Hargrove within a six-foot radius. And now he was agreeing to extra practice sessions, like it was no big deal.

But when he thought about it, really thought about it, Hargrove hadn’t been horrible to him lately. Had actually been… pretty okay if Steve was being completely honest. It was nothing like how basketball had been; the undercurrent of tension that always seemed to fizzle through the air whenever they were around each other. No, it was way different than that. Maybe it was the fresh air, or all the running around or something, but it felt miles different than it had before. And after the thing with Edwards today, he felt more confident that things weren’t still weird or hostile between them.

He almost wanted to say that that was the reason he had agreed; some kind of favor in return for Billy defending him today, but even that explanation didn’t sit right. The fact of the matter was: when Billy offered to help him practice, he had wanted to say yes.

Against his better judgement, of course, but it was still true. He hadn’t hung out with someone his own age in God knows how long, and even though he was willingly subjecting himself to what was sure to be an afternoon of intense physical activity, it was still something to do that wasn’t carpooling the kids around town or sitting through another one of those weird, artsy movies that Jonathan and Nancy seemed to like so much.

Yeah, okay, it was with Billy Hargrove, but he felt pretty confident that he wasn’t about to beat his face in again. To be safe, though, he wasn’t gonna mention anything to Dustin. God knows the kid would probably talk his ear off until Saturday talking about how dangerous it was gonna be. And maybe it would be… but Steve was kind of doubting it. He wouldn’t know for sure, though, for a couple of days.

The rest of the week passed by, with another Thursday practice that had him well and truly exhausted again, and suddenly Saturday morning was hanging over him. At the last practice Billy had said they could meet some time around noon, when the sun was supposed to be high and bright enough that they wouldn’t be too chilly. It was… almost kind of nice, Billy thinking ahead for them like that. It was a weird thought to ruminate on, though, so he made a point to put it out of his head.

He found himself driving to the football stadium with sweaty palms and the odd sensation of nerves climbing up his throat, although he didn’t know why he was being so weird. Steve had to take a deep breath, steeling himself, before he turned the key in the ignition and parked.

Billy was already messing around by the time he got there and crossed the field, practicing with a crosse while another one lay right next to him on the ground. He looked good out here, Steve had to admit. Basking in the sun like it was his natural state of being—was everyone in California that tan?

“Did you borrow those from Coach?” Steve asked as he walked up. Though once he got closer, he could see they looked a little different, not at all like the secondhand ones Coach had been letting them use every practice.

“Nah, these are mine,” Billy said, confirming his suspicions. “Theirs are way shittier, compared.” He bent forward and picked up the other stick, handing it out to Steve to inspect.

It was a bit longer, and instead of plain brown paint it was a smooth and shiny maroon and white combination. On the side of the shaft he could see “Property of Crescentia Valley High School,” he lifted it up and raised his brows, an unspoken question hanging in the air.

“Yeah, I jacked them from my last school,” Billy admitted with a grin, “I’m sure they’ve replaced them by now, though.”

Steve just snorted, testing the weight in his palms. “This is… one of the long ones, right? It’s different from the others.”

“Yeah, it’s the long stick for the middies and attackers,” Billy took the crosse from him gingerly, showing him the difference in length, “You always want at least one midfielder to have one of these for extra defense. I don’t have a goalie crosse, but these should be fine. If you can learn how to shoot with one of these then you’ll be able to make any shot with one of the regular ones. You wanted to practice your shots, right?” He handed the stick back to Steve, reaching over to grab his smaller one off the ground.

“Sure, that sounds good,” he watched as Billy meandered his way over to one of the goal posts, all the while thinking how crazy it was that he was even there in the first place. He was becoming more and more surprised by the moment; shocked in how prepared Billy came to the practice session and how he apparently wasn’t gonna half-ass it. Not that he had expected Billy to completely drop the ball—he’d been the one to offer the session, after all—but it still perplexed him to see how much thought he’d actually put into it.

When Billy got to the middle of the goal, he widened his stance and tightened the grip on his stick, Steve could see it even from here. He swallowed down the nervous apprehension, gripping the longer stick and scooping up the ball before his nerves could get the best of him. Weirdly, he was most freaked about hitting Billy in the face or something since they didn’t have any protective gear. He tried not to look into the thought too deep, aware that he was worrying about Billy Hargrove of all people and how ironic that was in the first place.

It turns out he had nothing to really be scared for; the ball was shooting up higher than it should have been, a not so graceful arc, sailing through the air before Billy was able to snag it easily mid-flight with his own crosse. He lobbed the ball back at Steve smoothly, looking as easy as breathing.

Steve bent over and scooped the ball up again, taking an extra deep breath to ground himself (and for patience) before he tossed it again; this time it didn’t sail quite as high, but it cut too wide for the goal post. Billy still caught it pretty easily, though, jumping a little to snag it out of the air before it could fly back even further.

“Okay, Harrington,” he said, walking over, “Your arm’s way off. You’re going for an over-the shoulder, but really all you need is an overhand. There’s too much force behind your swing, you can’t be as heavy with it.”

It all kind of made sense, but Billy must have seen the wisps of confusion on his face because he fell in line next to Steve, lining them up so they almost matched. “Pull back like you’re about to throw,” he instructed, and Steve followed, winding his arm back. “Now hold the dominant hand a little over the other one, so you can get the right amount of force. Then you’re gonna hold it up a little high—not that high—and then—” he made a throwing gesture with his arm. He motioned to Steve. “Try it out.”

Steve got in formation, bending his arm back, until Billy’s hand wrapped around his forearm, startling him. He didn’t flinch, per se, but he definitely started a little, twitching under Billy’s hand. Billy took it in stride, at least; just giving a little uncomfortable cough while he waited for Steve to unclench, grabbing his bicep not as tight this time. He slowly adjusted Steve’s angle, and even though he knew he should be paying attention to the technique, he still couldn’t quite get over the shock of having Billy’s hand on his bicep. It was warm, crazy warm, like he was a furnace, and the grip was firm.

“Harrington?”

He jerked out of his thoughts. “What?”

Billy just looked at him like he was loony. “The shot. You wanna try to take it?”

“Oh, yeah, sure,” he said, like he’d only just noticed he was already in position. He planted his feet a little firmer into the ground, heeding Billy’s previous advice, and took one last steadying breath before launching it.

It sailed, directly into the net of the goal post. It wasn’t the cleanest shot and was definitely skewed towards the top rather than the middle, but it was the best one he’d done so far. He found himself grinning and turning to see Hargrove, a little surprised to see he was also smiling a little and staring right back at him already. “Good job. Now let’s see if you can make that with someone actually in the goal.”

He jogged back over while Steve readied his stance again, winding his arm back so it was at the same angle Billy had moved him to. He shot again with the same force and was gratified to see Billy reaching to get it; even though he hadn’t been able to score the point, it was still better than what he was doing before.

They practiced like that for a while, Steve throwing the balls while every so often Billy would come over and adjust his arm to get the right amount of power behind it. He walked Steve through the other types of throws, too, some that Coach Turner hadn’t even mentioned yet. They also ran drills—Billy making sure he knew how to effectively plant his feet so he wouldn’t get blindsided by any defenders.

It had felt like barely any time had passed, even though the sun was starting to creep towards the horizon, setting into late afternoon without either of them noticing. It was only when it started get dusky out there that Steve stopped, catching his breath, and wiping the sweat off his forehead. He tried to ignore how badly his shirt was sticking to his chest from how much he’d sweated right through it, but other than that gross sensation he was feeling pretty good; he could say without a doubt he was already leagues better than he had been before, and that was after only a couple of hours with Billy.

“Thanks, man, I think I actually can manage a shot, now,” Steve said truthfully. Towards the end he’d been able to sink a couple balls past Billy into the net, something he thought he’d never be able to do.

“It’s cool,” Billy said, waving it off like it was just every day that he offered to help Steve out. “Um, if you want, we could do it again—practice out here.”

“Oh,” Steve said, surprised. He’d kind of thought this was gonna be a one-time thing and was a little jolted from the offer. The most sensible part of him—which suspiciously sounded like Dustin—said it was a bad idea. But this afternoon hadn’t gone too bad; in fact, it wasn’t bad at all. Was actually pretty… decent, if he was being honest. So even though all logic pointed to him calling this a one-time thing, he found himself nodding instead. “Yeah, that sounds good. Same time and place next week?”

Billy looked, again, like he hadn’t been expecting Steve to agree, almost kind of taken aback. He recovered quicker than Steve had, though, tossing a nonchalant shrug and saying, “Cool. See you Tuesday, then.”

Practicing with Billy paid off in more ways than one. Coach almost immediately noticed the remarkable improvement in his technique and commented a couple of times about how he thought Steve would be a good midfielder. He was a little surprised at that, since all the midfielders were supposed to be good at basically everything and he still felt like a fish out of water. But Coach was adamant, though, and insisted on using him in that position for practice. Coach was having Billy be a midfielder too, so at least he wasn’t gonna be completely left out to dry.

That was another benefit of the weekly practices with Billy. The more they moved through everything, not just working on throwing and catching but actual passing and shooting, as well as taking some trips around the track, the more he found them to be a cohesive unit. The second he scooped up —never rake it, Harrington, just scoop, Billy’s voice rang crystal clear in his head— the ball with his crosse his eyes were darting around, trying to find Billy so they could make a seamless pass across the field.

Billy was good at lacrosse, he already knew that, but seeing the way he played up close and personal was kind of dizzying to Steve. He chalked it up to being on the other end for so long that he didn’t know how to deal when Billy was actually on his side. Where he thought Billy had just been good before, he could see that didn’t even cover the half of it; Billy was amazing at lacrosse. He could tell the Coach was having a difficult time choosing his position, since he was good for basically every single one, and Steve felt pretty thankful that for the time being they were at least both midfielders.

All the extra practice time had also made things a little easier between them, edging out some of the previous tension and instead replacing it with something lighter, making it easier to breathe and actually enjoy himself most of the time, not wondering any more if Billy was gonna lose his temper and snap. Where before Steve would usually be one of the first to leave once practice was over, now he found himself lingering behind to leisurely walk with Billy back to their cars while they shot the shit. Neither of them ever went back to the showers with the other guys, choosing instead to leave together once all the equipment was packed up at the end of practice.

It was easier at school, too, where he no longer had to watch his back for Tommy and his cronies to say something or give him shit in between classes. He’d been walking past Tommy a week or so ago, and when he’d gone past he could see Tommy take a step forward, smirk starting to curl on the edges of his mouth. He wasn’t able to get further than that step, though, because not even a half-second later Steve had seen Billy’s hand shoot out and grab him by the collar; yanking him back so roughly that Steve had a tough time forgetting the look of shock on his face. It was pretty fucking funny, and especially more so when he saw Billy give a little commiserating eye roll over the top of Tommy’s head.

Having Billy as an ally was a hell of a lot better than having him as an enemy, and Steve was beginning to realize they were quickly approaching what might be considered “friends” territory. Where last semester that might’ve seemed impossible to him, and something he didn’t really even want in the first place, now it didn’t seem so bad. In fact, if he was being honest, he was kind of alright with it. It made his life a hell of a lot easier—and it was nice feeling like things were staring to shift back towards some semblance of normalcy. Or at least a normalcy that made it possible for him and Billy to get along.

~

It felt like one moment they were all still running over the basics, and then the next Coach was suddenly telling them they were a week out from their first scrimmage. It wasn’t supposed to be anything major, just against another amateur intramural team that was about forty-five minutes out from them. They were probably at the same skill level, and probably didn’t have a star player like Hargrove on their team. But it still made Steve anxious, and it still sent his nerves going in all directions on Tuesday’s practice. The thought at failing the thing that he’d been enjoying a lot up until this point hung over him like a dark storm cloud.

Coach was adamant that he play as a midfielder, and while before he’d been pretty flattered at the prospect—now he was starting to doubt. He was in his head the whole practice on the Tuesday, trying and failing to keep up with the rest of the guys. By the end of it he felt pretty shitty, ignoring the look from Coach, and instead focused on putting his crosse back in the bin—as if that required all his attention. He was jerked out of his concentration when he felt a shoulder knock into him lightly from behind. Whirling around, he was about to open his mouth to snap at whoever did it, thinking it was fucking Edwards again, but deflated when he saw Billy instead.

“Hey,” he said dully, turning back around and leaning down to tighten his shoelaces.

Billy waited patiently for him to finish, quirking a brow at him when he finally stood back up. “Who pissed in your cornflakes this morning?” he asked, a smirk on the edge of his lips.

Steve gave a dry snort. Always so eloquent, Billy was. He wasn’t surprised Billy had noticed his bad mood, though. He seemed to notice way more than Steve originally gave him credit for. “No one ‘pissed in my cornflakes’ this morning, thanks.” He started walking back towards the parking lot, trying to will Hargrove to drop it for now.

No such luck. Billy immediately followed after him, trailing about a half-step behind. “O-kay, so then what’s your damage?”

“There’s no damage,” Steve shot back irritably, still not letting Billy catch up with him and speeding up his pace a little bit, “Just, y’know, trying to keep my head in the game, or whatever.”

“Yeah, right,” Billy remarked dryly, somehow pulling forward and falling in line with him, “Your head was in the clouds almost the entire practice.”

“Just fuck off, okay?” Steve snapped, feeling his nerves and frustration finally boiling over and getting the best of him. He didn’t even care that he was tempting fate by being a dick to Billy, too subsumed in his own harried thoughts over the impending game.

Instead of getting angry and snapping back like he expected, though, Billy just fell back a half-step. “Okay, Harrington,” he said, the words coming out a little stilted and awkward, “Will do,” he pushed past Steve, making pains not to even brush his shoulder, and Steve felt the steady trickle of guilt spread through him, feeling like a colossal asshole for being rude when it seemed like Billy was actually trying to be nice. No one else had asked him why he was in such a shitty mood—and here he was being a dickwad to the only person that had. He didn’t even think too hard on the fact that he was rushing to tell Billy that he wasn’t mad at him.

“Hey, wait,” he jogged to catch up to Billy, who was now determinedly marching down the field like his life depended on it. When Steve finally caught up to him, he reached out and closed a hand around his arm, a little surprised when Billy abruptly flinched back. He dropped his hand, feeling out of place, before running it through his hair and trying to start over again. “Hey, listen, I’m just stressed—”

“It’s no biggie,” Billy cut in, not even looking at him.

It only made Steve feel shittier, and he suppressed a groan. “No, man, it’s not you or anything. It’s just…” he sighed, not wanting to admit it, “It’s just the game on Saturday.” He finished lamely.

“The game?” Billy’s forehead wrinkled; it looked like the thought hadn’t even occurred to him that that would be the reason Steve was in a funk—like Steve being a dick to him out of nowhere could have been completely expected. It took the last of the wind out of his sails.

“Yeah,” he admitted with a sigh, looking off somewhere in the middle distance and ignoring the way he could tell Billy was watching his face now. “I just… I don’t think I should be a midfielder. I don’t think I’m good enough.”

The bray of laughter Billy let out was enough to startle him, staring back at the other boy with wide eyes. Billy looked like he was honest to God about to clutch his stomach, the way he looked so amused. “Harrington. You’re worried about the scrimmage? And if you’ll be able to play middie?”

Steve shrugged, a little put off that Billy apparently found his apprehension funny. “Whatever, I just—”

“Harrington,” Billy cut him off, and Steve only stopped because of how oddly sincere he looked, something in his eyes that Steve hadn’t seen before, not even after things got better between them, “You shouldn’t worry about that, okay? You’re a good midfielder. Honest. And there’s no one on the team that could take your place, or else you know Coach would have subbed them in after the shit you pulled today.”

It all sounded well and good, but there was still a tiny part at the back of his head sowing doubt. “I mean, okay sure, but—”

“But nothing,” Billy said firmly, looking at him in a way that had Steve’s words unceremoniously dying on his lips, too caught up in the sudden assault of steady eye contact from Billy’s light blue eyes. “You’re good, okay? I wouldn’t tell you that if you weren’t. And don’t worry about the scrimmage on Saturday, it’s just the first one. Even if we lose, at least we’ll know what to do for the next one.”

It was pretty shocking, hearing that from Billy. He thought that the other boy would definitely have a serious problem with losing, just after what he’d seen in basketball. But he was beginning to learn that he really didn’t have a good grasp on who Billy Hargrove really was.

There was still a part of him that wanted to disagree—sow the doubt in his head even more, but something about Billy’s look made him hold his tongue, eyes tracing over Billy’s face and searching for any sign of deceit. There was none, as far as he could tell anyway; just Billy Hargrove with an open look on his face, probably the most vulnerable Steve had ever seen him. And it was all just to assure him that he wasn’t gonna play shitty this weekend.

An odd feeling of warmth bubbled up from his stomach to his chest, and he found himself reluctantly smiling back at Billy, the crappy mood from earlier miraculously dropping like it hadn’t been hanging over him all afternoon.

“If you say so,” he finally said at last, starting to steadily resume the walk back to the car, relieved when Billy joined him rather than rushing ahead again. “I just… what if I freeze? Or I completely forget all the rules in the moment, or something.”

“You’re not gonna,” Billy said confidently, still taking strides by his side, “First of all: you’ve played in games before. You’re not gonna forget anything, alright? Second of all: you’ve got me as one of the other middies. Cameron probably won’t be a lot of help,” he shrugged, truthfully, “but I’ll be there, too. And I bet we won’t need him anyway. You’ve just gotta have confidence, Steve.”

The use of his first name had him starting back a little, since up until this point he’d been “Harrington” the entire time. For some reason, just hearing it out of Billy’s mouth set his nerves alight again, a deep flush blooming over his cheeks without him even knowing why. “Well, thanks,” he said after a moment, realizing he’d kind of been walking and smiling and staring off into the parking lot, “We’ll see on Saturday, I guess.”

Billy waved a hand. “You just gotta loosen up a little, man. We’ll be just fine.”

Steve kept repeating that phrase in his head for the rest of the week; calling upon Billy’s words whenever his anxiety was beginning to mount again. It didn’t fully get rid of the jitters, but it was effective enough to have him more focused on Thursday’s practice, and by the time Saturday rolled around he was feeling marginally better than he would have before without the pep talk.

The scrimmage itself was being held at the rec center, so at least they had a home turf advantage. It still didn’t stop him from sizing up the other team, warily looking at the other players gathered on the opposite end of the field and trying to figure out what kind of competition they’d be. He felt like half his concentration was torn on watching them, while the other half went through the motions of suiting up and putting all his pads on. Under the weight of everything it felt heavier than it had in practice, but he chalked it up to the anxious throb that was still running through his mind.

Billy appeared at his side, bouncing his stick on his ankle. He jerked his head towards the other players. “Don’t think about them,” he instructed, a final kernel of advice, “Just pretend we’re back in practice. Or we’re on the Hawkins’ field, running drills.”

It helped a little bit, taking himself out of the moment and kind of grounding him to reality. “Thanks,” he smiled at Billy, gratified when he gave a smile of his own back, “We’ll knock ‘em dead,” he added, trying to tap into that endless well of confidence that Billy seemed to carry around him. Sometimes it felt like if you even stood next to the guy long enough, it would rub off on you.

“Hell yeah,” Billy laughed, before clapping a hand on his shoulder and jogging off to join their team gathered by one of the sets of bleachers. Steve jogged after him; focusing on the steady thrum of his footsteps against the grass instead of how anxious he was for the scrimmage to start.

He couldn’t even tell you what they said in the group huddle before the game; only that everyone (except for Billy) seemed to have the same expression of wariness, eyes shifting around at each other like they were all trying to catalogue how nervous everyone else was. Billy was the only one who really kept his eyes on Coach, and he was the first one to give a big whoop! when they broke their huddle. Steve gripped his crosse tightly in his hands as he walked down to his position, trying not to look at the other guys on the fields as much.

Steve was on the right-hand side of the field, and Cameron was on the left—hands gripping his stick just like Steve and looking just as determined. Billy was stood right in the middle of the field, waiting for the referee to set the ball. He was supposed to be the one who started the game at the face off; a position that probably only Billy Hargrove would’ve been able to do. They were the ones that began the game, trying to get control of the ball before the opposing side could, making the first move to determine the tides of the game.

It took a certain level of tenacity that basically no one on the team possessed—except for the obvious. He could see Billy crouched a little, looking intense and staring directly at the guy from the other team. He had a grin on his face though, a mean one, and from here Steve could see his mouth moving. Talking smack, most likely, which was such a Billy thing to do that it made him snort and roll his eyes from where he was stood, a temporary reprieve from the nerves.

He only had about half a second to think this is it before the whistle was being blown and madness descended upon the field. Sure enough, Billy shot his stick faster than the guy from the opposing team, and he realized with a breathless rush of excitement that Billy had sent the ball careening his way. Without another thought, he ran to scoop the ball, shoulder checking one of the other middies on the way to do so. It was like his brain was in the survival mode it usually went to whenever he dealt with the Upside Down: the absolute singlemindedness to get things done being his only driving force. He felt both present and non-present as he watched himself scoop the ball into the mesh, legs moving faster than he thought was possible as he raced down the field.

Billy and Cameron were there at either side, but Cameron was blocked by the defenders, so without any hesitation he swung the crosse towards Billy, sending the ball shooting out and heading in his direction. It sailed through the air in a clean arc that he wouldn’t have been able to do without all the extra practice, and he was satisfied to see Billy catching it seamlessly with his mesh, before darting a couple paces and sending it off to one of their attackers. When they passed by each other, a momentary lapse in movement since everyone was heading toward the other end of the field, they exchanged easy grins; so far everything was flowing like melted butter.

It continued that way for most of the game; Steve realized that they had been better off than he thought, and there really was no point in the major freak out he’d been having beforehand. He forgot that it was just a game, and even though it was intense and felt like life-or-death in the moment, it was still just a game. Nothing actually life ending or resulting in real-world consequences. He felt another rush of exhilaration running up and down the field, working the air through his lungs and pushing himself to run faster than he ever had in basketball.

When they broke for a huddle, Coach didn’t seem concerned at all. In fact, he looked just as elated as Steve felt. “Great job on the field, boys,” he said earnestly, making sure to give each of them a brief moment of eye contact. He stopped on where he and Billy were stood next to each other, addressing them head on. “Hey, you two, good work out there. The only way we’re gonna win any game is through teamwork, alright?”

They broke the huddle after a course of yes, Coach and a brief summary of what the game plan was for the second half. On the walk back to his position on the field, Billy nudged his shoulder. “I told you to chill, didn’t I?” he cast a roguish grin that had Steve tripping over his feet unexpectedly, “We’re fine. Just keep giving me those clean passes and we’ll be good to go.”

“Will do,” Steve snorted back, eyes lingering for a moment as Billy marched back to his position in the center.

The third quarter passed by quickly, and the other team did better than they had in the first two. They weren’t near enough to do a tie, yet, but they were getting close. He knew that it wasn’t the end of the world if they lost, or anything, but Steve still wanted to win, desperately. He wanted that unshakeable euphoria of victory. To finally fucking win, after he felt like he’d been losing for so long. Hell, even to see the look on his teammates’ faces when they won. To see the look on Billy’s face.

Abruptly, he shot that thought process down before it could get a mind of its own and he’d be stuck in a spiral. Where in the hell had that come from? Before he could ruminate any further, the high-pitched screech of the whistle jarred him back into the moment, back into the game.

The fourth quarter was the most difficult one yet, especially when they were getting towards the end. It looked like the other team was finally getting on with the program, because this time around they made sure to swarm Billy with their middies, descending on him almost immediately after they restarted for the play. It was in the last minute or so of the game that things got especially hairy. Billy looked like he desperately wanted to do more than shoulder check them, practically snarling in some of the guys’ faces. He was still able to catch a pass from Cameron, though, standing on his tiptoes and extending his arm as far as it would go to catch the ball with his crosse.

“Harrington!” Billy called, and they locked eyes over the heads of the opposing players still gathered around. He braced his stick and Steve shifted immediately, gearing up for the pass that he innately knew was coming his way. He stretched, and there was a brief terrifying moment that he thought he may have missed it, before the satisfying weight of the ball sank into the cradle of the mesh, relief running through him like a train.

He looked down the field, searching for someone who was open to take the shot, though he could see their attackers were busy, and the other teams’ defenders were quickly closing in—there was a burly guy heading his way that looked like he was practically salivating to check Steve. There was a brief moment of panic where he thought what do I do what do I do before he tuned into the voice practically roaring at him from across the field, Billy screaming out, “Take the shot!”

He swallowed and suppressed the instinct to screw his eyes shut; instead, watching the goal and sending the ball in an overhand throw he’d practiced a million times in those Saturday practice sessions. It was crazy, the way it felt like everything slowed down and then sped up all at once. The ball almost floated through the air, before suddenly slamming into the net—coincidentally, the same time that defender slammed into him, going for the gut.

It definitely was an illegal move, a desperate one too, and it nearly sent him sprawling and took the breath right out of his chest. But he couldn’t find it in himself to care at all when his team was swarming him immediately; hooting and hollering in a near-deafening cacophony of noise.

“Fuck yes, Harrington!” Billy screamed in his ear, and Steve didn’t even mind that it sent his ear drum ringing, too overwhelmed by the jubilation of the win. He felt the other guys slap his back in congratulations, but the stinging weight on his back and shoulders just added to the excitement, if that was possible. It took another ten minutes for the guys to calm down a little so they could go give the opposing team some handshakes, and Steve took a particular delight in not flinching from that burly defender’s death grip. His stomach felt like it was in knots—but the good kind, not what he’d been experiencing earlier. He couldn’t keep the manic grin off his face, even when Coach told them not to “Get too cocky, it was just your first game, boys,”

He was just standing back up after packing his bag, startled to see Billy suddenly standing in front of him. “Hey,” he said easily, still riding on that high of making the goal.

“Hey,” Billy smirked back, before it morphed into something a little nicer. “You going to Emma’s tonight?”

“Oh, uh, I don’t know,” Steve hedged. He knew there was a party tonight, but he was still kind of skirting on the edges of social pariah status, so that meant that he wasn’t technically invited. He could show up, sure, but he didn’t exactly want to get gawked at.

Billy seemed to pick up on his hesitation and where it might stem from. “It’s okay, Harrington,” he assured, waving his hand. “Let me deal with them. You should come, man, celebrate the win.”

Steve dithered; sorely tempted but still kind of on the fence when it seemed like the only person who really wanted him there was Billy. Which, surprise of the millennium, but he was slowly getting more used to it. “Well—”

“Steve,” Billy cut him off, and he was so shocked by the use of his first name again that he let him, “Just come on. It’ll be fun. And the subjects need to see their King, they haven’t had a viewing in a while,” he finished with a grin.

He rolled his eyes even as his face heated up a little at the use of the nickname. “Alright, yeah, whatever,” he agreed, surprising himself a little. He hadn’t been to a party in a while, he reasoned internally, and he was due for some regular teenage fun. Besides, he couldn’t say no when Billy looked so earnest like that, when he looked like he actually wanted Steve to go. There was no explaining the weird bubbling in his stomach, but he figured he could valiantly ignore that and save it for later—when he was in the middle of one of his spirals.

Billy grinned and smacked a hand on his shoulder. “Rad, we’re going in my car.”

“Oh,” Steve blinked, momentarily taken aback, “I mean, I don’t mind taking my own car or anything, I—”

“Harrington,” Billy rolled his eyes, “Let me drive you. I swear your car will be fine here, I’ll take you back later. Come on, we gotta make a big splash.”

“Oh, um, okay,” he stuttered out, feeling like a plum fool for acting so weird when Billy wasn’t even being unreasonable or anything. Actually, on the walk to the Camaro, Steve thought about how it was going to at least be a little easier showing up to the party with someone rather than by himself—especially when that someone was Billy. It made him feel a little more assured, like he wasn’t about to walk into the party and get blindsided or booed out or something.

He slowed a little as they reached the Camaro, almost stumbling over his feet when he was hit with the visceral memory of waking up in the back of Billy’s car, sunken into the scooped back seats, uncomfortable plastic divide digging into his spine while his face throbbed. He had no clue if Max had ever told him about her little joyride, but he figured Billy had to know some antics had come up with his car, since it had been pretty dinged up by the time she was through with it. There was no way he was about to bring it up and risk Billy’s ire, though, even if he felt a little weird opening the door to sit in the passenger’s side this time.

He hadn’t really been able to catch it that night (see: his concussion) but sitting there now he noticed how much of Billy’s scent permeated through the car. It wasn’t bad, or anything; on the contrary, it was… kind of pleasant. The smokey combination of the Marlboro Reds he was sure Billy chain-smoked in here and the heady masculine scent of his cologne formed an almost intoxicating duo. Sometimes Steve caught whiffs during practice, but it was nothing like how it was concentrated here. It was enough to get his head spinning, and he surreptitiously cracked a window to let some air in.

“Oh, I’m sure we reek,” Billy snickered, checking over his shoulder before pulling out of the parking lot. “Probably should’ve showered off before we left.”

“Yeah,” Steve agreed quickly, even though that hadn’t been the reason at all why he’d rolled down the window, “I don’t need to make things harder on myself than showing up to Emma’s in some ratty gym clothes and smelling like B.O.”

Billy cast an askance glance his way. “Trust me, you look fine,” he said roughly, before giving a little cough.

“Um, thanks,” he replied, struck by the comment and if he was being weird thinking that it was weird. Was he being weird?

Without another word, Billy reached over him to get to the glove compartment, popping it open to reveal the collection of mixtapes—sliding over each other with the clacking sound of plastic. He was more preoccupied with how much Billy had leaned into his space, though, and the arm extended right in front of him. He’d made note about it a couple times, sure, but up close he could really tell how much Billy worked out compared to all the other guys on their team. Hell, their school. “You can choose,” Billy said.

“Huh?” he tore his gaze away from the strangely arresting sight of fine blond hair dusting over Billy’s arm, “What?”

“The music?” Billy quirked an eyebrow back at him, gesturing to the glovebox. “Pick a mixtape.”

“Oh, right, yeah,” he ignored Billy’s look, choosing instead to rifle through the pretty impressive mixtape collection. It was surprisingly more diverse than he had expected—nothing even resembling a semblance of country or folk, but a couple of pop and disco mixtapes that immediately caught his eye. When he held up the Boney M. one, Billy just rolled his eyes.

“Those are for Max,” he clarified, smirk dragging up a corner of his lips, “Pick something I can actually stomach.”

Steve snorted but didn’t call him out on what was sure to be a lie. Instead he dug a little further, letting out an involuntary noise of delight as he pulled out an ELO tape, popping it into the player and immediately switching to track two. When the grand piano came on, Billy barked out a laugh.

“Interesting choice,” he said over the music, “You still got a bone to pick with Wheeler?”

Rather than taking it to heart and getting defensive like he would have done a couple of months ago when it was still relatively fresh, Steve just rolled his eyes and smacked Billy in the shoulder—not even questioning whether it was safe to do so. Billy rolled with it, though, sending a lopsided grin his way. “Fuck off,” Steve said without any heat, “It’s a good song!”

“You’re right, you’re right,” Billy grinned back, conceding, before darting his eyes Steve’s way again, “Even if you’re singing those lyrics a little too passionately.”

This time when Steve went for his shoulder, he just cackled and jerked the steering wheel, sending them in a set of choppy zigzags on the road that had Steve trying to jerk the steering wheel back in retaliation—crowing with laughter the entire time

The rest of the drive was easy after that, so easy in fact that he couldn’t even remember why he’d been so nervous to come in the first place. When they went to pull up in front of Emma’s, though, he remembered his hesitation.

Billy didn’t let him stew in it for one second. “C’mon,” he said forcefully, jerking his head in the direction of the house as he climbed out of the car, “We got some simple-minded hicks to impress,” he shot a grin over his shoulder as Steve made a noise in protest, stumbling over himself to get out of the car, too. The momentum carried him across the lawn all the way to the front door before some of the bravado seemed to have petered out. Billy just clapped his hands on Steve’s shoulders, ignoring the startled look he tossed over his shoulder, and pushed him forward through the open door, making him front and center to face the parting crowd.

“Get a drink for my man Harrington, here,” Billy ordered broadly into the house, exuding that unshakeable confidence that someone was gonna do what he said—without a doubt in his mind. “The guy deserves it. Chop chop!”

Within a couple seconds someone was pushing some red solo cups Billy’s way, and he handed one off to Steve while he downed the other in three deep gulps. Steve stared at him for a moment, in breathless fascination, before he caught up with the program and downed his own cup too. It was jungle juice, and it burned going down—he was almost out of practice, but the muscle memory of partying in the past had him keeping down his liquor.

Billy pushed him even further back into the house, where it wasn’t so congregated and crowded. Unfortunately, this only opened him in the line of sight for Tommy and some of the other guys from the basketball team, and suddenly Steve wished he hadn’t drowned that drink so quickly.

“What’re you doing with him?” Tommy practically sneered; eyeing Billy’s hands still clasped on his shoulders with something almost like betrayal.

“Calm down, Hagan,” Billy ordered, finally letting go and grabbing another couple of drinks from someone passing by, handing one off to Steve again. It felt like the imprint of his hands were still there, though, a reverberation of warmth he wouldn’t admit to himself that was kind of nice. He clapped a hand on Steve’s back, the force of it almost making him stumble forward. “King Steve here just scored the winning goal for our lacrosse game. I think that warrants a couple of free drinks, don’t you?”

The last part was said with a little bit of an edge to it, like Billy was just daring Tommy to question his judgement. Tommy’s eyes slid nervously between Steve and Billy, taking a visible moment to mull it over before shrugging and saying, “Whatever,” like he never cared in the first place.

“Great,” Billy flashed a smile at him, something about his teeth glinting making it shark-like. “Glad we’re able to come to that agreement.”

“You play lacrosse, Harrington?” one of the guys from the basketball team piped up in the ensuing silence, cutting through the air that had been growing charged with tension. “I didn’t know you were a part of the team,”

He glanced around a little, kind of shocked that it had blown over so quickly and there wasn’t any more conflict. He caught Billy’s eyes, silently urging him on. “Uh, yeah,” he replied, turning to him, “I joined the league a while ago.”

“Sick,” he said easily, clutching a beer bottle. Steve desperately tried to remember his name. “You any good?”

Before he could answer, give some kind of a half-hearted well, Billy was already looping an arm around his shoulders, drawing him in close. He was suddenly hit with a wave of Billy’s cologne, still somehow carrying over from the game, and tried to blink past the blood rushing in his ears. “Harrington here scored the winning goal for our game tonight, shot the ball from practically halfway across the field.”

“For real?”

It was a complete exaggeration; the goal hadn’t been the winning goal, but rather the last one before the whistle was blown. And he didn’t exactly shoot it from halfway across the field, even if that’s what it felt like. But Billy was throwing him a bone here, giving him something to work with and trying to make it easier on him. So instead of owning up, he decided to run with it.

“Well, you know,” he said with an air of indifference, like it really hadn’t been that much effort anyway, “Their defense was full of a bunch of pussies. Made it easy on me.”

The gathering semi-circle around them laughed. He snuck a glance towards Billy, loosening up when he saw the growing grin on Billy’s face. He looked pleased that Steve was taking the bait, making it easier on himself. When the others turned to Billy for confirmation, he shifted back to them easily.

“You guys shoulda seen it; it’s the last minute and this tank practically barrels towards him. He takes the winning shot, and then boom! Too late for them, though.”

“No way,” some girl at his side said, and he had to twist to see her. Her eyes were wide when she looked at him, hand hovering over his side. “Did it hurt a lot?”

“Knocked the wind outta me,” he admitted, caught off guard by having all the attention on him—especially the fact that it was good attention. It’d been so long since the King Steve days that he felt a little rusty putting on the old crown.

“He took it like a champ, though,” Billy asserted one last time, loosening his hold around Steve before looking at the group gathered around them expectantly. “Now can we get some more drinks for the winners?”

Steve rolled his eyes, halfway expecting that line not to work, and watched in wonder as the group slowly dispersed around them, finished with the show now that the initial introduction was over. Someone still appeared over his shoulder for two drinks, and they were gone before Steve could even think to say thanks. He shook his head in wonder, staring at the empty places where everyone had been before they’d gotten their fill. He expected a little blowback, maybe some resistance to his presence since he’d been absent from the popular scene for a while, but there was none of that. Just a couple words from Billy and they were appeased, simple as that.

Billy must’ve seen the look on his face because he just let out a laugh next to him. “I’m telling you, Harrington, these people are easy,” he said sagely, leaning forward like he was giving worthwhile advice. “Just give ‘em what they want, and the rest is taken care of.”

“And what do they want?” he quirked an eyebrow, leaning forward too. It felt kind of exhilarating, like they were in on some big secret no one else was.

“Attention,” Billy shrugged, looking out into the sea of bodies around them. He turned back to Steve. “Why do you think your little disappearing act made you so unpopular? You’ve gotta at least pretend to be interested to get anywhere with these people.”

“Oh yeah?” he asked, watching Billy instead of the crowd. The question came unbidden into his mind, and he was asking it before he could stop himself. “Is that what you do, then? Pretend to be interested?”

“It’s not as bad as it sounds,” Billy said dryly, sending him a look before draining half his cup. “In fact, it works wonders as a survival tactic.”

Steve couldn’t help but let out a snort. “Hawkins isn’t exactly that difficult to survive.” The social aspect, anyways. He wasn’t going to comment on the aspect concerning supernatural problems, though.

“To you, maybe. Some of us got dropped here in the middle of the first semester.” Billy polished off the last of his drink, unceremoniously crushing the red plastic cup and tossing it off to the side. He nodded towards the drink still in Steve’s hands. “C’mon, drink up. Guarantee you’re gonna need some liquor in your veins for this next part.”

Without any warning, he grabbed Steve’s arm and began dragging him into the throng of people, obviously intent on them to make their way around the party. He drained his drink quickly, ignoring the tart taste and the mild burn of vodka it left in its wake as he stumbled along.

It made sense, what Billy said about survival tactics. Sometimes it was easy to forget that Billy was the new guy, and that he hadn’t grown up with the rest of them. He had just inserted himself into the scene so seamlessly that it was like he had always been there, almost. But he hadn’t; he was transplanted all the way from somewhere halfway across the country, something that was jarring to think about. Maybe if he was in the peak of his King Steve days he would’ve been able to adjust—maybe—but he knew that if his parents tried to move them right now, he’d have a complete mental breakdown. There was no way he’d adapt as well as Billy, who seemed to navigate a crowd of what was practically strangers with relative ease.

Steve let himself be guided even though he already knew the layout of the house; he was thankful someone was taking the lead so he wouldn’t have to keep explaining himself. Billy was like a human shield of popularity, quelling any disagreements or dirty looks cast towards Steve with just one menacing glare. When he finally let go, after dragging them to the room with beer pong, he tried not to read too much into the disappointment he felt at the sudden absence of Billy’s warm hand on his arm. Billy folded the both of them into the fray, and Steve let himself go with the flow.

From then on, he was able to jump back into the easy rhythm of things: accept a drink, hold a meaningless conversation with another drunk person, and play a game of beer pong or two. The hardest part had been coming in, and Billy had basically taken care of that for him. A couple more people asked about the game, ostensibly having overheard them talking about it in the kitchen, and Steve found himself the center of attention once again as he regaled them with the details. He may have over-exaggerated a couple of parts, but Billy never said anything; just gave him an encouraging smile from where he seemed to be hanging on the outskirts.

He broke from the wave of people, stumbling over to Billy and finding himself way more drunk than he initially thought. It’d been a while since he drank, though, and everyone had kept passing him cup after cup to celebrate the “big win”—even though they never would have known about it in the first place if it wasn’t for Billy.

“Having fun?” Billy asked when he was finally able to break free, nearly falling over his feet and smacking into him. Billy stuck out a hand to steady him, and when he let go of Steve’s bicep it was met with that same pang of disappointment. “Woah there, ese. I think you need a little break from the punch.”

“Yeah, probably,” Steve agreed easily, letting out a burp only seconds later that felt hot and probably smelled rancid. Billy didn’t say anything, though, just made a face. “You wanna get some air?” he asked, suddenly struck with the idea. It was hot and muggy in the room, probably from all the bodies, and the thought of the brisk air outside seemed promising.

Billy was already starting to shake a cigarette out of its carton. He jerked his head over his shoulder. “Yeah, c’mon.”

They spilled out from the doorway into the side of the house, and the sudden chilly air felt good on Steve’s warm cheeks as he tried to get his bearings together. He was definitely way more drunk than he initially thought, and when he looked up at Billy, he seemed to be holding back laughter. “Oh, shut up,” he mumbled, waving a hand haphazardly while he went to lean up against the side of the house.

“You doing okay over there?” Billy asked, blowing air out of the side of his mouth. He didn’t seem bummed at all that he was basically babysitting Steve, though, just smoked his cigarette easily like he didn’t wanna be anywhere else in the world.

“Gimme,” Steve said, nodding towards the cigarette, feeling like he needed something to tether him back to the moment.

Billy didn’t protest, just rolled his eyes and handed it over. Steve took a big pull, holding it in for only about half a second before he hacked up a lung, trying to wipe the taste off his mouth while Billy just cackled right next to him. “Fuck,” he cursed, feeling his stomach start to churn. Sometimes it felt so good to have a quick smoke when he was drunk, but he’d been out of the practice of either of them for so long that now it just made him nauseated as hell.

“You okay?” Billy asked again after a moment, snorting a little. Steve fought past the pounding in his head to look at him, but he didn’t seem like he was poking fun.

“Yeah,” he said, even though it wasn’t all the way true. He just didn’t want to bring down the vibe by admitting that if he took another drag, he probably would upchuck over both their shoes. Billy was still staring at him when the tide of warmth washed over him. He was just drunk enough to go with it, carried by the tide of good feelings. “Hey, thanks,” he said after a minute.

“For what?” Billy asked with a wry grin, “Almost making you puke in the bushes?”

“No,” he rolled his eyes, swatting halfheartedly in his direction. He hesitated, trying to find the right words while also trying to not drunkenly word-vomit on Billy. He always talked way too much, and for way too long when he drank too much. “I mean, thanks for the party. And everything. I wouldn’t’ve come on my own, I’m pretty sure no one even wanted me here before… well, you know.” The before you brought me here remained in the air, unspoken.

Instead of giving another quip with a smirk, Billy’s face dropped, and he stubbed out his cigarette, even though it was only half smoked. He straightened up, facing Steve, and he was suddenly aware that the air around them had grown charged. He straightened up too, watching Billy as carefully as he could through his haze, eyes starting to go half-lidded.

“Listen, Harrington—” Billy began.

“Steve,” he replied quickly, cutting him off. He was kind of sick of the whole last name thing, especially when no one else called him Harrington, anyway.

“Steve,” Billy amended, before going on. “I… wanna say I’m sorry, alright? For that night, back in November.”

He reeled back a little bit. “Oh,” was all he could say. It was probably the last thing Steve had been expecting.

“It was really fucked up of me to go in on you like that,” Billy said baldly, like he was determined to get the words out before Steve could interrupt again, “I wasn’t really…” he cut himself off with an aggravated sigh, looking off into the dark lawn before turning back to Steve again. “It wasn’t really you I was fucking up, if that makes sense. You were just… there. Not that it makes it any better, or whatever, but…” he trailed off, shrugging self-consciously. “Either way, it was still messed up. And I’m sorry.”

“Um, okay,” he replied, stuttering a little and completely caught off guard by, well, everything. “Well... I’m sorry, too.”

“For what?” Billy’s eyebrows climbed up his forehead in shock.

Steve shrugged, embarrassed. He’d talked about it afterwards with Nancy and Jonathan, a somewhat uncomfortable conversation that covered basically everything concerning that night and the events leading up to it, and while Jonathan had been firmly in the fuck Billy Hargrove camp, Nancy had objectively pointed some things out that made sense looking back on things. “I shouldn’t have lied about Max,” he said, not quite able to make eye contact, “I know it probably looked bad, since it was just her with me and a bunch of guys in the middle of the woods. But I swear nothing weird was happening, it was all just… some stupid misunderstanding.”

“Yeah, not gonna lie, that part was pretty fucked,” Billy agreed, shifting to face him fully. He didn’t look tense anymore, though, just mildly curious. “You ever gonna tell me what really happened that night?”

Steve shifted on his feet. He didn’t want to outright lie again, seeing as that obviously hadn’t worked out in his favor last time, but there was nothing he could tell Billy that was even near the truth. And he was way too drunk to come up with a believable enough lie on the spot. “Um, would it sound totally lame if I told you it was top-secret? And that I swore on Dungeons and Dragons that I wouldn’t tell?”

Instead of getting angry, Billy just huffed out a laugh. “Yeah, that makes sense,” he said, looking back out into the dark lawn before turning to look at Steve again. He seemed to be choosing his words carefully. “You know… you really take that whole ‘babysitter’ thing seriously, huh?”

“Yeah, I guess,” Steve huffed, wincing a little when he realized just how lame he sounded. “I mean—”

“No, it’s cool,” Billy cut in now, grinning, “I mean, I wish I knew what your rates were before I agreed to watch Max on Sunday, but—” he laughed when Steve shoved him in the shoulder, moving with it easily and turning his back on the wall.

They shot the shit for while after that; Billy lighting up another cigarette (this time refusing to give Steve a drag when he inevitably begged for it again), and the both of them seemingly not noticing the bracing air around them steadily dropping in temperature as the night wore on. It was easier, talking out here one on one than being inside, even if there were more people. He kind of felt burnt out and standing outside talking to Billy was surprisingly the balm he needed after being exposed for too long around his classmates. At one point it really got frigid, and they headed back inside, but they stayed together rather than splitting up like they had done earlier, to which Steve was grateful. He had about a cup and a half more of the mystery punch before he called it quits, stomach churning uncomfortably towards the end of the night.

“You ready to go?” Billy clapped a hand on his shoulder, steadying Steve when he started wavering a little bit. He moved them easily past the front door, and out onto the lawn.

“I think I’m gonna puke,” Steve told him instead, and promptly swiveled around to throw up in the bushes by the walkway.

He heard Billy mutter a “Jesus Christ,” from just above his head, before a hand tentatively came down on his back and thumped it lightly. It helped him heave the last bit out, and he felt Billy’s fingers clench in the back of his shirt when he started to cant forward accidentally, nearly faceplanting himself right into where he’d puked. Billy hauled him up by his shirt a couple moments later, almost making him dizzy enough to go another round.

“Oh, no you don’t,” Billy said, catching the way his mouth twisted, “This is a no-puke zone. If you gotta ralph, you’re keeping that shit to the bushes.”

Steve breathed in through his nose and out through his mouth, willing the vertigo down. He felt better after puking, sure, but the spins were still messing with his head. “Huh?” he said, not sure if Billy was still saying something to him.

“C’mon, let’s go,’ Billy said, grabbing him by the shoulders and steering him towards the Camaro, “I’m taking you home. We’ll get your car later, there’s no way you can drive right now.”

He didn’t bother protesting, just let himself be manhandled in the direction of Billy’s car. He stumbled along valiantly, tripping over every other step when his feet got too clunky to move right. Billy kept him steady the whole way, though, not letting Steve veer off or hobble off the sidewalk like he kept trying to do. It felt like no time at all had passed between their first talk outside and Billy buckling him into the passenger seat, even though he knew that it had. He was out before Billy had even finished turning the key to the ignition, the instructions on how to get to his house dying on his lips as he dropped off into unconsciousness.

He came to a couple of times, like when they were turning on his street or when it was finally time to get out of the car. He was too far gone at that point, though, and could only moan in pain as his stomach jostled around and the spins came back in full force. Billy was by his side to help him out of the car, and he was so dizzy and nauseated that he didn’t even think twice about sinking his fingers into the soft sleeve of Billy’s jacket, holding on for dear life while the other boy got him up the porch steps. He was too far gone to even be embarrassed about the fact that he was stumbling around like a freshman who’d just drank for the first time, too focused on putting one foot in front of the other and making sure he didn’t flop face-down into the carpet by the front door.

The last clear memory he had was Billy helping him blearily stumble to the couch, making sure he was situated before gingerly unfolding a plaid fleece off the back of a nearby chair and draping it over him. He wanted to comment on it, maybe say thank you, maybe say how crazy it was that Billy was practically tucking him in, but it felt like his tongue had gotten glued to the roof of his mouth and he was already having a hard time cracking his eyes open, so he just drifted off without another word. Steve barely caught the sound of the front door shutting lightly behind Billy as he left, and his last thought was that he wished he could’ve stayed awake for it.

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“You’re acting weird,” Dustin narrowed his eyes across the table at him.

Steve scoffed, even though he knew Dustin was right. “Weird? How am I being weird?”

“Well, you’ve been cagey all week, we haven’t hung out in a while,” he listed, counting down his fingers. His eyes narrowed even further as he gestured to the sundae placed in front of him, “Plus, you got me ice cream. You never willingly put up with me on sugar if you don’t have to.”

“That’s not true!” Steve protested, “Do I have to have an ulterior motive to hang out?”

“No,” Dustin allowed, “But usually you do when you take me out to get ice cream. So spill,” he waved his spoon menacingly in his direction.

Steve sighed, running a hand through his hair. Dustin was actually right; he did have an ulterior motive for hanging out today. He thought he could take Dustin out for some sundaes, maybe sweeten the blow (literally), but apparently, he was completely transparent, which really wasn’t the shocker of the century. He’d never had a good poker face.

He spread his hands out in front of him, ignoring his own half-eaten cup of Stracciatella and bracing himself for what was sure to be a difficult conversation. “Well, you’re right,” he admitted, ignoring Dustin’s crow of satisfaction at being correct, “I kind of wanted to talk to you about the lacrosse thing.”

The “lacrosse thing” wasn’t really about the lacrosse thing, but more the fact that Billy was on the team. He still hadn’t told Dustin yet, even after all these weeks, and he figured it was about time to do so.

After the party two weeks ago, things had changed pretty drastically between him and Billy. It was like that had been the final hurdle to overcome; getting past those awkward—but necessary—apologies so they could actually be friends. Billy had swung by to pick him up the next morning so he could get his car, and while he didn’t bring up the whole you were so drunk I had to walk you to your door and tuck you in thing, he had lightly given him a hard time for not being able to handle his liquor. Steve had rolled his eyes, but agreed, and got them a greasy breakfast to make up for it.

Steve was pretty confident that that’s what they were now—friends. They were friends who smoked cigarettes under the bleachers, grabbed burgers at the diner sometimes after practice, and Billy had even taken to dropping by his lunch table a couple of days out of the week (much to Nancy’s consternation). It was wild to think of how last semester there was no way he would’ve willingly been in the same room as Billy—let alone hang out with him. But things had changed, and Steve found himself thankful that he had his own friend again; not anyone attached to the party, or a part of a couple. Just a friend that was Steve’s and Steve’s alone.

And Billy really wasn’t all that bad, once you got past the initial asshole-ness at least. He was pretty funny and was actually smart—smarter than Steve thought a jock would allow himself to be, if that made sense. But Billy was in mostly advanced classes, even shared a couple with Nancy where she begrudgingly admitted that Billy “wasn’t completely inept” which was basically glowing praise at that point.

Overall it felt like things were finally starting to pick up: he’d found a good routine with the lacrosse thing, he was sleeping through most nights without the paralyzing nightmares, and he was actually doing shit that a normal teenager would do. The only thing that was left… was telling Dustin.

He didn’t know why he’d put it off for so long, it wasn’t like Dustin was scary or anything… but he kind of was. The kid was full throttle, all the time. And Steve was about to tell him that not only was Billy on the lacrosse team that he’d been devoting most of his time to, but that they were also friends. Not just friendly, but like actual friends.

So here he was, sat there with Dustin after taking him to the freaking ice cream shop, because he was a coward that felt like he had to bribe a thirteen-year-old first before telling him the actual truth. It was pretty pathetic, but Steve was kind of used to that feeling by now.

“Steve?” Dustin prompted, shaking his head a little and sending his curls bouncing, “I’m wait—ing,”

He took a deep breath for fortification, folding his hands in front of him like it was Serious Business. Technically, it was. “You’re right, I’ve been acting weird. I’d rather just rip the band aid off now than drag this out any further, so here goes: Billy Hargrove is on my lacrosse team.”

There was a beat where they both just stared at each other. Dustin blinked back at him. “…Okay?”

“And we’re also… kind of… friends now. Well, not kind of. We actually are… like, friends, I mean.” He screwed his eyes shut, anticipating the blowback.

He was met with silence. When he opened his eyes, it was to see Dustin’s unimpressed face staring back across the table. “Is that it?” he asked wryly, “You made me wait for like ten minutes while you had a meltdown so you could tell me that you and Billy Hargrove are friends now?”

“Um… yes?” Steve responded weakly. “I kind of thought you’d be having a hard time with this, not gonna lie,” he watched Dustin cautiously, like he was waiting for him to say the jig was up and throw the rest of his sundae across the shop.

But Dustin just rolled his eyes. “Dude, Max told us forever ago that you and Billy were in the same league. Is that why you haven’t taken us to any of your games? Because I gotta say, that’s real messed up man. I’ve been looking forward to seeing you play for, like, ever, we even—”

“Dustin,” he cut him off with a hand, brows furrowing as he tried to process the last minute and a half. “Are you actually trying to tell me you’re cool with this? That there’s no freak-out I should be waiting for?”

“I mean, don’t get me wrong, it sucks that you kept it from me for this long, but I get it, I have the tendency to jump the gun,” Dustin shrugged casually, “Besides, Billy apologized like ages ago to Lucas. That’s old news.”

“He did?” Steve gaped back, completely at a loss. “When?”

Dustin gave him a look like he was being purposefully slow. “I don’t know, maybe two months ago—ish? You remember when we were at the arcade that one day for, like, ten hours? He gave us like a pound of quarters as a part of the apology.”

“Oh,” he said in surprise, leaning back in his seat and drumming his fingers as he thought it over. It made sense, since he had noticed that the kids hadn’t complained about Billy in a while, but he figured that was because Max was forcing him to be nice, or something. Billy apologizing was kind of surprising—but maybe not really, seeing as he’d just apologized to Steve, too. “Well, good then,” he finished lamely, still too caught up in the thought of Billy apologizing and the weird fluttery feeling that settled in his chest as a result.

“Yep,” Dustin said brightly, heedlessly not paying any mind to Steve’s internal emotional tidal wave, “So does that mean we can finally come to a game?”

He laughed easily, feeling looser and more at ease now that the heavy lifting was done, and he no longer felt like he had to watch every word he was saying. “Sure, whatever you want. I didn’t think you’d really care about it that much, though.”

Dustin looked at him like he’d grown another head. “Steve, you’re on the team, of course I care about it!”

He couldn’t help the warm grin that spread across his face, cheeks heating up in a happy sort of embarrassment, “Aw, buddy,”

“Plus I wanna see what it is that has you, like, completely absorbed all the time. Like, no offense, but I’m kind of struggling to understand what the big deal is.”

“Oh, shut up,” Steve flicked the wrapper for his plastic spoon in Dustin’s direction, too overwhelmed by the warm-fuzzies to actually feel annoyed, “Just wait and see.”

~

Like he said he would, Steve gave Dustin the time and date for their next scrimmage, on the stipulation that he wouldn’t have to pick him up beforehand. He was still kind of jittery before games, even though they’d been doing well so far, and didn’t want to add in the factor of stress that included driving a hyperactive Dustin right before the match. He’d chosen a game on a weekend where they didn’t have to travel, hoping that the home-field advantage would play in their favor again like it had last time. It wasn’t like he was nervous about losing in front of Dustin… more like he was afraid of losing in front of the entire Party. Especially when he knew Mike and Lucas would probably give him shit ‘til the cows came home.

He hadn’t really expected all the kids to come but knowing Dustin he was sure he had a part in it. While it felt insanely dorky having his own personal posse of middle schoolers to cheer him on, he also couldn’t help but grin when he returned the enthusiastic waves from the bleachers, pulling on his shoulder pads and gear.

Mike, Will, Lucas, and Dustin were all sat on the highest row on the wooden bleachers, taking up space and talking obnoxiously loud enough that he could see some parents throwing irritated glances their way. Steve didn’t care, though, even if it did kind of make him look pathetic. Yeah, maybe his parents weren’t here, but at least he had four people rooting for him in the stands, anyway. Max was separated from the pack, standing off to the side and talking to Billy, twin smirky-smiles on either of their faces. When Max caught Steve glancing over for, like, the thousandth time she rolled her eyes before shooing Billy away, sending him in Steve’s direction.

Billy jogged over to where he stood, knocking his shoulder lightly into Steve’s when he got close enough. “Hey,” he greeted, before sliding his eyes to the bleachers and jerking a chin in its direction, “You see your little cheerleaders on the top row?”

“I’m pretty sure at least one of those is for you,” Steve shot back, smirking at where Max had joined Lucas at the end of the row, sending one last wave their way. Billy rolled his eyes but returned a wave in her direction anyways.

“Yeah, I know,” he turned back to Steve, and he looked kind of fond—a look that really suited him, Steve thought. “She was on the girls’ field hockey team in California. Sucks that there’s not anything like that over here for her.”

“Damn, that does blow.” Steve frowned, looking to where Max sat and recognizing what was a longing expression on her face. “I’m sure she must miss it.”

“Oh, she absolutely does, but I’m pretty sure none of her teammates miss her,” Billy snickered, tightening the string on his crosse, “She was a little fucking tyrant out on the field back home—you thought Edwards checked hard?” he snorted, tying it off.

Coach called them over, and they joined where the rest of the guys had begun the huddle. Nerves weren’t running through the group like it had before the first game—they were at a handful games under their belt now and had won a majority of them, so everyone seemed a little more at ease than otherwise. It felt good to get a good rhythm going, knowing that the team was finally starting to come together as a cohesive unit. When they all took their positions on the field Steve no longer felt the unsteady cadence of his heart, but rather a calm surety that was a blanket to any lingering thoughts of trepidation.

Like they were feeding directly off each other, Billy and Steve were on fire the whole game. They’d really homed in on their nonverbal communication when it came to passing, and it always sent a little thrill down his spine to know that he could look up at any point in the game and find Billy in his direct line of sight—waiting for an opportunity where they could assist the other. It made the whole experience of the game headier, and he tried to manage his dopey smile around his mouthpiece.

They hadn’t stopped their Saturday training sessions—even though they were turning out to be mostly horsing around for a couple hours rather than actual practicing. He was reluctant to let go of those Saturdays; something like a silver lining he could always look forward to at the end of the week. It still felt like they were making a difference, though, spending so much time together that they were able to pass easily without glancing for longer than a couple seconds.

Things started to get a little messy during the second half—literally. Halfway through the third quarter it had started drizzling, which didn’t stop them at all, but by the fourth quarter it was starting to come down more and more. It was heavy enough that everything was starting to go light grey, signs of a torrential downpour once the game was over. They kept playing through it, even though Steve could feel the clinging grit of mud and grass stuck to practically every part of his body. It felt like his concentration was doubled down, trying to keep an eye on the ball while keeping an eye out for any errant defenders, blinking away rain from his eyes in the middle of it all. He managed a couple of good passes by the time the game was finished, and while he was relieved that they had won (if only so he wouldn’t get shit from the kids), he was more thankful for the fact that he could strip out of his uniform and get clean.

Billy had the same idea, if the similar twist to his mouth at his uniform was any indication, and they herded the kids to the lobby of the rec center while they went and got changed. Steve usually opted for either leaving from practice directly or changing quickly in the locker rooms before heading out, so it took them a little longer to find the showers in the rec center. It wasn’t like he was uncomfortable, or anything, it was just that usually by the end of practice or a game the only thing he wanted to do was go home. Now, though, he had no qualms about pausing for a quick rinse, even if it was just standing under the hot spray long enough to get all the mud off of his body.

It was like a shocky form of déjà vu to see Billy in one of the stalls once he stripped out of his uniform. Not that he should have been surprised—seeing as they had the same line of thought, but something about it still made him stumble in the doorway a little, only letting his eyes catch for about one second before he was looking down again, hoping against hope that his face wasn’t about to go as red as he thought it was.

He didn’t even know why he was acting so weird all of a sudden, just that the stark image of Billy Hargrove in the showers seemed to stop him in his tracks, making his chest feel tight and like he was having trouble swallowing. Maybe he could’ve pinned it on a nervous association with the last time he’d been in the showers with Billy—but it wasn’t like that time was exactly traumatizing either. The lingering memory that had followed him even after all these months still wasn’t the teasing or the name calling—anything definitively negative—but rather the warm smack of Billy’s hand against his back as he'd been leaving. He shivered, like he felt the phantom pressure again. If Billy did that again this time he might just die—spontaneously combust on the spot—and he knew it for a fact without even questioning why.

He would’ve gone to a cubicle in the far corner, or just turned on his heel and bypassed the shower entirely to wait for it to clear out a little, but like a magnet Billy’s eyes met his across the room, and suddenly he had to make a decision then and there. It felt like it would look insane if he just made eye contact and then walked out of the room—or maybe that was just how his mind was justifying it—and the reasoning was enough to have him taking a deep breath and heading for Billy’s direction, hyping himself up the entire walk over like they were about to go out onto the field again.

Steve sidled up into the cubicle next to Billy, shooting him a grin that was hopefully casual enough to hide the fact that it felt like his heart was about to beat out of his chest. Why weren’t they talking? Should they be talking? Or was that weird? It was like he’d never showered in gym class before, and he was so focused on trying to figure out what was weird or not that he was starting to get a headache.

“So,” Billy’s voice said under the spray, startling him from his paranoid haze, “The kids wanna go to the diner, right?”

“Uh, yeah,” Steve grasped onto that like a safety net, thankful to have any sort of talking point occupy the otherwise silent space, “There’s one near the high school they like to go to. Are you coming?” the question tumbled out of him suddenly, and as abruptly as it came, he was hit with the realization that if Billy had any other plans he was probably gonna be really fucking disappointed.

But rather than shooting him down immediately, Billy went a little pink instead; the color trailing from his cheeks and his neck down to the top of his chest—and Steve had to suddenly avert his eyes upwards, wondering why they had even strayed down that far. The rueful twist of Billy’s mouth caught his eyes, pinning them to where his naturally ruddy lips quirked. “You think I’m allowed to?” he asked, not mockingly but almost shyly—like he was unsure even asking it.

“Of course you are,” Steve said easily without a second thought, only mulling it over in his head a moment later before still deciding that yeah—the kids would probably be okay with it. Dustin just told him that Billy had basically bribed them a couple of months ago. Besides, if anyone had anything to say about it, they’d just have to deal with Steve first.

Billy gave him a small smile. “Cool.”

Steve smiled back, “Cool.”

It took Steve a couple seconds to tune into the fact that they were just standing there, looking at each other in the middle of the showers. With… well, everything hanging out. Like they’d both come to the same realization, Billy jerked back into his movements abruptly, scrubbing down his chest to clear away the last of the mud flecks. Steve snapped his eyes away from the sight, hurriedly washing himself down before the water went cold and he was left shivering.

Like some twisted game of tug-of-war, he found himself battling the urge to sneak peeks at Billy, immediately shot down every time by his hindbrain telling him don’t do that, he’s gonna catch you, and then he’d end up thinking, well what is there to catch? And then the cycle would start all over again. It wasn’t like he hadn’t seen Billy in the showers before, or anything, so why did it feel so brand new this time? Why was he having such a hard time keeping his eyes from straying, from catching the way the water droplets sluiced down Billy’s broad chest and his biceps—and yep, Steve began scrubbing his body with a renewed vigor as he tried to get himself under control.

It was like things were tense, but they weren’t. Like, Steve could definitely say that the air had changed in the locker room, but he couldn’t pinpoint how. There wasn’t any tension or animosity leaching off of Billy; in fact, he seemed like he was in a pretty good mood. So the only answer had to be that the awkwardness was coming from Steve, which absolutely made sense. He’d been acting weird since he walked into the locker room, and he couldn’t just chalk it all up to showering in an unfamiliar place for the first time. No, he was making things weird, and he couldn’t even pinpoint why. He was terrified Billy might notice, might call him out on how strange he was being, but instead Billy shot him another smile as they left, sending Steve into another tailspin. By the time they made it back out to the kids in the lobby, Steve was determined to put the last ten minutes behind him, confusing as it all had been.

It wasn’t hard to do so, seeing as the second they were in eyesight he was hit with an avalanche of noise; all of the kids trying to talk about the game at once, while all trying to speak over the other at the same time. Steve ushered them outside to the awning over the entrance, sending an apologetic grin on the way out to the disgruntled receptionist who was eyeing them like she was seconds away from kicking them out herself.

From there on it was a matter of herding the kids into the cars, and while Steve had been afraid at first that no one was gonna want to ride in the Camaro, he was pleasantly surprised when both Lucas and Will decided to tag along with Max; leaving Mike and Dustin to gripe the entire ride over about some illegal use of a power up in their game. Distantly, Steve wished he was able to ride with Billy to the diner, anything to get rid of the whining filling up the space of the car.

Billy had beat him to the diner, no surprise there, and Steve pulled into the empty spot next to his car, crunching on the gravel in the lot. “Okay, out,” he shooed them, ears still ringing with the last ten minutes of Dustin screeching. The sooner they got in the diner and in a less enclosed space the better.

When they walked in, he spotted the others at a booth in the back. Billy was stretched comfortably on one end, arms crossed and rolling his eyes, while the kids sat on the other side of the booth. They seemed to be deep in discussion, if the way Lucas was practically leaning half his body across the table meant anything. While Lucas and Max seemed to be getting worked up, Billy was cool as a cucumber and tossing them grins in between what he was saying. Will was sat in the middle of all of them, wide brown eyes flicking back and forth between the three as they argued.

“What’s going on?” Dustin demanded, eyeing Billy distrustfully.

“Nothing,” Billy said, grinning brightly and easily. It was kind of a really good look. He glanced over to Steve and they made eye contact, a split second of something weird curling down his gut before the kids were interrupting again.

“Not nothing,” Lucas said, hands splayed out in front of him. “Only the fact that Hargrove has the worst opinions, like, ever.”

“You asked and I answered,” Billy shifted his eyes back over to him disinterestedly, knocking his head back like they’d been over this a thousand times, “It’s not my fault you don’t agree. That’s why they’re, y’know, opinions?”

“Agree about what?” Steve asked, slipping into the booth when Billy scooted out of it to let him pass, trying not to think too hard about that familiar whiff of cologne he got as he was inching by.

“He said his favorite character from X-Men was Shadowcat, and that Wolverine was overrated!” Lucas said heatedly, looking like it had personally offended him.

Steve, who had no knowledge of any of that whatsoever, just stared blankly back. “Since when did they start making animals superheroes?”

Lucas stared back at Steve, his top lip almost curling in disgust, the overdramatic dipshit, “Steve, I’m not even gonna dignify that with a response. Back to what we were talking about before, please.”

“You mean my super accurate X-Men opinions?” Billy raised his eyebrows innocuously, stirring the pot and looking like he was enjoying every minute of it. “Yeah, let’s get back to that.”

The way Dustin scoffed in response clued him in to how much of a big deal it apparently was. “Are you freaking kidding me? How can you even say that? How can you even believe it?”

Steve made eye contact with the waitress who was eyeing them warily across the diner, giving her his best apologetic smile as the volume escalated around him. He hoped desperately that Billy wouldn’t spur Dustin on any further—the kid genuinely never knew when to stop.

Billy, of course, chose to just make matters worse. With a shark-like grin on his face, he leaned forward and gleefully began counting on his fingers. “One: she’s got a badass fucking dragon as her sidekick. Two: she can phase her consciousness through time. Three: she phased the fucking space bullet through the planet and merged with it.” He leaned forward, a mischievous glint in his eyes, “And finally? She’s one of the only ones to kill your precious Wolverine in the comics.”

“What?” Mike sputtered from his spot next to Will, glancing furiously between them, “No she didn’t.”

“Yeah, she did,” Billy snarked back, temporarily taking his eyes off Dustin to level a look at Mike, “Enemy of the State, first issue. Phased her hands straight through his brain.”

There was an ensuing silence, in which Mike reeled back and looked like his entire world was ending. In fact, almost all of them looked like that, like Billy Hargrove one-upping them in knowledge about comic books was enough for some self-reflection. Steve fought the urge to snort at the over dramatics.

“I… I can’t believe this,” Dustin said, like he was in a state of shock.

“I told you guys not to talk to him about this,” Max interjected, rolling her eyes, “All he’s gonna do is piss you off.”

“Well, it worked,” Lucas remarked sourly, looking at Billy distrustfully like his opinion on comic books might have destroyed his character yet again. “Congrats on having, like, the worst taste on the planet.”

“Thanks, I appreciate it,” Billy grinned back, unabashed. “And hey—lemme know if you guys wanna get schooled again, I’m always down.”

Steve laughed when the boys dissolved into an incensed argument, riled up by Billy who only kept stoking the fire by keeping his easy smirk on his face—enjoying seeing all the kids get worked up. He let him have his fun for a little bit, only coming in to knock Billy’s shoulder when he started to get them really hyped, casting a wary glance at the waitress who was now purposefully pretending she didn’t see them.

“Quit it,” He said, turned towards Billy, “You see what you did?

“Boo-hoo,” Billy rolled his eyes back, effortlessly calling the avoidant waitress over their way with just a casual two-fingered wave, “I had to hear them talk about that shit for like twenty minutes. I deserve compensation for losing a couple brain cells on the way over.”

He gave a dry laugh, ignoring the kids’ token protests in the back, “Yeah, yeah, get in line, man.”

“I thought you liked our debates?” Dustin frowned, still hung up on the thread of conversation, “You said we always get super spirited.”

Steve opened his mouth to respond, elbowing Billy in the side when he heard a snicker to his right. He was saved making excuses by the appearance of the waitress, however, which he took as a much-needed distraction. By the time she was gone with their orders the kids had completely forgotten about Billy one-upping them on their superhero knowledge, already chattering and raising the volume level every other minute trying to speak over each other all at once.

“Jesus,” Billy said lowly next to him, surveying the table before turning to Steve with raised eyebrows, “This is what you put up with all the time?”

Steve shrugged. “You kind of get used to it after a while.”

Billy gave him a look of disbelief, followed by a snort. “Who’d a thunk it: King Steve, babysitter extraordinaire. Remind me to book you next time I need a Friday night free.”

Maybe he would’ve bristled at the comment in the past, especially if it had been coming from last semester, but the mischievous gleam in Billy’s eyes told him it was just some good old-fashioned riffing. Instead, this time around, he gave an easy grin and a casual shrug, “Please, like you’d be able to afford my rates.”

He dodged an elbow from Billy this time, sending a sheepish look Dustin’s way when he ended up mashing right next to him in the booth just to get away. The rest of the dinner was easy like that; bantering back and forth with Billy while the kids talked a mile a minute in the background.

While for the most part he figured it would go over fine, a part of him had been concerned about Billy joining them at the diner. Yeah, he was Steve’s friend, and yeah; he had made his apologies, but if the kids still felt uncomfortable or scared around him there was no way he was gonna keep hanging out with him. Not after what he and the kids had been through together. He was willing to admit that he was relieved, though, when it seemed like the kids didn’t mind him tagging along. Well, aside from the whole schooling-them-in-superheroes thing. Mike was still sending a periodic scowl his way, and Billy always made sure to send a shit-eating grin back.

It was there, surrounded by the chatter and the warmth of the bodies on either side of him, that Steve realized he was finally content. Whatever he’d been looking for with this lacrosse thing seemed to actually pan out the way he wanted it to; he was sleeping easier and longer every night, and it finally felt like he was here and present during his days. Like he wasn’t just going through the motions anymore, time passing like it was bleeding him dry. For the first time in probably a year or so he felt whole again, lit up from the inside by a warm light.

And who’d have thought that part of it would be because of Billy? Once again, I was crazy to see the comparison of last semester with to this one—going from avoiding Billy Hargrove at all costs to eating with him and the Party at the diner. And without any actual bloodshed, even. Although Mike still looked pretty disgruntled with Billy.

Either way, he was happy to finally let himself relax and scale back, watching the goings on around him with a small smile of satisfaction. A couple of times he caught some looks from Dustin, especially when he was talking to Billy, but it didn’t look suspicious or hostile, so he didn’t focus on it. Instead, he sunk into the conversation and let the chaos of the kids take up most of his attention. When it was time to go, he snatched the bill from the waitress before anyone else could, sending a threatening (or at least his interpretation of threatening) look Billy’s way when he tried to reach for his wallet.

It wasn’t only until after, when they were all meandering out, that he found himself dragging his feet a little. He didn’t know what for, but when Billy asked if he wanted a cigarette he accepted so fast it probably looked a little desperate. He just didn’t want the night to end yet, not when it’d been one of his best so far.

Billy seemed to be in the same mood. “So,” he asked after he lit both their cigarettes, looking to a point that was just over Steve’s shoulder, “You got any plans tonight? Other than carting the shitheads back home?”

He snorted, ashing off to the side. “Not really, unless you count channel-surfing on the couch as ‘plans’.” He tried not grimace after the words came out, not realizing how uncool he sounded until it was already too late.

But Billy didn’t seem to notice or care about the lack of a cool response, just flicked his own ash to the side before meeting Steve’s eyes, like he was determined. “You wanna hang?” he asked, “I’ve got a six-pack in my car and a blunt. We could do either, or both.”

“Seriously?” Steve blinked back, a little surprised. Before Billy could think he was refusing though, he was quick to say, “Yeah! Totally! I mean…” he coughed a little, trying to not to sound like an over-excited dork. “Yeah, that sounds cool.”

It seemed to make Billy relax, enough that he sent a tiny grin Steve’s way. “Okay. Cool. You wanna meet at the quarry?”

“Yeah, sounds good,” he said, practically biting his tongue in half so he wouldn’t say it’s a date at the end instinctually. The fact that those were the first words that popped into his head were concerning enough, let alone that he almost just said it out loud in front of Billy.

After they finished their cigarettes, they parted ways to drive the kids home; Billy with Max and Steve saddled with the rest of the Party. He let the sound of the boys yammering all at once wash over him, providing a particular brand of background noise that he’d been getting used to over the last couple of months. He didn’t bother pitching in or telling them to take the volume down; just settled into that relaxed mood he’d been in since the diner, mindlessly humming along to whatever was playing softly on the radio.

Suddenly he felt that pin-prick sensation, the kind you got when you could tell someone was looking at you without seeing it. He looked to the passenger seat, only to see Dustin staring back at him inquisitively.

“What?” he asked warily, one hand letting go of the wheel to hover near his head, “Is there something on my face?”

“No, no,” Dustin waved him off, still watching in that weird way. “Just pay attention to the road, would you?”

Steve barely suppressed a scoff, settling for rolling his eyes. “I was doing that, you dip…” he muttered, focusing back on the road.

It wasn’t until all the other guys were dropped off that he finally said something. Dustin’s gaze had been weighty the entire ride, and he was getting tired of having the kid staring at him out of the corner of his eye. “Can you stop staring at me, please?” he asked, not taking his eyes off the road pointedly. “Take a picture, it’ll last longer.”

“You really like Billy, huh?”

He nearly slammed on the brakes in the middle of the road, only just stopping himself in time. “Ex-cuse me?” he croaked, sending a furtive glance Dustin’s way as he corrected himself in the street. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

“Um, exactly what you think it does?” he answered, like Steve was the one acting crazy. “Like, I thought maybe you guys were just, like, cool with each other. But you guys are actually friends. Legitimately.”

“Oh, right,” he tried to get his heart rate back under control, not even sure when it had sped up in the first place. “Well, yeah, I guess so.” Guess so was somewhat of an understatement, even though he wasn’t about to admit that to Dustin or anything. It just seemed like bringing it up was like an open invitation to put his foot in his mouth.

“It’s cool!” Dustin was quick to assure, like he was trying to comfort him, misreading his discomfort, “I think it’s good. You don’t look so miserable anymore.”

He let out a scoff. “Miserable?”

Dustin didn’t relent at the tone, giving him a hard look. “Miserable, Steve. Like, so desolate we thought were gonna have to do an exorcism or something to get your soul back.”

“Okay, you guys really gotta lay off the horror movies,” he said dryly, giving him his own look back in response. “Seriously? It wasn’t that bad. Not, like, enough to warrant an exorcism, or whatever.”

“Yeah, but still,” Dustin waved off his over dramatics, already moving on, “It’s cool that you’re, you know—normal again.”

“Right. Well, thanks buddy.”

“And if that’s somehow a result of being friends with Billy Hargrove—” Dustin gave a fake shudder, “then I guess he must be pretty okay.”

There was a beat of silence. Steve’s cheeks were practically aching from how much he was grinning, cheesing it up. Before he could say anything, Dustin rolled his eyes. “Shut up. Whatever you’re gonna say: keep it to yourself.”

“Okay, okay!” he promised, holding up a palm. “Thanks for just being so sweet, Dusty.” He held the open palm up in defense when Dustin tried swatting at him, keeping one hand on the wheel while he tried to fight off his advances. “Alright, cool it, I’m not trying to have us crash into a ditch, or anything.”

“Anyway, what I was trying to say before you regressed to age ten,” Dustin sniffed scathingly, “Was that I’m happy for you, even if it’s at the expense of liking Billy Hargrove.”

“He’s really not all that bad,” Steve rolled his eyes, shooting Dustin a quick look, “I know he pissed you off with the superhero thing, or whatever, but—”

“Irrelevant,” Dustin waved a hand, “And yeah, I know, I know, Billy’s like the coolest thing since sliced bread and now you’re obsessed with him.”

This time Steve did swerve in the street, Dustin yelping as he narrowly avoided a mailbox when it came directly into his line of sight. He corrected the wheel again, heart racing, and ignored the look Dustin was casting him out of the corner of his eye. “Very funny,” he bit out, trying to get his voice sounding normal.

Dustin had caught onto his weirdness, though, if his narrowed eyes were anything to go by. “What was that about? You know I was joking, right?”

“Duh, of course,” Steve said hastily, aware that he really just sounded overly defensive at this point. “Just forget it. My hands slipped.”

“No they didn’t,” Dustin wrinkled his brow, “they were gripping it and then you totally spazzed—"

“Dustin,” he said; half out of desperation, the other half trying to convey just exactly how much he wanted the subject to be dropped.

“O-kay, weirdo.” Dustin replied, rolling his eyes. “You sure you didn’t get hit in the head or anything? You know, again?”

Steve sighed, relieved at the sight of Dustin’s street coming up. He flicked on his turn signal, pointedly looking away and making a show of scoffing and rolling his eyes. “Har-har,” he said, finally turning to face Dustin as they crawled up to the curb in front of his house. He still heard the rush of his rapid pulse, but he kept his voice as casual as possible. “Now scram, man.”

Dustin seemed content to drop it there, thank God, scurrying out of the car with an overly-enthusiastic wave, almost completely wiping out on his porch steps when he scrambled up too quickly. Steve kept the cardboard smile up on his face the entire time, waving stiffly while he tried to calm his heart rate.

Part of him was chomping at the bit to analyze just why exactly Dustin’s words got to him, the other part (and the larger one) was telling him to just not think about it for now. No use working himself up over something that probably didn’t mean anything. Especially when he was supposed to go hang out with Billy later; he had the irrational fear that if he somehow kept thinking about it Billy would be able to tell, would be able to sniff out the weirdness from a mile away.

So instead he threw his car into park in his driveway, climbing up the steps and whistling as if he wasn’t trying to stave off some kind of episode. The next couple of hours passed by in a combination of nervous anticipation, and false bravado that he had to keep reminding himself to put on in order to fend off the anxious thoughts. The last hour he’d been messing with his hair, too; at first just little touch-ups here and there, before it catapulted into him painstakingly separating the sections of his hair, trying to achieve some sort of even combination of cool and casual.

He didn’t know why he was freaking out about his hair, didn’t know why he was primping like this was supposed to be a date or something, but it was like once he started, he was unable to stop. He reasoned to himself that there was nothing wrong with wanting to look good, and if it just so happened that Billy was the only one to see the fruit of his labors, well, that was just something to add to the list of things to unpack later. He kept his eyes glued to the clock on his bedside table, waiting up until it was 10:50 to go, forcing himself not to leave a second earlier. It’d take like fifteen minutes to get to the quarry, and he didn’t wanna show up like on the dot, not that five minutes late was really all that better—but at least it didn’t seem like he was counting down the minutes until they could hang out. Even though he kind of had been.

His palms were a little clammy, and he felt like a total wreck wiping them down on the thighs of his jeans as he drove. The nerves from before returned in full force; only this time they were tinged with a giddy restlessness that had him cutting corners a little sharper and rolling through some stop signs, not even fully pressing down on the brake. When he got to the quarry Billy’s car was already there, and he let himself have exactly three seconds to let out a series of nervous breaths before he shut his mouth and opened the door, grateful for the brace of cold air against his warm cheeks.

 “Well I’ll be damned,” Billy drawled from where he was leaned up against the Camaro—Steve fought back a shiver, “Who knew the way to get Steve Harrington out of the house was a six pack and some weed?”

“Yeah, what can I say, I’m a simple guy,” Steve replied breezily, like he was still cool as a cucumber. Billy leaned up against his car like that, at that angle, with that shirt—it was all kind of messing with his head. It felt like a fight to stay in the moment and not let his mind wander off. “So, which one you wanna do first?”

Billy leaned back over his shoulder to grab the case of beers from where they were perched on the hood. He took one out and tossed it to Steve. “Let’s drink first. Makes the shitty Hawkins weed go down smoother.”

He popped open the tab, holding it out so it wouldn’t spray foam. “I’ll drink to that.”

After a couple of beers he was less nervous than he had been driving up; in fact he was so relaxed he was wondering why he’d even been freaking out in the first place. Hanging with Billy like this was easy—just as easy as practicing with him had been and going to the party as his plus one. He didn’t know why he got in his head so much around Billy, and was feeling like kind of an idiot for making such a big deal out of it in the first place. Then, they smoked the blunt.

It had been a bit since Steve had smoked, so his tolerance was mostly shot. That combined with the fact that Billy forced them to go into his car to smoke it—rolling up the windows and purposefully making them hotbox—and suddenly things were starting to feel different. Not bad different, like he was paranoid or scared or anything, but different like… he could swear he felt them both breathing in the car. Which, obviously they were, duh—but he felt it in a big, visceral way; like everything was magnified and was bouncing off the car’s interior like an echo.

Billy didn’t have any music playing in the background either, so when they would temporarily lapse into silence it felt that much more loaded, like Steve could feel every second that was passing in between them. Not only that, but the car had gotten so warm—a drastic comparison to outside where he’d been tugging his jacket closer to his chest. No, in Billy’s car everything felt so heated and intense.

“So, Steve,” Billy drew him out of his thoughts, a slow drawl that had a blush spreading across his cheeks, although he couldn’t figure out why. Maybe it was the fact that Billy was actually using his first name. Honestly, he was really just thankful that they were shrouded in darkness at the moment, didn’t need Billy to start wondering why his face was so goddamn red all the time. “Why did you really sign up for lacrosse?”

That hadn’t been what he was expecting. “Oh, I dunno,” he shrugged, feeling heavy in his own body, “Just wanted to try something new, I guess.”

He was met with silence. When he turned, Billy was facing his direction. It was still dark, but he could tell Billy had a look on his face. “What?” he asked defensively, shifting towards him.

“Oh, c’mon,” Billy cajoled, leaning closer. Steve could smell his cologne so clearly from here. He wondered why Billy had even bothered putting it on tonight. Then he thought about how his own hairspray was probably smelling up the car, too, and decided to drop the thought. “You’ve never wanted to play it before, so why now?” he drew Steve out of his thoughts abruptly.

“How do you know I’ve never wanted to play it before?” Steve countered, aware that he sounded like a little kid. The responding silence from Billy told him the same. After a beat he let out a sigh, looking out the window. “Fine. Yeah, you’re right. I didn’t really wanna play it before.”

“So?” Billy prompted, leaning even closer.

“So…so…,” Steve tried to find the words, before deciding to say fuck it. He felt warm, and light, and it didn’t feel like anything was weighing too heavily on him anymore. He was past the point of thinking Billy was gonna laugh in his face, or something. “So… I was having a pretty shitty year. And I felt like I wasn’t even there—like I was going through the motions. Everything became so routine it was like I wasn’t even present—like…like… I dunno man. Like I was just going through the motions. Every day.”

The silence that came this time was deafening. His heart started to race as the seconds continued on, already cursing himself internally for his big fucking mouth and how just one blunt made him spill everything like Billy was a diary, or something. His cheeks flamed in embarrassment, and he was close to just backtracking and saying fuck it, before Billy spoke up.

“Damn,” he said in the darkness, before continuing. “So you’re saying that… all in all, you’re just another brick in the wall?”

Steve let out an unattractive snort, grateful for Billy lightening the mood. “Shut the fuck up, man.”

They both gave a little laugh, before lapsing into silence again. Billy broke it once more, speaking up in the darkness. “Was it because of me?” he asked, in a quieter voice.

“What?” Steve asked, confused. “What do you mean?”

“You said you were having a shitty year,” Billy repeated, still quiet, “That was because of me, right?”

It was so outlandish it actually made him laugh out loud. That, and the weed was making him act like a doofus. Yeah, Billy hadn’t exactly been the highlight of last year, but he was far from being the reason why it was so shitty. “Trust me,” he said once he’d recovered, still chuckling a little bit, “You were not the reason why I’ve had a shitty year. You weren’t even in the top three, man—no offense.”

“Really?” Billy sounded skeptical, “I kind of thought beating your face in and stealing your crown would take the place.”

Steve shot him a look, certain that Billy could see it even if he really couldn’t. “Okay, first of all, you never stole my crown. It was already, like, on the ground and then you just so happened to pick it up—”

Billy snorted, “Nice analogy.”

He continued on like Billy had never interrupted. “Second, that wasn’t even the worst part of my night. Don’t get me wrong, it wasn’t the best part, but it also wasn’t the worst part.”

There was another snort from Billy’s end, this one disbelieving. “Yeah, sure, whatever you say.”

“Hey, I’m serious,” Steve said, looking Billy’s way even though he still couldn’t see his face. His tone brooked no room for an argument, and he felt like he could feel his pulse in his ears. “It wasn’t you. I swear. Alright?”

“Alright,” Billy replied—and if Steve didn’t know any better, he’d say that he almost sounded meek. “If you’re sure, I guess.”

“I’m sure,” he said firmly. Feeling the need to break up the tension a little more, he tried to joke, “You know I also got dumped last year too, right? Like I said, you weren’t the reason why it sucked.”

Billy gave out a laugh, and Steve felt successful in lessening the gloomy mood that had been beginning to grow in the car. “Yeah, yeah, alright. So, what, you just wanted something to do? Something that wasn’t a part of your routine?”

“Yeah, break up the monotony I guess.” He was kind of over talking about his issues, plus he was afraid just how much he was going to accidentally say, so he tried to change the subject. “What about you? Just wanted to show us hicks how a real city-slicker plays lacrosse?”

Billy broke out into a bray of laughter, one that was so startling he jumped a little, but then felt comfortable enough to join in. “Jesus, Harrington, never say the phrase ‘city-slicker’ again, I swear to God.” He let himself chuckle a little longer, Steve kind of reveling in making him laugh that hard and fruitlessly trying not to feel overly proud about it. “Yeah, I dunno, I guess so. Really just needed a reason to get out of the house.”

“Oh yeah?”

There was a sound of rustling fabric, like Billy was shrugging his shoulders. “Yeah. It’s a sport, so he can’t even get mad,” he ended it with a bitter scoff. It was kind of obvious that the “he” Billy was referring to was his dad, but he didn’t exactly sound very forthcoming about the information. He was being purposely reticent, and Steve decided to let him have it—wary of confronting him further and creating tension in the car again.

“Ah,” he said, searching for something lighthearted to say, internally cursing himself for asking Billy in the first place and ruining the good rapport they’d had going, “Lucky us then, I guess, huh? The team would be complete shit if it wasn’t for you.”

Even though he couldn’t fully see him, Steve was pretty positive that Billy had a smile on his face when he turned his head and said, “Yeah, I guess.”

He gave it a beat, before speaking up again. “All jokes aside, though, it’s cool you joined the team,” he cleared his throat a little, cheeks already starting to get hot again from what he was about to say next, feeling like he was about to dangerously show his cards, “I mean, not just because our team is better. But… y’know. Now we’re friends. And I didn’t think there was any possibility for that after last semester, so. Yeah.”

It still felt kind of dangerous to say they were friends out loud—not that he didn’t think they were, at this point, but more like he was afraid if he somehow spoke it into existence the something bad might happen. Jesus. He needed to get a grip; the weed was making him act so embarrassing.

Billy didn’t seem to care though, snorting, “That’s for fucking sure. Guess that’s the power of lacrosse, or some bullshit like that.”

Steve gave a laugh of his own, relieved that Billy didn’t call him out on being too sappy or something. “Yeah, I don’t know how a bunch of sweaty guys playing with balls made you stop hating me, but—”

“Hey,” Billy interrupted suddenly, “I never hated you, man. I mean… I can see how you thought that way—but I never hated you.”

“Really?” he asked, incredulous, “All the stuff in basketball… the stuff with the kids…”

Even in the dark he could tell Billy was rolling his eyes. “Okay, I still think it was weird as fuck that you were hiding my sister in the middle of the woods and lied to me about it,” he ignored Steve’s half-hearted squawk, already moving on, “But all the other stuff… like, that wasn’t me disliking you, man.”

“Then what was it?” he asked, leaning forward. He was tempted to switch on one of the interior lights, but it felt like the second they were out of the blanket of darkness Billy would clam up. It didn’t make sense to him how Billy could’ve been so antagonistic if he didn’t at least dislike Steve. Obviously now that he knew Billy more, he could understand that he didn’t hate him now, but that first semester he was pretty convinced he was holding the top spot of Billy’s shit list.

There was another pause of hesitation, and even through the haze of his high he could sense a reluctance on Billy’s part to clarify any further. Steve waited it out, though, desperately curious to hear Billy’s explanation.

Finally, it came. First Billy sighed, then he said, “It’s ‘cause you wouldn’t even look at me, man, unless I was messing with you.”

His mind went blank. All he could reply was a dumb, “Huh?”

Billy heaved another sigh, this one a little heavier, and Steve could hear the fabric of his denim jacket as he shifted around restlessly. “Like… you just didn’t care. I beat your fucking keg stand record and you just… fuckin’ stared at me. Like I wasn’t even worth your time. Then, it was the same in basketball. Your head was never in the game—you weren’t even taking any of the passes I gave you… I dunno. And then after… that night… it was back to the same. So, yeah. I thought I’d just leave you alone after that, since I was pretty sure you hated me by then.”

Steve blinked, taken aback. His mouth opened and closed uselessly, too stunned to speak.

There was a nervous laugh on Billy’s end. “Listen, forget I just said that alright? The blunt just had me saying—”

“It wasn’t because of you,” Steve cut in, determined to set the record straight. “I was already like that beforehand. It wasn’t—it wasn’t me purposefully trying to ignore you, or something.”

“Really?” Billy asked, sounding skeptical.

Steve nodded firmly, even though Billy really couldn’t see him. “Yes. Yeah, I mean—I was that way with everyone, dude. And that was before you even came to town.”

Having the words flow out of his mouth made Steve take a second—because yeah, it was true. Even though he had been trying to blame it on the shit that happened in November, it really had begun long before that. Maybe it was because he was still with Nancy, so he was able to lie to himself better, but the truth was: he hadn’t been okay for a while. It was easy to pin everything on being a recent development—but maybe it was because he’d been going in motion for so long that when he finally came to a stop, it all seemed to pile on at once.

“I dunno,” Billy’s voice still sounded kind of small, disbelieving, “It really kind of seemed like I was—like some kind of annoying fly you couldn’t just swat away.” He gave a laugh at the end, but it still sounded a little forced, like maybe he was still trying to convince himself or something.

“No,” Steve insisted, adamant. “I swear, it wasn’t personal. I… didn’t know it came off like that. Sorry.” He frowned, looking down at his lap. He hadn’t thought he was acting like a dick or anything, but from Billy’s point of view, he could kind of see what he was talking about. Steve honestly thought people weren’t giving him any second thought and was surprised Billy had felt that way.

“Steve, don’t sweat it,” Billy said, somehow picking up on his quickly spiraling internalization, “Everything’s cool, now. Right?”

“Right,” he agreed immediately, thankful that Billy was giving him an out.

They both let the conversation peter out after that, neither of them sure how to continue or bring up something else without it being painfully obvious that they were trying to deflect onto less tense subjects. The resounding silence was starting to mess with Steve’s head a little bit; he’d always been a little on the paranoid side whenever he smoked, but now it felt like he was looking into everything. Whether it was the way the both of them were breathing too loudly, the way he could still feel the smoke curled around his throat, the natural body heat he swore he could feel radiating off of Billy… all of it felt like it was overwhelming, giving him sensory overload.

Oddly, Dustin’s words from earlier came ringing through his head: and now you’re obsessed with him, lingering around like it was on reverb. He didn’t know why it had bugged him so much, why he had taken it so strangely. But right now, in the car, it felt like he was starting to inch towards the explanation. And it was enough to get his palms clammy and his heart racing uncontrollably.

In that moment, he was absolutely positive that if he waited another second in the car, he was gonna do something stupid. He didn’t even know what it was gonna be (or maybe a small part of him did) but it was enough to have him abruptly scrabbling for the car door and throwing it open.

The alarm blared, startling them both. Billy cursed and started the ignition quickly, killing the noise before turning the car off again and getting out to face Steve. “What the hell, man?” he asked, breathless. He sounded more confused rather than angry, at least.

It felt like there was a lump the size of a boulder in his throat, and his mouth was dry. “Uh—I needed some more air,” he stuttered, trying and failing to will the flush from his cheeks.

“Right,” Billy looked at him like he was a crazy person, before giving a short little laugh and a shake of the head, “Jesus, man, nearly gave me a heart attack there.”

“Yeah, sorry,” he nervously laughed, aware that he was starting to act weird but no clue on how to stop it. Even having Billy just staring at him across the hood of the car had him feeling like he had to shift from foot to foot.

Billy squinted at him in the dark, still wary, and now starting to look a little unsure of himself. “Okay…” he trailed off, obviously still taken off guard by Steve’s abrupt departure. “Well, guess I’ll see you Monday, then.”

“Yeah, see you then,” Steve bleated out anxiously, giving a stilted little half wave before clambering over to the BMW and folding himself inside. He didn’t look up through the windshield at all, making himself busy by clicking his seatbelt and reversing out of the quarry, only glancing back when he was finally pulling away.

When he had made it out of the gravel road and back onto the street, he let out a deep breath. “What the fuck, you idiot,” he muttered, running a hand through his hair, and miserably taking the route back home, “Why did you do that?”

He felt utterly stupid unlocking the front door and letting himself in, not even bothering to kick off his shoes before he miserably threw himself face-down onto the couch. Without picking his head up, he grabbed a cushion and stuck it under his face, finally letting out the guttural frustrated scream that had been building in his chest the entire drive home.

Steve had a crush on Billy. It was the only thing that made sense, at this point.

Dustin’s words from earlier floated through his mind, and now you’re like obsessed with him, ringing through his brain clear as a bell. He didn’t know why it had taken him this damn long to figure it out, but a small part of him was also willing to admit that maybe he had known for a while, but it was much easier to just suppress and ignore like usual—when he knew it would make things easier. But if he was really being honest with himself—he had been noticing Billy for a while. In more ways than one.

Not just in the day to day stuff; like how Billy was closest to him out of all the guys in the league, or how he’d gotten Tommy and the other guys to quit ragging on Steve, or how even though Steve could tell that he really didn’t like Nancy he still kept sitting with them at lunch—just because that’s where Steve sat.

No, he’d noticed other things as well. Like how built Billy was, or how firm his biceps were, or how sometimes when he smiled directly at Steve, he felt like he had trouble breathing. He realized he’d been looking at Billy for a while, even before they had really become friends—thinking back to those random practice sessions where he’d get caught up in the feel or Billy’s muscles or the sight of his bare stomach when his jersey rode up. It had just been easier to pretend that he wasn’t having those thoughts, noticing those things, rather than looking at it head on. And wow, what a surprise, Steve had decided to ignore something instead of recognizing it. He’d felt like he’d made so much progress since last semester, and now here he was: completely circling back to square one.

When he was finished being melodramatic, he rolled over onto his back, looking up at the ceiling and trying to think of just where the night had gone wrong. It had started out fine—great, even—and then when they got to the car it felt like everything had just been upended. Suddenly it wasn’t as laid-back or easy as it had been before, and it’d felt like he hadn’t been able to catch his breath the entire time they were sat in there. He couldn’t even really blame it on the weed, even though it would’ve been easy to. No, this was all Steve, fucking it up all by himself.

And he really had fucked it up, hadn’t he? The look on Billy’s face after he had practically fled from the car, like he thought he was Public Enemy No. 1 or something. Not like Steve had hurt his feelings, or anything—but, basically like that. It was hard to reconcile that Steve could get Billy to look that way, that specific brand of disappointment. And that facial expression just kept flashing and flashing through his mind, like it was reminding him just how much he’d really screwed the pooch. It wasn’t that he had really wanted to leave; in fact, at that moment he had considered just saying fuck it and inviting Billy over back to his house. But the moment held on for too long, and he hesitated for even longer, and by the time he’d summed up the courage it felt like it was too late. He didn’t want things to end the way they had, all awkward and open-ended, and the whole ride back he felt like a bumbling fucking idiot for letting his nerves get the best of him.

Because that’s really what it was. Nerves. Every time he was around Billy nowadays it felt like everything was kicked into hyperdrive; his heart rate, his breathing, the level at which his hands fucking sweated—everything. And in that car, enclosed in that small space, he’d felt that heady feeling of impulsivity. That insane desire to just—cross the distance between them. In the only way he knew how. He dug the heels of his palms into his eyes, watching the stars burst out from behind the lids. He took a deep breath in and out as he tried to understand what he’d been intending.

Well, that was a lie. He knew what he had been about to do at that moment. But it was such a colossally fucking stupid idea he had gone on autopilot, removing himself from the situation before he could somehow make it worse. And kissing Billy, like he wanted to in that moment? That would’ve made things worse. So, so, so much worse. It was the smart move, right? Taking himself away before he could actually act on the idiotic thought running through his head? It all made sense when he mulled it over, but Billy’s disappointed expression from earlier also kept popping in between each thought, chipping away at his resolve, and making him doubt himself.

No, he’d done the right thing—no matter how much his traitor of a brain was trying to convince him otherwise. If Steve had done anything other than platonic he was sure Billy would’ve decked him, or called him something horrible, or whatever other nightmare scenario he could come up with. Either way it wouldn’t’ve ended well, and he was kidding himself if he thought otherwise. The best thing he could do now was just act like everything was normal—and if that meant shelving his little crush, then so be it.

It felt a little painful swallowing past the lump in his throat, but he knew that there wasn’t really any other options. The odds that Billy even liked him like that were absolutely slim to fucking none, and he wasn’t about to risk the best thing he’d had so far just because he couldn’t stop thinking of what it would be like to go on a date with Billy, hold hands with him, maybe kiss him—no, it was best to cut that train of thought off before it really got steam. Come Monday he would just pretend like everything was normal, completely hunky dory, even if that kind of gave him a sour taste in his mouth. He wasn’t willing to lose Billy, even if it meant that his heart ached just a little every day from the sight of him. He’d get used to it; he’d done it with Nancy, after all.

~

Everything was normal when Monday came around.

There was a few couple seconds in the morning, where Billy had kind of watched him nervously. Like he was afraid Steve was gonna bring up whatever had happened on Saturday night. But he kept his mouth shut and pretended like the night hadn’t ended awkwardly, and Billy caught the drift. Soon they were talking again like nothing was ever wrong in the first place—although there was a downward tick to Billy’s mouth that Steve had a hard time not focusing on. He told himself it wasn’t disappointment again—couldn’t be—because there was no way Billy could have been expecting anything different, right?

But at least things were back to ordinary, which was all he’d really wanted. He’d rather have Billy as a friend than nothing at all, and he was going to stick by that, even if it was a little hard to look at him in the hallways and at lunch. Since he’d come to terms with how he’d been feeling, it was like everything was tinted differently. Suddenly everything Billy said was funnier, his eyes were brighter, even his skin was warmer. Now that Steve was aware, it was like all the small details that he’d noticed before were big and bold now, framed in a technicolor that he hadn’t been able to really grasp or understand before. It was like the shrimp that Nancy had talked to him about when she was tutoring him in biology; only instead of seeing everything in a million different colors, it was like seeing Billy in a million different colors.

Practice was at least alright, since most of the time he was preoccupied with the drills Coach put them through. There was another moment of hesitation at the end, though, where it looked like Billy paused a little before walking with Steve back to their cars. It was silent most of the walk back to the parking lot, and Steve hated the awkward air that seemed to hover between them. He had no clue what to say, though, to make it any better, so when Billy just gave a wave and bounded off to his car, Steve could only watch him go with an unhappy lilt to his mouth.

“Harrington!” Someone called across the lot.

He spun from where he’d been watching the Camaro drive off, only stopping his face from grimacing at the last moment when he realized who it was. The guys from the country club, all leaned up against the bustle back of Carter’s dark blue Seville. He suppressed a sigh before reluctantly approaching, wearily taking in the sight of sailing shoes and expensive athletic duffels.

“Hey, guys,” he greeted when he was within earshot, hoping that the interaction would be wrapped up quickly, already dreading what they could possibly have to talk to him about. “What’s up?”

“Haven’t seen you around the club in a while,” Carter said easily, while the rest of his cronies hung back. “Where you been, man?”

Steve kept the wooden smile painted on his face. “Parents have been out of town, lately, haven’t had a reason.”

It was actually the truth; Steve only ever went to the country club when he was being practically dragged there by his parents, no amount of pool time or access to the tennis courts could convince him to come otherwise. Since they’d started leaving the country more and more over the last couple of years, he hadn’t really made an appearance. He didn’t think anyone had really noticed, but it seemed that Carter apparently had. Steve didn’t know why, but it kind of bothered him, set off that tiny voice in the back of his head that wondered why?

Carter’s eyes traveled over him, a cool indifference that made Steve a little uncomfortable. “Bummer,” he said, sounding anything but put out, “Maybe we’ll see you around soon? You’ll get tired of slumming it, eventually.”

“Right,” he replied back warily, not really understanding what he meant by the “slumming it” comment and not knowing how to respond in kind—but also not caring enough to ask him about it. Instead he just watched how all of Carter’s friends snickered and tittered around him like he wasn’t in on the joke, discomfited but trying not to broadcast it.

“See you around, then,” he said, still a little unsure. Carter just gave him one of those patented douchebag nods, and Steve fought the urge to roll his eyes in response. Instead, he turned back towards the BMW and set out for it, running the conversation over and over in his head and wondering why it felt like he was missing something.

When he pulled out of the parking lot they were still there, laughing now at something that was probably as stupid and stuck-up as the rest of them were. He decided to put it out of his mind, figured that whatever Carter was getting at really couldn’t have been as bad as he was starting to build it in his head.

He didn’t think about it until the next practice on Thursday when Carter stopped him again in the parking lot, just like earlier in the week. Only this time Billy was still with him, not having scurried off to his car yet. Things were a little better today than they had been on Tuesday, thank God, and Steve was hopeful that everything was shifting back to some semblance of normalcy that had been there before he’d had his… well, revelation.

Steve was just about to ask Billy if he wanted to eat at the diner afterwards—crush be damned—when he heard Carter call his name across the lot again. He shut his mouth and breathed a heavy sigh through his nose, trying not to look as put out as he felt. Billy looked downright tickled; just like every other time he caught Steve lacking on his patented Midwestern manners. He gave a broad sweeping gesture, lifting an eyebrow. Steve tossed him a glare before turning their way, resigned to his fate.

“You too, Hargrove,” Carter called out when only Steve came forward, and he exchanged a confused look over his shoulder with Billy as he began to follow.

“What’s up?” Steve asked, eyeing them. He was a couple paces ahead of Billy, who lingered behind a little bit. He didn’t blame him; Carter had never spoken to him at all outside of this conversation, and it was only because he was with Steve.

“Couple of the guys are going to Hawthorne’s big kegger on Friday. Heard some of the Hawkins’ crowd was gonna be there, too, you should come,” his eyes shifted over his shoulder to Billy, and there was something kind of off in the look of his eye, “Bring Hargrove, too. The more the merrier.”

Steve stared a second longer, feeling like there was something distinctly wrong that he just wasn’t getting. Still, he gave a non-committal, “Yeah, maybe,” before turning around and heading back, clearly broadcasting that he was done with the conversation.

Billy fell into step by his side as they walked to their cars. “So?” Billy asked, knocking their shoulders together, “Whaddya think?”

“I don’t know,” Steve said uncomfortably, resisting the urge to look over his shoulder to see if they were still watching them as they retreated, “They’re kind of dicks.”

“I’m kind of a dick,” Billy rolled his eyes, before continuing on, “Besides, parties over there have to be like trick-or-treating in rich neighborhoods, right?”

“Huh?”

Billy leaned up against his car, fixing Steve with an amused look. “You know; go to all the rich houses to get the king-size candy bars. I’m sure they’ve got better booze and better pot than the keggers in Hawkins’.”

“I mean, I guess,” Steve hedged, still not fully on board, “But do you really wanna hang out with them?”

Billy laughed. “Fuck no. Just ‘cause we’re going doesn’t mean we gotta hang out, or anything. C’mon, it’ll be fun. We don’t even have a game, so you really have no excuse.”

Steve didn’t want to go. He really really didn’t. But Billy looked like he really did, and he kept fixing Steve with those clear blue eyes—and he really never stood a chance. Not when it was this obvious he wanted to go. So he just swallowed down his doubts, that churning feeling in his gut, and sighed. “Alright, fine. But we’re taking my car, okay?”

“Yeah, yeah, whatever,” Billy waved him off, that familiar shark-like grin spreading across his face. Pleased as punch that he’d gotten his way. “See you tomorrow.”

He woke up the next morning with that same anxious feeling, the nerves churning his gut so bad he thought he might be sick. You’re acting stupid, he told himself when he got ready for school, what are you so scared about? What do you think is gonna happen? The truth was: he had no idea. He just had some kind of… vibe, or whatever. Carter hadn’t looked very friendly when he invited them; more like he was appraising. Trying to measure the value of Steve and the value of Billy, it felt like.

By the time the party came around the feeling had grown significantly—enough that he was wishing he’d just put his foot down and said no to Billy, just said something like let’s hang out instead. The just the two of us left unsaid.

But Billy wanted to go, and Billy was pulling into his driveway, so it was too late to back out. When he stepped out of his house he noticed that Billy was wearing that red shirt; the same one from the night at the Byers. Back then when he’d been staring at Billy’s chest, he’d convinced himself it was because he was sizing up the competition. Now he knew that it was because there was nothing more enticing than the sight of Billy in that shirt, only about three buttons at the bottom done up. No excuse to press two fingers to the middle of his chest tonight, unfortunately. He cleared his throat and busied himself with locking the door, trying to will his blush down before Billy could properly see it.

His cheeks flamed again, however, when Billy let out a low wolf whistle as he trudged down the steps. “Well, well, Harrington,” he drawled, “Who knew you cleaned up so nice?”

“Shut up,” he muttered, not looking Billy in the eye and moving to the driver’s side. Yeah, okay, so maybe he had dressed up a little bit, but it was only because he knew the type that was gonna be at the party. If by coincidence Billy saw him looking better than usual—well, that was just a twofer.

The drive was longer than usual; the party he was talking about was in a whole other county, the rich part of town that Carter and the rest of his ant trail lived too. It’d been a while since he’d been to one of these parties, and he was already dreading the fake smiles and awkward small talk that the night was sure to be full of. Billy next to him kind of helped with the nerves, but he still couldn’t shake that feeling.

Billy was in a great mood the whole ride over, messing with Steve’s radio and then mixtapes before settling for smoking a cigarette and blowing rings into the side of Steve’s face while he tried to drive and swat them away at the same time.

When they pulled up to the house, Billy let out another low whistle. When Steve looked over, he was staring up at the house with wide eyes. That was fair; Jimmy Hawthorne’s house was bigger than Steve’s, and that was saying something. Billy was probably right before, about the better booze and better pot thing, but Steve was still having a hard time with seeing how that outweighed everything else. They were about to willingly throw themselves into the lion’s den (if the lion’s den was filled with snotty, upper-class rich kids) and Billy didn’t seem to care at all. Maybe he didn’t know any better, but Steve kept a side eye out on the walk up the drive, trying to gauge just how packed it was gonna be with the number of cars piled out front.

The inside was massive, obviously, and when they finally got past the foyer it was easier to take a breath. Music was coming from, like, every angle and he was trying not to let it get to him even if it felt like everything was too loud and too much. Billy seemed to not know where at all to look, eyes following and tracking all the yuppies with poorly concealed disbelief; to be fair, not a lot of people were this well off in Hawkins’ and if you weren’t used to it then it kind of did seem like an exhibit at the zoo.

“C’mon,” he nudged Billy, trying to get them in the direction of those drinks, and maybe a safer corner.

They meandered around the party like that—finally locating a couple of the Hawkins’ crowd that also showed up. It was mostly the football players and cheerleaders, but they still stood there and talked for a bit, Steve finally beginning to unclench from his earlier anxious mood.

A couple drinks in, and he was feeling pretty good. They’d managed to avoid Carter and his crew, so far, and had both gotten enough drinks in them that he was slipping into that easy buzz, everything going a little numb while he let a lazy grin stretch across his face for most of the evening.

It was when Billy had to go to the bathroom that everything went downhill.

“I gotta drain the main vein,” Billy yelled at him over the music, laughing when Steve just scoffed at his choice of words, “Any idea where the bathroom is?”

“I think it’s upstairs,” Steve shouted back, trying not to slur too much, “I’m pretty sure I saw a line down the hallway, though.”

“Just great,” Billy huffed, rolling his eyes before heading in the direction of the staircase. Steve went to follow him, if at least to just talk to him while he stood in line but stopped in his tracks when he heard Carter’s distinct voice calling his name. God, he still wasn’t drunk enough for this.

It was too close for him to pretend like he hadn’t heard, so he just wiped the sour expression of his face and put on a placid smile, heading over to where Carter was hanging out in the kitchen, holding court. “Hey, man,” he said easily, like they hadn’t been purposefully trying to dodge him all night, “How’s it goin’?”

“Going good, can’t complain,” Carter replied, eyes sliding up and down his form. Steve fought the urge to fidget. Carter’s gaze was nothing like the one Billy had when they were in his driveway.

“Cool, cool,” he said breezily, already starting to take a step back, hoping against hope that this was where the conversation ended.

Only, of course it wasn’t. Instead, Carter stood up from where he’d been sat, walking up to him and shaking his head with a disbelieving smile on his face. “You enjoying the party?”

“Uh huh,” Steve replied, really trying not to slur his words now. It felt dangerous to show Carter just how drunk he was. “Thanks for the invite,” he added, trying to maybe appease Carter’s ego enough to get him off his back.

“Of course,” Carter replied magnanimously, like he was some benevolent ruler, or something. It was grating at Steve’s nerves. “Noticed that you haven’t ditched the riff-raff all night, though.”

“Excuse me?” it felt like things had come to an abrupt halt; like a record scratch in real time.

Instead of answering, Carter just shook his head with a condescending smile and continued on, “I don’t know how you do it, man,”

Steve stayed where he was, aware of all of Carter’s cronies’ eyes on him. “Do what?”

“Oh, c’mon, you know,” Carter leered at him, like they were in on something, “Your little charity work, or whatever. I wouldn’t have the patience for it. Honestly, it’s admirable.”

Despite the sinking feeling of dread dropping in his gut, he still firmly said back, “I have no clue what you’re talking about, man.”

This time Carter rolled his eyes, seemingly fed up with Steve’s “dumb” act. “I’m talking about Hargrove and your little pity party.”

Steve went cold. “My what?”

Carter shrugged, still looking unbothered. “Hey man, good for you for being nice. God knows there’s no way I’d be able to hang around that white-trash all day, you should—”

One moment Carter was talking, and then the next he was stumbling back, clutching his nose. Steve shook out his fingers afterwards, feeling the ache in his knuckles, and the white-hot zing of anger that was traveling from his chest to his throat. “Fuck you,” he spat out, turning to leave before he got more pissed off.

The second he turned his back, though, he went stumbling forward from a sharp shove. When he turned around, Carter was standing there, bloody nose and eyes blazing. “The fuck is your problem man,” he hissed, advancing closer, “I’m trying to help you out here, dipshit.”

“Oh yeah?” Steve stepped forward too, a hot rage taking over that he hadn’t experienced in a while, “And how is that?”

“Hang out with garbage too long and you’ll smell like shit too,” Carter stopped to sneer, even uglier than usual with his fucked-up nose, “But I guess it’s too late now. Why don’t you both go back to the run-down trailer park he lives in and—"

Without thinking, he shoved Carter back as hard as he could in the chest, sending him stumbling backwards and almost crashing into the table. All of his friends and the other partygoers in the nearby vicinity had stopped what they were doing, watching the two of them like they were waiting for blood to be drawn.

They didn’t have to wait too long; Carter was already charging him before he could even blink. But Steve’s feet were firmly planted—for once—and he wasn’t afraid to rush him back, eyes seeing red as he finally got fed up with Carter pushing him and pushing him and pushing him. He was holding up his own pretty well and managed to land a couple of right hooks that had Carter coming back and snarling for more. It felt manic and wild, and he couldn’t stop himself, no matter how hard he tried. What Carter said just kept repeating in his head and he just felt like he was burning up with anger, and the only solution was to pummel Carter’s face in.

One of Carter’s friends came out of the woodwork, fist raised like he was about to jump in. Before Steve could even try to defend himself, Billy appeared out of nowhere and grabbed his shoulders, drawing him forward before violently headbutting the guy, sending him groaning and stumbling backwards. It was enough to cause Steve and Carter to still, momentarily caught off guard by Billy… well, being Billy.

“We got a problem here?” Billy wheeled on Carter, a familiar dangerous glint in his eyes, seemingly not giving a shit at all that he’d just headbutted someone. Last time it was Steve on the other end of that look, and he was extremely grateful that it was directed at someone else this time.

Carter unclenched his fist where it had snatched Steve’s polo collar, flushing red and sending a scathing look his way. “How ‘bout you mind your own business, Hargrove.”

“How ‘bout you make me, Carter,” He stepped closer, before looking at where the rest of Carter’s friends were still gathered, a considerable distance further than they had been before, “Or are you too big of a pussy?”

“Fuck you, and fuck you,” he seethed, rounding on Steve. “Have fun with the bottom-feeders, you—”

Within seconds Billy was pulling Steve off of Carter, practically foaming at the mouth to get his hands on him again. But Billy was stronger, and practically hauled Steve away, still spitting and cursing, and still a little buzzed from the keg. The crowd that had gathered parted immediately for them, and when Billy got them out into the cold air it felt like he was finally able to take a breath of relief.

When he turned, he saw Billy staring at him, eyebrows raised sky high. “Wanna tell me what that was all about? Not that I’m not always down for a fight, but a little warning would’ve been nice.”

“Doesn’t matter,” Steve said, finally cataloguing all the tender parts of his face where Carter had been able to land some punches. His right eye socket felt like it was on fire, and when he went to touch it gingerly it sent a wave of fresh pain down his temple, “Fucking shit,”

“C’mon, let’s go, I’ll drive,” Billy held out his palm, wiggling it a little for the keys, “We’ll fix you up good as new, promise.”

“Yeah, alright,” Steve muttered, following behind Billy, and ignoring the twinge in his side that must have been from one of Carter’s stray hits.

He couldn’t help but stew on it the entire ride back, Billy for once keeping quiet and not trying to get a rise out of him. It just fucking made his blood boil; hearing Carter say that shit. He knew they were all stuck-up pieces of shit, but he didn’t think they’d sink that low. The assumption that the only reason he was Billy’s friend was because he felt sorry for him felt like an endless slap to the face; jarring him and making him more irritated by the second.

The car was silent except for the sounds of them breathing, and even then Steve could only really hear his controlled deep breaths in his ears, along with his rushing pulse. By the end of the ride he had calmed down a bit more and sobered up, and when Billy finally pulled into the gravel driveway he mostly just felt exhausted and drained, although there was still the waves of agitation that kept cropping up every time he remembered what Carter said.

It was kind of a strange sensation, walking up to his own house behind Billy as he led the way, unlocking the front door with Steve’s keys. It occurred to him that Billy had never actually been to his house, other than when he’d briefly stopped in to put a drunken Steve to sleep on the couch. That night they were hanging at the quarry he almost asked him to come, but he had still been reeling from his own revelation on his crush. At the time, he figured if it felt dangerous to sit next to Billy in his car, his house would be way worse. He was happy that Billy was here now, though, even if the circumstances were pretty shitty.

Billy tossed the keys onto the counter before pushing him lightly. “You got a bathroom in this mansion?” he asked.

“Yeah,” Steve replied, kind of dazed now that all the adrenaline had worn off, “Third door on the right.”

Instead of leaving, however, Billy just pushed him lightly again, gesturing towards the direction of the hallway. “C’mon, let’s get you patched up.”

He tried not to let the shock show as Billy herded him towards the bathroom, a little startled and trying to calm his racing heart at the prospect of Billy actually cleaning him up. One look in the mirror, though, and he understood why Billy thought he might need a hand.

“Jesus,” he muttered, leaning closer. Half of his face was gonna be bruised and swollen, that’s for sure. There were some scratches at the top of his cheekbone where Carter’s nails must have glanced off of him, and there was already blood pooling on his split lip.

Without prompt, Billy dug through the drawers before finally finding the first aid kit, gently tugging on Steve’s shoulder until he faced him.

Up this close, he could see all the freckles smattered across the bridge of Billy’s nose, such a faint brown that you could probably only see them in the summer. Or, if Billy’s standing right in front of you. He tried not to go cross eyed. Billy silently reached behind him, wetting a washcloth and wringing it before lightly dabbing at the cut under his eye.

It stung, and he’d probably be wincing a hell of a lot more, but he was too absorbed by the sight of Billy’s occupied face; eyes steady and focused like he was determined to get his task done. He was about an inch or so shorter, so Steve had to stare down at him. He let Billy gingerly wipe up the rest of the blood, eyes wide and almost holding his breath. He never knew he could be this delicate. Billy reached behind him again to wet one of the cotton balls with hydrogen peroxide.

“It’s probably gonna sting,” he said softly, paused with the cotton ball just inches from his face.

Steve didn’t have a good reply. His face felt hot, and it was like his brain short-circuited the moment Billy stepped forward. He was barely keeping his breathing under control, as it is. Instead of replying, he just dumbly nodded back, hoping Billy took it for an assent.

It did sting a little, making him wince and suck in a breath through his teeth while he tried not to flinch back. Billy was as delicate as possible with it, lightly dabbing at his cheekbone and taking care not to press down too hard. When he went to put the cotton ball on the counter, he reached for the washcloth again.

This time, he held it to Steve’s lips, where the split was, and there was about two whole seconds where he flicked his eyes up and caught Steve already staring at him. Abruptly, he cleared his throat and stepped back, placing the cloth in Steve’s hands. “Here,” he said gruffly, avoiding eye contact.

Steve took it before turning back around to face the mirror, assessing the damage. Not the worst he’s had, and the lip really wasn’t bleeding too much anymore. Still, he held it to the corner of his mouth for a minute before he looked up, catching eye contact with Billy again in the mirror. It was easier this way, instead of seeing the actual thing. Still made his heart thump in his chest too fast, but it was safer than having Billy’s electric eyes pinned on him and him alone.

“Got me good, huh?” he joked lightly, trying to break up the tension.

In the mirror, Billy rolled his eyes. “Yeah, hotshot. You guys were practically mauling each other. What was that all about, anyway?”

Steve swallowed past a lump in his throat. “Just Carter being an asshole.”

Billy’s eyes narrowed. “Carter’s always an asshole. What gives this time?”

“It’s nothing, alright?” Steve tried to insist, “Nothing important, anyway.”

There was a beat of silence before Billy finally spoke up again. This time, there was no confusion in his expression, just a stony set to his mouth and eyes. “It was about me, right? Carter was talking shit to you about me or something?”

“Billy—”

“What’d he say?” Billy looked resigned, now, like he already knew the answer and didn’t really need to ask, “Something about me being poor, or how I’m a shitty person, or maybe—”

“Stop,” Steve cut him off this time, spinning around so he was facing Billy again, “Don’t say that, okay? Just, you’re—you’re not a shitty person. So don’t say that. And the other stuff, who gives a fuck, okay? Carter’s a fucking spoiled douchebag, it doesn’t matter what he thinks.”

Billy just stared at him, eyes roaming over his face. Finally, he spoke up. “So… what, you just punched him then?”

“Well, yeah,” Steve shrugged helplessly, blood rushing in his ears. He couldn’t tell if Billy was mad or not, and it was fucking killing him not knowing where they stood. Suddenly he was beginning to feel like the world’s biggest idiot. “He had it coming.”

“I can take care of myself, you know,” Billy’s eyes were still locked on Steve’s face, evaluating, looking almost confused, “I don’t need King Steve to step in like some knight in shining armor.”

“I mean—I know that.” he replied, an embarrassed flush starting to spread from his cheeks to his ears, “But I had to, okay? I… just had to.”

There was a moment of silence between them once the words tumbled out of Steve’s mouth. Already his mind was going in about a hundred different directions, most of them trying to find a way to backtrack without it being too awkward. God, why did he say that? Why couldn’t he say something casual like “No problem,” or “No worries, man,” why did he have to say something so… sincere? Laying his cards out on the table around Billy felt dangerous on a normal day, why’d he have to do it when they’re about five inches away from each other in Steve’s guest bathroom?

Billy took a deep breath, still staring at Steve, and clenched his jaw. “I’m about to do something pretty stupid, so feel free to punch me afterwards.”

Steve scrunched his eyebrows, heart racing, “What do you mea—”

Before he even got the question out, Billy was leaning forward. The kiss was… the kiss was fucking shocking, honestly. His brain went offline for about three seconds, at first only able to focus on the dry press of Billy’s lips against his own. Before he could even move to reciprocate, Billy was stepping back, eyes wide and scared. His breaths were coming out heavy through his nose, and he looked like he was bracing for that punch.

Choosing to say fuck it and go with his gut, Steve rushed forward all at once, catching Billy’s forearms and tightly gripping them, hauling him back into his space. This time, it was Steve who started the kiss. And just like Steve, Billy completely froze at first. Steve was persistent, though, dead set on having this kiss he didn’t even know he was allowed to have—determined to make it last. It was heady and dizzying; spurred on even more when one of Billy’s hands came up to cup the side of his face, smoothly sliding it into his hair before gently tugging at the roots.

He hummed into the kiss, satisfied when Billy pressed further and he was able to lick just inside the seam of his lips, reveling in the strangely intoxicating combination of Marlboro Reds and whatever he’d been drinking that night. For a couple seconds the only sound in the bathroom was the soft-clicks and smack of their lips against the other; hushed—but it still felt deafening. Steve only pulled back when Billy pressed forward again; this time accidentally catching his split lip.

“Ouch,” he recoiled instinctively, reaching up to touch the tender part of his mouth. His lips felt warm and rubbed-raw, and when he pressed his fingers to the corner, they came back slightly damp with blood. He glanced back up.

Billy was staring back at him; eyes wide and lips parted. There was a concerned furrow between his brows, and he looked like he was holding his breath. Steve cleared his throat. “Um…” after not speaking so long it felt like he was practically screaming in the small bathroom, “You okay?”

“Me?” Billy breathed back, sounding small, “Are you? I just… kissed you.”

“I mean, yeah,” Steve said back, a little incredulous, “But you noticed the part where I kissed you back, right?”

“Right,” Billy replied, even though he shook his head. “Sorry. I just—I didn’t think you’d actually. Well.”

“Kiss back?” he asked, a grin starting to form at the edge of his lips. He’d never seen Billy look so thrown off before, and it was kind of endearing.

“Right,” Billy said again, eyes roving over his face. He must’ve seen something he liked in the expression, because his shoulders dropped some of the tension. “Well, that went better than expected, I guess.”

“You guess?” Steve asked in disbelief, letting a couple of laughs escape. He was riding high, nearly bordering on hysterical from how happy he was. It felt like they were in their own little bubble, and after that kiss he was feeling especially giddy. “As opposed to what, me punching you?”

“As if you actually could,” Billy shot back, grin starting to spread across his own face.

Steve scaled back a little, making a show of raising his brows. “Excuse you; didn’t you see me defending your honor earlier? I can throw a punch.”

Billy laughed breathlessly, tugging him closer again. “Yeah, you can.”

This time they both closed the distance, meeting in the middle with a clash of lips that was gentler than it had been before—mindful of Steve’s split lip this time. Steve pressed himself flush against the line of Billy’s body, reveling in the pure heat that radiated off of him and warmed Steve up from the outside and inside—almost giving him the shivers. They parted again after a couple minutes when they both needed to break for air, letting out small gasps that echoed off the bathroom tiles.

Steve cleared his throat a little, still not fully pulling back from where he’d been clutching Billy’s forearms. “So… you know I like you, right?”

Billy gave a light laugh, looking just as dopey as Steve felt. “Yeah, I kind of got that.”

“And you like me too,” Steve replied, not a question.

This time Billy rolled his eyes a little, raising them up to the ceiling before dropping them to Steve’s mouth and then back to his eyes. The corners of his mouth were upturned, and it made the tip of his nose scrunch up like a rabbit—knowledge Steve was definitely saving for later. “Obviously, Harrington.”

Steve pretended to pull back, “Oh, so it’s ‘Harrington’ now, huh? Maybe I should—”

“Shut up,” Billy groused good naturedly, tugging him back with his arms secure around Steve’s waist, “You’re such a fucking goober, oh my god—”

“Now I’m a goober?” he laughed, incredulous, “And the hits just keep on coming, huh?”

Now Billy made the move to push him back, “You know what, I don’t need this, especially from the King of Dorks—”

“Okay, okay, I’m done,” Steve laughed again, tugging him back. “No more teasing, promise.”

There was a beat of silence, before Billy spoke up again. “Can’t believe you kissed me back,” he said, shaking his head like he was in wonder, “Like, I really thought you were gonna deck me.”

“Are you kidding me?” Steve asked, disbelieving, “I was about to kiss you in your fucking car at the quarry. You should’ve done this a while ago.”

“At the quarry?” Billy squawked, really pulling back a couple of inches this time. The expression on his face would’ve read as outraged—if it weren’t for the grin on the edge of his lips and the mirth twinkling in his eyes, “You mean when you shot out like a bat outta hell?”

He rubbed the back of his neck sheepishly. “Alright, I’ll admit, not one of my finer moments,” he dropped the hand, reaching for Billy’s arm again, “But we still got here, didn’t we?”

The only way he could describe the expression on Billy’s face was fond, and the sight was so arresting he went a little breathless. “Yeah, we did.”

They stood like that for a couple more minutes, neither of them breaking the delicate silence; only the sounds of their mingled breaths resonating in the small room. He couldn’t help the borderline manic grin spread across his face, helpless to the overwhelming onslaught of warmth that was fighting its way out of his chest. Billy looked the same, if it was any consolation; cute pink blush spread over the bridge of his nose and the apples of his cheeks. He’d never seen Billy blush before, and the sight was just as intoxicating as he thought it would be. Billy’s smile was a little smaller, but no less bright—almost making Steve go crazy with the sight.

When they finally shuffled out of the bathroom towards the living room, Steve tentatively reached for Billy’s hand, interlocking their fingers. He watched nervously as Billy tensed; afraid that he was about to suddenly yank it back and yell gotcha! or pull the rug out from under his feet in some way. Instead, he was relieved when Billy tightened his own fingers after a moment, pausing before continuing to follow Steve down the hall. He didn’t know where they stood, or where they were supposed to go from there—but in that moment he was content to just revel in the fact that Billy felt the same way, trying to memorize the impression of their hands folded into each other.

~

Obviously, things were different after that. He’d been a little trepidatious the next day, still thinking that whatever had happened the night before was too good to be true and that he was about to have an unpleasant wake up call for sure. Billy immediately cleared all that away, though, when they met up for their usual “practice” that Saturday and he greeted Steve with an endearing chaste kiss on the mouth, trying to dart back quick enough so that Steve would miss his red cheeks.

Since then, he’d been riding pretty high. The days started blurring together again; this time in a good way. Not like how it’d been before, when it felt like he was trying to claw his way back to the surface; replaced instead with the steady satisfaction that he was finally in a good place. Like his days finally had worth, again.

The last game of the season went off without a hitch, securing them the win in what was a pretty close match; making the victory all the more sweeter. Steve didn’t even care when the younger guys went crazy and dumped the Gatorade on them, because Billy got drenched too and the sight of him looking like a drenched rat was enough to make his sides hurt from laughing.

They separated themselves from the team pretty quickly after they all made their goodbyes, the both of them giving half-hearted promises to meet up with the other guys soon—trading looks with each other that signaled how that absolutely was not gonna happen. Skipping a shower after the Gatorade thing was definitely a choice, but the prospect of getting to use his own shower with Billy? Yeah, he’d put up with feeling gross for the twenty-minute drive back.

“So,” Billy said, lacing their fingers over the dash and refusing to look Steve’s way when his cheeks while his cheeks went red, “Final thoughts on lacrosse? Was it worth it?”

“Oh, definitely,” Steve laughed, waiting until Billy looked at him before he tentatively pulled their hands up to his lips, kissing Billy’s knuckles and feeling his own cheeks heat up a little, “Was worth every minute.”

“Yeah, yeah,” Billy griped back, but he could see him biting down on a grin that was threatening to poke through. “So what’s the next sport, then? I was thinking about being a lifeguard this summer; maybe you wanna join the swim team?”

“Sorry, but I think I’m done with the intramurals for now,” he replied, “I think I could have a different reason to stop by the pool, though.”

Billy grinned back at him, quirking a brow. “Oh yeah?”

“Yeah,” Steve smiled back; and the both of them lapsed into an easy silence, hands still clasped together over the gear shift. He decided to just revel in the peace, deciding for once to just let himself stop thinking and feel content. The whole summer was stretched before them, and the possibilities felt exciting and endless. He let his grin stretch even wider when he glanced up at the rearview mirror: the crosse stick that Billy had stolen gently peaking out from the backseat, almost like a beacon.

Notes:

now let's all just pretend that s3 never happens and they move to california at the end of the summer, lmao

hope you guys enjoyed!