Chapter Text
H. A. R. —Those three letters are the reason Steve Harrington is stuck in a dorm room with Billy Hargrove. In retrospect, Steve probably should have guessed this was going to happen. He knew he and Billy got into the same college, he knew they were both staying on campus, he knew that those damn three letters had made his life impossible all of his senior year.
But, he didn't think out of the thousands of students, he would be sharing a dorm room with Billy Hargrove.
So, now, he has to deal with Billy Hargrove in all his glory. And look, maybe at the start of senior year that would have been the worst thing Steve could think of. But now? Now, he’s indifferent. The pros and cons are fairly balanced. The pro of being able to ogle the guy who may or may not have sparked his bisexuality crisis definitely is at the top of the list—okay, so maybe he’s more than indifferent.
“I thought you were going to Robin’s?” Billy asks, head still buried in his literature book as Steve walks through their dorm room door.
“I was, but she apparently forgot, which was awkward for everyone.” He replies, throwing his bag next to Billy’s feet under the desk and flopping on his bed. “I walked in on her going down on Heather Holloway.”
Billy barks out a laugh and finally looks up at Steve, “Heather owes me 50 bucks!”
Steve lifts his head to look at Billy, “You bet on her ruining my perfectly sin-free image of Robin?” He asks before dropping his head back on the pillow and staring up at the popcorn ceiling.
“No, I bet that she would be in Buckley’s bed before the end of the semester.”
Steve sighs and covers his eyes with his arm, “Winner winner chicken dinner.” He mumbles.
“Oh c’mon, you got to see two girls doing it—Isn’t that like, the hetero fantasy?” Billy questions, leaning forward and poking Steve’s foot with his pen.
“Not when it’s your, like, pseudo little sister.”
There’s a knock at the door, “Shotgun not.” Billy calls.
“You’re literally closer to the door.”
“I said shotgun, Harrington.”
Steve reluctantly rolls out of bed, flicking Billy’s ear as he passes him to the door. He opens it and sees Barbara Holland. She’s got her arms crossed over her chest, and a green face mask on.
“Harrington.” She says.
“Holland.”
“You got Bryce Shaw,”
Steve makes a face, “Sorry, what?”
“For the Valentine's Day Raffle. He’s your date.”
Oh fuck. Steve forgot he had signed up for that. To be fair, it was before winter break and he was most certainly wasted on a mixture of white claw and ‘ Carol’s Love Potion’ aka Carol dumbing every bottle of alcohol and bags of peaches into a massive tub and calling it punch. And, well, it was punch in a way, it felt like you’d be punched in the throat after your first sip.
But anyway, Steve was drunk and some pretty girl with big tits and green eyes touched his arm and said you should like so totally enter the raffle, like what if we get matched together, that’d be like soy funny!
And how could Steve say no to that? The argument was flawless .
But now he regrets it because, one, he didn’t get matched with Big-Tits-Green-Eyes Girl, and two, he got matched with Bryce Shaw. And like Steve doesn’t care that he’s a guy, Steve went through his whole sexuality crisis at eighteen, he’s twenty now and he knows he likes dick just as much as he likes cunt and that’s totally fine. But Bryce Shaw was just, a big No in his books. For so many reasons.
“Actually, I can’t.” He says, gripping the door frame causally. Well, trying to.
Barb wipes away some of the green goo sliding down her neck, “You can’t?” She questions suspiciously. “Why not?”
“I’m dating someone.” Steve blurts out.
Barb frowns up at him. She crosses her arms over her chest again and huffs. “Nancy never said you were dating.”
“Well, I don’t know about you, but I don’t normally go and run to my ex and let them know who I’m seeing.”
“Jesus,” she mutters “Well, who is she?”
“Why does it have to be a she?”
“So it’s a guy.”
“I didn’t say that.”
Her arms drop to her side and she stares up at the ceiling and groans. “I swear to god, Harrington, if you’re lying I’ll make your life a living hell.”
“Like you don’t already,” Steve says below a whisper.
“What was that?”
“Why would I lie?” He says louder.
Steve feels a hand touch the small of his back and slide around to land on his waist. A warm breath ghosts over his neck before a stubbly face is pressed into it.
“Everything okay, baby?” They rasp into his skin.
It’s Billy. Billy his friend. Billy his roommate. Billy who is not his boyfriend.
“You’re dating your roommate? God that’s so cliche, Steve.” Barb says.
“What’s it to you, Barbara?” Billy hums, moving to rest his chin on Steve’s shoulder to look at Barb.
“Steve signed up for the Valentine’s Day raffle and now he’s bailing.” She huffs.
Billy’s hand works its way under Steve’s shirt, his palm warm against his tummy. Steve feels his stomach dip, goosebumps running down his legs.
“Well, he’s taken. Find someone else.”
Barb looks down at her feet and sighs before looking back up at them, “Can you two at least come? We need the numbers. Please.” She very reluctantly begs.
“What’s in it for us?” Billy says. His hand hasn’t left Steve’s skin, instead now scratching at the hair that trails south.
Steve feels like he’s on fire. He can feel a chub starting to grow in his jeans and he really doesn’t want to have to deal with that while Barb is staring him down.
“There’s free drinks.”
“We’ll be there!” Billy exclaims, “Now, if you’ll excuse us, Barbara, Steve was just about to rail me into next Wednesday.”
Barb makes a gagging sound before walking off. Billy pulls away from Steve slightly, just enough to grab the door and pull it closed. Tugging at Steve’s sweater to move him out of the way.
Billy pats him on the back slightly and walks back to his desk, re-opening his textbook.
Steve watches him for a second, waiting for some type of explanation.
“Umm,” Steve prompts.
Billy looks up at him with raised brows, “Yeah?”
Yeah. That’s all he has to say? Steve’s blood is burning through his veins, heading further away from his brain.
“What was that?”
“What was what?”
“ Umm, the whole, boyfriend thing?”
“I was helping you out.” Billy shrugs, looking back down at his textbook.
He reaches for a highlighter and puts the top in his mouth to pull off the cap and highlight some text. He spits the cap onto the desk and Steve watches as it bounces off.
“You got Bryce Shaw, I was doing you a favor. Pretty sure the guy has herpes and if he doesn’t, he’s definitely a republican.”
“Sure bu-”
Billy cuts in, waving his uncapped highlighter at Steve, “And you know what’s worse than a republican with herpes, Harrington? A gay republican with herpes.”
Steve scrunches his nose, “I feel like that's homophobic somehow?”
“I’m gay, I’m allowed to say it.”
“Uh, I don’t think that's how th- y’know what , I don't care. So, what? We’re just gonna have to pretend to be some loved-up couple for the night?”
Billy shrugs again. “For free booze, could be worse.”
Steve’s not too sure if he agrees.
*
They’re walking down the footpath together, Billy watches Steve purposely avoid all the cracks in the concrete, tiptoeing over them like a child.
“We need to get our story straight,” Billy says, brushing his shoulder against Steve’s.
“Our story?”
“Yeah, on how we got together. Otherwise, people will know we’re lying.” Billy reasons. His hands wave out in front of him as he explains, “And we don’t want Holland to call you out on your bullshit.”
“My bullshit? This was your idea!” Steve exclaims, his hair flopping in front of his eyes when he turns his head.
“Dramatic much. Sheesh.” Billy teases.
He pokes at Steve’s side. Steve can feel the burn of Billy’s fingertips through his jacket.
“Fine. How did we?” Steve asks.
Billy reaches his arm up and hangs it over Steve’s shoulder, his other hand coming up to smack him on the chest.
“My vision is, you seduced me one night. Admitted you’ve had feelings for me since high school, and you make such sweet sweet love to me that I just can’t be without you.” Billy says in a serious voice but with a hint of a smile tugging on his lips.
Steve shoves him off and Billy laughs loudly as he stumbles off the path and onto the grass.
“You’re such a dick.”
Billy is still laughing slightly when he makes his way back onto the path. Steve looks at the crinkles around Billy’s eyes and how the blue looks so much brighter when he smiles, but he turns his head and focuses on the path before he can get caught staring.
“Okay. But seriously, I think we just say we got drunk one night and hooked up from there. Super easy and believable.” Billy says.
“Who says I’ve ever been drunk enough to hook up with you?”
Billy clutches at his chest dramatically, a wounded expression covering his features, “Ouch. That hurt, Stevie. You’re supposed to be my loving boyfriend.”
A sigh leaves Steve’s lips as he looks up at the cotton candy sky.
Steve thinks about this whole arrangement, Billy’s boots cracking against the pavement, the background music to his dilemma. He starts weighing up the pros and cons in his head.
He decides the cons are:
Barb could find out and make his life absolute hell.
Nancy might find out and they’ll have to have a discussion.
He does something too boyfriend-y and Billy no-homos him and applies for a new roommate (that’s a bit dramatic but this is the worst-case scenario).
And Bryce Shaw’s fraternity finds out he lied, meaning Steve can never show his face at another party.
He decides the pros are:
Free booze.
Not getting herpes from Bryce Shaw.
Not hearing Bryce Shaw rant about politics.
Hopefully, good music,
And—getting that warm fuzzy feeling and tingles on his skin when Billy touches him.
He pretends the last one isn’t there but decides the pros still outweigh the cons.
Somehow.
*
The party is in full swing by the time they get there. Steve can feel the bass from the music bouncing around his chest as he squeezes through the crowd to get to the booze in the kitchen.
He feels a hand on the small of his back, guiding him through the mass of people. It makes his spine tingle.
Billy’s hot breath hits the back of his neck before he speaks. “What’s your poison, Harrington?”
“Uh, vodka lemonade.”
“Of course.” Billy huffs and looks around the kitchen, over Steve’s shoulder.
Steve frowns, “What’s that supposed to mean?”
Steve could almost get whiplash from how fast Billy’s demeanor changes.
He leans forward, a well-practiced grin growing on his face. He ducks his head slightly, to nose along Steve’s jaw. One hand reaches up and cups the back of Steve’s neck, while the other slips into his back jeans pocket.
His humid breath covers Steve’s skin. Steve knows his cheeks are red, the color most likely trailing down his neck.
“Relax, sweetheart. Just messing with you.” Billy laughs a bit at the end and nips at Steve’s jawline.
Steve thinks he may actually be dead.
Billy slides his hand out of his pocket and gives it a quick pinch, soothing it with a few pats. “Someone is watching us, needed to put on a show.” He says, just below a whisper against the shell of Steve’s ear.
Steve clears his throat and finally moves his hands that have been hanging at his side the whole time. One reaches up to rest on his waist, the other going and catching his finger in one of Billy’s belt loops. He tugs him forward slightly, presses his thigh between Billy’s open stance.
“If I could get some warning next time, honey?” Steve rasps out, inches from Billy’s face.
He thinks he sees Billy’s composure drop for a second. Thinks he sees Billy’s eyes dart down to his lips and his thighs go rigid on either side of Steve’s. But he can’t be too sure.
“The show started the minute we walked in here, baby.” Billy hisses back, topping it off with a slight slap to Steve’s cheek.
He takes a step back and walks over towards the kitchen bench, pushing his way through anyone that doesn’t immediately step out of his way.
This is a bad idea, Steve thinks. This is not going to end well.
Steve doesn’t wait for Billy. He begins to track through the house, he knows it better than the back of his hand. Could walk through it blind drunk if he needed to—and he has needed to. On multiple occasions.
Steve hears someone calling him, a voice so soft and delicate he knows who it is straight away.
“Steve! Over here!” Nancy calls.
She’s sitting on the stained mold green couch tucked away against the corner of the room, huddled up against Jonathan, Barb on her other side. Steve knows if she was sober there’s no way she would be sitting on that thing. Steve’s seen the types of spillages that have soaked themselves into the worn material.
“Nance, Jon…” Steve smiles, “...Barbara.”
“Steven,” Barb replies, equally as unenthusiastic.
Nancy groans, “God, can you both just drop it for five minutes! I wanna have fuuuuun . Don’t want my two best friends being catty with each other and ruining the night.”
Barb rolls her eyes so hard Steve’s sure she saw her brain.
She huffs out a small ‘ fine’ and gets up, grabbing Nancy’s empty cup and walking towards the kitchen.
Steve feels a hand on the small of his back and someone presses a kiss on his cheek. He can see Nancy sober up at the sight.
Billy is at his side, pushing a vodka lemonade into his hand, while the other hand on the small of his back works its way under his clothing to press at his warm skin. Goosebumps cover the skin and Steve hopes Billy doesn’t notice.
“You ran off, pretty boy,” Billy says, loud enough for Nancy and Jonathan to hear.
The look Nancy is giving Steve is the same look she gave him when he said he thinks Dustin’s cat might be the reincarnation of his great aunt Greta. Wide eyes, crinkled forehead, pulled lips.
Steve tries to clear his throat and looks down at his drink and nods. He coughs.
“Sorry. Uh yeah, Nance called me over.” Steve looks up and turns his head to finally meet eyes with Billy.
Billy smiles with soft eyes, looking like a lovesick boyfriend, playing his part in this charade.
“Just gotta make it up to me later, baby.” Billy purrs.
He slides his hand over Steve’s skin, from his lower back to land on his hip. His other hand takes the opposite side. He pulls Steve closer to him, the red solo cup Steve’s still holding with his vodka lemonade awkwardly putting a wall between them. Steve feels like a deer caught in headlights.
Nancy makes no show in being subtle. “What the fuck, Steve.”
Billy doesn’t move, pushing his face into Steve’s neck as he turns his head to look back at a bewildered Nancy and Jonathan.
“Don’t fucking blow it.” Billy rasps into Steve’s skin, just low enough for only him to hear.
He takes a breath and lifts his cup to his lips, letting Billy push himself flush against Steve’s chest and reaches his other arm up to attach his slender hand into Billy’s shaggy hair. He pulls at the hair a little, thinks he hears a small gasp fall from Billy’s lips but he can’t be sure.
“Har -- Uh, Billy and I are dating," Steve says.
Billy is still pressed against his skin. He can feel him smile as those words fall from his mouth.
“Again. What the fuck, Steve?!” Nancy doesn’t give him a chance to respond, “Since when? You hate him! You’ve hated him since senior year! That’s-yo-” She keeps stuttering and staring at the two of them wrapped up in each other.
“...Nance.” Jonathan tries, putting an arm around her to calm her down.
“No! This makes no sense!”
Billy finally stops hiding against Steve and looks down at Nancy, not letting his hands fall from Steve’s hips.
“God, Wheeler, it’s not that crazy.” Billy laughs, “Look, it’s no big deal. We were drunk one night, fell into bed together, kept falling into bed together, then bada-bing-bada-boom, we’re dating.”
Nancy huffs, brows still pulled tight, “For how long?”
“Two months.” Billy says the same time Steve says, “a few weeks?”
Billy side-eyes Steve and lets out a little laugh, “Okay, officially dating then, yes, a few weeks. But -- the first time Steve bend me ov-”
“Okay!” Steve yells over Billy, “Two months, technically, a few weeks officially.”
Nancy still has that sour-faced expression as she looks up at them. Steve is worried that he’s about to be called out and they haven’t even been here for ten minutes.
“Why didn’t you tell me?” Nancy finally says. She’s frowning but it’s more sad than angry.
Steve is a terrible person. A terrible person that is lying to his friend all for what? Free beer? To live out some high school fantasy?
He shrugs, “Didn’t know how to tell you.” He settles on.
Nancy stands up in front of Steve and Billy’s hands tighten a little on his hips as she gets closer. She takes his face in her hands and gives him a sad smile.
“You can tell me anything, Steve.”
God, Steve is such an asshole.
Billy, ever the peacock in a room full of pigeons, interrupts their moment.
“Who wants to play beer pong. Couple verses couple?”
Jonathan stands up and pulls Nancy to his side as she still stares at Steve with this soft look.
“Alright,” He agrees.
Billy grabs Steve’s hand and pulls him along and Steve can’t help but think this was such a bad idea.
Chapter 2
Summary:
Check out the Fine Pairings Podcast to hear this fic!
Chapter Text
The most surreal thing has happened, the wonderful people at @finepairingspodcast have read my Harringrove fanfic on their podcast!
You can listen to the amazing podcast on Spotify and Apple podcasts. It’s so funny and truly a joy to listen to!
Also see more links to their social media here!
Thank you so much, it’s honestly the coolest thing that’s ever happened to me. And fingers crossed I can pump out the rest with your amazing suggestions!!
(let me show you what you're missing) paradise
