Chapter Text
Billy discovers Steve's biggest secret five months into their relationship.
It's not the monsters.
That one comes out before they're even together. It's not like it's a secret anymore anyway, not really, not now Billy's been through the MindFlayer and the goo monster and seen just how damn fucked up Hawkins really is. Steve figured that he deserved an explanation. Deserved to be helped through it. Deserved something more than the spiel from the guys in suits before they forced your signature on some terrifying non-disclosure agreement. So Steve tried. He sat by his bed in that damn creaky chair and started from the beginning. From Barb and the pool. He’d explained it all. And Billy listened and nodded and took it all in and then replied with a single, solitary, ‘Fuck’.
That made Steve laugh. Longer and harder and realer than he had in ages, with Billy joining in after a few seconds, both of them laughing until they were gasping for breath.
Until Billy’s laughter had started to sound more desperate, more hysterical, and Steve watched in horror as Billy sobbed openly in front of him. Desperate tears that wracked his body and had him tugging out handfuls of hair as he curled his aching body into a ball and just...broke.
So Steve held him while he shook and whispered reassurances and promises.
And helped him through that part too.
It's also not the hairspray.
Billy finds that the first morning he stays over.
After Steve finds out exactly what Billy's got waiting for him at home and a few things start to make sense, Steve offers him a place. A space. A guest room and a spare key for whenever he needs it.
Billy takes up the offer after only a week back at Cherry Lane, turning up on Steve's doorstep with a timid knock and a bruised cheek, asking if the offer still stands.
In the end he doesn't use the guest room.
Steve's can't face the hassle of sorting out fresh sheets, and his bed's big enough for two, anyway.
It all feels right when their hands meet under the covers, and their fingers entwine and Billy pulls him closer to whisper a 'thank you' against Steve's lips.
It feels even better when they wake pressed together, Steve's arms around Billy, their legs entangled and their lips barely inches apart.
By the time they're done kissing, Billy's hair is even more mussed from the pillows, but when he comes out of the bathroom, his curls have never looked better and when Steve presses another round of kisses into them, he recognises the scent of Farah Fawcett spray instantly.
It's not even the fact that, although he usually orders take out or heats up a frozen dinner, Steve can actually cook like a pro.
Steve saves that reveal for exactly one month after they get together.
A month in which Billy's been staying over more and more, a month in which kisses and hand holding has progressed into more heated territory, and ‘Hargrove’ has given way to ‘Billy’ and ‘Bill’ and, more often than not, ‘sweetheart, babyblue, Bee’.
And maybe it's dumb to celebrate a month anniversary. Maybe that's not even really a thing. Maybe Billy will freak out because it’s too much too soon.
But it's been the best month of Steve's life, and he’ll be damned if he’s not going to celebrate that feat, at least.
And it's worth all the mess, worth the round burn on his wrist when he misjudged a pan, worth the constant stream of bullshit, too soon, scare him off running through Steve’s head when he sees Billy’s stunned expression at the table laid with finest china and a pristine white cloth, a couple of bottles of expensive wine standing beside two crystal glasses.
It’s worth it when Billy takes his first bite of carbonara, lets out the kind of moan that goes straight to Steve’s dick and says, “Damn, baby- if I’d known you cook as well as you fuck, we’d’ve spent a lot more time in the kitchen.”
It’s worth it when they curl up together on the sofa, too full for anything more strenuous than an episode of Dynasty, and Billy turns to Steve with a fleck of sauce on his cheek and the most satisfied grin Steve’s ever seen, and plants a soft, chaste kiss on his lips before falling to sleep against his shoulder.
No.
The biggest secret is Steve’s damned stuffed toy. His little dog. The saggy, baggy bean filled sack of love that he’s had since he was tiny.
And, of course, Billy has to find it while he’s rooting around under the bed. Steve wants to kick himself for being so...enthusiastic when he ripped away Billy’s clothes earlier, because now Billy’s hunt for his missing shirt has turned into the ultimate embarrassment for Steve.
“Hey, uh Stevie?” Billy calls, holding the dog aloft and wiggling him in the air, “Didn’t know you had any pets.”
Steve can feel his blush grow, and he grins sheepishly,
"Oh, yeah that’s...that's Elvis.”
Billy’s cocky smile grows even more, "Elvis?"
"Yeah,” and Steve wants to kick himself again for letting that slip, “like, y'know, 'you ain't nothing but a hound dog'."
It's a terrible impression, but Steve curls his lip and thrusts his pelvis just right to get Billy licking his lips, and Steve thinks he might have got away with it.
Until Billy spoils it all with a snort and a ‘dork’ , so Steve reaches down to throw the now-found shirt at him,
"Shut up, man, I was like...five. It seemed cool."
Billy’s snort turns into a fond chuckle, "Oh yeah, so cool."
He slips the shirt on, leaving it unbuttoned, and makes Elvis pad all over the covers.
“So does this poor little guy live under the bed then? Or do you just boot him out to make room for me?”
Billy turns Elvis’ head to look up at Steve, ‘Don’t worry Steve, I like it down there, chasing all the dust bunnies and chewing on your crusty socks,’ Billy puts on some cute raspy Scooby Doo voice, and Steve bites down on his smile.
'And thanks for leaving those pornos there too. Got a real boner over those, ow-woo!'
Billy tips back his head in a howl, and Steve can’t fight the smile anymore but he reaches over to swat at Billy’s shoulder, “Don’t be gross,” he snatches Elvis back, resisting the urge to give him a quick hug before placing him down on the desk instead, “Elvis is innocent. Pure. To be kept away from you and your...corrupting influence.”
“You love my corruption,” Billy leers, all bedroom eyes and flicking tongue, “And you’re the one who wanted to try that thing with the ties and the-”
“Hey, yeah, no, no. NOT in front of Elvis,” Steve snatches the dog up again, pretending to cover his droopy ears, “He’s heard enough.”
Billy just laughs, “Oh, I bet this little pup heard more than enough back in the days of King Steve. God, the thing these button eyes have seen. He lost his innocence years ago Stevie, trust me, poor thing’s gonna need years of therapy to-”
“Alright, alright, I get it.” Steve huffs, “Anyway, you must have something too?" He steps over to sit beside Billy on the bed, "Some teddy or something? C’mon, who do you cuddle up to when I’m not around?"
Billy freezes at that, and Steve knows he’s hit a nerve, but before he can apologise, Billy’s sneering, "No way, I didn’t keep any of that sissy shit. Neil made me throw ‘em out. "
Steve looks at him. He can see the old Hargrove mask starting to slide back onto his face, and he reaches out a hand, slowly, to rest on Billy’s thigh.
"It's not sissy, Billy. It's...you were a kid. Kids can have teddies and stuff like that."
Billy’s defenses lower a inch, Steve can tell by the way his shoulders slump, but he’s still tense,
"I had 'em, I just. I don't have 'em now. 's fine, Stevie. It wasn’t... I had to grow up after Mom. That’s all. Dad... Neil, he told me he was proud of me for getting rid. He bought me a baseball glove and we played catch for hours that day.”
Billy’s smile is small, and pained, but it’s there. And though Steve hates Neil even more for now, he doesn’t want to taint what little bit of happiness Billy has been attaching to the memory. He lets the topic drop, but he also puts Elvis casually down onto Billy’s lap, making no comment when Billy picks the dog up and starts stroking its dingy fur.
***
It's later, when they're curled up in bed, after they've brushed their teeth and discarded their clothes again, making the most of a night when Steve’s parents are away and Billy had no curfew, no looming expectation to be home, no need to hold back and keep one eye on the clock.
It's after all of that, that Billy lets Steve in a little bit more,
"There was one toy I kept," he says into the darkness. "Bubbles. My...my mom got him for me."
"Yeah?" Steve asks. And that's all. He knows it’s best to wait. To leave the space open for Billy to continue. An invitation without expectation.
So Billy does,"He, uh, he was special, I guess. Slept with him every night. And, uh, when mom and dad...when they used to fight. I would, I would hide with him under the covers, pretend we were under the sea or something dumb like that."
Steve nods, not sure if Billy can even see him properly, but it's enough, Billy keeps talking,
"Neil found him after mom left. Said I needed to grow up. Get rid of my baby toys. That's what...it started the whole thing."
They're already close, but Steve moves even closer, sliding a hand along Billy's arm as he keeps talking,
"I couldn't. I couldn't get rid of him. Not with the others. So I hid him. Stuffed him right at the back of a drawer. And then I felt bad, thinking of him all sad and alone with my stinky socks so one night I went and got him out, cause I wanted...I wanted…"
He tenses up, and Steve can tell Billy’s struggling. That he can’t quite force himself to say the word, so Steve says it for him.
"A cuddle?"
"Yeah. But...uh. I fell asleep and didn't...I didn't put him back and...my Dad. He...he found him. He wasn't...he wasn't happy. I, uh, I guess you can imagine." Billy tries for a laugh, but it comes out choked.
He’s not crying, not quite, but Steve can tell from his voice and from the tremor in his hands that he's close.
So Steve wraps his arm around Billy and lets him be small, lets him curl his body around and hide his head in Steve's shoulder and just. Be.
It’s progress that Billy does. That he lets Steve feel the wetness against his skin while Steve stokes his back, fingers tracing idle patterns, drawing simple shapes- spirals, fluffy clouds, love hearts and figure eights- while Billy pulls himself back together.
It doesn’t take long. Billy soon lifting his head just enough to look at Steve with narrowing eyes,
"You drawing a damn dick and balls, Harrington?" he huffs, and Steve's laugh ruffles his curls as he finishes the shape he’d been tracing onto Billy’s bicep,
“Trust you to spot that one,” he grins, and Billy smirks back,
“Pervert.”
Steve laughs again, but there’s still a sadness lurking in Billy’s eyes, and Steve wishes he knew how to help. How to take it away."I am sorry about your toys, Bill. You know you didn't deserve that, right? You should’ve been allowed to be a kid. A little kid."
It’s something he’s trying. Reminding Billy that it’s nothing he did, that he’s not to blame for all the shit that happened. Sometimes it’s the big things, his mom leaving, Neil’s ‘lessons’, the MindFlayer. But often it’s simple, Moments like Billy getting antsy if they forget to do the washing up after dinner, or panicking if he turns up a few minutes late. Things Billy thinks of as normal reactions to situations that he hadn’t realised had hurt him until he had the space, the safety, to look back and process them.
Billy swallows and nods, "Yeah. Yeah. It's fine, Steve. Was a while ago, I'm not...I'm ok."
But Steve notices the way Billy’s hand reaches up his chest and brushes against his necklace. He doesn’t say anything, there’s no need to draw attention to it, but Steve knows what it means.
"You could always borrow Elvis, anytime. He gives good hugs,” Steve keeps his tone jokey, but he hopes Billy gets the meaning behind it. Anything he wants. Anything Steve can give him. At all. Anything that would help. It's his.
Billy responds with a small smile,
"Nah, baby. Don't need anyone else to hug. Got all I need with you."
And God, that makes Steve’s heart sing. He loves it. Loves hearing Billy letting himself be soft and sweet and...sappy. It took a while, took plenty of missteps and misunderstandings and slammed doors and angry tears and assertions of ‘not a fucking pussy, Harrington’.
And Steve understood.
But he kept trying. Kept presenting Billy with loving words and gentle touches aimed right at Billy’s armor and, bit by bit, he worked his way into the cracks of it and tugged until it fell away and set him free.
And Steve knows that while free means open, for Billy it also means vulnerable.
So he makes sure that Billy feels his happiness as he presses kisses into his curls,
“Yeah, you got me, babyblue. Forever and always, OK?”
Billy murmurs an agreement, and Steve kisses him again, thinking about a younger Billy, the kid who had to grow up so fast. Who had every single fucking comfort ripped away from him. Pictures him, all big blue eyes and angelic curls, clutching on to a cuddly...fish? Turtle?
"Hey, baby?" Steve murmurs, barely lifting his lips from Billy's curls, "What kinda animal was Bubbles?"
He can't believe he didn't ask it before, but he hadn't wanted to interrupt.
"A narwhal," Billy whispers, showing no sign that he thought it was an unusual question.
Steve cocks his head to the side. Knows he's doing that 'damn adorable puppy dog head tilt', as Billy calls it, but he can't help it, "What's a narwhal?"
"It’s a whale. With a big horn on its head."
Steve pauses for a minute. The name isn’t exactly familiar, but the description reminds him of something. His head is filled with an image, an illustration from a storybook or maybe a cartoon he watched as a kid, he’s not sure. He can’t shake the phrase, ‘the unicorn of the sea’.
"Oh, cool. Was he one from a book? Or a film or something?"
Billy pulls back a little, looking at him with confusion,
"No. What?" he shakes his head, "No, Stevie. Just a normal narwhal. I dunno why my mom liked 'em so much but she said it was her dream to see one some day."
Steve’s heart breaks at that, thinking of Billy’s mom telling little Billy all these fairytales. Stories to keep him smiling when she wasn’t around, a glimmer of hope for him to cling to, so he could think of her tracking down mythical creatures and adventuring to unknown lands, rather than the more likely truth of her settling down and starting another family. Letting Billy think that she’d been drawn away by the lure of the magical, instead of having to face that fact that a mother could just up and leave her own child.
And Billy’s smiling again, so Steve’s not going to bring him down,
"That's cute, my Nonna said she used to see fairies in her garden, right under the apple trees."
“Huh?” Billy’s brow is crinkled, and his eyes are doing that squinty thing they do when he’s trying to figure out how to marry Steve’s response up to the conversation they’d been having. Steve decides to help him along,
"Just...y'know, like your mom believing in narwhals. It's sweet."
He sees the moment it clicks for Billy, a furrowed brow giving way to twitching cheeks as Billy tries to suppress a grin,
"Steve. Stevie. Darlin’," he closes his eyes for a moment and then opens them to look right at Steve, “You know narwhals are real, right?"
And, oh, ok, it’s some kind of shared delusion. Billy inherited his mom’s curls and her love of the oceans and a belief in mythical creatures.
He tries to break the news gently, “No, baby, really, they’re... No they’re not.”
He can see Billy biting his cheek, face growing redder and eyes watering as he’s clearly trying to stifle a laugh. Progress, Steve thinks. Billy from before would’ve been laughing in his face. Would’ve called him an idiot, a moron, a stupid hick. Not even to be mean, but purely because he found it funny and had no reason to hide it. Billy now is at least trying not to do that, even if it’s taking him a lot of effort.
And maybe that’s why Steve doubles down on his argument, maybe that’s why he plays it up a bit. He wants to show Billy that he’s not hurt, that he can have fun with this. And anyway, he’s right.
"Billy, they're really not. They're like...unicorns or mermaids. Kids’ stories or whatever."
Billy shakes his head, having finally controlled his urge to laugh, "No offense Steve but, you’re not exactly a marine biologist."
“And you are?”
“I know more about it than you.” Billy puffs out his chest, and it’s not even an argument, because Steve knows he can win this one.
“Oh, ok then, Professor fucking… Ocean. Have you ever seen one?"
"Well. No." Billy admits, "They live at the North Pole or something."
Steve's grin grows wider. He’s got this in the bag, "Oh yeah, real convenient. Living with Santa and the reindeer, right? 'Cause, Bill, I've got some more bad news tonight."
Billy gives him a little shove, a gentle push at his shoulder, "Shut it. They're real. Definitely. I'm right. I'll fucking prove it."
And he wiggles backwards, away from Steve and- despite Steve’s protests- out of the covers, padding over to Steve's bookshelf.
Steve leans up on one arm, leaning over to flick on the lamp and watch as Billy stands scanning the books. It’s adorable, seeing him in the flannel pyjamas bottoms he borrowed from Steve after his own boxers got too messy. There’s something sweet about the way that the hems are about half an inch too long, bunching up over Billy’s bare feet, and Steve can’t help but look at the way the material pulls tightly around thick, muscular thighs.
He lets his gaze travel upwards, taking in the way Billy’s muscles flex as he stretches his arms to flick past old school books, pristine copies of Romeo and Juliet and Death of a Salesman, a few well worn Mad Libs books and a bundle of comics borrowed from Dustin and never returned.
"How do you not have an encyclopedi-aha!"
Billy reaches up onto his tiptoes and pulls down a thick, heavy hardback. Some huge 'Children's Encyclopedia' that Steve thinks must have been a gift from one of his many aunts or uncles.
Billy turns straight to the index, tongue poking out of the side of his mouth as he runs a finger down the pages, "L..M..ah, N...Na... Nar...there."
Steve can’t actually believe he’s still doing this, and he shakes his head and gets up too, shivering at the chill in the bedroom and quickly moving to stand behind Billy and wrap an arm around his waist, resting his chin on Billy's shoulder,
"Baaaby," he whined, just a little, "Come back to bed."
"No." Billy's still flicking back through the book, "Because I know I'm right."
"Yeah but I'm right here." Steve tries, his hand tracing a patch down Billy's bare chest, fingers skimming down across those divine abs. He rocks forward on his heels to press his crotch firmly against Billy's ass.
Billy hums, leaning back into Steve's hold, but his eyes never leave the book, and Steve’s about to move his hand lower, make his intentions even more obvious, when Billy gasps and spins around in his arms.
"Here! Look! Narwhal! 'A small toothed whale found along coasts and in rivers throughout the Arctic.' Hah. Real."
He holds the page up so that Steve can see, jabbing at the tiny text and accompanying picture, before slamming the book shut in triumph and dropping it onto Steve's desk with a slam.
"Knew it," he smirks, spinning around to grip Steve by the hips, "Told. You. So. Real."
He punctuates each word with a kiss across Steve's cheeks and nose, before dipping down to press another, more heated one against Steve's lips.
Steve smiles into it, tilting his head as Billy's mouth makes its way down his throat, "Ok, ok, baby. You were right."
"Damn right, I was right," Billy growls, "say it again."
Steve raises an amused eyebrow, "That does it for you? Really? Me admitting you were right about something."
"Fuck, yeah." Billy licks a stripe across Steve’s collarbone, “Music to my ears, darlin’”
So Steve says it again and again and again.
*****
