Chapter Text
The second Billy steps through the door to Upside Down Cupcakes, two things happen.
One, he notices that the place is covered in enough different pastel colors it makes him want to actively vomit all over it just to see if that might make it look better and two, he hears a guy say: "He asked me to give him a handy so I punched him in the dick and charged him five dollars," and he can't help but burst out laughing both because that's hilarious and because it's exactly the sort of thing he would have said himself.
But then he identifies the guy who said it and something in him falters in a way he doesn't think he's ever experienced before. Like this guy is so pretty the world stops dead just so Billy can stare at him and his ridiculously big, brown eyes and his thick, gorgeous brown hair.
But time, as it always does, quickly picks back up again. And this time it's when the curly-haired dorky guy standing next to Pretty Boy snort laughs so unashamedly and so fucking loudly it has Billy cringing even as Pretty Boy shakes his head.
Then Pretty Boy turns and looks at Billy and says, "Hello and welcome to Upside Down Cupcakes. What can I get for ya?" with this easy, lazy, sugary smile that has Billy fully snapping back to himself and matching that sugary smile with one of his own, though his is more meant to bite than to look sweet. And if the way Pretty Boy bites his lip on seeing it, Billy figures it must have worked.
So, feeling a bit more confident, he runs his hand through his hair, tries to pretend he doesn't at all feel gross or sticky or sweaty from Chicago's nasty, brutish attempt at something approaching summer and he saunters up to the counter.
"Hmmm…" he says, thinking. His eyes drift over to the large, glass display case to the right of the main counter and his mouth starts to water as his eyes rove over the rows and rows and rows of brightly colored, intricately designed little cupcakes in immaculate pastel paper liners.
He lifts his eyes from the cupcakes to look back at Pretty Boy, who, it would seem, is pretty proud of himself for the way Billy was looking at what Billy guesses must be his cupcakes. "I've got a friend's birthday party in a couple of hours, what kind of cupcakes do you have for that?" Billy asks.
Pretty Boy makes a face and tugs at a chain around his neck, unintentionally withdrawing a circular pendant from inside his sickeningly blue polo shirt. "Well…" he says. "We've got—" he keeps going but Billy doesn't hear him. He's too busy staring at that pendant, more specifically the colors making up the swirling metal bands of it. Black, purple, white, and gray. Billy knows those colors. Billy lives those colors. Billy is those colors.
But this guy can't be that perfect, can he? He can't possibly be those colors, too. He can't possibly be asexual like him. Billy's eyes almost bug out of his head at the thought of it. No. This guy can't be that perfect. He can't be. It's not possible.
The dorky guy, unfortunately, catches Billy staring at the necklace and mistakes the look on Billy's face for something malicious instead of something full of longing and starts scowling. He straightens up and folds his arms across his chest. "I know that look," he says, his voice going higher-pitched rather than lower, like most guys do when they're being threatening or trying to be. This guy, Billy thinks, probably hasn't been threatening a day in his life.
"What look?" Billy says, going for genuine confusion. (And it's not entirely a lie. He's not 100% sure what the guy is going for, exactly, much as it's obvious he doesn't like him.)
"We don't serve acephobes," the curly-haired dork says. Which... oh. Kay. Not at all where Billy thought this was going, but, it is at least a problem he can solve.
"Dustin…" Pretty Boy says, his tone very nearly almost resembling something that could be called a whine. Clearly, he's used to his friend's poorly implemented scare tactics and just as clearly tired of them.
"Look, kid—" Billy starts just as the swinging door to the kitchen bangs open, and a tall, thin brunette backs into the room carrying a tray of cupcakes that carry with them this deliciously thick, chocolatey scent that has Billy momentarily distracted from the issue at hand.
The woman puts the tray of cupcakes down on the sickeningly pale pink back counter before turning around to face the three of them. It takes her all of two seconds to pick up on the tense vibes and she squares her shoulders to match Dustin's. "What happened?" she says to Dustin even as she's glaring at Billy like she's picturing setting him on fire.
"Guys—" Pretty Boy says sharply, but whatever he's about to say next Billy cuts him off with a raised hand and a loud, "I'm ace, too." And at that, Dustin unfurls a little, as does the woman.
Billy's hands drop to his pockets and as his fingers brush across them, one hand hits the hard enamel edge of the asexual pin he'd taken off of his shirt earlier.
He fishes it out of his pocket and flashes it at them, it's a small planet-shaped pin with stripes in the asexual colors. "See?" he says.
"Oh," says Pretty Boy, sounding shocked.
"Yeah," Billy says. "I know. There aren't…" he trails off, but Pretty Boy quickly picks it up.
"A lot of asexuals around, yeah."
"Huh," Dustin huffs. "Whatever." He looks off to the side in the best imitation of a pissed off teenager Billy thinks he's ever seen a grown adult do and mean it.
Then the woman does this little sort of laughing without opening her mouth thing before turning to grab a couple of cupcakes off the tray on the back counter and without being asked, Dustin reaches over and unlatches then shoves open the door to the display case, the whole motion seeming so practiced Billy knows it must mean they know each other really well.
And the cupcakes, they're these dark chocolate cupcakes with these little green stars that look like handmade Lucky Charms sprinkled on top and they make something in Billy leap, like, Yes, those! Those ones are perfect.
The woman says, "Come on, Dustin, you handle it just as badly any time you see a fellow asexual in the wild or whenever you try to discuss being ace," just as Pretty Boy says, "Well, now that that's been handled..."
Then Dustin sputters, "Well, I—" just as Billy goes, "Yeah, so…"
The woman pauses.
Billy clears his throat.
Dustin looks at his feet.
Pretty Boy looks at the wall.
Nobody seems to want to break the awkward silence so Billy takes it upon himself to do it. "Those look perfect. Can I get them all boxed up?" he says, pointing at the chocolate cupcakes the woman was just shuffling into the display case and looking right at Pretty Boy as he says it.
The woman leans back out of the display case and straightens up to smile at him. "Sure thing," she says, even though he was clearly talking to Steve. Then, to Dustin, she says, "Well, you—" and cuts herself off giggling before she can even finish. "What was that thing you blurted out to that girl you went out with last week? 'I only know sexual words for non-sexual feelings'?"
Dustin blushes a fiery red that does not at all go with his curly hair or his chubby cheeks. "That was! I! You!" he stammers, making it clear that whatever the woman is teasing him for, it's embarrassing. Apparently very embarrassing as he gets all stiff and huffy and his cheeks puff out not unlike a chipmunk's. "You know," he says, indignant as anything, "I don't have to take this."
The woman laughs and says, "Oh, come on. You know I only do it out of love."
Dustin huffs (it seems to be something he does a lot) and stomps off through the swinging door, disappearing into the kitchen.
Once Dustin's gone, the woman turns towards the back counter again and starts digging around in the shelves underneath for a box big enough to put the cupcakes in.
"Sorry about... that. But don't worry about him," Pretty Boy says. "He's just kinda dramatic sometimes." And this time… this time there's a look on his face that's fond enough to get Billy worrying.
"Yeah… my last boyfriend was dramatic like that, too," Billy says, calculated and curious but going for light.
It's something he clearly doesn't quite achieve as Pretty Boy nearly does a spit take with just his own spit and the woman bursts out laughing.
"Wait..." she says, still elbow-deep in the long dark shelves under the counter. "You mean like... Steve? And Dustin? Together?" Her fingers brush the edges of a pale pink and very large box that she then grabs and starts pulling out. "That wouldn't last more than five minutes." She doesn't turn around as she says this, either, she just starts putting the cupcakes into the box. It's a weird sort of confidence, doing something like that, but Billy can't help but admire her for it.
"It wouldn't be that bad," Steve says, trying to sound cool even as he turns as red as Dustin had earlier, though the effect here is much prettier, the blush highlighting his cheekbones and making Billy want.
"So you're not seeing anybody, then?" Billy asks as Steve starts punching numbers into the cash register. Steve's blush deepens and starts spilling over onto his neck so deliciously it makes Billy lick his lips.
"Uh, no…" Steve says. "I guess not."
Billy takes this as his opening and leans in, putting his elbows up onto the pastel green counter and giving Steve his best smile. "Well, if you're not going out with anybody else, do you wanna go out with me? Maybe tomorrow night?"
Steve looks up and it takes a second for Billy's words to actually register, but once they do Steve smiles back with that same easy, sugary smile from earlier and it gives Billy the biggest rush he's had in a while. "Sure," Steve says. "That'd be great." And for a moment they just stare at each other and Billy thinks he could get lost just trying to memorize all the details of Steve's face. He thinks he might, actually, probably would, really, he definitely wants to, except—
Except the woman thumps the box of cupcakes onto the counter between the two of them, breaking the moment. Then with a grin and a glance at the cash register she says, "That'll be $42.50."
