Actions

Work Header

Battles of the Brothers

Summary:

The Company of Thorin Oakenshield was made up of brothers.

Entirely too many brothers.

Brothers everywhere: being underfoot, being overprotective, telling embarrassing stories around the campfire, arguing over portions, tucking in at night, stealing blankets, double-checking packs, squabbling over watch duties, helping each other on ponies, shoving each other off ponies, sharing dried meats, nicking dried meats. Family dynamics and lifetimes of deep, abiding affection (and annoyance, oh, so much annoyance, and knowing every single button) combined into a sure recipe for disaster.

Notes:

Blanket Permission Statement

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: An Overview of the Battlefield

Chapter Text

The Company of Thorin Oakenshield was made up of brothers.

Entirely too many brothers.

Brothers everywhere: being underfoot, being overprotective, telling embarrassing stories around the campfire, arguing over portions, tucking in at night, stealing blankets, double-checking packs, squabbling over watch duties, helping each other on ponies, shoving each other off ponies, sharing dried meats, nicking dried meats. Family dynamics and lifetimes of deep, abiding affection (and annoyance, oh, so much annoyance, and knowing every single button) combined into a sure recipe for disaster.

The ingredients for said recipe were divided thusly:

The Elders: Balin, Dori, Bombur, Oin, Fili

The Youngers: Dwalin, Ori, Bofur, Gloin, Kili

The “Neutral” Party: Nori, of questionable repute, the middle brother Ri

The Semiofficial Referee: Bifur, Axe-Addled, the older cousin Ur

The Pointedly Ignorant: Thorin Oakenshield, His Royal Grumpiness King Under the Mountain

The Unimpressed Spectator: Mister Bilbo Baggins, Burglar, of the Shire

The Youngers and Elders were easy enough to identify. Even Fili, with a good eighty years less life experience than his closest fellow Elders, was welcomed with metaphorically open arms after the Youngers initiated the first volley (really, they definitely started it) and he showed himself loyal to the order of Big Brothers. Likewise, the great divide in age between Gloin and Dwalin, Kili and Ori, did not prove an impediment for the Youngers. Bonds of shared big or little brotherhood could not be sullied by mere differences in age.

The other four members of the Company were left to find their own place in the Battles of the Brothers.

Initially, Bofur had assumed he could bring Bifur to the side of the Youngers. After all, Bofur had always been Bifur’s favorite (singing, funny Bofur with his excellent carving skills). Bombur, however, had exactly the same idea on his side, as he had clearly always been Bifur’s favorite (loving, gentle Bombur with his excellent roasting skills). After some jockeying between the two, it was generally decided that Bifur was best suited to a sort of overseer’s role, gently (sometimes violently) ensuring that nothing got too out of hand. This was a good call, since without Bifur this role might have fallen on the leader of their Company and frankly, everyone preferred to believe Thorin didn’t know what was going on.

“What if he does take an interest?” Bofur whispered feverishly to his fellow Youngers one night when they were feeling a bit set-upon by a joint effort of Fili, Oin, and a foul-smelling medicinal salve that ended up on their grooming accessories. “He’ll join them, won’t he?” He said “them” the way most dwarves would say “elven elk excrement” and motioned violently at the gathered Elders, who were pretending to innocently eat stew.

It was clearly a façade.

“Aye,” Dwalin agreed. “And he’d be a poor enemy to have.”

“Why?” Gloin demanded, obviously confused. “He has no sense of humor to speak of.”

“Isn’t that the problem?” Ori this time. “He’d probably rip our arms off.”

Kili scoffed. “Uncle wouldn’t hurt us.” He offered a feral grin. “We’d be no use to the quest that way.”

Dwalin cuffed the young prince on the back of the head. “I’m telling you he’d be a horrible addition to the enemy’s camp. YOU lot don’t remember Erebor-”

“I do,” Gloin insisted, though he’d been barely ten at the time.

“-but I do. He may be the King of Grumpiness now, but take my word for it. Thorin dealt with Frerin every day for over fifty years, and he still has Dis to contend with, who’s twice as dangerous. He’s no lightweight when it comes to siblings.” Dwalin cut his hands through the air in an absolutely not gesture. “Take my word for it; we do not want Thorin involved in any way.”

And so, Bifur took on his role as general referee, and everyone pretended their king didn’t have a clue what was happening right under his rather delicate nose.

Nori’s placement was more complicated. He was both a younger and an elder brother, with life experiences that caused him to have sympathies for both sides. He also had a wicked sense of humor and an inborn tendency toward smug superiority, so he decided to stay out of it, getting his laughs at the expense of each camp. He also took bets occasionally, and always came out on top because he had an unbiased view of the proceedings. He didn’t want to chance losing an amusing source of income by becoming involved in childish behavior.

Everyone had assumed that their Master Baggins, bless his beardless Hobbit heart, would be completely out of his element and flustered by the shenanigans of the Dwarves. They did not, however, account for the fact that Bilbo was half Took (in fact they had no idea what this meant until Bofur asked him) and, though an only child, had a large number of boisterous Took cousins who could “put you lot to shame.”

Well. That was just a challenge, wasn’t it?