Actions

Work Header

A Selkie’s Dilemma

Summary:

“I care for you, Master Baggins, and I’d hate to see any harm come of you.”

Bilbo sucked in a breath, meeting Thorin’s eyes and searching for certainty.

What he found, instead, was a reminder.

A reminder of why he’d stayed on this ship for so long. A reminder of why he’d continue to stay here on this ship, with these men, with this man.

He was in love.

This fic and art piece are part of the Acorn and Oak Leaves WIP Round-Up 2025 Event!
The fic is written by me and the incredible digital art piece is made by the wonderful Tetchy_frog!

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

The moon was high in the sky that night, not a cloud in sight as the light cascaded down onto the surface of the murky waves. The ship rocked peacefully, and the sound of thirteen men snoring below deck could faintly be heard in the background.

Bilbo sighed wistfully as he hung his arms off the side of the ship, gazing longingly into the waves.

It had been far too long since he’d felt the dark water’s embrace. His skin itched with the urge to just plunge into the water and never look back, yet something kept him here. 

That thing had kept him here for weeks now, and he’d managed to convince himself time and time again not to abandon ship. Tonight would be just like every other night.

That longing for the sea would keep him awake until his eyes could take it no longer, and he’d drift off to sleep, lulled by the waves, the soft snores, and that warm thing in his heart that kept him right where he was.

As if it was destined to break up his thoughts, the water just around the ship rippled familiarly and Bilbo jumped up, eyes darting to the movement. 

But nothing was there.

The water stayed calm, almost mocking him with the silence.

His posture was tense as he leaned far over the ship, almost convinced his tired mind had conjured up ghosts or visions. 

 

To his immediate relief, he’d yet to go insane, as he saw the water ripple again. Yet, the sight of a very familiar rear flipper grazing the surface made his heart leap into his throat.

He couldn’t hold back the gasp that took all his breath away. His nails dug into the wood of the ship in a maddening grip.

He held his breath as he waited, but didn’t have to wait long before a tiny head popped out of the water. 

Bilbo’s mouth hung open as the small seal gave him a whiskery grin and trilled at him happily.

“F-Frodo!” Bilbo stumbled out helplessly, watching the seal pup chirp cheerfully at the sight of him.

 

“Frodo! What are you doing here?” Bilbo said exasperated, leaning as far as he could over the ship now to get a good look at the pup.

 

“It’s dangerous out here! You should not be traveling these waters alone, you could get hurt!” 

As he spoke his eyes roved over the pup’s body, looking for signs of damage. 

Frodo merely squinted his eyes mischievously at him before submerging himself again.

“Wait! Frodo! Don’t-“ 

 

Bilbo’s fingers latched onto his seal pelt before he could even think about what he was doing. His heart raced as he readied himself to dive head first, but Frodo’s return had him hesitating just long enough to not do something rash. 

Frodo surfaced again with a bark this time, but he was not alone.

A dusty blonde seal emerged alongside him, and at least had the audacity to look sheepish about his presence.

“By Manannán, that can’t be… Samwise Gamgee? Is that you?”

Sam made a small noise at being recognized, but Frodo seemed spurred on by his presence, barking and trilling up a storm. He was chattering so quickly that Bilbo could barely take in the information with his human ears. 

“Yes, Frodo, it’s all good and well that you’re not alone but you cannot be here! These men-“ 

Another series of barks interrupted him. 

“…yes, yes there are men aboard this ship. Men like these on large ships hunt seals-“

“… no no, these men don’t hunt seals, but others really do! It’s not safe for you here! Go back to the shire!” Bilbo pleaded.

 

Frodo fixed him with an unimpressed look, before he partially removed his pelt, revealing a young boy with piercing blue eyes and dark hair.

“Uncle, you’re on that ship… you cannot stand there and tell me it’s not safe when you’re the one aboard that beast!“

Bilbo opened his mouth to respond but Frodo cut him off again.

“What’s keeping you there anyway? I see your pelt there in your hands, so I know they haven’t taken it from you! Come home with us, uncle! Sam knows the way from here!” 

Bilbo stared. Opened his mouth and promptly shut it again when words failed him.

The call of the ocean felt strong now, as he looked down to his pelt, rubbing his fingers against the soft fur; his soft fur. 

What was keeping him here again? 

He untangled the pelt from around his waist, the entirety of his beautiful fur clutched in his hands now.

Frodo only grinned, donning his pelt again, and barking encouragements up to his uncle. 

Bilbo could hear only the roar of the waves now. He couldn’t feel his legs anymore… no, he didn’t have legs to feel anymore. He closed his eyes and could almost feel the give of the water as he maneuvered through it. He could taste the salt on his tongue and hear the water rushing through his ears. He could feel the fresh breeze on his face as he soared through the air, back into the ocean again, diving deeper, deeper, deeper-

 

A warm hand grabbed his shoulder and pulled him off the ledge of the ship. He stumbled backwards into a familiar broad chest, the air punched out of him as his eyes shot open. His pelt lay uselessly at his feet as he came back to himself, once again regaining all of his senses. Only then did he think to acknowledge just who pulled him from the ledge.

When he turned his head he was met with piercing blue eyes, downturned lips, and a scent that could only be described as “worry”, emanating off the captain. 

The Captain.

Bilbo didn’t quite process just how close he was to the man until he pulled him tightly against his chest and heaved a great sigh, tension seeping out of his broad frame. 

“That was a close one, Master Baggins.” Thorin said with heavy relief, letting go of the smaller man but not moving far. He stepped back, hands hovering over his shoulders as his eyes searched Bilbo’s form, worry still heavy on his face. Bilbo found himself missing the warmth immediately.

 

“The sirens nearly had you…What were you thinking?”

 

Bilbo’s mouth opened to respond, yet no words came forth as Thorin’s words registered in his head.

 

“I’m sorry… sirens?”

 

“Aye, in the water. They were calling to you, were they not?” 

 

Bilbo glanced towards the water again, then back to his pelt. He slowly picked it up, fixing it back around his waist, Thorin’s eyes fixated on his every movement.

 

What was that look in his eyes? Fear? Worry? 

 

Thorin watched as Bilbo slowly walked to the side of the ship, hesitantly peering back into the depths.

No seals greeted him this time; not a ripple against the surface. The only sound to be heard was the creaking of the old ship, and the gentle song of the waves. 

Bilbo sighed mournfully.

 

He hadn’t seen his family, what little of it he had, in months. Not only did he feel the pull of the water calling to his heart but he also felt the ache of loss. Worry for Frodo had nagged at his heart ever since he’d come aboard this ship, and for the first few days, he’d wanted nothing more than to leave and find the pup. He was still a young seal, and the ocean was a large place. A dangerous place. The only comfort he had was knowing Frodo was safe in the Shire.

But now…

Frodo had somehow tracked him down, and by the looks of it, would not be swayed to go home that easily. 

Seeing the pup made something in his heart sing, but the brief interaction was not enough to satisfy the months worth of missing him. 

He found himself feeling that heavy loss again, and hoped beyond belief that Samwise could somehow convince Frodo to return home. 

I’ll be home soon enough, boys. I just need a little bit more time. 

 

Thorin silently took his place beside him, resting his arms against the rail and looking out to the sea. 

 

They stayed silent as the sounds of the night washed over the two of them. Bilbo snuck a glance at the stoic man beside him and could see how the moonlight made his eyes shimmer. It brought out the silvery shine of his graying hair and made him look absolutely ethereal…

 

“You shouldn’t come out here at night” Thorin started softly, and Bilbo’s head whipped to the side, mouth open, an argument ready on his tongue. 

“Not alone at least.”

Thorin turned to meet his eyes then, leaving the words to die on Bilbo’s tongue as he took in the look on his face.

There was vulnerability there as they looked to each other, and Bilbo could tell that Thorin was being genuine. 

 

“I worry for you, Bilbo.” He said softly, taking one of Bilbo’s hands and caressing it gently.

“I don’t want you to meet your fate in these waters.”

His hands were much larger than his own, and Bilbo couldn’t help but watch as the rough, calloused thing rubbed soothing circles into his palm. 



“I care for you, Master Baggins, and I’d hate to see any harm come of you.”

Bilbo sucked in a breath, meeting Thorin’s eyes and searching for certainty.

What he found, instead, was a reminder.

A reminder of why he’d stayed on this ship for so long. A reminder of why he’d continue to stay here on this ship, with these men, with this man.

 

He was in love. 

 

Notes:

Thank you all so much for reading! I want to, once again, give the largest shoutout to my event partner Tetchy_frog for being so wonderful to work with and for creating such a beautiful piece for this fic!
If you enjoyed, feel free to check back in for additional stories to be posted in the future!