Actions

Work Header

Inside Street-Corner Gangs: Observations from a Darts Match

Summary:

Yet this charming leader with long golden hair was not entirely hostile toward all people with unkempt hair. He treated Bard rather well.

Notes:

A headless, tailless The Hobbit × Street Corner Society crossover brain-itch turned into a short vignette. Very likely won’t be developed any further. Mostly because the character setups in this AU are interesting, and the original Little Burglar already reads very much like someone doing fieldwork.

20th-century setting. First-person sociological report by Bilbo.
The Master of Lake-town is named Goldwine in this work.

English is not my first language.

Work Text:

Certain figures at the leadership level seemed to take a particular liking to Bard of the Lake-town Gang, back when he was still an utterly unknown nobody. For instance, during the period when the Erebor Gang and the Lake-town Gang were on friendly terms—in 1932, to be precise—we agreed to meet on a Friday evening in autumn at the Community Cultural Hall to play darts. Kili, Gloin, and Dwalin were sent out to compete against Percy, Bard, and Alfred. Almost everyone put their dinner money on Kili and Alfrid. Thorin suggested that I choose someone as well, offering to cover my dinner either way. I, of course, explicitly refused this kindness and, out of regard for him, placed both my dollars on Dwalin instead. Dwalin nodded and smiled gratefully at his only supporter. It was the first time I had ever seen him smile. That said, deep down I was convinced that Bard would win the match without question; the only reason no one supported him was the vicious warning glare from Goldwine, the Lake-town Gang’s leader, who stood beside him.

Thorin insisted that I, the “college student,” go up and keep score. I noticed that they were using the meeting room door as a scoreboard. This was highly unusual, given that during my time at Shire University I had been explicitly instructed not to damage any property in meeting rooms—doors being specifically named. This would explain why my hand trembled as I held the chalk.

Bard’s hand, on the other hand, was steady to an extreme degree. Nearly every dart landed squarely in the bullseye. He would then step down from the line with an unhurried air and continue drinking the Fresh Fish brand original soda he had smuggled in. Kili was equally formidable, though his brother Fili forbade him from drinking soda.

By halftime, the overall trend was already clear: the Lake-town Gang was ahead by five points. It was only then that everyone noticed Thranduil, seated several rows back.

I did not know much about Thranduil. He came from one of the few wealthy families on the street corner, yet had not moved out due to his superior financial circumstances, instead choosing to remain in the old house his family had occupied for three generations. My impression of him was limited to Thorin’s subjective evaluations—“troublemaker,” “cold-blooded animal”—all of which still awaited verification. As such, I could not possibly miss an opportunity like this. I overheard the following exchange:

Thorin: What are you doing here?

Thranduil: I have every right to be here. There’s no sign on the door saying anyone’s barred. Besides, Thingol had a hand in founding the Cultural Hall. What reason do you have to drive me away?

Thorin: Our ancestors contributed too. That’s not the issue—the issue is your Mirkwood Gang. Last time Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur got taken in, your people were involved.

Thranduil: They shouldn’t have disrupted the campaign meeting. Your people and ours were about to come to blows.

Thorin: So you’re admitting it was you?

Thranduil: That’s a hasty conclusion.

Bard: For heaven’s sake, let’s all speak civilly, friends.

Thranduil: Good evening, Bard. —(to Thorin) The police only held them for one night. Galion went first thing the next morning to inquire and ended the detention early.

Thorin: That explains nothing. Offend people first, then put on a show of concern afterward—

Me: Perhaps we can resolve this peacefully. There’s a new round of campaigning in the coming month. Any major incident before then would likely affect the vote count.

Thorin: Mr. Baggins has a point. We can have a proper bout at the boxing gym, or you can cover my brothers’ dinner tonight and we’ll call it even.

Thranduil: Then I’ll cover the Erebor Gang’s dinner. This matter isn’t worth the Mirkwood Gang getting its hands dirty.

Goldwine: I’d be very grateful if you included my share as well, Thranduil. Business has been quite poor these days, though you, at least, shouldn’t have to worry for the next couple of years.

Bard: That’s terribly unfair to the Lake-town boys.

Thranduil: I don’t believe I owe you anything, Goldwine. Generosity doesn’t mean reckless spending.

Afterward, Thranduil told me that Thorin was “rotten to the soul,” and that Goldwine “ought to marry money.” While it is common enough for the middle class to hoard savings in a run-down street-corner district like this, Goldwine’s penny-pinching—almost to a caricatured degree—was indeed rather unbecoming, especially given his position as the head of a gang. This, in fact, was the root cause Eof the Lake-town Gang’s internal conflicts, a point I analyzed in detail in my coursework paper at Shire University.

I told him that I was writing a sociological field report. Thranduil was quite intrigued and even invited me the following January to his residence—furnished with white leather sofas—where he served chamomile tea and red wine. He spent three full hours carefully walking me through the conflicts and cooperative relationships among the gangs. His evaluation of Thorin differed entirely in substance from Thorin’s evaluation of him, yet their attitudes were strikingly consistent. He appeared wholly unconcerned about whether I might mention this meeting to Thorin.

Yet this charming leader with long golden hair was not entirely hostile toward all people with unkempt hair. He treated Bard rather well. Halfway through our conversation, Bard emerged from Thranduil’s kitchen to greet us, a glass of red wine in hand. He circled the sofa and sat down beside Thranduil. However, the first time I noticed this cross-gang friendship, we must return to the dart match mentioned earlier.

The second half of the game was fiercely contested, with Kili and Dwalin desperately trying to close the gap. Thranduil watched the board intently, drinking his malt beer. Whenever Bard scored, he clapped loudly. Someone like him would never get used to shouting “bravo.”

I seized an opening and asked Bard about it. Bard handed me a paper towel to wipe my hands and shrugged, saying that Thranduil was probably doing it just to spite Thorin. But when I asked, “Why doesn’t he clap when Percy scores?” Bard was left speechless. I then asked about the trade relationship between the Mirkwood Gang and the Lake-town Gang. This proved to be an excellent point of entry, as Bard was the “largest supplier” of alcoholic stock to the Mirkwood Gang. In reality, the “supplier” consisted solely of Bard himself, who every afternoon at half past four rowed barrels of alcohol with great effort from the brewery across the lake to the Mirkwood Gang’s headquarters. Bard described the workflow to me in detail and instructed me not to tell Goldwine.

“I trust you,” Bard said.

Beyond this, I could see no entanglement of benefit between Thranduil and Bard that might explain their closeness—leaving only personal ties. After the match ended, Thranduil suggested going to a bar for a drink and, ignoring the rest of us entirely, took Bard by the arm and walked out of the Community Cultural Hall. This behaviour further confirmed my hypothesis.