Actions

Work Header

Just a Couple of Hunters

Summary:

Expecting a possible case for them, Dean and Castiel end up meeting a shifty FBI agent named Will Graham at a crime scene. What's worse is that they keep running into him and his ominous companion, a certain Doctor Lecter, when all Dean wants to do is have a little hunting date with Castiel.

Notes:

A little FYI: I tagged this as Canon Compliant meaning this could take place at any given time in both canons - but I did write this having post season 9 Cas and season 1 or 2 Will in mind. Just in case that helps anyone :)

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

“And make sure you don’t hold your badge upside down again; it makes you look like an idiot – scratch that, it makes us look like idiots.”

“I know, Dean, you’ve already-”

“You know what, let me check your badge just one more time to make sure everything’s alright.” Before Cas could intervene, Dean already stopped right in front of him, getting into his personal space by reaching for his trench coat. He pulled the badge out of the inner pocket like it was second nature and let his eyes wander over the fake FBI badge that read “Jack Twist”. A little smile crossed his lips as he gave the badge a one-over. With a nod, he declared it as good to go and put it back on the inside of the beige trench coat the angel was wearing.

“Okay,” Dean offered him a smile as he patted his shoulder, “Are you ready to go, Agent Twist?”

“I was already ‘ready to go’ before you decided to lecture me on the basics of investigating a possible hunt, Dean,” Cas sighed.

If Dean hadn’t known him so well, he would’ve thought that Cas was annoyed by his admittedly over the top precautions for this hunt. But after years of spending time with the stoic angel, Cas wasn’t that hard to read anymore: The way his brows furrowed were obviously a sign that he was indeed a little exhausted but then there was also the slight tilt of his head, the amused twitch at the corner of his lips, and the fond sparkle in his eyes.

All in all, Dean wasn’t really worried about the angel being mad at him.

And so what if he took preparations a little too serious this time? It’s been forever since he’s worked a case with Cas alone and he wanted everything to go smoothly.

“A little less sarcasm then and a little more hunting, Cas.”

“I wasn’t the one who insisted on going over our fake background three times.”

Dean rolled his eyes. “Yeah, okay, point taken.” He grabbed the sleeve of Cas’s beloved trench coat and pulled him forwards as he started walking toward the crime scene. “Let’s just go,” he murmured. Beside him, he could hear a low chuckle and Dean couldn’t help but smile too.

It was a good thing that Sam decided to sit this one out and rather stayed back at the bunker – he forgot how much he missed bickering with Cas while working a job. Even though they technically didn’t know if this one was their kind of job yet.

Man, he really hoped it was.

 

The police officers let them through without much of a fuss, Cas held his badge up the right way, and nobody questioned why he tried to sniff the corpse. So far, so good. Dean squatted next to the torn-up body of a browned haired young woman with pale skin (Louise Mallard, 19, student at the local University of Minnesota, and beloved daughter – as a friendly police officer filled them in).

“What do you think, Cas?” Dean lowered his voice as soon as the policewoman let them alone. Cas squatted down next to him, narrowing his eyes on the body in front of them.

“I’m not so sure.” He took a few seconds before adding, “To begin with, there is no sulfur here.”

“Or any signs of EMF,” Dean continued.

Cas tilted his head, one hand hovering over the victim’s body and working his angel magic. “I cannot detect anything wrong with her. Aside from her missing heart and other organs.”

Dean weighed his head, eyeing the precise cuts on the victim’s body. “But that’s definitely not the work of a werewolf. There are no other scratches on her skin; hell, even her clothes are mostly fine.” Cas nodded in agreement. “Werewolves are not usually that careful with the dissection of their preys. And the next full moon is in 10 days.”

“So what, maybe a Skinwalker? Do we know something else that takes hearts?”

“I will call Sam and ask him.” They stood up and Dean nodded. “Yeah, good idea. I can ask around and maybe find some witnesses.” Dean let his gaze wander around, considering which police officer to approach. At the other side of the crime scene, a man in a worn-out flannel shirt ducked below the crime scene tape, looking over in their direction. He heard Cas say, “I’ll be right back,” and his steps faded as he pulled out the phone Dean bought him a few months ago.

Dean was still focused on the man in plaid who was not only looking at him but walking towards him. He furrowed his brows and took a few steps in his direction. “Hey, can I help you?”

The man didn’t answer him, just kept on coming closer until he was standing in front of him with more space between them than what was socially common. “My name is Will Graham. I’m a Special Investigator with the FBI.” Dean grimaced.

There was no way this guy was actually FBI, right? At least not judging by the way the so-called Special Investigator kept dodging his eyes, looking around like he’d rather not talk to anybody here – but then again, Dean knew better than to judge a book by its cover.

“You, uh, got identification?” He asked with more confidence than he was feeling. On the off chance that this guy was FBI, he and Cas had to take off. Graham reached for his back pocket and oh shit – Dean was talking to an actual agent of the actual FBI.

Agent Graham put away his papers as soon as Dean nodded, his mind searching for another cover-up story why he would be at this crime scene. He couldn’t pull the federal agent card to an actual agent now, could he? He’d pulled it off before with Sam but that was years ago and now he didn’t have Bobby to play boss for them. Plus, he didn’t want to risk it with Cas by his side.

But before he could come up with a solid excuse, Cas popped up next to him, pressing his arm to Dean’s and smiling politely at the stranger in front of him. “Hello, we’re FBI agents. Do you want to see our badges?” Sometimes he wanted to smack this idiot of an angel. He shot him a sideways glance, but Cas either didn’t notice or chose to ignore Dean’s warning glare.

Agent Graham rose his eyebrows, for the first time looking Dean dead in the eye, before he settled on Cas. “Go ahead.” He sounded indifferent but Dean couldn’t help but feel that something had amused him, as he glanced over the badge of Agent Twist. If there was something funny, he didn’t comment on it.

Cas put his fake badge away, appearing a little proud that they once again had fooled someone and gotten away with it. Dean wasn’t so sure about that. He still introduced himself with his fake name – “Oh, and I’m Agent Paul” – and waited for Graham to call their bluff but he didn’t.

Huh.

Maybe they got lucky. Cas definitely seemed to think so. “Well, well, well,” he tried to segue way; hands on his hips, looking over to the victim, “what do we have here?” Dean was one hundred percent certain that Cas had written down some detective lines from a bunch of tv shows somewhere. What a dork. He would’ve smiled if it wasn’t for Agent Graham and his grim face.

“Didn’t you already take a look at the body?” Graham wondered.

Cas stiffened next to him, turning to Dean in a silent signal to help him out. Dean sighed. “Yeah, uh, I guess we’re a bit lost what thing could have caused these sorts of cuts,” he tried to smoothen things over. Graham was kind enough to not point out their awkwardness. Or he just didn’t care enough. Either way, he shrugged and rubbed a hand over his face, pushing his hair out of his forehead. Man, was this guy always sweating this much? “You’re simply going to assume it was some kind of animal?”

Dean shifted in his stance. “Do you have another theory?”

Graham grinned, taking slow steps towards the corpse. “I have a few.” Apparently, he didn’t feel the need to elaborate further.

“Mind sharing them with us?” Dean probed.

The agent didn’t answer immediately, as if he was considering whether he should share his thoughts or not. “First of all, there are a few serial killers running amok in this area.”

Dean and Cas shared a look. Yeah, this Graham guy seemed a little too casual, going around and mentioning serial killers off-handedly. “Is that so?” Dean followed up.

Graham hummed in agreement; eyes focused on the corpse. “Some of which might fit the profile.” He shrugged. “But this wasn’t the work of anyone we already know. This is the craft of someone knew – of a man trying to provide for his family. Feeding off the weak because they are less important in the grand scheme of things. He chose her because he thought it was his right to decide over her death. He saw a better way to use her organs, so he took them. The example of a black and white morality in which he defines the qualities of a hero – a god imposing his will on humanity.” The agent snapped out of wherever he just went mentally, only to add an ominous, “This is my design”.

Dean eyed Cas who looked as irritated as he was feeling. What sort of Special Agent was this dude exactly?

He turned to Cas. “Maybe we should get out of here, this guy gives me the creeps,” he murmured.

“This agent does seem odd,” Cas agreed with a nod.

“Okay then, let’s hit the road.” Dean tucked at Cas’s sleave, motioning him to get going. Cas didn’t move. “Do you have the name of any witnesses?”

“Nah, we can just ask around later. Come on, now. I don’t trust this guy.”

The corner of Cas’s lips twitched upwards. “Is this another instance of your nonspecific hunter instincts, Dean?”

Dean narrowed his eyes at the angel. “Okay, first of all, I feel like you’re mocking me-”

“I would never,” Cas had the audacity to interrupt him with such an outright lie, “I think it’s very charming.”

“-and secondly,” Dean went on, ignoring how warm his cheeks felt, trying to shove down the forming smile on his face, “yes, Cas, my gut's telling me that there’s something off about this Graham.”

Cas took a moment to think his word over. “I see your point. And you know I trust your judgement, Dean.”

Leave it to Cas to hit him with that sort of emotional honesty out of the blue. Dean, as so often, didn’t really know how to react, so he just nodded it off. Cas shook his head fondly at his reaction. Once more, Dean tucked at his sleeve and the angel finally let himself be pulled away by him.

He glanced back at Graham, considered to say their goodbyes but the agent was still in this sort of weird reverie, staring down at the corpse as if there was anything more to see than feign skin, glassy eyes and a bunch of seemingly random incisions. He turned back around and left the crime scene with Cas by his side, heading towards the Impala which was safely parked away in a near distance.

Maybe it wasn’t their kind of job after all. But Dean wasn’t ready to give up just yet.

 

Talking to potential witnesses turned out to be a complete waste of time. It took them way too long to find some people who actually knew something about the victim and even then, they didn’t learn anything of importance. No sighting of any animals, no recently passed person who might hold a grudge, no suspicious activities wherever they looked. Not even Sam had an idea. The only thing worth of mention were a few disappearances over the past weeks, but they had been all over the place and they couldn’t find any connection yet. Sam and Cas agreed that they’d probably been unrelated to whatever was going on with their vic, anyways.

“This is a bust,” Dean complained later in the evening. He leaned back in the hard cushion of their booth, taking a sip of his half-emptied beer. Cas uncrossed his arms, sighing for the nth time. “Maybe there is nothing to hunt here, Dean.” The bar-slash-diner they found in the next town over wasn’t that well visited but he still lowered his voice to make sure no one would overhear them.

Dean shook his head vehemently, stuffing his mouth with a few fries. “We’re missing something, I’m telling you.” By the look Cas gave him, he could tell that the angel thought he was being unreasonably stubborn. Dean rolled his eyes, grabbing some more fries.

“You’re acting very weird about this.”

The statement made Dean shift uncomfortably. “I’m not acting weird,” he mumbled, dodging Cas’s demanding eyes. Cas tilted his head. “Dean.”

“Don’t ‘Dean’ me.”

“You’re being childish.” Dean didn’t need to look up to know that Cas was shaking his head in his trademark Dean Is An Idiot kind of way. He looked up anyways and found Cas smiling at him.

Dean gave in with a sigh and dropped the fry he had just picked up from the giant plate between them. “Is it so bad that I just want to go on a hunt with you?”

Cas leaned forwards, putting his hand on top of Dean’s. Dean tensed but didn’t pull away. He was working on this whole physical affection in public thing. Besides, no one was looking over to their corner anyways.

“You know that’s not bad thing,” Cas started out, his voice dropping lower than usual in an attempt to sound reassuring. It was working. He could feel his body relaxing. “I always value the time we spend together, Dean. If you wanted to simply take a drive with me, you could have said so. I don’t want you to insist on this in order to keep me here.”

Dean couldn’t help but smile at the words. “That’s, uh,” he lowered his voice a bit, “that’s sweet and all, but my gut is telling me-”

“Your infamous hunter instincts, I know.”

“-that there might be something here. Shut up,” he grinned and pulled his hands away to throw a fry at Cas. The angel just looked at him pointedly, as if Dean just confirmed his previous point about being childish. Which, yeah, okay, he did but whatever. Dean was still chuckling when Cas suddenly went stiff, looking at something over Dean’s shoulder.

“What’s wrong?” Dean was immediately on alert.

“The agent who ‘gave you the creeps’ just walked in,” Cas explained, doing air quotes with his hands. Dean turned around and yup, there he was: Agent Graham walked in with the same worn-down flannel from earlier today, behind him a tall man with neatly combed hair, wearing a dark colored suit that practically screamed ‘I am wealthy and superior’.

Dean groaned. “What’s he doing here? And who’s Slender Man behind him?” Cas responded with a shrug, eyes transfixed on the two figures who moved their way around the few people inside. Something about the way the shifted around the room reminded Dean of hunters who creeped up on the deer they wanted to shoot. He took another sip of his beer. “Do you think we can sneak out before they notice us?”

Cas shook his head. “I don’t think so. But I could get us out of here right now.” He lifted his index and middle finger to Dean’s forehead.

“Whoah, hold your horses.” Dean caught his wrist, effectively stopping the motion. “Don’t think to just apparate out of here is gonna help us blend in, if we wanna stay in town a bit longer.” He decidedly ignored the question mark that appeared on Cas’s face regarding the Harry Potter reference. He pressed Cas to lower his hand and let go of his wrist afterwards. “Let’s just wait ‘till they’re settled down or one of them is going to the toilet or something and go then.” Cas agreed reluctantly.

 

Waiting it out took longer than either of them had hoped. After another hour, Dean couldn’t take it anymore. This was getting ridiculous. That agent was also just another guy, admittedly a very strange (bordering on creepy) guy, but Dean has dealt with worse. So, after they’d paid, he grabbed Cas by the wrist, dragging him along as he hurried to the exit door. It was with one hand on the door, ready to push open, that he heard a voice behind him go, “Agents.”

Oh, come on.

Dean turned around, his hand unconsciously tightening around Cas’s wrist. “Agent Graham,” he greeted as politely as he could. Graham and the fancy suit man stood a few steps behind them.

“We were about to head out as well,” the stranger next to Graham offered in a charming and heavily accented voice, “after you.” He gestured for them to open the door in a way the host of a party would show guests around his apartment. Dean obliged anyways and pushed the door open. Cas followed suit, still letting Dean hold onto his wrist. Graham and his companion were right behind them.

“I believe I have yet to introduce myself,” the fancy man started as soon as they were outside, “I’m Doctor Lecter. I occasionally help good Will in the form of case consultations.” He even shook their hands and boy, this man had a tight grip. Dean couldn’t help but wonder if the Doctor straight up popped out of a fairy tale and wanted to swoop them off their feet with politeness and manners. “Agent Paul and Twist,” Dean introduced himself and Cas, nodding to the angel at his side.

“Ah, I see,” Lecter responded in good fashion. By the way he exchanged a look with Graham, Dean couldn’t help but feel like he’d just missed something.

Graham leaned towards Lecter next to him, shoulders touching. “The FBI agents were very interested in the case of the mutilated woman I consulted today,” he filled the older doctor in with unnecessary emphasis. The doctor seemed to find that somehow intriguing, because he gave Dean and Cas a once over, accompanied with a suggestive, “Were they now?”

The fuck was going on here?

Dean glimpsed over to Cas who had his eyes narrowed, looking as if he was failing to solve a very hard puzzle. “Yes, we were,” he answered the theoretical question. Under different circumstances he’d find Cas’s trait to take things too literal endearing (even though he’d never say that out loud) but now it seemed to have the unwelcome effect of prolonging their conversation. And Dean did not want to converse with the odd agent and odd doctor right now – he just wanted to find the nearest hotel, book a room for him and Cas, and sleep this day off.

Before Lecter or Graham could continue their little talk, Dean took matters into his own hands. “It was nice to meet you, Doctor, and, uh, you too, Agent,” he tried to wrap things up, “but me and my partner better get going before there are no hotel rooms left.”

He nudged Cas’s side with his elbow. “Oh, yes. We need a hotel room,” Cas nodded a little too serious, “for sleeping and resting.” Sometimes, Dean wondered how anyone could look at Cas and not see the giant Not Human sign he was basically walking around with.

But all things considered, they somehow managed to wiggle themselves out of the lowkey uncomfortable situation rather smoothly; even though Dean got the feeling that Graham and Lecter watched them a little too closely – like animals who studied their next meal. Dean shook off that weird analogy on their way back to the Impala. It was probably best that they were heading to get some sleep; his brain was producing nonsense.

 

Dean insisted they’d stay in town for a couple of days longer. Cas made it clear, repeatedly, that he didn’t think there was anything up their ally going on, but Dean just wanted to make sure. At least, that was what he told Cas. And to be fair, that wasn’t even a lie. Dean got a weird feeling about this whole thing; about the young woman who was missing freaking organs and it was treated as no biggie, but also everything about agent Graham and that doctor friend of his were just a raging red flag to him – he just didn’t know why or what to do about it.

Cas wasn’t helpful on that front either. “I thought Doctor Lecter was very polite. How is that suspicious?”

Dean stopped his frantic walking around in their little hotel room to shoot him an incredulous look. “Come on, Cas, he introduced himself with his doctor’s degree. That’s just a douche move. Besides, there’s no way a posh guy like him hangs out with mister creepy pants – something doesn’t add up there, too.”

“What do his pants have to do with anything?”

“It’s a saying, Cas,” Dean groaned. “Don’t tell me the way the two talked were normal. They were talking in, like, code or something.”

“If they were, there would be no way for us to know. The point of encoded talking is to obscure the actual intention of-”

Dean cut him off with a lax hand wave. “Yeah, yeah, I know. Thanks, Wikipedia.”

Cas crossed his arms displeased. Dean sighed. “Sorry. I just…” He let the end of the sentence trail off, not really sure how to put things into words. He sat down on the edge of their hotel bed. Cas’s expression changed to worry and he slowly made his way over to him. Dean felt his posture fall, a sense of exhaustion suddenly overcoming him. Cas didn’t press for him to speak, just waited quietly.

“You know,” Dean eventually muttered, “it’s just that was gonna be like our first hunt together and stuff.” He kept his head down, eyes focused on his hands in his lap. The mattress dipped next to him as Cas tentatively sat down. A warmth spread through his body from where their knees touched.

“Dean,” Cas spoke softly, “We’ve been on several hunts together.”

Dean kept fidgeting with his hands, not really embarrassed to say the thoughts in his head but also not brave enough to just spit it out. Another sigh escaped his lips. “Yeah, I know, but, uh,” he took a deep breath and felt kind of ridiculous that it took him so long to just say some simple, little words. “This would’ve been our first hunt since, uh, you know.” Good thing he wasn’t facing Cas because he was definitely blushing now.

“Since we entered a romantic relationship?” Cas helped him out.

Somehow, that rather dry phrasing made Dean chuckle. “Always the romantic, huh, Cas?” He finally looked up to see the angel smiling back at him, blue eyes fixed on him as if he was something precious. “We can find something else to hunt. You once said that there is ‘always something to hunt out there’, remember?”

“I feel like I should tell you that you don’t actually have to do the air quotes every time.”

That made Cas laugh. Dean felt himself relax instantly. “But yeah, I know. We’ll find something else to hunt.” He patted Cas’s knee and let his hand rest there. “Maybe an actual werewolf or a skinwalker.”

“I have never encountered a werewolf on a hunt before.”

“I know, buddy, why’d you think I jumped at this when I read ‘missing heart’?”

Cas smile grew wider. “That was very considerate of you,” he tilted his head, “and very sweet.” He put his hands on top of Dean’s and looked at him like that and Dean could’ve just melted right there; but his body wasn’t made of liquid, so he just laughed it off with a cocky grin and a Dean Winchester patented wink. “Yeah, I’m the best boyfriend, I know.”

Cas rolled his eyes, but his smile betrayed his feigned annoyance. “I wouldn’t know. I don’t have anything to compare your aptitude with,” Cas teased dryly. “Also, this case didn’t turn out to be a hunting event at all. As I said to you many times over the past days.”

“Well, sue me for trying to go on a nice hunt with you.”

“I’m not going to sue you, Dean.”

Dean just shook his head, laughing at his stupid boyfriend taking things too stupidly literal. Cas eventually broke a smile as well, knowing that Dean wouldn’t want to change him either way.

“Fine, you win. There’s no case for us here,” he begrudgingly admitted after he’d calm down again. “Might as well just head back to the bunker.”

Cas was kind enough to not tease him further. He just squeezed his hand and got up. Dean groaned as he stood as well, holding Cas’s hand for a little longer before he let go, reaching for his bag to finally pack things up.

 

Apparently, the universe or whatever god wasn’t quite done with them yet. Dean didn’t know how else to explain the sheer bad luck they seemed to have, running into Graham and Lecter again out of all people on their way outside of town. They had just sat down in a nice little place that served late breakfast – because Dean refused to drive all the way back to Kansas without some proper meal first – when they saw the two figures approaching their table.

Dean laid down his fork in exhaustion; he really wasn’t in the mood to deal with codes and weird looks right now. Cas just looked up to see the cause of Dean’s mood swing. Graham and Lecter made a halt before their table. “Agents, what a pleasant surprise,” Lecter smiled down at them.

Dean grimaced, not really able to offer him a sincere smile before he’d eaten his daily portion of bacon. “Hi,” he forced himself to greet curtly. After all, he didn’t want to be a total asshole.

“We saw you and wanted to come over to inform you that we’ve arrested a suspect in the murder case of Louise Mallard. No need to worry anymore.” Graham sounded a little to intense to come across as nonchalant.

Dean nodded slowly, looking over to Cas to make sure he played along. “Yeah, of course, we’ve been informed,” Dean lied casually.

“Then you must know that the FBI will stop their investigations following the arrest,” Lecter added. “The case is no longer of great concern for the Bureau. We are off the hook so to speak.”

Dean wasn’t really sure why the doctor felt the need to tell them all of this, but he let the two of them go on. “There are bigger fish to fry,” Graham added unhelpfully.

“Do we know what happened to the organs that were taken?” Cas asked curiously.

Graham and Lecter shared another look which Dean could not interpretate. “The primary theory is organ harvesting.” Dean blinked at the doctor. “Like, selling kidneys at the black market and all that crap?”

Lecter smiled amusedly, “Yes, that is the belief.”

Graham let out a sigh. “Point is that this case will be probably closed soon. Just thought you’d wanna know.”

Admittedly, Dean was pleased to know how the case has ended, but at the same time, he wondered why the agent went out of their way to let them know of that. The simple answer would be that the agent had figured out they weren’t legit – but, of course, that was absurd because wouldn’t they report this? Or was this some sort of test?

In the time, it took Dean to make sense of this whole situation, the agent and his partner somehow managed to talk Cas into letting them sit down at their table. Dean looked up as the doctor tried to take the place next to him. “Is the bacon to your satisfaction?” He asked after having settled in. Dean looked at Lecter, visibly confused. The doctor pointed at the long-forgotten plate with his breakfast.

“I found it to be lacking in aroma,” he went on. “Then again, I do prefer to prepare all meals myself. This way, I can hand-pick the ingredients on my own. No need to worry what you are about to put into your mouth when you selected it yourself.”

A little taken aback by the sudden change of the topic, Dean’s brain took a moment to catch up with the small talk. “Yeah,” he agreed slowly, “I get it. I’m not a picky eater but I sometimes like to cook too.” That seemed to spark Lecter’s interest.

Dean wasn’t really sure how they ended up there – he was partly convinced that this doctor was some kind of wizard who just enchanted people with the most random topics of conversations and lulled them with monologues about the art of cooking – but when he looked at his watch the next time, a little over an hour had passed.

He still thought Lecter was an odd figure and definitely way too formal and intense at times – but then again, so was Cas. And oddly enough, he found himself having had a nice time talking to the older man. Maybe he was a wizard indeed.

 

After his plate was empty and the food was paid for with a generous tip, Dean and Cas said their goodbyes to the odd pair, this time hopefully for real. They walked their way back to the Impala, hands brushing against each other, and Dean waited until Cas had settled in the front seat before he turned on the engine.

“Dean, do you think they were hunters too?” Cas wondered after a while of driving in silence.

Dean kept his eyes on the road but shot him a quick look, wondering where this was coming from.

“Agent Graham asked me if we like to hunt as well. But when I told him that I don’t like to hurt animals, he said that he wasn’t talking about that.”

Upon hearing these words, the pieces began to fall into place in Dean’s mind – the weird looks; the amusement after looking at Cas’s badge; the knowing glances between Graham and Lecter; the need to let them know how the case ended.

Of course, Graham recognized that they weren’t FBI because he was a hunter who’d stumbled upon the very same non-case. Dean felt stupid for not connecting the dots sooner – it all seemed to make that much more sense now.

“Now that you’ve said it – yeah, Cas, they were probably hunters too.”

Cas hummed in response. “It’s nice to meet another hunting couple.”

“I mean, they were still a bit weird,” Dean muttered, focusing once again on the road in front of him. He could basically hear Cas’s eyeroll. Dean laughed out loud and took one hand off the steering wheel to reach out to his boyfriend next to him. He ended up blindly gripping his shoulder. “But yeah, it was nice. And next time, you get your werewolf. I promise.”

 

-

 

“A shame they took off so soon. I would have loved to discuss the details of what they did with poor Louise Mallard’s internals over dinner.”

Will snorted, “Sure you would’ve.” Hannibal ignored his comment and pressed his right hand on Will’s lower back instead. Will started walking with him in the opposite direction to which the couple took off a few minutes ago. “You know, just because they were lying about their identities doesn’t mean they also happen to have committed the murder.”

Hannibal pulled the car keys out of the pockets of his slacks. “The timing of their appearance may have been coincidental. Yet you insisted that you recognized the spirit of well-seasoned killers in them.” He unlocked the car and, ever the gentleman, motioned for Will to get in first.

Will stood still and turned to face Hannibal, gaze set on his cheekbones instead of his eyes. “Doesn’t mean they did it. Maybe they’re innocent,” he shrugged.

A barely detectable smile started to spread on Hannibal’s face. “Or perhaps the man you had arrested by the police is the innocent.”

Will narrowed his eyes, looking up to watch Hannibal’s pupils darken. “If you’re trying to make me feel guilty, it’s not working, Doctor Lecter,” he teased right back, closing in on Hannibal’s face. “My conscience is just fine with my decisions.” He usually avoided eye contact wherever he could but, as with so many things, Hannibal was the exception to the rule. And it was so entertaining how easy it was to rile him up with a single look.

After a while, Hannibal broke the eye contact and opened the door to his car, emphasizing for Will to get in. “In that case, let us enjoy dinner tonight at my place. I have a new recipe I’ve been eager to cook.” Will let himself enjoy the little win of their little argument as he got in.

He looked up before Hannibal closed the door. “Is there any point of asking what we’ll be eating?”

Hannibal’s lips tightened into an amused smile. “None, my dear. It would only spoil the surprise.”

Notes:

This is my first time posting on here, so hi fannibals and spn fandom 🥰
Also thanks to my best friend who helped me find a title and convinced me into posting this - and to literally anyone who took the time to read this silly little story! 💜