Chapter Text
The arrow was pulled back to brush against a cool cheek. Lips pulled in careful breaths to steady hands and ready the aim. Everything seemed to pause, to wait, for just one moment.
Wood and feather flew through the air, striking its target true. There was not a sound as the body dropped to the ground. Silence drifted everywhere for a long moment.
Then, finally, the screams erupted as the tragedy was realized. People rushed forward, but the archer knew: it was too little, too late. The aim had been without equal, the shot perfect.
And in the end, Bilbo Baggins was still left on the ground, lifeless, a single arrow through his heart.
Two weeks earlier
What had once been empty of life was now filled once more with endless workers and dwarves who’d come for a home in Erebor. The mines were thriving, the market constantly exchanging with Esgaroth and the rebuilding Dale, and every dwarf he saw smiled. Life in Erebor was good. The years rebuilding had been good to them all.
What no one had told Thorin was that there was also a lot of political nonsense and inanity to make it all happen.
“Bilbo tired of the Council yet?”
“Bilbo’s tired of me being tired of the Council,” Thorin said dryly. Dwalin snorted.
“Aye, I figured. You’ve been a bit of a piss lately.”
Thorin gave him a hard shove towards the cavern wall, ignoring his friend’s laughter. It was the first time he’d seen Dwalin as a friend and not just his Captain of the Guard in far too long. When Dwalin had offered to escort him down to the mines, a relief had settled into Thorin’s soul. He could use a friendly ear.
And, perhaps, a dry wit to help.
“Not that terrible, I hope,” Thorin said, but there was a tension building at the thought. Had his anger and frustration begun to come out as cruel? Had he injured someone’s heart grievously? Mahal, had he hurt Bilbo-
The smack upside the back of his head would have been instantly denounced by the Council as a crime worthy of death. How dare someone strike their King?
All Thorin did was rub the back of his head and glare at Dwalin. Dwalin glared back. “Stop it. Mahal, Bilbo was right: you’re too wound up and too damn worried about everythin’. Mountain won’t fall if you take a break for a bit.” Dwalin paused. “And your husband’s fine. More worried about you, says you come back late and tired. Obvious to see, now. Least, from my perspective it is.”
It was a reprimand even while it was an offer of comfort. If Dwalin had seen it and was commenting on it, then it was very obvious indeed. But not too obvious to those who did not know him well enough, which meant his subjects wouldn’t see it yet.
His subjects. Three years after being crowned, and it was still odd to think of his fellow dwarves that way. Bilbo told him it made him a good king by holding that view and not thinking himself above them. Thorin held to his belief that it was Bilbo that made him a good king.
“There’s still so much to do,” Thorin said, pausing to look up. All of Erebor stretched above him, hundreds and thousands of feet from the earth. There were miners and tinkers working above him, many pathways flooded with working dwarves. The noise, while intense, was soothing. This was the sound that Thorin remembered from his childhood, his many years running wild with Dis and Frerin behind him.
There was only a faint twist of his heart when he thought of Frerin. He didn’t let himself think too often of his brother, for the grief was still strong. But here, in Erebor, he found himself catching glimpses of his brother in the hallways, the old rooms, the hot springs where they’d run amok.
“Thorin?”
Thorin shook himself. Dwalin wasn’t glaring at him anymore: Dwalin looked downright concerned. “Go home,” Dwalin said firmly but gently. “Go back to Bilbo. Not jestin’ with you. You’re miles away and too damn tired to drag yourself back.”
“Years away,” Thorin admitted. Dwalin frowned. “Frerin.”
Dwalin nodded slowly. “I can imagine. There’s a lot of ghosts that run through the mountain, whether they perished here or not. Legolas said he’s felt ‘em, their memories. Offered to look with Ori for a blessing of some sort to settle ‘em.”
Thorin would never have put stock in it, but he’d wandered the Paths of the Dead, and he’d seen those who didn’t rest. The thought of his kin wandering aimlessly, a silent memory, left him sick to his stomach. “If they will,” he said, and Dwalin nodded.
“Good. Now go home-“
“I’ll just pace,” Thorin finally said, agitated for no reason. That was all he’d been, lately: agitated and frustrated and unable to do anything about it. He wondered if this was why his grandfather had turned to the gold: it had been a comfort for something to not demand anything of him, but to only give pleasure instead.
Thorin didn’t need gold for that. He had a hobbit with a curly mop of hair whose only request was for Thorin to take care of himself and, sometimes, to fetch them both a cup of tea. Or to stay abed, just a little longer, amongst the furs and his husband’s sleepy smile.
Perhaps he did need to go home.
“One mine, and that’s it,” Dwalin said firmly. “Then you’re home to Bilbo. M’not crossin’ a hobbit, let alone Bilbo. Learned my lesson the hard way.”
In spite of his frustration, Thorin grinned. “You were sick and should’ve been resting. Bilbo tends to get…upset when those he cares for don’t take care of themselves.”
“He yelled at me in front of the entire Guard. Like I was a wayward child. Last time I got scolded it was Balin who did the scoldin’, and it was in these very halls.”
“Last week, then?”
Dwalin growled and punched him in the arm. Thorin finally laughed, feeling some of his tensions ease. Only when he stopped did he finally try and soothe his friend. “If Bilbo had thought for a moment that…scolding you would lead to a diminished respect from your Guard, he would never have done it. If you will recall, he scolded the rest of your Guard even more than he did you.” And what a sight it had been: a small hobbit, fury in his eyes, yelling at a group of weapon-laden dwarves for letting Dwalin be there when he was obviously so ill.
It had made the gossip rounds of Erebor, thanks in part to Bofur and Nori. Kili and Fili hadn’t helped by embellishing just how much fear had been in the eyes of every Guard.
Actually, they hadn’t embellished all that much, now that Thorin thought of it.
“You ever tell him?”
“What, how his scolding still rings in your ears?”
“About Frerin.”
The words pulled Thorin up short, so close to the mine’s entrance. Now that he thought of it… “I must have,” Thorin said, but his memory pulled nothing to him. Had he truly never spoken of Frerin? “Dis must have.”
“Maybe. He might want to hear it from you, though.” Dwalin sighed and rested his hand on Thorin’s shoulder, a firm grasp that had kept him steady many a time before. “I wouldn’t blame you if you hadn’t spoken of it. He wouldn’t, either.”
“He’s too forgiving,” Thorin muttered. Always quick to forgive, but it had done his husband more harm than good until after they’d been married. He was still ready to forgive insult and injury, no matter how slight or grievous, or who from. And that last one shouldn’t have mattered so much, but Thorin knew that a few dwarves had no care for Bilbo, whether he had saved Middle-Earth from Sauron’s destruction or not. Bilbo bore it with far more grace than Thorin did. Bilbo was his husband, the one Ringbearer, the greatest burglar of all, his husband. That alone should have settled any disgruntlements.
“Aye, ‘specially with the Council,” Dwalin agreed. “And us. You should still tell him.”
He should, and would. “After the mine,” he said, and made it a solid idea in his mind. “I’ll tell him about Frerin.”
Dwalin clapped him on the back with a soft smile he usually reserved for Ori or children. If anyone could understand how Thorin felt, it was Dwalin. For after the battle of Moria, it had been Dwalin who had found him kneeling beside Frerin’s lifeless body. It had been Dwalin who had been uncharacteristically gentle with him, kneeling and enfolding him in his embrace until Thorin had stopped shuddering. It had been Dwalin who had helped him to his feet and called for help bringing Frerin’s body back to where they would bury the dead.
And when Thorin had had to tell Dis of all the lives lost in the battle, it had been Dwalin who’d stood beside him and held them both as they’d wept.
The mine itself was cool, cooler than the others. It was almost a relief, given the long royal coat that Thorin now had to wear. Even Dis had encouraged him to wear what he wanted and not what was considered traditional. He’d married a hobbit, for Mahal’s sake; tradition wasn’t exactly a necessity. Now, feeling how much the cool air of the mine left him breathing easier, he wondered if perhaps he could not have two royal cloaks, one for the warm days, and this cloak for the winter ones.
It most certainly wasn’t winter now. Even Bilbo, used to the warmer air of the Shire, had started taking his vest off when in their chambers, leaving him in only his light, white shirt and his trousers.
And thinking of Bilbo dressed like that, sweat drenching his curls and making Thorin want to run his fingers through them, would get him nowhere. He nodded to the foreman of the mine who bowed deeply in return. “How go the mines?” he asked.
“Well, your majesty: we hit a trouble spot of a rocky nature yesterday, but my best team worked it hard. Aye but they were done quick enough.”
Good. Less things for him to deal with. He wandered further into the mine, watching the stone surface illuminate with precious stones and golden veins. Nothing extravagant, nothing truly full of riches here. Perhaps one of the business dwarves that Gloin told him so much about would be interested in owning a private investment. There was no need for Thorin to have to maintain all of the mines as royalty. His grandfather had loaned out the mines, but selling them to someone else made more sense.
The mines were tended to by his people. They deserved to be owned by his people.
“Thorin!”
He’d felt the rumbling half a second before Dwalin yelled for him. But it was shaking the walls now, rocks tumbling around him. Thorin grabbed a nearby miner who was running too slowly and pushed him forward towards the exit. “Go!” Thorin shouted.
The entire ceiling gave. The last thing Thorin saw were the large rocks coming down in front of him, and then there was nothing.
When he came to, everything was dark. Thorin shoved at the rocks above him and felt a few shift. That was good news: that meant he could get out.
After a long time digging, light finally began to stream through. He could feel the rumbling of larger stones being moved, and then at last the bright shine of lamps and candles poured in. He winced and tried to adjust his vision, and was rewarded with the sight of his nephews, Dwalin, and behind him, Bilbo. All of them were speaking at once, but none could be heard over the rumble of the stone. When the stone finally stopped, Thorin reached out for Bilbo, who desperately took hold of his hand. “I’m all right,” he promised them, then froze. His nephews were still speaking, but not a word of it reached Thorin.
His own voice hadn’t reached him. Nothing could. He moved to Bilbo, panic stirring in his gut, and found fear reflecting back at him. Bilbo said a word, but nothing came to his ears. When Thorin didn’t answer, Bilbo’s fear only increased, as if he’d confirmed that something was very wrong.
And it was very wrong. So wrong that Thorin didn’t have a word to describe how wrong it was, and even if he did, he wouldn’t be able to hear it.
Mahal, he couldn’t hear. He couldn’t hear anything. How was he supposed to rule without his hearing? How was he supposed to lead when the world was silent, when he couldn’t hear those around him, when he couldn’t hear Bilbo, his husband, he couldn’t hear Bilbo’s voice, would never hear it again-
Hands grasped his face and forced him to focus on Bilbo. His husband still looked terrified, but his eyes gleamed with purpose. When he spoke, he seemed to do so slowly, and Thorin realized he was over-emphasizing his words. No, just one word, one Thorin knew well. Thorin.
Thorin nodded. “Can you hear me?” he finally asked, unable to dispel the other fear: that his voice had been taken as well.
Bilbo nodded, and Thorin let out a sigh. At least there was that.
Bilbo tapped his cheek again, catching his attention. He pointed to Thorin, then mimed pulling him out. They would get him out. He nodded, suddenly so weary that all he wanted to do was collapse back beneath the rocks. His mind couldn’t even begin to grasp fully what had transpired, what it would mean. The panic in his gut kept churning, leaving him feeling ill.
A familiar hand caught his shoulder, and Thorin looked to Dwalin. Dwalin spoke his name, determination set into every line of his friend’s face, and Thorin nodded. Beyond him were Fili and Kili, both of them looking just as set as Dwalin.
He was alive. He could speak. He would get out from under the rocks.
Perhaps it was Miner’s Ear, he thought suddenly. When the miners went down with exploding powder, many would come back up, unable to hear for some time, sometimes a few minutes, sometimes a few days. But their hearing would always return. Perhaps the rockslide had done just that.
He would be fine. He breathed and focused on Bilbo’s hands caressing his face as Dwalin, Fili, and Kili began to dig him out.
He would be fine.
“It’s not Miner’s Ear.”
Thorin wouldn’t have even needed Ori to transcribe Oin’s words: Bilbo was certain that the looks on everyone’s faces would have said it all. He kept his hand on Thorin’s shoulder, firm and strong, when Thorin wilted on the stool at the news.
“Are you certain?” Balin asked.
Oin glared at him. “They’re not buzzin’, lad. Ears buzz when it’s Miner’s Ear. He’s said there isn’t a buzz to be felt or heard, and his ears are perfectly still. It’s not Miner’s Ear.”
Ori began to transcribe it, but Bilbo gave a quick shake of his head from behind Thorin, and Ori quickly began writing something else, to keep Thorin from worrying. You’re sure your ears don’t buzz? he wrote.
Thorin sighed. “No, there’s no buzzing, no feeling of a vibration, nothing at all. I don’t even know if I’m speaking to you or if I’m just putting air in my lungs.” His words had a slight slur to them, slight enough that Bilbo was certain only he’d picked up on it so far. You had to be close to hear it, and while everyone was crowded in, Bilbo had firmly taken his place by Thorin’s side and not allowed anyone besides Oin near. Thorin felt caged in and out of control as it was, and as well meaning as the company was, he wasn’t about to let it get any worse.
Dis hurried into the room, Dernwyn right behind her. The slamming of the door behind them made the floor tremble, enough that Thorin looked up to see them. “What’s going on?” Dis demanded. “All Fili said was that Thorin had been hurt.”
“Deaf, actually,” Bilbo said, grateful that he was behind Thorin where his husband couldn’t see them. There were only so many times Thorin should have to know they were explaining what had happened, again. “One of the mines collapsed and took his hearing.”
“I know you’re speaking,” Thorin cut in, startling them. “I can feel the vibrations when you talk, Bilbo. What’s going on?”
Bilbo blinked, surprised. He kept his hand on Thorin’s shoulder all the same. “We’re explaining what’s going on,” he said, and Ori dutifully transcribed it. “We’re not leaving you out, simply sparing you from having to read it all again.”
Thorin sighed and nodded, and he looked so defeated that Bilbo tightened his grip. “Tell him we’re here,” Bilbo said to Ori. “We’re here and we’re not leaving.” And that I love him.
The words were written quickly, read even faster, and everyone nodded in fierce agreement when Thorin looked up. He turned to Bilbo after a moment, and Bilbo gave him the best smile he could. His Thorin, his whole world silenced. This hadn’t been like his old uncle who’d gone deaf slowly and accepted it. This had been an accident, and to have a sense stolen from you, taken for no reason at all, there was nothing Bilbo could say or do to make it better.
But Thorin put his hand over Bilbo’s and offered a sad smile. “I love you, too,” he said softly.
Bilbo ignored the others and pressed a kiss to his husband’s lips. “We’ll figure it out,” he murmured, forgetting for a moment that Ori couldn’t have heard him to write it down. Before he could repeat it for Ori, however, Thorin nodded. His eyes were on Bilbo’s lips, and Bilbo said it again, more slowly this time.
His uncle had been decent enough at reading lips, but had still relied mostly on the motion language. Perhaps Bilbo could show him what he remembered and knew. He reached out and brushed his hand through Thorin’s hair, trying to keep him grounded and calm.
He’d barely brushed his hand past Thorin’s ear when Thorin hissed and jerked away from him, pain clouding his features. “What’s wrong?” He pursed his lips at himself when he realized his mistake. Of course Thorin couldn’t hear him.
Oin came forward, pulling Thorin’s hair away from his head. Bilbo stepped around and winced when he saw the wound. It was dark and jagged, and Bilbo could easily imagine the stone that had struck him going deeper, splitting his skull completely. He clutched at Thorin, forcing himself to breathe. Thorin was alive, he was fine.
It still helped when Thorin leaned back into him and Bilbo could feel his chest moving with each breath he took. Couldn’t hear him, couldn’t even see him, and yet Thorin still knew what he needed.
They didn’t need to speak with words. They’d understood each other by a simple gaze for years now. A touch would speak in much the same way, Bilbo had to imagine.
“Quite the blow,” Oin said, and he wagged his finger at Thorin. “Should’ve told me!”
“I was more focused on my hearing. I didn’t honestly feel it,” Thorin admitted after Ori had transcribed. He raised his hand towards the wound. “How bad is-“
“NO!” everyone shouted, and the effect should’ve been lost on someone who couldn’t even hear them. But Thorin still froze, eyes wide as he stared at the company who’d taken a sharp step forward as if to stop him. Bilbo carefully reached out and put Thorin’s hand back by his side.
“You don’t want to do that,” he said, his voice more calm than before. “Trust me.”
After that had been transcribed, Thorin carefully lowered his hand back to his lap. Oin began prodding at the wound, and really, there was no need to touch that closely. Bilbo forced himself to take a breath, again. Oin knew what he was doing. He was a much more advanced healer than Bilbo, and honestly, he was acting like a mother hen, clucking at her chicks the instant they did anything wrong.
Considering how Kili had burst into their quarters just a few hours ago, panting out the words ‘Thorin’ and ‘mine collapsed’ and ‘could be dead’, Bilbo felt he was entitled to feeling a little overprotective. Seeing Thorin, bleeding and panicking when he couldn’t hear, still trapped under a horrible amount of stone, hadn’t helped either. When they’d finally gotten him out, he’d clung to Bilbo and trembled, refusing to let go until Dwalin had helped him rise to get him to Oin. The sight of Thorin, his beautiful, strong, capable husband, reduced to a shaking mass of fear and pain-
All right, so he wasn’t going to let his husband anywhere out of his sight anytime soon. He could accept that. And Thorin would as well, if he knew what was good for him. He’d just have to deal with Bilbo fussing.
“Must’ve been quite the rock,” Nori said, wincing at the sight. “Could’ve been your whole head. Could’ve taken your whole ear.”
The memory didn’t so much as trickle down as it did suddenly spring to mind from the almost forgotten past. “That’s it!” Bilbo exclaimed, startling Ori, who’d been transcribing his brother’s words. “That’s it!”
“That’s what?” Kili asked. “Uncle?”
Bilbo moved around until he could see Thorin face to face. He’d nearly forgotten about that day as a child. A horrible day it had been, at the time, but he was never more grateful for the memory than he was now. “When I was a lad, my cousin slipped in the shallow part of the river and cracked his skull on a rock,” he explained. “Blood, tears, the whole works. It was dreadful. Worst of all, the strike took his sight and his hearing.”
Thorin looked ill at the thought of losing two senses and not just one. Bilbo pressed a warm hand against his husband’s cheek, still smiling. “Not two weeks later, he was back playing in the creek, sight and hearing restored.”
“How?” Fili said, staring. “What did you do?”
“Was it a medicine?” Kili asked.
“A draught?”
“Was it Elven?”
“Enough,” Thorin demanded. Apparently he hadn’t needed to hear his nephews to know they were rambling right over Bilbo. “Let him finish.” Ori didn’t even bother writing down what they’d said.
Bilbo grinned. “We didn’t do a thing.”
“Nothing,” Thorin said incredulously. “What, it simply…came back on its own?”
“A bruise, deep within,” Bilbo explained. Oin’s eyes widened with understanding.
“Of course! Didn’t notice the wound because it hadn’t bled out and matted your hair. You bled inside, lad, bruised your head a bit. Enough pressure to cut off your hearing. Mind if I try somethin’?” And Ori had barely managed to transcribe his words before Oin pressed on the side of Thorin’s head, between the cut and his ear.
Thorin scrambled away, clutching at his head. “Oin!” Dis hissed while Bilbo caught his husband and held him.
Oin looked far more pleased with himself than he should’ve. “Bruised,” he said. “Bilbo’s right: it could go away on its own.”
“Could?” Dwalin said, the first he’d spoken since he’d pulled Thorin out from the mine. “Could?”
“Can’t guarantee anythin’,” Oin said gently. “And I’m terribly sorry about it. But I’ve seen bruised heads before, and some have diminished a sense or two. Bilbo’s got the best hope we can think of: could be a temporary thing.”
Bilbo tried to keep his worry from his face, but he didn’t quite manage it in time. Thorin raised his head after the pain had settled and looked to him first. He didn’t even glance to Ori for an answer. “It’s not that, is it,” he said quietly.
“It is,” Bilbo said, firmly enough that Thorin would understand him by reading his lips alone. “It might not be, but it is.”
He had to hope it was. For himself, as well as for Thorin. Thorin could live without his hearing, of course he could. He would still take meals and hold Council meetings, stupid things that they were, and he could watch Fili and Dernwyn’s children grow. He could still rule Erebor. He could still love Bilbo.
But to lose a sense would be devastating. And if there was a chance that he could have his hearing back, Bilbo had to cling to that, for his husband’s sake and for his own.
“What did your cousin do?” Dernwyn asked. “What helped speed the process of healing?”
“Rest,” Bilbo said firmly. “Rest and cool cloths and good food. There was a tea his mother gave him, some herb that she swore would help with the swelling.”
“Tea and good food for healing: there’s a notion I never would’ve expected from a hobbit,” Bofur said with an easy grin, and Bilbo threw a nearby towel at him, inciting more laughter from the company. Thorin gave a small smile when he read the transcription, and Bilbo leaned his forehead against his husband’s.
I love you. I love you and I’m not leaving you. We’ll get through this together, he tried to say with his gaze.
Thorin gave a small nod, just one, but his smile grew a little. I know.
They’d get through it together.
“You know, it’d be easier to see and speak with him if you were inside instead of out here in the hallway.”
Some days, Dwalin truly enjoyed Bilbo’s company for his quick wit, his caring, and his perceptiveness. He was glad to have the hobbit as a true friend.
And then there were days like today where he wanted to shove him into a small hole not even he could get out of.
“Maybe I’m not goin’ in there,” he growled, crossing his arms. Wasn’t like Bilbo knew he’d been standing outside the door for twenty odd minutes now, glaring at the wood that separated him from his friend, his king.
“You just like admiring doors? You’ve been staring at it long enough.”
Damn the hobbit. “Got news for him, you can take it to him,” Dwalin said curtly, finally looking up at Bilbo.
It was worse than he’d thought. Bilbo didn’t look smug or reproachful. He looked sympathetic. He knew. He had to know.
“You need to speak with him, Dwalin.” The tone was soft and tender, more than he deserved.
“You can give him the message sure enough-“
“It wasn’t your fault.”
“Mahal’s beard it wasn’t,” Dwalin snapped. “I told him to go upstairs and back to you, because he was doin’ that thing you said he was, driftin’ off and thinkin’ of other things, too tired to even stand on his feet but too agitated to settle. Then I told him he could do one mine, that was it. Just the one mine, then I’d get him back to you.”
And hadn’t that been the absolute worst thing he could’ve done. His king, his brother for all intents and purposes, had disappeared under an avalanche of rocks and stones and hadn’t answered a single shout from Dwalin. No, he’d been too busy saving a miner to worry about himself.
“And if Thorin hadn’t gone down there?” Bilbo countered, but he was still too damn gentle about it. “Dwalin, he saved a miner’s life. The miner swore he’d have died if Thorin hadn’t shoved him towards the exit. He got himself tangled up in a mess someone else had left behind, and it was Thorin’s shoving that pushed him out of the mine. He would’ve been right under the rocks and probably died.”
It felt like being scolded in front of the Guard again, except this time, it was worse, because Bilbo was trying to make him feel better. And Dwalin had no right to feel better about this. “You should be fumin’ at me,” Dwalin yelled. “I about damn near got Thorin killed! If I hadn’t insisted he do the one mine, he wouldn’t have been caught, he’d still have his hearin’!”
“And if you hadn’t been there, Thorin would’ve done all the mines, and no one would’ve had the strength of arm and voice to start hauling rocks and calling for help,” Bilbo shouted back, apparently done being gentle. “You saved his life, he could’ve suffocated, Dwalin! But because you moved as fast as you did, he’s still alive and probably wondering why it takes me so long to wander down the hall and call for dinner!”
“That’s what you told him?” Dwalin couldn’t help but ask incredulously.
Bilbo snorted. “What else what I supposed to tell him? That his friend was standing outside the door, scowling at it like the wood had done him a personal offense?”
He wasn’t even going to ask how Bilbo knew he’d been there. It wasn’t worth the time or effort. “I shouldn’t face him,” he said, his voice sounding as defeated as he did. “Nearly got him killed.”
“Believe it or not, we’re both concerned about you. We were, even before Ori came around and told us how quiet you’ve been.”
He should’ve known his husband was in on the plot. Ori looked sweet and innocent, but under that knitted cardigan was a spine of steel. It was one of the things he loved most about his scribe. Still, tattling on him to Thorin and Bilbo wasn’t exactly a nice thing to do. What had he done to Ori?
“Don’t blame Ori,” Bilbo warned. He caught Dwalin by the elbow and hauled him forward before Dwalin could even protest. By the time he caught his feet, Bilbo had already flung the door open to where Thorin was sitting at the table, reading papers by the fire. The movement of the door must’ve caught his attention, and Thorin looked up, frowning slightly when he caught sight of Dwalin.
He didn’t look injured. His hair was pulled back a little from his right ear, in deference to the wound there. But Dwalin knew that he held an injury past anyone’s healing except for time and mercy. He swallowed and tried to pull his arm back from Bilbo. Mahal, he wasn’t an errant child.
Bilbo let him go, but only stood there until Dwalin moved forward. Thorin was watching him with a calculating gaze. Too knowing for his own good, too. He should’ve just gone to spar with his guards or something, and then Balin had given him the message and of course he’d known too.
A sketchbook was pushed into his hands, much like the one Ori carried everywhere with him. “We’re still working on reading lips,” Bilbo said. “Write to him.”
He made to protest, but then Thorin pinned him with that look, and there wasn’t much Dwalin could do against that. Despite not having his hearing, Thorin still had the look of a king, firm and unrelenting. The only other person Dwalin knew of who could look like that was Bilbo. And even Thorin didn’t say no when Bilbo looked that way.
Dwalin took the pen from the table Thorin sat at and began to write. Balin’s got a message for you about the Council. They want to meet regarding the possible purchasing of market space and several mines. He didn’t even flinch when he wrote the last word out.
“I’ll meet. They’ll have to know eventually about the loss of hearing.” Keeping that close to the chest had been one of the swifter moves Fili had ever done. With Kili beside him, they’d spoken of how Thorin was recovering from the cave-in, and mentioned nothing of the loss of hearing. The word had spread through Erebor like a wildfire.
He moved to give the book back to Bilbo, but Bilbo resolutely crossed his arms and refused to budge. Throwing it at him seemed like a prime idea. “That’s not why you’re here,” Thorin said. “Dwalin, what else is there?”
Dwalin swallowed. “It’s nothing-“
“Write,” Bilbo said stubbornly. Thorin leaned forward, waiting.
Fingers tight enough to nearly break the pen, Dwalin wrote in the swiftest script he could. I’m sorry you went into was crossed out and replaced by I’m sorry I told you to and replaced again with I’m sorry you
Thorin caught his hand the third time, his pressure gentle but insistent. “What happened was not your fault or mine,” he said. “We had no idea that the cave wasn’t secure.”
Dwalin shook his head resolutely. “No, I should’ve-“
“It wasn’t your fault,” Thorin said, pursing his lips. “And if this is the reason you’ve been avoiding me for the past two days, it’s a terrible excuse. If I’m angry about anything, it’s at the thought that you have let this settle in your gut for so long.”
Silence fell. Dwalin felt something almost like relief threatening to choke him, lodged too firmly in his throat. “M’still sorry,” he said at last.
“Don’t be,” Thorin said, and for a moment, Dwalin almost dared to hope that somehow, Thorin had heard him. But the slight hesitation between Dwalin’s words and Thorin’s was as telling as where Thorin had looked when he spoke: at his mouth. Reading lips; he was getting good at it.
“Gettin’ good at it,” he said, careful to enunciate. It only took another moment of hesitation before Thorin gave a small nod.
“Trying to. Bilbo’s a patient teacher.”
Dwalin caught the paper and wrote down his next words. I don’t want to know how you two read lips.
Thorin punched him in the arm, and as soon as Bilbo caught sight of what he’d written, he punched Dwalin in the other arm. Despite being bruised – and he never should’ve taught Bilbo how to fight, he had a mean right hook – Dwalin still felt better than he had the past two days.
The Council, Balin thought privately, was one of the most ridiculous things he’d ever had to deal with.
Oh, half of them weren’t bad. A great number of them were there for the same reason Thorin and Balin were: to ensure the future of Erebor. And while they disagreed on a great number of things, they were, for the most part, willing to put aside those differences – such as which was greater, the sapphire or the ruby, and which ale from the brewery was this week’s favorite – for the good of Erebor and its king and people.
Unfortunately, they usually wound up in spats, such as this one.
“The market space should go to a guild!”
“And if it does, what then for the winter? The men have asked for a greater, more permanent space within the mountain-“
“And why should we give it to them? We’re well equipped to go into Esgaroth and retrieve things from there!”
“The men are taller than the snow that’ll come down in the winter; they can make the trip more readily than we can.”
“We aren’t weak!”
“We’re not tall, either!”
“Enough!” Bilbo said, carrying his voice without shouting. The other dwarves grumbled but settled back. “Thank you. Ori, have you transcribed the…conversation?”
Would’ve been better deemed an argument, but Balin appreciated his tactfulness. What they would’ve done without the hobbit, he didn’t quite know, but he was grateful for the tactician Bilbo had become. It made things easier with a hobbit who knew politics like the back of his hand, thanks to his kin.
Plus, it left Balin more able to watch the typically amusing faces that followed any of his announcements. Three years doing this, and one would’ve thought they’d have gotten used to Bilbo and his manner of placating all parties as best he could without calling for battle…
“I have,” Ori said, as authoritative as Bilbo. Sitting next to Thorin, Ori looked noble himself in his Royal Scribe robes with his beard and mustache coming in nicely. But in his eyes there was still that inherent gentleness and kindness that Balin knew was simply Ori.
Dwalin had made a good choice indeed. Even now, standing behind Thorin, it wasn’t the king his brother was gazing at, but his husband. Balin hid a smile and focused on Thorin.
His cousin king seemed to be weighing choices on the paper before him, but after no more than a few moments looked to his husband. “And what are your thoughts?”
It was the quickest and best way of telling Bilbo, I would have your choice as mine. When Thorin sought guidance, he would turn to Balin for advice, or to Bilbo if Balin could not be there. Both would guide him as best they could. Even Fili had become a great wealth of knowledge and ideas, young and bright, and Balin would be proud to see him on the throne. These were who Thorin turned to when he wanted to hear opinions.
When Thorin wanted an answer, he would turn only to Bilbo.
And, as he always did, Bilbo had an answer ready for him. “Let the men come into the mountain and give them stalls in the best spots of the market, but give them only a few. Demand the same courtesy in their own market. If the weather becomes a problem, we have rooms within the mountain we can give them, and I’m certain Bard would allow us our merchants similar housing conditions if snow becomes a factor. We can’t expect to trade with them if we don’t let them in. This way, those merchants who don’t do well will be moved out and new ones put in their places. It’ll keep the competition friendly but strong.”
As Bilbo spoke, Balin found himself watching the hobbit. His friend moved his gaze briefly to various members of the Council, but truthfully his eyes were only for his husband. He enunciated more clearly than he usually did, yet didn’t slow down enough to let the others catch on. No one but those of their company probably knew what he was doing. Giving Thorin a chance to read his lips, and though Ori wrote it all down, Balin knew Bilbo’s gestures would go a long way with Thorin. They usually did.
It seemed Thorin had caught a significant amount of them, for he only glanced at Ori’s sheet briefly before nodding. “I concur. A healthy competition will encourage our own merchants to do their best and leave the best merchants from Lake-town to settle who will take the places on their own. I believe Bard will be amenable to this.”
Dwalin coughed. Thorin didn’t hear it, but Bilbo and Balin did, and they both shot him a sharp look before returning their attention to the table. Yes, they all knew that Bard would do just about anything for Bilbo, if asked. All these years later, and Balin privately thought the once bowman, now Ruler of Esgaroth, still held guilt for his part to play with the Arkenstone and how he’d turned Bilbo away. They were close friends now, and if there was ever anything to do with Esgaroth or the rebuilding of Dale that was to begin imminently, Bard would usually come himself, if just to see Bilbo and the company.
Bilbo could’ve asked Bard for his very bow, at one point, and Bard would’ve given it to him without hesitation. To ask for such a reasonable thing now, especially when it offered Bard a better chance of rebuilding Dale sooner, would be agreed upon within moments.
Muttering down at the other end of the table caught Balin’s attention, and he caught Dekir glaring at Bilbo. Balin couldn’t make out what the dwarf had said, but if Ori’s sharply inhaled breath and forced attention on his paper was anything to go by, it hadn’t been kind. Bilbo himself paid no attention to Dekir or his cousin Rutar, who were talking between themselves and glaring heatedly at the hobbit, but Bilbo’s lips were pursed in agitation and more than mild irritation.
It was usually how the meetings went. Dekir’s father, Mekir, was studied in the laws of their people to help with minor courts, though it had been less lately due to his loss of hearing. He was a kind dwarf who usually only scowled at Bilbo if for some reason the hobbit wasn’t being quite loud enough. Bilbo had tried to sit closer to Mekir to fix the problem, but Dekir had put forward such an offense against Bilbo that the hobbit had quietly just taken his usual place.
Balin clenched his fists under his table. There were few dwarves who held a slight towards Bilbo, and he honestly couldn’t fathom what bothered Dekir so much about Bilbo. Bilbo was more than fair to all the members of the Council, though some didn’t quite deserve it. Yet Dekir continuously undermined and belittled Bilbo when he could, giving snide comments always before Thorin entered the meeting. Always before Thorin arrived.
Balin supposed that with Thorin unable to hear them, Dekir and Rutar had assumed they were free to speak amongst themselves.
The meeting didn’t go on for much longer than that. The Council all bowed to Thorin instead of giving their customary spoken farewells, in deference to his loss of hearing, and Thorin gave them all a long bow back before leaving the room. Balin followed the others, and a good thing too, for Thorin got no further than the royal hallway before he stumbled.
Dwalin and Balin caught him from the sides, Bilbo from the front, and Ori was thankfully able to open the doors to the main room for them. Once seated, Balin crouched in front of Thorin and frowned. He looked queasy. “Dizzy?” Balin asked, enunciating his word clearly. Thorin nodded wearily.
A small mug appeared so suddenly all of them started. Tauriel managed to keep her eye roll to a minimum. “It will help,” she said, and though her words were laced with annoyance, her hands were gentle as they helped Thorin take the drink. He gave her a nod of thanks before taking a sip. He paused and glanced at Tauriel. The elf glared at him. Thorin swallowed the sip down, then gave a full body shudder.
Nothing Balin wanted a taste of, then. “Still having headaches?” he asked.
Bilbo nodded as Ori furiously wrote their words. “It’s to be expected, with the bruising. As dreadful as it is, I’m taking it as a good sign.”
Thorin coughed, having completely drained the mug. “That is the most foul thing I have ever tasted, and I once caught an orc’s tunic in the mouth,” he said, and Balin would’ve sworn he looked to scrape his tongue. “I don’t want to know what it is, and I do not want any more.”
“You’ll reconsider when you start feeling better,” Tauriel said knowingly, but she set aside the mug. “I was actually seeking your youngest nephew; he swore to practice archery with me today. I have a feeling, however, he’s playing with his nephew.”
“How do you not play with Holdred?” Bilbo asked, giving her a look. “I’ve seen many a young child, and I can say with no bias at all that Holdred is one of the cutest I’ve ever laid eyes on.”
“No bias at all,” Dwalin muttered. Ori took a break from writing Bilbo’s words to elbow his husband in the leg.
“Says the dwarf who sat and played with Holdred for hours upon hours and let the babe chew on his beard.”
Of all the dwarves Balin knew, no one could so quickly wring a blush from his brother as Ori could. “If I can’t handle a wee babe, shouldn’t be fit to lead the Guard,” he blustered, but his cheeks remained red.
The door quickly opened, and Kili hurried into the room, arrow and quiver thrown over his shoulder. His hair was a mess of tangled knots, and Balin grinned. “Sorry, Holdred,” he explained while pointing to his hair. “That and bumping into Dekir and his cousin. Remind me again how much longer they’ll be here? Because I’m done with them both.”
“You and everyone else,” Ori muttered. Balin frowned, recalling the quiet conversation Dekir had held in the Council meeting.
“Which reminds me: what were they talking about? In the Council meeting?”
Ori glanced at Bilbo, surprisingly enough. Bilbo finally gave a nod. “They kept talking about ‘the plan’ and ‘needing the right dwarf’. Among other things,” Ori couldn’t help but add, and Bilbo quickly took over.
“Whatever it is, it’s obviously not something they want anyone else privy to. And given their attitudes, I’m not keen on whatever it is.”
“They won’t let you sit near them,” Thorin said. “It’s obvious they don’t want you to know.”
“Won’t let me near ‘em, either,” Dwalin said. “Or Ori, or Fili.”
Now that Balin thought about it, it was quite clear that they’d kept themselves from the others in the Council quite deliberately. “It’d be a boon to know what they’re doing,” Balin said. “We’ve finally got peace and stability; I’d hate to see two young dwarves cause a ruckus.”
“Or worse,” Dwalin added grimly.
It was a terrible thought to think of. But when it came to the royal line and the future of Erebor, especially when thinking of all they’d gone through to get this far, it was best to consider the worst idea before the better one. It meant everyone got out alive.
“Kili, I want you and Fili to do your best to engage them; use Gimli to help, as he’s still young enough to perhaps not be viewed as a threat,” Thorin ordered. Kili nodded, and he and Tauriel both left. “Dwalin, have some of your guards tail them, if you can. Balin, you will have to be my voice in this matter, and Ori my ears.”
Dwalin gave a short nod. “Be more than happy to.”
“Wait a minute, what am I supposed to do?” Bilbo asked, having realized that Thorin wasn’t going to appoint him anything. “Stand around and do nothing?”
“Preferably, yes,” Thorin said once Ori had transcribed for him. As soon as Bilbo began to object, Thorin held up his hand. “I know that they say unkind things about you, and if they truly have plans of a dangerous nature, I want you nowhere near them.”
“I can handle myself-“
“And I know you’re telling me you can handle yourself, and I know you can. I can’t hear to protect you anymore: please keep away from them. Please.”
Bilbo let out a sigh but moved to brush the marriage braid away from Thorin’s face. It always seemed like such an intimate moment when he did so, though he moved naught but hair. Yet it always left Balin feeling as if it were a private moment between the both of them that no one else should see. “You don’t need to protect me all the time,” Bilbo said quietly. “I can protect you, too.”
Ori held the paper out for Thorin to look at, but the king didn’t so much as glance at it. “I know,” he said, and Balin had a feeling that even if he hadn’t understood Bilbo’s words, he’d known the message behind them all the same.
Bilbo finally gave a sharp nod. “You and I’ll figure out how to handle the small courts system the way Mekir wants it so he can either return home or send his son back.”
“We could send him back now-“
“Mekir’s knowledge and wisdom is invaluable,” Bilbo told his husband after his words had been read. “And others would start prying into why he’d been told to leave. Besides, we have a chance to figure out what Dekir and Rutar have planned if they’re close by. Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer.”
“Close enough to strangle ‘em,” Dwalin added. Bilbo rolled his eyes but gave a quick grin.
“I’m not entirely certain that was the point of the age-old phrase, but yes, close enough to do that too, I suppose.”
Thorin huffed a laugh when Ori reluctantly transcribed their words. He looked less green already, and when he stood, it was without aid. The elves could be a prickly bunch, their two elves excluded, but they knew their herbs and healing. “In two days time, before the next meeting, we’ll meet here again and share what we know. The sooner we know of what they intend to do, the better for us.”
Balin secretly hoped that it was nothing dreadful. They had allies around Middle-Earth, firm trade agreements with the cities of Men, and Mirkwood was being taken back every day. Erebor was flourishing under her ruler and king, and never before had they enjoyed such prosperity, thanks to Bilbo’s tactful words and gentle nature.
Yet he had a terrible feeling in his gut that it was all about to be overturned.
