Actions

Work Header

Oathbound

Summary:

A strange and creepy dwarf arrives at the gates and demands to speak with Thorin and the Loremaster. His story and Bilbo's reaction to it. A slice of life from a reborn Erebor.

Work Text:

"You're lucky Lord Dwalin didn't see that," Mun said laconically, cutting his eyes at Bur as the other guard sidled back into the guardpost. He leaned back against a gatehouse wall that still had the shivery, gritty feel of new-cut stone. "Have you down the training sands in a minute, that one, with a mattock up your arse to boot."

Bur's chuckle was loud in the tiny room. "If he had to piss as bad as I did, he'd have gone himself, arse-mattock or no," he said, eyes twinkling. "I heard once that in the Blue Mountains, they..." he paused, head coming up and looking out the window overlooking the approach to the gate. His vision was quite a bit better than Mun's, which was one of the reasons he was assigned to this duty. He could see furtive movement close to the gate. Very close, he realized. "Someone coming," he murmured intently. "Only one, though. Khuzd." At his words the companionable energy shifted completely and became all business.

"Khuzd? Alone?" Mun replied quietly. They exchanged a wary glance. Single dwarves usually meant trouble of one type or another. Several minutes later, Mun leaned out to peer down to the scruffy figure at the gate. "State your name and business, traveler, if you wish to enter Erebor." The dwarf before the gates looked like he might be a bandit or beggar, dressed in filthy ragged clothes with iron plates sewn into it. Effective armor, but made him look a bit like an orc, Mun thought.

For his part, Bur thought the dwarf looked like he'd fought his way out of a tomb. Middling height, he had the tea-colored skin and steel-grey hair of the Ironfists, though his skin had an unhealthy grey pallor that made him look dreadful. Black eyes as cold and sharp as chips of obsidian peered from under tangled brows, and both beard and hair were cut raggedly short, another mark of trouble. The dwarf had a short spear in the Ironfist style across his back and an axe at his belt - both weapons were old and high quality. They also showed signs of tremendous use, though they looked well maintained and, Bur would bet, were kept as sharp as razors.

"Brogi," came the reply in a strange, growling voice. Ah, Bur thought, recognizing the sound. Throat wound. Still, though, not a response that inspired comfort; no dwarf of good standing would... "Brogi Oathbound." Bur felt his thoughts sliding away sideways. Ah, shit, he thought numbly. Oathbound. Not good, not good at all. The growling voice came slowly, seeming to be trying to dredge the words up out of memory and picking them with care. "None... within this hold are..." the strange dwarf said before repeating himself more clearly. "None within this hold are under my doom." Almost immediately he added "To my knowledge." Fair enough, Bur thought. Nothing but Mahal can get between the Oathbound and his sworn task. Still, he grimaced. Lord Dwalin wasn't going to like this. Brogi stared at Bur and Mun for a long, cold moment. "I seek a judgment from your king and the Lore."

"Aaaye," Bur replied nervously, meeting Mun's eyes with a shrug. This was far, far beyond their mandate. "We'll... uh... take you to the court, then?" At his companion's furtive gesture, Mun peeled off to the barracks to get more troops for the escort. For his part, the strange dwarf just nodded and stood like a stone. Suspecting that he would end up dead if he asked the stranger to disarm he decided to try small talk. "You, uh, you from down South?" Bur ventured. There was no reply.

=

Later, Bilbo heard tales of the strange procession as it made its way through the halls of Erebor. The reclamation was just hitting its stride and every set of hands that could work was doing so. Half the city was up on scaffolding along the main routes but the sight of a grim, grey stranger stomping along uncaring in the middle of a swirling ring of guards was enough to capture anyone's attention. The first the hobbit knew of it, though, was when the doors of the court opened and the group streamed in.

Dwalin, Thorin, Balin and Bilbo were sorting through a table full of records of reclaimed supplies but broke off at the sight of the strange procession pouring through the doors. "Court's not in session so this better be bloody good," Dwalin growled at the guards with a fearsome glare. "Bur, I told you what I was going to do if..." Bilbo noticed the others had stopped at the far end of the hall and only then saw the odd figure in the midst of the throng. It was clear Dwalin had spotted him as well. Stepping forward, Dwalin put himself between the guards and the stranger they escorted and the king. "Who's this, then?" He asked with a gesture at the stranger. He paused for a moment, seeing Bur and Mun both, and barked "And who's watching the Mahal-damned gate?!"

Bur grimaced and tried to give a salute and nod at the same time, looking almost like he was having a spasm. "Brogi Oathbound, to, er, see the king and Loremaster, Lord Dwalin, sir," he mumbled. Bilbo eyed the stranger cautiously. Oathbound, he puzzled. That's a new one. "Reki's at the gate."

"Reki's sun-blind as a half-mole goblin, idiot! Get back to your assigned posts!" Dwalin fumed before Thorin's throat clearing brought him back to business. "Right, I'll settle up with you lot later. No offense to you, Oathbound, but stay there among the guards, aye?" Brogi acted as though he hadn't noticed any of it, cold black eyes staring at the group standing around the table full of parchments.

Thorin stepped up onto the dais that held the throne, moving into the beam of light shining down onto it. He settled himself into the imposing stone chair with a wince as his injuries pulled but gave the newcomer a stern and regal look. "The king you have found," he said (though Bilbo thought the effect rather ruined by the dust on the royal tunic). Bilbo hurriedly stepped up beside him as Balin had drilled into him that he should stand there as consort. "What business has an Oathbound with Erebor?"

Bilbo thought the stranger was deeply odd by the standards of every dwarf he'd ever seen. His appearance was curious, with a greyish hue to his skin that Bilbo had never seen before on any race but Orcs. Even more noteworthy than the skin, though, was the stillness. Dwarves were not a still people by nature, any more than hobbits; he'd never seen one that wasn't moving, working, doing, or at least twiddling and fidgeting. This dwarf stood like a statue carved of stone, an impression only helped by the greyish cast. His eyes were flat and black, utterly emotionless, and in spite of himself Bilbo understood why the guards had gotten a case of what the Shire called 'the nerves'. The stranger's harsh, gravelly voice did little alleviate his concerns.

"You are the king," Brogi said, staring at Thorin, though it wasn't clear if it was a question, a statement, an accusation, or exactly what. Slowly, he ground out "I seek a judgment. My Oath... was fulfilled, but not by my hands." For the first time, he moved, eyes looking right and left before landing on Bilbo. "There are those here who are not khuzd."

Thorin nodded regally, this time with a grim expression of his own. "My Consort, Bilbo Baggins, is a hobbit, and is also part of my council and court." He gestured at those present. "Also present are Dwalin and Balin, the sons of Fundin, my Guard Captain and Chief Advisor respectively. Who are you and where are you from?" The dwarf didn't react as Bilbo expected - he was quite familiar with objections, but dwarvish objections tended to be loud if not violent. The stranger just stared, eyes sliding from Bilbo to Thorin. Thorin motioned without looking away from the stranger. "Balin, fetch Loremaster Frun." With a nod, the white-haired advisor bowed and withdrew.

"Right, all of you... out," Dwalin said, waving at the guards. Bilbo suspected they would be waiting right outside, but that didn't upset him. Better they were close by... in case. In case of what he wasn't sure but the stranger made him feel ill at ease somehow. As the group swirled around, slow to disperse and casting curious and nervous looks at the Oathbound, the old grey dwarf took no notice. He stood as though carved of basalt, unmoving and seeming not to even breathe, while everyone else glanced at each other. Dwalin sighed; he knew why the guards hadn't asked, but he was made of sterner stuff. "Oathbound, your pardon, but you must disarm if you wish to approach. I will personally stand surety for your weapons, but..." he shrugged. "The King is mine to guard. Your Oath is your own."

Brogi gave the huge dwarf a look that would have chilled Bilbo to his core for a long moment. Surely we're safe, he thought, then remembered how unpredictable some dwarves could be. If he attacks, the hobbit thought, I'm not sure what I should do. After a long tense moment, though, the grey figure nodded once and slowly set down his axe and spear onto the granite tiles. "I can leave my weapons." He seemed almost to be reminding himself than speaking to the room. "My Oath is fulfilled... although..." With this he wound down, simply staring, and no more was forthcoming. Even so, Bilbo was interested to note both Thorin and Dwalin nodding. Ah, he thought. More obscure Dwarven mysteries nobody bothered to tell me about. I should have known.

After only a few short minutes, Balin bustled back in accompanied by the tiny, wizened shape of Loremaster Frun. The diminutive dwarrowdam looked almost like a hobbit in size, despite her wispy grey beard, but looks could be deceptive - Bilbo thought she was among the most formidable dwarves he knew. They had clashed a few times in the early days and he still nursed the scars from her all-too-incisive perceptions. Today she wore a plain scribe's robe and blue hood, though her chain of office jingled around her shoulders with hammers and anvils cast of various metals and beads of all stones and gems strung on it. "My king," she greeted Thorin in a voice absurdly deep for one so small. "You summoned me. I am here." Thorin beckoned her close to the throne.

"There is an Oathbound dwarf here for a judgment," Thorin murmured in a low voice, bending close to her once she approached. "He is... odd. Disturbing. But he needs your aid more than mine, I'd reckon." She nodded once and gave the peculiar rolling shrug Bilbo had only seen from scribes. With that, Frun turned to the immobile figure in the center of the hall. Dust danced in the light shafts from the mirrors above, making his unnatural stillness even more eerie.

"Loremaster," Brogi growled in his damaged voice. "There are those here who are not khuzd." Thorin drew in a breath but Frun was already speaking, deep tones rolling through the hall, as smooth as Brogi's were rough.

"Yes and no," Frun replied. As always, Bilbo was amazed at such a huge voice in such a tiny body. "Lord Bilbo is khuzdbaha by Royal decree, and One to the King. As amrâl and One to a khuzd, he is likewise khuzd under the Lore according to the ruling of Durin III for the dwarf Narvi Truehand. He is known by the Lore. Set your fears at rest by knowing." Bilbo sighed in relief at the increasingly familiar formula; the last thing he wanted was that battle re-opened. His status as a non-dwarf at court had been hotly contested for over a month by various factions while Frun made up her mind and did her research, but one thing you had to give Frun... when she decided, she decided for good. All the factions were also terrified of her, so the issue didn't arise again. For her part, Frun didn't even glance around at the hobbit as she spoke. "What is your need?"

Brogi paused, flickers of almost-expressions passing across his grim face reminding Bilbo of clouds scudding across a night sky. In halting words, picking and setting each word down like a man stepping gingerly across loose rocks in a stream, his story unfolded. "My Oath was fulfilled, but not by my hands. There are other complications. I seek to know... what action is appropriate." Flat black eyes gazed up at the throne and the dwarves (and hobbit) upon it. "Shall I speak?" Frun nodded once and Thorin gestured for him to continue. Brogi settled himself firmly on his feet like any other dwarf about to tell a story. Not only was it the first shifting of position Bilbo had seen since Brogi's arrival, it seemed an oddly familiar touch for such an odd-seeming dwarf and (the hobbit hoped) a good omen.

After a long, trenchant pause, Brogi spoke again. "Many years ago Brogi son of Drogi was a guard in the service of Lord Farkû the merchant in Samirzalud. His father Drogi was a merchant in his own right in the service of the same Lord. His amrâl Varga daughter of Gurun was a guard in the service of the same Lord." Bilbo wondered why Brogi was speaking in the third person, assuming he was speaking of himself. Unusual for a dwarf, he thought; usually you can't get them to stop bragging. Still, glancing around, he noticed Thorin and Frun were raptly attentive. "A caravan departed to the Iron Hills. Drogi went as a factor. Varga went as a guard. Brogi had other duties." The rasping voice was almost hypnotic in a way, Bilbo realized; no trace of emotion was visible on the cold face in front of him, but yet... "That caravan was destroyed by orcs." Thorin grunted softly; Bilbo wondered what he had missed as a non-dwarf, but Frun was nodding slowly as well.

"Brogi son of Drogi was..." Brogi paused and a shiver went through his entire body, once, like a flicker across a horse's haunch to drive away flies. "...tumun." Even Dwalin winced at this; Bilbo didn't know what the word meant, but to get a reaction from the stoic guard captain was noteworthy. For his own part, imagining how it would feel to lose his parents and Thorin at the same time, he suspected he knew what 'tumun' meant. The dwarf's next words confirmed it. "Food had no flavor. Sleep brought no rest. Brogi searched for answers and finally learned the truth. The orcs had been in service to one called the Necromancer. They dwelled in a ruin in the forest to the south of this mountain. Brogi took an Oath that he would destroy the Necromancer as he had destroyed Brogi himself. This dwarf's life was over and so Brogi son of Drogi died. I was born in my Oath." At this Bilbo's suspicions came roaring back. Was this dwarf truly the walking dead? What had they let into their mountain? Frun shook her head grimly, but Thorin was nodding. Bilbo knew his husband understood something of hopeless quests, though to go against the Necromancer...!

"I went north to this place, this filthy pit in the forest hills, and lived there in secret, killing every orc I could find. I sought always to find the evil spirit that governed the place." He paused. "Orcs I slew by the hundreds as year piled upon year. I hope that I killed the orcs among them who killed Drogi and Varga but there is no knowing. Even so, cutting the fingers of the hand that killed them would not fulfill my Oath. Wargs, wolves, even trolls at work in the deep places I slew, but the Necromancer could not be found. I was unable to strike at the head." Brogi paused, staring at memories only he could see and Bilbo shivered. What a way to spend a life! "I killed and killed but to no purpose. My true enemy eluded me." Brogi paused for a long moment, blinking once and staring down at the cracked granite tiles. "I knew my death awaited me in him. I had no rune weapon strong enough to pierce a sorcerer's magics. No mithril axe of old. I had only my hatred and my Oath." Frun whispered something Bilbo suspected was a prayer. "But I would not shirk my Oath. I was already a dead dwarf walking. And so I fought on."

"Year upon year upon year passed, tens of years, and no closer was I to my goal. The orcs whispered of me by this time. They called me 'the elf hunter', because it did not seem to them that anyone but an elf could kill so many of them so quickly and silently." He glanced back up at the throne, and this time Bilbo recognized the flatness in the old dwarf's eyes - despair. It was an ancient, depthless despair, and his own inhale sounded harsh in his ears as Bragi started speaking again. Thorin's hand touched Bilbo's shoulder briefly in comfort as the story continued. "But then there was a change. The change came at night, though I do not know what night. Time has no meaning for the dead. But I saw a light where no light should be, then another. There were tall figures moving in the ruined parts of the fortress where orcs did not go. I thought perhaps the Necromancer was finally to come forth, and so I crept after them." He paused and the hall was deadly still. "There was a group there. Two elves, one a she-elf, and two old men. They were fighting a... thing. A dark thing, a man made of iron and fire and hatred. I realized that this dark thing was the Necromancer. I saw at last the enemy I had sworn myself against. And yet. As I poised to spring on him and fulfill my Oath at last, the she-elf cast out a blazing bright fire from a talisman and destroyed him." Another of those full body shivers went through the old dwarf.

"Surely..." Bilbo said, only to fall silent at the grip of Thorin's clutching hand on his shoulder. He stopped speaking immediately; this was clearly some deeper dwarf mystery than he had ever encountered. Brogi glanced over at him, black eyes landing on Bilbo and pressing down like lead weights before shifting back to Thorin and Frun.

Brogi clasped his hands, another echo of the dwarf that was; Bilbo saw this gesture in every story told inside Erebor, signifying the end. He wondered what Brogi was like before... everything he was describing. In spite of himself, his heart went out to the dwarf but the grating voice continued. "This is my story. My Oath is fulfilled. My Oath cannot be fulfilled. Both are true. Both cannot be true. I have seen my enemy cast down... but it was not my hand that did the casting, as I swore." Brogi turned to Frun and for the first time, a hint of emotion seemed to appear on his face. "But... there is more. I will speak it freely, for the dead feel no shame. When the Necromancer fell, I realized my mind had not been my own. I was being used by him as a tool to cull the weak and fearful among his servants, nothing more. He had bent me to his purpose though I was sworn before Mahal to his destruction. I..." the old dwarf paused, giving yet another shiver, this one stronger and more severe. "I saw the truth when he was gone. My Oath was a thing of mockery and scorn to him, of no more moment than a breath of wind. I ask for a judgment from the Lore. What do I do? Do I swear to avenge myself on the one who took my kill from me? Do I lie down and die? Did I fail at the last? Did I delay too long? Have I acted rightly?" The last sentence was said in a voice so guttural and harsh that Bilbo could barely understand it but Frun stepped forward.

"I have heard you," she said softly. She stood for a moment, toying with her chain of office with her fingers. "Hear now a Loremaster's judgment, given before the king of this place and Mahal Himself in this room beneath the stone." Bilbo had heard her say this formula a few times before, but never before with such a still room. Balin, Thorin and Dwalin all seemed almost entranced, staring at the scene before them. Frun stood still, apparently thinking, for longer than was comfortable - to him, anyway, though the dwarves seemed prepared to sit until the next Age of the Earth. The sounds of the rest of the mountain were unheard here in the Receiving Hall, and it seemed to Bilbo as though they were in some fairytale of his childhood stories. Frun's deep voice finally broke the silence. "This is my parsing of this story and the Lore. First, I say that if your story is complete, you have honored your Oath scrupulously. You do not say that you delayed, you did not turn aside in distraction, you sought always to achieve your goal, so I say to you that you hold no fault. You have complied with the three requirements of the Final Oath as set out in too many stories to list. Set your fears at rest by knowing. This is my first ruling." Brogi nodded once, though he shivered again and his eyes slid shut briefly before reopening. Dwalin's grunt of approval was loud in the stillness.

"Second, I say to you that you do not and cannot know the workings of Mahal's will. As told in the story of Muli and the Single Seed, Mahal's plans are deep and complex. To say that you did not accomplish your purpose is to do a disservice to our Creator. It may be that, as in Torgun and the Forge, you were acting as His eyes. You slew many among the host of the enemy, and that is no small thing; who knows what serpents might have grown from the eggs you crushed? Do not discount your own works. Further, the Necromancer may have thought to have made you his servant but that does not mean he was able to do so fully. The enemy deceives but he may also be deceived in turn. You know only that he thought it true, not that it was. It may well be - indeed I suspect that it is - the truth that the Necromancer's pride in his supposed achievement was his own undoing by allowing you to endure." Frun grinned fiercely, looking for all her tiny size like a warrior. "Did our Lord not forge a chain strong enough to hold even the Great Lord of Darkness himself captive and powerless like a babe before the court of the Hammer Wielders? There is no dark power strong enough to overcome Mahal." The dwarves all bowed their heads as one, even Brogi. "I therefore judge that you did not fail, but that you may account your Oath fulfilled, since you were there at the end to see your enemy unmade. How would a dwarf be present for the fall of such a great darkness at the hands of elves and wizards if not for the will of Mahal? I believe you were His eyes, and I think also that glad He was in the seeing. Set your fears at rest by knowing. This is my second ruling." Bilbo glanced at Balin, who he realized was weeping silently. At that moment, he realized his own cheeks were likewise wet and he dared not look at Thorin. Bilbo would have expected some degree of relief from Brogi but the Oathbound looked, if anything, a bit lost.

"Third, I say to you it is incorrect to ask the Lore what to do next. You were accounted dead for the duration of your Oath, but that Oath is done, and you live. You must again decide for yourself. The Lore guides, it does not and cannot compel. This is my final ruling." Frun paused, and for the first time Bilbo could remember, she looked a bit uncertain. After a moment, she continued. "I have spoken as Loremaster, now I will speak as Frun. Your Oath is fulfilled. You... Brogi son of Drogi... may be reborn, if you wish to return to hearth and forge, though it may be a struggle. You have dwelt long in dark places, with only filth for company." Bilbo grimaced, suddenly understanding. If he had spent decades hiding in a dark fortress and hunting orcs, he would probably be grey and odd-looking too... though if he was being honest, he would simply be dead. Frun continued. "You are free to swear further vengeance if you feel it necessary to do so; you are also free to return to the company of the living. This is rare, to be sure. Few among the Oathbound fulfill their Oath, and so there is no marked path to follow." She paused, and her face became compassionate. "If it were your choice to return, I would recommend you live for a while as a penitent in the scriptorium where life is more quiet and ordered than most places in this mountain, and it will be easier to remember how to be alive. But this guidance arises from the heart of Frun and not from the Lore, so take or leave the advice as you please." With this final bit of counsel, Frun shook her chain to make the hammer pendants strike against the anvils with a ringing sound and then stepped back.

Thorin cleared his throat. "You have heard the judgment of the Lore, now hear the judgment of the king. For the time being..." he said slowly, glancing at Frun, "you are welcome to stay here, bound only by the rules that bind all. There is food and shelter and work for your hands, if you desire it. If you decide to take another Oath, you will be given food and drink to provide for you on your way; if you stay, you will be found a place where you can be useful." Bilbo was familiar enough with dwarves to recognize the value of the last statement; this more than anything else was a reminder to Brogi of what life as a dwarf was about.

For his part, Brogi simply stood still in the middle of the floor. His face showed an expression for the first time... it was clear he was confounded. Finally, he murmured "I do not know what to do. I have been so long without choices." He stared at the floor for a moment and then looked up. Glancing at Frun, he said "It seems to me that the she-elf did me the favor of accomplishing what I knew I could not. I do not feel it... rasup... to blame her for it." Frun nodded with a smile as though he had done something clever but he looked back at Thorin. "But... I don't know what else to do." He paused, closing his eyes again. In an even harsher voice than normal he said "I wasn't supposed to live."

Dwalin coughed and stepped forward. "I ain't tellin' you what to do," he began, ignoring Thorin's snort. "But the Halls come soon enough for us all," the captain said with a grimace. "Don't be so fast to cast off the life Mahal has given back to you. If the time should come that you need work for your hands, I'd welcome you to train the guards if you promise not to kill 'em in the doin' of it. If half your story is true - and I don't doubt a word of it - you could probably teach all of 'em some things about fightin' that would save their lives one day." Dwalin gave his usual feral grin. "You might have noticed on the way in that they're a bit... green." Brogi nodded blankly, though Bilbo wondered if he'd even heard the comment. Then he saw the barest flex of the mouth beneath the short beard. It wasn't a smile... but it might be one day. Who knows, he thought. Maybe there's a good ending to this tale yet.