Work Text:
“Bilbo says Hobbits don’t ever leave the Shire, but for us he did. Have we... Tharkûn have we done him wrong?”
“Believe me, if you had, he’d be the first to tell you. It is indeed rare for Shire-folk to venture into the wider world, but it happens, and I firmly believed it was best for him.”
Bilbo pretended he hadn’t heard any of it as he pushed open the doors to the room the company was using for this lunch. They did not get nearly enough time together now the mountain was reclaimed, and this had become a sort of ritual. To try and find a mealtime together, to catch up and share stories outside of the running of the mountain. Thorin and Gandalf were already inside, he and Ori had come from the libraries, gathering more of the company en route. By the time they made it to the solid doors, they had all come together.
The others were not so courteous as they filed in to take seats.
“What’s this about our hobbit?”
Never mind that it was a private conversation between Thorin and Gandalf, never mind that it was about him. They were a curious bunch, and especially so about one of their own. Which he had firmly become, somewhere down the line. And now every set of eyes were flicking between him and Gandalf, wonderful.
“I was simply explaining that this adventure was good for Bilbo, and quite frankly necessary, given his Tookish blood and...”
“Gandalf,” he cut the wizard off sharply, “it’s not your story to tell.”
“You are as much a Took as you are a Baggins, and after your parents died you forced down a side of you that...”
“And who’s fault was that?”
The room went deathly still.
He had not meant to snap, nor make such an accusation, but there was no taking the words back now. The tension could have been cut with a knife, and though he was certain Gandalf knew exactly what he meant, the others clearly did not. His outbursts were few and far between and almost always warranted, his dwarrow knew that, they would not take it lightly or brush it off. Already he could see confusion and anger starting to bloom, worry and the beginnings of comprehension at what he’d implied.
“Bilbo...”
“What I mean by that is that it’s a private matter, not for you to meddle in or air about. If we could perhaps move on to other topics of conversation?”
He had not defused it, not even a little, but nobody pushed. He was certain they would ask, his words had been cutting and severe, his tone was sharp, but even Gandalf had gone quiet.
In the end, it was Bofur who saved him, rolling his eyes and loudly commenting on how he’d had to skip breakfast and how much he’d been looking forward to lunch for hours now so let's all sit down and eat. It did the trick, especially with a grumbling Dori confirming that Bofur had indeed been complaining for over an hour. Those who’d had their mouths opening like they’d been about to ask more questions or pry had snapped them shut, and they’d dug into their lunch instead. Gandalf had excused himself quietly, stating he had business to attend to, and promptly vanished out the door. If he could have bitten the words back, he would have, but they were out in the open now.
As much as lunch was supposed to be a break from work, their duties tended to come up. Whether they’d have enough usable fabric to keep everyone well dressed in the coming months, how the food and fuel stores were faring, if the weather was clear enough for hunting parties as winter deepened, if any interesting developments or discoveries had been made. It acted as an unofficial council for Thorin really, private with trusted sources of information, letting him know where they stood. Less rigid and formal, almost like they were still on the quest. Still, there was an undercurrent of tension at this meal, a question bitten back on every tongue.
Damn meddling wizards.
To his surprise, his dwarrow kept their questions back, and Ori dragged him out and back to the bowels of the library the second they could be excused. Ori who clearly had questions but broke into a ramble about finding the architectural maps and diagrams to the mountain instead, dragging Bilbo into a conversation about old healer's gardens and how they might regrow them at some point. To his credit, Ori listened to and noted down every instruction he gave for the best ways to raise those herbs, even in conditions such as these. He rather wished he had his father’s book, with it’s hand drawn diagrams and careful descriptions. If they could find the old gardens on the maps, he would certainly look at getting them growing before he had to leave.
Should he decide to leave.
It had all become so dreadfully complicated.
Gandalf had been right to say he’d needed this adventure, that it had done him good, but he really had intended on going home after, if he survived at all. He hadn’t expected to find the other half of his heart in Thorin, hadn’t expected to feel the weight slipping off his shoulders even as he faced death time and again. The release of finally stepping over the boarders of the Shire to see what there was to see after so long forcing himself to fit the role he had inherited too young. The feelings his mother had spoken of when she explained her adventuring, why she could never stay settled, he’d never understood it so well. For so long as winter lay over Erebor, he would remain, but come the spring, he truly was not sure what he would do. Winter would not last forever, eventually he would have to choose.
He had not let his thoughts linger on that choice much, there was so much to do that he’d simply let the thoughts fall by the wayside. What happened come spring had simply become a problem for later, for they had so many more pressing issues. Gandalf had just had to bring it all up, meddle, set his thoughts looping. So much so that even Ori’s careful distractions did not fully serve their purpose, so much so that his friend had been forced to shake his attention to the time at the end of the day.
He was deeply grateful for Ori’s friendship and support, and as he wandered from the library, he resolved to find a way to repay his kindness.
Bilbo stepped into Thorin’s rooms in the early evening, basking for just a second in the smoky warmth of the fire as it enveloped him. He was growing slowly more used to the chill of the stone, but this warmth was so very welcome.
Just as the company tried to carve out mealtimes together, it had become tradition for the two of them to spend their evenings together, to take a meal and discuss the day and relax. A place where Thorin could set down the weight of the kingdom from off his shoulders, where he could breathe and simply be the dwarf Bilbo knew, without the eyes watching his every move, without all of it. It provided that solace for the both of them, and precious time alone. He knew the whole mountain seemed convinced he’d be consort under the mountain before the thaw, but he still did not know if he would stay. If he could stay.
Before the dragon, curled around each other in that bed in Laketown, he’d told himself if they survived retaking the mountain, he’d give Thorin his heart and accept whatever came next. But then the goldsickness, the battle, the burden of the kingdom, it had all been so much and he just needed to be certain. That this was what was best for him. That this was what was best for Thorin.
More than anything that this was what was best for Thorin.
He could not risk Erebor losing her king for his selfish love. If it was better for Erebor, for his friends, for Thorin, he could take the pain, he could endure it. He could give up Thorin and his own happiness if it was for the best.
Still, he could not give up these quiet evenings just yet.
“Bilbo.”
In the moments he’d been basking in the sudden warmth, Thorin had looked up from the paperwork spread in front of him. He worked so hard for his people, harder than most would ever know. He crossed the room to Thorin’s desk, noting requests and reports from the repair teams made up most of it.
“Are you almost done?”
“It seems unending, but I am ready to take a break from it until morning.”
“Good, it wouldn’t do for Erebor to lose her king from exhaustion.”
Thorin laughed softly in response, and it was a wonderful sound.
“You fuss over me, Bilbo, but I am certain Erebor thanks you for it. I thank you for it.”
He sank into one of the chairs, the days exhaustion finally catching him yet again. Shire-folk weren’t really made for long dark days or stone roofs, and he found himself more tired with each passing day, though not beyond what he could manage. Everyone was tired, he was hardly going to waste time or energy complaining. Thorin seemed just as weary as he sank into the chair beside his, the fire cracking in front of them. A small table between them held two cups, and he knew one was a tea blend they’d managed to put together. Food would come later in the evening, but for now, they both sorely needed this time to simply unwind.
“Bilbo?”
“Hmm?"
“What did he mean? Gandalf, earlier. About you pushing down a side of yourself, and your parents?”
He felt himself deflate into the chair a little, Thorin’s furrowed brows and warm concern digging deep. Thorin had been asking after him, that had been what sparked this, his concern and his love. He did not want to explain this, but with Gandalf's meddling, he now had no choice. He had to tell Thorin, the idea of keeping this from him, keeping anything from him, burned. He was sure the rest of the company would pester him with questions too, their curiosity was piqued, and they would only continue to ask. He did not want to talk about it at all, and now it was going to be aired to everyone. He should never have lost his temper and snapped at Gandalf.
He did not even know where to begin, except that perhaps the start would be easiest.
“All Tooks go on some sort of adventure, usually not much further than Bree, but they go off and see something for the sake of doing it. It’s in our blood, from back before our people settled in the Shire at all. Adventurous faunts grow into wild tweens, and then when a Took reaches adulthood, they’ll get it out of their system, before returning to the Shire and settling. Usually. My mother never really settled, and she’d already gone on several adventures when she was still a tween. People always said it was like she had a thousand years of wandering in one Hobbit; she simply had to see the things that there were to see. It would never have been acceptable if she hadn’t been a Took, it was barely acceptable even though she was one.”
“She sounds amazing.”
He wasn’t surprised Thorin felt that way. Belladonna would have taken this quest in a heartbeat, she’d have loved it, he got the feeling Gandalf really would have rathered she was the one here, instead of him, but he was all that was left.
“She was. Went all the way to Gondor once, just before she hit her majority. Promptly declared a Gondorian alstroemeria her favourite flower, it was a scandal, she’d all but declared herself un-courtable. Except my father had contacts with big folk through his healing, managed to get a hold of some to grow in secret, all so he could present them to her to start their courting. He was respectable, a Baggins, he’d never have done it any other way. Had to be proper. He was proper, she was wild, as a child I was expected to fall somewhere in the middle.”
He wasn’t entirely sure why he’d explained the alstroemeria to Thorin, or his father’s actions. If his brain had been trying to hint to Thorin that courting a Hobbit really started with the presentation of their favourite flower, and without it, officially, there was no courtship, it was a poor hint. He'd never declared a flower back in the Shire, he’d been far too busy and had rather condemned himself to a solitary life. If he was trying to hint to Thorin, it would not help him, not without a flower for Thorin to work from. In truth, he was not sure he’d even know what to say.
Fortunately, Thorin did not ask, or focus on that detail at all. As Thorin’s gaze swept across his face, he asked instead about Bilbo.
“Were you? Somewhere in the middle?”
“More or less. I ran off into hedgerows and studied maps and dreamt of the wider world, more than was probably acceptable, but I also paid attention to my every lesson and shadowed my father. I loved every story my mother told me, I wanted to be like her, though I knew when I came back from my journey, I’d have to take on the responsibilities of Bag End and all the Baggins clan.”
There was something nice about sharing these stories. He hadn’t shared much of himself or the Shire on their journey, his people were perhaps more secretive than the dwarrow in some ways, and though he’d shared a great deal, many of the more personal things he’d kept close to his chest. He had heard so many of their stories, it was nice to share back, he just wished the rest of the story were more pleasant.
“Where did you go?”
“I didn’t.”
The honest truth slipped out so easily, it was almost surprising. Several emotions passed over Thorin’s face, most of which did not stay long enough for him to discern.
“You cannot tell me you didn’t have an urge to wander. You came all this way; it must reside within you.”
“I was still a tween when my parents died, and I was their sole heir. I didn’t have a choice. I could not adventure, I could not wander, I could not waste time with things that could not be. I had thousands of Hobbits to take care of, and in a time of crisis, the farms and the lands and the people, meetings to attend as a clan head, so much to be done. My coming of age came and went, I barely even remember it, and I remained in the Shire, the picture of respectability. I could not be anything less.”
Erebor was not his first time inheriting a crisis, and he was far less alone here than he had been then. A warm hand rested on his, the slight squeeze of reassurance was so familiar. The compassion glowed in Thorin’s eyes, soft and concerned.
“I am sorry. That was not fair.”
“Life is not often fair; we must simply step up and do what needs to be done.”
It was a thought that had seen him through so many difficult times, and he was certain Thorin had felt the same way many times in his own life, his own journey. Losing their home after Smaug came, inheriting what survived of the kingdom and her people after losing his parents, long before he was ready. Certainly, Thorin understood better than most what it meant to set things aside for the sake of a greater goal.
“Did we pull you from those responsibilities?”
“You pulled me from nothing; I chose to come. But no, my cousin and heir, Drogo, had come of age, no adventures on his side, but he's married and I suspect he will have an heir of his own soon enough. I had already been slowly handing more responsibilities to him, in case something should ever happen to me, I simply handed it over the rest. Everything will be well in hand back in the Shire, though I’m sure a scandal and a half.”
“But you never left before? Even though it was traditional? Nobody made any allowances for you?”
Thorin seemed genuinely baffled. He supposed it made sense, culture was deeply important for the Dwarrow, the idea that Bilbo had missed an important milestone would be shocking. He'd heard many times how hard they’d worked to allow their younger members to meet those milestones, somehow, in some way. Even on the road, or during the wanderings, or settled in the Blue Mountains, they’d tried so hard to make sure those things happened. It must be bizarre to Thorin that such could not be done for him within the safe borders of the peaceful Shire.
“Technically, as I am a Baggins, not a Took... nobody really batted an eyelid. Not every hobbit with Tookish blood has that urge to wander, and the Bagginses are a very... respectable lot. Most never questioned that I never went, just assumed my father's sensible temperament won out.”
They never questioned it, in fact many were grateful for it, but the urge had never truly left him. He'd simply pushed it away, ignored it as it clawed and screamed like a beast in a cage. With every year it had growled a little louder, dug it’s claws in a little sharper, but he’d grown better at ignoring it too. Until he’d barely noticed it at all.
“When Gandalf said it would be good for you, he knew you needed it, but that you’d never been able?” Thorin pressed his lips, “I am sorry you did not have the opportunity when you should have, though perhaps glad it led you to come with us.”
“As am I. I had thought the urge quashed completely.” he admitted, “I had crushed it down so far, it was only once I let myself join you all that I realised how... unwell it had been making me. Gandalf was right to say it would do me good, I should apologise to him. My words were harsh.”
“Were they true?”
Thorin's concern cut deep, too deep. Brazen and honest and angry on his behalf, tugging at emotions he was trying so hard to keep down.
“I...”
“You implied it was his fault that you could not adventure, that it was his fault your parents died. I have never known you to accuse with that severity without truth behind it, which makes me think your words were truth.”
“No... no not entirely. That is to say, most of the Shire blames him, but only because he contributed, he was hardly the one holding the blade. It was not even a blade at all.”
Thorin didn’t look remotely convinced.
This was the other part of the conversation he’d been dreading. His own choices he could explain, but his grief and loss, he’d held it oh so close for oh so long. So rarely did he speak of that winter, or his loss. So rarely did he discuss with anyone the circumstances that had led to his early inheritance. It simply was, and it needed not be spoken of. After all, everyone in the Shire already knew.
“My mother adventured, as I said. She went far and wide, and Gandalf supported and encouraged it. He often travelled with her or helped her find people to travel with. She was hardly the first Hobbit he dragged on adventures, and I surely won’t be the last, he seems to love meddling with our people. She did not settle after she hit her majority, nor after she married, nor after she had me, and they blame him for that. Never mind it was in her blood, never mind my father’s first courting gift to her was that bouquet of alstroemeria and a book on how to heal yourself in the wild, that he encouraged her too. He never wanted her to give up her passion for him.” he paused for a second, realising the tangent he’d started down, “My father’s love was simply love, but Gandalf was an outsider, they blamed him for her... oddities. And when the Fell Winter came and she ran into the fight with a sword she actually had some skill wielding and her leather armour...”
“They blamed him for her choice to fight.”
“Hobbits don’t believe death in battle is noble or brave. The only true respectable death is old age, after a life well lived. Even our bounders prefer to drive attackers away instead of direct confrontation, but the Fell Winter was so different from anything we’d faced before. A wolf clawed her open, and there was nothing the healers could do to save her. My father’s grief took him less than a month later, he withered away, nothing anyone could do.”
He kept his eyes locked on the wall as he spoke, the way the firelight made the shadows flicker. Anything but Thorin’s face. He was not sure what it was he didn’t want to see, but the wall was a safer bet. Walls did not have compassion or judgement or any other emotion to display.
“You stepped up.”
“Of course.”
“Just as you stepped up for Erebor, Master Baggins, you never cease to amaze me. Spine of mithril. If more people acted simply because it was right, the world would be a different place indeed.”
It had been easier here in Erebor than then, there was less grief to blur the world around him, and more support in all of it. The rest of the company, and it was never permanent, because Thorin was going to recover and take it back. None of it was ever his sole burden, not the way things had been in the Shire, in the aftermath of the Fell Winter, exhausted and sick and alone. He hadn’t let anyone see how much it had affected him, he’d closed himself off, convinced everyone he was fine.
Let them see what they wanted to see.
“I can understand why they see the issue with your mother taking up arms, but they blame Gandalf for your father succumbing to grief?”
The question caught him off guard for a second, before he realised the detail he had missed. He had explained it before, that Hobbits had matching hearts the same way Dwarves had Ones, but in truth not with much detail. His people were secretive too, after all.
“My parents exchanged their hearts; I think dwarves would call them Ones. My father was the only one who loved her deeply enough to get that flower, even if it was all cultural taboo. Most Hobbit’s avoid it, they don’t give that first flower over or their heart, even if the Shire is a peaceful place. Accidents can happen after all.”
He shrugged, but Thorin only seemed more confused. As though that hadn’t answered his question at all.
“You don’t traditionally choose your Ones?”
He was certain he’d mentioned this briefly, though come to think of it, it had been after they’d entered the mountain. Perhaps Thorin did not remember it clearly.
“Of course not. I know other races don’t mind the risks, but we’re a cautious people. The last thing you want is for a faunt or tween to end up without either parent the way I did. All it takes is a sickness or a storm or some bad luck and you’ll have two funerals; it was decided long ago that it was hardly worth the risk. Especially when my people love freely and easily, with passion and joy. You do not need the other half of your heart to live a long and happy life full of love.”
Nausea painted Thorin’s face as he spoke, and he realised for the first time that maybe the loss of your heart was not the same for every race. Perhaps that was why so many chose to take the risk, because it was no risk, not to them. Not the way it was to his people. That maybe the way grief had rotted his father, numbed his fingers and toes and travelled back up to his shattered heart, was not a common ailment. The ease with which Kili and Tauriel had decided to honour their hearts, the ease at which Thorin had offered his... How deeply had he offended Thorin with his caution, if Dwarrow did not face the same risk as Hobbits did?
Had his rejection has seemed more personal, a criticism of Thorin and the love he offered rather than the truth. That there were factors to consider beyond the ones he’d been aware of.
Thorin slipped from his chair to a position in front of Bilbo, keeping his hand clasped, but loosely, like he couldn’t decide if he wanted to hold on for dear life or pull away completely.
“You’ll die if you... if... if we...”
“We do. Hobbits do.” He squeezed Thorin’s hand back, not letting him pull away in his shock and horror, “Thorin... when I said I needed time to decide, I didn’t realise you didn’t know that. I would have explained, I would have. I am so sorry.”
Thorin was shaking his head slightly, letting his fingers squeeze back.
“No, no, I understand now, I should have realised, I should have talked to you. I was asking for your love, I did not know I was asking for you to tie your life and your fate to me, I would have never...”
“That wasn’t my concern, Thorin. I was concerned for you. I am no warrior, what would stop them targeting me to kill you, after all this work, I was not about to be the reason Erebor lost her king.”
Thorin's eyes snapped up to his.
“Even though you thought I had already accepted the risk by asking.”
“Even then. I watched my father die; I did not want to be the reason you suffered the same long death. I’m sorry Thorin, I truly didn’t know. I thought all races faced the same thing.”
“We don’t even know if it would affect me that way. Dwarven Ones are different, the loss changes us, but we persist. You are my One, I know it more than I know myself, but I cannot bear the idea that you would lose your life with me.”
“You are my heart, but until I give mine to you, I do not believe our roots will intertwine. That said, if I stay that may simply happen. And yet I find myself more and more certain that I will stay...”
