Work Text:
It hadn’t started with a letter, far from it, but it was, in its own way, a beginning. For a long time, that was all there was to it: a single letter that sat upon Bilbo’s desk in his study at Bag End. It had arrived some years after his return from the adventure—if it could be called that. Bilbo preferred not to think how long ago that had been.
The royal seal of Erebor, King Thorin’s own, closed the letter. It was written on fine parchment, quite likely by Thorin’s own hand, by the looks of it, Bilbo suspected. Even the raven who carried it had been remarkable: young, strong, his feathers glossy. A bird fit for bearing messages across great distances. When he had landed upon Bag End’s fence, he had not gone unnoticed (indeed, he was the subject of hearty gossip for weeks afterward).
Bilbo had quietly thanked him but gave no message in return. He hadn’t even opened the letter, an omission that had clearly displeased the raven. But the thought of what might lie within had simply been too much to bear.
Certainly, he had hoped Thorin had been thinking of him. It was a relief to know, to have tangible proof, that he had spared a thought for this silly old hobbit. Yet Bilbo was painfully aware of how he had betrayed Thorin’s trust, and how the dwarf had really every right to hate him, despite what he had said on what most believed would be his deathbed.
Surely Thorin had not wanted to go to his maker in anger, and truly, weren’t his last words to Bilbo little more than a kindly phrased order to go home? All in all, if Bilbo used his head rather than his heart, Thorin’s thoughts about him were likely far from what Bilbo had so quietly hoped for. It was probable that Thorin still saw him as a reminder of his own moments of disgrace. And yet, for some reason, he had still taken the time to write.
Bilbo swore he would open the letter tomorrow. Surely, by then, he would have gathered the necessary courage. That, at least, was what he told himself, day after day. Yet still, the letter remained on his desk: unopened. Accusing. Demanding. Mocking him.
And yet, he couldn’t bring himself to hide it away in a drawer. As long as he didn’t open it, it could still be anything. He didn’t have to face what it truly was as whatever that might be, it would surely break him. Perhaps it said that Thorin was happy in his kingdom, that Erebor was everything he had ever dreamed of. Or perhaps he was unhappy, or even in trouble.
Worse still was the thought that Bilbo’s hopeless, unspoken love for the fierce and determined king, whose every word burned with conviction, whose voice left Bilbo breathless, whose ice-blue eyes could undo him with a glance—had not been unrequited after all. That he had fled halfway across Arda from the possibility of happiness. (A silly dream, of course. But for one brief, shining moment, he had allowed himself to hope—until it all went pear-shaped, as things tended to do.)
Or perhaps the letter was confirmation that he had been alone in his affections all along, that all his deeds were defined by one mistake, however well-intentioned, that could never be forgiven.
“Never mind,” Bilbo told himself. “Thorin has a kingdom to rule now; the last thing he needs is a pining hobbit.” And surely, if it had been truly important, Thorin would have sent another letter, wouldn't he?
Bilbo had tried to pry from Gandalf any tidings of Erebor, the few times he had been to the Shire. The wizard had told him only that the mountain prospered, and that Thorin ruled wisely and well. “For anything else,” Gandalf had added with a knowing glance, “you’ll have to ask him yourself.” Bilbo had huffed, and changed the subject.
Still, at times, Bilbo would take the letter in his hands and trace the blue seal, the green silken ribbon beneath his fingertips. Following night, he would often dream of Thorin. It never grew easier, no matter what the dreams contained, and so he had learned to avoid them.
The years slipped by. The letter yellowed, the ribbon faded, yet it remained unopened.
Tomorrow, Bilbo promised himself. Always tomorrow.
He told himself he didn’t regret leaving, and truly, he didn’t. Never mind that it had cost him much of his reputation, that he was no longer considered quite as respectable as before. (After all, who could say what silliness he might be up to next?)
It wasn’t the leaving that troubled him so much as the returning. He wasn’t the same anymore; he didn’t quite fit as he once had. “Mad Baggins,” they called him now—and that was without knowing the half of it. (If they’d had any inkling how a hobbit of the Shire had fallen for the King Under the Mountain, he would never have heard the end of it!)
So he kept up the act of a proper hobbit—though for whose benefit, he couldn’t quite tell. It had become a mutual game of pretend, one that only occasionally faltered. Sometimes it was simply exhausting to go on as though nothing had changed.
So Bilbo kept Bag End spotless: doilies straight, windowsills dusted, tomatoes the envy of all Hobbiton. He looked after his tenants in Bagshot Row, attended parties, made perfectly polite conversation, and sometimes enjoyed a quiet pint at the Green Dragon.
And if, in the evenings, he sat in his garden smoking his pipe and gazing east, his heart full of what-ifs, well, that was nobody’s business but his own. He’d been doing it for years, and he could keep doing it for years more, though it all felt… empty.
~~~~~~~~
Then along came little Frodo.
Bilbo’s younger cousin Drogo and his wife, Primula, often invited him for tea and Bilbo, in turn, was always delighted to welcome them to Bag End and show off his rather impressive baking skills. In time, their visits led to a natural familiarity between Bilbo and their firstborn, Frodo, who had known him since the days Frodo was but a tiny bundle in Primula’s arms.
Bilbo was never particularly confident around small babies, but Frodo grew like a weed and, for some reason, the boy seemed especially taken with “Uncle Bilbo.” Bilbo never quite understood why, but he found the child’s affection quite endearing.
After the sudden loss of Drogo and Primula, the fauntling went to live with his mother’s kin at Brandy Hall, on the far side of the Shire. Still, it was only fair that he spend time with his father’s side relatives as well. When he began staying more frequently at Bag End—something Frodo himself had insisted upon—Bilbo found himself only too happy to oblige.
There were even days when, only late in the evening, Bilbo realized he hadn’t thought once of Thorin, or of the letter, all day. But when his smial grew quiet again, it was another matter entirely.
“Oh bother,” Bilbo sighed. “Much too late now anyway.”
Nonetheless, the letter remained on his desk.
~~~~~~~~
Little Frodo, Bilbo soon discovered, was surprisingly perceptive for his age. The boy understood far more than he let on and often drew his own conclusions—typically without telling anyone. It was a proper challenge to coax out what was going on in that bright little mind of his.
Quiet, endlessly curious, and somewhat bookish, Frodo was ill-suited to the constant bustle of Brandy Hall. The Great Smial, full of generations of hobbits, could easily overwhelm someone who had not grown up amid such commotion. With Bilbo, though, he didn’t have to pretend to be happy all the time. Bilbo, after all, knew what it was to lose something dear, and he couldn’t blame the child for still feeling sad on occasion.
The two shared many interests. Frodo loved their long walks together (especially when a picnic basket was involved) but most of all he adored Bilbo’s stories. Once he discovered that Bilbo’s shelves held even more tales of elves, dwarves, and far-off lands, he had declared with great enthusiasm that he would learn to read for himself. He was already picking it up quite nicely.
Most of Frodo’s lessons took place at Brandy Hall, under the capable guidance of Miss Marigold Brandybuck, who had decades of experience with fauntlings. But when Frodo stayed at Bag End, Bilbo taught him about plants and history, supplied him with books, and kept an ample stock of paper for writing and drawing.
It was a small glimpse of a life Bilbo had never imagined for himself, nor one he had ever thought to desire. Yet there was no denying the quiet companionship that had grown between them. When Frodo visited, Bag End felt alive. The smial was rather large for one hobbit, too, so Bilbo had even refurbished a guest room into a room of Frodo’s own: a tidy bed, lace curtains, pictures on the walls, a small dresser for his spare clothes, toys, towel, and hairbrush. On a dresser drawer sat Frodo’s very own writing set: a pen, a little ink, and a stack of paper.
Some of the pages were already half-used, covered with small notes and scribbles. Nothing important. But perfectly good for practicing.
~~~~~~~~
In addition to enjoying Bilbo’s company, little Frodo had made friends of his own age in Hobbiton. It was a fine spring day, sunny and bright, and he had been staying with Bilbo at Bag End for the past week. The fauntling had run out to play almost immediately after first breakfast, and since he was to return to Brandy Hall later that day (and would not be back for weeks), Bilbo had wisely chosen not to argue about second breakfast. That, he reasoned, counted as choosing his battles. Instead, he packed a sandwich in wax cloth for Frodo to take along.
Bilbo doubted the children would stop their play for something as dull as eating anyway. (Appreciation for a proper hobbit’s mealtime came with age, he’d noticed, though the irony of him being one to speak of propriety did not escape him.) Frodo’s absence left Bilbo free to water his seedlings, enjoy a cup of tea, tidy his smial, and, after all that, pay a visit to the market.
Returning home with a basket full of spring vegetables and fresh eggs and firm plans for lunch (fried eggs and beans with spring onion and herbs, of course) Bilbo came upon a curious sight. A small troop of Hobbiton fauntlings was marching along the road with the utmost determination. They were armed with wooden toy axes and swords (sticks, really, pretending to be such) and their leader appeared to be young Folco Boffin, wearing a felt crown that Bilbo recognized from the autumn harvest fair. A bit odd, perhaps, and not what some would call proper hobbit play, but quite harmless enough.
Frodo was among them, marching proudly, the gardener’s son Samwise at his side, with the Bolger children following close behind, tiny Estella making up for in attitude what she lacked in size.
Bilbo paused beside Bell Gamgee, who was also watching the procession on her way to the market.
“I wonder what they’re up to now,” he mused, amused.
“I’ve been told we’re looking at a dwarf king’s retinue,” Bell chuckled. “Their new favorite game, they’ve been at it for days.”
A dwarf king’s retinue. The words stung a little.
“I suppose it was bound to happen,” Bilbo said with a half-smile and a small, dry laugh. The children had all heard his tales of adventure many times over—at least, the carefully selected parts. There was no need for them to know everything. Not yet, and for some parts not ever.
“Samwise says it was Frodo’s idea,” Bell went on, cheerfully. The thought made Bilbo’s chest warm. Frodo had always been a quiet, solitary child; seeing him with friends, leading games they all enjoyed, was a happy change. By the next visit, they would surely have invented something new.
“A lot of talk of dwarves lately,” Bell added. “Daisy Proudfoot says there’s a travelling dwarf blacksmith in Bywater. Repaired her brewing kettle beautifully, she says. He’s bound for Bree soon, though, otherwise I’d have sent Hamfast to get his tools sharpened.”
Bilbo shifted his basket as Bell continued. “Well then, enough gossip for one morning. I wouldn’t want to stand between you and your luncheon.”
Bell nodded toward the children. “And where are you lot heading, hmm?”
“We’re going to the Shire,” Folco declared in a very kingly tone, “to meet Frodo’s uncle. And we’ll ask if he wants to come with us to the Mountain. We’re armed, too!” he added proudly. “We’ll guard him from orcs—give him safe passage.” He glanced at Estella for confirmation, then nodded solemnly, assured he’d said it right.
Bilbo shook his head, smiling. “So that part of the story, then,” he murmured to himself, and turned to go. “Very well! Frodo, I’m starting lunch. It’ll be ready in an hour!” he called over his shoulder as he headed home.
After Bilbo had disappeared down the lane, the group of children exchanged uneasy glances and elbow nudges. There was something they wanted to ask, but none seemed quite brave enough, until Fredegar Bolger finally blurted out:
“Mrs. Gamgee, what does abdication mean?”
~~~~~~~~
Not quite an hour later, Bilbo heard the door open and close again, followed by Frodo’s bright voice announcing his return.
“Perfect timing, dear, lunch is just about ready. Wash your hands and help me set the table,” Bilbo called from the kitchen. As expected, the soft patter of small feet followed. But the footsteps stopped short of the kitchen. Frodo lingered in the doorway.
That alone told Bilbo something was wrong. Still, it wouldn’t do to fuss. He kept his attention on the frying pan, ready to listen.
“Uncle Bilbo…” Frodo began, his tone carrying the weight of long pondering.
“Yes, dear boy?” Bilbo encouraged, glancing over his shoulder to make sure there was no visible mishap. Finding none, he turned back to the stove. Neglecting the onions, after all, would mean burnt onions.
“The dwarf king…” Frodo began again, then paused until Bilbo turned fully around, spatula in hand. “He was sad.”
Bilbo frowned. “What do you mean?”
Frodo bit his lip, twisting the hem of his shirt between his fingers. “In his letter,” he said at last. “He used a lot of words I didn’t understand, but he was sad that you left. Did you make King Thorin sad?”
The clatter of the wooden spatula hitting the tile floor seemed far too loud.
“...Letter?” Bilbo managed in a strangled whisper.
Frodo’s eyes went wide, realizing he’d done something wrong, though not what.
“It was in my drawer…?”
A wave of panic rose in Bilbo’s chest as the pieces fit together. Frodo had found Thorin’s letter. He had read it—before Bilbo had. Thorin had been sad, Frodo had said.
Bilbo exhaled sharply, rubbing his face with both hands in an effort to steady himself. The Erebor letter—of all possible papers!—had ended up among the discarded notes he’d given Frodo for practice. It was hardly something he’d ever expected to happen. But if anyone was to blame, it was himself.
Explaining it would be another matter entirely. How could he tell the boy what had happened at Erebor, when he didn’t even know what Thorin’s letter said?
And Frodo looked so miserable, standing there with that “are you leaving me too?” expression, that Bilbo’s heart twisted. He loathed being the cause of that look.
“No, no, you didn’t do anything wrong, dear,” Bilbo said quickly. “Far from it. It’s just… I… It’s very complicated. I’ll tell you in a while.”
Lunch passed mostly in silence. Bilbo could barely keep his thoughts straight, managing only the occasional, “Have some beans, dear,” while Frodo nodded solemnly. At length, Bilbo drew a breath and spoke.
“You see, King Thorin and I were good friends—or at least I considered him one. He wanted what he thought was best for his people. But once, he was about to do something terribly foolish, and I tried to stop him. I meant well, but it made him very angry. He told me he never wanted to see me again.”
It was a clumsy simplification, but Frodo seemed to accept it.
“Oh,” Frodo whispered. “And you left—and now he’s sad.” He frowned, thinking deeply. “So… that’s like when Merry and Rory took Mrs. Goldworthy’s blueberry pie, and Amaranth told on them, and Merry said she was stupid for ruining his plan, and he didn’t want to play with her again—but then they went fishing together as soon as Merry was allowed out?”
Clever boy, Bilbo thought. Though comparing the Arkenstone to a blueberry pie—however unknowingly—was utterly absurd. The image of Thorin’s expression if he’d heard it nearly undid him.
A strangled snort escaped, followed by an undignified fit of laughter. Perhaps, he thought, he was a touch hysterical.
Frodo looked bewildered.
“Well,” Bilbo said at last, wiping his eyes, “in a way, yes—something along those lines.”
~~~~~~~~
Frodo’s departures for Brandy Hall always left Bilbo with mixed feelings. He relished the return of quiet mornings and the peaceful hum of solitude—but the silence also left far too much room for thought.
This time, though, he was nothing short of relieved that Frodo’s return to Buckland had been scheduled for that very day. The faunt’s bag was packed, and Bilbo had already arranged with old Master Whitfoot to borrow a pony and small cart for the journey.
The route had become familiar by now. Bilbo would take Frodo as far as Frogmorton, where his uncle Saradas would meet them. They would share dinner at the inn—trading news and stories—before Bilbo turned his pony homeward.
It was only then, alone on the road, that realization struck like a hammer. Bilbo inhaled sharply, squeezed his eyes shut, and muttered a string of words quite unfit for polite company. How incredibly dense he had been!
The fauntlings’ “dwarf king’s retinue”—they hadn’t been playing at the dwarves from the Erebor quest, had they? Frodo had tried to make sense of the letter with his friends and now every Hobbiton fauntling knew. And if they hadn’t yet shared the tale with their parents, they soon would.
Within days, the entire village would be gossiping that the King Under the Mountain had written to Bilbo Baggins of Bag End—sad, no less!—and was apparently considering coming to fetch him himself.
Bilbo felt the familiar flutter of panic rise in his chest.
By the time he reached home, the sun had set. The thought pressed down on him: this was it. He could delay no longer.
First, though, he poured himself a glass of brandy—to steady his nerves—and drank it in one gulp. Then he went to Frodo’s little room and opened the drawer of writing supplies.
The Erebor letter wasn’t immediately in sight. He found it tucked beneath a shopping list for fence repairs and one of Frodo’s drawings—a cow, apparently. The parchment was still folded tightly, though the blue wax seal was now broken.
Bilbo lifted it carefully, scarcely realizing he was holding his breath. Cradling the letter in both hands, as though it were a fragile relic, he carried it to his study and laid it upon the desk. Only then did he sit, slowly, deliberately. He drew it toward him and opened the first fold…
And stopped.
He could not go on.
Years of shame—sneaking away from Erebor, years of cowardly inaction—and the memory of Thorin’s fury on the ramparts came crashing back. Those eyes, cold and mad, his hands at Bilbo’s throat… all of it culminated now in this one piece of parchment.
The disappointment in himself was almost unbearable. He smoothed the letter closed again, tears threatening.
He had faced a dragon, and yet he could not face a letter.
But… he could start with a letter of his own, couldn’t he?
With trembling hands, Bilbo lifted a pen and dipped it into the inkwell. He straightened his back, rolled his shoulders, drew a deep breath. So. A letter starts with a greeting.
Dear… No, no. That wouldn’t do. It had hardly been appropriate even during their journey—let alone now.
King Under the Mountain… Goodness, no. Far too formal.
Thorin… He hesitated. No, that didn’t feel right either. Too familiar. Or perhaps not familiar enough.
It was absurd. He hadn’t written a letter in his life that felt so impossible.
A drop of ink fell onto the page.
He stared at it for a long while—the single dark mark on the blank sheet. That, and nothing more.
He sighed. “Another brandy, then,” he muttered.
The room was growing chilly. Bilbo shuffled down the hall to the pantry, refilled his glass, and carried it to the sitting room. He lit a small fire and sank into his favorite chair. For a moment he considered his pipe, but decided against it.
Leaning forward, elbows on knees, he stared into the flames. The truth was obvious enough: he couldn’t write until he knew what to say. A sip. He couldn’t simply pour out everything in his heart. Another sip. But what else was left? He’d been silent long enough. Another sip. He leaned back in his chair.
After all this time, what could he possibly expect from any reply? Another sip.
At some point, he must have drifted into uneasy sleep. His mind carried him to places he hadn’t visited in years. He didn’t see the face but he knew, he felt the strong arms around him, the coarse beard brushing his cheek, his own near-desperate whispers—I’m sorry, so terribly sorry, I’ve missed you so much—and, in answer, a voice murmuring softly: But you’re here now.
Bilbo woke with the ghost of that touch still on his skin. There was no escaping it now.
He lit a candle and made his way back to his study, eyes still hazy with sleep. The pen and paper were where he had left them. This time, he knew what they were for.
When at last he stopped, five pages lay before him. They were unplanned, unstructured, and wholly undignified. Whole passages crossed out, ink smeared where tears had fallen. In places, he had pressed the nib so hard it had nearly torn the paper.
The candle was nearly spent, and dawn’s first light painted the sky in pink and gold. Bilbo wiped his cheeks, looked at the mess of pages before him—and laughed.
He pushed the sheets aside, took up a fresh page, flexed his cramped fingers, and began again.
My dear friend Thorin,
It was never my intention to disregard your letter, and thinking back, I see I acted in poor judgment by not replying sooner. I can only hope you find it in your heart to forgive my dreadful silence. I think often—and fondly—of our journey and our time together. It is my deepest hope that, despite all, you still count me as a friend.
I wish you all the best,
Your burglar.
He let the ink dry, folded the page neatly, and sealed it. It was ready.
Not too forward. Not too much. Thorin could make of it what he would. Yes, this he could send—and quickly, before he lost his nerve.
Bell had mentioned a travelling dwarf blacksmith in Bywater, one likely bound for Bree. There were ravens there for messages. He could reach him before he left, perhaps.
Bilbo barely paused to check he was decent before rushing out the door. The morning air was cold, the sun barely over the horizon.
He clutched the letter tightly as he ran down the hill, heart pounding.
Once, long ago, he had run after a company of dwarves with a contract in hand. Now, it was his own words he carried, and, again, he had no notion of what awaited him.
There would be time later to question his sanity. For now, Bilbo Baggins of Bag End ran toward the dawn, a letter in his hand.
Bilbo found himself out of breath before reaching the borders of Hobbiton and had to settle for walking, much to his annoyance — Bywater was still far away. The cool morning air bit pleasantly at his cheeks, and the rising sun was just beginning to gild the hedgerows and damp grass. As he strolled past the fields and farmhouses, he paid little attention to the signs of a new day beginning.
By second-breakfast time, he realised he hadn’t packed anything to eat in his rush out the door — such a beginner’s mistake! But as Bywater drew nearer, that seemed a trifling matter. This was a more important errand, perhaps the most important of his life. Depending on the outcome, of course, he corrected himself before finishing the thought. No use getting ahead of himself. Still, the idea made him quicken his steps, until by the time he approached the village, he was nearly running again.
The Bywater smithy had been without a permanent occupant for years, and this dwarf wasn’t the first to stay and work for a short while. (As far as Bilbo knew, none had ever considered settling permanently.) The rhythmic clang of iron against anvil would have guided him there even with his eyes closed.
He found the smith, a burly dwarf, not exactly young anymore but not yet going grey. With his beard and hair the colour of gold, much like Fíli’s, it would have been difficult to tell in any case. His hair was plaited in simple, practical braids, though Bilbo hadn’t the leisure to study them.
The dwarf was absorbed in his work and didn’t notice Bilbo’s arrival until the hobbit blurted out, breathless,
“You’re still here! Oh, I’m so grateful to find you — you’ve no idea! I mean—where are my manners? Good day, Master… or rather—Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”
His face was flushed, his curls wild, and his waistcoat quite askew. The dwarf regarded him with some amusement, setting down his hammer before giving a polite nod, clearly trying to make sense of this unexpected visitor who, at least, knew something of dwarvish courtesies.
“Romli, at your service,” he said.
“I—well, I was wondering— I need a small favour. Could you kindly help me? It’s urgent, and it’s been so terribly long overdue, and I’ll compensate you well for the trouble, of course! So, if you can find a raven, or if you know of a caravan leaving from Bree…”
Romli’s beard twitched as if suppressing a laugh; he seemed both bewildered and entertained by this small, dishevelled creature who could speak for so long without taking a breath.
The letter in Bilbo’s hand was warm and creased from being clutched too tightly. He hesitated only a moment before offering it to the dwarf.
“I need this delivered to Erebor,” he said quietly.
Romli’s brows rose, but he quickly regained his composure. He looked again at the folded letter in his hand, and then back at Bilbo.
“I’ll see what I can do,” he said solemnly.
For a long moment, Bilbo stood there, unable to find the right words. Then he nodded, smiled faintly, and murmured,
“Thank you, Master Romli.”
When he stepped outside again, the sunlight had risen higher, warm on his face and the road gleaming ahead. He took a deep breath, feeling something inside him finally ease.
It was done.
And as he turned back toward Hobbiton, humming softly under his breath, Bilbo Baggins of Bag End felt lighter than he had in many, many years.
