Chapter Text
Forbidden fruit had been bitten into - climaxed into… and on, actually, and now Steve and Billy were sitting in Steve’s red BMW. It’s weird having Billy in him still. He had cleaned up the best he could with a flushing red face while Billy told him what to do exactly because he had experience. But he could still feel it, clinging on to Steve. It was disgusting, but also… exhilarating to a point. The blood on both of their faces was smudged and only slightly washed away with spit and the cotton of their t-shirts.
They were sitting in Steve’s car now, driving though. It was still super early, they had hung out for a while until the car’s clock read 4:30 and Steve said he wanted to get something to eat. He suggested his own house, because he knew Billy probably wouldn’t be able to suggest his.
And now they were driving to the Harrington House. Steve’s parents were still going to be asleep, but they could sneak into the backyard and Steve could quickly steal something from the pantry or fridge for the 2 of them to eat. The music in Steve’s car is loud, loud enough for it to fill Steve’s ears completely and make him forget that he’s been hating himself for the past 2 days, because now Steve feels great. Steve’s never felt so amazing in his entire life - never felt more alive. He’s so happy and he doesn’t care if his smile makes him look like a nerd. He’s fucking ecstatic. Steve doesn’t want to use the word love, because that’s way too soon and even though it took him quicker to figure out he was in love with Nancy, this is different, it’s all different.
Steve doesn’t really know what he’s doing. He’s trying out a lot of personality changes right now and figuring out which ones best fit who he is at the moment. He even steals the cigarette between Billy’s fingers and presses it between his lips, letting the tobacco painfully sting his lungs.
He isn’t dating Nancy anymore.
They get to a split in the road and Billy stops them, holding onto Steve’s arm.
“Can we stop at 7-11 and get slushies before getting food at your house?”
And how can Steve say no to those eyes - those lips. Those cherry red lips that drive him insane. Jesus- he was sick.
So they stopped at 7-11, for their slushies, Steve blue and Billy’s red. Somehow that matched them. And now they were sneaking into the Harrington’s backyard. Billy grabbed two pool chairs and sat them on the stairs in Steve’s pool while Steve snuck inside to steal some food. He made sure to never lock up the back door for moments like this. Who cared if someone broke in? They had enough money to replace everything in this house twice.
He pulled some leftover potato latkes, Jewish food he had never cared enough to listen about from his dad. His mom was Christian, very Christian, but his dad was Jewish and because his mom was such a ‘loving wife’, she made sure to make some Jewish foods now and then. His dad didn’t really give a shit though, rather digging deeper into the stereotype that was Jewish people love money, naming their real estate agency ‘Gold Home Property’.
Steve just saw their Jewish-ness as an advantage rather than a disadvantage. His dad selling it with the stereotypes got them a really prominent place in the Hawkins matriarch, and he got to eat some good food now and then because of it too.
He grabbed some applesauce from the pantry and made his way outside, kicking off his shoes and socks before going into the pool to sit down in the chairs. The water only went up to his ankles.
“What the fuck is this?” Billy asks, taking a latke from the plate. They’re best served hot, but Steve wasn’t turning on the microwave.
“Potato latkes.” Steve opened the applesauce and dipped one into it.
“Huh?” Billy says with a mouth full.
“Jewish food.”
“You’re Jewish?” Billy took another from the cold plate.
“Dad is, we don’t really bother with it though. My mom is Christian, so we go with that most of the time. We just get a lot of money and good food from being Jewish.”
“You get paid for being Jewish?”
Steve laughs. “No, it’s this whole stupid thing where people think Jewish people are super greedy.” He says. He likes talking with Billy. “My dad just uses it to his advantage when people get mad at him for his high prices on houses.”
Billy snorted. It’s ugly and obnoxious, but Steve’s already repeating it in his head. “Sorry, man, gotta raise your taxes. I’m Jewish.”
Steve giggled. He felt high. “Exactly!”
And the two continued like this, eating cold potato latkes in Steve’s pool, Billy tried them with the applesauce once asked Steve how insane he really was because ‘who the fuck would like that!?’ They talked about random things, conversation starters with no plan on how to continue or end the conversation. But Steve was okay with that. He’d usually have a big spreadsheet of how to end and start a conversation, how to keep it going, how to make it stop, but he didn’t need any of that now. All he needed to do was talk about the things on his mind, speak endlessly, start a new topic in the middle of one they had been on for a while, diverge into a side story that got them talking even more.
When the sun started peaking up above the trees and everything looked golden, Billy told Steve he had to go home.
“What time do you think it is?” He asked, messing with the straw in his empty slushie cup.
Steve drew in a breath and turned his head over to look at Billy. God, he was gorgeous. “It’s gotta be around five or five thirty.”
Billy tsked. “I gotta get going then.” he stood up and Steve whined.
“No, why?”
“My dad will murder me if he finds out a snuck out.” Billy said while stepping out of the pool, taking the chair with him.
Steve let out a groan while standing up and following Billy, taking his chair out of the pool as well. “All parents say that. Why can’t we just hang out more?” Steve didn’t care if he sounded pathetic. He was having the time of his life talking with Billy.
“Because, the only thing the police will be able to find will be my teeth.” He looked at Steve after putting his shoes on. “I need to go.”
Steve sighed and set down the empty plate of latkes. “If you say so.” He rolled his eyes and Billy cackled behind him.
The car ride was quiet, the music wasn’t so loud, and they weren’t so hyped with the adrenaline of having sex. It was calm and smooth; it was nice. A layer of brick had been ripped away from Steve and now he was just… himself.
It was just about to turn 6 when Steve parked two houses away from Billy’s (his instructions).
“Will I be able to… see you again?” Steve asked, quietly and nervously, as Billy unbuckled himself.
“Damn, pretty boy.” Billy teased. “You really love me, don’t you?”
Steve’s face went hot. He didn’t know if it was love he was feeling for Billy or something else. He just felt really happy when he was with the boy. Complete. “It’s not- I just… I like hanging out with you.” There was a beat of silence and Steve got self-conscious. “We don’t have to- We can forget-”
“No, no, I’ll budge.” Billy turned slightly in his seat to face Steve. “What do you wanna do?”
Steve shrugged. Hookups weren’t really his thing, he was a romantic. Flowers and candles and all that fun stuff. “I don’t know… I want something more formal between us since…” They’re dating… right?”
Billy gave him a look of uncertainty. “You do know we can’t really go out and be boyfriend and girlfriend, right?”
“No, yeah, I know… I know.” Steve stuttered. He was well aware. “I meant like… a formal dinner. Like we can make something at my house. My parents are going to be leaving Sunday morning, so you could come over later that night for dinner?”
“So tomorrow?”
“Yeah.” Steve had been up for so long he forgot it was Saturday.
Billy went quiet for a minute, knots twisted in Steve’s stomach. “I don’t think I’ll be able to see you at a reasonable dinnertime, but I can definitely sneak out for around ten? Maybe eleven?”
Steve nodded, a smile pulling at his lips. “That’s fine, my parents will be long gone by then… hopefully… could I get your number?”
Billy gave him a deadpanned look. “I’m not giving you my number.”
“Well, what if I need to cancel, asshole?” Steve poked his shoulder. “I can’t have you knocking at my door with my parents home.”
Billy squinted at Steve before giving Steve his phone number. No paper, just pure word of mouth. Steve planned to write it down as soon as he got home.
“‘Kay I gotta go now.” Billy leaned in and gave Steve a chaste kiss, but Steve wanted it to go on forever. “I’m so glad that Nancy bitch broke up with you.” He whispered against Steve’s lips before getting out of his BMW with a cheeky smile.
And shit- Steve had forgotten all about Nancy. Now that she was invading his mind again, he needed to do something. He couldn’t tarnish the only real friendship that he had in that fucked up highschool. Yeah… it was a friendship now, and Steve was okay with that, but he wasn’t okay with Nancy hating him. He could go get dressed into something more presentable, grab some forgiveness flowers, and head over to the Wheelers in the afternoon.
Everything would be fine. He had a boyfriend, he was going to apologize to Nancy, and he was going to graduate with a smile on his face. Nothing would go wrong.
There was so much going on Steve hadn’t even thought about the time - it hadn’t even crossed his mind. All he knew was that he spent the day and half with Dustin fighting demodogs (his words, not Steve’s). So when Steve entered the Byers’ house with everyone else and he got to see a clock for the first time, his stomach dropped. It was 11… not the girl… the time.
The only thing that was going through his head was panic. Billy was probably pissed at him, and Steve didn’t blame him.
“Shit.” He hissed and ran back outside, ignoring Dustin’s confused calls. He quickly opened his car and searched around in his glove box for a minute before finding a flooded piece of ripped paper he had torn from one of his school notebooks. Steve quickly ran back inside and waited patiently until Chief Hopper was done with the phone. Thankfully, it didn’t take him long to finish his call and as soon as he was. Steve dialing the scribbled number on the piece of paper he had.
“Who are you calling?” Dustin asked.
“None of your business.” Steve responded while putting in the last 4 digits.
“Is it a new girlfriend?”
“Stop asking, Dustin.” New girlfriend - new boyfriend, same thing really. In the corner of Steve’s eye, he could see Nancy looked at him with furrowed brows and a confused look on her face. Deserved.
Steve waited impatiently as the phone rang in his ear. There was a knot in his stomach and it was only getting tighter. He thought he was going to throw up.
“Hello…” Billy’s eyes were red and wet with tears and he looked out of it, his confidence was kicked in the balls.
Steve let out a sigh of relief. Thank god. “Hey.” He responded. He still smiled, even though Billy wouldn’t be able to see it. “I feel terrible about this, but um… I won’t be able to make it tonight.” He explained. “Some… shit came up.”
“Yeah… I don’t think I’d be able to make it either.”
“Oh, what’s up on your end?”
Billy shrugged. “Some shit came up.” He wiped his nose and looked out his half-cracked open door.
“Oh, no… well, I’m still super sorry about not being able to make it.” Steve twirled the phone line in his fingers, he felt terrible about this. Hopefully, they’d be able to have dinner another time.
“Steve!” Max hissed, and he turned around to face her.
“What!?” he hissed back. This little ginger was getting on his nerves. So annoying, but she was tough.
“We’re mourning! Get off the phone!”
“I didn’t even know the dude!”
“I didn’t know him either, but I’m still being nice about it!”
Max was only a little right. Mrs. Byers was off somewhere in the house crying over Bob Newby, her boyfriend that had just gotten eaten by demodogs. The entire house was quiet and Steve was trying to be as quiet as he could, but he was still talking.
Billy was holding the phone away from his face. There was a feeling of almost… betrayal in his stomach. Because Billy knew that voice, he had been living with that voice for the past 5 years.
“I’m sorry.” Steve’s voice came back on the phone. “Some things are going on right now, but I’ll be sure to make this up to you, okay?” And then Mike started talking about how Bob Newby was the founder of Hawkins AV club and Steve had to pretend like he really cared.
“What’s going on?” Billy asked.
“Oh, I’m just babysitting at the Wheeler’s and the kids are being annoying.”
“Wheeler?”
“Yeah, Nancy’s little brother. Weird, I know” Steve gave a little nervous laugh and his eyes darted back over to the kitchen table where the kids were all talking in hushed tones. That couldn’t be good. “Hey, I gotta go, but I promise I will make this up to you, okay?”
Billy was thinking, Wheeler, like Mike Wheeler, frog-faced loser. He had been in Hawkins for little under 2 months now, he knew where the Wheeler’s lived. The question on his mind was, why the fuck would Max sneak out to go to that loser’s house? It was fucking weird.
“Okay?” Steve repeated.
“Yeah… okay.”
Steve smiled softly. “Well, um… I see you at school, bye.”
Billy only hummed before hanging up the phone. He had to go visit the Wheeler’s.
