Chapter Text
Bilbo waited outside for the rest of the day. And at length, after work hours, Thorin came.
His astonishment was impossible to hide. “I thought you left with the elves.”
“Was I supposed to?”
Thorin shook his head. It took a while for him to speak again.
“Bilbo. About the flowers. I...”
“Nah, don’t bother. If I had known they were a courting gift, I could have saved Thranduil some trouble. You see, based on the fact that I liked those flowers, he probably thought I liked him.”
“Are you saying... you’re not interested in him?”
“No - I mean, yes. That is what I’m saying.”
Bilbo looks to the sky. If his theory is correct, something like a second sun should appear, to spell out Thorin’s relief.
Instead, Thorin’s face becomes murky and grim.
“The coward. I’ll have his head.” He moves past Bilbo and proceeds to examine his oak. It will comfort him to see it’s all right, Bilbo thinks, though he can’t miss Thorin’s terribly unsettled look as he circles around, concern only deepening on his brow.
Perhaps Thorin came here for the tree, not for him.
“So. Did you end up taking time off?” asks Bilbo, determined to cut to the chase.
Thorin catches on immediately. This is about him ditching what could have been their first date. “Mahal. You waited for me all this time?“
“Oh. I had a book, you know. Brought lunch, afternoon tea... And” - Bilbo points to the tree - “I had Mister Redemption here for company.”
“Redemption,” Thorin repeats in a self-deprecating tone. “I spoke too soon.”
All right. Thorin won’t explain why he didn’t come, nor will he apologize. Bilbo can try to be patient, as much as he’d like some things clarified.
“So how did you do it?”
“Do what?”
“How did you save this tree?”
Thorin regards him quietly. He’s not in a hurry to give away anything.
“I watched you fight the flames. They ruined some branches, but not all of them. The ones that didn’t burn... I wonder how you managed to protect them.”
Thorin’s silence gives off a secretive vibe. If Bilbo didn’t know him, he would say he’s afraid.
“You... seem to control the weather as of late.”
“I froze them,” Thorin says, and it’s like a block of stone heavier than a mountain moved. “I froze everything that had a chance to survive.”
“That must have been difficult.”
“It was. The most difficult thing I have done.”
“How...” The question begins, and pales, inhibited. But Thorin means to be honest with him.
“The tree... was formed of something that started out good, and pure. Feelings,” he intones insecurely. “I poured my feelings into planting that seed; I don’t believe the tree would have grown without them. When the fire came, I knew that what started it was the very thing that gave this tree life.” Thorin pauses, clearly in a struggle with himself. “To freeze this being... required freezing my own feelings.”
Suddenly, whatever reassurance Bilbo may have received re: feelings is rendered futile. He could excuse himself right now, if not for the fact that Thorin is going through a lot, still. He looks pale, tired and not himself; something is off with him.
“I can’t begin to think how you did that.”
“It was my feelings that caused the fire, Bilbo. That led to madness, which endangered the safety of my loved ones. So I thought, if love can be destructive, then it should be restrained.”
Bilbo feels the ground shatter beneath him. The feelings have been named.
“I told myself love is a choice. That I can unlove, if I want to.”
On second thought, here’s hoping they weren’t for him.
“That must be the ultimate form of self-control.”
“No. It was a desperate measure,” Thorin says with great pain. “The tree was burning; I had to act fast. I had made a promise, to put this being above my own needs; to take care of it no matter what happens to me.”
A dwarf putting a tree first... Hmm. Would a hobbit have done the same? Bilbo isn’t sure. But that a hobbit - granted, a less emotionally invested one - would be impressed by this, he knows.
I told myself I can unlove, if I want to.
It’s a small observation, but Thorin said if; he didn’t say I want to.
“I actually had a close view of the tree earlier,” Bilbo says. “I didn’t notice any ice. I wonder what could have melted it. Perhaps the freeze was a temporary thing?”
“For the tree, yes. It was a temporary thing.” Bilbo can hear the unspoken in the embarrassed silence that ensues. The oak regained its vitality in the meantime, but Thorin... frozen doesn’t describe him, not quite. He just seems... numb.
“So what are you saying? That just like that, feelings can disappear?”
“I don’t know. In that moment, I didn’t feel any change. There was no time. As soon as the tree was safe, the fire turned against me; after I put it out, all I could do was worry about it coming back. For it was plain that freezing my feelings did not put out the fire within.”
A friend, Bilbo thinks; this is what Thorin needs. He wants to be that friend; even now, when it appears Thorin froze something that...
No. It couldn’t have been for him.
“But later, when I calmed down and went into the Mountain, I did notice a change. My heart... I cannot...” And just like that, Thorin loses his train of thought. “Excuse me,” he says, suddenly distracted, and Bilbo abandons patience and any hope this guy ever wanted to court him. Because if there’s one thing he cannot stand, it’s Thorin addressing a serious topic that five seconds ago had him look dejected as hell, only to now give Bilbo a royal ignore. Because as of now, believe it or not, Thorin entirely forgoes their conversation and starts circling the tree again, looking up and down, inspecting every ridge in the tree trunk. What are you doing, Bilbo wants to ask, but there is no point: it’s clear Thorin didn’t come here for him.
“Unlove,” he mutters bitterly. “Not bad. That certainly can lead to a decrease in broken hearts on this earth.”
No courage would have been needed to tell Thorin everything. How Bilbo would have wanted to be courted by him. No, it turns out courage is reserved for this super lame, anticlimactic end, where Thorin treats his feelings as an afterthought, while coddling the tree like a baby.
“Hey. I just remembered. Gandalf should be here any time, to take me home. Ori offered to help me with packing; I’d better get to that. See you later.” Bilbo leans over his blanket, rolls it up and leaves, careful to avoid Thorin’s eyes.
* * *
Thorin remains there, eyes fighting to stay focused, his body to hold his balance. Everything is happening too fast. So traumatized by today’s events, his processing is severely delayed; only now he fully registers Bilbo is still here, safe from the disgraceful elf.
But one thing he did notice, as soon as he found Bilbo outside. That warmth that accompanies every thought of him, that happiness Bilbo’s presence ignites, that mind-blowing feeling that has unrivaled worth and yet comes at no cost, that life is just wonderful now that he is in the world, is gone. There’s an emptiness where his heart used to be. This is how Thorin knows something is very wrong. The tree mirrors his feelings: if the ice in the tree melted, he should be able to regain them in their true form. Yet he cannot find those feelings at all. Which must mean they are now worse than frozen; they’re lost.
This is why Thorin didn’t say anything, as much as he would have wanted to tell Bilbo who those feelings were for.
It’s a good thing Bilbo doesn’t know.
He could have said it, though. Thorin’s mind may be a poor substitute for his heart, but it holds the certainty of that love: it knows he loves Bilbo, and will love him, always.
He could say it, still. If Bilbo were still here...
Did Thorin upset him? Probably. That’s how it always ends: in the visions he’s had, the tree thrives for a while, but Bilbo...
Bilbo is -
The mind can’t meet reality; can’t cut through the numbness, the fog. His eyelids drape heavily over his field of vision, and Thorin’s head drops. He ponders absently, was it fighting the fire that exhausted him, or that the fire is not there anymore.
What did he do to himself? In his attempt to avert danger, he substituted one madness for another: one that appears to have claimed his heart.
Can he even function without his heart.
I am not thinking about that. I can function just fine, I-
What did Bilbo say?...
A loud, powerful THUD is heard, very much in Thorin’s proximity. Something rigid knocks him to the ground.
The tree smacked him.
It’s refreshing, for a minute, to lie there in a daze and taste this medicine, and thank Yavanna for letting him grow this thing. It absolutely was not a waste of time.
Thorin opens his eyes, and something, finally, clicks into place.
Bilbo is leaving.
He gets up, starts running and catches up with the hobbit in no time.
“Don’t go,” he begins - begs - trying to keep his body from advancing towards Bilbo and binding them together for eternity, because lack of feelings will do that to you: Thorin has never felt so bold in his life.
“What?...”
“Please, don’t go,” he tries desperately to articulate.
“Look, Thorin,” Bilbo replies in a friendly tone. “It’s getting late, and I don’t have much time left to pack. We can postpone our meeting for another time.”
“Not that. I mean... don’t go home. Please. Stay.”
“Stay? Where, exactly?”
“Here. In Erebor.”
“Um. I don’t mean to sound impolite, but Erebor is not my home.”'
“I understand. I didn’t think this Mountain had anything to offer you. Until-” Thorin takes Bilbo’s hand and walks them back to the oak. “Bilbo, listen. I planted this tree for you. Regrettably, it won’t be complete any time soon, and in my madness I destroyed some of it. But I can still offer it to you, and promise you it will grow again. I know it’s not enough, you deserve a lot more, a house like your Shire home, a proper garden, fifty shades of green, and... better weather than what you’ve seen this past week. But it’s a start. Please, consider it.”
Thorin is out of breath. How in the world could he get all of this out?
Bilbo, I care for you more than anything, he wants to say next. But the words won’t come out; it’s like a force prevents Thorin from opening his mouth.
It makes sense he can’t say it. Words getting anywhere close to love should come from the heart, after all; but as of now Thorin is still without one.
* * *
Bilbo listens with interest; he’s looking forward to hearing why Thorin practically begged him to stay. Take your time. But Thorin has other plans, it looks like. He approaches the tree again, who seems to have guessed his mind: it lowers its branches and invites its king to climb. And now Thorin is in the tree, poking frantically at every leaf within reach.
“What in Yavanna’s name are you doing?” asks Bilbo, exasperated.
Without a by-your-leave, the tree immediately drops Thorin to the ground.
“I thought maybe the tree had the answer.”
“To what?”
“To what happened to my feelings. I’m thinking they must be somewhere... in here.”
“Yeah, I wouldn’t put it past it to play a prank,” says Bilbo. He meant it as a joke, though the same thing occurred to him while here alone, except he thought Thorin had done it, Thorin had hidden his love, who else could have tampered with such a personal thing.
“Earlier, I protected the tree; it’s possible it tried to protect me. Perhaps it saw what I was trying to do was dangerous, and decided to help. As in, literally, took my feelings and placed them somewhere safe. Here,” Thorin says, gesturing towards the oak but not knowing exactly where. “But I cannot find - I do not even know how to look for them.”
Who could have tampered with such a personal thing...
Bilbo may know something about this.
The realization is frightening.
“I think I know what happened,” he says in alarm.
“You do?”
“Yes. I. It’s possible your, um... feelings - completely inadvertently - ended up with me.”
And Thorin may be gazing at him with fondness, for once. It matters not; it does not calm Bilbo down. A second sun does seem to be emerging, though; or is it the same sun that has set in the meantime, and now reappears above the horizon line.
“My feelings ended up with you?”
“Y... yes - maybe,” says Bilbo. He’s absolutely terrified. “Thorin. I know it doesn’t look good. Please, bear with me. I didn’t mean to steal them.”
Thorin holds his arms firmly, steadying him. “You have nothing to worry about.”
Bilbo reaches in his pocket, then opens his shaking hand, revealing a tiny thing.
His acorn.
“Here.”
Thorin knows what he is looking at. What started it all, what set in motion his disaster of a courting plan, and the thing that still holds power over him. To make him forget what was once intoxicating lust and greed, for gold less than for him, resigned into submission to an inordinate amount of guilt that didn’t feel right either, and now - always - this. To take away the madness and let him come back to himself.
And there’s a way to tell Thorin Oakenshield has come back to himself.
His face relaxes into a smile: the most beautiful in Middle Earth, without a doubt. Bilbo has seen Thorin smile like this only once, when likewise he spoke about leaving Erebor and planting his acorn at home; in Bag End, he had specified. There were tears, too, then, in Thorin’s eyes; Bilbo didn’t understand why.
“Tell me.” Bilbo feels the heat in the king’s voice; it startles him. Is anger going to manifest in the fire within... if anger is something Thorin can still feel.
“All right. This is super awkward, but I’m pretty sure the... stuff you mentioned is locked in here.”
And Bilbo cannot think why Thorin regards him with adoration, cannot know: that warmth that is always present when Thorin thinks of his One, he regained it as soon as Bilbo opened his hand.
“Bilbo,” he says, thoroughly smitten with hobbit and acorn both.
“When I was here earlier, I had... an experience. You see - blasted inquisitiveness of hobbits: having understood recent weather events were caused by your emotional states, I got your tree - who was very kind, by the way - to show me a glimpse of one of those... states. It’s hard to describe what it felt like. Out of this world? I don’t really have a name for that emotion, but it was probably what you’re looking for.”
Bilbo pauses; prays he’s allowed to stop here. He’s grateful for the open air; much better than being confined inside, or worse, on Erebor’s wall, because he will look in Thorin’s eyes and confess it, as he should have done the first time.
He dares look up, only to find Thorin’s eyes rest in him, as if they would immortalize this moment if it weren’t for Bilbo actually being nervous out of his mind. “Please, continue.”
“Right. Let’s just say I enjoyed that experience so much, I made a wish. I imagine a feeling like that is vast, boundless, like... like the weather, so maybe it’s not much to ask... I asked if your tree could transfer a small part of that feeling to... to this.” Bilbo points to the acorn, in true bewilderment at his own action. “And I’m starting to think that it did,” and now he can really hear You would steal from me? with both ears. “And since you cannot find any of it, the tree probably transferred it all,” he completes with the absolute worst part.
“Anyway. You can have this.” He offers Thorin the acorn. “I am sorry to have intruded in your privacy.”
Thorin closes Bilbo’s hand around the seed.
“If your intrusion had been unwelcome, the tree would not have obeyed you.”
“No, really, Thorin. The tree was just being nice. There was an acorn involved; maybe they’re related, who knows? It is, of course, right that your feelings... your heart should return to you.”
“They already have.”
Bilbo breathes in relief - and disbelief. I guess that means I won’t get anything. Not even a fragment of that emotion he didn’t call by name, though Bilbo knows exactly what it is. It’s only fair, he supposes, to have lost his chance at getting the thing he craves most, considering he now managed to steal Thorin’s heart twice. Maybe Bilbo should just go ahead and admit it: he’s really going about love the wrong way.
He should. And yet... hold that thought. Because in the meantime, and more to the point -
There’s something to be said about Thorin’s smile. Especially when he’s overcome with happiness, and there are no tears in his eyes; more so when it distinctly appears this outcome is leaving him satisfied. Does this mean Thorin will forgive him, will there be another opportunity for a date, does Thorin still want him to stay. Bilbo would ask, but even that seems small and stupid and not worth fretting about. Not when all Bilbo can think right now is how in Yavanna’s green gardens can this dude get away with so much; not when his mind is irremediably stuck on Thorin’s smile. Love him or hate him, it’s an irresistible sight.
