Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Picture Perfect

Summary:

Frodo Baggins always sees his parents’ relationship—Bilbo and Thorin’s—as the perfect fairy tale kind of love, full of warmth and devotion. That is, until Thorin’s Company shatters this ideal, forcing Frodo to confront a far more complicated truth.

Notes:

I hope you enjoy a glimmer into Thorin and Bilbo's love story in this series of mine, through the eyes of their dwobbit son! Thank you andyrucos for cheering me on, betaing this for me!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

After returning to Azsâlul'abad from his yearly visit to the Shire, where he enjoys the festivities and reunites with his hobbit relatives, Prince Frodo Baggins sighs in relief as he lands on his bed with a thump. As much as he loves seeing the Shire, traveling always takes a toll on the dwobbit. Still, he cherishes the new memories he has made. His Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin dance the festivities away, free from the weight of their royal responsibilities. Frodo knows his parents are devoted to their duty, but he also understands how stressful it can be. Seeing them so carefree makes him smile.

Of course, he also enjoys spending time with his relatives and hobbit friends. It is always wonderful to be around people who see him not as a prince, but simply as himself, a dwobbit, a friend, and a teenager. It is a refreshing change. His parents, aunts, uncles, and cousins do their best to make him feel like an ordinary lad in private here in Azsâlul'abad, but it is far more liberating in the Shire, where there is no need for pretense. He does not begrudge his family for maintaining appearances in Azsâlul'abad; they are royalty, after all, and must uphold a certain image.

Still, never in his life did he imagine he would receive a marriage proposal in the Shire. In Azsâlul'abad, yes, many nobles have attempted to offer their daughters’ hands in marriage, hoping to strengthen ties with the royal family. His parents, being such an unconventional couple, two males, a hobbit and a dwarf, never even consider the political advantages and flatly reject these offers, doing their best to shield Frodo from them. But he is aware of them nonetheless. He has met a few of these daughters; most are awkward, clearly as uninterested as he is. A few are poised and accepting of their roles as political pawns. And an even smaller number manage to befriend him. But none spark the kind of connection his Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin describe when they speak of love. In the end, every proposal he receives fizzles out without much fuss.

But the one in the Shire is by far the most surprising, and the most awkward. Little Samwise Gamgee, a sweet fauntling with his heart on his sleeve, presents him with a red rose and asks to court him. Naturally, Frodo declines. The lad is far too young, and Frodo is certain his affection is nothing more than a romanticized idea of princes, likely inspired by fairy tales, the same ones he once heard as a child from Papa Bilbo. He, too, once dreamed of rescuing a princess and making her his queen. Now, a little older, he understands how unrealistic those fantasies are, and he believes Sam will grow out of his infatuation as well. Still, it is endearing.

Yet, the more Frodo thinks about the unexpected proposal, the more he longs for a love like that of Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin. Theirs is a love straight out of the stories, effortless, unwavering, filled with pure joy in each other’s presence. They never fight, they always stand by each other’s side, and they find happiness even in silence, simply existing together. Many have tried to pull them apart, yet they always emerge unscathed. Frodo wonders if he will ever find someone like that for himself, someone who sees him as their perfect love, someone he can trust wholeheartedly, someone who just knows what is on his mind. 

Oh, he knows his parents are blessed by Mahal and Yavanna, and he can only hope for the same. But as Adad Thorin always says, one must work for what they wish to gain, and Frodo believes love is worth the effort. But how does one go about finding it? Perhaps he should ask around. His uncles and cousins, Fíli and Kíli, were there during the quest when Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin met. Surely, they know how their love blossomed into what it is today. If he asks them, maybe he will gain insight into what his own picture-perfect love will look like when he finally meets them.

But first, he needs rest. He can seek answers in the morning.


Frodo finds his uncle Dwalin in his usual spot by the barracks, overseeing recruits whenever he is not guarding the royal family. Noticing him, the dwarf smiles.

“Frodo! How are you, laddie?” he asks, grabbing Frodo’s cheeks and gently bumping his forehead against the dwobbit’s.

“I’m doing good, Uncle Dwalin!” Frodo smiles happily at the warm greeting.

“Need anything? You here for some practice? Just because you’re a prince doesn’t mean I’m going to hold back, laddie.” Dwalin grins in anticipation but frowns when Frodo shakes his head.

“Actually, Uncle Dwalin, I wanted to ask a few questions. You were with my Papa and Adad during the quest, right?” Frodo asks.

“Of course! But you already knew that. What about it, laddie?” Dwalin leans against the wall, waiting for Frodo to answer.

“Well, I wanted to hear about how Papa and Adad were back then. They seem so in sync now, no fighting, no misunderstandings. It’s like they can read each other’s minds. I want that kind of love for myself. One that feels like it came straight out of a fairy tale. So I was hoping you could tell me how they realized they were perfect for each other,” Frodo confesses.

But instead of answering, Dwalin covers his face with one hand, clearly trying to hold back laughter.

“Uncle Dwalin?”

Dwalin can’t stop himself and bursts into loud laughter. “A love straight out of a fairy tale?! That’s priceless! Frodo, dear lad, your parents are nothing like that!”

Frodo pouts, twitching his nose in indignation. “I do have eyes, Uncle Dwalin! And I know their love is as perfect as the ones in those books!” he declares proudly.

Dwalin only laughs harder. “It’s not funny!”

“Oh, yes, it is! Frodo, your Papa and Adad are the most dysfunctional couple I have ever witnessed!” Dwalin gasps as he tries to recover from his laughter.

“Not true!” Frodo huffs, feeling the need to defend his parents.

“So true! Let me tell you a story, laddie. Now, this was before your Papa and Adad became official, alright? Azsâlul'abad was being rebuilt, and your Papa Bilbo was helping us. But some dwarrows didn’t like that, thought he had no right to be there because he wasn’t a dwarf. But your Papa wasn’t afraid, he did face Smaug, after all.” Dwalin’s voice softens as he recalls the memory, clearly fond of the hobbit’s stubbornness.

“But Papa helped reclaim Azsâlul'abad!” Frodo exclaims.

“He did, which is why anyone with a brain actually enjoys having him around. But idiots exist everywhere,” Dwalin shrugs with a chuckle before continuing. “Now, one of those blockheads insulted your Papa Bilbo during a meeting in front of everyone. To protect your Papa Bilbo’s honor, your Adad Thorin rose from his seat and challenged him to a duel.”

Frodo’s heart swells at the thought. Among dwarrows, fighting for someone’s honor is a romantic gesture. He imagines how flustered Papa Bilbo must have been at such a grand declaration.

But then Uncle Dwalin says, “Your Papa Bilbo was horrified and said he’d rather have me fight for him.”

Frodo’s jaw drops. That means Papa Bilbo basically said he preferred Uncle Dwalin over Adad Thorin. “No way! Papa Bilbo wouldn’t choose you over Adad!”

“Hey, I’m a catch!” Dwalin glares before laughing. “But yeah, that’s exactly how your Adad Thorin reacted! He was so angry and hurt that he practically declared he was the only one who could fight for your Papa Bilbo’s honor, and then ignored your Papa for days leading up to the duel.”

Frodo bites his lip. That does sound exactly like his Adad.

“Your Papa Bilbo, though, is just as stubborn. So, on the day of the duel, he snuck into the preparation room to beg your Adad Thorin not to go through with it. And, of course, your Adad did not take that well.”

Frodo is horrified. He knows how much Adad Thorin values his skills as a warrior, and any suggestion otherwise would be an insult. Not to mention, it made it seem like Papa Bilbo didn’t want to be with him, which Frodo knows isn’t true.

Dwalin watches Frodo’s expression and chuckles. “Yep, your Adad Thorin was insulted. He yelled that he was going to do it, that there was no way he’d back down now. He even said he’d gladly spill his blood to protect your Papa Bilbo’s honor. And then, your Papa Bilbo started crying.”

Frodo isn’t surprised. His Papa Bilbo always told him that crying wasn’t something to be ashamed of. He has seen him in tears before.

Dwalin continues, “Your Papa Bilbo said, ‘Don’t leave me, Thorin. Not again.’”

Frodo snorts at Dwalin’s attempt to mimic Bilbo’s voice but listens on.

“Your Adad Thorin’s anger vanished instantly. He asked why your Papa Bilbo was crying and saying that. And that’s when your Papa Bilbo explained that he knew your Adad’s wounds from the Battle of the Five Armies hadn’t fully healed. And they hadn’t, true. But you know how stubborn your Adad is. Your Papa Bilbo was terrified he’d get hurt or, worse, die from this duel. He couldn’t bear to see your Adad bedridden again, fighting for his life.”

“Oh…” Frodo murmurs, suddenly understanding. He has heard stories of how his Adad Thorin, along with his cousins Fíli and Kíli, nearly died in the Battle of the Five Armies. He can see why his Papa Bilbo wouldn’t want him to fight.

“Yeah. So once your Adad Thorin finally understood, he immediately gave me the honor of fighting for your Papa Bilbo instead. I won, obviously. And while I was busy fighting, your parents were all cuddled up in the audience.” Dwalin chuckles. “So, see, Frodo? Your parents’ love isn’t perfect.”

Frodo still thinks it is. That was just one misunderstanding.

Dwalin notices his expression and grins. “Go ask the others. You’ll see, they’re a disaster. Go on.”

Frodo pouts but thanks his uncle. “Thank you, Uncle. I’ll go and ask the others.” He turns and walks away, determined to prove Dwalin wrong.


Frodo walks toward the office of the one family member he is certain will tell him the truth, his uncle Balin. No one is as observant as Balin, save for his own Papa Bilbo and Uncle Nori.

When he steps inside, he wastes no time. “Uncle Balin, do you have some time to answer a few questions?”

Balin looks up from the paperwork he has been reading and smiles. “But of course, laddie. What questions do you have?” He sets the papers aside, giving Frodo his full attention.

“You know how perfect my parents’ love f—”

“HAH!”

Balin lets out an uncharacteristically loud laugh, cutting off Frodo’s sentence. He quickly covers his mouth, looking mildly horrified at himself. “My apologies, laddie. Do go on…” he says sheepishly.

Frodo pouts, clearly unimpressed. He does not like the way Balin just reacted. “As I was saying, Uncle,” he glares, taking a seat across from Balin’s desk, unconsciously mimicking his Adad Thorin’s posture, “you know how perfect my parents’ love is. I was wondering if they noticed any signs early on, how quickly they got close. Did they show any indication that they were the One for each other?”

Balin leans forward, takes Frodo’s hand gently, and says, “Frodo, my sweet dear lad… I say this with all the love and affection I have for your Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin…” He sighs dramatically. “How they haven’t murdered each other yet, I’ll never know.”

“I beg your pardon?” Frodo’s nose twitches in disbelief.

“Well, truthfully, I imagine one giving the other a heart attack before outright violence,” Balin replies matter-of-factly.

“Uncle Balin, you’re not making any sense.” Frodo crosses his arms, now glaring daggers at his dwarven uncle.

“Laddie, your parents aren’t perfect. No one is. Especially not with the nightmare of a relationship they have,” Balin chuckles fondly. “I can give you an example right now if you’d like.”

“It can’t be that bad, Uncle.” Frodo refuses to believe his parents’ love is anything less than extraordinary.

“Oh, laddie, you weren’t there to witness it all.” Balin laughs as Frodo’s glare sharpens. He finds it adorable. “Alright, settle down. I’ll tell you a story.”

Balin leans back in his chair, reminiscing. “Now, at this time, Azsâlul'abad had reached a stage where your Aunt Dís could start bringing in more dwarrows that weren’t essential to the rebuilding effort. For all intents and purposes, the mountain had begun healing in earnest, giving your Adad Thorin time for breaks.”

Frodo scoffs. “He didn’t take them, did he?”

Balin chuckles. “No, he did not. You know what he did instead? He spent that time making adornments for your Papa Bilbo, beautiful pieces of jewelry crafted with precious stones and fine metals. Many of which you can still see your Papa Bilbo wearing today.”

Frodo nods. He knows his Papa Bilbo has numerous cases of jewelry, most of which were made by Adad Thorin. Only a few are gifts from friends, subjects, or visiting nobles, and even then, Papa Bilbo only wears those when absolutely necessary, usually when the noble who gave it is present. Otherwise, he almost exclusively wears the ones Adad Thorin made for him.

“But isn’t that sweet?” Frodo asks, puzzled. “What could possibly go wrong with Adad Thorin making gifts for Papa Bilbo?”

Balin smiles knowingly. “It is sweet. But tell me, laddie, you’ve been to the Shire, haven’t you? Visited it yearly, yes? Can you tell me how hobbits view jewelry? How often they wear it?”

Frodo groans. He came here for answers, not questions. But he supposes it wouldn’t be a visit with Uncle Balin if he didn’t make him think first. “Hobbits don’t wear jewelry often,” he answers. “At least, not highly decorated pieces, and never in large numbers. They prefer simple ones, usually just one or two pieces. The more fashionable ones are worn for celebrations. Anyone who wears too much, or overly extravagant pieces, is seen as vain.” Like a certain Sackville-Baggins.

“And how do dwarrows view jewelry?” Balin asks, his smile widening.

Frodo groans again. “Dwarrows love jewelry. The more, the better, it’s a sign of status, wealth, and personal pride. A bare dwarf is considered an oddity.”

Balin nods. “Now, knowing this… what do you think your Papa Bilbo did with your Adad Thorin’s gifts?”

Frodo frowns, thinking. Then, suddenly, his face pales.

“Papa Bilbo… would have kept them on display in his room instead of wearing them… essentially implying that Adad Thorin’s craftsmanship wasn’t worth wearing,” Frodo whispers, horrified. He can picture it, the look of pain on his Adad Thorin’s face.

“That’s right,” Balin confirms. “Your Papa Bilbo hurt your Adad Thorin deeply. Thorin was so ashamed, he refused to be in the same room as him. And when your Adad is in a mood, he is never a good king. The entire court suffered for it.”

Frodo winces. He can imagine the tense atmosphere of the throne room during that time.

“Luckily, I asked Bilbo about it,” Balin continues. “And once he explained, I told him why Thorin was avoiding him. An hour later, your Papa Bilbo snuck into your Adad Thorin’s room—draped in every single piece of jewelry he had received from him—begging for forgiveness and promising to always wear at least one of Thorin’s gifts. That was enough to make your Adad smile again. He forgave Bilbo and, of course, made even more jewelry for him after that.”

Balin finishes the story with a fond smile.

Frodo pouts. “They still sound like the perfect couple.”

“Really?” Balin raises a bushy brow. “Because I have plenty more stories. But before you accuse me of making them up, why don’t you go ask your other uncles?”

“I will!” Frodo declares, waving goodbye as he marches out of the office, determined to prove them all wrong.


As soon as Frodo steps out of the room, he begins searching for his other uncles. Uncle Óin and Uncle Glóin should be in their respective offices. But on the way, he spots Kíli waiting in the hallway. He’s likely waiting for either Tauriel or Fíli, both are equally probable.

The more Frodo thinks about it, the more it makes sense to ask Kíli about his parents’ relationship. After all, his cousin was there during the quest too.

“Cousin Kíli!” Frodo calls out, waving as he runs toward him.

“Frodo! My favorite cousin!” Kíli grins when he sees him, gently grabs Frodo’s cheeks, and presses their foreheads together in greeting.

“I’m not doing so well, actually,” Frodo admits. “I’ve been asking around about love, and Uncle Dwalin and Uncle Balin say that Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin’s relationship is less than perfect.”

Kíli bursts into laughter. “Oh, that’s true! You’d think I’d have the worst relationship, being with an elf and all, but no! That honor goes to them.”

“Oh, not you too!” Frodo groans, exasperated to see Kíli agreeing with the others.

“Well, it’s true! I still don’t know how Uncle Bilbo and Uncle Thorin are even together . There were so many times I thought Uncle Bilbo was going to pack up and head back to the Shire,” Kíli says with a shudder. “Things went wrong between them so many times, cousin.”

“That’s not true! Papa Bilbo stayed here!” Frodo yells, unable to hold back his frustration.

“For some reason,” Kíli shrugs with a chuckle. “Every time, Uncle Bilbo stayed, even when Uncle Thorin hurt him. Not on purpose, of course! And Uncle Bilbo hurt him too. They never meant to, it’s just how interspecies relationships are. I should know. I’m married to the most beautiful and amazing elf,” Kíli sighs, momentarily lost in thought at the mention of Tauriel.

“Cousin, focus ,” Frodo says, snapping his fingers in front of Kíli’s face.

Kíli blinks and shakes his head. “Sorry about that. But yeah, even couples of the same species hurt each other. It’s inevitable. But you know what they say: communication is key, so we don’t keep making the same mistakes. Sadly, your uncles have made those mistakes, just in different flavors.”

Frodo rolls his eyes. “Yeah? Like what?”

“Well… you know how Uncle Thorin is a tad... xenophobic when it comes to elves?” Kíli asks.

Frodo nods. He knows his Adad Thorin holds a grudge against the elves, especially the Greenwood elves, because of how they treated the dwarrows of Azsâlul'abad after Smaug’s attack. And while the old grudges between dwarrows and elves have mostly faded in Azsâlul'abad, Thorin’s disdain seems focused squarely on King Thranduil.

“Yes, what about it?”

“Well… alright, let me paint the picture,” Kíli begins. “I was trying to get Uncle Thorin’s approval to marry my amrâlimê , Tauriel, and… things got heated. I yelled, he screamed, I yelled some more, he screamed louder. You know how passionate us dwarrows can be. I’m honestly surprised we didn’t draw weapons on each other.”

Frodo nods grimly. He can picture it. His Adad Thorin can be terrifying when angry, and those of Durin’s line are known for being particularly stubborn.

“I can see that happening. But how does this relate to Papa Bilbo and Adad’s love for each other?”

“Well…” Kíli scratches the back of his neck. “Uncle Thorin got so angry, he shouted that he wouldn’t allow any ‘leaf-eater’ to stay in the mountain. That anyone with sharp ears was impossibly ugly, and anyone who’s hairless should just die in a ditch. And that no dwarf should ever marry someone who isn’t a dwarf.”

Frodo bites the inside of his cheek. Those insults... they apply to elves, sure. But hobbits too. Hobbits enjoy their greens, they have pointed ears, they barely grow any hair aside from their heads, and feet. The last statement hits hardest.

“Don’t tell me…” Frodo says, already dreading the answer.

“Oh yes. Uncle Bilbo heard everything ,” Kíli confirms. “I hadn’t even noticed him. He was standing in the corner, listening the whole time. The moment he sobbed, Uncle Thorin and I turned just in time to see him running away. And Uncle Thorin ran after him, yelling, begging him to listen, saying it was only meant for elves —that he didn’t mean to include hobbits in the insult. He said Uncle Bilbo was worthy of Azsâlul'abad, that his ears are adorable, and that he loves how smooth his skin is.”

Kíli rolls his eyes. “Truly incredible wordplay from your Adad, cousin.”

“Oh, ha ha . Very funny,” Frodo says dryly. “So what happened next?”

“Well, Uncle Bilbo asked him about the last part, about dwarrows not being allowed to marry non-dwarrows. And Uncle Thorin told him that he would make it legal in Azsâlul'abad. Then they stared into each other’s eyes for so long, I had to walk away.”

Frodo tilts his head. “That’s… kind of a sweet proposal, isn’t it?”

“Oh, they weren’t even courting yet at that point,” Kíli says with a laugh, just as Tauriel steps into view.

“Greetings, Frodo. How are you?” Tauriel asks warmly. Kíli immediately kisses her hand.

“And hello, my love,” he says, smiling dreamily.

“Greetings, Cousin Tauriel,” Frodo says cheerfully, waving hello.

“Hello to you too, beautiful. Ready for a day out in the market?” Kíli asks, beaming at her.

“I am. Would you like to join us, Frodo?” Tauriel offers.

Frodo quickly shakes his head. “Oh no, thank you. I still have a few more people to question.”

“Yeah, bye! Me and Tauriel have to go!” Kíli calls as he walks off, hand-in-hand with his wife.

Frodo watches them go, already thinking about who to bother next.


Before Frodo can take another step, he hears a familiar voice. Turning around, he sees Fíli walking toward him with a smile.

“Hey, cousin! Have you seen my brother? I wanted to ask him for a spar or two since I finally have a rare break.”

“Ah, sorry, cousin, but Kíli just went out with his wife, Tauriel, to the market,” Frodo replies.

Fíli groans loudly. “Damn it! And I can’t bother Ori today either because he’s with your Papa Bilbo cataloging the food storages.” He sighs again, heavier this time. “I wish I were the secondborn instead. At least then I’d have time to date my own husband.”

“I mean, Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin seem to find time for each other,” Frodo points out.

Fíli gives him a half-hearted glare. “ They work together. Unlike me and my Ori.”

He sighs again. Despite Ori being named Crown Prince Consort after marrying Fíli, his main duties still revolve around his role as the royal librarian, something Fíli is proud of. That is his Ori’s Craft, and Fíli can’t bear to keep him from it just for consort duties, especially when Uncle Bilbo and his mother, Dís, handle such work efficiently. That doesn’t mean Ori never does consort duties, like today, where he’s assisting Uncle Bilbo.

“Aha! So you do think their love is perfect! I knew it!” Frodo exclaims, triumphant.

“Perfect? Oh, sweet cousin of mine,” Fíli says, shaking his head with a chuckle. “Despite my lack of time with my own husband, I wouldn’t trade my relationship for what your parents have. The amount of drama those two stir up makes me shudder . And that’s coming from me, a royal who married a commoner .” He pauses, then laughs. “Then again, my brother married an elf , so mine seems the least problematic.”

“You’re just jealous!” Frodo pouts.

“So worked up today! Cousin Frodo, are you okay?” Fíli asks, amused but also concerned.

“I’m fine, it’s just… I had a confession back in the Shire—”

Fíli makes a face, knowing what kind of confessions royalty gets, but he lets Frodo continue.

“—and it made me wonder how Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin found each other. How they knew they were perfect for each other. Because their love is just so beautiful , like the ones I’ve read about.”

“Oh, trust me, cousin, that kind of love takes a lot of hard work . Especially with those parents of yours.” Fíli crosses his arms. “Why, I remember a time when Uncle Thorin was so busy he couldn’t see Uncle Bilbo at all . This was when my mother finally arrived in Azsâlul'abad with the rest of our people, so naturally, there was a lot of paperwork involved.” He groans at the memory.

Frodo wonders just how much paperwork it must have been to put such a dreaded expression on his cousin’s face.

“To be fair, it wasn’t just Uncle Thorin who was busy, everyone was. We were so overworked that none of us had time to spend with Uncle Bilbo. So, seeing how exhausted we all were, Uncle Bilbo tried to help out. He started doing paperwork, handling trades for Uncle Thorin, and all sorts of things. He was essentially acting as a consort before they even started courting.” Fíli smiles at the memory.

Frodo can easily picture it. Papa Bilbo has been doing consort duties for as long as he can remember. But before he and Adad Thorin even began courting?

“Wait… how did he get away with that?”

“Ah, yes. How did he get away with it?” Fíli smirks. “Well… that was my fault. I was desperate for help—and for some time with Ori—so when Bilbo offered, I gave him a copy of my seal. As Crown Prince, I had the authority to delegate tasks however I saw fit. But when Uncle Thorin found out, he panicked —because of what it implied .”

Fíli shakes his head, still amused by the memory. “He was terrified Uncle Bilbo would realize that what he was doing looked exactly like consort work. He thought that if Bilbo understood how it made him appear to our people, he’d be scared. Or worse, disgusted.”

Frodo frowns. “That’s ridiculous. Why would he—”

“Because Uncle Thorin was convinced that if Uncle Bilbo ever realized people saw him as a potential consort, he’d be appalled. The very idea of being tied to Uncle Thorin might horrify him.”

Frodo sighs. His Adad is a worrier, but then again, so is Papa Bilbo.

“So what happened?”

“Well, Uncle Thorin made me tell Bilbo about how his work was making him look like a consort-to-be, because he didn’t want to see Bilbo’s reaction himself.” Fíli snorts. “And then he proceeded to eavesdrop by hiding behind a pillar.”

Frodo groans. That sounds like something his father would do.

“So, I told Uncle Bilbo. And you know what he said? He asked if Uncle Thorin didn’t want him to keep helping. That if Thorin thought the rumors of him wanting to be with a hobbit were so horrible, then he would stop.” Fíli’s voice softens as he remembers. “He apologized , cousin. He said he was just trying to help, but if he was causing problems, then he’d step back.”

Frodo clenches his fists. “That’s not fair —”

“Oh, Uncle Thorin agreed with you there. The moment he heard that, he rushed out from behind the pillar, grabbed Uncle Bilbo’s hand, and told him his help was needed , but, more importantly, it was wanted .” Fíli smirks. “He told him the rumors were just rumors, and that he didn’t mind if people saw Bilbo as his consort-to-be.”

Frodo blinks. “And?”

“And then they both got so blushy and awkward that I had to walk away before I saw something that would give me nightmares.”

“That’s how they started courting?” Frodo asks, raising an eyebrow.

“Nope!” Fíli laughs. “The next day, Uncle Bilbo kept working, but now he was using Uncle Thorin’s seal instead of mine. Which, of course, sent the rumor mill wild . And yet? Still no courting bead in either of their hair.” He shakes his head. “Most of the Company wanted to lock them in a room together after that.”

Frodo groans. “So… you’re saying their love isn’t perfect? I—uh…” Frodo hesitates.

Fíli smirks, ruffling Frodo’s curls. “In any case, I’m off to see if Uncle Bilbo will let me follow Ori around today. If it were Mother or Uncle Thorin, they’d say no, but I think I can persuade Uncle Bilbo.” He waves. “See you later, cousin!”

Frodo waves back, watching him leave.

For the first time, doubt creeps in. Is it real? Is his parents’ love truly imperfect ?

But then he remembers how disgustingly happy they are together.

No. It’s perfect.

He just has to find the right person to tell him the truth.

So, with renewed determination, he continues his task, asking everyone from the quest about his parents’ relationship.


Frodo walks out of the castle and heads toward Uncle Dori’s guild, the Weaver’s Guild. Normally, his cousin Gimli would accompany him whenever he goes outside, but today, Gimli has a fever. Frodo plans to visit him later, but first, he has a question for Uncle Dori.

When he enters the guild, several dwarrows look up from their work making clothing, offering their hellos, but none get up or bow before him as tradition dictates. His Papa Bilbo made sure the royal family remains accessible and friendly enough that such formalities are unnecessary.

Frodo waves back before making his way to Dori’s office, where his uncle is busy sewing.

“Oh, Frodo! Nice to see you! Did you need some new clothes? You could have sent a messenger, you know,” Dori greets him warmly.

“Hello, Uncle Dori,” Frodo replies with a smile, walking over and gently pressing his forehead against his uncle’s. “I just came by to ask a question. And you know I like to walk, Uncle.”

“Ah yes, something you inherited from your Papa Bilbo. You’d think after our quest he’d hate walking, with all of his complaining back then,” Dori chuckles fondly. “What’s your question, dear lad?”

“Oh, you know how perfect my parents’ love is,” Frodo begins, pausing to gauge his uncle’s reaction. As expected, Dori’s lips curl up ever so slightly, though he says nothing. “I was wondering if they showed any signs early on during the quest? Like, how did they know they were the one for each other? Because I want a love like that, and well… I’d really like any hints.”

Dori sighs, shaking his head. “Oh, dear lad, I can tell you that your parents’ love for each other is true, but it isn’t perfect. The same can be said for me and your Uncle Balin. Same for my brother Nori and your uncle Dwalin. And the same for my brother Ori and your cousin Fili. No love is perfect. The thing is, it only seems perfect because your parents try their best not to show any problems in their relationship. No parent wants to subject their child to their relationship troubles, after all. I’ll admit, it isn’t as bad as it was back then. Now, they know how to communicate, how to be brave enough to tell the other when something makes them uncomfortable. But back then, Frodo? It was a disaster.” Dori chuckles fondly at the memory.

Frodo pouts. Hiding it? Have his parents always had problems? Just for his sake?

“You see, even with the best intentions, one can still hurt another,” Dori continues. “For example, your Adad Thorin once asked me to help him make a gift. Before then, he had only given your Papa Bilbo dwarven gifts—beautiful and well-received, I assure you, but he wanted to show that he loved your Papa Bilbo just as he was. That he was willing to incorporate hobbit culture into Azsâlul'abad. And this was even before they officially started courting. So he asked me to help him make a bouquet.

“We had heard from Ori that your Papa Bilbo once told him flowers were common gifts in the Shire. We dwarrows don’t see the appeal of such things, flowers wither and die, and ephemeral gifts don’t suit our traditions. But your Adad Thorin wanted to give them to your Papa Bilbo anyway, because he understood their meaning to hobbits.”

Frodo’s face lights up. This story sounds like it will prove that their love is perfect! Just like in the storybooks! But then he sees his uncle’s expression twist into something pained.

“Now, you know that we dwarrows have a language using precious gems, yes? The same way hobbits have a language with flowers? Well…” Dori hesitates, looking guilty. “I had no clue what flower language was, so I made a bouquet based only on color. And it was a beautiful bouquet, but… I used white lilies, yellow chrysanthemums, black dahlias, purple snapdragons, yellow carnations, foxgloves, and cedar sprigs…”

Frodo winces. He recognizes those flowers and what they mean together. White lilies symbolize purity and renewal. Yellow chrysanthemums represent grief and farewell. Black dahlias signify betrayal and the end of a relationship. Purple snapdragons stand for deception and resilience. Yellow carnations express disdain. Foxgloves symbolize insincerity. And cedar sprigs are associated with mourning and finality. Individually, they’re common in funeral arrangements, representing grief, remembrance, and renewal. However, together, they send a message that—

“You made a bouquet that said, ‘I acknowledge your passing, but I have no love left for you. This is my final farewell, and you are dead to me in more ways than one’—and had Adad Thorin give it to Papa Bilbo?!” Frodo exclaims in horror.

Dori groans. “Aye, the worst commission I ever did. Naturally, when your Papa Bilbo received it, he burst into tears and begged your Adad Thorin to forgive him for a sin he had no idea he committed. It was a confusing time for us all, and an even more painful one for your Adad and Papa. Eventually, your cousin-in-law Tauriel, though she wasn’t married to your cousin Kili yet at the time, explained the flower language to us, and we were all horrified.

“Your Adad Thorin locked himself in a room with your Papa Bilbo that day, refusing to do his work because he spent the entire day convincing Bilbo that he didn’t know what the bouquet meant, that he wasn’t saying goodbye, and that he truly wanted him there. That he would be devastated if he ever left. Naturally, after all that reassurance, your Papa Bilbo recovered.” Dori sighs and rubs his forehead, the memory clearly exhausting him even now.

Frodo pinches the bridge of his nose. “Let me guess… they still didn’t start courting after that?”

Dori nods. “No, they did not.”


Frodo decides to stay with Uncle Dori for a while to recover from his mental exhaustion, and Dori is more than happy to let him. He leaves Frodo alone to prepare tea and biscuits when Uncle Nori walks in.

“Oh, Frodo, my boy! What are you doing in here?”

“Hello, Uncle Nori,” Frodo says with a smile, pleased to see the uncle he encounters the least. “I came to ask Uncle Dori a question.”

“Did he give you a real answer, or was it a Dori answer?” Nori asks, raising an eyebrow. Frodo is old enough to know what that means, Uncle Dori tends to sugarcoat certain subjects because of his youth, even though he’s already a growing dwobbit.

“I’m unsure, actually. It was the same answer as the others, but I really don’t want to believe it.” Frodo sighs, rubbing his forehead, still reeling from the growing pile of evidence.

“Well, what’s the question about?” Nori asks, plopping down beside him and propping his feet up on the desk. Frodo knows Uncle Dori is going to hate that when he comes back, but also knows that even if he tells Nori, he won’t move his feet. So, he simply answers.

“I was wondering about love, and I wanted a storybook love like my parents’ and—”

Frodo is cut off by Nori’s laughter.

“Storybook love!? That’s shi—I mean, pish posh! Their love is anything but that! Let me tell you a story about how much of a disaster your parents are, Frodo!” Nori grins as he begins his tale.

“Now, this was when your Papa Bilbo had just started his consort duties. Not officially, but everyone knew it, even though your Adad Thorin still hadn’t started courting him properly. But anyone with eyes could see your Adad Thorin had the hots for your Papa Bilbo. There were bets going on left and right about when they’d finally get together. You can ask your Uncle Gloin about the details.”

“I would rather not,” Frodo replies with a frown.

“Suit yourself,” Nori shrugs before continuing. “Now, during this time, there were quite a few unsavory dwarrows lurking around Azsâlul'abad. You’ve heard how your Adad Thorin asked for help on the quest, but no one came except for us and your Papa Bilbo, yeah? Well, some of those same dwarrows showed up after Azsâlul'abad was reclaimed, thinking their past connections would land them high-ranking positions, even though they hadn’t lifted a finger to help. And your Papa Bilbo hated that.

“Especially when it became obvious how selfish they were, always trying to fill their pockets, despite already having more than enough. But your Adad Thorin couldn’t just remove them, so he did the next best thing: restricted their movements. And that’s where I come in! Your devilishly handsome uncle!”

“Uncle Nori, I know Papa Bilbo well enough to know he would never hire you for murder,” Frodo deadpans.

“Yes, your Papa Bilbo is boring like that. But your Adad Thorin is more fun!” Nori replies cheerfully.

“Papa Bilbo wouldn’t let him,” Frodo says flatly.

“No, he did not. So your Adad Thorin asked me to spy on them instead.” Nori smirks. “My job was to dig up dirt, any evidence we could use to get them removed. But these bastards hid their tracks well, so I needed help . And that’s where your Papa Bilbo comes in.”

Nori grins in delight as he watches Frodo’s shocked face.

“Yes, your Papa Bilbo’s burglaring days weren’t over after reclaiming Azsâlul'abad! With his help, we quickly started stripping undeserving dwarrows of rank and replacing them with ones who would actually do the job properly. But there was one little problem… I might have forgotten to tell your Adad Thorin that I enlisted your Papa Bilbo’s help.” Nori grimaces.

“I’m guessing Adad Thorin didn’t like that?” Frodo asks, already knowing the answer.

“Oh, he hated it. Flew into a righteous rage, he did. Accused me of endangering your Papa Bilbo, said I never should have recruited him. But the truth is, your Papa Bilbo volunteered , you know how honorable he is. And of course, he told the truth, shielding me from your Adad Thorin’s fury.”

“And, well… it devolved into a screaming match. You have to understand, these dwarrows we were investigating were dangerous. Your Papa Bilbo could have been seriously hurt, which is why your Adad Thorin was so afraid for him. But your Adad Thorin is a Durin through and through, and being honest with himself? That’s not his strong suit. So instead of admitting he was scared, he told your Papa Bilbo he was unskilled and should stop.”

Frodo winces. “Oh no.”

“ Oh yes. But your Papa Bilbo? He’s faced a dragon , saved us from elves , spiders , and orcs . He thought he deserved some credit! And he wanted to help. He couldn’t stand seeing greedy, power-hungry dwarrows abusing their positions.”

Frodo can picture it perfectly. It’s so in character for both of them, Adad Thorin worrying himself sick whenever Papa Bilbo gets riled up for the sake of justice. Papa Bilbo likes to call it his Tookish side, and after meeting his Took relatives, Frodo understands why.

“And then your Adad Thorin, in the heat of the moment, said something he really shouldn’t have,” Nori continues. “He said it was dwarf business, and that only dwarrows should handle it. That no outsider should have any say in what goes on in the mountain.”

Frodo sucks in a breath.

“Oh yeah. That hurt your Papa Bilbo. His face just… fell. He looked so ashamed of himself, like he didn’t belong, and then he ran . Your Adad Thorin chased after him, only to find him packing .”

“Your Adad went to his knees , begging him not to go. And for the first time, he was honest , he admitted he just wanted to protect him. That he was scared of losing him.”

“And your Papa Bilbo? He told him that he was trying to protect Thorin too.”

Nori leans back with a satisfied smile. “They hugged each other so tightly, just basking in each other’s warmth.”

Frodo waits a beat before sighing.

“… They didn’t get together after that, did they?”

Nori throws his head back in laughter. “No! Those idiots weren’t that honest with each other.”

Frodo groans loudly.


A little while later, Uncle Dori returns with tea and biscuits, slapping Uncle Nori’s feet off the desk before he begins serving them. They chat about mundane things, how Dori’s apprentices are doing with their studies, where Nori has been off to lately, and their plans for future dates with their respective husbands—when the youngest of them, Cousin Ori, walks in.

In truth, Frodo has no real blood relation to them, but he calls the older two ‘uncle’ and the younger Ori ‘cousin’ because they are family by bond. Not to mention, Cousin Ori looks very sad if he calls him ‘uncle,’ insisting he isn’t that old.

“Oh, Frodo! What are you doing here, cousin?” Ori asks as he sits down, his older brother Dori serving him tea and biscuits.

“Oh, he was here asking questions about love and learning that his parents’ love story is actually a disaster, ” Uncle Nori answers for Frodo with a chuckle.

“That doesn’t mean it isn’t true, of course! Every relationship has its faults,” Dori tries to reassure Frodo, who only groans in response.

“Um, if it helps, Cousin Frodo, I can tell you that their love story is the most exciting to read. So many twists and turns, so much drama that—” Ori pauses when he sees Frodo’s pained expression. “I-I didn’t mean it like that! I mean, so much has happened, yet they’re still together! And that’s beautiful! Even more beautiful than classic storybook love stories! Um, here, let me tell you one of the best parts of their love story!”

Cousin Ori takes a deep breath, trying to calm himself before beginning.

“Well, it was during the first spring after we reclaimed Azsâlul'abad, which means the mountain was still in disarray. Many paths were dangerous for a hobbit without stonesense, so your Papa Bilbo was locked up inside a room to keep him safe. But you know your Papa Bilbo, he doesn’t like staying put for too long. So he asked me if there was anything he could do to help, and with me as his companion, we began repairing the library.”

“It was a peaceful time, we talked about our favorite stories, authors, and the like, or sat in companionable silence as we tried to save books that had been left unattended for decades.” Ori smiles at the memory.

Frodo can picture it, Cousin Ori and Papa Bilbo working together, stacking towers of tomes in comfortable silence.

“And then, well… I noticed your Papa Bilbo started writing letters. I asked him about it, but he said it was nothing to worry about.”

“Well… I am sorry to say this, but I was curious. So when your Papa Bilbo went off for a tinkle, I checked. And I saw the letters were addressed to the Shire.”

“I panicked. I thought, Oh no, he wants to go home! So I ran straight to your Adad Thorin and told him about it.”

“Oh, Frodo, you should have seen him. He was devastated , nearly fell to the floor in shock. You see, his injuries hadn’t completely healed yet, so he was still using a cane at the time. After your Uncle Dwalin picked him up, we all started preparing to say goodbye.”

“We arranged a farewell party, despite our meager supplies, hoping to send him off with smiles instead of tears. We never said anything, but all of us tried to spend as much time with him as possible, staying close whenever we could.”

“But your Adad Thorin… he couldn’t bear to see him. He avoided him entirely, knowing that soon… they’d have to say goodbye.” Ori fidgets slightly.

Frodo groans, already seeing where this is going.

“Well, your Papa Bilbo noticed , of course he did, and he confronted your Adad Thorin about it. And your Adad, being your Adad, was dismissive and rude, clearly trying to put on a brave front.”

“And, well… it turned into a loud argument.”

“Their shouting echoed through the halls, Azsâlul'abad was still mostly empty back then, so everyone heard it.”

“ Including the sobs that followed when Roac arrived with a letter from the Shire.”

“Your Adad Thorin completely broke down, convinced that this was it, this was confirmation that your Papa Bilbo was leaving.”

“He fell to his knees, grabbed your Papa Bilbo’s hand, and started begging. Begging for forgiveness. Begging him to stay. Begging him to make Azsâlul'abad his home. Begging for a chance to make him happy here.”

“It sounded so much like a proposal, honestly. I remember feeling so flustered at the whole thing,” Ori giggles at the memory.

Frodo can easily picture it, his dramatic Adad Thorin, getting overwhelmed and throwing himself at Papa Bilbo’s feet.

“Except, turns out, your Papa Bilbo wasn’t writing about going back to the Shire.”

“He was writing to name your Aunt Primula and Uncle Drogo as heirs of Bag End, so the Sackville-Bagginses wouldn’t be able to take it.”

“He was arranging to have his belongings sent here , so he could properly move into Azsâlul'abad.”

Frodo stares, wide-eyed.

“Your Adad Thorin was so relieved that he fainted, ” Ori chuckles. “Right there. In your Papa Bilbo’s arms. Just… mentally exhausted from the ordeal.”

“… Did they finally get together then? Start courting officially?” Frodo asks, praying that this is when it happened. But the timeline doesn’t add up, which means…

“No, not really,” Ori answers, looking a little sad.

“Your Adad Thorin did give your Papa Bilbo the consort’s suite as his own personal room, though!” Nori chimes in happily.

“Yes. Even that early on, your Adad Thorin loved your Papa Bilbo,” Dori adds. “But, well… he was a bit of a coward when it came to him. He didn’t want to impose. And Azsâlul'abad was still recovering. But everyone in the Company could see it, he was dying a little inside, not being with him.

“Same as your Papa Bilbo, honestly,” Dori chuckles.

“They danced around each other for years. It was both entertaining and painful to watch,” Nori laughs loudly.

“Still, when they finally got together, everyone celebrated,” Ori says with a fond smile. “So while I wouldn’t call it a storybook love story, I can safely say it is a beautiful love story nonetheless.”

Frodo tries to take it all in, but it’s so different from what he thought he knew about his parents that he’s struggling to accept it.

So he remains silent, focusing on his tea and biscuits, determined to ask his other uncles about it later.


After a rather lovely tea time with his uncles and cousin, Frodo says his goodbyes and begins walking toward the barracks where Cousin Gimli is staying, like the rest of the guards. Though each guard has the option to go home or stay at the barracks, Cousin Gimli personally chooses the barracks, wishing for some independence from his parents.

Frodo knows Cousin Gimli loves his parents, but he also knows Uncle Glóin can be a tad too protective. So he understands why Cousin Gimli wouldn’t want to stay in his parents’ home. He also doesn’t have any plans to make a home of his own yet, he says he’s in no rush to start a family, and the barracks are good enough for now.

Still, Frodo has to admit the barracks aren’t the best place for a sick dwarf. They’re always loud and bustling with activity, filled with both veterans and recruits. Honestly, he should have visited earlier while he was already here talking to Uncle Dwalin. But back then, he hadn’t known Cousin Gimli was sick. The guilt nags at him, so he quickens his pace to find Gimli’s room.

When he enters, he finds Uncle Óin already wrestling Cousin Gimli into drinking a foul-smelling concoction.

“Stop resisting! You need to drink this, Gimli!” Uncle Óin glares at his nephew as he puts him in a headlock, trying to pour the liquid into his mouth. But Cousin Gimli is desperately holding his uncle’s hand back, straining to keep the brew away from his lips.

“No! I don’t need that, Uncle!” Gimli shouts stubbornly, gritting his teeth.

Frodo twitches his nose at the smell, watching the struggle. He has no idea why his dwarven relatives are so fond of not listening to healers. He wonders how Uncle Óin hasn’t murdered any of his patients yet. He truly is a patient dwarf.

“Uncle Óin, should I help?” Frodo asks, raising his voice so his uncle can hear him through his impaired hearing.

Uncle Óin turns, sees Frodo, and grins. “Ah, Frodo! Good you’re here, lad! Come restrain your cousin’s limbs.”

“Traitor! I trusted you, Cousin Frodo!” Gimli thrashes harder, trying to escape, but with Frodo and Uncle Óin working together, they manage to force-feed him the horrible concoction.

“I will remember this treachery! Mark my—” Before Gimli can finish his sentence, he drops onto the bed, out like a light and already snoring.

“Honestly, that lad is as bad as his father,” Óin huffs, placing a damp cloth on Gimli’s forehead, though he smiles fondly down at his nephew. “Well, at least father Gróin will be glad to know his grandson has a warrior’s spirit. Bifur and I can’t give him one.”

Frodo stays quiet for a moment, watching the gentle worry in Uncle Óin’s eyes as he tends to Gimli. He’s about to slip out to give his uncle some privacy when Óin suddenly speaks up.

“Each and every one of my patients is stubborn. No one listens to me, except you, Tauriel, and your Papa Bilbo. The number of times I’ve had to tie people to beds, Frodo! Though…” Óin chuckles, “I think your Uncle Bifur likes that particular skill.”

“Uncle Óin, please don’t tell me that!” Frodo yelps, horrified.

“Ah, apologies, lad! Where was I? Oh right. My worst patient to this day is still your Adad Thorin. That stone-headed king wouldn’t stay in bed for more than five seconds. He kept finding ways to escape bedrest. The only reason I had any peace treating him after the Battle of the Five Armies was because your Papa Bilbo kept distracting him. If he hadn’t been there, I swear your Adad Thorin would’ve worked himself to death.”

Frodo perks up. That sounds like something out of a storybook, someone sick and only able to recover with their lover nearby! Like the sleeping princess and the kiss of true love!

“Even after Azsâlul'abad was restored,” Óin continues, “your Adad Thorin never stopped. Always putting others before himself. Makes him a good king, yes, but a terrible patient. He never listened to my warnings. Wouldn’t drink his medicine on time. Honestly, I wanted to tell your Papa Bilbo how badly he was treating his own body, but the bastard forbade me. Told me it was a royal order. The fool.” Óin shakes his head.

“He kept working late, skipped meals, barely drank water. So it was no surprise when he finally collapsed one day.”

Frodo winces. That definitely sounds like Adad Thorin. He’s seen it himself, seen how the king runs himself ragged if no one steps in. Even he’s told him to take breaks before. And considering how Papa Bilbo is…

“How did Papa Bilbo react?” he asks, even though he already dreads the answer.

“Oh, he was a disaster, ” Óin says flatly. “Looked like he’d become a widower. He was crying so loud, clinging to Thorin’s body and fighting off anyone who tried to move him. I had to explain that your Adad Thorin was still alive, but needed to be moved so I could help him. Took a bit, but eventually, he let us get Thorin to bed.”

“But then he stayed , right there in the room with me, asking questions, repeating them, hovering constantly. And they still weren’t courting at that point! By all the Valar, it was so obvious. I was starting to lose my patience, so I decided to have a little fun and told him the truth, that it was all Thorin’s own fault he collapsed.”

Frodo’s eyes widen.

“When your Adad Thorin woke up, your Papa Bilbo lit into him. Started scolding him, screaming about how irresponsible he was. And when Thorin tried to argue that it was his duty as king, your Papa asked if he wanted to leave him alone. That shut him up real fast. After that, he promised to start taking care of himself better.”

Óin groans. “Still needs reminders from time to time, though.”

Frodo sits there, dumbfounded. How— how —were they not courting after that ?

“How did they even... what did make them start courting,” Frodo mutters, exasperated, “if that didn’t?”


While Uncle Óin does his best to keep Frodo from ripping his hair out from the mental stress of realizing how much of an idiot his parents actually are, Uncle Glóin walks in, looking worried for his son. Without a word, he quickly sits on the edge of the bed and gently presses his hand against Cousin Gimli’s forehead, moving the napkin aside to check his temperature. He sighs in relief when he feels that Gimli is cool to the touch.

“Brother, I’m already working on him. Don’t worry,” Uncle Óin says with a reassuring smile as he takes the napkin to rewet it before placing it back on Gimli’s head.

“Aye, thank you, brother. I should be mad he didn’t tell me he was sick, but alas, my boy probably didn’t want to worry me,” Uncle Glóin says, shaking his head before chuckling softly, he knows his son too well.

“Kinda like you. Our family would rather suffer than worry their loved ones,” Óin sighs, having seen the same pattern over and over again.

“Like Adad Thorin?” Frodo asks, glancing over. Glóin turns around, surprised to notice him there.

“Frodo! I’m so sorry, I didn’t even see you! Did you come to check on Gimli?” Glóin asks with a warm smile.

“I did,” Frodo confirms with a chuckle. “How often does our family suffer in silence before saying anything?”

“Oh, far too often. Even your Papa Bilbo, actually!” Glóin laughs, much to Frodo’s surprise. He knows how Papa Bilbo always encourages him to speak up when something’s wrong instead of bottling it up, but apparently, that advice wasn’t always practiced by the hobbit himself.

“What do you mean? What happened?” Frodo asks, suddenly curious about what could have shaped that part of Bilbo.

“Well, you know about Bag End, right?” Glóin begins, and Frodo nods. “Well, during the spring after the Battle of the Five Armies, your Uncle Gandalf came to visit us. catching up, sharing stories from his travels. Turns out he also had some news from the Shire. But he only told your Papa Bilbo.”

“Turns out, a certain relative of yours had declared him dead and started auctioning off Bag End, and everything in it.”

Frodo’s jaw drops. One of his relatives did that? He’s sure Papa Bilbo wrote letters to the Shire regularly after the battle!

“That can’t be right! Papa Bilbo did write letters! That should’ve been proof enough that he was alive!”

“Well, it should’ve, but it wasn’t,” Glóin explains. “Anyone could forge a letter. Mimic handwriting. Use a seal. That’s why your Papa Bilbo had to go back to the Shire, even though it pained him. See, Bag End no longer felt like home to him. He started seeing your Adad Thorin as his true home, and he didn’t want to leave him. But Bag End still mattered. It was the last piece of his parents left to him.”

Frodo bites his lip. He knows how important that smial is. Every time they visit the Shire, Papa Bilbo always visits his parents’ graves. Sometimes, he breaks down, wishing they could have met him, or Thorin. And Frodo had developed a fear of outliving his own parents because of it.

“So… did he go back?” Frodo asks quietly.

“He did. Told us he needed to return, but never said why. It was hard. You probably know he tried naming your Aunt Primula and Uncle Drogo as his heirs, but since it was just paper and words, no one believed it. So your Papa Bilbo figured it was best if he stayed at Bag End, even if it meant hurting himself. Living so far from home. So far from your Adad Thorin.”

Glóin’s expression softens with a bit of sadness.

“When your Adad Thorin found out, he insisted on escorting Bilbo himself. Didn’t listen to Uncle Balin’s protests—said Azsâlul'abad had only just begun to recover, but Thorin had already placed Bilbo’s importance above Azsâlul'abad. He trusted your Cousin Fíli and your Uncle Balin to hold things down for a few months until he came back. Turns out… he didn’t have to return alone.”

“During the journey to the Shire, your Papa Bilbo ended up telling him everything, how he’d tried to protect Bag End by naming Primula and Drogo as heirs, how none of it worked because he was declared dead, and how the last thing left of his parents was being auctioned off. ”

Frodo listens, holding his breath.

“Your Adad Thorin got furious. And by the time they reached the Shire, he rampaged through it, humiliating your Papa Bilbo, but sending a message loud and clear: mess with Bilbo Baggins, and the dwarrows of Azsâlul'abad will come down the mountain and take their revenge.”

“Once they got everything sorted, Primula and Drogo properly declared as heirs, Thorin asked Bilbo to come back with him. Said he could always visit Bag End, but begged him to make Azsâlul'abad his home. And your Papa Bilbo agreed. They returned to Azsâlul'abad, together.”

Glóin finishes the tale with a fond look.

Frodo smiles, touched by the image. But he also knows, according to the timeline...

“They hadn’t started courting, had they?”

“No, they did not! ” Glóin bursts into laughter. “You’d think after such a romantic moment they finally would, but nope! They’re both idiots!”


After spending some time catching up with his uncles and making sure that Gimli agrees to take the next day off to properly rest from his fever, Frodo says his goodbyes and begins to wander the castle. His mind churns with everything he’s learned. That’s when he notices his Uncle Bifur looking lost in the hallway.

“Uncle Bifur? What are you doing out here? You seem lost,” Frodo asks, a little puzzled. Uncle Bifur usually doesn’t come to the castle unless it’s for the weekly Company dinners or if he needs something.

“Ah, Frodo, laddie, I came to pick up my husband Óin for a date,” Uncle Bifur explains with a smile. “But he wasn’t in his usual room, so I’m looking for him, you see.”

Frodo brightens at the thought. “Oh! I just saw him in Cousin Gimli’s room. Gimli had a fever, and Uncle Óin went to check up on him. It looked like the fever was already cooling down by the time I visited. You’ll find Uncle Glóin there too.”

“Thank you, Frodo. Now, what seems to be the problem?” Bifur asks, his voice soft and knowing. Frodo blinks in surprise.

“Come now, lad. I can see it in your posture and your eyes. You’re brooding, just like your Adad Thorin,” Uncle Bifur chuckles, especially when Frodo pouts and twitches his nose in protest, just like his Papa Bilbo.

“I do not brood, Uncle Bifur! …But I must admit I was thinking,” Frodo confesses with a sigh.

Uncle Bifur gives him a small nod, encouraging him to go on.

“You see, Uncle Bifur, I’ve been going around asking the Company about my parents’ love. I always thought it was perfect, like the fairy tales. But I was wrong. They… they seem like the biggest fools of the Age. And I just, everything feels so different now. I don’t understand how they’re even still together.”

Uncle Bifur frowns thoughtfully before he speaks. “Surely you know your parents love each other. Even after everything they’ve put each other through, their love is real, yes?”

“That’s what the Company says,” Frodo murmurs. “But it’s just… hard to picture now that my image of them is…” He trails off, unable to find the right word.

“They hurt each other, yes,” Bifur agrees gently, “but they also try to make amends. Óin and I butt heads sometimes too. But what matters is we learn from our mistakes, tell each other what’s wrong, and try to swallow our pride.”

He chuckles, “And your Adad Thorin had to swallow his pride many times. I remember the time your Papa Bilbo complained about his hair. It was winter, after the Battle of the Five Armies. His hair had grown out during the quest—just long enough to hold a bead. He asked to borrow my whittling knife to cut it, and I was horrified. ”

Frodo immediately understands why. Among dwarrows, cutting hair is akin to self-harm, except in mourning. He knows his Adad Thorin once kept his beard short to honor fallen kin after the Sack of Erebor and the Battle of Azanulbizar, but now he wears a rich, full beard, worthy of the Longbeards. Thorin always says he has more to be joyful about these days than to grieve. Frodo even remembers vague moments of being tucked into Adad Thorin’s mebarmababnulzant as a child. When things went wrong, he’d bury himself in that beard and cry. It was a comfort. It’s been years since he’s done so, but the memory lingers, along with the importance of hair in dwarrow culture.

Still, Frodo also knows hobbits don’t share that sentiment. Hair is just hair. So the misunderstanding makes perfect sense.

“When your Papa Bilbo managed to calm me down and explained that hobbits don’t see hair the same way, I was relieved, but I still asked him not to cut it,” Bifur continues. “Everyone in the Company knew your Adad Thorin was hoping to court your Papa Bilbo.”

Frodo groans audibly. “Yes, I’ve heard.”

Bifur laughs. “I figured. Well, Bilbo needed the length if Thorin ever got the courage to offer a courtship bead. But Bilbo also wanted to keep hair out of his eyes, so I offered him a bead, one that signaled he was part of the Company. Nothing romantic. These days we use finer materials, but back then, we made do with just wood. I whittled one quickly and started showing him how to wear it properly.”

“That’s when your Adad Thorin walked in.”

Bifur sighs at the memory.

“He misunderstood. Thought I was braiding a courtship bead into your Papa Bilbo’s hair. He practically pounced on me. Called me names, said he’d have my head after shearing me bald, all kinds of nonsense. Thank Mahal he was still recovering, otherwise it might’ve ended in blood.”

“Your Papa Bilbo had to pull him off me. Once I explained the bead wasn’t for courtship, and how dare he imply I’d betray Óin like that, he finally calmed down.”

“Then he told everyone in the Company that he alone would be the one to teach Bilbo how to braid his hair.”

Frodo groans again, burying his face in his hands. He adds this story to the ever-growing list of his parents being complete idiots in love. And this one even predates the others.

So that means they still didn’t get together after this story either.


After saying his goodbyes to Uncle Bifur, Frodo heads to the kitchen in need of a snack. As a dwobbit, he has a higher appetite than most dwarrows, though not quite as ravenous as a typical hobbit, so it’s not unusual for the kitchen staff to see the prince come in.

What is unusual, however, is seeing Uncle Bofur inside.

“Uncle Bofur? What are you doing here?”

“Frodo! My good lad!” Bofur beams. “I came to deliver something for my brother Bombur! Were you looking for him?”

Before Frodo can answer, Bofur narrows his eyes and grins. “Uh oh. The dwobbit prince is brooding. I knew you were Thorin’s son, but you don’t have to copy everything he does.”

“I do not brood, Uncle Bofur!” Frodo snaps, his nose twitching, making Bofur burst into laughter.

“Oh, you are such a perfect mix of your parents!” Bofur chuckles, gently patting Frodo’s back. “So what’s eating you, Frodo?”

Frodo sighs. “Well… I’ve been thinking about my parents’ love story. I asked around, and now my image of them is… well…” He groans loudly, unable to even finish the sentence.

“Ha! They’re idiots, no doubt, but lovable idiots, nonetheless,” Bofur says cheerfully. “And since your fairytale view of their love is already shattered, how about I break your Papa Bilbo’s impeccable image while we’re at it? Ever seen your Papa drunk?”

Frodo groans, dreading the answer, but morbidly curious. He can’t imagine the ever-composed Bilbo drunk . “...Fine. What happened, Uncle Bofur?”

“Well,” Bofur begins, clearly enjoying himself, “Lady Dís had just returned with most of our people. It was a joyful time, days of feasting and celebration. Everyone was in high spirits. But of course, that also meant dealing with a few unsavory dwarrows who hadn’t lifted a finger during the quest but still wanted high ranks in the court.”

Bofur smirks. “And one of the seats they were after? The consort’s seat.”

Frodo winces. He already sees where this is going.

“Oh, dwarrowdams were practically throwing themselves at your Adad Thorin,” Bofur goes on with a shake of his head. “Touching his beard, leaning into him, trying to get him alone, and then claiming they were too drunk to remember. Your Adad Thorin tried to reject them, but because they came from ‘important’ families, though how important can they be if they couldn’t be bothered to help during the quest, he couldn’t turn them down harshly enough to make it clear.”

He snorts, clearly remembering the awkwardness. “He looked miserable. And we all noticed.”

Frodo frowns. “What did Papa Bilbo do during all that?”

“He smiled and played nice with everyone,” Bofur says, voice softening a little. “But no one in the Company was fooled. We knew he was crying himself to sleep each night.”

Frodo’s heart sinks.

“And it only got worse when Lady Dís noticed. She liked your Papa Bilbo, still does, but she had no idea about the drama between your parents. So when she caught the way Bilbo was looking at Thorin, she thought it was unrequited love. Tried to gently tell him to give up.”

Frodo cringes. “Oh no…”

“Oh yes ,” Bofur confirms with a dramatic nod. “Your Papa Bilbo broke down that night. Drank himself into a stupor. Now, I love seeing your Papa get a little tipsy, makes him giggly and loose. But this? This wasn’t the fun kind. He wasn’t even eating. That’s when we knew something was very wrong.”

Bofur leans in. “So imagine the Company all trailing after your Papa Bilbo, trying to stop him from drinking himself into a hole. It wasn’t quiet, either. Your Adad Thorin noticed and came to see what was going on. And the moment your Papa saw him, he just bawled . Told him Dís was right. That he should go back to the Shire because it hurt too much to watch Thorin entertain all those suitors. Said that by tomorrow he’d be gone, and not to invite him to a wedding that would kill him on the inside.”

Bofur grins wide as Frodo buries his face in his hands.

“I’m guessing Adad Thorin tried to calm Papa Bilbo down?” Frodo mumbles through his fingers.

“Oh, definitely. He told him he wasn’t enjoying the attention, that there wouldn’t be any wedding, and that he’d be very sad if Bilbo ever left Erebor. Then he picked him up, just scooped him into his arms, and took him to bed to sleep it off. The next day, he stayed with him the whole time, nursing him through the hangover.”

Frodo blinks. “Wait, he stayed with him?”

“All day,” Bofur says with a proud nod. “After that, Thorin didn’t just reject advances, he humiliated anyone who tried anything. And as for Lady Dís? He tore into her . But she was thrilled, honestly. Realized it wasn’t unrequited love after all. Especially when Thorin started handing Bilbo gifts, you know those fancy bits of jewelry he always wears?”

Frodo groans again. “Yes. I’ve heard about that too…”

“Yup!” Bofur laughs. “Your Aunt Dís was so confused. After all that, Bilbo still didn’t have a courting bead in his hair. She was dumbfounded . Hilarious, if it weren’t so sad.”

Frodo groans again, dragging his hands down his face. He suddenly understands exactly what Aunt Dís must’ve felt all those years ago.


Uncle Bofur continues telling Frodo about everything Papa Bilbo did while drunk that night, going into far more vivid detail than before. Frodo is clearly overwhelmed when Uncle Bombur finally appears from the back.

“Ah, Bofur! Got my—oh! Frodo! I didn’t know you were here! You should’ve said something, I could’ve whipped up something quick. Now, what are you feeling peckish for? Something fruity? Or something meaty?”

“Anything, Uncle Bombur,” Frodo groans. “I just… I need something to do , something other than thinking about how much of a fool both my parents are. Like… so much happened and they still didn’t get together right away? Seriously!?”

“Ah, so you’ve finally realized it, huh? Just now?” Bombur asks innocently, earning a sharp glare from Frodo. Bombur grins, it’s the same glare he’s seen countless times from both Thorin and Bilbo.

“Well, it’s true. It was obvious to everyone. Even Lord Bard and King Thranduil noticed, and they hardly ever come into the mountain, let alone the castle.”

Frodo groans even louder, and both uncles laugh. Uncle Bofur gives his back a comforting pat.

“Hey, that’s all in the past,” Bofur says cheerfully. “Now they’re disgustingly sweet instead of awkwardly tense. Which, honestly, is somewhat better than the sexual tension choking the air all the time. At least now they talk instead of just staring.”

“Uncle Bofur please ,” Frodo mutters, making a face. “We’re talking about my parents here.”

“Alright, alright, I’ll ease up,” Bofur chuckles. “Bombur, why don’t you take over and tell Frodo a story about just how stupidly in love his parents are?”

“ Are ?” Frodo echoes, raising an eyebrow as both uncles burst into laughter.

“Oh, they’re still stupid, Frodo,” Bombur assures him. “And I’d love to. Now let’s see... This happened right after your Aunt Dís returned with caravans full of our people. Naturally, that meant tons of work for all of us. And sure, it was a happy time, but it was also stressful . Your Adad Thorin trusted us enough to place us in high positions. That was kind of him, and I’m grateful for it. But the workload he dumped on us? I wanted to crush his skull.”

Frodo’s eyes widen.

“Oh, I don’t anymore,” Bombur adds with a laugh. “But that’s just how much work there was. Your Papa Bilbo actually started doing consort duties around then, with Prince Fíli’s help, of course. Little rascal didn’t even ask your Adad Thorin’s permission!”

Both uncles chuckle at the memory.

“I heard about this from Cousin Fíli, actually,” Frodo says, tilting his head. “Wasn’t there some drama where Adad Thorin freaked out about how Papa Bilbo would react to doing consort work?”

“Oh yes, that happened, but I’m not telling that bit today,” Bombur replies brightly. “This story came just after.”

He leans in, voice warming. “Now you know how hobbits show affection through food, yes?”

“Yes, why?” Frodo asks cautiously.

“Well, your Papa Bilbo loved cooking for your Adad Thorin, even before they were together. He didn’t tell me why, just claimed he liked cooking. And I was so tired during that time, I was just grateful someone else was feeding the king. A meal I didn’t have to cook myself? Bless him.”

Bombur's tone shifts, quieter now. “But your Adad Thorin... he kept forgetting to eat. Your Papa Bilbo didn’t realize that at first. Then one day, he goes to check on him, finds his lovingly cooked meal untouched. And he just starts crying.”

Bombur looks at Frodo. “Now, Frodo, I’m sure you know why, don’t you?”

Frodo winces. He does. Among hobbits, leaving a meal untouched is one of the deepest rejections. They express love through cooking, an act that says, I want to provide for you, share a home with you, a life . Refusing that meal means rejecting that life together. It’s worse than words.

“He locked himself in his room,” Bombur continues, “crying his poor little heart out. I tried asking what was wrong, but he was sobbing so hard I couldn’t make out a word. Took me a while to figure it out. But once I did? I ran straight to find your Adad Thorin.”

He chuckles, recalling the moment. “Your Adad glared at me for interrupting a meeting. But when I said it was about your Papa Bilbo? He ended it right there and ran after me.”

Bombur laughs. “You should’ve seen him, pounding on Bilbo’s door like his life depended on it, shouting that he’d eat everything Bilbo ever cooked, even if it was poison ! That he’d eat leaves if that’s what made him happy!”

Frodo gapes. “Oh by the Valar—”

“No one laughed then, it was too heartbreaking,” Bombur says, though he can’t help but smile now. “Eventually, your Papa Bilbo opened the door, glared at him, and cried, ‘How dare you say I’d poison you!’”

“Thorin apologized like he’d just been sentenced to death,” Bofur adds, snorting.

Bombur nods. “And when Bilbo was about to accept his apology, as long as Thorin promised to always eat his meals, your Adad fainted .”

“ Wait ! There’s more to that fainting story!” Frodo exclaims. “Uncle Óin told me about it! And it happened after Fíli’s story too! How often do these ridiculous moments happen between them!?”

“Oh, too many times,” Bofur cackles.

“You already know how this story ends, then,” Bombur chuckles, ruffling Frodo’s curls while the poor dwobbit groans and rubs his temples.


After enjoying a hearty meal of savory steak and berry-filled cupcakes, Frodo heads toward the royal quarters, eager to rest. His mind, however, is far from quiet. No matter how hard he tries, he keeps thinking about who his parents truly are, how different they seem now from the perfect image he once had of them.

As he enters the room, he’s greeted by a romantic scene. His parents, both half-dressed, clearly fresh from a shared bath, sit close together. Papa Bilbo is gently drying Adad Thorin’s hair with a towel, a soft smile on his face, while Thorin leans into the touch, eyes closed, looking utterly content.

It’s a picture-perfect moment. One Frodo has seen often. And it’s real. But now… he knows their love isn’t actually perfect.

“Ah, Frodo, my boy. You look exhausted. What happened?” Papa Bilbo asks, frowning with concern as he puts the towel away and begins braiding Thorin’s hair.

“I asked around the Company about your love story and well…” Frodo trails off, unsure how to phrase it.

“We were idiots, Frodo,” Adad Thorin chuckles, answering without hesitation. “Me and your Papa both.”

“Yes. Everyone told me stories about how foolish you two were, being in love but not doing anything about it. But the thing is, I’ve seen you together. I see it even now! You’re perfect for each other. Like something out of a storybook. A fairy tale. You feel like a happily ever after but…” Frodo sighs, struggling to make sense of it. “It just doesn’t add up.”

“Frodo,” Papa Bilbo says gently, “your Adad and I love each other deeply. And I’m sure your uncles and cousin already told you how we went from dysfunctional idiots to functioning idiots in love, yes?”

“‘Trust, communication, and swallow your pride.’ That’s what they said. It sounds so simple. I don’t think it should be that hard,” Frodo frowns.

“It isn’t. But you’ll understand when you find your own love,” Papa Bilbo replies with a small chuckle.

“What I don’t get is… there were so many times when you could have gotten together. Could’ve been happy sooner. Why didn’t you?” Frodo asks. Both parents frown at the question.

“Son, you’ve read the history books, yes? You know what your Adad did to me?” Papa Bilbo asks softly.

“I do. The books say Adad Thorin tried to kill you when he was sick. But… that’s just an exaggeration, right?” Frodo asks, already dreading the answer. His heart sinks as both his parents give him the same sad smile.

“Wait… that was true? That actually happened?”

“It did,” Adad Thorin says, voice low and full of sorrow. “And I will always regret it, Frodo. I hurt your Papa. My amrâlimê.”

Frodo watches as his father’s eyes become glassy. He nearly cries, but not quite. Papa Bilbo leans forward and kisses Thorin’s cheek, steadying him.

“It’s alright, honey. We’ve been through this,” he murmurs, then looks back at Frodo. “It’s true your father hurt me deeply. But I hurt him too. I betrayed his trust. I took the Arkenstone, an incredibly important family heirloom, and gave it to his enemies. I did it to save him and the rest of our family, but it was still a betrayal, no matter the reason.”

Frodo watches as his parents hold onto each other, visibly in pain from revisiting the past, yet bravely continuing.

“Papa… Adad… how did you get through it?” Frodo asks softly.

“We didn’t. Not at first,” Thorin says with a small, bitter smile. “You’ve heard the stories, how we were obviously in love but still never got together? We knew . We weren’t blind. But we were both waiting for the other to take the first step. And at the same time, we each felt like we shouldn’t be the one to do it.”

“I don’t understand…”

“After the Arkenstone, your Adad became afraid,” Bilbo explains. “He believed he didn’t deserve me. That if I stayed with him, I’d get hurt again. And I… I was afraid too. He was a king. What was I? A simple hobbit who had betrayed him. I thought I could never be enough for him.”

“We both knew we loved each other,” Thorin says, “but we convinced ourselves we weren’t right for each other. And it hurt us both.”

Frodo falls silent, his frown deepening. As he thinks about it, he can see how fear crept in, how it wrapped itself around his parents' hearts.

“So what changed?” he asks. “What broke through the fear?”

“Well…” Thorin chuckles. “What broke the fear, was fear itself.”

Frodo tilts his head, confused.

“I had a nightmare,” Bilbo says quietly. “You’ve heard the stories, how your Adad and your cousins Fíli and Kíli nearly died during the Battle of the Five Armies? In the nightmare… your Adad did die. It was horrible, Frodo. So real. His eyes went dim. His blood turned cold in my hands. I tried to stop it, but I couldn’t…”

He shudders, eyes tearing up. Thorin pulls him close and kisses his forehead, holding him tight. Frodo notices how Bilbo seems to settle at the sound of Thorin’s heartbeat.

“I woke up in a cold sweat and ran straight to his room,” Bilbo continues. “I sneaked past the guards, jumped onto his bed, and just… held him. Touched him. I had to feel he was alive. I couldn’t stop crying.”

“I woke up to him clinging to me,” Thorin says, gently rubbing Bilbo’s arm. “He was sobbing too hard to speak, but he kept touching my scars. I figured it was about the battle. About my life.”

“My head knew he was safe,” Bilbo whispers. “But my heart… my heart was still in terror. I held onto him and begged him not to go. To live. To stay. I told him I loved him. That I couldn’t bear a life without him.”

“I couldn’t say no,” Thorin says, tears now falling freely. “I saw how much it hurt him not to be with me. And I swore then—I would rather stab myself than ever hurt him again. So I told him I was alive. That I wasn’t going anywhere. That I loved him too. And if the Valar allowed it… I would grow old with him.”

Their hands are intertwined now, their tears falling together. Frodo wipes his own eyes before he even realizes he’s crying.

“Our love story isn’t perfect, Frodo,” Bilbo says softly. “But it’s real . And we would never trade it for some storybook fantasy. It’s messy. It’s scarred. But it’s ours . And I hope one day, you’ll find something like it too.”

“Maybe with… less drama than ours,” Thorin adds, laughing through his tears.

Frodo laughs with them, heart full. He will never see their love the same way again. But maybe that’s not a bad thing. Maybe a love that’s weathered storms, endured time and mistakes, and still stands strong, is more beautiful than a perfect one untouched by life.

Yes. Frodo thinks he would rather have a love like that.

Notes:

I must tell you, I planned to actually write this for Thorin's Spring Forge 2025 but then forgot that it's actually not allowed so hey, it's here and I hope you enjoyed it! Oh and Azsâlul'abad means Erebor