Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Pitiful Fate

Summary:

Nienna didn’t so much ask Eru for a race to call her own as she found the hobbits wandering and pitied them. They were a people, she found, who knew hardship but still looked to the future with hope in their spirits. Claiming them had not only been easy but it had felt right. They would never know of all the injustices of the world and yet they mourned with her.

Bilbo grew up learning to pity. He didn’t understand grief until he lost his parents. And for as smart as he thought he was, he didn’t truly start to become wise until a group of dwarves showed up at his smial.

Notes:

Enjoy~

Work Text:

                “I understand that you are travels far from home and you thought you could just invade mine,” Bilbo huffed as he faced the group of dwarves sitting around his table. “So I forgive you for your bad manners.”

                “Bad manners?” One of them muttered in disbelief.

                “But now that you have eaten, it is time to go,” Bilbo finished as he tipped his head and motioned at his door.

                No sooner had he said the words and gestured than there was a knock.

                Bilbo’s shoulders slumped as he frowned down at his toes.

                “Bilbo,” Gandalf said with amusement coloring his tone, “aren’t you going to open the door?”

                Sighing, Bilbo turned away from the group he’d already fed. “Wisdom,” he whispered to himself. “I will find wisdom in this grief.”

                He pulled the door open with words on the tip of his tongue and promptly forgot all of them. The dwarf standing before him had a bearing that the others were lacking. There was a sadness that clung to him that Bilbo found familiar.

                “I thought this place would be easy to find,” the dwarf said as he gently smiled at Bilbo. “I got lost on my way here twice.”

                Bilbo blinked hard as he stepped back as the dwarf stepped forward. “I do believe your cohorts are already here.”

                The dwarf dipped his head as he entered Bilbo’s home.

                “Thorin,” one of the other dwarves called out.

                Gandalf managed to get up from the table as he nodded to the dwarf. “Bilbo Baggins,” he said without looking at Bilbo. “May I present the leader of our company, Thorin Oakenshield.”

                Bilbo felt his spine straighten despite the fact that he hadn’t planned to stand taller beneath Thorin’s gaze. “Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

                Thorin hummed as he circled around Bilbo to the other dwarves. “I was expecting something more than a grocer for our last member of the company, Gandalf.”

                Bilbo felt the type of shock that renders the feeler unable to move. His jaw did not drop. His eyes did not widen. In fact, he felt as though he froze. He was not about to be the last member of any sort of company. In fact, he wanted the company he had to leave.

                Especially if they were going to insult him in his own home.

                A grocer?

                Bilbo scoffed at the idea, freeing himself from his frozen state. He turned to set his newest guest straight but found himself distracted by the dwarves and wizard as they talked lowly around his table.

                “The time to act is now,” Gandalf urged them gravely. “Smaug has been left to rest for too long inside the mountain.”

                “We can’t get in,” Thorin muttered as he crossed his arms over his chest. “The front gates were ruined. That worm stole our home from us. It won’t be easy to get it back.”

                “I beg your pardon,” Bilbo said without thinking. He flushed as everyone turned to look at him. “A worm stole your home?”

                “Ah,” a dwarf with a delightfully weird hat said as he stood from his seat. “That would be Smaug the Terrible. He’s a fire breathing dragon from the north.”

                “A what now?”

                “A calamity,” the dwarf said with a grin that was far too joyful for their topic. “The dragon came down and attacked. We lost our home that day.”

                Bilbo blinked at that as he shifted his weight back until he found the edge of his doorway to hold onto. “Your home?”

                “Bilbo,” Gandalf started before he was interrupted.

                “Yes,” Thorin scathingly replied with a lift of his brows. “We were attacked and forced from our home years ago. My people have suffered since that fell beast forced his way into Erebor.”

                “Oh,” Bilbo said softly as he turned slightly away from the dwarves to hide the tears in his eyes. “I’m so very sorry. I didn’t know.”

                “News of the attack,” Gandalf said quickly before anyone else was able to, “did not reach the Shire. You couldn’t have known.”

                Bilbo nodded weakly before he turned away from the group. “I’m going to sit down for a bit.”

                “I’ll be in to talk to you,” Gandalf assured him.

                Bilbo nodded again before he staggered away from his dining room. He made his way down the hallway to his sitting room before his knees grew too weak. He sank into his favorite armchair before he buried his face into his hands and squeezed his eyes shut.

                They had suffered. For years. And not just the dwarves in his smial but all of their people. Because of calamity.

                Once his tears began, Bilbo knew they would be difficult to stop. But such was the life of a hobbit.

                Hours later, after his guests had found spots to sleep, Bilbo sat sniffling in his chair. He didn’t look up as Gandalf joined him.

                “Bilbo,” Gandalf said in a gentle voice. “I did not mean to spring that on you.”

                “They are without a home,” Bilbo whispered. “They have been without one for years.”

                “Yes,” Gandalf replied. “They have suffered.”

                Bilbo ducked his head. “What is it that you would have me do?”

                “Join them,” Gandalf said, not without consideration. “Help them.”

                “I am a hobbit.” Bilbo lifted his head and met Gandalf’s gaze with his red-rimmed eyes. “Our Lady has taught us to mourn. What need would the dwarves have of me?”

                Gandalf sighed as he dropped to one knee at Bilbo’s side. “The Lady Nienna has taught you well, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire. All hobbits know the importance of grief and mourning. But that’s all these dwarves have been doing for a very long time. They have no hope for their future. Join them on their quest. Be their hope.”

                Bilbo turned his head away from Gandalf as he squeezed his eyes shut to hold back his tears.

                “They cannot do this without you.”

                Bilbo’s breath hitched in his chest before he slowly nodded. “I don’t know the first thing about journeys.”

                Gandalf smiled as he rested his hand on Bilbo’s arm. “Not to worry. The destination is the most dangerous part of this quest. We’ll leave in the morning. Get some rest.”

                Bilbo released a small breath of air as the wizard left him to sit. He was a hobbit. He might not have left the Shire once during his life, but he knew of the tragedies of the world. Maybe it was about time he saw them for himself.

 

XXX

 

                “Just sneak in there and steal them back,” Fili whispered from one side of Bilbo. “It’ll be easy.”

                “Yeah,” Kili quietly but enthusiastically agreed. “You’re small and quiet. Steal them back. There’s no need to tell the others anything happened at all.”

                Bilbo frowned between the two dwarves as he eyed the massive trolls sitting around a campfire. “I don’t think that’s going to work.”

                “What?” Fili all but demanded. “Why not?”

                “It’ll work,” Kili agreed as he crossed his arms over his chest. “Just try.”

                “We’ll be right here,” Fili reminded him. “Not that you’ll need us.”

                “You definitely won’t,” Kili said with a firm nod of his head.

                Bilbo opened his mouth to argue again but swallowed the words as he was shoved out of their hiding spot. He froze for a moment in the open before he scowled over his shoulder and slinked into another bush for cover. “Dratted dwarves,” he muttered to himself as he made his way around the clearing to where the ponies were being kept.

                “They need your help, Bilbo,” he whispered harshly under his breath. “Be their hope, Bilbo. Pity them.”

                Groaning softly to himself, Bilbo studied the pen the ponies were in. “Pity me,” he murmured before he left his cover.

                The pen was held together by a rope that was knotted in such a convoluted manner that Bilbo knew he had no hope to untie it. He looked at it for a moment before he groaned softly to himself again. He turned enough to look across the clearing where Fili and Kili were supposed to hiding. There was no sign of them amongst the shadows of the trees.      

                Bilbo looked one last time at the knot before he tipped his head back and sighed at the night sky. He knew he wasn’t going to be able to do what the dwarves wanted of him. He didn’t have their skills. He did, however, have the skills of a hobbit.

                Clearing his throat, Bilbo planted his hands on his hips and marched around the trolls to stand in front of them. He made sure to wear his best scathing look as he tipped his chin to look at them. “Excuse me! Those ponies do not belong to you. Release them now.”

                “Who’re you?” one of the trolls asked as he leaned forward. “What’re you?”

                “I,” Bilbo replied as he tipped his chin even further up, “am a hobbit. And you have stolen my ponies! That was very wrong of you. Stealing is a terrible crime to commit. I’m sure you just didn’t realize that you were harming me in the process of doing whatever it is that you think you’re doing. So I will forgive you if you release them to me at once.”

                A different troll started to laugh such loud guffaws that he could not stay upright.

                Bilbo eyed him as he fell over. He frowned a little harder before turning to the troll who had spoken to him before. “Release them.”

                The troll looked back at him for a moment in silence. “No.”

                Bilbo spluttered as he crossed his arms over his chest. “What do you mean, no? Those are my ponies!”

                “Grab him,” the troll said as he sat back. “We’ll eat him, too.”

                Bilbo’s mouth dropped open. He barely managed to take a half-step back as a giant hand swung through the air at him.

                A cry from the edge of the woods distracted the troll, allowing Bilbo to get out of the way as the dwarves charged out of the trees together and attacked.

                For a moment, it was chaos. Bilbo could not keep track of any of the dwarves long enough to understand what they were doing beyond fighting. “Stop,” he managed weakly as Kili flew the air with a war cry.

                Bombur was smacked back from one of the trolls. He went rolling and broke through the fence holding the ponies.

                “You can’t,” Bilbo breathed as his eyes widened. He caught sight of Dwalin swinging his giant hammer around only to drop it onto one of the troll’s toes. “Please,” he whimpered.

                “Take him down!” Gloin yelled as they focused on one of the trolls in particular.

                “Stop it!” Bilbo cried as he regained his wits and threw himself into the fray. “Stop fighting! Stop hurting each other!”

                One of the trolls noticed him and scooped him up in their fist. Bilbo’s words were cut off as he was squeezed too hard to breathe in.

                “Drop your weapons or I’ll turn him to jelly!”

                Thorin caught Bilbo’s eyes and glared hard before he threw his sword down.

                Bilbo, held tightly in the hand of a troll, was stunned as the rest of the dwarves followed suit. He hadn’t even known that they liked him enough to stop him from being turned to jelly.

                What little air he was able to suck into his lungs as he was dropped into a sack was forced back out of them as the troll tossed him onto a pile of groaning dwarves. Before he could gather his bearings, the dwarf beneath him jerked. Bilbo rolled until he was face down on the ground.

                Snorting the dirt out of his nose, he lifted his head and blinked hard to get rid of the spots dancing in front of his eyes. Half the company was being tied to a spit to be roasted while the rest were in sacks like he was. All of it was wrong.

                “No,” Bilbo called as he scrambled to get to his feet. Sack or no sack, he would not be having this conversation face down on the ground. “You cannot do this!”

                “What’s this?” The same troll that had spoken to him before turned to look at him again. “Yelling again, little hobbit?”

                “You cannot eat them,” Bilbo said firmly as he crossed his arms over his chest. The sack hid most of his movements but he felt better having crossed them. “You were not given life on Arda so you could do harm to others!”

                One of the dwarves behind him snorted in such a manner that Bilbo knew they weren’t dealing with dirt in their nose.

                “You cannot be serious,” Thorin muttered from behind him. “You want to have a philosophical debate with a bunch of trolls?”

                Bilbo sniffed as he kept his eyes focused on the troll still looking back at him. “So much harm has already been done,” he said as he pleaded with the troll to understand him. “This world was meant for life. Don’t cause more death.”

                “Your death will bring us life,” the troll said with a bit of a smirk. “I think I’m going to enjoy eating you.”

                Bilbo dropped his chin as he flushed a bit in embarrassment. Even his strongest scoldings that would have worked on any other hobbit were no match for these creatures. They didn’t care. They didn’t care who they hurt as long as they benefited.

                Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo caught sight of Thorin. The dwarf who had already suffered so much did not deserve to have to suffer further.

                “I said,” he bit out as he lifted his gaze back to the troll. “You cannot eat them. Release us. Now!”

                The trolls laughed. They laughed for quite some time, all without pausing in rotating the dwarves over the fire.

                Bilbo clenched his jaw as he dug deep to find his courage. “You can’t eat them!”

                “Because it isn’t right?” a troll mocked as he wiped a tear away from his eyes. “Eating you will be satisfying if only to make you stop demanding things.”

                Bilbo took a half-step back but didn’t manage to make it any further before Gandalf appeared yelling about the dawn. Bilbo watched in anguish as the trolls were turned to stone. He dropped to his knees and blinked back the burn behind his eyes. He would not weep for these creatures. He could not.

                “Bilbo,” Gandalf said as he dropped next to him to help him out of his prison. “Are you all right?”

                “They wouldn’t listen,” Bilbo whispered back as he lifted his hand to cover his eyes. “I told them they were harming us and they didn’t care.”

                Gandalf’s hand was warm as he rested it against the top of Bilbo’s head. “You are far outside of the Shire, Bilbo Baggins. But I hope that you do not lose your heart. Many of the people you will encounter on this journey will be swayed by you. Some won’t.”

                Bilbo nodded without lifting his head. Wisdom. He had to find wisdom in this grief.

                Only, he didn’t get the time to find it, what with the other wizard and then running for their lives from orcs and wargs.

 

XXX

 

                “Oi, Bilbo!” Bofur called from where he was sitting around a large fire. Its flames danced high into the sky of the courtyard they’d built it in. “Come and join us.”

                “What,” one of the dwarves hissed, though Bilbo still wasn’t sure which one. “Don’t invite him!”

                “Why not?” Bofur whispered loudly back. “He’s a member of our company.”

                Bilbo winced but did his best to keep his smile on his face. “Don’t worry about me. I’m just going back to my room to rest.”

                “Sit,” Thorin grunted before Bilbo was able to make his escape.

                Meekly, Bilbo took an empty spot in their ring around the fire. “This is nice. Where did you get the wood?”

                Dwalin smirked.

                Bifur said something in their dwarven language.

                Nori snickered. “Don’t worry about it.”

                Bilbo frowned. He turned back to the fire to study it. His mouth dropped open as he caught sight of one of Elrond’s ornate benches. “Oh, dear.”

                “Mister Bilbo,” Ori said haltingly from the other side of the fire. “I was wondering if I could ask you some questions. About hobbits.”

                Bilbo sucked in a deep breath before he smiled. “Of course, Ori. What would you like to know?”

                “Well,” Ori answered before he stopped to swallow hard. “What’s being a hobbit like?”

                Frowning, Bilbo dropped his gaze back into the fire. “You were in the Shire. You know a bit about my home.”

                “We saw it,” Balin agreed with a polite nod of his head. “But we didn’t understand everything we saw there.”

                “Oh?” Bilbo intoned as he turned to the older dwarf. “What confused you?”

                “Well,” Ori said again. “There were quite a few hobbits just sort of walking around and crying.”

                “Sobbing, really,” Gloin muttered.

                Bilbo pursed his lips as he watched the flames dance for a moment longer. “What do you know of the Valar? Specifically the Lady Nienna?”

                “Not much,” Ori answered.

                “We were made by Mahal,” Fili said proudly as he lounged by the fire. “He crafted us himself.”

                “Well,” Bilbo said slowly as he looked back up to meet some of their gazes. “Hobbits weren’t made by our Lady Nienna but she did find us as we wandered and took us as her own. She taught us about grief and mourning.”

                “She taught you,” Thorin repeated before he stopped to take a breath. “About grief and mourning?”

                “Exactly,” Bilbo said with a smile.

                “So hobbits cry all the time?” Dwalin asked skeptically.

                Bilbo rolled his eyes at him. “Do you see me crying all the time?”

                Dwalin lifted one of his brows as he let his gaze linger on Bilbo. “Well,” he said in such a way that dragged out the word and made it clear what he thought without having to say it.

                “I have not shed a tear since before we left the Shire,” Bilbo said as he narrowed his gaze on Dwalin. “The hardships of the road will not make me cry. Our Lady does not weep for sore thighs and hard beds.”

                “What does she weep for then?” Dori asked as he straightened the bits of furniture they hadn’t added to the fire yet.

                “The marring of Arda,” Bilbo answered. He thought nothing of his reply until he looked around the fire and noticed the confused looks on his companions’ faces. “She weeps for every injustice done by those who are evil and she pities those who were harmed.”

                “Pity and grief,” Dwalin grunted. “Don’t need em.”

                “You do,” Bilbo replied with another roll of his eyes. He really needed to break that habit. “I would like all of you to know that even though we haven’t known each other for very long, if one of you were to die on this quest, I would mourn you.”

                The dwarves fell silent at that declaration for a moment. Bilbo smiled gently to himself, glad that he’d been able to tell them something so important.

                Then they started yelling.

 

XXX

                Shaking, Bilbo stood on the slick ledge of the mountainside. The stone giants continued their fight further away from where he and the rest of the company stood. Only moments before, they’d been far too close.

                “You!” Thorin roared over the thunder and rain. “How could you be so foolish? You were almost killed! And then what? Would you have turned around and told those giants that you forgave them for killing you? You should have never come on this quest!”

                Bilbo sucked in a hard gasp as he clenched his cloak with soaked fingers. He dropped his gaze to his filthy toes as Thorin continued to berate him. Any words he could have thought to say got stuck in his throat. Though Thorin called him foolish, Bilbo knew what forced such emotion from the usually stoic dwarf.

                Thorin was grieving him before he’d even lost him.

                Bilbo shuddered. He kept his head down and let the dwarves drag him along into a cave. They left him alone to remove some of his more sodden clothes and get situated for the night, which he was grateful for.

                Only once more of them were settled down did Bilbo get up and move from where he’d been sitting with his pack.

                “Where are you going?” Bofur whispered as he Bilbo got near him. “You can’t leave. He didn’t mean what he said.”    

                Sighing, Bilbo dropped to sit next to the dwarf. “I know,” he murmured back. “I know he was just scared. I was, too.”

                “Then stay,” Bofur all but pleaded. “Don’t go.”

                “I’m not,” Bilbo answered quietly. “I just wanted to catch my breath and process what happened. There is wisdom to be learned in grief.”

                “Wisdom-“

                Bofur’s words were cut off as the floor dropped from underneath them.

 

XXX

 

                Bilbo sat in the dark with his hands pressed over his mouth to stifle his breathing. Fear laced through him as the goblin he’d tumbled with was dragged off into the darkness. He was so afraid he could barely move.

                Unsure of what urged him on, he suddenly got up from his hiding spot and darted forward through the darkness. He could make out the walls of the cave he was in enough to know which way he had to run.

                The goblin’s death echoed all around him.

                His foot slipped and Bilbo stumbled. His hand hit something on the floor. He didn’t mean to pick it up but his mind was reeling as loud cries of anguish rang in his hears. Without thinking, he dropped whatever it was into his pocket.

                The screaming silenced. Both from whatever he’d heard and the goblin.

                Bilbo swallowed hard before he got his feet back under him and ran. A noise behind him told him that his presence had been noticed.

                Frightened, Bilbo did not slow. He ran and ran until the sounds of his pursuer were far too close. Then he ducked into a crevice and covered his face to stifle the sounds of his panting breaths.

                “Find him, precious. We must find him.”

                The creature coughed.

                “We will,” he answered in a different voice.

                Bilbo’s eyes widened as he shoved his hand further into his mouth. He bit back a whimper and squeezed his eyes shut for a moment.

                Shouting distracted both him and the creature that was hunting him.

                He knew those shouts.

                Relieved, Bilbo listened as the dwarves called to one another and fought for their freedom.

                Just as their voices grew loud, they began to soften once more. They were moving on without him.

                Bilbo silently berated himself. He was hiding. Of course they didn’t know he was there!

                Moving as only hobbits could, Bilbo got to his feet. The creature he could make out in the darkness was a gangly, sickly thing. Not that he was surprised since it was eating goblins.

                It was looking away as if also listening to the dwarves and where they were going.

                His sword did not make a sound as he pulled it from his belt. He gripped the hilt of it tight in his hand as he sucked in a slow, deep breath. He had to rejoin the company. They were his dwarves! He could not be left behind.

                He would have to escape this thing that would kill him if it had the chance. He had to fight. He had to.

                Bilbo took one step forward and faltered as the creature turned back. Its eyes were huge in the darkness, which made them easy to see. It was frightened.

                Pity. Pity unlike anything he’d ever felt before lodged itself inside of his chest and squeezed his heart.

                Tightening his grip on his sword, Bilbo shifted his weight. It was enough to draw the creature’s attention. Without thinking, Bilbo raised his sword and hit the blunt end of it against its head.

                The gangly thing crumpled to the ground.

                Bilbo darted out of his hiding spot and dropped to his knees. “I’m so sorry,” he whispered as he made sure it was still breathing. “I’m so sorry this has happened to you. I’m so sorry to have hurt you. I have to go. Those are my friends. I have to be with them.”

                Unconscious, the creature didn’t move except to pull in little puffs of air.

                Bilbo ran his hand along its shoulder as he bowed his head. “I’m sorry,” he whispered again.

                A lone tear surprised him as it dropped from his eye and landed on the pitiful thing.

                Shocked, Bilbo staggered to his feet and put away his sword. He glanced back at whatever it was that lived in that cave. “What a horrible fate,” he mumbled as he turned back to run after his dwarves.

 

XXX

 

                “Bilbo! He’s still in there!” Fili’s voice sounded from up ahead. “We have to go back!”

                “He fell,” Dori fretted. “I saw him tumble.”

                “Uncle,” Kili pleaded. “He could still be alive.”

                “We roused all the goblins, Thorin,” Gloin pointed out. “It would be suicide to go back.”

                “Bilbo is one of us,” Bofur argued. “We can’t leave him behind.”

                “You haven’t,” Bilbo huffed as he finally caught them. “I fell but I heard you and got out.”

                Thorin turned to look at him for a moment in silence. “You came back,” he said slowly.

                “Came back?” Bilbo questioned as he frowned. “We were separated. I didn’t leave you on purpose.”

                Thorin took a small step toward him. “You could have left,” he whispered. “You could have returned to your safe home in the Shire. Why didn’t you?”

                Bilbo sighed as he looked around at the dwarves and saw them all wearing the same hopefully confused looks on their faces. “I know that we have a hard time understanding each other,” Bilbo told them as he smiled. “I find you lot thick-headed and stubborn while you find me annoying.”

                “We agree on that,” Dwalin muttered.

                Bilbo graciously ignored him as he turned back to Thorin. “I pitied you when you came to my home in the Shire.” He raised his hand before any of them could protest. “I know that you think pity is a terrible thing but it isn’t. It isn’t. Everyone deserves pity when they’re having a rough time. There is strength in mercy and helping those in need.”

                Bilbo stopped to suck in a deep breath before he smiled sadly at his dwarves. “I still pity you but not because you are homeless but because something terrible was done to you. I want to help you because you deserve to be helped. I could have returned to my home but I would much rather return your home to you.”

                Thorin’s mouth dropped open to say something in reply. His words never made it past his tongue as howls filled the evening.

                “We have to run,” Gandalf said as he turned to dwarves. “The goblins sent for the orcs. We have to get away from here.”

                “Run,” Thorin breathed without looking away from Bilbo’s gaze. “Run!”

 

XXX

 

                Bilbo struggled to hold onto the tree. His grip faltered as he dug his fingers into the bark. Around him the dwarves called out in fear to one another while the wargs snarled and the orcs jeered. They were cornered and with the trees on fire, Bilbo knew they weren’t going to make it.

                Shifting his arm, he found the strength to pull himself back onto the trunk of the tree.

                “Mister Gandalf,” Dori cried. “We’re slipping!”

                Bilbo turned back to the wargs and orcs. Through the flames and the chaos he could see the pale orc that had taunted Thorin sitting on top of his white warg. Whether he was looking for Bilbo or just spotted him because he was the only one standing, Azog sneered at him.

                Without realizing it, Bilbo’s feet took him down the tree.

                “No!” Thorin yelled as he pulled at his branch. “Don’t!”

                Bilbo ignored him as he went past him. He kept his gaze on Azog even as he moved to stand before him. “I do not know what was done to you,” Bilbo said quietly at first though his voice grew louder as he found his courage. “But you do not have to live this way. You do not have to continue to harm others.”

                Azog scoffed as he steadied his warg.

                “Nothing will ever make it right,” Bilbo all but shouted over all the other noise. “Your people have been wronged. End this needless battle. Live in peace.”

                “Peace,” Azog sneered. “You will never know peace!”

                Bilbo braced himself as the white warg jumped forward. His shoulders hunched as he ducked his head.

                “No!” Thorin roared as he shoved Bilbo down out of the way. He swung one of Dwalin’s mighty hammers and hit the warg off course. “Your fight is with me, Azog! You will not touch him!”

                Bilbo rolled to the side in a cry of pain as he was jarred against the rocks that littered the top of the cliff. He managed to open his eyes and watch as Thorin hit another warg that tried to attack him just as the other dwarves joined him in their battle.

                He tried to breathe through the pain of his ribs getting battered as he lay on the ground. He just needed to catch his breath.

                Before he could, a dark shadow swooped through the night.

 

XXX

 

                “I thought you weak and pathetic,” Thorin admitted as they stood on top of the spire of rock. “You looked at me with such pity in your eyes and I vowed to dislike you for it.”

                Bilbo winced as he ducked his head. Thorin’s words stung more than the wind that swept over them. “Thorin,” he said weakly.

                “I have never been more wrong in my entire life,” Thorin finished as he pulled Bilbo into his arms and held him tight. “Courage,” he murmured against Bilbo’s curls. “Gandalf said that you would give us all courage.”

                Bilbo slumped into Thorin’s arms as he raised his arms to hug the dwarf back. “Thorin,” he said just as quietly as the first.

                “He was right,” Thorin whispered as he pulled back to allow the rest of the dwarves to hug their hobbit. “He was right.”

 

XXX

 

                Bilbo stumbled before he fell to his knees before the giant of a man. Beorn was so huge that he easily overshadowed Gandalf.

                “What’s this?” Beorn asked in equal measures of confusion and concern. “Is the little thing all right?”     Bilbo sucked in a shuddering breath before he lifted his teary eyes to look up at Beorn. “Master of the change,” he uttered before he stopped to swallow hard. “I grieve with you.”

                Beorn stared down in concern for a moment longer before he slowly knelt. “Do you know of my grief, little one?”

                Haltingly, Bilbo shook his head. “It is so much. Too much.”

                Gently, Beorn rested his fingers on the top of Bilbo’s head. “Do not shed your tears for me. I have found peace in my mourning.”

                Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut as he took another shuddering breath. “The world would be a much better place if more people were like you, Master Beorn,” he whispered as he tried to calm the burning behind his eyes. Beorn had told him not to cry.

                “I am honored you think so,” Beorn said so softly Bilbo wasn’t quite sure he’d heard him at first. “Though I suspect it would be much better if there were more like you.”

                Bilbo’s breath hitched but Beorn was already moving. He stood and turned to Gandalf and the dwarves. “Whatever you have need of, I will see to it.”

 

XXX

 

                Sitting beside the river at Beorn’s house, Bilbo slipped his hand into his pocket without thought. He jerked it out as the sound of thousands of voices crying out in despair echoed in his mind. Slowly, he pulled his pocket open and looked down into it. Sitting at the bottom was a tiny golden ring.

 

XXX

 

                “There is something wrong with this forest,” Bilbo whispered as he stood swaying in the middle of the path. “I can hear them crying.”

                “Who?” Bombur questioned as he made sure their hobbit stayed on his feet. “Who is crying?”

                Bilbo sighed as he stumbled forward. “The trees. Can’t you hear their despair?”

                The dwarves shifted on the path in discomfort as they looked around the eerie forest.

                “I can’t hear anything, Bilbo,” Bombur told him as he helped Bilbo keep going. “What does it sound like?”

                Bilbo cocked his head to the side to listen. “Death.”

 

XXX

 

                Standing before the elven king’s throne would have been more intimidating if he hadn’t just battled giant spiders in the forest outside. And if he hadn’t spoken to Beorn. Not to mention the stone giants. Really, Thranduil was probably the least intimidating thing he’d faced.

                Maybe the most annoying.

                “There are gems in the mountain that I, too, desire,” Thranduil drawled as he lounged on his throne. “We could strike a bargain.”

                “I’ll not bargain with you,” Thorin spat out from where he was being made to stand by the guards.

                Bilbo sighed before he tipped his head forward so his chin touched his chest. He shook his head before he lifted it to look past Thorin at Thranduil draped over his ornate chair. “I will.”

                Thorin didn’t so much as gasp (though some of the other dwarves standing behind them definitely did) as he just sharply took in a breath of air. “What?”

                Thranduil sat up a little straighter on his throne. “And who might you be that you think you can talk for this dwarf?”

                “Talk for him?” Bilbo repeated as if he couldn’t quite understand what Thranduil meant. “No, no, I don’t speak for him.”

                “Then I don’t have-“

                “I speak for my Lady,” Bilbo continued as if Thranduil hadn’t been speaking. “As long as I honor her, I am blessed with the privilege of speaking on her behalf.”

                Thranduil raised one of his brows as he dropped back in his chair. “And who is your lady?”

                Bilbo straightened his spider web covered jacket. He frowned up at Thranduil before clearing his throat. “My Lady is the Lady Nienna.”

                Slowly, Thranduil sat up once more. “You are so bold as to speak for one of the Valar?”

                “Yes,” Bilbo said without hesitation. “For I share in my Lady’s sorrows. Her grief is mine.”

                “Her grief,” Thranduil repeated.

                “And with it, she shares her wisdom,” Bilbo said with a small smile tugging at his lips. He would never tire of speaking of his Lady. He only wished that the people who he spoke to would stop repeating his words every time he did.

                “And what wisdom has she shared with you?” Thranduil asked in such a way that made it clear he did not believe for one moment that Bilbo would have something worth his while to say. “How to defeat the dragon?”

                “I look at you, oh King of the Forest, and I see its rot.”

                Thranduil’s gaze hardened as the other elves in the room stood a little straighter. “You dare-“

                “The forest is crying,” Bilbo continued without concern for the guards moving closer to him. “But you cannot hear it over the sound of your own grief.”

                “Grieving is important, wouldn’t you say?” Thranduil bit out.

                Bilbo conceded that point with a tip of his head in Thranduil’s direction. “Grief is important,” he agreed. “You must allow yourself to mourn for in your grief there is wisdom.”

                “Wisdom,” Thranduil repeated. “You said your Lady shares her wisdom with you.”

                “Yes,” Bilbo answered with another tip of his head. “Her wisdom is the ability to look at the cause of my grief and see if it was something that I caused or something that was done to me. For if I caused it, I can learn from that mistake. But if it was done to me, I can learn to gather the strength to move on and know that I was strong enough to overcome such sadness and keep living.”

                Bilbo knew that the dwarves and elves were all looking at him but he kept his eyes on Thranduil. “Have you looked at the cause of your grief and found wisdom in it? Have you learned from your mistakes?”

                Thranduil’s face closed down. Nothing of what he was feeling slipped through his gaze. “I could have you thrown into the dungeons so you’d have enough time to think about yours.”

                “I will weep for you,” Bilbo told him as he held the king’s gaze. “For you and for the elves that live here in this forest and for your pitiful fates.”

                “Our fates are not to be pitied,” Thranduil all but snarled as he got up from his throne. “You shall not shed a single tear for us, Child of Nienna!”

                Bilbo dropped his chin and thought of home. He closed his eyes and picture his parents and felt their loss like it had just happened and not many years before. With his eyes full of tears, he lifted his chin and met Thranduil’s gaze once more. “I will weep for you,” he said again.

                Thranduil faltered. He stepped back and fell hard onto his throne. “Take them away,” he said without any bite to his words. “Out. I want them out.”

                Bilbo ducked his head again. “You do not wish to confront your pain.”

                His words were not an accusation but rather an acknowledgement.

                “Get them to the river’s end, I don’t care how,” Thranduil said with a bit of urgency coloring his tone. “I want them gone.”

                An elf bowed before she ushered the dwarves out of the throne room and down the hall.

                Bilbo fell into line with the company as they walked. He blinked until he was sure that he wasn’t about to shed a tear. The elves, though they probably deserved them, would not receive any tears from him.

                “Where do you think they’re taking us?” Oin muttered in suspicion, or at least, he thought he was muttering, as they walked through the halls.

                “My lord said to get rid of you,” the elf answered with a sharp smile. “The choice on how to do so is mine.”

                Bilbo lifted his brows as they entered a large pantry like room with a stack of barrels in the middle of it. “This is an odd way to be rid of us.”

                “Yes,” she agreed as she made them stand next to the barrels. “But it’s also amusing.”

                Then she reached out and grabbed a lever that he hadn’t noticed and dropped them through the floor and into the river below.

 

XXX

 

                Bilbo coughed and spluttered as they crawled out of the river just before it met the lake. Their ride had not been pleasant, though that was partly because he could not swim and spent almost the entire ride clinging to the outside of a barrel.

                His dwarves were no better as they helped each other to shore.

                “Who are you?” A man stood on the rocks above them with a bow in his hands.

                Bilbo took one look at him and shook his head. “Thorin,” he called just as the king managed to get out of the river. “How far is it to the mountain from here?”

                “A few days walk,” Thorin replied as he sat heavily on the rocks and began the process of emptying his boots. “Unless we barter for passage across the lake.”

                Bilbo was a hobbit. He could see the grief that other people carried. “No, we’ll be walking.”

                The man’s brows lifted. He did not say anything as he began to gather the barrels. “Suit yourselves.”

                Bilbo only shook his head when the dwarves looked at him. He could not explain to them that this man, whoever he was, had suffered much in his life. They could not add to his troubles.

                Besides, he would rather have his feet on the earth after that river ride.

 

XXX

 

                Thorin sat next to Bilbo on the ledge at the top of the secret stairs. Their hands weren’t touching though the space between them wasn’t much.

                “And what do you plan to do?” Thorin asked lowly, mindful of the dwarves slumbering behind them. “Pity the dragon to death?”

                Bilbo snorted as he shook his head and smiled. “You said I just had to steal a gem.”

                “Bilbo,” Thorin said softly as he turned his head to look at him. “Smaug will be in there.”

                “I expect so,” Bilbo answered with a grin. “Otherwise, you’re going to feel very foolish.”

                Thorin rolled his eyes before he reached out to brush his fingers against Bilbo’s. “Please, be careful.”

                “Don’t worry,” Bilbo said as he shifted to lace his fingers with Thorin. “I don’t plan to give you cause to mourn me yet.”

                Thorin sighed at the sight of Bilbo’s cheeky smile but found that he couldn’t argue with him.

                Bilbo turned his head to look back out at the night. He made sure that his fingers stayed tangled with Thorin’s as he sucked in a deep breath and prayed to his Valar for strength and wisdom.

 

XXX

 

                The caverns that made up Erebor’s great halls were silent as Bilbo crept through them. He was not expecting an overabundance of noise but still found the utter stillness odd. Sadness lingered in the halls. One that he recognized from the night he first met Thorin and was bombarded by dwarves.

                He followed the directions that Balin had given him until he found the treasure hall. It was so vast that he almost couldn’t see the distant walls from the platform that he was standing on. The sight of all the gold and jewels around him that he was supposed to somehow find a singular gem in distracted him until his gaze landed on the dragon.

                Smaug’s eyes were open as he gazed back at Bilbo.

                Bilbo stiffened as his gaze stayed locked with Smaug’s. He could not hide. There was no point in running. The dragon was both bigger and smaller than he’d imagined while on their way to the mountain. His red scales gleamed against the piles of gold he was nestled in.

                But while Bilbo stood there and looked back at him, Smaug didn’t do more than blink. “Uh, er, hello?”

                A slow release of breath was his only reply.

                “I am, uh, here?” Bilbo stuttered as he managed to take a step forward on the platform. “I came to see you?”

                Smaug’s eyes flicked to the side for a moment before the returned to Bilbo. He had the distinct feeling the dragon was not impressed with him. “Are you all right?”

                Just as slow as before, the dragon drew in air. “No,” he said as he breathed it back out. “I am dying.”

                Bilbo stumbled another step forward at that. Now that he was looking, he could see that Smaug seemed to be resting at an odd angle on the top of his stolen hoard. “Dying?”

                “Yes,” Smaug answered as he breathed slowly once more. “My life is at an end. My magic has run dry.”

                Blinking hard, Bilbo stepped off the platform and down onto the treasure. He slid a bit as he made his way to the dragon. Smaug didn’t seem to be playacting or luring him in. The dragon did not have the strength to lift his head. “How long have you been dying?”

                “For weeks,” Smaug answered. “Or months. I do not know.”

                Wincing in sympathy, Bilbo tentatively reached out and rested his hand against the red scales of Smaug’s leg.

                The dragon shifted his massive head ever so slightly. “You,” he whispered. “You are blessed.”

                Bilbo dropped his head but did not take his hand away. “I am a hobbit,” he quietly told the dragon. “Our Lady blesses us.”

                “Please,” Smaug breathed as he struggled to lift his head. “You could save me.”

                Bilbo opened his mouth before he shut it again. “You have lived a long life, Smaug,” he said in the same soft tone. “I cannot extend a life that is at its end.”

                “No,” Smaug whined as he tried to turn to Bilbo. “You can. I know you can.”

                “I could,” Bilbo agreed easily as he kept his hand on Smaug’s leg. Despite the way the dragon weakly thrashed, he could not turn enough to do more than just looked at Bilbo with one giant, golden eye. “But I won’t.”

                “Please,” Smaug tried again. “I’ll do anything.”

                “You’ve already done too much,” Bilbo shushed him. “Your life was long and it has come to its end. Make peace, Smaug. And let go.”

                Smaug whined again but did not have the energy to speak.

                “Let go,” Bilbo told him again as he kept his hand firmly against his scales. “I will stay with you until you do.”

                For hours, Bilbo stood in vigil over the dying dragon. His body grew weak and his mind grew weary but he did not step back from Smaug’s side. He did not remove his hand.

                “Bilbo,” Thorin called from the platform behind him in worry and awe. “What?”

                Ducking his head, Bilbo felt as Smaug took in a slow and labored breath before he released it. He did not take another. “It is done,” Bilbo told the dwarves behind him in an exhausted voice. “So passes Smaug, the chiefest of calamities.”

                 “Did he,” Bofur asked haltingly as the dwarves all stared in shock. “Did he just pity a dragon to death?”

 

XXX

 

                “We demand you open the gates!” Thranduil called from the back of his elk. “Come forth and prove you are still alive.”

                “Oi!” Dwalin yelled from the top of the gate. “We’re still alive, you rotten tree shagger! “

                “Dwalin!” Bilbo scolded as he scurried across the top of the gates. “Have better manners.”

                “He started it,” Dwalin muttered as he stepped back and let Bilbo look down at their guests.

                “What he meant,” Bilbo called with a small smile on his lips, “is that the gates are still in need of repair. We couldn’t open them even if we wanted to.”

                Bard glanced at Thranduil before he looked back up at the hobbit who had refused to ride with him across the lake. “And the dragon?”

                “Oh, he’s very much gone,” Bilbo assured them. “He was dying when I found him.”

                “You slayed the dragon?” Thranduil asked in a way that made it clear that he was surprised but desperately trying to hide it. “You?”

                “I did no such thing!” Bilbo gasped as he crossed his arms over his chest. “He was already dying! I just refused to help him get better.”

                Bard, very much confused, looked between the two of them before he shrugged. “So what are you going to do?”

                “Not to worry,” Bilbo said as he waved his hand through the air. “Thorin already sent a raven to his cousin. There’s a whole army of dwarves on their way to help us get this sorted out.”

                As he spoke, his gaze lifted to the sight of a small grey blob on the back of a horse making its way toward them. He grinned as he realized just who he was looking at. He couldn’t wait to make sure that Gandalf had known how wrong he was all those weeks ago. The destination was the most dangerous part. What had that wizard been thinking?

 

XXX

 

                “You would be safer if you stayed inside the mountain,” Thorin said lowly as he took Bilbo’s hands into his. “Out there will be dangerous.”

                “Thorin Oakenshield,” Bilbo all but scolded. “I have not left your side since I followed you out my door. I won’t start now. Not without a better reason than it’s dangerous.”

                Thorin studied his gaze before he gave in with a sigh. “If you insist on joining us then will you please consider wearing some armor?”

                Bilbo’s brows rose as he shook his head. “It’ll be too heavy.”

                “No,” Thorin said with a soft smile. “It won’t.”

 

XXX

 

                Bilbo panted as he kept pace with Thorin and the boys. Dwalin was hot on his heels as they made their way up the last bit of Ravenhill. “Do you see him?”

                “Not yet,” Thorin answered as he scanned the tower in front of them. “Fili, Kili, go scout.”

                “No,” Bilbo gasped as he caught their arms just before they darted off. “Look!”

                At the top of the tower stood Azog. He sneered down at them in derision. “Have you come to offer me salvation again, little bug.”

                “Bug?” Bilbo frowned as he turned to Thorin in confusion. “Does he mean me?”

                “Well,” Dwalin drawled as he leaned on the handle of one of his hammers. “I definitely didn’t try to offer him salvation before.”

                Bilbo huffed as he turned back to the orc. “No, you made your choice. My Lady has granted me the wisdom to understand now that there are some who would rather walk the path of darkness. I cannot sway you.”

                “You said you gained wisdom but you were still foolish enough to walk into my trap!”

                At his words, orcs streamed out of the tower. Fili and Kili immediately began to pick some of them off with their bow and daggers.

                Bilbo ignored the chaos around him as his dwarves fought. He looked back up at Azog. “I cannot change your fate,” he called above the noise. “All I can do is make sure you don’t harm anyone else.”

                Azog bared his teeth before he turned and left the edge of the tower.

                Bilbo watched him go before he ducked under the swing of a sword and rejoined the fight. Every time the pointy end of his sword found the unprotected flesh of an orc, he gathered another small piece of grief to bear. They were choosing to be creatures of evil but Bilbo found that he still had enough of himself left that each of their deaths weighed on him and his bloodied sword.

                He was so caught up in fighting the orcs around him that he didn’t notice that Azog had emerged from the tower and pulled Thorin into a fight until Thorin cried out in agony.

                “No,” Bilbo breathed as he spun and found Thorin pinned to the ice beneath Azog’s blade. “Fili! Kili!”

                The boys turned as one and charged. They attacked Azog with such combined skill that the pale orc was overwhelmed. Together, they plunged their swords into his chest and then kicked him over the cliff.

                Bilbo dropped to his knees at Thorin’s sides and reached out with shaking hands to look at his wound. “Thorin,” he pleaded. “Thorin, can you hear me? Are you okay?”

                “Bilbo,” Thorin breathed wetly as his gaze focused. “I meant to tell you,” he gurgled before he turned his head and coughed the blood from his throat. “At the gate. Before. Before the fight.”

                “Hush, Thorin,” Bilbo gentled as he lifted Thorin’s cloak and then had to look away from the ghastly wound. “You’re going to be all right.”

                “I love you,” Thorin gasped. “Bilbo.”

                “I know,” Bilbo told him as he bowed his head over Thorin’s heaving chest. “I love you, too.”

                “Don’t,” Thorin said shakily as he managed to lift his hand and cup Bilbo’s cheek. “Don’t cry. Find strength in your grief.”

                Bilbo opened his mouth to say something, anything. All that escaped past his lips was a sob. He pressed harder into Thorin’s hand as he brought both of his up to keep Thorin’s palm against his face. “You cannot die,” he cried. “I will not be able to bear such a fate. Please, Thorin. You have to live.”

                “Gandalf was right,” Thorin moaned as Bilbo’s tears leaked down his cheeks and onto Thorin’s hand. “You were my hope.”

                Gasping, Bilbo tipped forward to rest his head against Thorin’s chest. “No, Thorin,” he whispered even as he sobbed. “You were mine.”

                “Uncle,” Fili breathed as he stood just behind Bilbo with Kili tucked under his arm. “Don’t give up, Thorin.”

                “Please,” Kili added as he did his best not to cry. “Please don’t die.”

                Sniffling, Bilbo sat up. He smiled, though it was wobbly and very wet, at Thorin. “You won’t die, Thorin. I told you. You’re going to live.”

                “Bilbo,” Thorin murmured as he took his face into his hands again. “I felt his blade pierce me. This is goodbye. My body is done.”

                Bilbo frowned as he looked down at Thorin. “Azog stabbed you.”

                “Yes,” Thorin said weakly. Bilbo was covered in his blood. He knew that. “Are you okay?”

                “Am I okay? Thorin,” Bilbo complained as he tugged at the dwarf. “You’re fine.”

                “What?” Kili said from behind them.

                “What?” Fili repeated.

                Thorin lifted his hand and gingerly pressed at his chest before he sat up with a gasp. “What!”

                Bilbo sniffled again even as he smiled. “My tears,” he told them as the dwarves looked at him. “They have the power to heal.”

                “For fuck’s sake,” Dwalin muttered before he spun and stomped away. “I’m going to find more orcs to kill.”

                “Bilbo,” Thorin said with wonder in his voice. “You saved me.”

                “I love you,” Bilbo said simply. “Of course I saved you.”

                Fili turned from them to look out over the cliff at where hundreds of elves and dwarves were dying from their wounds. “Do you think you could save them, too?”

                Bilbo got to his feet before he helped Thorin back onto his. “Let’s go see about that.”

 

XXX

 

                Exhausted, Bilbo slipped from another tent. He felt dehydrated and knew that if he laid down he would not get back up.

                “Little one,” Beorn’s deep voice rumbled from nearby. “I heard that you were in need of my help.”

                Bilbo turned to look at the massive man. He tiredly smiled as he patted the pocket he hadn’t dared to put his fingers back in since the last time he’d seen Beorn. “Yes, it seems that I’ve stumbled upon something that must be dealt with. Sooner rather than later. Tell me, dear friend. Are you too tired to give me a ride?”

 

XXX

 

                “No one knows where he went,” Balin reminded Thorin as he paced one of the cleared halls within the mountain. “He was helping in the tents and then he wasn’t. Dale has been searched. Laketown has been searched. The battlefield was searched. We cannot find him.”

                “Bilbo has to be somewhere,” Thorin snapped as he turned to face Balin again. “He has to be!”

                “It’s been over a week,” Balin said as gently as he could. “Maybe it is time to honor him by mourning him the way he would have mourned any of us.”

                “No,” Thorin snarled before he stopped to suck in a deep breath. “I can’t. Not until he’s found.”

                “Thorin!” Fili yelled as he burst through the doors. “It’s Bilbo!”

                “He’s back!” Kili cried as he rammed into his brother’s back. “He’s back!”

                Thorin raced through the halls until he found his hobbit. Bilbo was fine, a little on the burnt side, but alive and smiling. “Thank Mahal!”

                “Ah,” Bilbo said as his gaze landed on Thorin. “I don’t think he had much to do with my little side trip with Beorn.”

                “Hobbit,” Thorin growled as he stalked toward his hobbit. “You have caused me much grief over these past days.”

                “Have I?” Bilbo asked with a grin tugging at his lips. “I am so very sorry. I had an errand to run, you see.”

                “No,” Thorin grunted, “I don’t see.”

                Bilbo’s smile did not diminish as he took in the pout on Thorin’s face. “And did you embrace your grief? Were you able to find wisdom in it?”

                “Aye,” Thorin replied. He ignored the snorts of disbelief behind him. “And I have found strength.”

                “Have you now?”

                “Yes,” Thorin said as he closed the distance between them and pulled Bilbo into his arms. “You came back, Bilbo,” he said lowly to him. “You hadn’t left my side since we departed from your home.”

                “Until I did,” Bilbo said with a sigh.

                “Until you did,” Thorin agreed.

                “Thorin-“

                “I found strength and hope,” Thorin quietly cut him off. “In you. I did not realize until you were gone, how much I would detest being parted from you.”

                Bilbo allowed Thorin to tip his head back. Their gazes locked as Bilbo licked his dry lips and tried to swallow. “I missed you, too.”

                “So I found the strength to tell you,” Thorin continued. “That I wish to never be parted from you again.”

                “Thorin.”

                “Stay,” Thorin pleaded before all the assembled people in the hall. “Stay and cause me grief for the rest of my life for I am stronger with you.”

                Bilbo felt the telltale heat in his eyes. He did his best to blink back his tears but was able to stop one from sliding down his cheek.

                Thorin caught it with a gentle brush of his thumb before he pulled Bilbo forward into a kiss.

Series this work belongs to: