Work Text:
He didn't realize it right away the loss of Thorin, especially on the long way back, not until he saw the Valley of Imladris and, above all, Rivendell. Serenity came over him immediately, as the elves in the trees sang in praise of his deeds. At last, time slowed down and the transition between the journey and the return to Bad End took place. Bilbo had not been alone since their departure from Erebor, and though the thought of the king who had never been haunted him, he pushed each feeling further into his heart. The lament sung during the three burials kept looping in his head and bruising his heart. The voices of the company and the dwarves echoed again and again, and Bilbo couldn't forget those heart-rending laments, which had been mixed with his tears and his voice for the last verses.
A warrior, leader, a proud flawed king?
A lover, he liked to add to that line. So many unspoken things between them, so many things they thought they'd have all the time in the world to say and admit to each other... He already missed his envious, tender or even embarrassed looks, but he refused to stop thinking about them and one day forget, forget everything that Thorin's little attentions brought out in him. Never again would he be able to recapture the immense joy of this adventure, to feel it again in his whole being. How ready he was to fight for what Thorin believed in, to help him reclaim his own home or even to assist him with whatever came next. But nothing came after Erebor's claim but madness, flames and death.
The quietude of his room, despite the elves' songs to lull him to sleep, distressed him, too quiet. His adventure with the dwarves had made him forget how heavy the silence of the night was. No more jokes, no more laughter, no more phrases in Khuzdul or Thorin's grumpy remarks to Fíli and Kíli. The three of them were no longer present in Middle-earth, and his heart constricted every time he realized this. His tears refused to flow, constricting his throat and blurring his vision. After all, why was he holding back his grief when he was at last alone and out of sight of anyone?
Not even the singing of the elves could help him resist the great sadness that kept consuming him. Bilbo gazed up at the clear, starry sky and the magnificent moon. No candles were burning in his room. The hobbit only wanted the soft, cold light of the star in the sky to remind him of all the moonlit nights only with a campfire to warm them on their long adventure in the Eastern Lands. Bilbo had also opened the window so that the fresh night air and the scent of Rivendell's woods and flowers would help him to ground himself a little more, to bear the pain pounding in his chest.
Pillar candles and new candles were placed on a pedestal table. Bilbo rose from the bed, almost dragging his feet, an idea having occurred to him to help him cope better with this deluge of emotion. A flint and an iron coin lay on a silver tray. He took a large blue pillar candle and centered it on the tray, lighting it. Bilbo let go of all his emotions - his grief, his mourning, his pain - as soon as the flame appeared on the wick. He collapsed, too, meaning that his whole body was releasing what he'd been feeling since November, since his departure from the Lonely Mountain. Even during the wintering at Beorn’s, Bilbo had resisted the urge to collapse, to weep or cry out his unhappiness at this absence.
No more elf songs echoed, were they still nearby or had they gone far away to leave the hobbit entirely alone to give him the space he needed to express this rage, this emptiness of his soul with no one to witness it.
He wept again and again, torrents of tears pouring down his cheeks. Bilbo was still on his knees, staring at the flame as if it were still binding him to Thorin's soul. Where did dwarves' souls go when they died? Surely to Mahal's side. Thorin was once again among his ancestors, and Kili and Fili were not alone...It struck him as a certainty that Durin's three descendants were at peace, all three reunited with their families. This comforted him a little, but not for long, and Bilbo even smiled a little. In seven months, he had glimpsed a joyful life surrounded by companions, each more different than the next, but sticking together in adversity, almost becoming a family in this suicidal quest. And he'd loved sharing this adventure with them; his place would have been with Thorin in Erebor if he'd survived... He'd have tasted this life with people who held him in high esteem, at least not at the start of their journey, but who cares... He wanted to remember the best moments first.
And the moments with Thorin immediately came to mind. He remembered every detail of the dwarf king, his king, the one who had captured his heart and gone before Mahal with it, without returning it. A gaping wound now occupied the place in his chest where his heart used to be. It bled and refused to close. Would it ever close? The smirk Thorin had given him during their first interaction was the first image he saw. Bilbo had wanted to wipe that smile off his face, especially after calling him a grocer or the predatory stroll he'd taken to size him up. The hobbit hadn't forgotten, didn't want to forget. His voice came back to him, Thorin was almost whispering in his ear, as he had done in Laketown, the whisper of his last words on the ice.
The pain, the denial, of this death. Thorin could not die! They had won: Smaug was dead, the battle of the five armies was over and Erebor was claimed! Impossible! The throne was Thorin's, and he had fought so hard to get it back!
I’m glad you are here. I wish to part from you in friendship, Bilbo. I would take back my words and my deeds at the gate. You did what only a true friend would do. Forgive me. I was too blind to see it. I am so sorry that I have led you into such peril. Farewell Master Burglar, go back to your books and your armchair. Plant your trees, watch them grow. If more people value their home above gold, this world would be a merrier place.
The words resonated with the dreadful pain that accompanied them, how everything was turning upside down, how it no longer made sense, he didn't want to believe it, he still refused to accept it. Thorin could not die in his arms! And yet he did.
Bilbo cried again, even harder, he didn't want to remember, awful, tearing his being and his soul apart.
Thorin! King Under The Mountain
Alas no more shall rule this domain
We brethren must go on without him
And ensure his death was not in vain
In sleep eternal he will rest
With the Arkenstone upon his breast
Which evermore shall emit its light
To banish the darkness of unending night
And on his tomb is Orcrist laid
An Elven blade forged in Elder Days
To warn of foes and roving orcs
And ward off all evil from Erebor
How shall we remember our fallen friend
Who conquered Dragon Sickness in the end?
A warrior, leader, a proud flawed king?
A worthy descendant of mighty Durin!
The lament struck him like daggers through his body, bringing him back to reality. Despite his desire to sing it, the words left his lips like a whisper. He remembered the same verses in Khuzdul. How could the absence of someone be such a big part of his daily life when Bilbo had only known Thorin for a year? All this suffering because of a stubborn, emotionally constipated dwarf, a king even in the most difficult of times. He missed his tender blue eyes. The hobbit hadn't forgotten how close he'd come to bringing Thorin back to them in that armory, how even in psychosis Thorin protected him and how Bilbo was his priority, after his treasure, after his gold.
His voice, too. His voice when he sang in either Westeron or Khuzdul.
The warmth of his voice.
The emotions his singing evoked.
The voice that comforted and supported him.
That voice that had frightened him like a dragon
That he'd always stood up to.
His stubborn character.
His kingly bearing under the mountain.
His kingly bearing, his ability to lead his people.
And finally, Bilbo calmed down a little, enough to try and speak out loud, perhaps his pain would ease somewhat if he felt he could talk to Thorin, empty his bag of unsaid things.
“Thorin...I don't know if these words will reach you wherever you are. I hope you've found your ancestors in the halls of your creator Mahal. I hope your brother Frerin, but also your parents and even your grandparents have welcomed you warmly with Fili and Kili. My heart whispers to me that the three of you are at peace, far from the suffering of death and with peaceful hearts, free of all problems and material possessions. Far from the gold that made your lineage suffer.”
“Yet I struggle to find this peace. It's illusory, I suffer. I've changed, Thorin. As Gandalf warned me, I'm no longer the same as the hobbit who adores his food, his garden and his armchair in front of the hearth. My heart is empty, I feel nothing. I feel nothing. Except your constant absence from my side. How can I return to The Shire? To my old life? I have no taste for anything. Emptiness consumes me, pain, deep sadness.
By Yvanna, my heart cries out for you and my arms. I don't want this life of mourning for the person who believed in me the most, who knew how to see my best sides as well as my worst. I miss you Thorin Oakenshield. I miss you. That stubborn, proud dwarf who walked through my door while calling me a grocer with that mischievous grin. How I wanted to strangle you. Those scathing retorts, that morose air, a real charm, isn't it!
Bilbo found himself bursting out, almost laughing, as he thought back to that morose Thorin whose face never faded.
“But I got to know you quickly during our adventure, and I saw your courage, bravery and loyalty to your people. I also saw a loving uncle, always attentive to the slightest action of his nephews, of the whole company. A dwarf with love to spare and you chose to share it with me...But you see the problem is that you took my heart as you breathed your last in my arms. I no longer feel anything for the things I love if it's not you.
I miss you, Thorin.
I wish you'd come back to me or that I'd wake up from the dream where you're no longer present by my side, to put an end to this nightmare. To finally cuddle up in your arms, to see you walk through that door and tell me that never again will you leave me alone and in the abyssal cold of this life without you.
I can't go back to before this adventure, I don't regret a single second or the bad times.
Thorin, you'll always live on in what's left of my heart, in my poems, in my stories, in the tales.
No one will forget you, no one will forget how you sacrificed everything for your people, to give them a home.
In Bag End, you said you weren't sure you could keep me safe...Well, you did everything you could to keep me alive, safe at the risk of your life.
My life will never be the one I dared to dream of with a dear, stubborn dwarf at my side.
Farewell, Thorin, king under the mountain.”
And he couldn't go on any louder, tears having knotted his throat for too long already. Bilbo wept but kept staring at the flame in front of him, in some hopeful conch.
I love you.
At the same moment, a draught entered the room to extinguish the flame. A chilling sensation grazed Bilbo's cheeks and lips, like fingers trying to comfort him. Could it be? Thorin? No, he was going mad thinking Thorin could hear him from where he was. His mind was playing tricks on him. Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't. But that cool breeze had had that soothing, warming effect.
Either way, Bilbo could never know the truth about Aulë's intentions with his children. A mystery to all.
