Chapter Text
Thorin felt nothing when he saw the two dwarves brought forth to him. Gander Son of Vander was no less familiar to the Crown Prince than Thenli Son of Renli. Their names nothing to him, nor did their faces, both battered and bruised, just as they'd left him six years ago when the two highway men deemed Thorin to be an easy target.
"We'd never have gone after ye' if we knew ye' were the Crown Prince! Honest!" Gander had groveled as Dwalin kicked him in the back of the knees when he tried to crawl his way forward to Thorin to beg for forgiveness.
Something inside Thorin's patience snapped. He'd been through quite a bit since returning to Ered Luin, living along side his family and his people once more, relearning everything about himself slowly but surely…and for some reason, he thought he'd feel better if he had been attacked because of his title.
"So you'd beat someone to death if they weren't nobles?" Thorin snarled from his seat beside the King's throne. "You think the life of a random traveler is meaningless compared to mine, is that right?" He asked, his eyes narrowed in on the two responsible for his amnesia.
"Y-yes?" Thenli nodded, unsure how to answer, only to earn a glare and a click of the tongue from his partner.
"Balin!" Thorin summoned, and his advisor came to stand by his side. "Tell me…if I were to beat Gander here with the intent to murder him, rob him of all his belongings with the hopes of selling them, and then cut his braids and sell his beads, leaving him left for dead in nothing but his smalls…what would my punishment be?" He asked his advisor, though he never moved his enraged gaze from the two pitiful dwarves before him.
"The punishment for the attempted murder is either execution or a life sentence of hard labor depending on the King's judgment. As for robbery, you would face either restitution…repaying the victim a minimum of ten times the value of what was stolen, additional labor added to your life sentence, or imprisonment.
"Following that, you'd be charged for assault and battery, the most common of punishments would be imprisonment, or years added to your imprisonment. Then, there is also the fact that your victims were left for dead on the side of the road, so you would be charged with endangerment as well…this would certainly add years to your imprisonment. Then, there is your charge of cultural desecration for cutting their hair and stealing their beads…where the punishment can range from exile to death." Balin finished explaining simply, his eyes staring down at those who had harmed his prince with an unnerving neutrality, as if he were looking at nothing more than a pile of shit on the side of the road.
Before Thorin could speak, his heart pounding in his chest as he listened to the punishments that these dwarves could face for their crimes against him, Balin held his hand up once more to continue speaking.
"Yet there is one more charge against you, if you were to have been the one committing these heinous acts, your majesty…In your attempt to kill them, you rendered them not only broken and beaten, but had stripped their minds of their lives…not a single memory of who they were up to that point. Though you failed at taking their lives, as their bodies survived…their very identity and person hood did not survive. The charge of murder of identity, though uncommon, would be added to your list of crimes. The punishment being the same as true murder, which is death or in the most lenient of cases, exile." Balin added eloquently, his voice calm and cool, as if he were simply conversing with the Crown Prince about the weather.
"Please! Please, we didn't mean for-" Gander cried out.
"Silence!" Thorin growled, his hands gripping tightly to the arm rests of his seat so tightly that Balin worried he'd break them. "You meant to rob a dwarf of life and property…you admitted your intent when conversing with our informant, and many witnesses overheard your bragging…Something about how the money you earned from armor alone was still feeding your gambling addiction to this day."
Thenli glared at his partner harshly, keeping him from speaking as if their silence would earn them a less harsh sentence.
"Now…Balin…tell me, was I the one to commit these crimes?" Thorin asked, turning his face to Balin, disgusted at the pathetic sight of the dwarves crying.
"Why of course not, your majesty." Balin stated firmly.
"Can you tell me who committed these crimes against who?" Thorin continued, enjoying the way the men who had taken everything from him were now suffering before him.
'Getting their comeuppance, indeed.' Thorin knew Bungo would say, even if he would frown upon the near-giddiness Thorin was experiencing from their misery.
"The crimes listed were committed by Gander Son of Vander, and Thenli Son of Renli, and were against you, your majesty." Balin said, trying his best to not smile, as he was not one to enjoy another's pain, but he believed this moment was an exception, and he could pray to Mahal later to forgive him for his moment of hubris, as allowed his heart to revel in their misery and fear.
For the suffering of his kin who held him a funeral…
For the burden that Belladonna and Bungo had taken upon themselves to heal an injured, and lost soul…
For himself who had lost everything…
He couldn't help but think Mahal would forgive him for his satisfaction in their suffering.
"Tell me, Balin…as I am no mere dwarf, but the heir to the throne of Erebor and Durin's Folk…what would their punishment be?" Thorin asked, turning back to the dwarves with bitterness in his eyes and anger in his heart.
"They'd be shamed and shorn publicly, and then would be led to their execution." Balin explained…and it was those words that made any feeling of giddiness leave him.
'There is no better revenge than letting a lad live with the knowledge he was wrong.' Belladonna had said once after the ignorant Mister Diggle of Overhill had insulted the Bagginses for taking in a dwarf. 'Sometimes there is the itch to solve a negative moment with negative actions…but that's the thing about negatives, Holm…it takes…and someday, there will be nothing left to take away, and you'll be left empty.
'Smiling and nodding and ignoring the cruel words are not a show of giving in or acceptance of what was said…but that their words are so wrong you'd rather not waste your breath on responding. Do not waste your energy on petty folk like Mister Diggle. Use it on proving him wrong, and make him eat his words.' The mistress of Bag End had grinned at him, and though it was hard to let such demeaning words be thrown at his rescuers, he'd not disappoint Bella by taking…
"As Prince Regent, I am the one who will be deciding the punishment, yes, Balin?" He asked his advisor, who nodded twice. "Well then…" He took a deep breath, rose to his feet and stared down at his attackers…how such pitiful dwarves had gotten the better of him, he didn't know…But the fact still stood that it did happen.
"Shamed and shorn…is a fitting punishment. There is no honor in what you did, and to keep a single hair on your head leaves me feeling sick. It shall be done publicly, where your humiliation will be on display for anyone to see…But a good leader is not one without mercy…" Thorin spoke calmly, feeling satisfied with the conclusion he'd come up with, as if Belladonna had been by his side, helping him work through his rage, just as she had been before.
"In death you'd not feel the shame of your actions. You would not feel remorse, nor the agony of knowing you had done grievously wrong. Death would allow you freedom from your crimes…Instead, you shall be given the brand of the foulest of criminals and exiled from Ered Luin. Your possessions will be given to your next of kin, and you will be sent out with nothing but your undergarments." He declared for everyone to hear. "My word is law, let it be so."
With that, he turned his back on the scene, and when the doors to the chamber closed, it was as if a door on his past closed as well.
He didn't not watch the humiliation, unable to stomach it himself…He knew it was still terribly cruel what he had decided…but in the end, he was a dwarf, not a hobbit…and these were dangerous criminals who posed a threat to more than Thorin's pride. Yet he knew in that moment when he'd reached his decision, that he couldn't become a king who acted on his rage alone…
It was two years after Thorin had returned to Ered Luin that his memories came back to him. Thorin had found a harp in an abandoned room while getting lost on his way to his lessons with Balin, who had taken it upon himself to re-teach Thorin all the knowledge and lore he'd lost. But the harp drew him in, and he knew his lessons could wait.
He dusted it off, and tuned it, his hands acting on their own without much thought, his ears picking up the smallest variation in pitch as he plucked the strings and restored the beautiful golden instrument to its formal glory. But what was glorious about an instrument if it was not used for music?
Of course, Thorin didn't know how to play…just as he didn't know how to tune the strings…
He sat down on the stool that had been beside it, and before he was aware of it, music was filling the halls. Words that Thorin didn't know…notes that he could not recall hearing…they came forth from the harp, as if the song had been within him all along.
A song about grief and loss. A song about suffering…about a story he'd lived, but did not remember until now.
He remembered holding Frerin's hand, with Dis on his back as they escaped from the mountain as the fires raged on, and the dragon made it's claim on their home. He remembered the screams and cries…he remembered their exodus as his people spread across Arda, lost and searching for a place to call home.
He remembered begging his father to let him leave the safety of Ered Luin before he became an adult simply so he could help earn coin for their colony. At only fifty-eight he'd left the mountain to begin his travels alongside merchants, selling his wares and bringing home what he could.
He remembered the birth of his nephews, and how he'd try to save enough coin to be able to buy them a trinket now and again…and he remembered when he was seventy, marching alongside his brother-in-law to the Misty Mountains to fight in what became the Battle of Bizarre.
He remembered severing Azog the Defiler's head from his shoulders, just as the vile beast had done to their king — his grandfather. He remembered their trudging feet as they returned to the Blue Mountains, the dead burned and buried, never to be returned to their loved ones…
He remembered the haunting cry his sister choked out when he told her the news. How she trembled in his arms as her legs could no longer hold her in her grief. He remembered the dirge he played in memory of the family he had lost in that battle…and as Thorin's fingers continued to pluck and strum and dance across the strings of the golden harp, he remembered how he had once tried to gain his mastery in it. How he had wanted to become a musician like his grandmother who died in dragon fire…Only to put the dream away for more profitable pursuits to keep his family from starvation.
He played his harp.
And he remembered.
The halls of Ered Luin had long since been devoid of music since Thorin's disappearance seven years ago. With the loss from Azanulbizar still heavy in everyone's hearts, and their prince and hero vanishing without a trace no one had a reason for song.
But his music swelled and soared through the air like the Ravens of Ravenhill…and as it flowed through the halls, it was as if a message was delivered with each note. A message of hope.
'When there's life, there's hope…Always remember that Thorin. With air in your lungs, and a beating heart, it matters not what comes your way. There will always be hope.'
It was not even a day after Thorin regained his memories that his father the King passed away. Thrain had heard his song and for the first time in a long time, had eyes that were clear and seeing things as they truly were. Thrain held Thorin close, and the two were silent as they remembered together. He spoke of how good it was to see his son again, and Thorin had apologized for making him worry for so long.
Thrain died in his sleep with a smile on his face and peace in his heart.
Thorin's coronation was a week after the funeral. He had quickly become known for being a just and kind king, one who took the complaints of his people with the seriousness and respect it deserved. Even the most minor grievances were held to the same standard of consideration as the most important matters of state.
An older man who could no longer walk up the steps to Mahal's shrine was just as important to Thorin as orc packs and wargs becoming more prevalent in the north. So Thorin would summon his counsel and have a railing built at the steps to the shrine, and he'd send more scouts out to protect their home.
The king was beloved…but he was also tired.
When a certain Grey Pilgrim came to him about a task only he could uptake, he had to push his exhaustion to the side. He formed a small company with the hopes of reclaiming their ancestral home. The journey was perilous, and there were many times he was certain his life flashed before his eyes…but he refused to succumb to death.
He had slain the dragon.
He had conquered his line's madness.
He had overcome the trials of reclaiming his home.
It took time and patience, but as more and more of his people flooded the gates of Erebor, the mountain became alive once again. They cleaned the dust and the debris, and rebuilt what had been destroyed. He welcomed his nephews to their birthright that they had only heard of in their grand tales…and he became allied with the elves of Mirkwood, as well as the men of Dale, determined to put old grudges to the side, and form new bonds of friendship and respect.
Thorin was beloved.
And he so terribly missed his beloved.
Not a day went by that he didn't think of Bilbo…and every year on the twenty-second of September, for how could he ever forget such a date, he'd celebrate the night they shared together. He'd go to his balcony, and stare up at the stars. As he sipped at the honey mead in his goblet, he would remember the way the fireflies had danced around them as if they were a reflection of the sky above them, and play the song that both Bilbo and himself had claimed to be their favorite…and he remembered just how wonderful it felt to dance with his hobbit to that song.
He wondered if Bilbo looked up at the same sky. Did the hobbit think of him when he the song was played at parties? Did he dance with someone else? Did he take another as his lover and let them court him the way he deserved? Did they bring Bungo flowers and ask him for Bilbo's hand in marriage? Or did he begrudgingly marry one of his suitors, or maybe he perhaps find love at first sight again? Or, even worse, was Bilbo as silly as he was, still waiting for the day Holm would return to Bag End with a bushel of roses and a ring in a box?
Every time Thorin thought he was close to catching a break…to having the opportunity to reach out to the Shire, something always stopped him. Though he was King, it mattered not to his siblings, who were still weary about Thorin contacting his old friends. No longer did they worry that the hobbits of the Shire had kidnapped him and held him prisoner…instead they worried that their brother and King would leave them for his friends.
Thorin had never told anyone of Bilbo…it never felt right to do so, for some reason. He longed to tell his sister, ever the romantic, that he had found love in the Shire, and that his One was waiting for him…He wanted to tell Frerin about how Bilbo was far more cunning than he was, and how well they'd get along. He wanted so desperately to tell them that he'd given the hobbit one of his only beads, which he had remembered was the beginning of Dwarven courtship, and couldn't help but smile at how appropriate a gesture it was.
But he only ever mentioned the Bagginses as his friends…and as time went on, he mentioned them aloud less and less. Now, nearly a decade after reclaiming his home, he sat in a counsel meeting and wished, not for the first time, that he could be with those friends…not dealing with paperwork or problems of state…
And especially not dealing with looming starvation.
"We can reach out to Rohan?" Suggested one counselman, Baksur Son of Raksur, though he doubted it was a good suggestion…but when you were grasping for straws, anything was better than nothing.
"Perhaps the Iron Hills can spare some food this time around?" Chimed in Rees, Daughter of Thees.
"No good there either…Lord Dain is struggling enough as it is with his own. They've got enough for themselves and their stores…but it'd be a hit too damaging to share…" Lamented Vrilon, Daughter of Krilon, her head hanging low as she was ambassador to the Iron Hills and knew too well how little they could spare.
"What about Gondor? Surely they might have something...even just farmers to come lend us a hand?" Grumbled Gloin, son of Groin, the head of the treasury offered dryly, as if he were simply speaking to hear his own voice rather than truly suggesting it.
"Too dangerous…more orc packs are spotted South of Dorwinion by the month…we can't risk it…both the produce and the lives that could be lost…Not to mention it's too far…the food would go bad by the time we could store it properly…lest we survive only on pickles…" Bombur, the head of the Culinary Guild grimaced at the idea.
"What about…what about reaching out to Ered Luin? Could they possibly-" But Deya Child of Teya was cut off.
"Ered Luin has much now as they did when Durin's Folk still resided there in Thorin's Halls. No…we will not ask for what they do not have." Princess Dis spoke firmly, and Deya nodded, knowing it was a silly thing to even think, seeing as she too came from Ered Luin and knew their situation all too well.
Thorin had been sitting quietly, nodding and shaking his head silently, stroking his beard in contemplation, trying to find a solution. When the most obvious solution popped up in his mind, he stood up far too quickly, his chair tumbling back as he slammed his hands on the table, his eyes wide and shining, and his smile full of excitement.
The counsel had never seen their king with such an excited and eager expression. His eyes were as wide as his smile, a far cry from the brooding and scowling he was known for.
"Your Majesty?" Balin son of Fundin asked, a fuzzy white eyebrow raised high as he waited for an explanation from the king.
"We will write to the Thain!" He spoke with little room for anyone to so much as think to argue.
"What? Who? Who's the 'Thain'?" Frerin finally chimed in, waking up from a nap, as he had a habit of getting too comfortable in his chair during these meetings.
"The leader of the Shire! They have food to spare…stores and stores of it. Even after the Fell Winter their fields never suffered…their farmers are the best in all of Arda. No other knows how to care for the earth like a hobbit. I will write to the Thain…ask him if we can make a deal…I don't know what we'd exchange though…" Thorin paused, wondering what in the world a dwarven kingdom could ever offer the Shire.
"Gold." Gloin said plainly after a moment of silence, as everyone had thought their king was being dry and sarcastic.
"Hardly. They care not for it…They'd do better if we traded buttons for tomatoes." Thorin snorted at the exaggeration, but it wasn't too far off from the truth.
"And why would halflings even think about helping us?" Asked Vrilon with very little enthusiasm. "I've met them plenty of times…terrible to do business with. They're all a bit…primitive and naive…If we asked them for food, they'd send it to us in a box, thinking we were asking for a snack. They're too idealistic…they'd never be able to imagine the state of our fields…" She tisked, shaking her head and rolling her eyes, too tired and hungry to think about how disrespectful she was acting towards the king.
But it wasn't her attitude towards Thorin that irked him, but the blatant prejudice against the people he still cared deeply for.
"They're not half of anything, Master Vrilon Daughter of Krilon. They are hobbits, and it'd be in your favor to remember that, am I understood? You are wrong on all accounts and I should hope to never hear you speak that way about them again." Thorin bellowed through the counsel room, his voice booming as he made his feelings on the matter known.
"They are a kind people who would give the shirt off their backs to help a stranger if they needed it. Maybe not a Sackville…but look no farther than the Baggins, a Took, or a Gamgee, and you'll find hospitality at its finest." Thorin smiled warmly to himself before clearing his throat and putting on a firm, regal expression once more.
"This meeting is over. I will send word to the Thrain of the Shire immediately. We will reconvene on the matter should anything occur…in the mean time, we continue rationing as we have been." He ordered, slamming his fist on the table to mark the meetings close, and he walked off with his advisor, guard, and siblings trailing behind him.
"Thorin…are you sure about this?" Dis asked, nervously glancing over at their brother as they followed behind Thorin to his office.
"Why wouldn't I be? I…I am not running off like you always fear I will! I am simply…I am writing. To their leader, as another leader. Not as Holm…" He sighed, face contorting with frustration and sadness before he took a deep breath and shook his head. "It'd be best to never even mention Holm again to someone in the Shire…for all I know, they'd riot if they see my name. H-his name…that name. I let a lot of people down by being taken away…" He glared at his siblings only to take another deep breath and hold up his hands as he backed down from the conversation.
"I will write to the Thain. I've no doubt some sort of aid will be sent to us…Bring me Roac." Thorin spoke very clearly and in a rhythm he often used when listing things off.
"You can't seriously think to send Roac to the Shire! You'd scare the hobbits into having heart attacks before they could read the message!" Frerin scoffed, crossing his arms as he wondered if his brother were going mad, or was just become that dim.
"Maybe if the Thain was a Bunce or a Pudifoot…but the Thain is a Took, and if I know anything about the Old Took, its that the only thing to give him a heart attack would be if he was asked to give up his pipe weed." Thorin chuckled, rolling his eyes as he walked into his office. Hobbits were used to being underestimated, and perhaps it should stay that way, simply because it was always so fun to watch others be proven wrong.
Thorin rewrote the letter at least ten times before he finally had something that he thought would suffice. He'd gotten so used to speaking and writing like a dwarf (as he reminded himself that that was what he was) that it felt odd trying to speak like the hobbits did once more, while still maintaining the sound of a King of Dwarves addressing a fellow leader.
The letter was carefully contained and put into Roac's message carrier on his leg, and after Thorin fed the loyal bird some scraps they could afford to feed their loyal ravens, and a relaxing scratch under his chin, the bird was off to the Shire.
April 5th, T.A. 2938
To the esteemed Thain of the Shire,
It has been a grievous fault of mine that our people's have yet to be acquainted. I had made it one of my main objectives that once our kingdom of the Lonely Mountain was once again reclaimed, that we would strive to have better relations with all the free people of Middle Earth.
I regret that it is due to unfortunate circumstances that have moved my hand, and not something more pleasant. I wish I could send joyous tidings and speak of good will between our peoples, but I lament that time is little and food is even less.
Since our reclamation, we have striven to revive our fields…But we are not farmers, or gardeners…Our allies in the City of Dale are also unable to provide aid as their fields are also failing despite their best efforts. We are but miners, and they are but fishermen…and even though our coal can cook a fish, neither will stave off the hunger we'll face this winter.
I write to you in desperate hopes that we can form an alliance. I know of your people to be kind and generous, and I know that gold alone is not worth the efforts of your people…If you can find it in your heart to help us in our time of need, Erebor vows to forever be at your disposal for a kingdom is nothing without her people, and it is that which we stand to lose should we not find help.
Please send your reply with Roac (the raven who has delivered this to you), and if you can spare it, a cracker to fuel his travels.
May the hair on your toes never fall out, and your pantry never be empty.
Thorin Oakenshield, Son of Thrain, Son of Thror, King of The Lonely Mountain and Durin's Folk
April 10th, T.A. 2938
To His Majesty Thorin Oakenshield of The Lonely Mountain and Durin's Folk,
I will put your heart at ease now, and reassure you that the Shire will come to your aid. Our own Fell Winter still haunts our memories to this day, and to know another is struggling similarly, and asking for our help, is not something we will ignore.
I must speak with my people's representatives (Mayors and Heads of Clans), so that we may discuss how we can best be of service. By the time this letter is in your hands a plan should be well under way.
If it is doable, please send as detailed a report as you can on the current state of your food stores as well as your fields…and, if Roac is able, a sample of your soil so that our farmers can determine the best course of action. What is your population size, as well as the City of Dale's, for it'd be shameful to help you and not the other. No one should ever go hungry.
I'm aware you dwarves eat far less than we hobbits, but it is a tragedy indeed when one must skimp, be it in coin or in meals. Rest assured, help will come.
And rest assured that your lovely bird has been well fed, and is taking a nap on my favorite throw as I write this. I shall make it his official perch during our correspondence, as I should hope that after all this trouble is put behind you, that our peoples may still be allied in some fashion.
May your beard never stop growing, and your hills always be rolling. (Or should I say your mountain stand strong?)
Now and for always.
-Thain Derwen of the Shire
