Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

The Ex Factor

Summary:

Both Bilbo and Thorin receive an invitation to Bard’s New Year’s Eve party, unaware of what the night holds for them.

Work Text:

Bilbo glanced at his phone one last time, just to be sure. He hadn’t spoken to his ex in two months, but there it was—digital proof.

He had been personally invited to Bard’s New Year’s Eve celebration, a major social event in the city.

True, he had clicked the RSVP button while slightly intoxicated from too much wine at his cousin’s wedding. But once he was sober, he thought, what the hell? He and Bard had once had a lot of fun together, and Bard was a nice guy. Maybe he had had a change of heart and wanted to be friends after all.

Or maybe there was still a spark. It was worth finding out, wasn’t it?

As Bilbo recalled, they had broken up because Bard wasn’t sure what he wanted—whether in his job or his relationships. He needed time to figure things out, he’d said.

Maybe two months was enough time for that. Bilbo was about to find out.


Dis had told him this was a bad idea. She reminded him that he could do better than Bard. Thorin had been on a couple of dates since their breakup, but nothing was clicking. He couldn’t find that special connection he was searching for. Not that he’d had it with Bard, but Bard was sexy, fun to be around, and kind—a combination Thorin was having difficulty finding in the city.

So, when he received the digital invite to Bard’s big New Year’s Eve bash, he didn’t think twice about accepting it. It could be fun to hang out again. Besides, he didn’t have anything better to do.

It was a little strange that Bard hadn’t reached out before sending the invitation, but that was just how he was. He needed time—he had told Thorin that—so Thorin had given it to him. Maybe his patience was about to be rewarded.


Bard lived in a large brick home in the more prestigious part of the city. This was the first time Bilbo had ever seen it. A valet took the keys to his hybrid, and he climbed the steps to the front door, which was opened by a butler. After handing his coat to the man, Bilbo was greeted by a few familiar faces. Bard had many important contacts within the city, and this party was a way to maintain those connections.

Bilbo was out of his element and he knew it. He was just a professor at the local community college, not well-versed in cut-throat business practices. Looking back, he wondered why Bard had asked him out in the first place. They had very little in common other than the fact he had taught Bard’s daughter. Yet, Bard had always made sure Bilbo felt at ease. He was a gentleman, and those were hard to find in this city.


This was only the second time Thorin had been to Bard’s home. They had spent most of their time in Bard’s uptown apartment. It hadn’t changed much, aside from the lavish party decorations and the disapproving look from the butler at the door.

“Happy New Year, Ron,” Thorin said flippantly as he handed over his scarf and coat, fully aware that the man disliked having his name shortened from Elrond.

“Indeed,” the butler replied in his usual haughty tone as he took Thorin's belongings.

“Is Mr. Bowman expecting you?” Ron asked, his haughty tone bringing back memories. Thorin had only met him on two occasions and for some reason, he had taken an instant dislike to him.

“I have an invitation right here,” Thorin said, pulling out his phone. “Need to see it?”

“That won’t be necessary. Have a pleasant evening,” Ron replied, though the sneer accompanying his words made it clear he didn’t mean it.

Once inside, Thorin grabbed a flute of champagne and scanned the room. Important figures—celebrities, politicians, and some of the city's most lucrative business owners—milled about. Thorin had no desire to engage with them. Though he was in business himself, he wasn’t nearly as daring as Bard. Over the years, he had convinced himself that he didn’t need to be. He wasn’t chasing wealth; his family-owned business was enough for him. Most years, they kept their heads above water, and that was satisfactory.

He enjoyed his life and lifestyle just as they were, though he sometimes wished he could find someone special to share it with. Bard wasn’t that person, but for now, he was okay.


A young woman in a business suit, her hair neatly in a bun, was explaining something about yield curve inversions signaling a recession. Bilbo tried to look interested, but as an English teacher, he had no idea what she was talking about.

As she continued her monologue about economic downturns, Bilbo caught Bard’s eye. He smiled and waved, but Bard didn’t wave back. Instead, he looked astonished.

Within moments, Bard made his way over, grinning at Bilbo. “Mary, if I may interrupt, I need to speak with Bilbo regarding… unsolicited market influences.”

The woman smiled tightly and walked away. Bilbo hoped he wouldn’t have to endure another finance lecture. Bard knew the only markets Bilbo cared about were those for buying vegetables.

“What in the hell are you doing here?” Bard asked, surprising Bilbo.

Despite the grand size of the parlor, it felt crowded. Bard grabbed Bilbo's sleeve and pulled him into the quieter library. Bard still seemed annoyed.

Bilbo didn’t appreciate Bard wrinkling his favorite sports coat. He jerked his arm free and glared at him. “Because you invited me! Do you think I would crash your party? We haven’t spoken in two months!”

“Exactly!” Bard replied, looking a little thinner and more stressed than usual. “Let me see your invite.”

Bilbo thought that was a rather rude request but he pulled out his phone anyway, showing the e-invite and his confirmed RSVP.

“Thranduil,” Bard hissed quietly.

“Who’s Thranduil?”

“My boyfriend.”

Now Bilbo was confused. “If you have a boyfriend, why invite your ex to your party?”

“I didn’t!” Bard said, swiping a hand through his goatee. “I asked Thranduil to send out the e-invites, and he must’ve gone through my entire contact list.”

Oh. That was a relief. Bard wasn’t as charming as he used to be, and there definitely wasn’t a spark. The best thing Bilbo could do was leave.

“If Thranduil finds out you’re here, he’ll kill me.”

Or he could stay. This might turn out to be an entertaining evening after all!


The shrimp cocktail was lukewarm, and Thorin wasn’t a fan of caviar. The mini beef wellingtons were tasty, but he’d have to eat the entire platter to satisfy his appetite.

He should find Bard and figure out why he was invited to this soirée. Then he could leave and stop by the drive-through for a cheeseburger on his way home.

After searching unsuccessfully for Bard for several minutes, Thorin asked the bartender if he’d seen him. The bartender pointed to the library just as Bard emerged, looking slightly unnerved and disheveled—definitely not his usual self, which piqued Thorin’s curiosity.

Thorin followed Bard to the bar in the parlor, listening as he ordered a Scotch on the rocks. Thorin tapped him on the shoulder. When Bard turned and saw him, his brown eyes widened. “Thorin! What… oh my god. Did you get an e-invite as well?”

Interesting. “What do you mean ‘as well?’”

“Nothing,” Bard said, though Thorin could tell he was lying; Bard’s left eye squinted slightly. “It’s good to see you! How have you been?”

Thorin would tell him, but Bard wasn’t interested in his answer. The man kept glancing around the room, avoiding eye contact. This wasn’t the warm welcome Thorin had hoped for.

“Let me guess: I was invited by mistake. That’s not like you at all. In fact, while we were dating, I remember you saying you don’t make mistakes.”

“It wasn’t me, all right?”

This was too good. Thorin couldn’t recall Bard ever looking this worried about anything, even the prospect of a recession.

“It was Thranduil, my boyfriend. He’s the jealous type, Thorin, so if you wouldn’t mind leaving? I don’t mean to be rude, but…”

“Then don’t be,” Thorin suggested, already formulating a plan for the evening. Their breakup hadn’t been a big deal. What did it matter if Bard had already found someone else?

Who was he kidding? He had to see this “Thranduil”—he needed to know what kind of man he had been replaced by.

“I think I’ll stay and have a drink, maybe introduce myself to a few people. Good for business, you know.”

Bard’s dark brows furrowed in annoyance. “Thorin, don’t you dare.”

He wasn’t planning to do anything, but Bard didn’t need to know that.

“You’d best get back before your boyfriend gets suspicious,” Thorin suggested, earning himself another scowl.


What he needed was a strong drink, Bilbo decided as he approached the bar. He ordered a martini with extra olives and took a sip just as he noticed another man staring at him.

Wow, Bard certainly had a lot of attractive friends. This one had dark hair, a neatly trimmed beard, and the bluest eyes Bilbo had ever seen.

“Let me guess: Accountant? Analyst? Investment banker?”

The man’s voice was as smooth and sophisticated as Bilbo’s drink, but it took a moment for him to grasp the context.

“Oh no, I’m not in finance. I teach English at the community college downtown.”

That bit of information seemed to pique the man’s interest, bringing a smile to his face.

“A teacher, huh? What a worthy profession. I’m a landscaper—part owner of Oak and Shield Lawn and Garden.”

“I’ve seen your commercials!” Bilbo exclaimed. “Oak and Shield—where your dreams take root!” he sang the catchy jingle.

The man laughed, and it was one of the sexiest sounds Bilbo had ever heard.

“So neither of us is in finance,” Bilbo noted. “What on earth are we doing here?”

He meant it as a joke, but the man looked at him curiously. “I was invited through one of those e-invite things. You?”

“The same,” Bilbo replied, though he still wasn’t making the connection.

“How do you know Bard?”

It was a simple enough question—kind of like being asked at a wedding if you knew the bride or groom. “I’m a friend of the host.”

A smile crept across the man’s handsome face as he extended his hand. “Thorin Durin. And you are?”

“Bilbo Baggins.”

Once their handshake was over, Bilbo noticed Thorin had a firm grip and plenty of calluses.

“Grab your drink and follow me outside. You and I have a few things to talk about,” he said, and Bilbo didn’t hesitate.

They stepped outside just in time to escape the loud techno music that had started playing inside the house.

“Bard has the worst taste in music,” Thorin noted, grimacing.

“I’d agree with that,” Bilbo replied. “Our musical tastes can’t be more different. I prefer light jazz. Sometimes, if I’m in the mood, the blues suit me just fine.”

“Johnson or Taylor?” Thorin asked, a twinkle in his eye.

“My tastes go further back than that—James and Holiday.”

Thorin nodded and sipped his whisky sour. “The classics. I prefer them as well. Nobody has the soul that Etta had.”

“I’ll toast to that,” Bilbo said as they clinked their glasses together.

Bilbo walked over to the wrought iron balustrade and looked out at a winter garden still adorned with twinkling Christmas lights. It was chilly, and he wished he had grabbed his coat, but before they went back inside, he had a question for Thorin.

“You didn’t tell me how you know Bard. Business acquaintance?”

Thorin’s eyes reflected the holiday lights, creating a mesmerizing effect. “We dated,” he said, jolting Bilbo awake.

“What? Are you kidding?”

“Nope. We broke up a couple of months ago. I got this invite out of the blue, and well…”

Bilbo started laughing; he couldn’t help it. “What a small world! I wanted to come mainly because I was curious. I haven’t spoken to him since we broke up—two months ago,” he explained.

“That jackass. He told me we were exclusive.”

“Same here,” Bilbo replied. “And he hated labels. We were just ‘friends with benefits.”

“He didn’t hesitate to call this new guy ‘boyfriend,’” Thorin brought up.

“I heard that,” Bilbo said with a sly smile as his mind began to stir with all sorts of mischievous ideas. “Want to have some fun?”

Thorin looked skeptical. “Only if nobody gets their feelings hurt. Even though Bard lied to me, he’s a decent guy. I don’t want to hurt him.”

What an admirable quality, Bilbo thought, looking at Thorin in a new light. “We won’t embarrass him. I was thinking more about his new boyfriend.”

“Oh, I see,” Thorin replied, a wicked grin forming. “That’s different. What do you have in mind?”


They decided to turn their search for Thranduil into a game. Since neither of them knew what he looked like, it would make Bard a little nervous while giving them a chance to meet new people.

There were plenty of guests—at least 200 in the parlor alone, with two more rooms to explore.

As they sipped on their drinks, they speculated about what Thranduil might look like based on Bard’s preferences. So far, Bard seemed to be the perfect host, moving from group to group and room to room. No one appeared to be accompanying him.

“I believe Bard prefers refined types like yourself,” Bilbo told Thorin.

“And handsome, like you,” Thorin added, bringing a blush to Bilbo’s face.

“Thank you,” he said. “Kindness is a given, and you just proved that. Although I do wonder…”

“If we have any idea what we’re looking for since he broke up with both of us?”

Bilbo was pleasantly surprised. Thorin had read his mind. “Exactly,” he said. “We might have no idea what Thranduil looks like.”

“Just makes the search more interesting,” Thorin suggested.

“And more complicated,” Which should affect the reward, I think. How about dinner tomorrow night at The Anvil?”

“That’s my favorite place,” Thorin admitted. “It’s a deal. Loser pays.”

“All right,” Bilbo agreed, sealing it with a handshake. Thorin used both hands and held on a little longer than necessary, looking at Bilbo in a way that made his toes curl inside his suede shoes.

Eventually, Thorin released his grip, and Bilbo nervously glanced around the room. “‘Ground rules,’” he suggested. “You can’t ask Bard directly, and you can’t say the man’s name.”

Thorin chuckled and ran his fingers through his short beard. “As if it wasn’t tough enough already! Okay. I’ll start in the foyer if you’d like to begin in here.”

“Good luck,” Bilbo called after Thorin, wondering if he had gone too far. Maybe he should have suggested they stay together and work in the same room, just to keep an eye on him. Not that he didn’t trust him, but Thorin was certainly nice to look at. No wonder Bard had dated him.


“Hey,” Bilbo said to the first person who caught his eye—an older man with kind brown eyes and slicked-back white hair. He was short and a bit on the chubby side. “My name is Bilbo Baggins.”

The man shook his hand and smiled. “Balin Fundin. Are you in finance, my boy?”

“No, not me,” Bilbo replied. “I’m an English teacher. I’m here by invitation from the host and his partner, although I’ve already forgotten his name. I was going to thank them for inviting me, but I didn’t want to embarrass myself.”

“Oh, I see. A little young to have memory problems, aren’t you?” the older man chuckled. “I believe Mr. Bowman’s partner is Mr. Rivers. They’re quite savvy in business.”

That made sense. He could see Bard settling down with someone he had a lot in common with—someone different from Bilbo.

“Would you mind pointing him out to me? Mr. Rivers, I mean. I know Bard, but I haven’t had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Rivers.”

“Of course! That would be him right over there, flirting with his secretary, Miss Knight. These young men don’t know how to act these days. Back in my day, such things weren’t so blatantly obvious.”

Bilbo followed Balin’s gaze and saw exactly what he had described. The attractive young woman was flirting and obviously intoxicated, leaning on Mr. Rivers and laughing loudly.

There was one problem with this scene: Bard wouldn’t date someone interested in women, and he definitely wouldn’t date someone who would flirt and take advantage of someone inebriated.

Bilbo turned back to Mr. Fundin with an apologetic smile. “I’m sorry. I think you misunderstood me. I believe Mr. Rivers is Thorin’s business partner, am I right?”

“Why, yes, of course! What other partner were you referring to?”

When he told Thorin this was going to be a challenge, he wasn’t kidding! Why had he added those rules? “A more personal kind?” Bilbo explained. “Like dating—or possibly living with.”

“Oh! You should’ve said so! Leaving out specific details causes confusion, my friend. But I’m afraid I can’t help you. Mr. Bowman is a private man and keeps his personal matters to himself. Do you need help with anything else?”

“No, thank you. It was nice meeting you,” Bilbo said as he ducked away, searching for the next possibility.
Honestly, there were plenty of good-looking men here, but most of them were dressed in business suits, with young women or men hanging on their arms. There were a few single ones, but most seemed too old for Bard. At least he thought so. Maybe he didn’t know Bard as well as he thought.

Damn. This wasn’t going to be easy. He wondered how well Thorin was doing.


“Thorin Durin, as I live and breathe.”

Thorin spun around to greet none other than an old college buddy. “Gloin, you old rascal! What are you doing here?”

“Ah, my tiny little tech company designed an app that uses data analytics to provide tailored financial strategies. It caught Mr. Bowman’s attention, and the rest is history. We recently moved shop to the city after our stocks skyrocketed. How about you? Still cutting grass?”

Like most of his friends, Gloin loved to poke fun at him, but he meant no harm. “Yep. Still running the mower. I’m here on a personal invitation.”

“Huh,” Gloin said, his eyes twinkling suspiciously. “Look me up sometime, and we’ll have a drink. I’d like to hear more about this personal invitation.”

“I’m sure you would,” Thorin chuckled. “I’ll see you later. I’m looking for someone—maybe you can help me. Would you happen to know what Th…”

Thorin stopped himself just before he said Thranduil’s name. He didn’t want to break the rules.

“Let me rephrase that,” he said. “You wouldn’t happen to know what the man looks like who Bard is currently dating, would you? I’d like to meet him.”

“To size him up. Check out the competition. I get it.”

“No, no,” Thorin hurriedly explained. “It’s not like that. I dated Bard a while back, but I’m not interested in him anymore. Just call me curious.”

“Uh-huh,” Gloin replied skeptically. “I’m afraid I know you better than that. Wish I could help you, but I wasn’t aware Mr. Bowman was dating anyone.”


Bilbo slipped away from Balin, feeling a mix of determination and frustration. He scanned the room, hoping to find someone who could shed light on the elusive Thranduil.

As he moved through the crowd, he spotted a tall figure with a striking presence, deep auburn hair cascading over broad shoulders. His sharp features were accentuated by the soft lighting, and Bilbo felt a flicker of hope.

“Excuse me,” Bilbo approached the man, who was chatting animatedly with a small group. “I’m looking for someone who might be connected to Bard. Do you know of anyone he’s… involved with?”

The man turned, a curious glint in his eyes. “Are you referring to his recent partner? I believe he's quite the catch.”

Bilbo nodded eagerly and decided to take a risk. “Yes! I’ve heard he’s very charming and has a flair for the dramatic.”

The man chuckled. “That sounds like him. He has a distinctive style—very elegant, and he carries himself with a certain… regal air.”

Bilbo’s heart raced. This could be the lead he needed. “Regal, you say? Interesting. Would you happen to know where I might find him?”

“Last I saw, he was near the bar. But be careful; he has quite the adoring fan club.” The man winked before turning back to his friends.

“Thank you!” Bilbo called out, determination fueling his steps toward the bar.


Thorin was grappling with his own challenge. He spotted Gloin again, chatting with another acquaintance. Thorin approached, hoping to pick up any hints about the man he was looking for.

“Thorin,” Gloin turned to tell him quietly. “I’ve been doing some espionage – discreetly, of course. Haven’t had a whole lot of time, but I did overhear someone mention that Bard’s partner has a penchant for the dramatic and a taste for the finer things in life.”

Thorin’s interest piqued. “Finer things, you say? Like what?”

“Clothing, art, the usual. And he’s got a reputation for being quite the charmer,” Gloin replied with a smirk. “You should probably keep your distance since you’re just curious.”

Thorin felt a twinge of annoyance. “I’m not looking to compete, Gloin. Just trying to understand Bard’s choices.”

“Sure, sure. Just remember, curiosity can lead to trouble,” Gloin said, clapping Thorin on the shoulder before wandering off.


As Bilbo reached the bar, he noticed a group of people gathered around a striking figure. He pushed through the crowd, his heart racing. There he was—a tall, man with long, blonde hair, elegant features, and an air of confidence that drew attention. He was wearing a shimmering silver suit complete with a hot pink boa around his shoulders and a silver tiara on top of his head. This had to be Thranduil.

Taking a deep breath, Bilbo leaned closer to catch the conversation. He heard snippets about a recent gallery opening and the latest fashion trends. The man’s laughter was melodic, and Bilbo felt an inexplicable pull. But could he really approach him?

Before he could decide, Bilbo spotted Thorin across the room, his gaze fixed on the same figure. They exchanged a glance, and an unspoken agreement passed between them. They were in this together.

Bilbo raised his glass, signaling Thorin to join him. As Thorin navigated through the crowd, Bilbo felt a wave of excitement. They were about to make their move, but they had to be clever. The rules of their little game loomed large in Bilbo’s mind.

“Remember,” Bilbo whispered to Thorin as he arrived, “no names. We have to be discreet.”

Thorin nodded, his expression serious.

With a shared determination, they approached the group, ready to unravel the mystery of Bard’s enigmatic partner.

 

“Honestly, it’s about time someone recognized true talent,” the blonde declared, his eyes glinting with self-satisfaction. “I mean, can you even imagine the chaos if I weren’t here to bring a touch of elegance to this place?”

One of his admirers chimed in, “You’re absolutely right,Thranduil! ! No one else could pull off this look like you do!”

“Exactly!” Thranduil replied, waving a dismissive hand. “And let’s not forget my impeccable taste. The rest of them simply can’t compete. I’m practically a trendsetter. It’s exhausting, really, having to maintain such high standards.”

Another fan gushed, “You should have your own fashion show! The world needs to see you!”

Thranduil laughed, a rich, self-indulgent sound. “Oh, darling, I’m already an international sensation. A show would just be a formality. But I appreciate the thought. You know, it takes a certain kind of brilliance to shine this brightly.”

His admirers nodded eagerly, hanging on his every word, unaware that their hero's true charm lay in his overwhelming self-absorption.

Bilbo stepped back hiding what he couldn’t decide was a giggle or a gag behind his hand. Thorin’s mouth was gaped open and his eyes were wide.

“That’s Thranduil?” he mouthed before Bilbo pulled him into the deserted library.

They had both spotted Thranduil at the same moment—a figure strutting about with an air of arrogance that made them roll their eyes in unison.

“Honestly, he’s insufferable,” Bilbo said, a smirk on his face.

“Let Bard have him,” Thorin replied with a chuckle. “They deserve each other.”

The two exchanged knowing glances, both silently agreeing that they deserved better than someone so pretentious.

“I guess I don’t get it,” Bilbo admitted. “After dating someone like you, that is who he picks?”

“To each their own,” Thorin said quietly, his eyes fixed on Bilbo’s. “Bard made a huge mistake by choosing Thranduil over you. I mean, look at you! You’re a snappy dresser; you’re smart, kind, fun to be with, and handsome.”

“And what about you? You own your own successful business, you look really good in that blue sweater, and your eyes sparkle when you smile.”

Just to prove it, Thorin smiled and Bilbo’s heart tripped.

“He’d be lucky to have you,” Bilbo said.

“I could say the same thing about you,” Thorin told him.

And then voices began chanting. It was the countdown to welcome the new year. When the crowd shouted zero and started cheering, Bilbo smiled again.

“Happy New Year, Thorin.”

“Happy New Year, Bilbo.”

Years later, they would argue about what happened next. Each swore that the other one had initiated it, but some type of unseen force brought them together; their lips meeting in a soft, tentative kiss. It felt right, a perfect end to their evening’s adventures.

“Want to get out of here?” Thorin asked as he drew Bilbo closer. “I know of the perfect burger place that’s open all night.”

“Bombur’s? Don’t you just love their spicy…”

“Pineapple and jalapeno cheeseburger,” Thorin finished. “It’s my favorite.”

“I’d love to but we’re still on for dinner at The Anchor tomorrow night, right? And since we saw Thranduil at the same time, we can split the bill.”

“I’m not so sure about that. I think I saw him first, but we can talk about that in the morning over breakfast.”

“You’re buying me breakfast?” Bilbo asked, growing a little confused.

“Sort of,” Thorin explained. “I bought the ingredients and I’ll be making it in my apartment…”

“In your apart…” Bilbo repeated until someone turned on the light. “Oh,” he said before he started thinking about what the rest of their night held. “Oh! Yes, of course. I’d love to argue with you over breakfast, lunch, dinner. Whatever.”

“Good,” Thorin said while taking his hand to lead him out. “You should know that arguing with you isn’t at all what I have in mind.”

Bilbo swallowed his heart back down and thanked his lucky stars. “Then perhaps we should skip the cheeseburger.”

Thorin’s smile was flirtatious. “I was hoping you’d say that.”

Series this work belongs to: