Chapter Text
THE RECORDING BOOTH - LATE AFTERNOON
(*The mood has shifted. THORIN's cravat is slightly askew, BILBO's hair more tousled than usual. Both men are looking at their scripts, avoiding eye contact.*)
DIRECTOR: Right, this is the pivotal scene. James has received the blackmail letter, and Marcus has just announced his engagement to Lady Elizabeth. Remember, it's 1924 - they have everything to lose.
BILBO: (*unusually serious*) Yeah, got it. (*swallows*) Heavy stuff.
THORIN: (*softly*) Indeed. Shall we?
DIRECTOR: From "I had to see you one last time."
THORIN: (*in character, his voice rich with emotion*) Marcus turns, seeing James in the doorway. "I had to see you one last time. Before the announcement in The Times."
BILBO: (*in character, his usual cheekiness gone*) "Congratulations. Lady Elizabeth is... she's everything a man could want."
(*Their eyes meet briefly, then quickly away*)
THORIN: "James, I..." (*his voice catches, surprisingly genuine*) "You must understand. The letters, the threats. My family name, everything my father built..."
BILBO: (*moving closer to his microphone, voice low and intense*) "Do you love her?"
THORIN: (*pause, then brokenly*) "What I feel doesn't matter anymore. It can't."
DIRECTOR: (*quietly*) Good. Now James moves closer.
(*BILBO shifts, accidentally brushing against THORIN. Both men startle slightly.*)
BILBO: (*in character, but his voice rougher than usual*) "What we had... what we are... it's not some filthy secret. It's not wrong."
THORIN: (*his hand gripping the script tightly*) "No. But it is dangerous. Peterson made that quite clear in his letter. And now with you shipping out to India… What we had cannot continue, should not continue."
BILBO: (*breaking character*) Sorry, quick question - would he really be so direct? Given the times?
DIRECTOR: Good point. Let's take it back, make it more coded.
THORIN: (*professionally*) Perhaps something like... "What we... shared. During the war and after. It sustained me. But now..."
BILBO: (*nodding*) Yeah, that works. (*back in character*) "The war taught us life was short. Too short for lies."
THORIN: "And yet here we are, telling the biggest lie of all." (*His voice cracks slightly*)
(*There's a moment of genuine tension in the booth*)
DIRECTOR: Now the stage direction reads: "Their hands brush one last time."
(*Both men look at their hands, remembering their own recent encounter*)
BILBO: (*almost whispering*) "I report to Southampton next week. The Regiment ships out on Tuesday."
THORIN: "Elizabeth wants a June wedding. White roses everywhere, apparently."
BILBO: (*with a sad laugh*) "We survived the Somme. Surely we can survive this."
THORIN: (*reaching out, then stopping himself*) "Can we? Sometimes I think the trenches were easier. At least there, we could..."
DIRECTOR: (*softly*) Good. Now James turns to leave.
BILBO: "I should go. Give Lady Elizabeth my... best wishes."
THORIN: (*voice full of restrained emotion*) "James, I... (*swallows*) Farewell."
(*There's a heavy silence in the booth*)
DIRECTOR: (*after a moment*) That was... that was really good, guys. Let's take five.
(*As they remove their headphones, both men seem lost in thought*)
BILBO: (*attempting his usual lightness*) Well, that was a bit of a mood killer, wasn't it?
THORIN: (*quietly*) Art imitating life, I suppose.
BILBO: (*looking at him*) Yeah, except... we're not in 1924.
THORIN: (*small smile*) No. No, we're not.
DIRECTOR: (*through intercom*) Sorry to interrupt the moment, but... Bilbo, your phone's been buzzing and the producer just send me a message. Something about your podcast trending?
BILBO: (*not looking away from THORIN*) Let it trend.
(*Thorin’s phone starts suddenly buzzing furiously in his pocket, breaking the mood. He goes outside for a conversation while BILBO takes the time to check his own phone, that was inside his jacket, hanging on a peg on the wall. When THORIN returns, he’s fuming, and BILBO has gone very pale.*)
THORIN: (*barely contained anger in his voice*) Could you come outside for a private conversation, Mr. Baggins?
