Chapter Text
The idea to build Thorin a cane came swiftly, and, like most good ideas, began with an opening of doors.
Bilbo stepped into the library, the heavy stone panels grinding shut behind him, their echo rolling across the dark walls until it dissolved within its depths. Cool air brushed against his cheeks, carrying the familiar smell of old parchment and ink. Dozens of dwarves bustled in front of him, muttering and rustling stacks of papers as they ambled from shelf to desk to shelf again.
No matter how many times Bilbo had walked through its entrance, the magnitude and magnificence of the atrium never ceased to amaze him. Veins of glowing crystals leaked soft, warm light from the roof, catching the fires of lamps and candles, and scattering across the well-trodden rock floors. Bookshelves towered above him like giants of old, their spines carved into the glittering stone of the mountain itself. Hundreds of years of knowledge, art and stories whispered around him, bound in leather, worn but loved, and stretched long into the distance until they were swallowed whole.
Even if he wore his very finest magnifying glasses, Bilbo doubted he could glimpse where the library ended from where he stood.
The Arkenstone was the heart of the mountain, according to the legends. To Bilbo, however, it paled in comparison to the hum and beating of this place. The library was alive beneath his feet, as though the mountain itself breathed here. Slow, deep and eternal.
He exhaled and drank up the sight. He would marry this great room in a heartbeat if he could, and if a certain, inconvenient dwarf didn’t have an iron grip over his heart.
Bilbo navigated between the winding tables and chairs, muttering a litany of pardon, excuse me, coming through, as Dwarves walked directly in front of him, with seemingly no spatial awareness or thought spared for the hobbit they almost trampled in the process. Not a single apology was given, an annoying trait of dwarves he’d come to expect, but at least a few voices called out cheerful good mornings, the occasional how are you Master Baggins, and a fond took you long enough to get yourself back here.
It was a gruelling affair that mercifully ended when he found Ori, perched at his desk, ink staining the hems of his sleeves. Yellowed papers and old diagrams were scattered before him, his quill hovering above the page. Ori’s complaints and groans sounded from the table, and it didn’t take Bilbo long to identify the source of such nuisance.
He was not alone.
Fíli lounged against the edge of the desk, boots crossed at the ankles and a grin tugging at his mouth as his brother leaned over Ori’s shoulder with far too much interest. Kíli sniggered as he pointed at a set of inscriptions and had his hand smacked away by the young scribe.
Bilbo coughed and raised his brows.
“Apologies gentlemen, it seems I’m interrupting your harassment of poor Ori.”
“Harassment! That’s hardly fair.”
“No! We would never do such a thing. Would we Fíli?”
“Absolutely not, Kíli.”
“Never.”
“Cross our hearts.”
“Hope to die.”
“Well, I wouldn’t go that far now.”
“I would,” Kíli said, a glint in his eye that Bilbo knew could only spell trouble. He clamped a hand down on Ori’s shoulder, who groaned and shook his head at Bilbo. “Considering we were just helping our dearest brother in arms pass the time.”
“It gets awfully-"
“Enough of that,” Bilbo cut Fíli off with a wave of his hand, “Here I was thinking that you both had better things to do with your time than pestering dwarves hard at work! Such as, oh I don’t know, healing? Resting enough to keep your mother from chasing you back to bed like misbehaving faunts? Hm?”
The brothers exchanged a brief, conspiratorial glance. Bilbo could practically see the gears turning in their heads. He pressed a hand to his temple, feeling the familiar mix of exasperation and fondness that came with their company. They were bright boys, charismatic, and far too clever for their own good. The chaos they left in their wake was nothing short of exhausting but, the Took-ish part of his mind rather unhelpfully supplied, entertaining. In its own way.
Fíli stretched and rolled on the balls of his feet, patting Ori softly on the back as he stepped away from the desk. Ori sighed in relief and shot Bilbo a grateful smile, before hunching back over the parchments and scribbling furiously once more.
Bilbo’s eyes softened as he watched the young scribe working diligently. It had been nothing short of a pleasure to work alongside him as they had toiled over the hundreds of scrolls, books and stacks of parchment that had been scattered and damaged during Smaug’s reign. It was a miracle they had managed to restore as much as they did over the last six months, but the work was far from over.
Every morning, they had found themselves wading through a sea of paper, each one demanding attention. There was a quiet rhythm to his and Ori’s work, and he found himself grateful for the unspoken understandings they shared as they laboured long into the night, working their way through documents and biscuits with an equal tenacity. Conversation came easy to them, and Bilbo was thrilled to share his knowledge of the Shire with someone who listened with hungry curiosity.
The moment of quiet was cut short by Fíli’s voice, breaking in with a teasing edge.
“You should know by now,” Fíli said, a single eyebrow raised, “that resting isn’t really in our blood.”
“Not at all,” Kíli agreed, pulling himself upwards and lowering his voice in mock solemnity. His shoulders straightened, hands behind his back, and twisted his face until it mimicked an exaggerated, but eerily familiar, royal scowl. “Rest is those who would let the mountain crumble. We must rebuild Erebor back to its former glory. Every stone in place. Every hall strong. Duty calls… and we must answer!”
The quill’s rustling stilled as Ori lifted a hand to his mouth and stifled a surprised snort. Fíli chortled and shook his head. Bilbo doubted that the Kíli’s impression was new to him. He could see them as children, skidding through halls, Kíli mimicking his uncle’s stern words as Fíli laughed himself senseless. The image settled in his mind like a warm blanket.
The fond feeling did not last. He shook his head and, not for the first time today, damned the obstinacy of his Dwarven company.
“Don’t even joke about that.” Bilbo said dryly, running a hand through his curls. The words he exchanged with Thorin the previous evening still pressed on him, and he struggled to push the irritation aside. “Your uncle has given me enough strife to last a lifetime.”
That earned him a knowing look from Fíli. Really, he shouldn’t underestimate how perceptive the young prince was.
“Let me guess, still arguing about his leg?”
Bilbo huffed. “Arguing implies there were two willing participants. I, very diplomatically may I add, recommended that he accept help before he grinds his bones to dust. He promised he would consider it, but I wouldn’t hold my breath.”
“He said that to Dwalin too,” Kíli rolled his eyes, “Right before nearly faceplanting down the eastern steps.”
“Oh, aye,” Fíli replied easily, “Thank Mahal he caught himself on the railing, or we’d have a very Kingly shaped dent in the floor.”
Bilbo’s mouth went dry and his heart fluttered. He was too old to be dealing with such nonsense. However, where stubborn, martyring kings were involved, it seems that the well of foolishness would never run dry.
One day, Bilbo was certain, Thorin’s pride would leave him unceremoniously sprawled on that blasted floor.
He was brought back to their conversation from the previous evening. The clatter of the cane against stone and the way relief crossed Thorin’s face for a heartbeat as he sat. Oh, he was infuriating, there was no question of that, but Bilbo was not a fool enough to deny how his blood thumped in his ears when Thorin met his gaze across the soft firelight. He had drunk in the sight of his thick black hair, unbraided, spilling across his rising chest as he breathed, soft and deep. The warmth that radiated from the dwarf’s skin was steady, and carried with it the rich scent of iron, smoke and something so undeniably Thorin that it had caught Bilbo’s breath in his throat.
The rest of the magnificent chambers had already faded from his, rather strong, memory. Bilbo couldn’t recall the tapestries or stones clearly, not even the colour of the armchairs they had sat so achingly close together on. All he could remember were the hard lines of Thorin’s body, and the brief flickers of uncertainty that breached the stone mask of his face at mention of his injury.
Bilbo had wanted to reach out then and find the magic sentences that would make him listen to reason, if they even existed. He would offer some small comfort, a careful hand, a loving word, anything to soften the weight that swam in the blue depths of his eyes. However, the moments slipped past like smoke through his fingers. As quickly as the shift in Thorin’s expression had come, it had been replaced by the familiar firmness that guarded more than just his foot.
Did he want to slap some sense into Thorin or, damn the consequences, kiss that maddening look off his face? Bilbo didn’t know. Honestly? He wasn’t sure he could feel one without the other as of late.
Bilbo turned his attention back to the three dwarves ahead of him. Ori had placed his quill down and turned his full attention to their conversation. There was a thoughtful expression on his face, Ori’s brows were furrowed and he bit his lip. Bilbo recognised that look. He had seen it many times as they shared tea while passing a particularly confounding document back and forth.
“All Uncle’s talk about rebuilding and duty is well and good,” Fíli cut in as he lightly stroked his beard, “We’ve tried reasoning with him, but he’s as stubborn as a mountain troll. You should’ve seen the grief Amad gave him. If that didn’t scare him into taking the cane, I don’t know what will.”
Kíli nodded emphatically, “Aye, I’d rather face down a hundred orcs than endure that. I would probably have a better chance of surviving them.” A grin broke across his face, but Bilbo saw a heaviness in Kíli’s eyes as he continued, “He won’t take it. The cane, I mean. Ego is the real Durin’s Bane if you ask me.”
“M-maybe if we present it carefully…not as a reprimand, but as something that may…” Ori cleared his throat, soft and earnest, “show that we care? I could draft a note and the whole company could sign?”
A soft smile tugged at Bilbo’s lips.
“That’s a good idea, Ori.”
The young dwarf beamed at the compliment, but his expression faltered as Bilbo sighed, “However, we’ve already tried sincerity. It doesn’t get us much further than the scolding, to be perfectly honest.”
The silence settled between them, thick and uncomfortable. Bilbo shifted on his feet and coughed, determined to fill the space between them before Ori burst into a polite panic, or Fíli begun pacing like a caged bear. The latter a very annoying habit he seemed to have picked up from his uncle.
“Honestly lads, I’m a wind’s whisper from making a cane of my own and forging it right into his hand. Good luck discarding it then!”
There was a brief pause, without the humour Bilbo expected. Kíli’s amusement faded into something more measured as he tilted his head, considering Bilbo’s words.
“You know, Master Boggins…” He said at last, “that’s not too bad of a plan.”
Bilbo looked at him incredulously, so stunned he didn’t bother to correct the mispronunciation of his name, for the hundredth time or so. He doubted it would’ve helped anyway. Kíli knew his name, of that Bilbo was certain, but took a particular delight in needling him.
“Kíli, I understand how futile it seems to change your uncle’s mind, but I like to think we don’t need to resort to maiming him further!”
“No, Bilbo,” Fíli stepped forwards, exchanging a glance with his brother. Bilbo’s eyes narrowed. That look could only mean trouble. “What my brother means is that you should craft him a cane. Balin mentioned that the one he was given used to belong to our great-grandfather, as if this mess didn’t have emotional baggage enough.”
Before Bilbo could fully wrap his head around the idea, a small thrill bubbled in his chest at the thought of Thorin’s calloused hand grasped around something he created. His heart skipped a beat, and he promptly scolded his own foolishness. This was a practicality, a sensible solution to an ongoing problem.
Across from him, Fíli’s expression softened, briefly, before it was gone. He exchanged a look with Kíli that lingered a fraction too long to be coincidence. Neither of them spoke, but something had passed between them all the same.
Bilbo saw it, registered it and deliberately set it aside. Why? He wasn’t sure.
He retreated into the safer comfort of measurements and materials, where thoughts were ordered and feelings could be ignored. At least, for now.
“Honestly Bilbo,” Kíli said, his voice soft but certain, drawing him out of his reverie. “He’ll take it if it’s made for him. He’ll always use what someone has crafted, no matter how, well…shit. I made him a hair bead when I was a pebble, I could barely reach the work bench! It’s hideous, a disgrace to Dwarven craftsmanship, but he wore it religiously. Still does.”
Bilbo blinked, caught somewhere between laughter and disbelief. He couldn’t keep himself from smiling, imagining a tiny, lopsided bead dangling proudly from Thorin’s meticulously fashioned hair. The image made his heart thump a little faster, part admiration, part fond exasperation. Only dwarves could treasure something so absurd without word of it. Only that dwarf could wear a childhood folly as a point of familial pride.
Kíli caught his shock and laughed.
“Our amad has a matching one. You should have seen Tauriel’s face when she showed her.” He grimaced, but his eyes were soft and an unmistakable blush warmed his cheeks like a lovesick faunt. “She won’t quit poking fun at me, although I probably deserve it.”
“You definitely deserve it. I’m just glad I’m not the only one trying to keep you in line,” Fíli threw an arm over his brother’s shoulder, and was awarded with an elbow to the gut. He turned his attention back to Bilbo, “We’ll help you make it. Kíli and I are jewellers by craft. We’ll make sure it is a point of envy for all dwarves under the mountain.”
Bilbo’s mind buzzed with tiny, meticulous details. He looked away to avoid the brothers’ expectant stares as he felt a hot flush creeping up the base of his spine and pool in his chest. The weight of the wood, the curve of the handle, the polish of a metallic tip. He imagined Thorin’s soft sigh, a noise that slipped passed his lips whenever he was caught off-guard. His fingers brushing over the woodwork, firm and sure.
Warmth coloured his cheeks. He loosened the collar of his shirt, fingers twitching as though they had a mind of their own.
“Well,” Bilbo said finally, forcing his voice into something resembling composure, “I suppose it is better than threatening him with bodily harm.”
It’s a sensible solution, Bilbo told himself again. He should not overdo it; just a sensible solution for an ongoing problem. Sensible solution. Ongoing problem.
He weighed his next words carefully and almost wished he could smoke in the library. It would do wonders for his racing thoughts.
He breathed out. “If we are going to do this properly, I suppose I should start thinking about the design. It must be practical, functional but not too…” Bilbo’s throat tightened as he searched for the right words, “…imposing.”
It would be a delicate balance. Bilbo doubted Thorin would want a cane that drew too much attention to itself, but it would have to be well-crafted. Well-loved. A design that would not yell, but whisper all the unspoken devotion that lingered around him in steady pulses.
Ori blinked, fiddling with his quill, cheeks warming as he averted his gaze. He opened his mouth, voice barely above a whisper, “Well, yes, but traditionally a gift such as-”
“Not now, Ori.” Fíli cut him off with a wink and jovial smirk, his tone light, and it earned himself a squawk from the scribe, “Let us enjoy the plan. We’ll hammer out all the pesky details later.”
“Yeah, don’t you worry that pretty head of yours, Ori!” Kíli smiled, moving away from the desk and towards Bilbo. Head thrown back in a laugh, he clutched the hobbit around the shoulders and practically shepherded him towards the doors.
Fíli jogged to catch up with them and, before Bilbo could fully register what was happening, stood on the other side, guiding him along as well.
“Now, now, hang on a moment lads!” Bilbo dug his heels into the ground and threw off their hands. He folded his arms and turned back to the scribe, who was watching intently with raised eyebrows. “As much as I am looking forward to our creative endeavour, I’m not leaving poor Ori alone with a mountain of work. Not while I go trapezing off on a half-baked project!”
“It’s urgent family business Master Boggins!” Kíli insisted, already reaching back for Bilbo’s elbow. “We can’t have the King limping around the castle like a kicked puppy!”
“We cannot waste a moment!” Fíli said briskly, moving back to his other side. “There are plenty fine dwarves here to help Ori out.”
Bilbo shot Ori a look. Ori coloured, fingers tightening around his quill. He offered a small, apologetic smile; half-flustered, half-amused, and entirely more willing than he was letting on. Ori gave him an awkward thumbs-up and insisted he would be just fine.
Well. That was Bilbo’s last defence. He turned back to the princes, who were beaming.
“Those tiny hands of yours won’t be missed too much.” Kíli added cheerfully, giving him a gentle but determined nudge forward.
“The library will still be standing here tomorrow.” Fíli steered him another step towards the grand doors, his fingers a warm weight on Bilbo’s shoulders.
Despite all the fussing, he felt like he was being dragged off to battle. Heat pooled in his ears. He felt both utterly unprepared and eager at once and the tension made his pulse stutter with every breath.
“We won’t keep you from the glorious smell of mildew and rotting paper for long!”
“Cross our hearts.”
“Hope to die, and all that.” Kíli finished, flashing Bilbo an irreverent smile as they pressed on, he and his brother’s laughs echoing off the stone walls.
Resistance was futile. Previous experience with the prince’s antics had taught him that much. Bilbo huffed as he was manhandled out of the great doors.
· · ─ ·✶· ─ · ·
Grief leads all down many wide, twisting roads. Yet, no matter the path chosen, they all seem to take its travellers to one same, inevitable end.
Thorin had searched the halls for Dís for the last hour, his frustration rising and thrumming in his chest with every unanswered question and dead end. Every dwarf he’d asked claimed to have no recollection of her whereabouts, insisting that they had not seen her all morning. Even Balin had been unsure, and for as long as Thorin had known him, he’d always possessed an uncanny sense of where everyone was and exactly how they were occupying their time.
It was only after he cornered Fíli and Kíli, catching them as they chuckled to each other on their way to the library, that he realised the truth. As for why they were heading to the library, Thorin did not know, and he doubted it would be for anything as important as study or diligence.
Yet, as they admitted their ignorance of their mother’s location, Thorin found he no longer cared about whatever mischief they were bound to be up to. It could wait.
There was only one place Dís would go without informing her healing sons on where to find her.
He had delayed that room long enough. He should’ve gone sooner. Weeks ago, perhaps months.
Thorin caught the fleeting glance between his sister-sons before he sighed heavily and spun in the opposite direction. They yelled after him as he walked, but he held up a hand, warning them not to follow. Their calls quietened, and he heard them turn and march back on their original path.
Trouble. Thorin was sure. He would have to ask the Master Scribe later about whatever antics his sister-sons were no doubt up to.
He had known it was going to be a bad day from the moment he had first opened his eyes. Sleep had come fitfully, each turn and toss a reminder of his foot and the ache that radiated through his body. It’d pulsed and throbbed with every heartbeat, following him into his dreams and leaving him weary before the day had even begun.
Rising from his bed had been an ordeal. His joints had protested with sharp, grinding aches, his muscles as tight as iron bands. The first mistake had been to pull himself up in one, swift movement, pushing both feet onto the ice-cold floor.
A sudden, seething pain had shot through his foot, a white-hot knife that’d sliced from his ankles and into his knee. His vision had blurred. Nausea had risen from the pits of his stomach and squeezed at his side. He’d gripped his mattress for support as he’d doubled over. Head between his knees. Breathing in slow, steady gasps.
The second mistake was to cry out.
His eyes were screwed shut when he’d heard the guards, good dwarves by the names of Damil and Táli, fling the door to his chambers open and scramble by his bedside. Thorin had gritted his teeth, tasting the metallic tang of iron in his mouth. Anger had flared hotter than the pain itself. They were only trying to assist, he had known. However, their presence was an intrusion. He would not, could not, be seen like this.
He felt a twinge of guilt as he recalled how he’d bellowed at them to get out. Pain, humiliation and fury had roared in his chest, thrashing against one another with no heed for reason. His fingers had dug into the bedpost as Damil and Táli leapt back and slammed the door on their way out. The throbbing in his foot had spread like dragon-fire across his flesh, up his bones until each pulse hammered against his ribs.
Thorin had wanted nothing more than to be left alone and nurse his injury in uneasy quiet. It was not meant to be. He’d waited by his bedside for the seething in his leg to spit and burn, until it had faded into a dull ache that he could manage. The pounding of his head had receded back into his skull, and the muscles of his back had loosened once the worst was over.
White knuckled faded to pink as the pain had ebbed. He had sighed, long and heavy. Without the throbbing heartbeat in his ears, the oppressive silence of his chambers had wrapped tightly around him. The only relief was the gentle scent of the lavender tea he had left out from the previous night. It’s sweet, floral smell had wafted into his nose and brought back memories of a kind hand resting against his arm. Round, warm eyes meeting his own.
It’d grounded him. He’d breathed in deeply again and stood, tall as he could. The fresh, morning air had pressed cool against the sweat that slicked to his forehead.
He’d bathed and dressed without indulgence. Careful with every movement.
Now, alone in these twisting halls, regret gnawed at him. Less for his display of hysterics than for the loyal dwarves he had expelled. Damil and Táli were white as sheets when he’d emerged from his rooms, and they’d kept their eyes planted firmly on the floor. Thorin had sighed, dismissed them, and had hoped that his offer of open access to the kegs of ale in the dinner halls were apology enough.
Both guards had bowed deeply and marched away, clearly keen to be around the other corridor as quickly as their dignity would allow.
Dwalin would not be pleased that he’d let them go. However, he would survive it.
Thorin shook the memory of the morning away and pressed forward.
For the first time since he’d been pulled from the battle, he walked the halls alone. Each step a dull echo of what he once took for granted. Thorin let the sounds of the present draw him on; the soft hum of the markets outside, the rhythmic chants of the forges below, as his mind narrowed on two things. Dís and, he sighed softly to himself, the room he knew he would find her in.
Frerin’s old chambers.
A chill traced the length of his spine as Thorin reached the entrance. Wide, brown doors stood before him, its shadow melted over the length of his boots. A draft seeped from under it, and he shivered at its cool touch on the warm, exposed skin of his face. With it was the faint, musty smell of stone untouched, old books and… pipeweed?
Thorin’s brows wrinkled. He squinted and sniffed. There was no question of it. Rich, earthy and smoky, a scent he knew Dís favoured.
There was a sharp breath taken on the other side of the door. A shuffle, another breath, drawn and held, like dust settling.
“Dís. It’s me,” his knuckles rapped on the door, before he added uselessly, “let me in.”
The doors cracked open, soft lamplight spilled out into the darkened corridor. This wing was mercifully empty, so they stood in the quiet together. Two pairs of icy, blue eyes staring intently at one another from beneath matching, thick brows.
Dís stepped forward slowly, strands of black hair falling loose from her braids. A neat, cropped beard similar to his own framed her jawline, dark against pale skin.
“Finally learnt how to knock, did you?” Her voice was teasing, but edged with steel, her lips quirked in a half smile. She didn’t suffer fools lightly. “Took you long enough to come here.”
“You should not be smoking in there.”
Dís waved her hand dismissively, “Frerin and I used to share a pipe in his room all the time. It wasn’t us that torched the mountain to smithereens.”
Thorin grunted and shook his head. He didn’t know that. However, he wasn’t surprised. Her sons’ penchant for mischief was not contributed solely by their father’s side of the family, and both his siblings had been as thick as thieves before…
Well…before.
A cold fist gripped Thorin’s heart as he stepped through the doors, passing his sister. He surveyed the room in one long movement. Dust motes danced in the warm light before sinking, slowly and steadily, to the floor. The old, oak furniture was grey with disuse, the wide bed made neat with absence. Discoloured papers, curling at the edges, lay scattered across Frerin’s desk, untouched since the day they’d fled. Half-melted candles lined the wood, and the shelves, their wax hardened in pale drips with wicks dark and unlit.
“Were you looking for me?” Dís’ voice snapped him from his thoughts.
“I needed an appraisal on the dispute between the jewellers’ and goldsmith’s guilds but…” He trailed off, the words caught in his throat.
“It doesn’t seem that important now.”
Thorin shook his head and wrapped his fingers around the desk chair. It was cold to the touch. He sighed, and lowered himself carefully, stretching out his injured leg before sinking into the seat.
Dís caught the movement and raised an eyebrow. He felt his eyes harden.
Not now. The bitterness of their previous argument about his leg still raw in his mind. The bruise on his bicep tender from where she’d launched a plate at him.
Dís nodded reluctantly and drew in another breath from her pipe. Smoke curled from her lips like a familiar shadow as she breathed out a long, deep sigh. The wood groaned when she sat on the made bed, taking the fabric of Frerin’s old blankets between her fingers and pulling it onto her lap. Despite everything that had changed, all the roads they’d trekked side by side, she was still herself.
Sometimes, when Thorin blinked, it wasn’t the hardened, battle-ready dwarrowdam that stood before him, but a small, stubborn pebble in messy braids, shaking her fists at the sun when she did not want it to set.
“I…I was not ready to see it yet.” Thorin admitted in a low voice before pressing his lips together in a firm line. The stone walls focused sharply into view. “Not after all this time.”
“No one’s ever ready.” She said softly, flicking the ash into a small bowl nestled by her side. “It still has to be done.”
Thorin screwed his eyes shut and tried to remember his brother’s voice. It had faded over the years, slipping through his fingers like crusher dust. Deeper in some memories, higher pitched in others, never quite the same twice. The shape of his laughter was easier to remember, how easily it had filled a room like water in a well.
“He would’ve teased you for all that brooding,” Dís stood up and sat on the floor to his side, resting an easy hand atop his own, “Used to say that you only did it to look important.”
He scoffed, almost amused, but pressed his other hand over their now laced fingers. Dís gripped tight and stared firmly at the wall.
“Yes.” Thorin said quietly. “That sounds like him.”
The minutes ticked by as they sat together in silence. A weight settled over them, sombre and aching. It was interrupted only by the soft clouds of smoke that Dís breathed out into the dark, that melted back into the shadows.
“If you need a smile, brother, open the top drawer,” Dís broke the troubled quiet and pointed at the desk, a new light twinkling in her eyes.
"No…Oh Mahal.” For the first time in weeks, Thorin barked out a laugh. The feeling of it was warm in his chest. He let go of his sister’s hands. Deft fingers clutched the drawer and pulled open, revealing stacks of hidden papers. One by one, he pulled them out, stroking each piece as if to feel where Frerin had touched them all those years ago.
“He always was a romantic. Never any good as a poet though.” Dís pulled herself up and peered over his shoulder. “Terrible penmanship too.”
Frerin’s writing bordered on illegible, runes looped and caved in on themselves, each one scratched impatiently onto the paper. He could see his brother bent over the desk with ink-stained fingers, grumbling at each messy margin and breathing a sigh of satisfaction when he felt the words land correctly.
Thorin let the pages tremble between his fingers, and for a moment he considered tucking them back into place, unread.
Yet his eyes moved anyway.
He read in a horrified silence. A heat crept up the back of his neck.
-Her heart beats like an anvil struck,
Her eyes burn like the forges at dawn,
It wounds to stare, and yet I must
Her love is wrapped in a thick, iron crust.-
Thorin stopped breathing midway through the stanza. A faint smile tugged at his lips, despite the thick waves of second-hand embarrassment that ran through him.
The rhythm was passable, but the rhymes were forced like ill-fitting armour. A memory pushed forth from the back of his mind. A baker’s daughter. Frerin had tucked poetry for her under loaves of bread. Insistent it would win her over, that the lines sounded better when read aloud.
He had not thought of his brother’s poor poetry in a long time. A warmth flooded his chest as he recalled his brother as a passionate, misguided youth, and not as a body, stone cold and alone in a tomb.
-Her love is wrapped in a thick, iron crust.-
“Comparing her to a defensive shell,” Thorin murmured, pointing the line out to Dís, “A bold strategy.”
She let out a strangled noise and covered her mouth, cheeks flaming red. “Is it meant to be flattering?”
“I believe it was supposed to be reverent.”
Another set of lines caught his eye.
-Yet if I aim, and strike it right,
She may see where I belong tonight.-
The heat behind his eyes surprised him. Thorin blinked rapidly and smiled.
Frerin always did strike first. There was no chance too small, no love too unlikely, to make him step down. Once upon a time, he’d called it foolishness. Now, reading the tremors between the lines, it felt unfair that he’d had such courage so young, and that it had not survived him in the songs.
“Why is he comparing himself to a hammer?” Thorin asked quietly and shook his head, “Why was it always a hammer?”
“Mahal, he was insufferable in his thirties. Remember when he ‘fell in love’ with three different ‘dams in one year?” Dís’ laughter echoed through the chamber. She pressed a hand against his forearm, and he was grateful for the strength behind it. She quietened, and her tone became gentler, “I’d bet good gold he’s fuming in stone, knowing that we got to meet our Ones before him.”
Our Ones.
Thorin’s fingers stilled at the edge of the desk. He tucked the papers back into the drawer and closed it softly.
The words sunk between them, heavy as iron.
Bilbo.
His traitorous mind supplied the name, and the ghost of Bilbo’s fingers on his wrist. The firelight that shone against his locks as bright and beautiful as sunrise over the mountains. He pictured the careful tilt of Bilbo’s head when he listened, the embers of his eyes when frustrated. The hot air that breathed past his lips as he huffed, rolling his eyes at any one of the litanies of Dwarven habits that caused him irritation. Silver-tongued, eagle-eyed, tentative holder of a smile that burned brighter than the heart of the mountain.
Thorin gripped the desk so hard that the wood bit into his palms. He loosened his fingers slowly, afraid that the room could fracture if he moved to fast.
Dís did not look at him. Her gaze passed over his shoulder to where the shadows pooled thickest in the corner of the room.
“Our Ones,” she repeated softly, as if testing how the words sounded when released from her throat.
“You say that with certainty.” Thorin said, carefully neutral. His spine straightened. “As if you know where my heart lies. You do not.”
Steel flashed in Dís’ eyes as she turned back to him. She shook her head, her expression calming, as she took another deep breath from her pipe. They watched as the smoke twisted in the air.
“My One is dead.” Dís said simply, without flourish or expectation of pity. It was a fact, and spoken as though she were summarising ledgers, or reading from a report. “He rests in stone, stolen from me too soon. Brother, I know a heart’s ruthlessness more intimately than you could ever imagine.”
A hollow ache stirred in his chest. Dís wore an almost unreadable mask, save for the growing redness of her eyes. He muttered an apology for his presumption and she squeezed his shoulder. The slight was forgotten as quickly as it was made. A rare occurrence for them, he acknowledged, but he was grateful for it in this moment.
Without thinking, Thorin’s hand drifted to the inside of his robes. He clutched a familiar weight, its surface worn smooth by the restless press of his thumb. He stilled at once, his breath catching in his throat, as if the box were his beating heart.
Dís noticed. Of course she did.
At first, she said nothing. She waited, her eyes following his movement, until the silence stretched thin between them.
“You’ve been carrying something.” Dís said finally, her voice brimming with expectation.
“It is nothing.”
“You’ve never been good at nothing.”
There was no purpose in hiding it any further. His sister was more akin to a war-pig hunting blood than a dwarf when she desired answers. The box, humble and a deep Durin blue, was pulled from his pockets. He gently removed the lid to reveal a silver bead. A winding river of sapphire curled around the delicate piece; diamond fragments caught in the lamplight and sparkled like a hundred tiny stars. Runes were etched onto either side, carved slowly, lovingly,
“Oh,” Dís breathed, recognition settling into the furrowed lines of her brow.
“You’re not as useless as I assumed. Well done.” Dís said as she peered closer, silver sparkles reflected in her widened eyes. “It’s beautiful.”
Thorin’s grip tightened reflexively as he snapped the lid shut. “He does not know of it.” He tucked the box back into his pocket, “He will not. Not yet.”
A small satisfaction tugged in Thorin’s chest as she took a step back and nodded, deep in thought.
They’d grown old together. He was there when she first breathed against stone, and she would be there as they closed rock over his tomb. Time and experience had stripped them of the ability to be truly surprised by one another, or at least, so he had thought. Yet now, in the quiet of Frerin’s old room, Thorin was cognizant of something new stirring between them. A pride, perhaps, or hands reaching through what once was a veil of misunderstanding.
She knew what it was to love. She knew what it was to lose. All of this, Thorin had known in his mind beforehand. Not in his heart. Not until now.
The courtship bead in his pocket felt heavier.
“When?” Dís asked, an eyebrow quirked.
For a moment, he did not speak. The question lay heavily in his thoughts and was one he had pondered himself for many weeks.
“I…cannot yet.” Thorin’s voice was tight, each word scraped against his throat. “There is too much between us to fix before he can accept it. Words and actions I cannot take back. Trust that I shattered.”
“Then the mending must start. Now.” The candlelight flickered as she took a half-step towards him and pressed her forehead lightly against Thorin’s own. The warmth of her touch released the tension in his shoulders, and the unforgiving throb in his leg faded into the soft recesses of his consciousness. Walls pulled back into focus, the ground became steady beneath him, and for the first time he thought of Bilbo without the guilt. Or the pain.
Just the simple pleasure of his company.
No words were exchanged. Brother and sister breathed in tandem, chests rising and falling together. Thorin let the silence of the room, still heavy with Frerin’s memory and dust, settle into his bones.
“I would give every jewel under the mountain to have one more day with Víli,” Dís murmured, her forehead still pressed against him. “Do not waste what Mahal has given you.”
Thorin closed his eyes and let the warmth press in further. A gentle ache in his heart lingered but did not burn. His hand twitched and slipped into his pocket and fussed the bead between his fingers. The thought of it braided within Bilbo’s fine hair made his heart flutter.
It would take time. Time well-spent.
Thorin withdrew first and sighed. He wanted to thank Dís, but the words did not form. Instead, he nodded and pulled himself up off the chair. Thorin hissed as he settled his weight evenly on both legs, but bowed low to his sister anyway. The coolness of the floor radiated against his nose.
“I shall see it done.” He stood up straight, his posture remained rigid and controlled. “As I must.”
Dís gave him a small, knowing nod. She drew in one last breath from her pipe before tucking it, and the ash bowl, under her arm. “Take care of yourself brother, in heart and in body.”
A flicker of irritation sparked behind Thorin’s eyes at the admonition, but he crushed it quickly. His jaw tightened. His hands fell neatly at his side. One pulse of annoyance, and then it was gone, swallowed by the room, the shadows and the quiet. An echo of a smile tugged at his lips as he glanced once more at the bed, the desk, the carpet, the books and all those papers scattered, documented with too short a lifetime and words.
With a steadied breath he gripped the doorknob and stepped out.
· · ─ ·✶· ─ · ·
It was not difficult to find Bilbo.
If one lost a hobbit, he need only search for him in a handful of places. The first, where the chairs are comfortable and warm, the second where the books might as well sing sweet songs, the third where the food is hearty and aplenty, and the fourth…
Where the grass grows green and strong.
Bilbo sat on a patchwork blanket, stretched over one of the few places with fertile soil in the mountain. A book perched precariously on his knees, a plate of honey cakes by his side. Crumbs dusted the top of his deep blue waistcoat with each bite, immersed in the page before him. Thorin allowed himself a moment to observe the hobbit greedily, absorbing the sight of his small, precise movements.
He leant against the stone arch that separated the halls and modest garden, his crown clinking against the rock. It was one of the few places in Erebor that broke open onto the mountain’s surface. Paper-thin snowflakes fluttered downwards, and one landed on Bilbo’s bare feet. He doubted it was noticed; snow tipped the hobbit’s toes without shudder.
He watched a while and smiled as Bilbo wrinkled his nose and huffed at what was, he presumed, a particularly frustrating page. If duty demanded nothing of him, he would’ve come here hours ago. If only to watch the hobbit’s chest rise and fall as he read.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin said in a breath, treading onto the grass and careful not to startle him. Leaves crunched beneath his boots anyway and harmonised with the soft psithurism of the breeze. He was gentle with every step, taking inventory of every strain seizing in his leg. Gritting his teeth, he pushed the pain down and looked upon the sight that made the march up the boundless stairs worth every ache.
A kindly wind was tangled in Bilbo’s hair, each lock catching light like finely spun gold. It carried with it the rich fragrance of the watered earth and dew drops. The air was cool, freezing the sweat to his forehead. He pulled his belt tight against his crimson robe.
He wondered if Bilbo was cold. Dwarves ran hot, after all, like an ever-burning forge.
“Sit down, you great lump. If you stare at me any longer, I think I’ll turn to stone.”
He had been staring, hadn’t he?
Heat crawled up the back of Thorin’s neck as he coughed and settled on the blanket opposite Bilbo. Relief seeped into his bones as he pulled the weight off his foot. His shoulders loosened.
“Are you warm?” Thorin asked.
“Quite cosy, thank you. Like sitting by a fire with a mug of tea.” As if to emphasise his point, Bilbo pulled his thick, woollen robe close to his chest and shivered. He smiled, but it faded as quickly as it came. Bilbo’s eyes flickered to his outstretched leg.
“Are you in pain?”
“No.”
“Hmph.” Bilbo arched an eyebrow, turning back to his book. He grumbled under his breath, words Thorin was almost certain he did not want to hear. What he wouldn’t give to smooth the crease of concern from his brow, but the words to do so caught in his throat. At a later date, perhaps. Amends must be made, and he could not deviate from them.
No matter the dread running cold through his blood.
The breeze shifted, stirring the edges of Bilbo’s robes and Thorin imagined the weight of the hobbit pressed against his side. The soft comfort of his hand in his. Snow drifted around them; the wind carried a snowflake into the thick curls of Bilbo’s lashes.
It was time.
“My foot is of no consequence,” Thorin said. “You need not concern yourself with it.”
Bilbo snapped to attention and placed the book firmly on the blanket.
Thorin held up his hand. A deep breath. Bilbo paused and cursed under his breath.
“There is something else.” Thorin continued, ignoring the muttering. His gaze fell to the ground. “Something that I have needed to address far sooner than I have done.”
Bilbo stilled. His eyes widened, meeting him with an intensity that made his body heat.
The moment on the embankment, his fingers drowning in gold, clutching at Bilbo’s waistcoat as he threatened his life. Guilt poured through him, deep within his guts. Shoulders hunched. His jaw tightened.
“On the ramparts.” Thorin said through gritted teeth, “I placed you in great danger. You were afraid and had every reason to be.”
He drew a deep breath and pushed forward. “A King who cannot master himself is a threat to all those he rules. To those closest to himself, most of all. There is no greater shame.”
“I already forgave you Thorin. You know this.” Bilbo’s voice was quiet and his face shifted. Solemness masked his usually expressive features. His hands stilled at his side.
“As I was dying. Words to comfort the departing on their way to the Great Halls.” The air grew taut between them; the silence was thicker than the snow. Thorin shook his head and moved uncomfortably. Heat pricked behind his eyes. He blinked it away quickly. This moment was not about him, nor his guilt, well-deserved as it was. The only thing of importance was ahead of him, watching him closely, holding his breath.
Thorin continued.
“For as long as I live, I swear, I will never forget your strength on Ravenhill. To forgive the unforgivable. If only so that I may have passed from this life in peace.” It was a kindness he could only imagine coming from Bilbo. A reserve of strength that kept the hobbit standing tall. A bravery he had failed to see for too long.
Bilbo turned his head, his expression softening.
“You came back, Thorin. To your people, to the Company, to…” A breath escaped his lips, “To me. That mattered more than what came before.”
The sun began to set behind them. Golden light flittered through the dappled leaves of the tree above them, and spilled through the parapet, landing at their feet. A raven’s cry pierced the quiet between them. The call echoed across the stone walls.
Bilbo stirred, a slight shadow of thought disturbing his expression. Thorin studied him as he placed his hands in his pockets and stared over the wall. His heartbeat throbbed in his head.
“I did. I am glad for it, but…” Thorin said, words thick as lead. “You were afraid. There are no words to express the deep regret I have for inspiring such a feeling in you.”
Bilbo regarded him quietly, steady and unflinching.
“I was afraid, yes. It’s difficult not to be rather petrified when your feet are dangling from halfway up a mountain.” Thorin winced as Bilbo spoke again, “but then again, I seem to have made a habit of surviving things that, in all reason, ought to have finished me off.”
His voice lowered to a whisper, but he looked over Thorin’s shoulder.
“I didn’t fall. You didn’t drop me. A rousing success all around, if you ask me.” His nose twitched, as if chasing a thought. Before Thorin could inquire about the contents of his mind, Bilbo shook his head. “That fear, Thorin, it didn’t matter as much as your courage that came after it.”
“No, Master Baggins, your fear was important. More so.” Thorin swallowed, his throat raw, “I never wished your fear to be outweighed. Only undone.”
A sad smile graced Bilbo’s mouth. He picked up a piece of honey cake and nibbled at the corner, his mind wandering again, expression intent but composed.
“I’m afraid that isn’t how it works. Not for me, not for hobbits, or anyone for that matter, I suspect.” He placed the cake down and pulled a handkerchief from his pockets to wipe his fingers. Old habits die hard, Thorin understood, and he suspected he knew that better than most.
“And that brings me to why I am here now.” Thorin spoke with a quiet gravity. At least, it was a reason amongst others; others he dared not voice, weighed down as he was with regret. He pushed those thoughts aside. “I am not here as a King. My only desire is to earn back your faith; I do not wish to live without it.”
I cannot live without it. The unsaid words hung between them.
He studied Bilbo’s face, searching for a response that could reveal his ambling thoughts. Betrayal, a righteous anger, or worse, a sadness. There was nothing but a weary acceptance, and a spark that he dared not try and name.
“And how do you plan on doing that?”
“I swear here upon all the tombs of my line that you shall never suffer by my doing again.” Thorin answered quickly. Unlike most of their conversation thus far, this was a question he had expected. The answer was one of deep consideration and had already been heard, and accepted, by Balin. “If my closest companions suspect me felled to dragon-sickness, I step down without hesitation. I relinquish all gold and cursed finery. If necessity demands it, I turn my back from the mountain and find healing in the same destitution faced by my people.”
Bilbo paused and peered at him quizzically. “I have one more condition.”
“Name it.”
“You should avoid heights. At least, for the rest of the year. I don’t want to see you brooding on the rampant, getting dark and terrible ideas whenever the Guilds test your patience.”
Thorin smiled, despite himself. Despite the shame. Despite the intensity of his thoughts buckling down on his crowned head. A breath escaped his lips, almost a laugh, and he looked ahead of him, meeting Bilbo's unyielding gaze.
“If those are your terms, Master Baggins, then I accept whole-heartedly.”
Bilbo shifted and moved to the other end of the blanket, stopping at his side. Thorin inhaled at the closeness, the smell of lavender oil and parchment rolling off the hobbit in waves. The courtship bead burned into his side. He wanted to caress it, feel the cool metal against his flushed body. Draw strength from it, to combat the lightness of his head and the ache of his leg that stalked him, even in the most important of moments.
Bilbo touched his shoulder, his palm caressing the lining of Thorin’s robes. Thorin felt his muscles loosen into the hold and shuddered. He could not banish the memory of Bilbo pressed up against the rampants, of his own voice, hoarse and unrecognisable, his shadow across the hobbit like a death sentence already passed. The terror in Bilbo's eyes, and the vicious rocks glinting below in cold, white light.
Despite it all, hot air filled the space between them, dampening the frost that clung to their clothes.
“I already forgave you Thorin, because I felt you were forgiven.” Bilbo said softly. “For no reason less or more.”
“Master Baggins, I-”
“It’s Bilbo.”
Thorin frowned, caught off guard. He exhaled and tilted his head.
“What?”
“Bilbo, Thorin. My name is Bilbo. I rather think we’ve been through enough to be on a first name basis, wouldn’t you say?” Mischief twinkled in the soft haze of Bilbo’s eyes. Fingers playfully squeezed his shoulder before retreating. The loss of touch was felt quickly. Thorin stiffened as Bilbo folded his arms, a defiant gesture, and waited for a reply.
There was only one that could be given.
“Aye,” Thorin breathed, a fondness heavying his heart. He sighed. “I suppose we have.”
“Now say it.”
“What?”
“My name.”
Another pause. The raven above twirled in the sky, cutting black against the gold of the setting sun. Snow floated down, falling in little patches next to their blanket and onto rock. The winds of the mountain huffed around them, as the bird landed on branches above, feet dancing on the wood before it settled.
Their shadows stretched onto the grass, pulled tight against the deep oranges and pinks of the sunlight, until their darkened silhouettes moulded into one shape against the stone wall. The clicking of the raven’s claws drew Thorin’s attention, and he noted the curve of its head and the light glowing through its feathers. The cold lost its bite; the dying sun was warm against his face. The scent of pinecones and damp stone huddled close, grounding him. Even the distant murmur of Laketown quietened, as though its population waited with bated breath and stilled legs.
Thorin shifted his focus to Bilbo once more. Small, steady and very much alive. His face was flushed, the thick wool of his coat pressed against his cheeks. The crumbs were still there on his shirt, disregarded and forgotten. He smiled, and his chest tightened. Stubborn, fussy and beautiful creature, who had survived far more than he, more than any of them, had any right to expect. Yet, there he was. Hot to the touch, his skin only an inch from his own.
Even the raven, above, whose mind lingered on matters of no importance to their Dwarven kin, seemed to hold the moment in a quiet, understanding regard.
When Mahal called him to stone, Thorin knew this would be the vision he recalled during his final breaths. He would not have it another way.
“Bilbo.” His voice was reverent, as though the name were a precious gem held tenderly in his grasp. The hobbit shivered, Thorin presumed from the fading cold. For a heartbeat, they lingered, breathing in the nearness of each other. Bilbo’s lips curled, triumphant and warm. A quiet laugh bubbling free. Thorin felt it snug against his chest, like sun on stone, valuable beyond measure.
“Now that wasn’t so hard, was it?” Bilbo was entirely too pleased with himself.
“It was not.” He conceded, a careful smile softening the hard lines of his face. Concern melted from Bilbo’s face, and he exhaled; satisfied, Thorin guessed, with his work.
Ahead of him, Bilbo straightened the edges with deliberate care. He cleared his throat and leaned back.
“So,” Bilbo said at last, the gentle, knowing grin spreading, “do you accept my forgiveness so we can finally move on from all that mess?”
“I do.” Thorin grasped the hobbits hands between his own and pressed their foreheads together before his mind could catch up to his body. Bilbo let out a short sound of surprise at the sudden motion, but soon stilled, and held his breath. Thorin dared not glance at the Hobbit’s reaction. He had betrayed too much.
He leant into the moment anyway.
The pain in his leg throbbed faintly, a reminder of every dragging step taken to be here. He swallowed, intent on memorising the flush of Bilbo’s heat against his skin and the rhythm of his breathing, chest rising and falling so achingly close to his own. He seared every detail, the soft curve of his shoulders, the warmth of his scent, the ruffle of his waistcoat, into his memory.
Thorin then spoke gently, but clung to every word, as though the care he gave each syllable contained a promise within itself. Pulled from the depths of his chest and released in the most devoted of voices.
“Once again, Bilbo, I am in your debt. This time, and at every moment forthcoming, I will live in a way that proves it.”
The sun dipped below the horizon. Thorin pulled away, and found himself in awe of the hobbit’s lips, ajar in surprise, and the pink that flecked across his cheekbones. He held unspoken words in their midst and tucked them protectively between his heart and lungs.
Guilt weighed heavy in his chest, and like the pain through his leg, he suspected it always would. Beneath it though, Thorin allowed himself to accept a cautious thread of hope, that what he had broken in sickness could be rebuilt. Regrown. That it could carved into something even more.
The silence spoke for him, dense and unbroken, better at carrying meaning that he was.
Thorin looked up towards the darkened sky and smiled softly at the emerging starlight. Bilbo followed his gaze and, without looking away from the night, gently grasped his forearm, fingertips grazing the fabric of his coat. The touch was light, tentative, and Thorin let it be. The moment between them felt fragile, as if the smallest motion may shatter it, and send them falling back to their good senses.
Thorin closed his eyes and realised, for the first time in what felt like a millennium, that he did not dread the coming dawn.
