Chapter Text
The ride out of Ravenhill was uncharacteristically quiet. While there were plenty of noises being made, they mostly came in the form of grunts and growls—primarily from Dwalin and Dori. Bofur, still too drunk to grasp the situation, could barely stay in his saddle. Bilbo felt a sense of responsibility for their early departure and rode alongside him, thinking that if Bofur leaned too dangerously to one side, he might be able to help keep him upright.
Thorin, on the other hand, was completely silent. There were times during their travels when he would become sullen and withdrawn, but Bilbo usually knew how to draw him out with questions about animal sounds he’d heard or the tracks they encountered. Tonight, however, Thorin ignored all of Bilbo’s attempts to initiate a conversation.
After making sure Bofur was as stable as he could be in his condition, Bilbo tugged on the reins, slowing Rose down to ride next to Dwalin. “What’s his problem?” he mumbled. “Why are we riding in the dark?”
There had only been one other time when Thorin insisted they ride through the night, trying to outrun a storm that had come up quickly from the South. They had managed to do so but paid the price the next day with quick tempers from lack of sleep.
Bilbo glanced back at Bofur who looked like he had fallen asleep. His body was slumped forward against his horse’s neck. “Is he going to be okay like that?” he asked Dwalin, who only grunted in reply.
“What’s wrong with everybody? Why in the hell are we traveling in the dark?” Bilbo pressed.
“Listen,” Dwalin said, reaching out to grab Bilbo’s reins and pull Rose to a stop. “You’re causing more problems than you realize. When we finally get to the ranch, I suggest you contact the school that hired you and see if it’s not too late to go work there. I think that would be best for everyone.”
Dwalin’s words were unexpected and hurtful, and Bilbo felt his ire begin to rise. “Just in case you’ve forgotten, I was forced into this little adventure! I didn’t choose to come!”
“Exactly!” Dwalin shouted. “I figure anyone else in your position would’ve fought back or tried to escape! But not you! Nobody’s as nice as you are—especially to Thorin. Just what kind of game are you playing?”
What? Was that an accusation that Bilbo was being too nice on purpose?
“I am who I am. I’m not putting on any airs, as you people call it,” he replied quietly.
“There, right there for example,” Dwalin said, pointing a finger at Bilbo. “You keep saying things like ‘you people’ or ‘you lot’—as if you think you’re better than us.”
“I most certainly—” Bilbo began to deny, but Dwalin cut him off.
“You think you’re smarter than us too. Just because we sit on the back of a horse and chase cattle doesn’t mean we don’t know anything. I see more than you think, and I believe you knew exactly what you were doing when you went upstairs with that little blonde tart. If this is your way of hurting him, you’re doing a helluva job.”
“Hurting? Hurting who?” Bilbo shouted, flustered and annoyed by allegations he didn’t understand. One thing he did grasp and dislike was the man calling Maggie a tart, and he shared that feeling with Dwalin.
“All right then, I’ll say it like it is,” Dwalin said through clenched teeth, leaning toward Bilbo. “Just like all the other girls at the Dusty Spur – She. Is. A. Whore.”
That was an unkind thing to say even though it was the truth. Bilbo wasn’t ignorant of Maggie’s line of work, but the way Dwalin said it made it sound even worse. If Dwalin was trying to get under his skin, he’d succeeded, and if Bilbo were a violent man, he might have done something about it. But as it turned out, he didn’t need to.
The moon hanging high in the night sky, outlined a shadow emerging from the darkness, swift and determined. With a forceful shove, someone knocked Dwalin off his horse, sending him sprawling onto the dusty ground. Bilbo's heart raced as he recognized the familiar silhouette of Thorin, the brim of his black hat barely concealing the fury in his eyes.
Dwalin, taken by surprise, rolled to his feet, his face flushed with anger. "What the hell was that for?" he barked, wiping dust from his face. But Thorin was already upon him, fists flying.
"You crossed a line," Thorin growled, landing a solid punch to Dwalin's jaw. The sound of knuckles meeting flesh echoed in the stillness of the night, drawing the attention of Dori and waking Bofur from his intoxicated slumber.
Dwalin retaliated, his fist connecting with Thorin's ribs, causing him to grunt in pain. "I was just speaking the truth! That girl ain't no better than—"
Thorin cut him off, grappling Dwalin and pushing him against the trunk of a tree. "You don’t get to talk about her like that! Not when Bilbo cares for her," he shouted, the passion in his voice rising as he struggled to maintain control.
Bilbo stood frozen, caught between concern for both men. He knew Dwalin’s words had been reckless, but Thorin’s fierce defense of Maggie revealed a loyalty that surprised him. The two men continued to exchange blows, each punch fueled by a mix of anger, frustration, and the weight of something unspoken.
Dwalin, realizing he was losing ground, twisted free from Thorin’s grasp and aimed another punch, but Thorin ducked just in time, the fist whistling past his ear.
"Enough!" Thorin shouted, his voice breaking through the tension. "Apologize to Bilbo!”
“Yeah, right,” Dwalin huffed, spitting blood-stained saliva onto the ground before heading for his horse. “I’ll do that as soon as you tell him the truth.”
“Truth?” Bilbo repeated, perplexed – first by Dwalin’s angry outburst, then by Thorin’s attack of his friend. This couldn’t all be due to the weariness of the road. They’d been tired before and nobody had acted like this! “What truth?” he asked Thorin pointedly, only to be ignored yet again.
“We’ll camp here,” Thorin announced, returning to Blue to lead her over to the trees where she would be tied for the night. Bilbo watched him in silent confusion as he removed his saddle and then crept off into the woods.
Hastily, Bilbo tied up Rose and followed him. He wasn’t sure where Thorin had gone, but when the sounds of his own footsteps on the forest floor ceased, Bilbo could make out the gentle trickle of water nearby. A creek, he thought, and he headed in that direction, feeling pleased with his improved navigation when he found Thorin kneeling by the water, splashing some on his face.
“Thorin,” Bilbo called, noticing the immediate tension in the man’s shoulders.
Was he the cause of that? What had he done to make Thorin so anxious? Not long ago, they had been riding together, exchanging stories and laughing. There had been some tense moments, but there had also been plenty of good ones as well. Bilbo had grown accustomed to being teased, though not by Thorin. For some reason, the man never made fun of him. In fact, he seemed to… respect him. When and why had that changed?
When Thorin didn’t respond, Bilbo approached the water’s edge and knelt beside him. Only then did he notice the gash on Thorin’s lip and the blood oozing from it.
“Oh my,” he said, concern flooding his voice. “Here. Wait just a second.” He fished a handkerchief from his jacket pocket, dipped a corner into the cold creek water, and gently dabbed at the cut, staining the white fabric.
In the moonlight, Thorin’s eyes appeared dark and luminous – quite mesmerizing. Bilbo felt as if he could get lost in them—the moving water reflecting in their depths. But then Thorin’s hand gripped Bilbo’s, halting his ministrations.
“What?” Bilbo asked, his voice a little deeper than usual. “Your lip is bleeding. Let me help…”
“I don’t need your help, Bilbo,” Thorin replied quietly. “I don’t… want your help.”
Those words struck Bilbo's heart like an Orchani arrow, nearly knocking the wind out of him. Embarrassed, he rinsed his handkerchief in the creek and stood, straightening his waistcoat and jacket.
“Yes, well. I was just being a good friend. And thank you for… whatever that was back there. I don’t know what came over Dwalin. Do you?”
Thorin’s gaze shifted to the water, where it remained, and his silence forced Bilbo to face a hard truth. Whatever they had shared—whether friendship or something deeper—had somehow been irreparably damaged. It didn’t matter whose fault it was; he couldn’t shake the feeling that he had lost something important.
“Good night, Thorin,” Bilbo said as he turned to make his way back to camp, which proved far more difficult than finding the creek. Without the water to guide him, he wasn’t sure which direction to take.
The moon was straight overhead, making it hard to judge which way was west. He tried to follow the trail he had clumsily made while following Thorin, but he could only make out a few broken sticks, which could have been caused by any number of creatures such as bears.
Bears. They’d only seen a few since entering Montana, but they were large and they were out there, and Bilbo was starting to feel anxious. With every snap of a twig or rustle of a leaf, his heart raced and he whispered the names of his companions. They should have a campfire going by now, but there was no light to be seen. In fact, everything was cast in shadow as clouds had moved over the moon.
That’s why the sound of an arrow being pulled taut over a bowstring took him by surprise. In the darkness, he could barely make out the outline of three white horses standing before him, before a deep voice sent a chill racing down his spine.
“Ish Katan. Niman oto.”
The world spun as Bilbo felt the impact—a sharp pain radiating through his skull. He stumbled backward, disoriented, and before he could regain his footing, darkness enveloped him.
