Actions

Work Header

The Unkindly West

Chapter Text

Bilbo supposed he had waited too long to speak up, but judging by the smug expression on Dis’s face, he felt no urgency.

The woman was on the move, sliding a gloved finger along the backs of the benches and across the low, foldable wooden tables in front of them.

“This town has been waiting for a teacher for so long; you have no idea,” she said, while Bilbo’s mind continued to whirl. “I imagine they would offer you anything you desire if you asked, but that’s not your way, is it? You seem to prioritize others over yourself. That will be quite an unusual perspective to add to our family.”

“The Durins have always been driven by a desire for wealth. It’s why Father dragged us all out here in the first place. Everyone came—even distant relatives—because Father painted the West as a fertile land just waiting to be settled, promising rich soil and abundant resources. We were such a selfish lot, eager to seize the opportunity. Dreams of wealth in cattle and sprawling, elegant homes in wide-open spaces filled our heads.

“Everyone sold everything they had and moved out here with him. They traveled by wagon, and it took a long time to find the place Father deemed perfect.

“It was about a week before the attacks began. I was just a young girl and didn’t understand why some of our men were disappearing or why the cattle were being killed or stolen.

“Despite the growing dangers, Father was stubborn and determined to stay. He built the ranch, and we made a home as he had promised, but sickness stripped away our joy. Mother contracted scarlet fever and died within months of the last plank being placed on the bunkhouse.

“After her death, Father wasn’t the same. He became increasingly difficult to live with and work for—always angry, and prone to bouts of paranoia and grief. Thorin probably got along with him better than I did, but I had to find a way out. So, I married a man who worked at the livery stable in Lonely Mountain on the Idaho side. Father had a conniption when he discovered that Vili wasn’t rich and didn’t aspire to be. He was happy, and he was everything I wanted—perhaps because he wasn’t a Durin.

“I moved away from the ranch and settled in town, gave birth to Fili, and Father never came to see him. Thorin visited far more often than I would have liked, especially after I had my second child, Kili. We were a happy family, and Thorin was a doting uncle.

“Then the fences started going up, which enraged both local ranchers and the natives. Thorin insisted they were necessary to prevent the loss of so many cattle. The Orchani disagreed and began cutting down the wires as soon as they were put up.

“No one knows exactly what happened, but one day, Father didn’t come home. He had been out on his horse checking the fences and was found a few days later in a gully on our property, an Orchani arrow lodged in his back.

“Thorin went to the sheriff and convinced him to form a posse. For some reason, despite my pleas, Vili insisted on joining them. Perhaps he thought he was showing loyalty to my family by avenging my father’s death. I don’t know why he went; all I know is that he didn’t come back.

“I was furious for a long time and wanted nothing to do with the ranch or my family. But then I realized I had two young boys to feed and no source of income. Do you know what a wealthy rancher's daughter is good for?”

Bilbo had taken a seat on one of the student benches during Dis’s story. She was walking lazily as she spoke, her eyes fixed on the chalkboard, though her gaze seemed distant. She turned to him when she asked the question.

“I couldn’t begin to guess,” he replied.

“Absolutely nothing. I had nowhere to go and nothing to do, so I ended up back where I didn’t want to be. I’ll admit now, years later, that it was for the best. I’m much safer at the ranch with all those gun-toting men around, and I do have a purpose. I manage the household, and as a thank you, my dear brother promised to hire a private tutor for my sons.”

“I’ve been hounding him for months to find someone suitable,” Dis said, her frustration evident. “He claimed he tried, but apparently gentlemen like yourself weren’t interested in the dangerous adventure of moving West. In a way, I suppose Thorin felt he had no choice but to handle things the way he did. I can be quite demanding, I admit. But he promised me he would find someone, and I reminded him every day to keep that promise—or I would take my sons back East with me. I wasn’t actually going to leave, but Thorin didn’t need to know that.”

“You need to understand that I had no idea he was going to kidnap you. I would never have agreed to such a desperate solution. I want to apologize for that and for any discourteous treatment you experienced on the way. My brother can be rude at times—sullen and moody—but he has a heart of gold.”

“Yes, I know,” Bilbo replied, seizing his chance to speak. He smiled warmly at her, grateful she had shared her story. It meant she trusted him and must like him; otherwise, why would she confide in him? “I got to know him on the trail, and I found him to be quite lovely.”

Dis laughed softly and took a seat at the opposite end of the bench. “And he never told you about me,” she said, as if concluding a thought.

“Not in any detail. I overheard him and Dwalin discussing your temperament at times, but I never had reason to believe you weren’t his wife. He certainly loves those two boys if he’s willing to go to all this trouble.”

“Yes, he does,” Dis said proudly. “But that’s not all. I’ll be thirty-five soon, and I’ve known Thorin all my life. He’s overly protective, brave, and loyal to a fault. Like our father, he can obsess over things—though fortunately not wealth. When something concerns him, he can become anxious and withdrawn.”

“Oh yes, I’ve witnessed that firsthand,” Bilbo admitted.

“I bet you have,” Dis smiled. “That’s how I figured out you had become his biggest concern. Since you left, he’s been completely unbearable. He won’t talk about anything but the ranch, and if anyone mentions your name, he swells up, saddles Old Blue, and disappears for hours. It took me a few days, but I finally realized what's happened. You see, he’s never been in love before and doesn’t know what to do with all those feelings. Instead of facing them, like many of us Durins tend to do, he's running from them.”

Bilbo had never been much of a runner. He always felt he was running toward something. He had been searching for peace and contentment for a long time. He thought he had found it here at Lonely Mountain, with the school and the students he was eager to teach, but it wasn’t enough. His mother had told him when he was young that the greatest joy one could find was to love and be loved in return.

A job is what you do, friends are who you share time with, but love is what makes life worth living.

Now that he had finally found it, he couldn’t afford to lose it.

“I do love him,” he confessed shyly to Dis. Her smile widened, and her blue eyes sparkled as she leaped across the bench and into his arms.

“I knew it! I told Bofur I was right!”

“Bofur?” Bilbo recalled the ranch foreman; they had gotten along well.

“Oh yes, the hands are fairly divided. Bofur and Bombur are definitely on your side.”

“And Dori?” Bilbo asked. They hadn’t spoken much, but since learning he was related to his new friend Ori, he was more interested in getting to know him.

“Dori doesn’t care either way. He minds his own business,” Dis explained. “As for Dwalin, just ignore him. He thinks he’s responsible for Thorin’s happiness and doesn’t believe you’re in love with him at all. Ever since you went upstairs with that saloon girl…”

“Maggie,” Bilbo corrected, feeling defensive. “And I didn’t… I didn’t sleep with her. We only talked. I needed someone to confide in—about Thorin, actually.”

“So you didn’t pay for a poke?” Dis began to giggle, covering her mouth with her gloved hands while throwing her head back in laughter. “Oh, this is fantastic! Dwalin has so much crow to eat! He’s gotten everything wrong! But then again, he isn’t the brightest one on the ranch. He’s all muscle without the mind.”

Her phrasing made Bilbo chuckle, and he immediately thought of Ori. “I’ve met Dori’s brother, Ori, in town. He’s been very kind to me. He says he’s dating a young woman in town, but from what I’ve gathered, I don’t think he cares much about Dwalin’s intellect. In fact, he seems quite fascinated with all the muscle. I think there’s something going on between them.”

The woman’s brows shot up. “Oh? Is that so?”

Bilbo was sure he’d just found a confidante. Despite everything he’d heard about this woman, he liked her a lot. “I’m not much of a matchmaker, but I believe we need to get these two together. It might just take Dwalin’s mind off me.”

Dis nodded, clearly in agreement with Bilbo’s idea. “And do you have a plan for how to make that happen?”

“Actually,” Bilbo replied, a smile spreading across his face as he recalled Ori inviting him to visit his brother at the ranch. “Let me check with Ori to see when he’s planning to visit Dori next. He invited me to go with him. While Ori distracts Dwalin with compliments about his muscles, I can speak with Thorin and hopefully straighten everything out.”

Dis’ smile turned sweet, and her eyes sparkled with enthusiasm. “I think that’s an excellent idea. I’m genuinely pleased for you both. When Vili and I were together, those were the happiest days of my life. I have a feeling you two will experience something similar, and I’ll do everything I can to help make that happen.”

“Thank you, Dis,” Bilbo said, reaching over to squeeze her hand in gratitude.

As he withdrew his hand, Bilbo became nervous about the task that lay before him. This wasn’t just about matchmaking; it was about bridging gaps and healing wounds—his own and Thorin’s. The thought of confronting Thorin both excited and unnerved him, yet he was resolved to at least explain everything that had been misunderstood. What Thorin did with that information was up to him.

Dis stood, her demeanor shifting to one of purpose. “Let’s make this happen,” she said, her voice steady. “You deserve to find your happiness, Bilbo. And Thorin… he needs someone who believes in him, just as much as he believes in his family.”

Bilbo nodded, feeling a renewed sense of determination. “I’ll do my best.”

With a final nod, Dis stepped outside, leaving Bilbo alone with his thoughts. He looked around the room, feeling a mix of anticipation and apprehension. The echoes of their conversation lingered in the air and he pinched himself to make sure he hadn’t fallen asleep on his desk while assessing his students’ work.

He wasn’t asleep; instead, he took a deep breath, deciding to talk to Ori first. Perhaps he could persuade his new friend to visit the ranch right after classes on Friday. That would give him four days to prepare everything he needed to say to Thorin and muster the courage to express just how much he loved him.