Actions

Work Header

The Unkindly West

Chapter Text

In two chairs, two pairs of feet wiggled twenty toes in front of the wood stove. Laughter and interesting conversation filled the teacherage until an abrupt knock on Bilbo’s door silenced them.

It was past dark, but not too late. Still, it was unusual for him to have visitors in the evening.

Even if it was Ori. Was it Thursday? Had he missed meeting Ori at Heritage House?

“Bilbo, can I come in? We need to talk.”

“Sure,” Bilbo replied, stepping aside to let his friend pass.

As Ori stomped the snow off his feet onto the woven rug just inside the door, he began speaking. “I needed to see you and let you know what I’ve been hearing in town. It’s concerning you, and... you’re not going to believe this, but—”

Once he lifted his head from his boots and noticed the young woman standing by the fire, Ori's mouth clamped shut.

“Ori,” Bilbo said, “this is Maggie, a good friend of mine. Maggie, this is another good friend, Ori Brown. He’s an attorney here in town.”

Ori was the friendliest young man Bilbo had ever known—smart, witty, and kind, but the shock on his face was evident.

“And where are you from?” he asked, his tone unexpectedly judgmental.

Bilbo stepped over to stand by Maggie’s side. “I was born and raised just outside of Ravenhill,” she answered.

“Is that where your family is still?”

Maggie’s brow furrowed with discernment, and she smiled. “I know how people around here are, Mr. Brown. Go ahead and ask me what you want to know.”

“I’m sorry,” Ori said. “I shouldn’t have come, but Bilbo, the townspeople are in an uproar. They’re saying you’ve got a saloon girl staying at your house. No offense, Miss Maggie.”

“None taken,” she replied smugly.

“Actually,” Bilbo interjected, “Maggie is currently without employment and is considering heading east to attend college. What was it you were going to study again? Medicine? Or was it law?”

“Bilbo,” Ori said seriously, “I’m not judging you or your visitor, but there are others who are. They’re talking about releasing you from your teaching contract.”

“Okay, I’m leaving,” Maggie stated, walking over to grab the skimpy shawl she had arrived in.

“You are absolutely not!” Bilbo exclaimed. “I am helping a friend! I am not engaging in any improper conduct!”

“That’s not what Sheriff Bowman says,” Ori told him with a wince.

“Sheriff Bowman!” Bilbo echoed. “I knew there was something about that man I didn’t trust. What have I ever done to him?”

“Nothing, as far as I know,” Ori said. “But I should tell you—no,” he corrected himself. “My mother taught me not to be a busybody and to mind my own business.”

Bilbo stepped forward and grasped his friend’s upper arms—not too tightly, but firmly enough to convey that he meant business. “Tell me what you were going to say.”

“Okay,” Ori replied, his voice barely above a whisper. “I’ve heard that when the posse was rounded up to clear out the Orchani, something happened between Mr. Durin and the Sheriff.”

“Something? What kind of something?” Bilbo asked, his hands dropping, his curiosity piqued.

“Something romantic,” Ori explained. “At least, that’s what I’ve been told. But you know how rumors are, Bilbo. Like my daddy used to say, ‘Rumors are carried by haters, spread by fools, and accepted by idiots.’”

A strange sensation bubbled in Bilbo’s chest—something he had never felt before. Was he having a heart seizure? He felt a hand on his arm and turned to look at Maggie.

“Are you okay? You look a little pale. Why don’t you take a seat?”

Thorin had had a relationship with Sheriff Bowman? Why had he never mentioned it? But then again, why should he? He owed Bilbo no explanations; they had made no commitments. Bilbo had had relationships in the past too, and he hadn’t offered any details about those either.

Wait. Was that why Bard Bowman didn’t like him? Was he jealous of his and Thorin's relationship? Was he trying to run him out of town so that he could have Thorin all to himself? Did he think Bilbo would give up so easily? No, he would not! Not without speaking his mind first!

A cup of something warm was placed in his hand, and Bilbo realized he had sat down without being aware of it. Ori was across from him, and Maggie was kneeling next to his chair. He took a sip of the tea she had made him and tried to smile.

“Feel better?” Maggie asked.

Bilbo wasn’t sure. That strange sensation in his chest had expanded, pressing outward until it filled his arms and head. Was this panic? Jealousy? Whatever it was, he wasn’t used to it, and he didn’t like it—not one bit!

“Ori,” Bilbo looked up into his friend’s concerned face. “Give the Sheriff a message for me. Tell him and the other school board members to meet me in the classroom at 7:30 in the morning. I have a few things I’d like to discuss.”

“Bilbo, you don’t have to do that,” Maggie said. “I’ll just leave.”

“If you leave, I’m leaving with you,” he stated firmly. “I won’t allow such judgmental people decide what is right and wrong for me. I am a grown man, and the last time I checked, this was a free country. I thought people in the West would be different, but they are just as close-minded as everyone else.”

“I’ll tell them,” Ori agreed, patting Bilbo’s knee before leaving the teacherage.

The following morning, Bilbo was dressed and waiting in the schoolroom by 7:00. He started a fire in the stove to warm the room and set out the writing assignments. He wrote the morning’s math problems on the chalkboard and passed out the readers. Then he sat behind his desk and waited.

At exactly 7:30, the door opened, and six members of the Lonely Mountain School Board walked in. First was Attorney Ori Brown, followed by Mrs. Clara Whitfield, the owner of the dress shop; Mr. Reginald Pembroke, the banker; Pastor Samuel Hawthorne; Mr. Benjamin Hargrove, the dry goods store owner; and, of course, Sheriff Bard Bowman. They approached the front of the classroom like a funeral procession and took their seats on the first row of benches.

Mrs. Whitfield stood and smoothed her heavy velvet gown before speaking. “Mr. Brown has informed the school board that you wish to address us. I would say your timing is impeccable, Mr. Baggins, for it is the school board who wishes to address you. It has come to our attention that you are allowing a woman of ill repute to stay in the teacherage—the cozy home that this school board and the taxpayers of this town have provided for you, free of charge, mind you! And yet you diminish its worth by bringing such a person inside its walls. It is not to be born!”

“Listen,” Mr. Pembroke interrupted, though he chose to remain seated. “We don’t have anything against you, Mr. Baggins, just the company you keep.”

“In the teacherage!” Mrs. Whitfield added. “He’s keeping her inside that house! She’s in there right this minute!”

“Is it true that she spent the night inside the teacherage with you, Mr. Baggins?” Pastor Hawthorne asked.

Was he going to be allowed to speak? Bilbo didn’t really see the point since they had already judged and sentenced him.

“She came to me for help after being attacked. As a friend, I helped her. What would you have me do? Turn her out into the snow? She walked here in her bare feet!”

“Of course not,” Ori finally spoke, rising to his feet. “But perhaps paying for her to have a room in the hotel would have been better.”

Bilbo stared at Ori, unsure what he had expected. This was his friend’s town, and Ori was a business owner here. He couldn’t afford to take a stand, regardless of his personal opinions, could he? Of course not.

“Perhaps so,” Bilbo admitted, now that he had the benefit of hindsight. Yet even with that insight, he would do the exact same thing again. He would never turn away a friend in need.

“The matter has already been discussed and resolved,” Sheriff Bowman announced. “The guidelines for hired teachers are clear. Did you not read them?”

“Yes, I read them,” Bilbo replied flatly, meeting the Sheriff’s hard gaze.

“And still, you chose not to follow them. This reveals either a lack of understanding or a rebellious nature—neither of which we wish to subject our children to. Mr. Baggins, you are hereby relieved of your position in this institution and will need to vacate the teacherage immediately. Have a good day.”

Bilbo sat in his chair, watching the six members leave the building where he had just begun making memories, filled with disappointment. Not in the school board’s decision, but in the fact that he was abandoning his students. He wished he could explain to them but he couldn't. He just hoped they would someday look back on this and choose to be more open-minded than their parents.

He gathered his personal items from the schoolroom and returned to the teacherage, where he found Maggie reading The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. She was so engrossed that she hadn’t heard him enter until he shut the door.

“Oh! You’re back!” Her sweet smile shifted to a frown. “It’s not good news, is it? Tell me.”

During the short walk from the school to the teacherage, Bilbo had come up with an idea. It was a good one, though it would be painful.

“Do you recall our conversation about you returning east to attend college?”

“Yes?” Maggie responded, sounding suspicious.

“You’re going and I’m going to be the one to take you there. The first thing we’ll do after I pack and rent a carriage is buy train tickets for both of us. We’ll be in Maine by the end of the month, and maybe we can get you enrolled for the spring semester at Colby College. That’s where I attended. They offer home economics, education, and nursing for women. Do any of those interest you?”

He was already busying himself with packing, opening the trunks stacked against the wall, and beginning to remove dishes from the shelves. Maggie followed him, sputtering wordlessly. “Bilbo! You can’t just… what about Thorin?”

Of course, he’d thought about Thorin. How could he not? But what was he supposed to do? Go to the man and beg for a place to live now that he had no job and no home? He couldn’t do that. He had some money, but after this morning, he wouldn’t live in this town. He couldn’t. And Maggie couldn’t have a new life anywhere close to here. She needed to get as far away as possible, and Bilbo felt responsible for getting her there. They had met for a reason, and he was her only hope. This was a higher calling. This was more important than finding love. Wasn’t it?

He would stop on the way to the train station to tell Thorin about his decision, but his mind was made up. He was going back home, and he wasn’t going alone.