Chapter Text
*~~*~~*~~*
“Aaaaaaaah!”
The dwarrowkin tumbled down the chute as before, and Bilbo with them, though this time with his pack on his lap instead of on his back, and Gandalf with them, too, making a deep “Oh!”-sound as he fell.
The shaft was deep, with sharp stone walls, and a sliminess to it, and goblins cackled, and laughed, and cheered as the Company shot past them, into the basket below.
*~~*~~*~~*
With moans, and groans, and shouts of protest, the dwarrows slowly made for their feet, and as Bilbo tried to regain his own, he discovered three things:
- He had successfully managed to hold onto his pack, covering his lap.
- Thorin’s coat was still wrapped around it.
- Thorin himself was beneath him, his cushion for this fall, and from the sounds of it, the weight was enough that he minded.
“Oh, I’m dreadfully sorry…” Bilbo managed to cry out, trying to jump backwards onto his feet, but hitting another person with his butt, bouncing straight back on top of Thorin, pack and coat and everything. Thorin gave another moan, as all breath was knocked from his body, and he looked up, looking ready to reprimand whoever was on top of him.
As his eyes met Bilbo’s, both of them stilled.
It was the cackles of goblins which tore them back into the situation, and Bofur pulled Bilbo up, before Dwalin helped Thorin to his feet. Bilbo started counting his companions again, and found Filí holding onto Kilí, a protective arm above his younger brother’s head, as though to protect him from the spears now poking at them from the sides.
As the dwarrowkin and one wizard were shepherded forward, Bilbo ducked down, wishing to be ignored, and ignored he was…
…and this time, he willingly climbed off the ledge, down towards the bottom of the ravine, carefully…
Whatever awaited the others, they had defeated it and escaped it safely before. Now they had a wizard with them, and Bilbo simply had to trust them.
Bilbo had somewhere else he needed to be…
*~~*~~*~~*
After a long, and heavy – he still carried his pack, and Thorin’s fur coat – climb, Bilbo finally made it to the bottom floor.
Gollum was nowhere to be seen.
Bilbo took a deep breath, then started looking for one, tiny band of gold, between dozens of rocks and… skeletons…
*~~*~~*~~*
…Bilbo finally found it, his ring of invisibility, behind a stone, after searching what felt like a hundred others like it.
As he picked up the plain, gold band, and pocketed it, a small yelp of triumph escaped him, and his feet did a little dance, all on their own.
It would be alright.
He would face Smaug invisible, and he would take the Arkenstone to Bard, and they could resolve that whole treasure conversation quickly, and easily, and…
*~~*~~*~~*
“You… took the Arkenstone? And gave it away?!”
Thorin had never looked so angry, so… devastated before.
*~~*~~*~~*
There was no way to avoid all that pain, was there?
Trying his best, Bilbo could think of no way to avoid it…
*~~*~~*~~*
“Oh, the Arkenstone.” Balin said, smoking his pipe on the bench outside Bag End, next to Gandalf and Bilbo. “Priceless little jewel, that one.”
Bilbo watched as his smoke rings slowly transformed into a rain of flower petals – Gandalf turning smoke into other shapes, as usual.
“Was it truly that important?” Bilbo asked, curious. “Everyone talked of the madness of Thror; I thought the stone just looked pretty, and made dwarves go mad.”
“It does look pretty.” Balin chuckled. “And many have acted a little strange after seeing it.” the old advisor allowed. “But more than anything else, it is a proof of skill.”
“Of skill?” Bilbo asked, intrigued.
“Aye.” Balin replied. “Gems are often very soft to the touch, or very brittle. The skills of Erebor, to extract such large gems, and so many of them, were highly prized because it is a bit like… how to put it… ah! Like trying to retrieved an egg, still in its unbroken shell, from inside a lembas bread. It requires accuracy, and the right tools, and the skill to recognise the difference between hard rock and soft gem, and change tools in time.” Balin gave a sigh. “The Arkenstone is the largest, and prettiest, of its kind. A true gift of Aulë, to mark the heir of Durin. Mining that, without breaking its surface…”
*~~*~~*~~*
…but Bilbo had to try. He would take the Arkenstone, as a precaution, but he hoped he could find another way…
“What is its?” a snivelling voice said, and Bilbo turned to see Gollum. “It smells of dwarves, and goblinses, and elvish filth, but no, it is different, different thing. What is its?”
Gollum.
“It is… a hobbit.” Bilbo replied to the pale, thin creature. “I am Bilbo. Who are you?” Bilbo's shoulders were tense, remembering the struggle they had had before, but these were Gollum's caves, and Bilbo did not relish the idea of knocking the strange creature unconscious again…
“I?” Gollum asked, seemingly confused. “I… gollum, gollum…” – it seemed to cough its name – “I… am of water, swimming, and fish-eating, and goblin-cleaving…!”
“Do you like games?!” Bilbo panicked, the creature too intense for his liking. “Do you like… riddles?” Bilbo hoped this could still work, the second time around…
“...gamesss?” the creature pondered, halting. “Rrrrriddles?”
“Yes!” Bilbo said, holding on to his hope by his fingertips. “Riddles! Question games. What… flies without wings, and arrives with a sting?”
“Questions…” Gollum pondered, then a light came on in its eyes. “Flies without wings, arrives with a sting… it shoots from a bow, falls from high to low… it is… an arrow!”
“Right.” Bilbo confirmed. He had forgotten how quick the creature was, at riddles. That riddle had taken the dwarves five tries, at Elrond’s party.
“My turn, my turn!” the creature said, jumping with excitement. “What has roots, as nobody sees, is taller than trees, up, up, up it goes, and yet it never grows?”
“Roots, but no tree… Tall, but never- Mountains!” Bilbo called out, triumphantly, and Gollum whined and shrieked, part from losing and part from… joy…
“My turn!” Bilbo said, carefully wandering towards the lake as he spoke. “Thirty white horses, standing on a red hill. First they champ, then they stamp, then they stand still.”
Gollum hesitated, opened its mouth, then hesitated again.
“Aha!” it suddenly called out. “Teeth! Teeth! …but I have only nine… My turn. Voiceless it cries, wingless flutters, toothless it bites, mouthless mutters.”
“Mouthless… wingless…” Bilbo muttered, pondering, slowly edging closer to the lake as he turned himself this way and that to distract from his movements. “Cries… bites… mutters. Wind. Wind, of course!”
Golum shrieked again, and again Bilbo heard both the pain of losing and a… joy… from playing?
When was the last time this creature had played a game?
“My turn.” Bilbo said. “Hmmm… An eye, up high, out of reach, and full of heat.”
The creature moved here and there, jumping rocks and rubbing its scarce head of hair. “High, high, up in the sky… The sun!” Gollum called out at last, though it had taken a good long while to think. Bilbo wondered when the creature had last seen actual sunlight. How long had Gollum wandered beneath the Misty Mountain, eating goblins and orcs and fish?
“Yes!” Bilbo confirmed, and Gollum danced a happy little dance, with lots of small jumps.
“My turn.” Gollum then hissed. “It cannot be seen, cannot be felt, cannot be heard, cannot be smelt. It lies behind stars and under hills, and empty holes it fills. It comes first and follows after, ends life, kills laughter.”
“Dark.” Bilbo called, almost as soon as the riddle ended. The thing surrounded them, uncomfortable and deep, and Bilbo was struggling to ignore it.
As before, Gollum whined and cried, and Bilbo took it as confirmed victory.
“My turn.” he said, the water of the lake three feet away. He had seen it shimmering in the distance for a while, and finally he was here. It would be a long way around it still, but he was here, and Gollum still played the game, with enthusiasm and vigour.
“A… box without hinges, key, or lid, yet golden treasure inside is hid.”
The cave was dark, and the lake was cold, and Bilbo could feel it all pressing towards him, but he inched slowly sideways, following Gollum with his eyes. This riddle took some time, and Gollum turned right, and turned left, and rubbed at its head, looking for the answer.
“...eggies. It is eggsies!” Gollum called out in triumph, and Bilbo confirmed it. “My turn!” Gollum then called. “Alive without breath, cold as death. Never thirsty, ever drinking. All in mail, never clinking.”
Bilbo remembered when he heard this one before, something cold had touched his foot, in the lake, but he pretended to think long and hard, walking this way and that, slowly circling the lake.
“Fish.” he finally said, and Gollum, who had looked quite excited, whined and moaned.
“My turn.” Bilbo said, and thought hard. It was never easy, coming up with new and new riddles, all alone, but he had played riddles with the whole Company and some elves, too, less than a week ago, and that helped. “It has no sun, it has no moon, though either one may turn up soon. It ends with light, yet isn’t dark. It shelters deer, and moth, and hawk.”
The riddle lasted a while, and Bilbo could smell fresher air by the time Gollum called out its answer.
“Twilight!” it called out excitedly.
“Yes!” Bilbo called back, a good twenty feet from the creature, and hoping to vanish by the end of his next riddle.
“Mine, mine, mine now!” Gollum sang, dancing around the rocks around them. “This thing all things devours: Birds, beasts, trees, flower. It gnaws iron, bites steel, grinds hard stones to meal. It slays king, ruins town, and beats high mountain down.”
Gollum looked excited by this one, eyes sparkling at Bilbo.
Bilbo vaguely remembered the image of the answer; beasts falling, trees dying, pots and pans rusting away, and King Thorin turning grey of hair, slowly fading from life…
“Time…” he said, sooner than he intended.
Gollum screamed with disappointment.
This was it. Bilbo could feel a wind from the outside right behind him, and Gollum was growing restless after the last riddle. Bilbo fondled the ring in his pocket, and thought hard…
“My turn.” he said, and Gollum stood still on a tall stone, listening intently. “Stretching high and digging low, has no finger, has no toe. Harder than grass, softer than stone, many limbs, and rarely alone.”
The next time Gollum looked away, Bilbo put on the ring, and ran.
*~~*~~*~~*
