Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of The Once Upon a Hobbit stories , Part 1 of The Epics
Collections:
The Hobbit Fanfics
Stats:
Published:
2024-06-01
Completed:
2024-08-27
Words:
106,258
Chapters:
51/51
Kudos:
1,552
Hits:
0

Once Upon a Hobbit - a Time-Travel Fix-It

Chapter 43: Closed Gates

Summary:

In which a man and an elf try to ask a dwarf for money...

Notes:

_________________________
This is a work of fiction.

The characters, locations, and canon events are a compilation from...
...the works of J.R.R. Tolkien, and
...of Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh & Philippa Boyens, and
...greatly inspired by the influences of Guillermo del Toro.

The final end result is my own chaos.
Enjoy. 💖
__________________________

Chapter Text

*~~*~~*~~*

 

Never in his long, long life, had Bilbo Baggins liked the elven king of the Woodland Realm.

 

Like many elves, he stood tall, but where many elves were confident, Thranduil seemed rather fragile, his elven confidence seemingly ready to crack at the first comment and unleash some sort of monster, hidden beneath.

 

Bilbo could understand why.

 

Thranduil was the King of the Woodland realm, who had lost much of the realm in the very beginning of his rule, and the forest he had been charged to protect had changed name from Greenwood to Mirkwood, the elves beginning to call it ‘Taur-no-Fuin’ – the Forest of Great Fear – under his rule, and not of his doing.

 

Anyone could feel insecure after such a thing… but Thorin II Oakenshield, King-in-Exile and heir to three kingdoms, all taken over by dragons and orcs and worse, still faced every day with determination, talking with friends and allies, hiring a bloody hobbit at the recommendation of a wizard, all in an attempt to make things better, and Thranduil could not be bothered to even allow the dwarf to pass him by, on an old, dwarf-made road.

 

The elf was despicable, conceited, self-centered, and rude. Very, very rude.

 

And now, Thorin would have to talk with the elf with respect, in order to borrow the git’s army in defense against their shared enemies. Shared! Enemies!

 

It made Bilbo boil on the inside, but what was necessary had to be done, and blast the elf if he fought them on this…

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

“Hail, Thorin, King-Under-the-Mountain!” the riders called out on that second day. “We bring you Bard the Dragonslayer and his protector, Lord Thranduil of the Woodland Realm, to speak!”

 

“Hail, leaders of men and elves, and welcome to Erebor! We would open the gates, but we see weapons still with you, and would rather not risk our necks so soon.” Bofur replied, sitting behind the crenelations above the gate, playing cards with Nori, occasionally peeking out past the stone at his back.

 

“Open the gates or come out. We will not leave our protection behind so easily.” Thranduil called, ever the arrogant, bossy git. “But talk we must, as the burning of Lake-town left many in need, and you have the means to ease that, and a responsibility to offer recompense for awakening the fire-dragon which burned them.”

 

“Aye, recompense is a conversation we can have.” Bofur agreed amiably. “But what fools would we be, to open these doors while Men with spears and Elves with swords stand by, armies waiting behind them? What happens when you disagree with our terms, during negotiations? I might be a mere guardsman, with a message from my king, but quite as foolish as that I am not. Return without weapons. Then we can talk.”

 

“Are we to believe there are no weapons of your own, waiting for us as we enter?” Thranduil called back, sneering. “What fools, us, if we were to agree to those terms, and wander into such an easy trap. What hinders you from waiving your axes at us, should you disagree with our terms?”

 

“Grand words coming from the king who took all the weapons we carried to Mirkwood!” Nori called back. “Where our weapons can be found, no one knows better than you, Thranduil King, and their return will be the first of our terms!”

 

“Halt!” Bard called, through the growing chaos between elf and dwarf. “I understand you have differences, and a history longer than with ours, but the people of Lake-town are in need of shelter, and the wealth of Dale rests within your doors! May we speak on that, at least, before we wander into arguments already old?”

 

“Aye, we can.” Thorin called, from his place on the wall, having risen into sight at the sound of Bard’s voice. “And the wealth of Dale may once more return to Eregoth, in due time, but first, Bard of Dale, we must speak of the terms of its delivery, and I will hold no such discussion out here, shouting between mountains, spears at my doors!”

 

“Then you do not wish to speak at all!” Thranduil hissed, and pulled his Great Stag around, riding back towards the camp below.

 

Bard hesitated, but offered Thorin a mere nod of parting, then followed his ally down the hill…

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

“The armies of orcs will be here within five days.” Bilbo told Thorin, an idea forming between them. “And they are old enemies of the elves. I do not think the elves will abandon the battle, as long as enough strength is by their side to survive it.”

 

“Aye, mayhaps, but Thranduil has been known to retreat between his trees before, using the forest’s twisting paths to break apart armies, wandering lost.” Thorin added, mulling it over. “Old enemies they might be, but he has survived a losing battle for a long time through maneuvers of stealth and evasion, and by choosing the field of battle for himself, not by standing where the orcs arrive first.”

 

“He will have sworn protection to the Lake-people.” Bilbo added. “As long as the people of Lake-town are with him, he cannot abandon them easily. He will stay to cover their retreat, with his own, which would give Daín more time to arrive.”

 

“So, Daín will arrive, then?” Thorin mused, a spark of hope in his eyes.

 

“Yes, and with an army of his own, but not enough to beat back the orcs.” Bilbo warned, waving a hand for emphasis. “If you place all your faith in the army from the Iron Hills, this mountain will be become our tomb as surely as Khazad’Dûm was your grandfather’s.”

 

Thorin sobered at that.

 

“I think… we need to keep them here.” Bilbo said, still thinking. “Until Daín arrives, and a day longer than that…”

 

“A waiting game.” Thorin suggested, eyes sparking back to life. “A distraction, keeping them waiting.”

 

“...yes.” Bilbo agreed, recognising what he had just allowed the dwarf to do. “...a distraction…”

 

“Oh, I can do that.” Thorin said, gleefully. “Keeping them on their toes, reaching for something beyond reach, for five days and one? Aye, I can do that…”

 

“Erü’s blessing…” Bilbo sighed. “Please don’t anger the elves… too much?”

 

Thorin took his hands with a smile. “Not… too much, no, but enough to make them stay…”

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

As the riders left the gates on that second day, Bilbo sighed where he sat behind the crenelations, Thorin chuckling next to him.

 

“Oh, it is a good day, when Thranduil plays into my hands with such ease.” the dwarrow king sniggered, hands on the crenelations, eyes following the riders as they grew distant. “I never knew there would come a day when I would be grateful for his pride.”

 

Bilbo slowly rose to his feet, brushing the dust off his clothes – someone should really take a broom to this place, if they were to sit down on it every day – and yelped, as the king grabbed him by his arms and kissed his head with joy.

 

“You, my jewel from the Shire, have brought great joy to these days.” Thorin told him with great warmth, then the dwarf wandered off, humming, probably to see to their projects and check in with the others.

 

Bilbo stood there dazed, but was soon awakened by the sound of chortling coming from the guards down the line.

 

“Jewel from the Shire.” Bofur repeated, with great amusement, mimicking a kiss onto empty air. “My greatest joy.”

 

Nori chuckled by his side, adding another jewel to the pile between their cards.

 

“Oh, shut up.” Bilbo grumbled, waving a hand at the fools, but he failed to muster any real anger, as his brow was still warm from the kiss…

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

…and so they held, asking for conditions neither side could meet, never mentioning the easy way out, not even once, while riders came to call at the gate, and dwarrowkin guarded it and called right back, and no true negotiations took place for many days, much thanks to Thranduil and the rider in the long cloak, and to the great amusement of several dwarves, as they roared with laughter at each evening fire, sharing stories of how they had managed to anger the two in the day, delaying conversations once more…

 

…and then, Daín arrived.

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

The dwarves of the Iron Hills were of stout stock, and each of them carried a huge pack on their back, filled with supplies. Daín himself left his pack behind his saddle, as he came riding across the waste on a Giant Boar, and the pack served to give the impression of a small throne, where he sat.

 

As Daín arrived below, the army across the valley refused to let him pass, and dwarf and elf and man argued for a while, until Daín’s dwarves relented and set up camp below, but their camp, too, stretched the width of the valley, locking the elves and men in place.

 

That evening, Gandalf appeared, riding up towards the gate in the company of Bard and Thranduil and the man in the long cloak..

 

“Hail, Thorin son of Thraín son of Thròr, King-Under-the-Mountain!” Gandalf called, and Thorin stepped out onto the walkway, showing his face between the embrasures above the gate, Balin and Dwalin by his sides, Bofur and Bifur by theirs. “I, Gandalf the Grey, come to ask for your aid, and for all of you to cease this foolishness, before it is too late.” Gandalf called, respectfully at first, then those last words came out a bit like a curse.

 

“Hail, Gandalf the Grey, and Bard the Bowman, and Thranduil of the Greenwood, and the man with the loud mouth, but no name.” Thorin called.

 

“I am here on behalf of the Master, as a councilour to his rule!” the long-cloaked man shouted, self-importantly.

 

Thorin barely paused to let the man speak, before continuing. “Three of you are welcome to our halls, and the fourth may come along when you do, if you but leave those swords outside. We have much to talk about, and not much time left to do it with.”

 

“Then, our swords will be left here, with our horses.” Gandalf replied, looking at the others and receiving – reluctant – nods. “But no one here shall be harmed, or imprisoned.”

 

“No harm will come to those who do not harm us first.” Thorin allowed, and signalled the opening of the gates.

 

As the large metal doors shifted, without a sound from their new hinges, Gandalf, Thranduil, Bard, and the councilor to the Master dismounted and strapped their swords and bows and other big weapons to their saddles, before they walked carefully into the mountain of Erebor…

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

The Company had had days to prepare, and while Balin counted coins with Dori, sorting through that mess of a dragon’s hoard, the rest had worked on restoring what they could, which in Ori and Bombur’s case had included the slow restoration of the city frescoes, starting in the front hall of the mountain.

 

As the visitors passed through the – still slightly broken – Protector’s Walk into the Grand Entryhall of the city, they found themselves surrounded by crystal ‘trees’, clean streets, and a large plaza fountain, in front of a large frescoed wall, picturing the founding of Erebor, given in millions of small, colourful tiles, re-attached to teh previously broken wall.

 

There were still damages visible, of course – the fountain had been tidied, but the bowl still leaked water from three cracks, joining the river flowing beneath, and the fresco was far from complete – but the moonlight shone on everything, and luminous gems had been recovered, to light the paths once more, and the massive table by the fountain held a comfortable amount of candelabras and refreshments.

 

“Welcome to Erebor.” Thorin called from behind them, walking down a hidden staircase from the battlements, followed by his guard – though none were visibly armed. “May the light of Dûrin lead the way.”

 

“And may the Stone Father shape our ways.” Gandalf replied, amused.

 

“Please, have a seat.” Thorin asked, walking over to sit down on one side of the table himself, Balin and Dwalin by his sides, Bofur and Bifur standing behind them, Bilbo wandering to a chair on one end.

 

“Certainly…” Thranduil replied, clearly uncomfortable, but he allowed Bard to sit in the center, and delegated himself to sit by his side, as the councilor sat on the other.

 

As Gandalf sat down on the other end, opposite Bilbo, Bilbo noticed a calculating look on his face, and hoped they had the same goals in the end. He thought they had, but this whole situation made him nervous enough to question it.

 

“Well, then.” Bard said, palms on the table. “Our terms.”

 

“One moment, laddie.” Balin interrupted. “First, we have a bit of advice for you all.”

 

Tension leaped high at the interruption, but no one yelled, and Bilbo thanked the blessings of Yavannah for their good manners, praying they would last for the length of the meeting.

 

“Ravens have returned to Erebor.” Balin told them. “And the ravens have brought us news, of an army on the way.”

 

Eyebrows were raised, though most of them sceptically.

 

“Ravens?” the councilor scoffed. “Since when do ravens speak anything but murder?”

 

“Ravens have been messengers for the kings of dwarves since the days of Dûrin himself.” Gandalf shared, an amused look on his face. “I think you have them confused with crows.”

 

The councilor sulked.

 

“Aye, messengers of the king they are.” Balin agreed. “And here by Erebor they have waited, for our return.”

 

“No birds remained on the mountain after Smaug’s attack.” Thranduil protested, his frown deeper than normal. “None would risk the dragon’s appetite or his flames. It was by the return of the birds we knew he had died!”

 

Most everyone stared at the elf, and he closed his mouth, lifting an eyebrow in a challenge.

 

“Be that as it may.” Balin tried again, quickly running out of patience. “The ravens are here, and they are about, and they have returned with news of an army of orcs, a day’s ride out.” – every gaze sharpened – “Now, that was the report at midday. We reckon they’ll be upon us sometime after dawn, sooner if they push through the night.”

 

“I… have heard news of a similar kind…” Gandalf intoned. “That bats fly with them, darkening the sky, keeping the sun out of their eyes.”

 

“...my rangers agree.” Thranduil admitted, reluctantly, leaving the councilor staring around the table, eyes wide.

 

“There is truth to these words.” Bard added, and the councilor started at him with shock. “The hobbit told me as much before they left Lake-town. When you refused conversations, I figured the army was close.” And Bard smiled, throwing an apologetic look at Bilbo, who had made a sound of another casual mentions of his knowledge.

 

“The hobbit?” Thranduil asked, suddenly very interested. “But that would have been-”

 

“Enough.” Gandalf said, voice strong and resolute. “What matters is that we all know what is coming, knowledge we have gained each through their own means, and now we must decide what to do about it.”

 

“We will pay you.” Thorin said, voice dark as doom, eyes meeting Bard’s. “For your aid, Erebor is willing to return all coins marked with the brand of Dale, once the battle has ended, with more wealth to come should you aid us in our repairs. For the elf, I have nothing, as I am left with ill memories from his halls, but for the Men of the Lake, I will honour your efforts, and those against the dragon, with all you are due as heirs to Dale. I would wish us to be friends, should we live to see another day.”

 

Bard looked stunned. “I.. can only accept.” he mumbled, the councilor by his side growing restless. “Though Dale was a long time ago..”

 

“But not so long ago that no one remembers.” Bilbo said, and watched as Bard’s face grew stronger, confusion loosing its grasp on the growing king, and he nodded.

 

Bilbo turned towards Thranduil, who was looking decidedly uncomfortable beside his ally. “Your story, too, is remembered, Thranduil of the Greenwood.” Bilbo said, trying to keep his disgust out of his words. They were talking about one of the greatest ballads of tragedy, after all, and Bilbo had once been a very appreciative listener to the Ballad of Thranduil and his Queen.

 

Thranduil sat stiff, barely moving to look in Bilbo’s direction. He looked confused, as though a maggot had spoken to him during a meeting of crows. Bilbo tried not to be too offended, and retrieved his package from his bag, put it on the table, and rested a hand on top of the wrappings. He had packed it in his finest handkerchief, but the embroidered wool still looked a little silly next to all the gems and jewels and magical things all around him.

 

Patting the package, he looked up at the elven king once more. “I know much has been lost.” he said, staring the elf down. “But not everything has to stay lost.” And he begun to unwrap the package, slowly revealing a set of jewels lying inside, half of them mounted on a beautiful silver string, the other hald sparkling beside it.

 

As Thranduil’s eyes widened with recognition, Bilbo felt a calm come over him. This was right. They had found the right stones, and things could still turn out… alright.

 

“These… I took as part of my share.” Bilbo admitted, several dwarves side-eyeing him with frowns. Thorin calmly kept his gaze forwards, though one of his hands was a fist beneath the table.

 

“And I would offer them to you, King Thranduil, in return for the aid you once refused their people.”

 

A dark cloud descended on the table, at the mentions of those days, a hundred and fifty years in the past, yet a vivid memory to most of those present.

 

“Do not speak of matters you know nothing of.” Thranduil threatened, eyes glaring through a dark scowl.

 

“If he may not speak, then perhaps I shall.” Gandalf said, reminding them of his presence. “It seems to me we have been having an excellent conversation so far, and agreed on some things of rather great importance. Well done. Now, Thranduil, I believe those are the very gems you once entrusted to Erebor, gems your late Queen once came with, as a gift from her family. If you feel quite done with such things, you have but to say the word, and they will never appear before you again. But if, as I suspect, you wish to have them returned to you, it seems to me the little hobbit has found a perfectly good solution for you, as no dwarf could ever give them to you directly without incurring the wrath of their ancestors and kin. Dwarves are very proud, after all, and you did, if you recall, refuse to pay for the work done on them, the last time you wanted them, incurring the wrath of King Durin, the Sixth of his name, before he died. As I recall, you both said some very unkind words at the time…”

 

“[Quiet, Mithrandir, before I lose my sight!]” Thranduil shouted in Quenya-elvish, a fist knocking hard into the table in front of him, and all the dwarves rose from their chairs and took a step back.

 

“[Grace, Thranduil, and accept what is near.]” Bilbo called, stumbling through his Quenya. “[What has passed, has passed, and remains only in memory. These are here, for the sighting and the touching and the listening, and they may be yours once again, for an act you were already committed to.]”

 

Thranduil had turned to stare at him, and a vulnerability had entered his face.

 

“[Though your Silverlight has passed,]” Bilbo continued, mercilessly. “[Her shine stays, but not for long. Greenleaves will fight, whether you fade away from this fight or no. Fight, and keep him alive.]”

 

“My son follows my words.” Thranduil protested, but his eyes told the truth, and he soon closed them.

 

There was a quiet around the table. During the conversation, Thorin and Balin had found their chairs once more, and sat patiently across the table, Balin twiddling thumbs and Thorin silently tapping the wood with his fingers.

 

“...I will fight.” Thranduil then said, eyes determined. “But not for jewels. For the lives of the Men of Dale, to whom I have already offered my protections, I will fight, and my people with me.”

 

Bilbo carefully wrapped the jewels back up, quietly wondering if the elf would change his mind later on… or if he should just sneak them in, as a quiet gift, after the fight… Bilbo himself had no taste for the jewels, after the part they had played in the divide between elf and dwarf. They… disturbed him.

 

*~~*~~*~~*

 

After that, talks of the battle ahead were easier, and at some point, late in the evening, Daín was allowed past the armies with a small contingent of guards, and he, too, joined in the conversations after a hearty greeting.

 

It was a late night for the council that night, as Bard and Thranduil, Thorin and Daín, Balin and Gloín sat up, discussing formations and terrain and all other such things which Bilbo Baggins had little interest in.

 

Instead, he found his way to the Overlook, where a raven waited, and asked it if Beorn was close.

 

Beorn was very close, and the Eagles were on the move, following behind the orcs.

 

At those news, Bilbo handed the raven a packet of nuts, and thanked it for the help, then he sat down on the ledge, and continued his poetry, hoping some of it might soon make sense, and there he fell asleep, leaned against a wall, quill bleeding through a page beneath his hand...

 

*~~*~~*~~*