Chapter Text
When he woke once more, he was lying in a wooden carriage, gently swaying from the horses pulling it and trotting into the night. Something in the air had shifted, in the way that it entered his lungs and lingered there like ballast while the Earth unshackled itselft from its axis and turned upside down. Thorin's head moved sluggishly to the side and, taking in the other presence sitting against the opposite wall, his hand reached across the dimness to graze heavy fabric, made rough by time and the harsh elements of nature.
“I am not the hobbit," the voice said.
The dwarf leaned back on the floor and looked at the ceiling. Dressed in his scorched henley, he couldn't help but shiver when a cold breeze ventured in the tight space.
“I still don’t fully understand what happened," Thorin confessed. "Why it happened."
“Certain things are not meant to be understood. Sometimes, we encounter terrible circumstances and all we can do is endure, hoping that the following day will ease your burden. Suffering has no meaning to it. Nor does madness.”
There were small clacking noises from the person chewing on their pipe.
“What’s the last thing you remember, Thorin, son of Thráin, son of Thrór?”
Hesitant, Thorin dampened his lips. “In which world? This fabricated one or the true one?”
“Both are true enough,” commented the wizard nonchalantly. "The real one.”
“I perished from Azog's blade on Ravenhill.”
“You would think so, yes,” Gandalf chuckled. “Well, there is much to tell you! Let us get to it. Elrond and I, we used the Arkenstone to preserve your and your nephews’ minds while we worked on healing your wounds. As sons of Durin, your souls are bound to the Heart of the Mountain and it is my belief that the stone, while sheltering you from the… hm… unpleasant interventions we had to conduct on your bodies, also corrupted your sleep and created this plane,” he ranted while gesturing around, “a remarkable feat! Dreams and memories and thoughts, all woven into the sickness trapped within the Arkenstone. It’s utterly fascinating!”
The carriage fell back to silence. Outside, a horse snorted loudly and Thorin took it as validation of his indignation. He then snorts himself when a trail of pipeweed smoke tickled his nose, making the wizard chuckle again.
“However, I can see how disturbed you feel.” The pipe’s bowl tapped against the ground to release its ashes. “And it is a relief to tell you we think this is the last of it. One last breath of madness, if you will. You are waking, and the Arkenstone’s power is burning itself out by manifesting these convoluted visions.”
A sense of finality settled on Thorin's shoulders. Around them, the sheets covering the carriage were slowly brightening as dawn broke over the world.
“So. The Arkenstone isn’t just a shiny rock?”
“Ridiculous! I am not answering that.”
"How long have we been asleep?" Thorin asked roughly, feeling more impatient with every passing second.
“Five months. Your bodies were safeguarded in the Lonely Mountain while Erebor was being rebuilt under Balin’s regency. It shall be a beautiful place once more.”
“How are you here?”
“I was merely curious about this intangible place. I had to see it for myself.”
“That was not my question.”
“You won’t understand the answer.”
Yeah, what did you expect.
Thorin sighed and let a few moments pass before looking to his side, not the least surprised by the wizard's disappearance. Birds started to chirp in the distance and his left thumb went to his ring. Hushed whispers in the wind urged him to stand up and leave the wagon, to go back to the City before it vanished, to run until exhaustion, and grief, and longing consumed his mind, but they were swallowed by the hope blossoming in his chest.
Blinking away the bluriness from his vision, he stayed put and let his thumb stroke the metal with a faint smile on his lips. His eyes closed, and when they reopened, familiar stone greeted him.
-
After all the madness he went through, Thorin was willing to stay in the hold of his Company until he fell asleep, and even further into the night. And perhaps through the next day too, just as a safety precaution. It made him feel safe. It made him feel sane. His face was pressed into the shoulders of his peers, their arms firmly curled around him and erasing the momentary disorientation of being back in his old, but whole body. Thorin barked out a hearty laugh when he felt repetitive shoves on his back from Fíli and Kíli jumping around, tears streaming down their cheeks as they shouted every one's name over and over.
It was perfect.
However, as time went on, Dwalin’s eyebrow started twitching. Bifur and Gloin mumbled under their breaths, Bofur giggled at his king’s unusual show of affection, Ori frowned with concern, all the while Bilbo was being smothered under folds of heavy furs. So, Thorin begrudgingly broke the embrace. Fear lingered in the back of his mind, and each blink of his eyes came with the dread of losing his kinfolk all over again and being sent back to the House.
Gandalf must have noticed his apprehension because the wizard gently ushered him to a table sitting in a corner of the convalescent room. “Come here, Thorin. I wish to show you something.”
Upon the table was a wooden box. Inside, a black and dull stone.
“Elrond and I cleansed the treasure room from Smaug’s spell. The Arkenstone is no more, and with it, its pull as well as the fabricated plane you and your nephews once knew. You are now free.” Fíli and Kíli whooped in the background. “Calm yourselves! I would still advise you to abstain from large quantities of gold. Thorin, you are free from the Arkenstone’s demented grasp, but the sickness could return. Stay true to yourself, do not fall to greed or pride, and in time, I dare say,” Gandalf spoke with a smile, “you’ll make quite the fine king!”
Thorin smiled back. He was about to thank the Maia when Kíli’s voice filled the room.
“You would NOT believe the dream me and Fíli had during our sleep!”
Clearing his throat, Balin corrected, “Fíli and I.”
“And it was no dream," Thorin added. "My educated guess would be a subconscious-driven,” and he spoke thinking himself quite smart, albeit with a pang of melancholy, “abstract plane inhabited by the souls and sickness held within-"
“Now, now! Let me tell you a story. We awoke in a strange and new world: one full of men, not a single dwarf in sight. Towers were made of iron and glass, roads were made of melted stone.”
“Brother, I do not think asphalt is-”
“And they stretched as far as the horizon! Nature dwindled in favour of modernity; according to this folk, every object had to be shiny, polished and colourful. People dressed in intricately woven and eclectic clothes. They travelled in sleek metal carriages that were faster than the wind. Oh, I drove one of them in fact! Fíli and I, we lived under the roof of our mother’s,” and he pronounced the word as if it was exotic, “flat. You see, it’s like a suite, but for the poor.”
Fíli lifted a hand to cover his eyes.
“We had these objects called phones. Wicked little things! All you needed was the right series of symbols and you could speak to any person in the world!” The young dwarf’s arm flailed across the air.
“So, like- like a raven?”, Ori said with a frown.
“Exactly like a raven! (“Kíli, phones are nothing like ravens.”) And of course, I had a bow. Obviously my skills surpassed everybody else’s. And I took Mister Baggins to shoot arrows with me!”
Bilbo’s eyebrows shot to the ceiling. “Excuse me?”
“God, it reminds me: UNCLE!” Kíli exclaimed with delight, unbothered by the sight of Thorin freezing and his brother making sharp gestures at his neck. “Oh, you all have to hear this, gather up people! Uncle! You were wedded to- “
“Enough!”
Everybody startled and the room fell silent. Thorin whispered painfully, “Kíli, please. I was present. That’s enough.”
Exasperated, Fíli gently slapped the back of his brother’s neck and spoke, “Read the room, brother. You’re embarrassing yourself. Anyhow, it has all been very pleasant and exciting, but I could go with a nice meal.” The royal heir made a cheeky bow towards Gandalf and Oin, adding, “I am eternally grateful for the healers who were able to assemble our bodies back to life. Though I will take on the mantle here and I decree it needs some sustenance. Bro, let’s hit it. To the kitchens!”
“Oh thank Jesus, I could eat a horse.”
“Why would you ever do that?!” Ori threw his arms in the air. “And who’s Jesus? Why are both of you speaking so confoundingly?”
-
“Why would Kíli eat a horse?”
Bilbo and Thorin stood alone in the convalescence room; one by one, the Company had fizzled out to let the three resurrected royals rest. The dwarf’s hand fidgeted absentmindedly in his pocket, perhaps searching for his lost phone when his fingers grazed a smooth and cool surface. He startled, and brought his hand out and on the table.
“He's hungry. It’s an idiom, a turn of phrase. In the other world, people spoke in a tongue very similar to ours. Westron, that is. Yet their quirks and turns were quite… singular.”
Twinkles gleamed in the hobbit’s hazel eyes. Ever the scholar. “Show me.”
Thorin laughed and gratified the demand, “Okay, I’ll show off. It’s weird that the boys and I still remember the slang; took me a while to get used to it, but it grew on me, eventually. Hell, my mouth got way too bold at times! But that’s basically how people communicated. Almost everyone had a loose tongue. At the end of the day, I think you get the gist of what I say, but the words remain very unfamiliar. Did I hit the mark?”
He paused to take in Bilbo’s expression, unsettlement written all over.
“… Forgive me. I was exaggerating it for your sake. It was not my intention to disturb you.” Mortified, he felt the need to add, “I didn’t… I didn’t actually talk like that. And you never did take to that type of crude speech anyway.”
“No, please. I asked. I never took to this speech of yours, you say.” Curiosity came rushing back to the hobbit’s face. “So you did talk to my alternate self. What was I like?”
Thorin coughed. “We certainly had a conversation or two. You were… Well. You were you.” And he mumbled under his breath, “Most times. Blasted and confound creature.” Then went back to an audible voice, “this is a hard thing to explain. You were everything I remembered you being, yet in a form that conformed to this new and strange reality. Most of all, you were a steady, comforting presence. One I thoroughly enjoyed.”
He should have not said that. The dwarf’s face remained impassive while his inner voice shouted in exasperation.
“You are very much ahead of me then,” commented Bilbo in a sad tone, “how strange it is that our friendship lived on in your world, while I spent five months having to watch you sleep in mine.”
“In time, I knew this fabricated version of you was not the real one. For all the similarities you two had, you were two completely distinct persons and treated him as such. Do not worry yourself, our paces still match. I merely have more memories to… put in perspective… Recontextualize. It was all rather complicated.”
“How so?”
“Everything felt so… conceptual. It is a strange experience, leading a life where everything could mean something else. With hindsight, now that I have all my memories, and that from both worlds, I could spend days scrutinizing every single sight or sound, or idea I encountered and ponder on their meanings.”
Bilbo looked hesitant, yet hopeful. “Would you tell me about it? Your whole story, what really happened during your sleep?”
“It is one long and confusing tale.”
“We shall put on some tea,” was the warm reply. “You need to rest, and I need reassurance that you will not vanish from my sight as soon as you do. Would you be willing to spend the evening with me? I don’t want to impose. But here you are, safe and sound, and. Well. I was worried for you, Thorin… I watched you die in my arms; my nightmares are giving me a hard time forgetting that. So, if you please, I would speak with you. It has been so very long since I could. I believe… We have a lot to talk about.”
The Arkenstone laid between them, dull and empty.
Always one to indulge Bilbo’s rambling nature, Thorin waited a little while to be sure he finished speaking before he gave a small bow and a smile.
“I believe we do, Master Baggins. Let us go somewhere more comfortable then. Besides, my nephews had a point. I could eat a horse myself.”
-
It had been a very long time since the dwarf king saw his chambers this refreshed; Balin did not idle during his absence. Prepared for his return, the room had a fire going, had been replenished with goods and dusted in every corner. While Bilbo peered around the lavish room, Thorin laid his coat on a hook and went to a cabinet. There, he took out his tray, a packet of dried tea leaves, and a whole array of cakes and biscuits. He meticulously settled the items on the counter and was about to heat a kettle when a hand landed on his arm.
“What are you doing?” Bilbo asked, amused. “Tea is my speciality. Go rest, I’ll bring the tray to you.”
Thorin blinked. “Sorry. Force of habit, I suppose.”
Apparently, that reply was worthy of Bilbo’s laugh.
“When did you ever make a habit of drinking tea, Thorin? Oh, don’t get me wrong, this is a pleasant surprise,” his tone softened when he caught Thorin flinching, “the best kind of surprise. We’ll make it together then.”
Warmth flooded his heart, and with that, refreshments were prepared. Bilbo shivered in his thin waistcoat and grumbled, hardly accustomed to the mountain’s chill despite living in Erebor for months, so Thorin draped a cover on his shoulders and the pair relocated to the hearth.
In comfortable armchairs and an equally comfortable silence, they drank their tea and ate their serving, Thorin cautiously watching the flames of his fireplace. I do not like the cold, he pondered, I certainly do not like the heat either. He became quite the fussy one himself. But that was never a bad thing to begin with, wasn’t it. He would simply have to get used to it. In fact, the thought made him smile; he was an expert at finding silver linings at this point.
“You’re changed.”
Thorin blinked at his companion. The words had hurt him once, but the present circumstances were hardly the same. After everything he went through, these words could very well mean the world to him.
“I was a different person, lived a different life in a very different world,” he replied, “I was bound to change.”
“Yet you were still you,” said Bilbo in wonder. “I have difficulties picturing you in this strange place; you’ll forgive me, my mind has a hard time warping itself around all the intricacies, but that is hardly my point. What I want to say is, you seem so… calm? Introspective, but not in a damaging way. When I met you, you had your occasional self-reflection sessions, yet you always seemed in pain when you did. Seeing you now… You look more composed.”
Thorin laughed. “I have a lot to think about. And perhaps, for once, I can reminisce on both sorrowful and happy memories without having to act upon them, like, say, retaking a kingdom. It is a calming thought. My fighting days, at the present time, seem to be over. I can take my time losing myself to my musings while enjoying the simple pleasures life has to offer. Hm... And ruling Erebor, of course.”
Bilbo huffed. “Of course.” The hobbit took a sip of tea and began stroking the porcelain saucer with longing. “You’re right. It is a calming thought, to be able to look back on one’s memories without fear of the pain they could bring. That requires a certain level of detachment… Emotional resolution.”
Leaving his cup on the side, Thorin’s hand reached across the space and curled ever so lightly around the nimble fingers. It made Bilbo startle, but the latter relaxed as fast and gave the king a smile.
“And you’re also right,” Thorin replied. “We have a lot to talk about.”
“Are you going to talk about the Arkenstone?” A soft thumb rubbed over his knuckles in an effort of condolence. “Or the ramparts?”
“We have to. I will not let these memories stand between us. I can’t.”
“We will. But indulge me for the evening, dear. I am still getting accustomed to your return. Would you… Would you tell me more about your world?”
Thorin brushed his own thumb over Bilbo’s skin before retreating his arm. He grinned, “okay, I can do that. What else do you want to know?”
“How long were you in this place?”
“Again, this is hard to answer. I could say it was a few months and I could say it was 48 years. Both are true enough.”
Bilbo made a small jump. “My goodness, 48 years? Your human lifespan, then. T- this is… Yavanna, how do you even relate to us anymore? How- how can you still care about this world when you had a whole life elsewhere?”
“Bilbo… Do not doubt me when I say I hold my life here, my kin, Erebor, everything including, and especially, you very dear to my heart. And as much as I’m fond of some aspects of this alternate plane, it was still all fabricated. I cannot spend the rest of my days in a dream. A very corrupted one at that. It wasn’t all fun and games,” Thorin weakly added. The hobbit scrunched his eyebrows, and he rectified, “some parts of my life there were deeply painful. It wasn’t… It was so, so far from an untroubled one.”
“Forgive me. I shouldn’t have assumed. The world was created by the Arkenstone after all. With the gold madness, and y- your thoughts… And- oh bother, why am I still talking. I’m sorry, Thorin… Please tell me if our discussion becomes too difficult for you.”
“It’s okay. I will tell you.”
“Okay.”
Bilbo wringed his hands. The dwarf stayed silent for a moment, wondering how he could soothe his companion’s worries. With a flutter in his chest, he spoke.
“I want to show you something.”
Feeling quite daring, Thorin pulled Bilbo’s chair closer with a strong grip and to his delight, the hobbit snickered and playfully slapped his bicep. Chuckles subsiding, he reached in his pocket and pulled out his ring, held it between them, trapping it in their new proximity.
“This is an object that came from the alternate world.”
His companion leaned in, tracing the golden curves with his awed gaze. “It’s beautiful, Thorin. And very fascinating, how does that work? Perhaps Gandalf has a clue.” Then Bilbo’s face turned contemplative. “This is odd. Our rings are very much alike.”
In a rustle of fabric, the hobbit took a small object out of the folds of his waistcoat. The sight of both jewelleries sitting in their palms next to each other brought a rush of fondness to the dwarf.
“It was my wedding band.” Bilbo raised an eyebrow, and Thorin paused for a short moment before carrying on with carefully chosen words, “the person to which I was betrothed is not a subject I will dive into this evening; that requires some… extensive context. And I will give you the full tale. But to get back to the matter at hand: such rings are an oath for affection, devotion, and companionship. For loyalty, to your partner and yourself. The love aspect of it is an integral part, of course, but it means so much more. For me, it was my greatest comfort, especially when I felt lost and confused. It was hope."
The king twirled the ring between his fingers, entranced by its shine. He went on.
“Because all these promises came in this delicate golden form. And for the first time since I was taken by Dragon Sickness, it didn’t hurt. It did not change me, nor did it trap me. It was just there, on my hand. When the world came to an end and I awoke, it was in my pocket.” He made a move to put the ring. “I am endlessly thankful that I get to keep such a gift.”
His actions were interrupted by a light touch on his wrist. The hobbit spoke with hesitance, “do you not fear falling to the sickness again? It is still gold after all. The consequences could differ between your dream world and this one.”
“No. Never to this.”
Thorin’s voice came down to a whisper. “Like I said, it’s a long story, dear. What I’m trying to tell you right now is, this ring? Amidst the insanity, it was the only piece of gold that could keep me sane.”
A promise to heal. A hope for brighter times.
Lost in memories of an alternate life, Thorin slipped his ring in its rightful place and, in the reflection, watched the golden figure gazing back with peace of mind. He felt like himself, serene and complete.
Then, wishing to humour the tradition, he took the other piece of jewellery. Holding his companion’s hand, his thumb caressed each of its curves, from the firm palm to the tip of every calloused finger; in no rush. His mind was very much distracted, missing the tremble in the other’s shoulders. Finally, he put the Ring on Bilbo’s finger. The dwarf pressed a kiss to the invisible knuckles and lifted his head with a sheepish but hopeful smile.
Silently, the hand left his own.
He waited.
Breathing hard and thoughts muddled by a fiery haze, Biblo feels his face being contorted to a grimace. He tries to fight the rage filling his chest, to no avail. Cruel mirth infiltrates his words as he speaks, a smirk on his lips.
“How very sweet. My Ring is the only piece of gold that can turn me mad.”
He lunges at the thief’s throat.
THE END.
