Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Eye of the Beholder

Summary:

Thorin Durin strode confidently down the bustling streets of Erebor, his shoulders back and his head held high. His dark locks fell in lustrous waves, neatly framing his angular features and piercing blue eyes. His muscled arms bulged against the tailored button-down shirt he wore.

Yes, he was accustomed to turning heads. In business meetings and bars alike, his presence dominated the room. Thorin knew well the power that came with good looks, and for years it had served him well.

Notes:

The reverse trope prompt for this story was: Ugly Duckling in Reverse

Work Text:

Thorin Durin strode confidently down the bustling streets of Erebor, his shoulders back and his head held high. His dark locks fell in lustrous waves, neatly framing his angular features and piercing blue eyes. His muscled arms bulged against the tailored button-down shirt he wore.

Yes, he was accustomed to turning heads. In business meetings and bars alike, his presence dominated the room. Thorin knew well the power that came with good looks, and for years it had served him well.

His profile on the dating app Grindr was very popular, and he was never in want of someone to hook up with.

When he wasn't working or dating, he was at the gym or the spa - working out, receiving facials and body scrubs. That left him little time for other activities like shopping. He had a personal assistant to handle such tasks, and he had also hired a nutritionist to help him maintain his perfectly toned physique.

He had told himself it was all worth it. As a teenager, it wasn't so. He had been too tall, too thin, and too awkward. He had suffered from teenage acne and greasy hair.

But everything changed once he had earned his degree and gone to work at his father's company. That was also when he had gone on his first actual date with a man.

The date had gone horribly wrong. The man's name was Thranduil, and he owned a health spa in the city. He told Thorin quite plainly that he wasn’t attractive enough for him and had made some very specific suggestions to Thorin about how he could improve his looks and his image.

At first, Thorin had been embarrassed and angry. He hadn't felt so belittled since middle school. And yet, as days passed, he took a hard look in the mirror, noticing his dated hairstyle, his wrinkled plaid shirt he’d bought from a wholesale outlet, and the stubble on his chin because he’d been too tired to shave.

He decided he could do better. And so, Thorin changed his life. After a year, everything was going well until one fateful morning when a chance encounter inside a coffee shop altered his very existence. While grabbing his regular sugar-free, fat-free chai tea, Thorin noticed a man hunched sullenly in the corner, his nose buried in a book. Unruly dark-blond curls obscured the man's face, and his clothes hung rather shapelessly on his small frame. Thorin normally wouldn't have given such a man a second glance, but something was drawing him in. Maybe it was the man's total lack of interest and the challenge he presented.

Curiosity pushed Thorin to break the stranger's solitude. "Good read?" he offered with a charming grin, perhaps overly confident in using such an icebreaker. But the startling multi-colored eyes that peeked over the pages were cool and calculating, seeing straight through Thorin's superficial facade.

"Appearances can be deceiving," the man replied evenly, and just like that, dismissed him. Thorin was used to people fawning over him, not...whatever that was. It planted an irritating seed in his head. He rushed out of the coffee shop, doing his best to forget about the rejection. But he couldn't. The challenge was real, and he was even more determined.

The following morning, he visited the same coffee shop, and lo and behold, there was the man sitting in the same spot. He was reading a different book, but just as before, didn't seem to notice anything around him.

This time, Thorin stood next to the booth, displaying his most radiant smile when the man's eyes gazed up at him through his gold-rimmed, round spectacles.

"May I help you?" the man asked in a lilting voice that Thorin found quite charming. It was neither too deep nor too high and squeaky - it was perfect.

"Fancy meeting you here twice in a row," Thorin said, sliding into the seat across from the man without waiting for an invitation. "We seem to keep running into each other."

The man continued to stare at Thorin, annoyance flashing in his eyes, which were a striking combination of blue, gray, and brown.

"And you seem incapable of taking a hint. I'm trying to read."

"No need to be rude, I was just being friendly," Thorin said with an easy smile. "I'm Thorin Durin. You never told me your name yesterday."

"Bilbo. Now if you don't mind..." the man sighed.

Thorin was determined. "Don't be that way, Bilbo. I have no place to be and I wouldn't mind spending some time getting to know you. I promise I'm great company." He leaned in conspiratorially. "Unless you're afraid you'll enjoy it?"

Bilbo's eyes narrowed. "You're insufferable. Leave. Me. Alone."

"And miss out on the opportunity of getting to know you? I don't think so. What are you drinking? Care for a refill?" Thorin offered.

"You certainly are stubborn, I'll give you that!" Bilbo exclaimed in exasperation.

Thorin huffed. "And you're as infuriatingly clever as you look unremarkable."

Bilbo smirked. "Ah, you think yourself quite the prize, don't you? But true worth lies deeper than a pretty face, as I'm sure you'll learn one day. If you're lucky."

A flush rose in Thorin's cheeks, though whether from anger or embarrassment, he couldn't say. Few had dared question his merit before, yet Bilbo's insults rang with unfamiliar wisdom.

Still, Thorin wasn't ready to surrender. He bristled and leaned forward onto the table, his voice lowering with aggravation. "I'll have you know I've worked very hard to become the man I am today. You wouldn't believe how many doors open for someone like me."

Yet Bilbo simply met his glower with patience. "Doors of substance or folly? What's inside matters far more than what is revealed on the outside, Thorin Durin."

Thorin had heard enough. He rose with a huff, tossed his empty paper cup into the trash, and left the building. He didn't return to the coffee shop for the rest of the week.

On Saturday, he went in for his normal spa treatments but stayed after his appointment to seek out the owner.

"What did you need to see me about?" Thranduil asked, his eyebrows raised haughtily. The thick brows resembled two fuzzy woolly bear caterpillars sitting on his face. The man was ridiculous. Why had he ever listened to him?

"Nothing," Thorin said, changing his mind with the abrupt realization that he didn't need Thranduil's opinions or suggestions anymore.

The next day, Thorin visited a local barber; not the Gentleman's Grooming Club where he was paying an exorbitant monthly fee. He asked for a simple haircut, perhaps a bit more stylish than he used to wear. An older man named Gloin with a long red beard and tattoos looked pleased to cut Thorin's hair, and Thorin even enjoyed their conversation as the dark locks fell to the floor. Gazing at his reflection afterward, Thorin saw the humble and honest man he used to be, not the swaggering, cocky one he had tried to become.

He went home and shoved his tailored suits to one side of his closet, digging until he found a few old favorites. Somewhere in there were his faded jeans, which he hadn't worn in years. He slipped them on, pleased they still fit and then pulled on a soft, blue flannel shirt.

Thorin still had to wear suits to the office, but he dressed them down a little now, forgoing the diamond cuff links and silk ties. His coworkers noticed the difference and to his surprise, began to be more friendly toward him.

On his day off, Thorin chose to visit the local coffee shop. It had been nearly a month since he had last spoken to Bilbo, and he didn't expect to see him there again. That was okay - the changes Thorin had made were for himself, not anyone else. Still, he hoped Bilbo would show because he just wanted to talk to him.

Thorin stepped up to the counter, drawing a smile from the woman behind it, whose name badge read "Tauriel."

"What'll it be?" she asked in a friendly manner.

Thorin recognized her, though she didn't seem to recognize him. "I think I'll have the most fattening, biggest coffee you have - something with caramel and whipped cream," he said, scanning the menu.

"Sure thing," Tauriel replied. "Hey, have you been in here before? I'm not sure I've seen you."

Thorin chuckled. "Nope," he answered.

"Huh, okay. Can I get a name?" she asked.

"Thorin," he told her, forgoing his usual "Durin" request.

As Thorin waited for his order, he glanced around, disappointed not to see Bilbo. When they called his name, he returned to the counter to retrieve his drink. That's when he heard a somewhat familiar voice.

"That's not your usual drink," it said. "Where's the fat-free, sugar-free Chai tea?"

Thorin's heart rate sped up. What was it about this man he found so attractive? He wasn't Thorin's usual type. He usually dated selfish, self-absorbed men like Thranduil. Maybe Thorin had lost his foolishness along with his hair.

"Thought I'd try something new," Thorin remarked.

"Good day, Mr. Baggins!" Tauriel said with a bright smile. "Is Frodo feeling better?"

"Ah, yes," Bilbo answered as Tauriel prepared his drink without asking what he wanted. "It was just a minor cold, not the near-death experience he was claiming it was."

Tauriel laughed as she frothed the milk. "Isn't that typical of most men? Something called 'man flu,' isn't it?"

"If you say so," Bilbo replied, while Thorin listened intently without moving. "Although I wouldn't know about such things, would I?" he teased before paying for his drink. "Thank you, dear," Bilbo said, then turned to Thorin. "Shall we?" he said with a tilt of his head.

"Shall we what?" Thorin replied with a little confusion.

"Go have a seat in my regular booth. Isn't that why you're standing here waiting for me? Would you like to join me?"

"Yes," Thorin answered immediately, his mind momentarily occupied by the name Frodo - was he Bilbo's boyfriend, husband, or roommate?

They took a seat in the corner booth where Thorin had first seen Bilbo. Something was different with the scene. He wasn't reading a book, despite having a bag with him. All of his attention was on Thorin. For the first time in a while, Thorin struggled to think of something clever, finding it quite difficult to be himself.

"So, Mr. Durin," Bilbo said, smiling into his latte. "You look...comfortable. How have you been? I haven't seen you in a while."

The usual spite was missing from Bilbo's tone. Had he been looking for Thorin?

"I've been...finding myself," Thorin finally said.

"Hm," Bilbo hummed, putting down his cup. "Were you lost?"

There was a slight tease in his tone, but Bilbo's gaze was serious. Honesty was Thorin's best hope, knowing Bilbo could see through his disguises as he had since their first meeting.

"I was misplaced," he admitted. "But I've recently had some pivotal moments and made some changes."

Bilbo smiled at him in a genuinely warm way. "I like the changes," he said simply, which meant more to Thorin than Bilbo could know.

They finished their drinks, engaging in easy conversation about their respective families. Thorin learned that Frodo was Bilbo's adopted nephew, whose parents had passed away. Thorin suggested a play date for Frodo with his own nephews, which Bilbo readily agreed to.

They left the coffee shop together; two average men strolling along the crowded city streets. Whether he realized it or not, it was Bilbo who had offered the support Thorin needed. He was thankful he had been able to recognize it and was wise enough to accept it with grace. Real beauty lay in what could not be seen and Thorin had never felt so radiant.

Series this work belongs to: