Work Text:
“I wish it would stop snowing.”
Bilbo leaned on the window sill, one of the few in the mountain, and felt a strange tug in his heart at the growing dance of snowflakes outside. He shouldn't have said that; he knew as soon as the words had left his lips, and still, he did not take them back.
Thorin behind him grunted. By now, Bilbo could interpret every type of grunt the dwarven king made, and still, it did not seem enough. Greedily, Bilbo wanted more and more, to drown himself in every part of Thorin, to be the only one to know him that way - he resented himself for it, but still kept wanting.
This grunt was a displeased one. Thorin was often displeased these days, and perhaps that shouldn’t be strange; he was still recovering from his wounds, battling with his guilt, and also running a kingdom that had been brought to ruin. Bilbo shouldn’t have been surprised at his mood, or hurt by it, but again, he couldn’t help himself, and felt that this was somehow his fault.
Which it probably was. He shouldn’t have spoken about the snow like this.
“It won’t stop anytime soon. Winters in Erebor are long.”
Thorin sounded bitter, offended. As if Bilbo had insulted him; it was a little childish, and Bilbo might have said so - in another time, a time that was past. He couldn’t quite recall when it had been, when he and Thorin had been so open with each other, but he was sure the time had existed, however short it had been. Bilbo longed for it.
These days, he was never quite sure what Thorin wanted from him, or what he wanted from himself.
“Don’t you miss the sunlight?” Maybe Bilbo shouldn't have kept going, but he felt unable to stop. His fingers brushed against the frame of the window, so foreign and cold, and for a moment, he wanted to open it, so wide he could stretch his head out, and breathe in the cold air till it froze his lungs. And then, maybe then he could scream, or maybe Thorin would - maybe Thorin would, and that seemed like all that mattered.
But Bilbo didn’t move.
“I’m a dwarf.” Thorin’s voice sounded quieter now, almost sad. “We live underground. I do not crave the sun.”
I wish you would crave me. But Bilbo didn’t say that, of course.
“And I am a hobbit who loves the sun very greatly. I hope it will come out again soon.”
Now, Thorin snarled. What an ugly sound, Bilbo thought, and yet, he did not blame his friend for it. Perhaps all this mess was his fault; he shouldn’t have stayed in Erebor in the first place. Gandalf had offered to bring him home, more than once, but stubbornly, Bilbo hadn’t even considered taking him up on it, his heart filled with fear that Thorin might yet succumb to his wounds. He had sat next to him, next to the sleeping Thorin, when Gandalf had asked him the last time, and Bilbo had looked at the dwarven king’s face and not missed his home a bit.
He hadn’t thought it through. He hadn’t really thought anything, at the time. Everything had just been felt; sort of experienced, but not evaluated. Bilbo had wanted to stay with Thorin, and so, Gandalf had left by himself - and hadn’t that seemed right, at the time? But now, Bilbo knew that Thorin didn’t want him here, not truly, that he looked at the hobbit with this quiet sort of pain every day, and it felt as if Bilbo’s heart might break due to it.
He shouldn’t have stayed. He should have expected that their relationship was too strained. He should have…
But stupidly, Bilbo also knew that he would do it just the same again if given the choice.
“I cannot will away the snow, Master Burglar.”
“I did not ask you to.” Bilbo didn’t turn around to Thorin. He was rude, perhaps, or ungrateful, for not appreciating the fact that Thorin had granted him the room with the biggest windows, the one his mother had lived in; for speaking of the sun in a mountain of all places; for not looking at Thorin even though he provided him with everything he could. But it was simply impossible to meet those blue eyes and see all the things that had happened between the two of them reflected in them, knowing that they could not be undone.
Bilbo had tried, really had, to go back to acting the way he had before. But it seemed the more he tried, the angrier Thorin became; he sought out Bilbo’s presence almost every evening, and Bilbo never refused him - but the dwarf wasn’t happy, and it felt like no matter what Bilbo did, he only made things worse.
Maybe he could run away. Maybe he could tell Thorin to stay away from him. But he didn’t want to; he wanted Thorin with him, even though nothing he ever said seemed right. What a mess for a simple hobbit to get himself into - oh, how they would have laughed at him back in the Shire.
But Bilbo wasn’t in the Shire anymore, and looking at the piles of white outside the window, it felt like he never again would be.
“What is it that you ask of me, then?”
Bilbo closed his eyes, wishing for the right answer to that to come to him. It didn’t. “I don’t ask for anything, Thorin.”
Sometimes it almost felt like resistance, to still use Thorin’s first name. Thorin rarely called him Bilbo anymore, and everyone else seemed intent on addressing the new king the way that was proper - but Bilbo felt that he would lose the last piece of connection they had if he did the same. Your Majesty. Hobbits did not have kings, and Bilbo did not want to be one of Thorin’s subjects.
He did not want to be like everyone else to Thorin. What a thing to wish for.
“And yet you are unhappy.” Thorin’s voice was always so strained these days; it seemed no sentence to Bilbo could just be spoken, but instead had to be pressed out between his lips as if it was a chore. “Do not deny it. If there is anything you desire, you shall have it if it is within my power.”
And didn’t that mean so much, too? But once Bilbo had felt the possibility that there might be more between them, months ago, he could never be satisfied with words like these. And he still didn’t want to turn around; how childish to feel like this, to lose himself in these meaningless hopes and wants when there was a kingdom to rebuild, and a future to carve.
Bilbo might be greedy, but he was still a Baggins. Being rude this way was simply unacceptable.
And so, Bilbo finally did turn around to Thorin, who sat on that chair next to Bilbo’s small table, his eyes fixated on the hobbit as if nothing was more important. He was starting to look better, healthier, although he still needed a crane to walk. He was starting to grow out his beard again, Bilbo had noticed, and suited him - suited him too much, really. It made him look like a king, and of course, he was one now; but as happy as Bilbo was for him to have achieved that, he also hated it, just a little bit. Exiled Thorin had been his friend, had seemed reachable, somehow, but the king under the mountain was no one a hobbit could have any kind of aspirations for. If Thorin had stayed the dwarf he had been before…
How horrible of Bilbo to feel this way. He needed to stop dreaming.
“There is nothing else you can do for me, Thorin. As you say, you can’t make the snow melt and spring come.”
Bilbo had tried to make his words sound lighthearted, but Thorin’s frown deepened. What could he have replied to make him smile?
“You don’t feel at home in Erebor.”
It wasn’t a question, so Bilbo didn’t try to refute it.
“The mountain was built for dwarves, not hobbits. I cannot make it suit your demands at whim-”
“I did not ask you to do that.” Bilbo felt irritated at Thorin’s accusing tone; as if he did not have the right to miss the Shire, or to wish for the sun. He shouldn’t have brought this up, no, but he also wouldn’t let Thorin demand how he was supposed to feel. Was craving some grass under his feet, the smell of flowers in the air or the sound of birds, really an attack on Thorin? Everything Bilbo said these days seemed to be. “I did not ask you for anything, in fact. Erebor is wonderful the way it is.”
For Bilbo could get used to all this, he knew. Used to long winters, used to the dark, used to stone.
But not used to Thorin resenting him.
“But you do not enjoy being here. You crave to leave.” Thorin’s blue eyes were so piercing that Bilbo felt he should look away; yet, he didn’t. If everything was going worse by the day either way, if they never again managed to converse in a way where they understood each other, at least they should look each other in the eye while doing it. Their relationship deserved that much. “If it is not Erebor that bothers you, there must be something else.”
He said it in a way that told Bilbo he knew what it was. Why did he bring it up this way, then? And with this quietness, too; Thorin wasn’t supposed to be quiet, he was confident and proud. Sometimes Bilbo wished he would just be yelled at, for that would have made things clear, and other times, he tried to provoke Thorin into doing so. One honest, open fight - but Bilbo was also fearful to have that moment come, and so he never pushed Thorin far enough.
What did Thorin truly want from him, anyway? Bilbo regretted many things, but not how he had acted with the Arkenstone. He hadn’t apologised for it, either. Perhaps if he had, things would be different now, but then he would have ultimately lost himself, and he had enough pride left not to let it come to that.
“Am I not allowed to feel unhappy at times?” Bilbo tried to change the flow of the conversation, but he already knew it wouldn’t work when Thorin squinted his eyes.
“Am I not allowed to care about your happiness?”
“Of course you are.”
“Then tell me what it is that makes you so miserable.”
Maybe this was the moment. Maybe this was when it all ended. And really, was there a reason not to let it come to that?
Not that it would truly change anything. Bilbo would see Thorin tomorrow, and the day afterwards, and the day after that, too. There was no way to have an actual cut.
“It’s you.” Bilbo spoke quietly, watching how Thorin’s face twitched. “And what is between us now. But you knew that already, didn’t you?”
He felt almost angry, for the fact that Thorin had made him say it. And now, after, Thorin only looked at him with that silent, frustrated expression, as if this was all Bilbo’s fault; as if the hobbit was making him suffer, for not being able to accept his friendship.
But Bilbo couldn’t. How could he, when Thorin never even smiled in his presence any more?
It didn’t take long for the king under the mountain to leave after that. Bilbo didn’t blame him.
***
When Bilbo felt the first warm ray of sunshine, he stood on the ramparts, his fingers clinging to the stone. It wasn’t truly warm; really, it felt only slightly less cold. But for Bilbo, that was enough to release a little sigh of happiness, to close his eyes and imagine spring, imagine the lands of Erebor without the snow, filled with grass and flowers.
Bilbo often went on to the ramparts, despite everything. Sometimes it depressed him endlessly, sometimes he only stayed for a minute, but still, something drove him to this place without fault, and he did not try to fight it. He liked how far one could see from up here, too - it seemed as if the Shire really was not so far away after all.
Thorin never wanted Bilbo to be on the ramparts by himself. Bilbo found it silly, but had become used to the guard watching him from behind by now. It was unbelievable, the things you could get used to if you only tried; living with dwarves, being underground, sitting in a council meeting concerning gold prices. The only thing that Bilbo could not get used to, it seemed, was Thorin.
And yet, his heart did not care for the dwarf any less. He did not want it to, either. Foolish, hopeless hobbit.
“You may leave us alone.”
Bilbo twitched in surprise at the sudden deep voice and turned around, but quickly realised that it wasn’t directed at him. The guard left his usual place, and instead, Thorin stepped onto the ramparts, stopping next to Bilbo, although at a safe distance.
How Bilbo wished Thorin would invade his space. How he wished he could see warmth in his face, an indication of interest, but instead, Thorin only looked at him with that frown, tension in his entire body.
Was it truly so hard to even look at Bilbo?
How angry this all made him. How frustrating it was, too, that Thorin never spoke first these days, always awaiting Bilbo’s words, as if only they could make him open his mouth. Thorin spoke to everyone else just fine, so why was it only Bilbo that was treated so coldly, as if he didn’t belong, as if he was some foreign object in this mountain?
Because you don’t, and because you are. And you know why.
Maybe Thorin would tell him it was time to leave Erebor now that the sun was coming out and spring not far away. Maybe it would truly all end.
“Is there something I can help you with?” Bilbo made it a point to look at Thorin directly, and he found he had no idea what mood Thorin was in. Were they growing apart even more? Bilbo did not want to lose him, not completely.
“You have been outside for quite a while. I wanted to see if you are alright.” Thorin’s voice was calm, and despite his anger, Bilbo felt the sincerity in his words.
“I am. Thank you for inquiring.” His own voice was polite, but distant. He found that if there was less emotion in the things he said, Thorin had less to get irritated by.
The dwarf stepped a little closer. Carefully, as if approaching an animal; but it was just Bilbo, and there was no need to be on guard around him, wasn’t there? “You were smiling.”
Was it an accusation? It did not sound like one, and Bilbo did not want to be cruel. It did not sound happy either, though, but a little resentful, and that undoubtedly hurt. Was Bilbo not allowed a smile?
“So I was.” He almost added Your Majesty, to give the absurdity of this conversation more weight, but that would have been childish.
“It is the sun.” Did Thorin have to sound so angry when he said that? “You haven’t smiled in weeks, but as soon as you see the sun, you do.”
Bilbo stared at Thorin, at the king, and found he could not keep on being calm. There were a million things to do, there was a kingdom to run, and yet, Thorin stood here, complaining that Bilbo had the audacity to be happy that the sun was shining? No, it was too much.
“And what does that concern you? I get to smile at whatever I like. I get to be happy, just like everybody else.”
Thorin furrowed his brows. Bilbo couldn’t see his mouth as well as he used to, given the longer beard, but he was sure Thorin was clenching his teeth, too. “I am not trying to take away your joy.”
“But you resent me for it.” Bilbo did not want it all to collapse; in truth, he loved Thorin too much to hear him say it out loud. But perhaps, if he heard it, he could let go? “Of all the things to fill your day with, you decide to come and berate me for being happy at seeing sunshine. Don’t you feel ridiculous?”
“That is not why I’m here.” Thorin’s voice was cold. “And not what I resent, Master Burglar. Stop insinuating -”
“Then what is it you resent?” Bilbo had enough. He was cold, and lonely, and his heart ached so much he felt like crying. “Besides me, of course. Or is it just that?”
Thorin’s expression became hurt, and Bilbo realised he had gone too far. He knew Thorin didn’t hate him; he knew Thorin cared for him, too. But in his silly mind, anything that was not the love he wished for seemed nothing but cruel. “You think I resent you?”
“You treat me like you do”, Bilbo replied, his own voice feeling foreign. “You don’t even say my name any more.”
Perhaps it was silly to point out this thing specifically, but he was reminded of it every time he and Thorin met. Bilbo was a friend, someone close, someone Thorin could trust; Master Baggins was an acquaintance, someone tolerated. And Master Burglar? A job description, and a job which was already fulfilled, too. It made Bilbo feel like he wasn’t needed any more.
“Can you really not see?” Thorin’s was heated now, angry, and Bilbo regretted having said all these things. But he did not move backwards, not when Thorin stepped closer, not when his face became twisted, and not when he saw the dwarf clench his fist. “Can’t you see how it hurts me to see you miss your home so much? To see how you crave to leave, how even the chance of a spring coming, a chance for you to travel home makes you smile while I never manage to? Resentment is a strong word, Master Burglar; but in every action you do, you show me how little you enjoy being in my presence -”
“My name is Bilbo.” Looking at Thorin, everything seemed to make less and less sense. Bilbo did not understand it; and right now, he only felt like he did not want to be accused any more. “In case you have forgotten.”
It took a moment, but Thorin’s face became a little softer. How strange; Bilbo had thought he might yell. But the king under the mountain only looked at him, his eyes filled with sorrow and a quiet pain.
“I could never forget it.” Again, Thorin sounded so quiet; afraid, almost. The same look Bilbo had loathed these past weeks, that look that seemed to say that all the trust built between them was gone.
Still, it seemed different now.
“Bilbo -” Thorin’s voice broke, and Bilbo felt his heart twitch, not knowing why, eyes widened, mind blank. “I have tried in so many ways, yet none of them have been fruitful. I have thought of you, for so long, of every little thing you have told me, in words or otherwise; and yet, no matter what I do, I cannot seem to reach you - not even now. Is there really not anything that would make you stay? Anything at all that might change your mind?” He stepped closer, closer than he had in what seemed forever, and with a touch unbearably soft, he reached out for Bilbo’s hand.
He sounded desperate and bitter, yet frail, so frail that a breath of wind might make him stumble.
Such beautiful eyes, Bilbo thought, looking up at him. Like sapphires.
“Bilbo -” Voice quiet, trembling, almost. “Is there not anything I can do to make you love me?”
Ah.
As if a storm had stopped. As if his heart had decided to stop beating. Bilbo was sure he wanted to breathe, but he couldn’t; he couldn’t even blink, his eyes fixed on Thorin, only Thorin, while the world seemed to have come to a halt.
Something inside of him understood before his mind did. His fingers wrapped around Thorin’s, slowly but surely, and the words seemed to repeat themselves in his ears, clear, and yet not easy to make sense of.
It was more what was behind them that made Bilbo speak up; the emotions that seemed similar to his own. Were they now, finally, speaking the same language again, for the first time in so long?
“But I do love you.” Bilbo’s own voice was more confident than he had felt in ages, and his mind seemed to have been cleared of anything that wasn’t the present. “I could hardly love you more, I think.”
He added I think, but Bilbo wasn’t really thinking much at all. His heart was pounding loudly now, he could feel it in his chest, and the longer he looked at Thorin, the faster it seemed to go. Thorin had something in his face akin to bewilderment, but mostly it was denial, seemingly prepared to close himself off any second.
But Bilbo wouldn’t let him, now.
“You cannot.” Thorin’s lips were pressed together in pain, but he did not look away, and did not pull his hand away either. “I see you avoiding me - I see you get angry at me. You turn your face away when I enter a room. I do not blame you for it; after everything that has happened -”
“I look at you a lot", Bilbo said. “You just never seem to want to meet my eye.”
“I spend every minute I have seeking you out”, Thorin replied, almost defensively. “You could hardly mistake that for anything else.”
He did not want to, but Bilbo couldn’t help but laugh at that. The laugh was freeing, although it also made him feel a little high, a little mad. Thorin looked at him, still bewildered, but a little more relaxed, and absurdly, the hobbit got the urge to kiss him.
“I thought you wanted me gone”, he said instead, trying to stifle his laughter again. The situation was not funny, just absurd - but it was true, wasn’t it? Thorin did not want him gone. He didn’t. He… “You never smile at me any more.”
“You do not smile at me either.” This time, Thorin did not sound defensive, but thoughtful, and it seemed that he, too, was starting to understand. “You are distant, whenever we speak.”
“Because you created that distance.”
“Because I am trying to give you space, after what I did to you.”
The words were riddled with pain, and right then, Bilbo felt it in his own chest, and understood. Perhaps, perhaps, perhaps -
It was not over, after all.
“I would like to stay here.” Bilbo hadn’t felt like himself this much since a long time ago, and as he was speaking it, the truth, he felt he was regaining a sense of what he truly wanted. “Very much. But I -” He did hesitate, because it was so much to ask for, wasn’t it? Greedy, selfish, completely out of question for a hobbit like him. But Thorin looked at him, fully now, and it felt like things had before - back when Bilbo had fallen in love with him.
Which had already been mad, and still, he had done it. He might as well keep on going, foolish hobbit he was.
“I can only stay here if you love me, Thorin.”
Bilbo took a little breath, and waited. Thorin’s eyes widened, and his grip became tighter; Bilbo must be imagining it, but the dwarf seemed to move closer to him, too, leaning in.
He was not imagining it.
Thorin’s forehead went down on Bilbo’s shoulder, his hair tickling Bilbo’s nose. Arms wrapped around him, softly, but with noticeable intent; Thorin took a deep breath, as if he wanted to inhale all that Bilbo could offer, and when his mouth touched Bilbo’s ear, the hobbit shivered. “I love you, Bilbo, amrâlimê. I love you more than this mountain and all its gold, more than light and darkness. I -” He stopped, and his warm breath hit Bilbo’s ear. “I love you more than I can express, my dear hobbit. I thought you knew.”
Bilbo felt the tears dwell up in his eyes, and tried to stop them. It didn’t work. “I thought you didn’t anymore. Couldn’t. You’re a king now, and -” And there were so many other things, too, but Bilbo’s heart felt so relieved he didn’t manage to recall them now.
I love you, he thought, and for once, he did not feel guilty thinking it.
“I believed you despised me. Which I would have understood; I could have lived with.” Thorin tried to explain himself, but the words felt as if they missed a lot of context; he too, seemed too overwhelmed to make sense. His head was still on Bilbo’s shoulder, and when he rubbed his face slightly against Bilbo’s cheek, the hobbit felt his skin tingle.
“Could you really have?” Bilbo wiped his tears away. “I don’t think so. I would not want you to.”
Thorin hummed deeply. “No, perhaps I couldn’t have.” He leaned even closer, as if he was afraid Bilbo would leave his arms. “I wish for your presence every second of the day, Bilbo; even if I wanted to, I could not stop loving you. I resent myself for it, but that changes little.”
“I thought it was me who you resented.” Bilbo swallowed, and things started to become a little clearer. He had misunderstood Thorin - just as Thorin had misunderstood him. Deeply held pain slowly seemed to make its way to the top again, to be reevaluated, to be, perhaps, healed. Bilbo couldn’t grasp all the things he felt, all the things to question, but still, it seemed he might hope for happier times. Still - “Do you think we could make it work, this time?”
Thorin was silent for a bit, and Bilbo felt he should have worded things differently. Had they ever truly tried it before? What did it entail, even? All Bilbo knew was that he wanted it; and after feeling grey and empty for so long, wanting something this strongly made his head spin.
He had asked Thorin whether it could work, but Bilbo really only wanted one answer. His hand slowly went up Thorin’s body till he could touch one strand of his hair; twisting it in his fingers, he waited, for what could hardly be longer than a few seconds, but felt like hours.
“I would do right by you.” Thorin buried his head further into Bilbo’s shoulder, and the hobbit now recognised what the shyness, the hesitancy Thorin had displayed around him had truly meant. “I promise that. Shall Mahal behead me if I ever -”
“Alright, alright”, Bilbo said, hiding a smile. “You can share your dwarven melodramatics later; let us stay on topic, first.”
Now Thorin pulled back, and his expression looked a little offended. Not enough to pull back entirely, but enough to make Bilbo reconsider. “They aren’t melodramatics. There is no higher promise to make than to swear to Mahal; do not make fun of it.”
“I apologise", Bilbo said, and he meant it. “Only - well, you did not answer my question from before. And since it seems we could work on our communication, perhaps we should start there.”
Thorin blinked, and if Bilbo squinted, he could see a bit of red on his cheeks. “You may be right about that.” Thorin cleared his throat, and the whole thing seemed absurd; after all the things he had just said, was this what Thorin was nervous about? But both of them were rather absurd together, in the end. “I believe we can do it. Make it work, as you say.” The dwarf halted, and his eyes stayed on Bilbo’s.
No contempt in them. And perhaps there had never been any at all; or at least, not in the way Bilbo had thought. It was cruel, how strongly love could make you see hate.
“I would like to try, if you will let me.” Thorin spoke with all his royalty, and Bilbo couldn't help but feel impossibly happy about the honesty in his voice. “Although - I don’t think I could try, so to say. I can either do it, or not.” Thorin made a little sound, reflecting his frustration at the inability to express what he wanted to. “If you know what I mean.”
And right now, Bilbo did. It was a wonderful feeling, and he vowed to keep it for as long as he could; squeezing Thorin’s hand, still in his, still his, he allowed a smile to crawl onto his lips. “I believe I do.”
