Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

The Fourteen Redemptions of Thorin Oakenshield

Summary:

Thorin Oakenshield's life ends, and begins again - hundreds of years earlier, on the same battlefield where he earned his name. Caught in a cycle that seems to have no end, Thorin can do nothing but attempt to fix his mistakes, lest he be trapped for all time.

Notes:

This fic was inspired by a wonderful art piece by anothershadowintheuniverse - Slide #24 from Tolkien Reverse Summer Bang 2026, entitled Wait for me (I'm coming Home).

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Thorin Oakenshield

The Eagles are coming. Thorin, look – but when Thorin looks up, it’s not eagles he sees circling the plains before Moria’s eastern gate. The gore-crows and vultures have been circling since the sun rose, drawn to the battle that began before dawn. Already, there is much for them to feast on, and by the time the fighting ends, there will still be more. All that remains is the question of whether Thorin will join them.

Thorin’s brother fell this morning, and as he watched the life leave Frerin’s eyes, Thorin swore that he would survive. Yet as the day has worn on, he’s become less and less certain of his vow. The waves of Orcs and Goblins swarming from within Khazad-dûm seem endless, and Thorin’s people are few. No matter how fiercely they fight, Thorin can see no outcome other than death. His people will be extinguished here, the fire they carried within them out of Erebor quenched in blood, and there will be no one left to bury them. All that will remain is empty armor and rusted weapons, and bones picked clean by the birds.

The Eagles –

There are no eagles here. Only scavengers, and something within Thorin rebels at such a fate. He swore that he would not die here, but more than that, he is certain that he is not meant to die here. There is more left for him to do. A different end awaits Thorin, son of Thráin, and when Thorin’s shield is struck from his hand, he continues to fight. When his father vanishes into the throng, leading a futile charge, he continues to fight. And when his grandfather’s head is tossed at his feet by a pale Orc with a wide, laughing mouth filled with jagged teeth, Thorin continues to fight.

The oaken branch he picks up to replace his shield feels right in his hand, familiar, as though it was always meant to be his. It’s natural for him to wield it, as natural as the sword he’s trained with since he was young. And when his sword slices through the pale Orc’s arm, Thorin feels something strange – not triumph, but certainty. Of course this is what happens. This is what was meant to be.

Destiny. For the first time, Thorin feels its hand upon his shoulder, guiding him as he gathers his people to him, as he leads them into a charge that ends in victory for his people. A hollow victory, bought with rivers of Dwarvish blood, and yet, it ends with Thorin ordering his brother’s body burned along with the rest of the dead, rather than lying dead beside him. It must be destiny that shadows Thorin, whispering that victory is what matters, victory at any cost. They won, so it must be worth it. It’s worth it because they won.

Life is cheap, it seems. Their people’s great works are what live on after them, and that is what must be protected, worth more than countless lives. Thorin blinks away smoke-wrought tears as he stands before the pyres, his grandfather and his brother dead, his father missing, and vows that he will reclaim his people’s treasures, one by one. Any price, any life is worth it. Even his own.

Thorin watches the flames climb high, first into the dusk, and then into the night. The scavengers have long since descended to consume the Orcish dead. And still, Thorin looks for the Eagles.


Thorin, look. The Eagles –

There are no Eagles at Azanulbizar this time, either. And before Thorin can question what ‘this time’ means, Azog the Defiler’s mace strikes his shield and smashes it back into his face. Thorin feels his nose break, his eyes water, and he stumbles backwards, over a rise and down a slope, landing hard on his hip, his shoulder. Thorin tucks his head to avoid cracking open his skull, but that’s all he’s able to do. The next blow of the mace shatters his ribs, and when Thorin rolls to one side, he feels shards of bone pierce his lungs.

He lives, still. He has enough strength left in him to block a blow on an oaken branch he snatches up from the ground, and enough strength yet to swing his sword. With the Pale Orc withdrawn from the battlefield to die, Thorin, too, can rest – and yet he’s carried from the battlefield by his soldiers, by his few friends who have survived. He shuts his eyes and finds himself looking up into the face of a healer. The sky is grey, and in the distance, Thorin can see the shadow of a solitary crow, winging its way to the battlefield to feast.

Thorin’s life is long. Longer than he wishes it to be, stretched thin with pain and grief. What kindness was in him to begin with is long gone by the time he embarks on his quest to reclaim his homeland, and those who love him, love him in spite of its absence. Thorin is loved, even though he shouldn’t be. Thorin fails those he loves, at every chance and every turn. He dies in failure, and still in pain.


The Eagles are coming. Thorin, look – Thorin shakes his head to dislodge the voice, and yet it won’t leave him. It echoes in his ear throughout the battle, through every loss and every failed charge, until it comes to an end at last. There is little glory in battle, Thorin has come to realize – although he’s not sure how he came to realize it, given that this is the first true battle in which he’s fought. He cannot call the massacre within Erebor a battle. It’s only a battle if both sides have an equal chance of winning.

Thorin wins his first battle, but he would be glad to never fight another. He knew his brother fell, watched it happen, and yet as he washes his brother’s body for a burial that will never be, he weeps as though he’s stumbled upon Frerin for the first time. Thorin’s eyes blur with tears. No matter how many times he wipes them away, they continue to fall, and sometimes his vision is so obscured that Frerin’s face seems to shift, becoming unfamiliar and familiar again in turns.

His brother’s face haunts his dreams for decades afterward. No matter how long Thorin’s life unspools, he always remembers not just the slackness in his brother’s features, but the way his brother’s face changed through the filter of tears. It’s not until centuries later, when Thorin finds himself looking down into the dead face of his sister’s son, that he understands.

And he need understand for only a few moments. His life has moments left itself. Thorin fights through the rest of it, his limbs heavy with guilt and misery, and when Azog the Defiler’s sword drives through his gut, it’s not pain or fear Thorin feels, but relief. It’s over now. It will be over soon, and then –

“The Eagles,” Bilbo Baggins whispers in Thorin’s ear, his breath warm in a world that’s going cold. “Thorin, look –”

Thorin’s eyes failed him moments ago, his last sight in this life the tear-filled eyes of the Halfling he betrayed. His hearing continues to work, though. Long enough for Bilbo’s voice to split and crack with sorrow, and long enough for that voice to echo in Thorin’s ears long after everything else has fallen silent.


There are two voices, Thorin realizes; one that speaks of Eagles, and one that speaks of ravens. One that sings to him of Erebor, and one that speaks of something else, some far green country that he’s glimpsed only briefly, if at all. One is strong, familiar. The other is faint, borne on a whisper and a wish. Both are familiar to him. Thorin has heard them before. Thorin has heard all of this before.

He has the sense that something went wrong. That this wasn’t supposed to happen. Thorin mourns for the library of Erebor, which certainly held books that detail what happens after one dies. He understands what’s meant to happen, at least; the souls of the dead join Mahal in his halls, to wait there until the last battle, after which the world will be remade. He understands, too, that the Elves disagree. To them, the Dwarves were a mistake, an aberration – something that should never have been, something for which the Maker of All Things has no plan for.

Something has a plan for Thorin, certainly. He can think of no other reason why he would be condemned to repeat the same stretch of time, over and over again. After all, it is not as if he lives his entire life over again. Thorin relives the stretch of time between a victory that was no victory and a victory he will never celebrate. How many times has it happened now? Four – no, five, Thorin realizes. The first time he heard Bilbo’s voice at Azanulbizar, it was because he had heard those words before. They were the last thing he heard before he died the first time.

Thorin has died four times. At the end of the journey to Erebor, he’ll die again, not at peace, but in misery and grief and failure. Dying once would have been enough. Thorin’s sins are not so great as to mandate five more.

The Elves stop them at Rivendell, as always. Thorin knows that the only way forward is to sneak out, to throw himself and his company first into the clutches of the Goblins, then into the jaws of the Wargs, and he dreads it. The pain, mainly. The sense of crushing dread and shame as the white Warg’s jaws close around his midsection. He carries the pain from those wounds for the rest of his life, and it makes him sharp, makes him cruel. This time, perhaps, he would rather not.

So Thorin delays in Rivendell, delays until there is no way for the Company to reach Erebor by Durin’s Day. The journey ends here, at least for Thorin. He wakes one morning to find that his nephews have continued on, taking the rest of the Company with them. Bilbo Baggins, too, accompanies them across the mountains. Thorin waits, and wonders. Part of him hopes that it was his presence that doomed the Company’s chances, that without him, they might prevail. That Erebor is meant to be reclaimed, just not by him.

He dwells at Rivendell, speaking to no one, rather than face the shame of returning to the Blue Mountains with his task uncompleted. With spring comes news from the east– the death of the Company, to a Dwarf, as an Orc army swept down upon the mountain. They did not reach the door in time. They made their stand before the shuttered gates and died there. A more courageous death than any of the four Thorin has already experienced.

And what does it matter? Thorin asks himself, as he considers their sacrifice, poised on the end of his own. Nothing has changed. They’ll only die again.

An Elf sees him, balanced on the rails. Calls out for him to wait, to stop, and Thorin steps off the edge into infinity. It should be infinity. In a just world, Thorin’s life would end here, and instead of striking the rocks at merciless speed –


Thorin crashes back down into his body, once again trudging through the mud and muck of Azanulbizar. This time, his ears are empty of Bilbo’s voice. Only the ravens call to him, singing of Erebor, of the doom that awaits those who attempt to reclaim it. Now Thorin knows that the journey east is inevitable, that if he does not undertake it, someone will. Someone is his oldest friends, who shook their heads at his cowardice and moved on. Someone is his nephews, who die for honor that was never their responsibility to regain. Someone is a halfling, who has no reason to throw his lot in with Thorin but did so anyway.

If Thorin allows them to leave without him, they all die. If they go together, the Company of Thorin Oakenshield, Thorin will not have to live with whatever happens afterward. And that, ultimately, is enough to decide him in favor of the quest for Erebor.

But there’s a great deal of time between Thorin and the quest. Centuries, in fact – and first, Thorin must survive this battle. Survive Azog, ideally without injuries, and survive what happens after. Thorin has stood vigil at too many funerals, and yet, it’s those that go unburied that haunt him. His mother, turned to ash or forever entombed in Erebor’s ruins. His father, never found. There are so many things Thorin would change if he could.

He catalogues those which are too late. Frerin dies early in the day at Azanulbizar, beyond Thorin’s reach. Thorin has tried in every life so far, and he’s never been able to fight his way through the enemy in time to save his grandfather from Azog the Defiler. Those deaths cannot be altered, but the rest – Kíli and Fíli might live. Thorin could still save them. He could win Erebor and save them both, and then, when he dies at the end of the quest, he’ll stay dead.

Is that what it’s come to? Here and there, Thorin finds himself aghast at the thought of what he’s fighting for – his own death, and that it be permanent this time. There must be more to it than that. Some answer hovers out of Thorin’s reach. Perhaps he’ll find it at the end of the quest next time.


“This quest is yours, and yours alone,” Dáin says, as if Thorin is somehow unaware of this fact. The other representatives from the dwarven families are nodding sagely. “Even if the dragon is dead, that mountain is a graveyard. It ought not to be disturbed.”

“The dead who lie there are my kin, not yours,” Thorin says, and as he does at every meeting, Dáin turns bright red. “You swore to answer the call of the high king of our people. Was your oath sworn falsely?”

“My oath was sworn to he who holds the Arkenstone!”

“He who currently holds it? I see now why you refused my grandfather’s call to the battle at Azanulbizar,” Thorin snaps, and Dáin slams his hand down on the table hard enough to spill flagons of beer. “As you will. I had not thought to see my own kin act more faithless than the elves.”

“And I had not thought to watch another one of Durin’s line descend into madness, but it seems we are both wrong!” Dáin explodes. “Your grandfather was not fit to lead our people. Neither are you!”

“And yet, I am still Durin’s heir,” Thorin says. “If you would like to change that, be my guest.”

He’s set this challenge to Dáin at least twice before, and Dáin never rises to the bait. Thorin almost wishes he would. It might lead to a different death than the two he’s already experienced. “I don’t need to change it,” Dáin says coldly. “A fool like you, you’ll do it yourself.”

Dáin isn’t wrong, Thorin thinks, as he begins the journey from the Blue Mountains to the Shire, and the meeting that will occur at Bilbo Baggins’ house this night. Thorin’s end will come at his own hands, by way of Azog the Defiler. No matter how many times Thorin fights the battle at Ravenhill, even though he knows what’s coming, he’s a moment too slow to dodge. By that point, Kíli and Fíli are already dead, alongside scores of dwarves and elves and men. There’s nothing left for Thorin by then, so it doesn’t matter if he dodges or not. He always finds himself staring up at the sky, his vision going blank, as Bilbo’s shaky, tear-filled voice echoes in his ear.

Why is Bilbo crying over him? Thorin can never understand that, given what happens to Bilbo at his hands on that very same day, or what he’s said and done from the moment he meets the hobbit. Thorin can already see it unspooling in his head. He knows exactly what he’ll say. More like a grocer than a burglar. Thorin supposes he thought he was being funny.

Why did he try to be funny? Thorin isn’t funny. No one Thorin’s ever met has accused him of having a sense of humor. He gets himself lost in the Shire, as usual, and trades the same set of words with Gandalf as always when Gandalf opens the door. Then he turns to face Bilbo Baggins. “So this is the hobbit,” he says, and Bilbo Baggins looks him up and down with a temerity Thorin once found insulting. “You have a lovely home.”

Bilbo Baggins blinks. “You’ve barely seen it.”

“The construction seems sound,” Thorin says. “And it’s – uh, clean.”

“No thanks to your – compatriots! Ever since they arrived, they’ve devoted themselves to taking it apart!”

“We cleaned up,” Kíli protests. “We did all the dishes –”

“And we didn’t break any of ‘em!” Ori adds.

“We even saved some food,” Dwalin grunts. “Not easy, with this lot.”

“Or this food,” Fíli says. He burps. “It was good.”

Thorin glances back at his Company, then forward again at Bilbo Baggins. Bilbo Baggins looks less disgruntled than he has on their other first meetings, and at the sight, some piece of Thorin’s mind eases. He’s not pained in this life, and perhaps that has something to do with it. “Thank you for hosting my fellows,” he says to Bilbo, “although it seems it was unexpected. I would be thankful to impose on your hospitality again.”

“At least he asks first,” Bilbo Baggins says to Gandalf, in a voice pitched to carry. “Right. This way –”

Thorin follows Bilbo Baggins through the house, and his Company follows him. As he walks, he rests one hand against one of the support-beams holding up Bilbo’s home against the weight of the hillside. It’s curved wood, sanded smooth. Dwarven construction uses stone, always, but perhaps in some cases, it’s better to bend. Thorin has spent the last easy sleep of his life in Bag End six times over, and he finds that he’s looking forward to it. On this occasion, at least, he’s on better terms with the master of the house than before.


Thorin tells Gandalf that he can read the moon runes himself, and tells Lord Elrond Halfelven the same, and when the elf takes the map and holds it up to the light anyway, Thorin reads the message off before the elf can say a word. He ignores the way Elrond and Gandalf are staring at him and makes his case. “We have until the last day of summer to reach the mountain, and every moment we delay makes the journey more dangerous. If your promises of friendship were more than empty words, you’ll resupply us with haste and send us on our way.”

He’s never addressed the elf so brazenly before. At the very least, something different is likely to happen. Lord Elrond tilts his head, studying Thorin. “You will keep company with us until the moon begins to darken,” he says. “Its brightness will leave you too exposed, and it is as you said – your road is a dangerous one. One week –”

“Three days,” Thorin counters.

“Five,” Elrond says, with a tone that suggest Thorin shouldn’t argue. Thorin strongly considers arguing anyway.

His sleep is fitful, and just as he has done seven times before, he spends the days wandering Rivendell. His Company spends it much more divertingly, and Thorin wastes an afternoon trailing a pair of servants who are complaining loudly about their behavior. They know he’s there, of course, but it wouldn’t cross their mind that a Dwarf could understand their language. Thorin learned it several lifetimes ago. He picks his way along the path behind them, awaiting the right moment to spring the knowledge on them and shame them into silence.

“Thorin Oakenshield,” someone says, and Thorin glances over his shoulder to find that his steps have been shadowed, too. Lord Elrond stands there. “Walk with me a moment, if you will.”

Thorin is tempted to refuse, to claim he has somewhere else to be, and enjoy the momentary satisfaction of ruining someone else’s day. Today, the thought tires him. “As you wish.”

They walk in silence for a while, Thorin lengthening his strides to keep up. He’s tall for a Dwarf, but even the smallest Elf towers over him. “As a prince of the line of Durin, I am certain you were well-tutored,” Lord Elrond says, “but I had thought the art of moon runes long-lost to your kind.”

“It’s the same as reading anything else. The only trick is the moonlight.” That, or hearing it said half a dozen times. “What do you want?”

“You are not the eldest among your Company,” Elrond says, “nor particularly old for your kind. And yet, your eyes speak of a great age. Of many sorrows suffered, and many lifetimes lived. It is not something I have seen before –”

“Then how do you know what it is?”

“On a mortal,” Elrond finishes. “I saw it once, in the eyes of an Elf. One who fell in battle, was healed in the Halls of Mandos, and was returned to Middle-earth because there was yet more he could do. How many times have you returned?”

Thorin is taken aback enough to go silent, and Elrond responds to the silence as an answer. “I know you are the second of your name. Have you always been a Thorin, or have you had other names?”

“I have had only one name,” Thorin says. “And only one life.”

Elrond gives him a strange look. “I don’t understand.”

“I live one life,” Thorin says. “When I die, I return to a particular point, and live my life again.”

“And the return, is it immediate?”

“Yes,” Thorin says. “I can still hear it. The last life, in the first moments of the new one.”

“And you understand what you hear?” Elrond asks. “That is to say, you are not an infant – unless Dwarves recall their entire lives from birth, which I had been led to believe they do not.”

“Which Dwarves have you been talking to?” Thorin resists the urge to break into a run and leave the Elf behind entirely. “I return to Azanulbizar, midafternoon. My brother is already dead. My grandfather’s death is imminent. My father is soon to vanish. That is where it begins.”

“And where does it end?” The question flies from Elrond’s mouth at once, and Thorin hesitates. The Elf stops walking. “You are not telling me the future. Only something that has already happened. And whatever you tell me now will be erased from history when you return to Azanulbizar, yes?”

“You will remember nothing,” Thorin says. “When we meet, again, it will be the eighth time you have told me that you knew my grandfather when he was King under the Mountain.”

“Then it matters not whether you tell me,” Elrond says. “In the grand design, it matters only whether telling me will serve you.”

The grand design. “This other Elf – he returned because his work was unfinished. Why have I been cursed to live the same life over and over?”

“But it is not the same life,” Elrond says. “Have you and I had this conversation before? If not, then this life is different than your previous ones. I would hazard a guess that between your first life and now, many things have changed.”

“Many things,” Thorin agrees, “but not enough.”

He felt different in the last life, but it ended the same way as always – oaths broken, kinsmen dead, the voice of Bilbo Baggins echoing in his ears. “Perhaps that is your answer,” Elrond says, and Thorin glances at him. “Things have not yet changed enough.”

“Enough according to who?” Thorin asks, frustration boiling up within him. “According to your Creator, who has no place in His world for my kind?”

“Only some elves believe that, and I am not among them. If something exists in this world, it is because it was meant to be here,” Elrond says. “Perhaps it is the Creator’s, but I think it more likely that it is you, Thorin Oakenshield. I think it likely that you found your way here of your own accord.”

“You would blame me for my own misfortune? Do you have any idea – what it’s like –”

Dying. Returning to life again, knowing what dying feels like, knowing he’ll feel it again. Knowing that some losses are irrecoverable. Knowing that some oaths he gave were made to be broken. When Thorin thinks back to his first life, he sees a litany of errors, so many that he can barely make out the path he once intended to travel. No one would do this to themselves willingly. The Elf is out of his mind.

“I can’t imagine what it’s like,” Elrond says. “But I can imagine hope where you cannot. If you got yourself into it, you can get yourself out.”

He makes it sound easy. As if Thorin could escape hell as easily as he could leave a room he no longer wished to occupy. Then again, Thorin has been looking at the problem alone for many lives. “How would you suggest I do that?”

“That depends on what you wish.”

“I wish for it to end,” Thorin says. “I wish to be at peace.”

“Then divine what will be necessary for you to go in peace, and make that your reality. Change what you must to ensure that you die without regrets,” Elrond says. “Perhaps, through your actions, you can bring a measure of peace to us all.”

It’s selfish of Thorin – unbearably so – but he wishes only for peace for himself. If even the Elf who died and came back to life has done it only once, the burden Thorin carries is already far too heavy for one soul to bear. But he nods in response to the Elf’s words. Some things, have changed, but not enough, and if the thing that needs to change is Thorin, they will be here for a long time.


“Some may imagine a noble quest is at hand,” Thranduil the Elvenking says, and Thorin tunes out the rest of his pointless speech, as he’s done for many lives now. Nothing Thranduil says will matter – only the fact that Thorin told Bilbo exactly what was needed well before they were captured, and that they should be released much earlier than scheduled. “I myself suspect a more prosaic motive. Attempted burglary, or something of that ilk.”

“Burglary?” Thorin repeats. “It’s my home. Is it stealing to reclaim what is mine?”

“Not everything in that mountain is yours,” Thranduil says coldly. “The dragon is a thief stealing from other thieves.”

A thief from thieves. The Elvenking hasn’t said that before. If he had, Thorin would have met his end much earlier in many of his previous lives. “My people’s losses were uncountable. I fear for your people, if you count the lives of your people the same as you count your treasure!”

“If I were you, Dwarf, I would speak with more caution,” Thranduil spits. “Your ignorance of history betrays you. I have seen the fruits of your ruinous ambition, and they are bitter indeed.”

Thorin’s stomach lurches. “What have you seen?”

“It matters not, to one such as you,” Thranduil says. He turns away. “In any case, your foolish quest is at an end. I have your burglar in custody. Bring him here –”

A guard appears, carrying Bilbo. He’s doing so with some difficulty, as Bilbo is kicking and biting with ferocity that Thorin has never seen from him. It matters not. It’s over – in this life, anyway. There will be another. There is always another. The Elf drops Bilbo in a heap at Thorin’s side, and the Hobbit struggles to his feet. “Well?” Thranduil asks. “What do you have to say for yourselves? Your pleas will not move me, but they will make for entertainment nonetheless.”

Thorin opens his mouth to retort that Thranduil’s personality is as ghoulish as his face, for how he laughs at Thorin’s pain, only for Bilbo to step hard on his foot. “They should move you, Your Majesty,” Bilbo says, and Thranduil raises an eyebrow. “Hobbits have no great and terrible history, but in its absence, I have read of yours. This is not your home, is it? You dwell here, but your origin lies elsewhere.”

Thranduil looks taken aback. “You’re from Doriath,” Bilbo continues. Thorin has never heard the name. It means nothing to him, but not to the Elvenking. “Thingol was your king, and he, too, feuded with Thorin’s kin – but that feud isn’t why you lost your home. It was other Elves, wasn’t it? They destroyed your city and slaughtered your people to satisfy their greed.”

The Elvenking’s features flicker strangely, the illusion that hides his wounds almost giving way. Thorin is standing close enough to Bilbo to feel him tense as he marks it, but he stays the course. “You and Thorin have more in common than either of you want to believe,” Bilbo says, and Thorin could almost laugh at the scowl that descends over Thranduil’s face. “You don’t have to be friends, but I don’t see why you must be enemies.”

“His people stole from me,” Thranduil says. “A necklace of value beyond measure.”

“I see,” Bilbo says. He looks over at Thorin. “Will you give it back?”

Thorin was there the day the Elvenking came to retrieve his white gems. He saw how his grandfather taunted Thranduil with the necklace, then withheld it, laughing all the while. King Thrór was cruel, well before the gold-sickness took him. Thorin recalls thinking, all the way back in the first life, that he would have done differently.

Now he can – but while his grandfather kept something that was not his, the Elvenking is not blameless. “My people came to you once – starving, homeless, seeking your help. But you turned your back. You turned away from the suffering of my people, and the inferno that destroyed us –”

“What would you have had me do? Your greatest warriors had failed. Girion of Dale and his Black Arrows could not bring the dragon down. Was I to throw my warriors’ lives away?” Thranduil snarls. The illusion shielding his wounds fails, and Thorin, who has seen this before, fails to flinch. Bilbo recoils in horror. “I have fought my share of pointless battles. I will fight no more!”

“I didn’t ask you to fight!” Thorin’s voice splits like stone struck wrong, breaking along fracture lines he hid lives ago. “I asked you to help!”

He remembers staring up at the hills, hoping and praying; remembers the crushing weight of anger and hurt on his chest. The same weight has fallen every time he’s been dragged before the Elvenking. How is he supposed to reason, to think, when he can barely breathe? “My grandfather wronged you, yes. My people didn’t! It was not Thrór you punished when you turned your back on us. It was my younger brother who went hungry. It was my sister who was cold at night. It was I who –”

Who was left alone. Who was left in charge. Who had less than nothing and hundreds of hungry mouths to feed. Who was not ready to be a king. Who still isn’t, if the number of lives he’s already lived is anything to judge by. “It’s ashes now. I will give you your damned necklace when Erebor was reclaimed, but I will think more of your honor if you admit who truly paid the price.”

Thorin’s hands are shaking. He folds them behind his back. A small hand lands lightly on his shoulder, barely perceptible through the heavy furs he wears. Thorin glances to his right and sees Bilbo there. A Hobbit should not have such sad eyes, and yet, this is how Thorin has seen them most often. This is how Bilbo looks at him in the moments before his vision goes black, before his eyes fall shut and open again on the battlefield with another life to live.

“No one helped my people when it was our time to wander,” the Elvenking says, and Thorin and Bilbo both turn to look at him. “I should have helped yours.”

It’s much too little, lifetimes too late, and only Thorin knows how much. “Help my people now. I will return your wife’s gems.”

“I said nothing of my wife,” the Elvenking says. “How did you –”

“Does it matter?” Bilbo asks politely. “The gems will be yours. Erebor will be Thorin’s. Each of you will have what he is owed.”

It crosses Thorin’s mind, again, to be more specific in the writing of the contract next time around. He’d have written it more carefully if he’d known Bilbo would read the damn thing, but Bilbo has a mind for details, and for fairness. And he can speak for Thorin, when Thorin’s own anger is too much for him to bear. “I accept your bargain,” Thranduil says. “My soldiers will escort you to the edge of the forest, and provision you for the journey.”

“Thank you,” Bilbo says. He looks at Thorin expectantly, but Thorin refuses. This is a business transaction, not a favor being done. “Well. Thank you from both of us.”

The Elvenking inclines his head. “Oakenshield chose well when he selected you for his Company, Bilbo Baggins.”

Most of what leaves Thranduil’s mouth is nonsense. Thorin supposes that occasionally he gets some things right.


Something goes wrong. Something always goes wrong, and that time, it was catastrophic. So catastrophic, in fact, that Thorin watched the majority of his Company die in battle before Erebor. They were not the only casualties. The Elvenking fell, as did Bard of Dale, leaving two kingdoms leaderless, and Thorin the only one to shield three peoples from a punishing winter. He did so. Buried his dead. Returned the gems to Thranduil’s son and paid the people of Lake-town their share of treasure. And then he lived.

It was a long life, for Thorin survived the battle uninjured. For the first time, he died of old age, after decades spent ruling a blasted, blighted land, haunted by even more regret than usual. He left no successor, for Fíli and Kíli fell, alongside Dáin and Dáin’s son and every member of the line of Durin. And he had no companion, for Bilbo Baggins took the blow that should have slain Thorin.

Thorin had known Bilbo had died, in other lives. That was the first time he had seen it, the first time he had spoken pointlessly of the Eagles, wondering if they were some kind of curse. If Thorin would be released, and Bilbo would be forced to live his lives over again instead. But it is truly Thorin’s curse, because he closes his eyes in a frail, ravaged body, and reopens them with blood on his face and mud beneath his feet, and an oaken branch clenched in his hand.

Something always goes wrong, but what was it? Thorin mended fences with the Elvenking, as much as it’s possible to do. The elves marched out in force to join them. Thorin remembers, but never enough, and the unprepared elves encountered the second force from Gundabad. Without them to defend Dale, the city fell; without the people of Lake-town to occupy the enemy, Dáin’s forces were torn all but to shreds. No help can come from the Elves. At least, not like that.

So many dead. The faces of the Company have always haunted Thorin, but he cannot shake the image of Bilbo’s death, even after he’s begun again. He’s able to hold his nephews, to treasure each moment with them. To speak to his friends and allies of how honored he is by their trust, how it invigorates him and spurs him to do better. He makes amends where he can, in advance, and yet, there is one person who remains out of reach.

It’s not until the night before the quest begins that Thorin sees Bilbo again, and when he does, he cannot look away. He simply stares, and Bilbo stares back, clearly affronted. “Have I got something on my face?”

“Forgive me,” Thorin says, and bows. “Thorin Oakenshield, at your service.”

Thorin is kinder to Bilbo in this life, just as he’s tried to be kinder to the rest of the Company. It doesn’t come naturally to him. No one has ever treated Thorin softly, and confusion boils within him every time someone responds with gratitude. He has a headache, constantly. He always feels as if he is holding back tears.

He begins to dread the return to Erebor, to dread everything that comes after. To devise method after method of defeating Smaug. He knows the old plan won’t work, that the dragon will wake, but when he tries to tell the others, the words come out garbled, incoherent, wrong. If he is meant to change something, whatever has commanded the change has opted not to make it easy on him. By the time they reach the mountain, Thorin need not fear gold-sickness; the others have decided that he’s simply mad, and they’re acting accordingly.

Only Kíli and Bilbo protested, Bilbo because Thorin is the dwarves’ king and he hasn’t done anything strange – simply started speaking in tongues, whenever certain topics arise. Kíli protested because Thorin is trying to tell them something, and they should keep listening until they understand.

Kíli knows something about making himself heard. He was an unusual child, more whimsical and less studious, more inclined to daydream about the world as it is than to put his head down and craft things to make it better. Their people’s language was difficult for him to master, and yet he continued to try, stubbornly and often fruitlessly. Thorin was the one to teach him, the one who sat there with him for hours until the script and syllables began to mean something. It should not surprise him that Kíli still has faith in him.

Kíli was not injured this time, nor the time before. By choosing to bargain with Thranduil rather than berate him, Thorin’s avoided the attack that wounds his nephew, and simultaneously, avoided his nephew falling in love with an elf. That choice is the right one, Thorin is certain, although what went wrong afterwards, he’s unsure of. Bilbo enters the mountain with Balin as his guide, and Kíli notices Thorin’s thrashing at the ropes and comes to sit by his side.

“I don’t think you’re mad,” he says, loosening Thorin’s bindings. “The thing you want to tell us – is it important?”

Thorin nods. “Is it about the dragon?” Kíli asks. Thorin nods again. “What about it? Does the plan work?”

The plan works in one respect, and one only – it forces the dragon to leave the mountain, at which point he burns Lake-town to ashes. Thorin shakes his head, and Kíli’s face falls. “What part doesn’t work?”

Thorin can’t answer that with nods or shakes of his head. He tries to speak again, first in the common tongue, then in his people’s own language, and Kíli frowns, shaking his head. “I want to understand you,” he says. “It feels important. Try again?”

It is important. Thorin wants to say it. On a strange whim, he tries speaking the words in the third language he speaks, one he rarely admits to knowing. “There is no plan we can make that the dragon will not foresee. At least not one I have thought of.”

“That made more sense,” Kíli says. “Is that Elvish? I wish Tauriel were here. She could understand –”

So much for his cursing of the elves, his gratitude that the Elf Kíli befriended is not present; whatever has ordained this torment for him, it has also ordained that he can impart vital information only in a language that no one present is able to understand. Thorin swears in every language he knows. That, at least, falls from his lips fluently, and the last sound he hears as the mountain begins to give way beneath him is the sound of his own voice, wracked with useless, impotent fury.


Thorin spends the next life trying in vain to teach someone else to speak Elvish, or to at least convince them that they should learn. No one is interested, and he hears more than a few of his kinsmen speculate that he’s gone strange in the head. Thorin’s options are few, and all of them are bad. He has lived and died nearly a dozen times by now, and there is no twist or turn in the quest that will lead to Gandalf in their Company on Durin’s Day. If he is the only one who speaks Elvish, the information the Company needs to survive will go unheard, and none of his kind are willing to learn.

That leaves Thorin with one detestable option. While the elves are escorting them to the border of the forest, well-laden with supplies and mounted on fresh ponies, Thorin takes a moment to speak to Kíli’s Elf. “If I give you a message, can you repeat it to my people in our common tongue.”

“Why can you not deliver it yourself?”

“Can you do it or not?” Thorin snaps. He coughs, clears his throat, and tries to speak. No luck there, either. It appears he can speak the truth at the mountain and not before. And if that’s the case – “Come with us to the mountain on Durin’s Day. You must be there, or all will be lost.”

“Why?” the Elf asks. Thorin is sick of ‘why’ questions, and in this case, he’s physically incapable of answering. “Why would you ask me for help?”

Is it really so strange? “More depends on it than you know,” Thorin says. “Will you do it or not?”

He hesitates a moment, then plays a final card. “My nephew will assist you with following our customs. Come with us.”

The She-Elf hesitates, too. “All right,” she says at last. “I will accompany you.”

It pleases Kíli greatly, and does some work to smooth the way in Lake-town, too. Both the Master and Bard the Bowman are more trusting of Dwarves when an Elf is involved, and in such a way Thorin is able to convince Bard the Bowman and his Black Arrow to join them on the last leg of the quest for Erebor. Their plan shifts accordingly. Bilbo will take only enough treasure to arouse Smaug’s ire, then flee, and when Smaug emerges from the mountain, Bard the Bowman will shoot him down. He will never reach Lake-town. And with the dragon disposed of, Thorin can turn everyone’s attention to the war that is about to begin. He cannot speak of the war, no matter what language he uses.

The plan, explained by Thorin through Tauriel, calls for the Company to allow the dragon to come to them instead of pursuing it. When it flies past Bard’s position, he will fire the Black Arrow into the beast’s chest, bringing him down well before he can reach Lake-town. Bard seems on board with the plan, and the Bowman seems eager to get it over with. Thorin visits him as he strings his bow, oversized and still too small for the bolt it intends to fire. The next time, Thorin will bring wood to craft a windlance.

“You seem unconcerned,” Bard remarks, after registering his concern yet again. “What if we fail?”

“Then we will try again.”

“Failure in fighting a dragon usually results in death,” Bard points out. Thorin shrugs. “What? Do you think you can’t die?”

“I can die.” Thorin has done it more than anyone, and although it’s never pleasant, it has ceased to be what he dreads more than anything else. “All the same. If we fail, we will try again.”

They do fail, when Bard’s bow is not strong enough to launch an iron arrow at a moving target. The dragon burns Lake-town, then comes back for the rest of them. Most he kills, but a few, like Thorin, he eats. As far as ways to die, being eaten by a dragon is among the worst. Given that he’s small enough to be bite-sized, he feels that there’s no reason for it to take as long as it does.


Almost. Thorin’s last few lives have been full of ‘almost’, and when he opens his eyes without Bilbo’s voice in his ears, Thorin decides that this time, he will not seek Erebor; nor will he assemble a Company to seek it without him. You have built a good life for us in the Blue Mountains, Balin said to him once, and Thorin knows it’s true. Perhaps he should see about living it. Erebor is gone. The Thorin who once dreamed of it is gone, too. Thorin cannot simply wait and hope for Fate to smile on him. He must find another way.

Life in the Blue Mountains continues past the day he left for the quest, past the day he met Bilbo Baggins. He sees his people grow in number, and prosper, and wonders if this was the lesson he was meant to learn, the one he learnt too late in his first life: Home matters far more than gold. Bilbo taught him that. The only thing wrong with life in the Blue Mountains, Thorin decides, is that Bilbo isn’t in it.

Thorin’s life unspools slowly, peacefully, until the day that news arrives from the east. The dragon Smaug has awoken again, and in fury. Lake-town, gone; Mirkwood, still in flames; the Iron Hills under threat from one army as roving bands of Orcs weave through the Misty Mountains, threatening those who live in peace on the other side. Thorin draws his people closer and listens with horror as the kingdoms of Elves and Men begin to fall, one by one. And when they do, the few ragged survivors find their way to Thorin’s gates and beg for entry.

In the first life, Thranduil turned Thorin’s people away as his people had once been turned away; when Thorin was faced with the choice of helping the people of Lake-town or refusing them, he chose wrong. This time, Thorin chooses right, and soon his halls in the Blue Mountains are full of songs he has never heard in languages he doesn’t speak. The refugees, mostly Men and the occasional Elf, make themselves at home in Thorin’s halls, settling in as though they expect to build a life here. Thorin would be willing to allow it, if he were not certain that the world outside is coming to an end.

He had forgotten that there was more than one reason behind the quest for Erebor. It was not simply about Thorin and his people reclaiming their home. Gandalf supported the quest because he wished to see the threat of Smaug removed, and Thorin was deemed an appropriate tool with which to do it. It angered him when he realized, in the midst of some other life. It angers him still. Thorin has the guilt of his Company’s deaths upon him already. Now he must add all of Middle-earth to its toll.

The sky darkens. The earth shakes. Doubt and fear begin to creep into Thorin’s halls, curling up and refusing to leave. And then, on a day when Thorin had been certain that the rest of Middle-earth was already dead, a single survivor struggles in through the door.

It’s been Thorin’s custom to meet them all. He asks that the visitor come to him, only to be told that they are too old and sick to walk. It seems they expended all their strength in an effort to reach Thorin’s halls. Thorin, not as old as he once was but still not particularly young, makes his way to the infirmary, a fist of dread closing around his innards. He knows. He cannot say how he knows, but he knows – and when he finds himself looking down into the weathered, dying face of Bilbo Baggins, he understands what his desire for a life that cost him nothing has done.

Bilbo never left the Shire before now. He planted his trees, watched them grow, and then watched them burn as Smaug fell upon the Shire. Behind Smaug came armies, who enslaved the Halflings or slaughtered them. Bilbo is ill from the foul air and the fouler breath of the dragon, and still he dragged himself to Thorin’s halls, to warn Thorin of what is approaching. To ask if anything can be done, perhaps. If his suffering has meant something after all.

Thorin tells him it has. Thorin sends his soldiers to make preparations, knowing they will be fruitless, and he remains seated at Bilbo’s side as Bilbo shudders through his last breaths. “Do I know you?” he asks Thorin on one of them. “I feel as though – I’ve seen you before.”

“I passed through the Shire a time or two, in my younger days,” Thorin says. Bilbo’s eyes narrow with a skepticism Thorin remembers well. “Or perhaps we met in another life.”

“Perhaps.” Bilbo coughs painfully. He claws at his chest with wizened, shaking hands. “Perhaps we’ll meet again then, too.”

“We will,” Thorin says. He understands now what he must do.


This time, all goes to plan. This time, Thorin saves them all. When he falls to the ground at the conclusion of the battle, staring up at the afternoon sky and the eagles soaring across it, he knows that he’s done what he must. This time, he will not wake again at Azanulbizar. He will go to the Maker’s halls, where so many of his family have gone before. He wonders how long they’ve been waiting for him. By how long he is overdue.

“Thorin!” Bilbo crashes down at his side, hard enough that he emits a whimper of pain. Thorin turns towards him, his eyes blurring already. He can see the misery in the halfling’s face, and in other lives, he’s never quite understood it. This time, it makes sense. This time, Thorin treated Bilbo as he deserves. “Thorin –”

“It’s all right,” Thorin says. He knows what he must say now. He’s said it twelve times before, and it comes naturally. “Go back to your books, and your armchair. Plant your trees. Watch them grow. If more people –”

“No!” The words burst out of Bilbo’s mouth. Thorin blinks. “No, it’s not all right. We’re the Company of Thorin Oakenshield. How are we meant to go on without our leader? How are  Kíli and  Fíli – and your sister – Dwalin and Balin and the rest of them –”

He breaks off in a sob, wipes his nose on his sleeve. Thorin fumbles with nerveless fingers for Bilbo’s hand and finds it. Bilbo holds on tight. “How do you expect me to go home again after all this?” he demands of Thorin. “How dare you say that this is meant to be when you aren’t part of it?”

“What?” Thorin says, or tries to. He coughs, blood spraying from his lips to spatter Bilbo’s face, and Bilbo doesn’t flinch or loosen his grip. “I’m not – you have to –”

Let me go, Thorin wants to say, but it’s too late. The last thing he hears is Bilbo’s voice, begging him to hold on, berating him for giving up, begging him to wait –


He’s miscalculated, somewhere – if he’s done everything right, and woken up on the battlefield again, that’s evidence that something still went wrong. But what was it? Thorin did everything perfectly, the twelfth time. His entire Company lived. Lives were lost – that was unavoidable – but Thorin conducted himself as a king should. He did not leave those who should have been his allies to die. He broke no oaths and ended no bloodlines. No matter how hard Thorin looks, he can see no failure severe enough to force him to return again and correct it.

Thorin lives his fourteenth life much as he lived the twelfth. If he’s unsure of what he did wrong, he’s more than certain of what he did right. It’s not until many years after Azanulbizar, as the hourglass is trickling down to the quest for Erebor, that Thorin crosses a particular line. He first meets Gandalf in a tavern in Bree, always. They exchange the same words. Gandalf makes the same offer, and now Thorin knows what happens if he refuses. He accepts. And then, rather than lowering his gaze and returning to his meal, Thorin continues to hold the wizard’s gaze.

Gandalf notices, raises a bushy eyebrow – and then his gaze sharpens suddenly. “You are not young by your people’s years, Thorin Oakenshield, but you have ancient eyes.”

“You have some nerve calling me ancient, Gandalf the Grey,” Thorin says. “I have not lived half as long as you.”

“Far longer than any of your kind before, save your people’s first king,” Gandalf says. Thorin counted, at one point. He supposes that’s an accurate number. “But even Durin the Deathless showed signs of aging. You have none.”

Thorin has been dreading this conversation for a lifetime. One would think that, in all his dreading, he would have come up with a plan for where to begin. “This is the first time you have met me, isn’t it?” He waits for Gandalf to nod, then continues. “This is not the first time I have met you. I have had this same conversation with you, with some small alterations, some twelve times. At the end of my life, I am sent back to the same moment, to live it over again.”

“Indeed?” Gandalf looks surprised, but not doubtful. “As for the rest of us – do we stay the same, or change with each repetition?”

“The same, unless I act differently,” Thorin says. Gandalf is smiling, bemused. “I did not tell you so you could smile at me. I told you because I want to escape.”

“I also want you to escape, since it appears the entire world is held hostage to your return,” Gandalf says. As if Thorin needed more guilt. “What have you tried already?”

Thorin explains the changes he has made. Treating Bilbo with more kindness, and the members of his Company, too. Learning Elvish. Bargaining with the Elvenking rather than insulting him, and accepting an Elf and a Man into his Company, so they might slay the dragon before it reaches Lake-town. Using the goodwill gained to form an alliance, one with the chance to decisively defeat Azog the Defiler. Keeping his Company alive, and whole. “It all went to plan. As it should be,” Thorin says. “And yet I woke up at Azanulbizar again.”

“After dying,” Gandalf repeats. Thorin nods. “You died on the battlefield.”

“That’s where I die.”

“You died elsewhere in other lives –”

“And woke up in the same place,” Thorin snaps. “I confided in Elrond Halfelven once, and he said that I must change things. How much more can I change?”

“One thing,” Gandalf says. Thorin grits his teeth. “You’ve spared every member of your Company but yourself.”

It’s absurd, so Thorin laughs at it. “That is as it should be. The throne will pass to Fíli, who has not committed nearly so many sins to achieve it.”

“The Thorin Oakenshield who committed those sins, by your own report, was a dozen lives ago,” Gandalf says. “The Dwarf you just described to me is a Dwarf who is worthy to claim his grandfather’s throne.”

Thorin dies in the end. That’s how it is. “Think harder. If I accept your help to reclaim Erebor, I want an actual answer.”

“I will see what I can do,” Gandalf says. “Think on it yourself as well. In the meantime, I will see about securing our burglar.”

There have been lives where Thorin goes through the motions. He opts for this not to be one of them, which means he endures Dáin’s refusal without challenging him to a duel and manages to travel in stealth. He allows himself to get lost in the Shire, however. It’s something of a tradition at this point. So is the warmth of Bilbo’s home, the taste of his food, the way the voices of Thorin’s kinsmen fill the space with laughter and song. It’s a lovely place, Bag End, but it’s too quiet. It’s oddly disquieting to picture Bilbo rattling around this place alone.

After Bilbo has wandered off to bed and the rest of the Company has begun to bed down for the night, Thorin confronts Gandalf for his answer. Gandalf, infuriatingly, appears to have done no extra thinking on the matter at all. “Assuming your tale is true, and you have no reason to lie, your death is the only factor that both remains unchanged and within your control.”

“You think I have control over that?”

“You tell me. I have never fought a duel with Azog the Defiler,” Gandalf says. “But if I had fought the same duel a dozen times –”

“It’s not a choice,” Thorin says, lies. “Our victory does not imply my survival.”

“Oh?” Gandalf raises both eyebrows this time. “Why don’t you ask your Company what they would consider a victory?”

“I will,” Thorin says, “and when they prove me right, you will speak no more of it.”

Gandalf nods sagely. The sooner Thorin concludes this, the better, and the sooner he can corner Gandalf into providing a real answer for his questions. He begins in the morning, after Bilbo Baggins has joined them, and he begins with Bombur.

There’s no particular reason why it’s Bombur, just that Thorin happens to be riding beside him at the moment. “What would constitute a victory in this quest?”

“Erebor reclaimed, of course,” Bombur says. He’s younger than Thorin – too young to have dwelt there, but old enough for his dreams of it to have shape and form. “My brothers safe and whole. The Company, too. The King under the Mountain restored to his rightful throne.”

Thorin was following along for a moment. Now he’s puzzled. “What?”

“For our people to reclaim our homeland, and crown our rightful king,” Bombur says. He gives Thorin a strange look. “Are you all right?”

“Yes,” Thorin says. He decides he won’t tell Gandalf about this. There is always an outlier or two.

An outlier or four when it comes to his Company, apparently; of the five dwarves Thorin asks by nightfall, four of them have concluded their litany with Thorin’s ascension to the throne of Erebor. The only exception was Kíli, who listed Thorin’s ascension first. Perhaps Gandalf put them up to this, in advance of his conversation with Thorin. Thorin will wait a while to continue asking, to see if it slips their minds.

He asks one each day, at most, and leaves days in between. No matter who he asks, or how carefully he words the question, his name is always included. Balin even goes so far as to add in a wish for Thorin’s health and happiness, and a blessed reign. “Don’t you think that’s excessive?” Thorin asks, and Balin only laughs. “Surely reclaiming Erebor is enough.”

“Erebor is a mountain. Its treasure is a treasure. What made it a kingdom were its people,” Balin says. “Our people will thrive best under the reign of a wise and happy king.”

“Uncle is never happy,” Fíli says. He mimics Thorin’s expression. Although Thorin avoids mirrors, he’s certain that even his heaviest scowl does not resemble that in the slightest. “He’s worried all the time. Will you be happier when you’re home?”

What makes it home? Thorin has ruled Erebor before. That life was a misery. “It depends on who is with me.”

“Then we do understand each other,” Balin says, patting him on the shoulder. “You can keep asking, laddie. You won’t get a different answer from any of us.”

Thorin is beginning to suspect that he’s right. He keeps asking anyway, working his way through the Company Dwarf by Dwarf, hoping that he’s waited long enough that each one will have forgotten what Gandalf told them to say. In Rivendell, there are other conversations to be had, and in the crossing of the Misty Mountains, a great many things slip a great many people’s minds. It’s not until they’ve descended the mountains, fought off Azog and his Wargs, been spared by the Eagles, that Thorin recalls who has yet to ask.

He’s wary of approaching Bilbo. After all, Bilbo is not a Dwarf. He has no ties to Erebor, only to the Company, and only via the contract he signed. Out of all the members of Thorin’s Company, Bilbo is most likely to give him the answer he could use to silence Gandalf, and yet Thorin is hesitant to hear it. Speaking to Bilbo carries an element of unpredictability that Thorin’s unused to.

Waiting won’t make him more used to it. On the second night of their stay at Beorn’s house, Thorin makes his way over to where Bilbo is struggling to turn the pages of a massive book. “Master Baggins,” Thorin says, and Bilbo slams the book shut. “I didn’t mean to interrupt.”

“You have a question for me, don’t you?” Bilbo asks. He turns a direct, inquisitive gaze on Thorin, and Thorin fights the urge to look away. “It’s about time. You’ve asked everyone else. I was certain you’d start asking the ponies before you got to me.”

“I thought it would matter less to you.”

“Because I’m not a Dwarf?” Bilbo scoffs. “I thought you were listening, back there in the mountains. I miss my home, and because I miss it, I can imagine the smallest fraction of how much you must miss yours. A victory in this quest includes you taking back your mountain.”

“Yes,” Thorin says. He can’t tell whether the sinking feeling is relief or something else. He turns away, and a small, strong hand seizes his wrist. “What?”

“I wasn’t finished,” Bilbo says. “Victory would be seeing your people reclaim your mountain. And seeing you claim your rightful throne. If the way the others see you is anything to judge by, you’ll make a very good king. Kind, wise – a bit hard-headed, but you are a Dwarf –”

“I’m not worthy,” Thorin says.

“Your people love you.”

“I’m not worthy,” Thorin repeats. “Did you not hear me?”

“I heard you,” Bilbo says primly, “and you’ll forgive me if I trust their judgment over yours.”

Thorin simply stares at him. “I haven’t finished answering your question,” Bilbo continues. “Victory involves you claiming your throne, and ruling wisely and well until the end of your days. And happily, of course. That’s very important.”

“Why?”

“People should want to be happy, Thorin. You need a holiday from all the brooding.”

“No, I understand –” Thorin doesn’t. “Why does it matter to you if I live, or if I’m happy? After what I’ve done?”

“What have you done? Have I missed something?” Bilbo relinquishes Thorin’s wrist, but only for the purpose of crossing his arms and staring. “Whatever events you refer to, they occurred only in your mind. Nothing I have seen or heard from you suggests that you deserve anything but happiness.”

They occurred only in your mind. It’s true, isn’t it? Everything that has happened to Thorin, every life he has lived, every loss he suffered and every death he has dealt – all of it was erased the moment Thorin returned to Azanulbizar. It’s real only to him. It will only ever be real to him. It may as well not have happened at all. Thorin takes one step back from Bilbo, then another, and turns away, striding off through Beorn’s house in search of somewhere quiet.

He thought Bilbo wasn’t following him, or else that he’d moved fast enough to avoid detection, but he’s wrong. He’s only just begun to cry when Bilbo appears at his side. “Thorin,” he says, “are you all right? And before you answer, recall that most people don’t run off crying when someone wishes them well.”

“I didn’t run off –” Thorin grits his teeth, wipes his eyes on the back of his hand. “It’s not because you wished me well. That has nothing to do with it.”

Bilbo looks skeptical. “Then what was it?”

Telling Elrond Halfelven or Gandalf the Grey is one thing. Telling Bilbo Baggins, burglar, is something else entirely. What has befallen Thorin is the stuff of myth and legend, nothing believable, and Bilbo is as skeptical as they come. “You wouldn’t believe me if I told you.”

Bilbo sits down at Thorin’s side, makes himself comfortable. “I’ll be the judge of that,” he says. “Tell me.”

Thorin thinks of the worst that could happens, then reasons that should the worst happen, he’ll die at the end anyway and have a chance to avoid this conversation next time. “As you wish.”

Bilbo listens to the story, and as a result, hears more of it than Thorin told Gandalf or Elrond. With them, he was attempting to get the facts across quickly, to see if there was an answer to his question, but Bilbo listens quietly, asking questions only when Thorin pauses for breath. Thorin finds himself caught on small details, things it would not have occurred to him to share otherwise. He lingers in the Blue Mountains, those few years of peace he stole. Something was missing from them, but he never understood what.

At the end, Bilbo is silent for a while. Then he looks Thorin squarely in the eye and says exactly what Thorin hoped he wouldn’t. “You want it to stop? You have to live.”

“No,” Thorin says. “It’s not that easy –”

“It isn’t? You’ve fought Azog two dozen times. If I know you, you’ve fought that duel in your mind’s eye a thousand times more,” Bilbo says. His voice pitches upwards slightly, goes shrill in the way that tells Thorin he’s angry. “If you choose to live, you will.”

“You think I want to die?”

“I know you think you deserve it,” Bilbo says. “You talk about it as if it’s inevitable. Do you think it feels inevitable to us? Don’t you think we’d give our lives to avoid it?”

In each life where Thorin undertakes the quest, Bilbo risks his life for Thorin at least once. In some lives, he’s done it more than once. At least one time, he took the death blow that should have been Thorin’s. “You can’t be right all the time.”

“Which is more likely? That all of us are wrong, or that you are?” Bilbo gives Thorin a look that’s almost disparaging, almost exasperated – but somehow, not unkind. “This time, try to survive.”

“I always try –”

“Really try. Fight like this is the last time you’ll ever do this, like you’ll never see another sunrise or forge another weapon or pretend not to laugh at one of Bofur’s terrible jokes.” Bilbo stares so hard at Thorin that Thorin tries to avert his eyes, only for Bilbo to grip his chin and turn him back. Thorin startles, and so does Bilbo. Bilbo’s face flushes. “I, uh –”

“You’re not letting go,” Thorin says. “Spit it out.”

“Fight like your life matters to you, the same as it matters to us. You know how much that is,” Bilbo says. “If I’m wrong, who does it hurt? You’ll go back to the beginning again anyway. And if I’m right –”

“I’ll die in peace.”

“Thorin.” Bilbo gives him a little shake. His hand is warm, and so is his voice. “First you’ll live.”

Many things have haunted Thorin over the course of his lives, but Bilbo so often finds his way to the top of the list. As the quest unfolds, Thorin continues to look for different answers, any answers but the one his Company has given him. What would that mean, if they were right? What would it mean if the one thing that must change is the thing Thorin’s always taken for granted? There is torment in the return to Azanulbizar, but there is safety in it, too. As long as Thorin knows exactly what mistakes were made, he can’t make any more. A life outside of it – what would it be like?

The Company has made their wishes known. The sins Thorin dies for were committed lifetimes upon lifetimes ago. Even as Thorin draws Orcrist against Azog for the last time in this life, he’s undecided. The battle is familiar to him, as cleanly choreographed as a dance. Thorin knows where every blow will land, and how to avoid each one, and as he has so many times before, he watches Azog vanish into the river, slipping away beneath the ice.

Vanish, and then reappear. Thorin leaves his blade drawn and marks the Pale Orc’s path to the waterfall, step by step by step. He sees Azog’s gaze shift, as it always does, and feels the distant tug of shock from many lives back. There was once a Thorin who dreamed of more than a quick death, a peaceful rest. That Thorin didn’t know what this one does. For the first time, Thorin steps back rather than forward, and Azog’s blade stabs upwards through the ice in the same place where Thorin’s foot was a moment before.

Is it that simple? The Pale Orc goes wild beneath the ice, thrashing and flailing, and Thorin keeps his distance, and keeps his sword drawn, too. The ice shatters upwards in one place, then another, punctured by kicking feet and desperate fists. At last, the Pale Orc breaks through his head and shoulders visible. A vicious smile forms on his face, and he pulls his blade free of the ice. A moment later, the current sweeps him off the edge of the waterfall.

He vanishes with a shriek. Thorin, unused to the thought of being careful with his life, makes his way to the shore before approaching the edge and peering over. There lies the Defiler, unmoving amidst ice and rock at the base of the waterfall. Blood is splashed out around him, his limbs twisted at unusual angles. Thorin waits a while, then throws a rock at him. His aim is true, but the Pale Orc doesn’t stir.

Bilbo comes upon him as he’s looking for another rock to throw. “Thorin!” he shouts, and Thorin turns to him just in time for Bilbo to impact heavily into his chest. Bilbo’s arms come up around him, but it’s not an embrace; Bilbo seems to be patting him down. “Are you hurt anywhere? There’s blood on your face. Thorin –”

“I’m alive,” Thorin says, and Bilbo looks up at him. “Azog is dead. I think.”

“You think?” Bilbo asks. Thorin points over the edge. Bilbo considers for a moment, steals Thorin’s rock, and wings it at Azog. His aim is better than Thorin’s, and still, the Pale Orc does not stir. “He’s dead. You’re still alive.”

“So are you,” Thorin says. “The others –”

“On their way here,” Bilbo says. “The first Orc army has been routed, and as for the other – well, you can look for yourself.”

Thorin glances back over his shoulder and sees the army Azog was leading in the process of being dismantled. Some of it is Dáin’s work; with the alliance of Elves, Men, and Dwarves holding the plain before Erebor, he was able to hold his forces in reserve to decimate the second army. The rest, however, belongs to Beorn. And to –

Thorin looks away. Bilbo shakes his arm, gently at first, then stronger. “Thorin, look. The Eagles –”

The Eagles. At last, Thorin can see them through clear eyes, circling the plain before Erebor and the ruins of Dale. Erebor awaits him. Those he loves the most have survived, and whether he wakes again at Azanulbizar or not, Thorin has lived a life he can be proud of. He is not the Dwarf who failed his people. He is the one who brought them, and himself, home – and if he must, he can do it again. As many times as it takes for it to hold true. And perhaps it will be this time. Thorin is willing to wait to find out.

Bilbo is still shaking his arm. “The Eagles –”

“I see them,” Thorin says, and with Bilbo beside him and the footsteps of his comrades coming closer and the afternoon sun on his face, he closes his eyes.

Notes:

Thanks for reading! Please leave a comment and let me know what you think, and be sure to check out the other art pieces and stories from the event!