Actions

Work Header

An unfriendly halfling

Chapter 17

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“I will help you,” Beorn said after a long pause. His voice sounded low, but firm. “I will give you as much food as you can carry to get through the forest. But be careful.”

He swept the dwarves with a heavy gaze.

“The Elves of Mirkwood do not hesitate to spill the blood of uninvited guests.”

The warning hung in the air — heavy and unmistakable.

“Thank you for your help,” Thorin inclined his head.

The dwarves followed his example. Even the most stubborn among them did so without hesitation.

For the next several days, the company spent their time in tense training. No one spoke of it aloud, but every one of them remembered the humiliating duel. They had no desire to be outdone by a hobbit — not in speed, not in endurance, and certainly not in tactics. From early morning until sunset, the yard rang with the clash of steel and the dull thuds of blows.

Gandalf watched all of this with open surprise. His companions had suddenly become unusually diligent, almost grim in their determination. He did not understand the reason for such a change — but no matter how many questions he asked, he received only evasive answers in return. Not a single dwarf wished to elaborate on his own defeat.

By evening they collapsed from exhaustion, falling asleep almost instantly.

All except Thorin.

Despite his fatigue, sleep did not come easily to him. And one night he heard a cry.

Sharp. Choked.

The cry of a hobbit.

For some reason, it did not wake the others.

Thorin rose quietly, moved soundlessly toward the door, and — remaining in the shadows — watched Bilbo. The hobbit stood at the table, pouring water with trembling hands. After taking a sip, he suddenly doubled over as if struck by sudden pain and began muttering something incoherently under his breath.

It happened every night.

And by the time they finally set out on their journey, Bilbo had grown several times more grim.

For a while they walked in silence.

The path gradually narrowed, stretching forward like a dark ribbon. In the distance the dull wall of Mirkwood was already rising — dense, almost black even in daylight. The trees seemed fused together, their crowns woven so tightly that the forest looked like a single, impenetrable mass.

The closer they came, the cooler the air grew. The smell of damp earth and rotting leaves drifted toward them in gusts of wind. Even the most talkative dwarves fell quiet, studying the gloomy border beyond which the unknown began.

Bofur was the only one who dared break the tension.

“Bilbo, did you get offended because the shapeshifter smelled your stink?” he laughed loudly, clearly hoping to lighten the mood.

Several dwarves snorted, and soon laughter rolled through the company — familiar, rough-edged, tinged with friendly mockery.

But the hobbit did not join them.

He did not even try to answer with a retort.

Bilbo simply turned his gaze slowly toward Bofur. The usual irony was gone from his eyes — the lively spark with which he normally parried any teasing. Now there was only tired irritation there… and something deeper, harder to name.

A short distance away, Gandalf rode his horse without interfering. Silently he watched Bilbo, recalling Beorn’s words about the strange smell.

Meanwhile the laughter gradually faded. One by one the dwarves fell silent, sensing that their usual teasing found no response.

Bilbo waited for the silence.

“You find that funny, do you?” he asked. A smile appeared on his lips — thin, mocking, almost painful.

He looked around at them, letting his gaze linger on each face a little longer than necessary.

“Soon we’ll be walking through a forest where there is neither food nor water,” he continued, quieter but harsher. “Where every step may be the last. And somehow we are supposed to make sure the forest’s owners never learn we are there.”

His voice grew colder. The mockery in it now sounded like reproach.

“I’ll show those elves — !” Glóin waved his arms fiercely, flaring up with his usual hot temper.

Bilbo let out a short, almost weary breath.

“Oh, of course,” he rolled his eyes, though there was no former playfulness in the gesture. “Even if you manage to defeat one elf, the rest will turn you into a sieve.”

He lowered his voice almost to a whisper.

“And that’s if you’re lucky enough that they reach for bows instead of swords.”

The words sounded sharp and unadorned. Not mockery — warning.

And that made them far more unsettling.

“What, are you implying that elves are stronger?” Glóin frowned.

There was less outrage in his voice than wounded pride.

Bilbo slowly turned his head toward him.

“Implying?” he snorted shortly. “I’m stating it outright.”

The words were calm, without challenge — and struck all the harder for it.

Glóin flushed instantly.

“That doesn’t matter!” he continued hotly. “Once all seven dwarf kingdoms unite, our warriors will have no equal!”

He clenched his fist so tightly that the knuckles turned white. There was so much certainty in the gesture that for a moment it might have seemed victory was already decided.

Bilbo smiled.

But the smile was strained.

“Planning to turn them all into minced meat?” he asked quietly. “Well… I look forward to seeing it.”

He watched Glóin for a long moment, carefully — as though before him stood not a warrior, but a stubborn child repeating loud words he himself did not quite believe.

“I’m serious,” Glóin muttered stubbornly.

Bilbo shrugged slightly.

“Well. So am I.”

His voice grew quieter. Colder. The mockery and irritation were gone now — replaced only by a heavy, almost weary conviction.

“You know what the most beautiful part of it is?” Bilbo suddenly asked.

He did not raise his voice. On the contrary — he spoke almost gently, and that only made a chill crawl down the spine.

“You walk onto the battlefield after the fighting is over… and all around you is silence. Such a deathly, crushing silence. No more shouting, no more orders. Only the bodies of your enemies… and of those you knew. Your friends. Your kin.”

He paused briefly, letting them picture it.

“The ground beneath your feet is sticky with blood. The smell of iron in the air is so thick you can taste it on your tongue. It settles in your lungs. In your thoughts. In your memory.”

No one dared interrupt him.

“And you look at a friend with whom you shared bread that very morning. You look at his face…” Bilbo’s voice grew duller. “At what remains of it. And you convince yourself that all of this was necessary. That there was no other way.”

He slowly shifted his gaze from one dwarf to another.

“And then you calmly return home.”

Now his voice was almost a whisper.

“They greet you. They ask. They hope,” Bilbo continued in the same even tone. “And you tell them how bravely he fought. How he did not retreat. How he held his ground until the very end.”

The hobbit’s lips twitched into the shadow of a smile.

“You won’t say that he fell right away, of course,” he added quietly. “No. You’ll say he fought for his kingdom. For honor. For the future. That he fell as a hero.”

He tilted his head slightly.

“And that the ‘wicked elf’ was a cunning bastard.”

The words sounded sharp — foreign to his usually measured speech.

The forest grew silent.

Even the sound of hooves quieted. No one clanked armor or shifted weapons anymore. The wind barely touched the treetops, as if it too were listening.

“I imagine they will be very proud,” Bilbo finished almost in a whisper. “When they sing songs about his death.”

He turned his gaze toward the dark edge of Mirkwood.

“Bilbo.”

The voice was quiet, yet it carried the kind of firmness no one dared oppose.

Gandalf had come closer and placed a hand on his shoulder.

The touch was soft — almost weightless — but there was not strength in it, only a quiet request.

Each of Bilbo’s words had already sunk into the company — not as a shout, not as an accusation, but as something far heavier. They settled in the chest like a dull ache, leaving neither excuse nor reply.

Even the most hot-tempered dwarves remained silent.

Bilbo’s words lay over the company like a heavy blanket — pressing down on them, stealing their usual fire, leaving only the dull sound of breathing and the rhythm of hooves on the ground.

The silence was broken not by a shout, but by a quiet, almost faltering voice.

“You cannot know what a real battle is,” Thorin muttered.

He did not look at the hobbit. His gaze was turned somewhere into the past — where steel rang louder than cries, and the faces of the fallen still rose before his eyes. And in his words there was no arrogance, no anger — only the weariness of a man who remembered too much.

“And yet you do,” the hobbit replied softly.

He did not even raise his voice. And that made the words cut deeper.

“You remember the feeling. The pain. The tears for those who will never return. In a world where darkness already devours hundreds of lives, you decided to start another war. For what? For honor?”

Bilbo gave a bitter smile.

“To lead your people to their deaths just to prove your own worth… If you call that the dignity of a king — then before me stands the most pathetic king imaginable.”

The dwarves froze. No one dared raise their eyes. No outrage, no fury — only heavy, hollow silence.

But Bilbo did not stop.

“Remember their cries,” he said more quietly now, yet more sharply. “Remember how they died in your arms. Remember the exhaustion that breaks your bones. And that emptiness after victory… when instead of triumph there is only silence inside.”

He looked at the king.

“Life is not a coin. You cannot buy it. You cannot trade it for pride or grand words. I thought that after losing so many brothers, you had learned to value those who are still alive. But you…” he exhaled shortly, “you are simply foolish dwarves.”

Having said that, Bilbo turned and urged his pony forward without looking back.

The company followed in silence.

Even among themselves the dwarves no longer spoke. Every breath weighed heavily in their chests. Each of them was thinking of his own things — of faces he would never see again.

Notes:

I'm currently working on the part with Bilbo’s backstory, and it turned out much longer than I originally planned.

So I was wondering — would you be interested in reading his full biography, or would it be better if I shortened it? Maybe I should even skip it in the main story and post it separately?