Chapter Text
A cold evening slowly settled over Erebor. The wind slipped along the stone ledges, tugging at cloaks and carrying away the last remnants of the day’s bustle, leaving behind an almost ringing silence. The sky had already darkened, and the first stars began to emerge through the clouds.
Bilbo stood at the edge, his silhouette still, only the faint rise and fall of his shoulders betraying his breath. His gaze was fixed on the distance—toward the world hidden beyond the dark mountains, a world to which he no longer seemed to belong.
He stood like that for a long time, unmoving, and from the look in his eyes alone it was clear that his thoughts were already far from this place.
Thorin did not notice it at first, but once he did, he could not look away. There was something unusual in that stillness, something that did not quite make sense. It was too deep a detachment, as though Bilbo, in that moment, existed somewhere else entirely, lost within his own thoughts.
He stepped closer, stopping at a distance, as if unwilling to disturb the fragile, tense silence. For a while, Thorin simply stood beside him, watching, trying to catch the slightest movement, any sign that the hobbit noticed his presence.
But Bilbo did not turn.
And then, after a brief pause, Thorin spoke quietly:
“Do you miss home?” he asked softly, noticing how the burglar continued to stare into the distance.
Bilbo did not answer at once. He stood motionless, as though the question had not reached him, as though the words had simply dissolved into the cold air before finding their mark. His gaze remained fixed beyond the line of the mountains.
Several seconds passed before his lips twitched into a brief, almost dry smirk.
He tilted his head slightly, as if considering the question.
“Home?..” he echoed quietly. “I don’t have one.”
He said it calmly, almost indifferently, as if it were something insignificant. But the calm was too even, too deliberate, and because of that it felt wrong—not acceptance, but exhaustion stretched to its limit, beyond which there was no strength left for anger or regret.
Thorin frowned, watching him closely. There was something in those words that would not let him simply nod and accept the answer.
“Why?” he asked more quietly than before, no longer out of curiosity, but because he was trying to understand.
Bilbo hesitated. He slowly turned his gaze toward the king, and for a brief moment tension hung between them—not just a question and an answer, but a choice: to tell the truth or to hide behind привычной колкостью once more.
Something sharp flickered in his eyes, almost dangerous, as though he were ready to push back, to wound, to cut the conversation short—but it vanished as quickly as it appeared. Bilbo simply looked away again.
“Home is a place where someone is waiting for you,” he said quietly, his voice lower, more subdued.
The words were simple, almost casual, but beneath that simplicity there was weight—too much for a mere definition. It was not an explanation so much as a conclusion, one not reached easily or willingly.
Thorin leaned forward slightly, not taking his eyes off him.
“There is no one there who would wait for you?”
Bilbo let out a faint laugh. Too light to be genuine.
“No,” he said, and there was a strange, almost misplaced lightness in his voice. “And, you know… I’m even glad of it.”
He fell silent, as though listening to his own words, testing how true they sounded. Then he gave a faint shrug, as if trying to close the subject for good and prevent the conversation from going any further.
But there was more defense than indifference in that deliberate lightness.
Bilbo smiled, though the smile came out hollow and strained. He closed his eyes and exhaled, as though already regretting what he had said, yet continued, as if unwilling to stop halfway.
“I wouldn’t be able to look at myself if I had remained part of…” he faltered for a moment, his expression tightening, as if even the thought repelled him, “…that people.”
The last words were quiet, but carried clear, barely concealed disgust.
Thorin frowned more deeply. There was not only surprise in his gaze now, but caution as well.
He studied Bilbo’s face carefully, trying to understand what lay behind those words—bitterness, contempt, or something far deeper and more dangerous.
Bilbo fell silent, as if building an invisible barrier between them, one not meant to be crossed. He did not look at Thorin, as though that alone should have been enough to end the conversation.
But silence was not enough to stop Thorin.
He stepped closer, closing the distance, and spoke again, quieter but more insistent:
“You’re speaking of your own people. The hobbits.”
Bilbo gave the slightest shrug, as if it did not matter, as if Thorin’s words had not touched him at all. Yet the tension in his posture betrayed more than he wished to show—his back too straight, his hands too still.
“What could make you hate them so much?”
“It doesn’t matter,” Bilbo replied sharply. “I don’t dwell on the past.”
He tried to pull away, turning slightly as if to leave and end the conversation for good, but Thorin did not move and did not let that happen.
“I’m only trying to help,” he said calmly, neither raising his voice nor backing down.
Bilbo turned sharply toward him. There was irritation in his eyes, almost mockery.
“You? Help me?”
There was disbelief in his voice, nearly a scoff, as if the very idea struck him as absurd.
Thorin held his gaze without flinching.
“I’m trying to repay you,” he answered evenly. “For everything you’ve done… and said.”
Bilbo narrowed his eyes, studying his face, as if trying to determine whether there was some hidden meaning in those words or if this was a rare, unfamiliar sincerity.
“In a good way or a bad one?” he asked, tilting his head slightly.
A faint smile touched Thorin’s lips.
“Both,” he replied without hesitation. “I’m simply curious.”
He paused briefly, but did not look away.
“You don’t react to us the way you do to hobbits. Why? Are they truly more unbearable than we are?”
Bilbo let out a quiet snort and shook his head.
“You could’ve just said you were curious.”
He drew a deep breath, slow and heavy, as if gathering himself before saying something he usually preferred to keep to himself.
“In truth, you’re far more unbearable,” he said at last, slowly, clearly, making no effort to soften the words. “But at least you can be understood.”
Thorin did not interrupt. He stood still, listening closely, not missing a word.
“You’re stubborn,” Bilbo continued, “harsh, sometimes blindly so.”
There was no mockery in his voice—only a dry statement.
“But all of that shows when you’re protecting what’s yours. When you have something to fight for. When you’re trying to survive.”
He paused for a moment, choosing his words, then added more quietly:
“That can be justified.”
He lowered his gaze, aware that he had said more than intended, yet there was no weakness in that retreat—only an attempt to hold the line he did not wish to cross.
For a few moments, he remained silent.
It seemed the conversation would end there.
But then Bilbo spoke again—softer than before:
“As for hobbits…”
The word sounded as though he had not spoken it in a long time.
He fell silent again, gathering his thoughts. His fingers curled slightly, the tension in them almost visible.
“Most of them…” he began, hesitating for a fraction of a second, as though he could still stop—but did not.
“…would tear each other apart,” he finished quietly, “like swine.”
He raised his eyes. And there was no doubt or regret in that look—only a hard, hard-won certainty that was deeply unsettling.
The silence that followed grew heavy, almost oppressive.
Thorin frowned, not hiding his reaction. There was not only surprise in his gaze, but clear disapproval.
“Where does such certainty come from?” he asked slowly, not taking his eyes off him.
Bilbo gave a faint smile again.
“I speak of what I’ve seen,” he replied quietly. “And of what I never wish to see again.”
Thorin remained silent for a while, considering his words, then asked more carefully, without the earlier insistence:
“And that is why you chose to separate yourself from them?”
Bilbo gave a short shrug.
“Better alone than among those who would slit your throat at the first chance,” he answered calmly.
For a few moments, they simply stood there in silence, allowing it to ease the tension. But the thought that had taken hold in Thorin’s mind refused to let go, returning again and again, not allowing him to leave the conversation where it should have ended.
And so, after a brief pause, he asked:
“Then why are you in such a hurry to return?”
Bilbo glanced at him briefly—a quick, almost guarded look, as if the question had struck deeper than he expected.
“My work here is done,” he replied after a short hesitation. “Our paths part here.”
The words came out even—too even—as though he had prepared them in advance and had no intention of straying from them.
Thorin watched him for a long time, without interrupting or looking away, as if trying to see something real behind that restraint, something left unsaid.
“And if you could stay?” he said at last. This time his voice was quieter, but there was weight in it that had not been there before.
Bilbo turned his head sharply.
“What?”
There was less surprise in that single word than disbelief, as though he had not expected—or did not want—to hear something like that.
“No one would object if you stayed. Even permanently,” Thorin said quietly. “You are part of the company now.”
He spoke calmly, without pressure. The words were simple, almost casual, yet they carried far more than he allowed himself to express.
Bilbo stilled.
For a few seconds, he simply looked at Thorin without turning away, as though trying to understand whether this was a joke, a mistake, or something he was wholly unprepared for.
Something in his expression shifted—barely, almost imperceptibly. But he quickly looked away.
“I’ll keep that in mind,” he said shortly, his voice returning to its usual evenness. “Perhaps someday I’ll visit. As a guest.”
He took a step back, increasing the distance between them, as though it were not enough.
“You shouldn’t stay out here too long,” he added without looking at Thorin. “You’ll catch cold.”
And without turning back, he walked away.
Thorin let out a quiet huff of amusement as he took out his pipe, but the faint smile faded almost immediately. He watched the hobbit until he disappeared into the darkness, and only then lifted his gaze to the stars.
He stood there for a long time, unmoving, as though hoping to find an answer there—something simple, clear, something that could be accepted without doubt.
But there was no answer.
Only the cold light of distant stars—and far too many thoughts to cast aside.
