Chapter Text
Bilbo looked about him blankly. The Shire was in full swing, but no less peaceful, and in his youth Bilbo would have been pleased with the view. To be sincere, the present Bilbo would not have given it much thought either, except that until just a few moments ago he had been watching a rather interesting game of cards between Frodo, Gandalf and, to the hobbit’s surprise, Galadriel.
The three of them had decided to play after dinner, and though Bilbo’s advanced age prevented him from moving about, he sometimes ventured out of his comfortable room. Galadriel, who since she had come to Valinor seemed younger in spirit than someone like Bilbo could understand, spent her afternoons together with Frodo, with whom she had formed a great friendship. Bilbo did not fully understand why, but it seemed that the weight of the Ring had brought the Elf and the hobbit together far more than Bilbo comprehended. He had been a ring-bearer too, and for many years longer than his nephew, but the weight of it had not fallen so heavily on him. And to that, not even Elrond knew how to explain.
Gandalf seemed to have an idea when the subject came up in conversation, but he always kept his mouth shut in those moments and smoked his pipe contemplatively.
It had been a quiet afternoon, and though the Lady of Lórien seemed on the point of winning, Gandalf’s mischievous smile told Bilbo that victory for the Elf was not yet assured. Frodo beside him smiled sheepishly, looking down at his disastrous hand of cards, but not looking pained to know that he was going to come last once more.
Bilbo had felt calm, almost happy, and had decided to close his eyes for a moment, trying to memorize the image before him…
And now he stood there, looking out over the Shire again, almost as if nothing had changed around him. Puzzled, he rose from the bench and almost gasped at the agility of his movement. He had been bedridden for nearly a decade, growing weaker and weaker, and though the care of the Elves had ensured him comfort, Bilbo had almost forgotten how quickly his body could move. Still startled he looked down at his hands, which, as his brain was processing, were as smooth as they had been days before he first left The Shire for Erebor.
Frankly, Bilbo didn’t understand anything.
“Don’t worry, it’s hard to adjust to the changes at first.” A soft voice answered him gently.
Bilbo, disgruntled, turned his head. The most beautiful woman Bilbo had ever seen stood before him. Bilbo had known beautiful Elves, like Arwen and Galadriel herself, but none could even compare with the woman before him. Tall and dark, with small freckles running down her face, and green eyes that seemed to hold the secret of the universe itself. Her green dress resembled the meadow around her, and though at first glance it looked like silk, on second inspection Bilbo could almost swear that it looked like real grass. Finally, and to Bilbo’s sudden realisation, the woman was barefoot.
He did not know her, but all the children of The Shire had grown up under her protection.
“Lady Yavanna…” Awkwardly, the hobbit tried to kneel, but the woman beside him grasped his hand and shook her head.
“I do not wish you to kneel before me, Lord Baggins.”
With a fluid movement, almost full of magic and elegance, the woman took a seat on Bilbo’s bench and urged the hobbit to do the same. Bilbo, who would not dare offend anyone in his house, let alone a Valar like her, sat down beside her.
The woman smiled at what she saw, obviously pleased at the gesture, and pointed at Bilbo after a breath.
“You are in my gardens, Mr. Baggins.” Bilbo sighed a little at the news.
“I am dead then. And please, Lady Yavanna, call me Bilbo, I am one of your creations after all.”
The woman let out a laugh, and though Bilbo had never heard it before, the sound comforted him, making him feel at peace.
“Is this where we hobbits go when we die?” Yavanna nodded subtly.
“After you die, all beings in Middle-Earth go to the Halls of Mandos, and there you are judged. Once it has been determined that you are good at heart, you go to your maker’s quarters where you will be forever. You Bilbo, you came straight here, do you know why?”
The hobbit shook his head.
“The Ring created by Sauron. You, Bilbo Baggins, carried out a mission that no other being would have been able to carry, and when the time came to relinquish that burden, you were able to do so. Your soul may have been corrupted in time by the influence of the Ring, but once you arrived at Valinor, all that corruption was gone, and before Iluvatar only your good deeds remained. Bilbo contemplated all this for a second, before whispering:
“What does that mean, Lady Yavanna?”
“It means that we Valar owe you Bilbo an immeasurable debt and that on behalf of us all, we thank you.”
Bilbo could not help but smile. It wasn’t every day that the deities of yours would thank you for your work, and though he wanted to sell himself short, he supposed a little pride in himself wouldn’t hurt after all.
Flustered by what had been said, he dared to look at the goddess again, and to his surprise, she had disappeared. In her wake, she had left a pleasant flowery scent that Bilbo had never smelt before.
He looked again at The Shire, and though he supposed that he would find many hobbits there whom he had said goodbye to long ago, he could not help looking at home first. And though his ears could have been deceiving him, he was almost certain that he heard his mother’s sweet voice in the kitchen.
It was time to hug his parents again.
Bungo and Belladonna had been ecstatic to see their son again, but though they knew nothing of his adventures, they listened tirelessly to the reason why it had taken their son so many years to join them. His father, ever the comfortable hobbit that he was, grunted during parts of the adventure but was content to know that the name Baggins was a symbol of respect throughout Middle-Earth. Belladonna on the other hand, ever the Took that she was, wanted to hear in detail of Bilbo’s adventures, and especially his story in Erebor with the dwarves.
When Bilbo had come to the battle, the two of them, though their father tried to deny it, had waited for the Dwarves’ victory, only to hear with sadness how Durin’s sons had died in that skirmish. Belladonna, who had remained seated on the ottoman, went over to Bilbo, who was sobbing again, as he did every time he tried to remember Thorin’s last words.
“Farewell, Master Burglar. Go back to your books. And your armchair. Plant your trees. Watch them grow. If more people valued home above gold this world would be a merrier place.”
The three hobbits stayed in the hall for the rest of the afternoon, and though Bungo had made tea and cakes, Bilbo had not tasted any. His thoughts kept going back to Thorin and what he could not even now explain to his parents. As ever since he had seen him on that floor, bidding him farewell, it had not been sadness that had seized him, but a grief so deep that he had never suffered it again. As from that moment, food had not tasted the same, nor drink, nor weed… Even on his return to The Shire, all that had gone on. And Bilbo sighed, it had never gone away. The hobbit had learned to live with it, and though in his head he had always thought it was due to lack of adventure, deep down inside he knew it was not so.
As night fell, the three hobbits went into their room, and though Bilbo thought that the events of the day would have left him with an inability to sleep, to his surprise it did not take more than a few minutes before he fell asleep.
Tomorrow the day would begin again.
Life in Yavanna’s Gardens was just as Bilbo remembered his youth in The Shire: quiet, full of hobbits, and with many polite parties. When his neighbours heard of Bilbo’s arrival, they held a party, as they did with the arrival of a new hobbit every time, and though Bilbo was terribly grateful to them, he felt that something was missing. Even Yavanna herself had been present at the celebration, and since then the hobbits have treated her with reverence. His parents were used to such treatment, having been a noble family for generations, but Bilbo was not, largely because of his adventure in Erebor, and partly because of his strange habits once he had returned from it.
And now that he had the favour of all the hobbits again, his days were busy with visits and parties.
At first, he was grateful for it, for one distraction after another made him feel better about his eternal immortality, and all his dear hobbit friends were still there after all this time. Among them, of course, Frodo’s parents. Primula and Drogo expressed their gratitude that Bilbo had looked after Frodo after they were gone, and though Bilbo assured them that they would see him in the future, they were still a little uncertain, especially with the knowledge of the Ring weighing on their minds.
And like all respectable hobbits, when the visits were over, Bilbo had sat back in his armchair and looked at his books gently, imagining the stories that awaited him.
Sadly, he found that the books were the same as those in his house before his departure, so he knew all the stores already. And dreading it very much, he felt the adventure bug tapping in his head. At first, it was only a light touch, a memory of Beorn’s meadow and the quiet days there, and Bilbo let himself go to those hours as he let the afternoon pass in his armchair. It was his mother’s voice exclaiming her desire to eat that had roused him from his reverie, and as he chided himself Bilbo went back to his chores, imagining that it had been a singular thing and would not happen again.
But it happened again. First, there were moments on some dead afternoon in the drawing room, others in the middle of dinner, and gradually they became so apparent that even his parents raised the alarm. Bilbo tried to shoo away his memories, but the more time he spent in his quiet life with nothing but his books or his father's garden, the more he got stuck in them.
It came to such a point that one morning his father shook him off the couch on which he had been sitting all night, remembering a talk with Bofur about the Mountain. The look of concern on his father’s face was such that Bilbo decided then and there that he had to do something.
“You are moving?” It was the second time Belladonna had asked the same question, and Bilbo could only nod again.
His father, more reasonable, looked over the top of his newspaper with weariness.
“Where?” Bilbo looked gratefully at Bungo and pointed to the hill behind the house.
“Lady Yavanna has allowed me a plot of land on the hill, I will be close enough to come and dine as often as you like.” Belladonna shook her head as she looked at the place. The garden was very large, and the magic of the Valar kept it growing.
“It is empty. The house will not be ready for years.” Bilbo shook his head at his mother.
“I will leave this very night. I will start work on the house at dawn, and some of Took’s sons will help me with the foundations. Besides, I have an eternity to make it.”
Belladonna didn’t look very convinced, but she knew her son wasn’t going to change his mind, so she contented herself with making him promise to come visit them at least once a week for dinner.
As Belladonna had said, the house took years to make to Bilbo’s liking. The hobbit, who had at first thought of making his own Bag End, had soon discarded the idea and had begun to make a home that reflected every step of his adventures. Before he knew it, the house was filled with architecture more reminiscent of Rivendell and Erebor than of any honourable hobbit house. The Took’s sons had been unwilling to deny him anything, so despite the odd glances they cast at the dwarf-looking columns or the Elvish windows, they continued to help Bilbo make his house.
It was only when they had finished the house that Bilbo realised that he had made too many rooms. To be more precise, he had made rooms for every member of the company, including one for Gandalf, who, Bilbo had to remind himself, could never come to visit them where he was. At least he thought not. He would have to ask Yavanna the next time he saw her strolling in his gardens.
Bilbo looked sadly down the empty corridor with the doors to the rooms and could not help but try to enter them all. And there the memories came back.
Sitting in Bofur’s room he had remembered his talks with him and had spent a whole morning on it. Entering Bombur’s made him picture a whiff of his stew and had quickly tried to recreate it in his kitchen without much success. Bifur’s had been next, and his deep voice in khuzdul had been ringing in Bilbo’s head all day. Gloin and his endless chatter about his wife and son echoed as Bilbo looked around the room full of empty picture frames in which to place Gimli’s pictures. Oin and his trumpet in his ear. Ori, so young and clever. Frodo had told him of Balin and Ori’s fate in Moria, and Bilbo had not been able to keep back tears at the thought of his most innocent friend.
After Ori, Bilbo avoided the rooms for a whole month, devoting himself to visiting distant neighbours and planting tomatoes in the large field that Yavanna had given him with a smile. Working the land kept Bilbo from thinking too much of sad events, and of longing for his friends, and the smell of the earth reminded him of the old stories of the halls of Mahal, as Thorin called him.
“When we die, we will go to his halls, to enjoy a place without death, full of our most precious jewels, and surrounded by the treasure we have always dreamed of.”
Bilbo could only laugh then, thinking of Thorin with all the wealth of Erebor under his feet, and reminding the dwarf that he would have that before he entered Mahal’s halls.
How naïve Bilbo had been then.
When the month had passed Bilbo plucked up his courage and went into the next room, preparing himself to think of the good things about each of his friends, instead of the longing that he would never see them again. Nori’s room had been next on his tour, and he could not help but laugh at the thought of Nori’s watchful eye as he explained the frequency of meals in The Shire, and how the dwarf had tried, in vain, to increase the frequency of meals on the voyage.
Dori had two pots of tea in the room, much to Bilbo’s pleasure, and deciding as he came in, he poured two cups of tea and drank them, remembering the sweet behaviour of his friend, who had been the gentlest of the dwarves in the company.
Balin, the wise dwarf, had a shelf full of books in his rooms, and Bilbo could almost hear his voice talking about them when he came in. As with Ori, Bilbo could not help shedding a few tears at the end of such a noble dwarf.
Dwalin’s room looked austere as he entered, but Bilbo had made sure that there was plenty of room for his viola, which few in the Company knew was his favourite instrument. Bilbo smiled for the rest of the day, imagining Dwalin playing that instrument with elegance.
As Bilbo tried to enter the next room, he felt tears welling up in his eyes, and he could not go on. He knew that he had three rooms left, and he could not bring himself to relive those memories, which, unlike the rest, were only tinged with pain.
His garden won the prize for best garden that year, thanks to the extra care, and each and every hobbit in The Shire had had him for almost a whole day at home. By the time winter came to the gardens (much quieter and shorter than in Middle-Earth), Bilbo had decided that it was time to face the tears again. The snow had blocked the roads, and that almost seemed a sign for Bilbo to go on.
As he had guessed, as soon as he had entered Fili’s room, he had not been able to stop himself from crying as he sat on the bed. The expansive empty wall, full of hooks and racks to store the young dwarf’s many weapons, seemed to mock the lack of their supposed owner, and the weapons that should have aided the young dwarf in his final fight. Bilbo wept for Thorin’s heir, and of course, he wept doubly as he remembered the grave in which his body had been laid.
It took him several hours before he could stop sobbing, but when at last he did, he took Sting from his room and almost reverently placed him on the middle hook. The young dwarf was not there to place his daggers and swords, but Bilbo would place his own in honour of his fallen companion. He would have liked to put the mithril shirt there too, but that seemed to be the only gift he had not been able to take with him to the Gardens.
Kili’s room brought the same bitter tears, heightened when he thought of why the room had the only full-sized bed in the whole of Yavanna’s Garden. Thinking of Kili brought with it thoughts of Tauriel, whom Bilbo had been able to see a few years before his last birthday.
The woodland elf had been one of the few friends from Erebor who had come to visit her after his adventure. The first time, Tauriel had frightened the hobbit, for she had seemed a shadow of her former self, and though Bilbo did not want to admit it, he was in a similar condition. Together they had been able to weep and tell each other of their grief, better than anyone else in the Company could have done. In that moment Bilbo had understood the pain of the Elf, now alone and banished, and heartbroken before she could even enjoy it.
She and Kili were what the Elves called “United Souls”, created by Iluvatar to be each other’s only love. All elves, dwarves, and even hobbits had theirs, and losing it was the worst thing that could happen in this life. Elves, being immortal, enjoyed more time and connection with their Soul, but Tauriel had not been able to spend a single day with him. The elf, who had never experienced love at its most blissful, had to suffer until the end of time for its loss. For a hobbit or a dwarf, losing them was horrifying, because part of their essence and soul died with them, and they would never be whole again until they were reunited, but for an elf, it was far worse.
Elves, immortal, were destined never to be separated, so their souls were not designed to be lost or drifted away. Even Valinor would not allow them to be whole again if their companion died. Bilbo was able to see with his own eyes the reunion of two Souls in Elrond and Celebrian on the former’s arrival in Valinor, and he could not imagine the pain of one without the other for so long. Tauriel would never have that comfort.
The woodland elf had stayed in The Shire for a full year, and though Bilbo received some comment from his neighbours about his guest, he was quick to assure them that his friend would stay there as long as she wished. Gradually Tauriel’s eyes had lifted from her grief, and by the end of the year, she had departed with a promise to return for his birthday.
Year after year, the Elf had returned, first with tear-filled eyes, and after meeting Frodo, with a small smile that never reached her eyes, once full of brightness, and now empty and eternally sad.
The last time he had seen her, Bilbo had been a hundred years old, and the Elf had told him of a little journey she wanted to make to Lothlorien. They had said goodbye in a very sentimental way, for in Bilbo’s old age neither of them knew when her last visit would be.
Now as he looked up at the pearly ceiling of hand-drawn stars, Bilbo wondered what had become of his Elf-friend. He had not seen her in Valinor when he had arrived, and that had saddened him, but he had not wanted to ask Gandalf, wanting to think that wherever she was, she would have found a friend to help her continue to move on.
Bilbo wept all night long, thinking of Kili and his smiles and jokes, of the dwarf’s young life that had been taken from him when he was hardly an adult. He wept for the beautiful possibility that Kili had found and lost without even knowing it was here. He prayed that Mahal, as the dwarves called him, would let the young dwarf not suffer wherever he was as Tauriel suffered in Middle-Earth.
That night Bilbo dreamt of his Elf-friend there in Valinor, and of Frodo, whom he would one day see in the gardens. When he awoke, Bilbo could not help looking at the last door that awaited him, that of the only one he would have called king.
And when the thought crossed his mind, Bilbo knew that he would never be able to open that last door.
Time passed in the garden almost unnoticed by Bilbo. Every day was full of tranquillity, and the comfort of being in a house that reflected its owner, but every day Bilbo grew worse. Apathy was taking its toll on his spirit, and more often than not Bilbo wondered what was the point of spending his eternal life in this way. Yes, his ever-growing garden took up his whole morning, and once a week he was able to spend dinner with his parents. But what the hobbit really wanted and longed for was something he could not have in that place.
He longed for the adventure that had taken him to places his hobbit mind could never have conjured up. But most of all he missed the Company.
His friends, with whom he had loved so much, and whom he could never, ever see again. He missed Tauriel, and Gandalf and Elrond. But to be honest, and now he could be, he missed Thorin.
The stoic dwarf with whom he had formed the closest of bonds on that adventure. With whom he wished he had had more alone time. Who had given him the courage to be who he was. And who was given him the gift that had saved the life of the one he considered a son.
During that time Bilbo had at last accepted the feelings he had tried for so long to write off as friendship. And his acceptance of them had brought him both respite and burden: respite because he could at last put a name to all that he dared not conjure up in his mind. And a burden because it had all come too late.
And that burden kept Bilbo from being able to get on with his days without sitting in his armchair staring at the door he would never open.
His mood did not go unnoticed by anyone, and one day, as he sat in his armchair watching the door, Yavanna appeared at his side.
The Valar normally knocked on the door, as she considered it impolite to enter without knocking on the doors of her creations, but on this occasion, she had decided to be more direct.
As soon as Bilbo saw her sit down on the floor, he stood up out of respect.
“Sit in my chair Lady Yavanna, I’ll bring you some tea. I have a chamomile one I picked up a little while ago…”
“Bilbo, please sit down. We both know I did not come here for your tea, delicious as it is.” The hobbit looked down and joined the Valar on the floor.
The silence lasted a second before Bilbo burst into tears. Yavanna took his hands and allowed him to sob quietly. Her understanding was the last straw that calmed Bilbo’s heart, and he seemed eager for the Valar to tell him that she understood his pain.
“Bilbo, have you ever wondered what happens to dwarves when they die?” The hobbit rinsed his eyes awkwardly and looked at Yavanna.
“They go to the stone again, at least that is what Elrond told me.” Yavanna shook her head softly.
“The elves believe that, but it is not quite true. If Iluvatar deems them worthy of punishment, then they do turn to stone from the place where they did the most harm, but the rest of them go to Mandos, where Aulë, whom you will know as Mahal, has his world prepared for them. Just as you are here in my gardens.”
Bilbo, dumbfounded, looked at his lady. “How do you know this?”
Instantly he regretted his question. How stupid to ask a Valar about his knowledge of the universe. The Valar must have been offended.
Yavanna had not, and on the contrary to what he expected, burst out laughing in that way that Bilbo liked so much.
“Aulë, as you may remember, is my husband. His creation and mine go hand in hand. I can walk in his halls, and he can walk in my garden. I have seen Erebor in his world, and I know that Thorin is there, living as he did in his youth. And besides him, Fili enjoys all he can.”
“And Kili?”
The Valar’s smile diminished before his eyes.
“Kili tries, but as you well know from Tauriel, the loss of an Elven Soul is more painful than usual.”
“Then Tauriel is still in Middle-Earth.” Yavanna shook her head softly.
“She died but refuses to return in a new body to Valinor. Tauriel is a wandering soul in the Halls of Mandos, for that is her choice. She will never pass into her body, any more than Elrond’s daughter will.”
Yavanna’s sadness seemed to permeate the whole house, and though Bilbo was already miserable, his maker’s grief brought fresh tears to his eyes. The Valar caught those tears between her fingers.
“Bilbo, I know your soul will never be at peace with this knowledge. I have tried to speak to Mandos, but he can do nothing. Only one Soul can plead for a reunion with another.”
Bilbo nodded, understanding that he could never do anything for his friend, eternally locked up, nor for Kili, who seemed to suffer the same fate wherever he was. His sorrow seemed to go on forever when a thought crossed his mind.
“Lady Yavanna, you have walked through Erebor, does that mean that the garden can…” Bilbo would have continued with the question, but when he looked up, the Valar was no longer with him.
The thought still did not go out of his head.
Yavanna had said that she had walked in Erebor and that Aulë could walk in the gardens. The two worlds were connected. It may not have been in a tangible way, but Bilbo knew that the Valar preferred to avoid entering other worlds. It made them very tired, Yavanna had said, though Bilbo had not understood how one of them could get tired.
If Yavanna knew the Durin’s status, it was because she and Aulë could see each other often. After all, they were a couple. And if they saw each other often, it was because, at some point, the worlds came together.
“The Dwarf world was always underground!” Bilbo exclaimed to the empty hall.
Maybe the idea was madness. Or that it would never come to anything, but Bilbo had an eternity to tire of trying that idea.
First, he was going to apologise to his plants. And secondly, he was going to get his stoutest shovel.
He had a lot of digging to do.
One of the advantages of Yavanna’s Garden, or rather life after death, was the lack of hunger and sleep. At first, Bilbo had found the lack of the feeling of his stomach strange, as he did the fact that he could spend the whole night staring at the stars without needing to sleep, but gradually he had gotten used to it and enjoyed the food and the dreams as he had never done before.
Now that he had been digging without stopping for so long, he wondered if the feeling of food in his stomach would be once again strange.
Since he had started digging, countless suns and moons had passed, but none of it had made him stop. It had rained, it had been windy, and he had even experienced a thunderstorm, but none of it had made him stop.
His mother’s cries had almost convinced him at first, but in the end, he had managed to make her understand his idea, and Belladonna had agreed to let him work without rest for a year. If in a year he didn’t get out of the hole he was creating, they were going to have a problem.
Manual labour kept Bilbo’s mind sharp, and just the thought of being able to see his friends again was motivation enough to make the shovel light on his mind. There were moments of doubt, countless between the hours of burying the shovel to find more soft ground, but he didn’t let any of those thoughts stop him. He wasn’t going to stop until he found something, anything.
The day he found solid rock he was almost in tears with excitement. Bilbo did not know if it meant anything, but when he looked up and saw how much earth he had cleared out of his way, he thought that was a good sign. Yavanna didn’t need the rock there at all, that was Mahal’s.
So sure was he of his discovery, that after climbing up the long ladder he had set up, he did not stop for a moment as he picked up the pickaxe and climbed back down.
Crushing stone was much harder than digging, but he didn’t care. He had to find something down there, among all that solid rock. He was so excited that he began to count his hits on the stone, almost like a little mantra in his head. One more hit meant one step closer to his friends.
97311379 blows later, Bilbo remembered two important things that he had not taken into account until then:
1) The hole he had made was big enough to stand in, but it did not offer much room to jump in if the ground sank beneath his feet.
2) What he was going to do when the grund sank beneath his feet.
.
.
Bilbo would like to say that the fall was graceful, or that he did not utter a sound as he went down. But in Bilbo’s mind, there was only one word: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!
He was sure he had kicked as he fell, but he barely registered anything but the fall. He was thankful for that, otherwise, he would have thought about how much it would hurt once he stopped falling.
Luckily, death meant you couldn’t break any bones, so when he finally hit the ground, he only felt a very painful second.
Praying that he had not made a mistake, Bilbo lifted his head from the stone.
And met the surprised gaze of the occupants of the table where he had fallen.
The humiliation he might have felt at the realisation that he had fallen on the food was cancelled out by the fact that all who looked at him had beards and manes.
Dwarves.
He had made it.
