Chapter Text
I
Months after their visit to The Shire on the road back from the Blue Mountains, Prince Thorin, Heir to Erebor, a great kingdom of dwarves, receives a golden, curly lock of hair seemingly coming from the head of one hobbit by the name of Bilbo Baggins.
The mere sight of it nearly makes him choke on his own breath.
Thorin had been thinking back on his days in the fair eastern country quite long and often ever since his company had made it back to Erebor, maybe even before, on Dale or, dare he say, Esgaroth, familiar, safe land for them even if it was not truly theirs, but of men. Of one particular man - although perhaps more of a thorn on his side - in the case of Esgaroth.
“You seem distracted, my friend,” Bard had commented during one of the few evenings he had managed to host Thorin and his folk before they had continued northwards along the Lake’s coastline. “Something heavy on your mind? Trouble on your journey back, perhaps?”
Thorin latched onto the line Bard had inadvertently cast him like someone near drowning, delving into a retelling of their encounters with goblins in the Misty Mountains and large spiders deep in Mirkwood, mostly watching them from the shadows beyond the poorly kept elven path.
Bard, keen as he is, keener than plenty of folks first realize or even suspect, had not seemed all that reassured by his reasoning and his concerns about the rising dangers even as near to their homes as Mirkwood, but he had let it slide and chosen to engage him further, at least for the time being.
“I have been told by trusty sources that the Elvenking has been concerning himself and his people with the matter of the spiders, it has simply been difficult to locate their wretched nest,” Bard had commented while swirling his wine indifferently, he even grinned his perpetually boyish grin - the one he has been shooting Thorin’s way ever since he was a wee lad - when the dwarf glared at him.
Trusty sources amongst elves, of course, and Thorin has weeds instead of hair on his head.
“Tell you what, my friend: you don’t say anything about my elven sources , and I won’t pry about whatever’s truly gotten into your head.” The fiend’s smile widened when he asked: “What say you?”
“I say your prolonged stay in Esgaroth is clearly helping you put your etiquette lessons behind, but other than that, I may be amenable to concede.”
Bard had snorted roughly at that and the evening had retaken more agreeable courses. The following morning, Bard had bid them farewell with a promise to further discuss the matter of the goblin and spider threats, maybe even with further news as to what Thranduil’s thoughts and plans on the matter were.
But Thorin had not left his thoughts about The Shire at Bard’s doorstep, nor along the new road - barely even it, truly - that connects the off-shoot fisher’s town to Dale, following the eastern shore of the Great Lake and further up the river. Thorin understood why the men of Dale had decided to raise another settlement, and why they had chosen the place they did; he even understood why Lord Habard had chosen to send his firstborn above anybody else to oversee the proceedings, but he still worries over his young friend, a good few days ride away from home, even further from Erebor, and with so few warriors and seemingly hardly any defenses whatsoever at his disposal. There are times when he can barely muster rest due to the consuming concern that washes over him at the thought of Bard, barely grown into manhood and persistently, annoyingly in love with an elf as he is, having to defend the sorry excuse for a town from all manner of foes with fishermen, weavers, herbalists, and two dozens soldiers, the only ones he will have at hand until Dale sends him another company.
But not this time, because this time he has The Shire to dream of instead, even as he finally gets to lay his weary head on his own pillow, his body sinking heavily into his luxurious bed, bathed in and lulled by the starless shadows of his darkened room after a long day marked by the last leg of their journey home from the City of Dale, and a long, bordering on tedious, welcoming feast, where it had seemed half the kingdom over had stopped by to offer greetings and wishes before Frerin had eventually been convinced, with no small amount of pleading and bribing, to help him flee without their Father or Lord Fundin noticing until it was far too late for either to do much about it.
It had been a hard won battle then, but it had yielded long, plentiful rest after so many long months away from his beloved home, as it had sweet, fanciful dreams of the fair land far to the west beyond the Misty Mountains. Dreams of wild meadows, rich fields, shady groves and clear springs; dreams of warm, comforting houses, inhabited by equally warm, welcoming folks. And flowers, flowers all around, growing untamed on the sides of roads and the edges of roofs, or with the care of a gentle hand in pots and on windowsills, or even cut and arranged into bouquets and vases. And then even more, vines crawling up pillars, grass on the roofs, moss thriving on stone walls.
He had left the country, ridden away on his trusty pony without a second backwards glance, but with a heart heavy with unearned peace and the knowledge that his mother would have loved even knowing about such a wondrous place existing.
Now, as the beginning of winter settles upon them like a too cold, white blanket, and the Prince stares at the lock of hair, wide-eyed with a numb, dismayed sort of shock, Thorin is not quite certain of much of anything anymore.
“Hobbits are simple, merry folk who rather keep to themselves and ignore the larger world around them if it means keeping their mundane peace,” Gandalf the Grey had told them the night before he had led them into the isolated country. “Just don’t drag mud into their homes, and compliment their food and gardens, that will get them to warm up to your lot in no time despite their guardedness.”
Thorin does not quite believe that Mithrandir himself, as cryptic, tempestuous or mischievous as he may be, has intentionally misled them, that much he can bring himself to trust, but something must have gone awry during their impromptu courtesy visit to the halflings, or maybe even in the meantime between their departure from The Shire and the posterior send off of the missive with the golden curl attached to it, something he had not noticed, he had not prevented.
Thorin freezes in his disheartened contemplation of the lock of hair he has been twirling every which way in his hand, lost in thought for the past several minutes, the realization that he has not read the missive yet spurring him on into decided action. Perhaps there will be an explanation on it, something, anything.
My grand Dwarven Lord, I send to you this token of my most sincere intentions with one of our most trustworthy messengers in the hopes that it shall reach you, whole and untainted, as you yourself reach your homeland and I await for your response, perhaps with the first snow, maybe with the first blooms.
- Bilbo Baggins of Bag End, The Shire.
The Prince, the grand Dwarven Lord , reads and rereads the text, stares at it, watches it as if willing the words to turn and change, and hopefully to reveal some more solid, straightforward meaning, all the while thinking of it as most irregular. Yes, most irregular indeed.
Thorin drops the items on the somewhat unoccupied circle at the center of his otherwise cluttered writing desk, emptying his hands so he can rub the palms against his face in a rough motion to scrub the sudden weariness off. Then he stands up with renewed vigor, takes the missive and the token , which he pockets away from prying eyes, and leaves his offices in search of Balin.
While in The Shire, the talks had mostly fallen back on his older cousin, if only because he had gotten along swimmingly with the Thain, Master Gerontius Took, and said gentle hobbit’s wife, Lady Adamanta, while Thorin had been plagued with the tiredness and tediousness product of the negotiating and chatting and everything else that came with both he had been dragging from the Blue Mountains, where he had only had very little, very distant kin, and everyone in the Court seemed weary, contrary, dismissive, or almost antagonistic. Matters in The Shire had been nothing like that, the worst they had faced had been poorly concealed suspicion from the more distrustful folks, most of which had kept to themselves, and the few that had been present in their councils in the so-called Great Smials had been cautious rather than hostile. In fact, between everyone in the company, they could hardly count enough instances of perceived hostility from the gentlefolk to raise all the fingers in one hand, and it had not been as if they had been kept isolated and indoors throughout their stay
Thorin thinks of all such things as he makes his way to Balin’s offices, where he gets to hear the same thoughts and then some as his cousin echoes his own dumbfounded distress.
“It simply makes no sense,” Balin agrees, reading through the missive once more after further consideration. “But…”
Thorin raises a dark, questioning eyebrow as both of Balin’s snowy ones furrow into a thoughtful frown, yet otherwise leaves the older, wiser dwarf to it; after all, his cousin never fails to deliver.
“This name, Bilbo Baggins ,” Balin begins anew with careful deliberation. “I cannot recall anybody going by Bilbo , but I do remember the name Baggins : it was the name of one of their most important families or clans. It was thrown around a few times in the Great Smials and I believe two or three people there bore it, perhaps you noticed as well. One of them had been a child of The Thain that had married into the family, Donna, who was accompanied by her own son, which I never had the pleasure to meet; the other had been an older fellow, almost as old as Master Gerontius, but his given name had been something with E, Edy perhaps.”
“And you believe that this Bilbo might be someone related to either, yes?”
Balin shrugs helplessly, handing the damned items back to him. “At the very least the name gives the declaration more credence, for all that the statement is most improper to our traditions: this could very well be the widely used form for their people.”
Thorin rearranges the items into a more presentable display for their sensitivities and stands up to head back out.
“Thank you very much, Balin. Your council is, as ever, much appreciated. My apologies for taking your time.”
Balin waves him off and wishes him the best with this new dilemma of his, still clearly concerned with it, and Thorin takes his leave, back to his office where he spends the next two hours attempting to make a dent on his workload instead of letting his mind be consumed by thoughts of the message resting in his pocket, which could not be clamoring for his attention any louder if it could in fact speak.
By the time noon comes and goes, Thorin cannot rightly say he has made much progress or if what he has managed to do is of any good, but he could - not that he would - proclaim that he has now forgotten to eat. He hardly feels any inklings of appetite as he makes his way to the throne room, either way, and he only has to wait for a moment as a royal guard ushers him past the queue and his father holds court.
When he finally finds himself before the King Under the Mountain, Thorin remains quiet, subdued, as he respectfully passes the missive to the dwarf, sitting straight and dignified on his throne, bare and plain with the Arkenstone gone, yet imposing nonetheless.
Thráin II accepts the items with a gracious nod and begins unraveling them as his son takes a few mannerly steps back. The older dwarf reads the short missive once, inspects the lock of hair with a keen eye and deposits it on the cool stone armrest to get back to the text once more.
“I see the design of this declaration is anything but standard,” his father notes and raises his serene yet tired glance towards Thorin. “Who sent it?”
“A hobbit from The Shire, Your Majesty. It would explain the irregularity in format, I believe.”
Thrain nods, rubbing at the leaf of paper in his hand with absent swipes of his ringed thumb.
“Well, there’s nothing to it: all declarations of war must be answered, regardless of who sends them.”
Thorin has the faint feeling that Gandalf will be most vexed by this news.
II
While yes, all declarations of war must be answered , there are regulations, times and places, bureaucracy, if one will, and they will hardly take up arms and make the journey across Arda and into the West during the worst of Winter for a formal conflict such as this one.
They consider and reconsider sending a reply, but the discussions around the subject always circled back to propriety and whether or not it was even worth it to risk sending a raven across the Misty Mountains at the time, or if any of their winged messengers would even agree to the task. In the end, they compromise and send a raven ahead of them as they part with the last of the early Spring thaws, Thorin taking the lead with one full company, his own personal troupe included, the main bulk of the army falling behind while they cross the Mountains, Balin and Dwalin steadfast next to him, one of their most trustworthy Lords leading the rest.
“Was this what you had in mind when you came back from the West?” Bard questions him as he meets them on the western shores of the Lake before they turn on the road into Mirkwood.
“Not at all, as a matter of fact,” Thorin replies and tries to vanquish the expression of harsh disappointment Bard cannot quite hide from him out of his mind from then onwards. “Do read my letter when you return to Esgaroth, it should be waiting there for you already, and explain what the matter is sufficiently.”
And promise you that I will do my very best with the preliminary negotiations, if only for yours and Frerin’s sakes and peace of mind , Thorin does not add, Bard will read all about it in due time.
Thranduil gives them very little trouble, likely because he is not entirely in the know of their goings on yet but knows it is nothing involving him or any other elven country; he may even be assuming they are taking the initiative against the goblin and orc problem in the Misty Mountains. His scouts believe they spot Beorn, Gandalf’s shapeshifter acquaintance, from a distance, cautious yet seemingly uninterested, likely of a mind with Thranduil about their proceedings.
And in all fairness, they do make quick work of the few bands of goblins and orcs they find along their path, or that try to ambush them with the cover of night. Tit for tat, he consoles himself after they dispatch what should be their last stray orcs before their proximity to Rivendell dissuades them from attempting anything further. The main host will likely send them scattering in fright with its presence alone, and even in the unlikely event of a band or two choosing to take their chances, they will find themselves with formidable, perfectly equipped and skilled dwarves, the kind that would make even the worst Gundabad orcs hesitant.
Their predictions are correct and they do not encounter a single orc moving forwards, the cries of their warg mounts breaking the nights from faraway as they keep pushing towards The Shire, as close to Rivendell and the settlements of men as they dare and only for safety. They do rush past Rivendell as to not be held back or confronted by Lord Elrond, and barely stop for rest until they reach the outskirts of Bree, where a small party is sent to the town in search of news and supplies while the others rest and tend to the ponies.
“Nothing of note from The Shire,” Balin relays when the party returns. “Not from the men and not from the halflings living here, so I assume they either have no affiliation to their country of origin or were waiting for us to return there with their own forewarning.”
“And what of Lord Dvalinn?”
His cousin gestures for one of his companions to step forward on his pony, a large, young adult raven, their black coat pristine and glossy under the noon sunlight, perched on the dwarf’s forearm. The message is short and straight to the point, raven and Prince may even spend more time presenting their pleasantries than on the act of transmitting the words themselves. And made even simpler: Lord Dvalinn and the host of the army continue their advance, unimpeded and at a good rhythm, not two days behind Thorin’s battalion.
Thorin watches the grand bird take flight towards the east and north of their location in an out of the way clearing and proclaims: “We will rest for another two hours, then push closer to The Shire, only enough to finish the last leg of the journey tomorrow morning and make our way into the easternmost borders of the country around noon, if all goes well.”
The older dwarf agrees with him but otherwise remains in his spot, staring intensely into the West, as if he could catch a glimpse of the fair country’s borders from where they stand, despite the distance, the terrain, and the woodland still between them. Thorin prods gently at him.
Balin sighs with a shake of his head. “Something, perhaps only a gut feeling, does not sit quite right with me. Like we are missing a key detail that could bring us a clarity we were not aware we are being kept from.”
“Well, whatever it is, if there truly is such a thing, it will surely surface to enlighten us come tomorrow.”
“Surely it will,” Balin acquiesces, falling silent and meditative once more. Thorin leaves him to it this time and goes to check on the rest of the group once more before having a lie down himself.
That night is spent half-hidden in a thick grove, quiet and fireless, until dawn starts to break through, tinging the clouds to the East with gentle grays, purples and oranges. Thorin does not believe he has slept more than an hour, heavy has been his mind and his heart.
The Prince takes the lead in the somber march into The Shire with Balin by his side, and surrounded by twenty of his finest warriors. Another twenty dwarves march at a slower rhythm much further back yet close enough to quickly come to their aid should they need it, and the rest of his company, under the command of Dwalin, remains waiting just by the borderline of the fair country, the larger group waiting for any signals of trouble as much as they do the arrival of the main host, which must be just shy of reaching them by the time Thorin’s group walks across the first signs of habitation.
Some of the few, scattered about hobbits they encounter at first stop to stare at them, awed at the sight but otherwise serene and devoid of any suspicion, either outright or thinly veiled. Perhaps these hobbits are not aware of the war the most esteemed amongst them have declared, which would be incredibly irresponsible from said esteemed halflings. Or maybe it is all a trick to confuse them and make them underestimate their own forces until it is too late and the dwarves fall into the trap; he doubts it is so, however, as Nori and his small group keep sending them cues to move forward, that everything is clear of traps and ambushes. There is yet a third option, and that is that these folks do not care or do not understand the severity of the situation, which only serves to make his heart sink even heavier within his chest.
Thorin prompts the flag-bearer to send a discreet sign for the group behind them to remain cautious nonetheless, and they keep pushing further in, into Buckland, all the way to Bucklebury, one of the most important centers on this side of the country, and their best chance at beginning negotiations as soon as possible instead of having to cut across most of The Shire in order to reach the Great Smials, even if they will still have to either wait for The Thain to reach them for the formal acceptance of the war declarations and any final agreements, or, most likely, for their group to be escorted the rest of the way, but even that could prove productive, if they are accompanied by any important, sensible gentle hobbits.
“Don’t they see our flag, our armor, our weapons ?” A soldier to his right, Dag he thinks, hisses, eyes wide under his helmet jumping from one impassive, curious hobbit to the next with sheer alarm. Thorin understands the feeling all too well.
“Back so soon, Dwarf Masters?” A voice calls out as they approach the village through the main road, along which the market sets up from sunrise to noon.
It almost makes Thorin stop in his tracks when he recognizes the owner of that voice as one Rorimac Brandybuck, the oldest son of the locally esteemed Gorbadoc Brandybuck, and held quite highly himself, as he had been deemed important or trustworthy enough, Thorin supposes, to have had guided them through the easternmost area of the East Farthing, nearly a year prior now.
“Master Brandybuck,” Thorin recovers quickly and discreetly. This hobbit, despite living in one of the hearts of this country, seems as unconcerned and unknowing as the ones they had found further out on the small roads, and the Prince would even go as far to say he even looks joyful as he goes to meet them. “I am afraid we are here on urgent matters. Is there any chance you could point us in the direction of any officials of The Shire? Or towards a Shirriff, in their stead?”
Master Brandybuck’s face takes on a concerned expression and an ashen pallor as he hears Thorin speak, and when he replies, the empathetic tone in his voice makes the dwarf prince feel like a villain.
“Well, that’s awful sad news to hear, my good Lord. I do hope it’s nothing too catastrophic,” the halfling says with genuine, heartfelt sentiment, and Thorin is of half a mind to say something back to him, to ridiculously comfort him, maybe, but Master Brandybuck forges on, already on the move even before he adds: “Follow me right this way.”
Thorin and his band of warriors do as much.
“Something’s not right here,” Thorin hears Balin mutter, just barely loud enough for him to hear and nobody else. Thorin cannot help but to agree with his cousin, if only within the confines of his mind.
“Now, I do have to make something clear, my dear lords,” Master Brandybuck begins as he energetically guides them forwards, towards his own paternal home from the looks of it. “I suppose I didn’t do much of a good job at explaining it during your previous visit, but it’s the kind of thing that slips from our minds, you see, I hope you can forgive my mistake. The matter is, this is Buckland , my Lord, not The Shire. We are very close neighbors, of course, and have enough relations to be considered irrevocably intertwined, but we are inherently independent countries despite that, if that makes any sense to your big world sensitivities, I suppose.”
“It does, as a matter of fact,” Thorin assures, surprised by this turn of events nonetheless. He glances at Balin and discovers the same sentiment in his expression. “We have a similar relationship with a city of Men.”
“Truly?” Master Brandybuck questions with a swift backwards glance, clearly curious despite the situation.
“Indeed. The city of Dale settled just shy of the skirts of The Lonely Mountain many centuries ago, and while they were very much dependent on our own Kingdom for several generations, they are now considered their own entity by us both, and everybody else in the neighboring countries.”
Master Brandybuck makes a curious noise of realization. “Won’t you look at that.”
“If you are independent of The Shire then, may I ask what you intend by leading us to your father, who, I now assume, is an authority of Buckland.”
“Oh, he is an authority alright,” young Rorimac nearly chuckles. “I know we’re using the term Master rather liberally here, but my father is the Master of Buckland as of right now. See, if there’s any help you need, we’re more than happy to offer it, as I know The Shire will be as well, and visiting my father can prove most productive. On the other hand, if your businesses are strictly with The Shire, surely you can still benefit from the guidance and help of a Brandybuck or two, don’t you think?”
While the first option was not quite the matter at the moment, the second does not sound entirely convincing to Thorin, but at a gesture from Bali, he decides to concede and accept the appropriate help from Master Brandybuck, who seems quite pleased with the agreement.
Just as quickly as young Rorimac previously turned things on their head, he also provides them with two trustworthy guides: Orgulas Brandybuck and Rodolph Burrows, the first an uncle of Rorimac, and the second an experienced boulder of Brandybuck. And off they go once again, this time straight to Frogmorton, first along the main road of Buckland that follows the Brandywine River, north towards the Bridge, where they turn to their left down The East Road. Masters Brandybuck and Burrows ride on ponies of their own, which helps them maintain a steady, trot-like pace on the well-kept roads. They are also both made of quieter stuff than other hobbits they have met so far, such as young Rorimac himself; still, when the opportunity introduces itself, Thorin does not let it escape him and he asks if either of them know of anybody named Bilbo Baggins.
Master Burrows shakes his head without much thought, but Master Brandybuck’s reply is more noteworthy, even if there is a hint of thinly veiled suspicion in his voice.
“He’s Belladonna Took’s and Bungo Baggins’ lad,” he begins, confirming one of Balin’s theories. “Lives up in Hobbiton, near The Water River, with his ma. Good people, the both of them, never mind how weird the rest of Hobbiton likes to say they are.”
“ Weird how?” Thorin presses with genuine confusion. Hobbits are odd to him and his people, and he cannot quite envision what strangeness may entail to them in turn, other than, say, dwarves themselves.
Master Brandybuck scoffs. “They’re too restless, too adventurous,” and Thorin does not believe he is imagining the tired aggravation in the hobbit’s voice. “If you ask me, Master Dwarf, it’s the rest of Hobbiton that’s too sheltered, you mark my words. Truly, being a rebellious young lad is nothing so severe, in the grand scheme of things.”
Thorin almost wants to scoff at that himself. In the grand scheme of things that was nothing, which only gave further credence to the intent behind the missive.
Keeping a good pace and only stopping twice to let their mounts rest from the exertion and out of the sun, they reach Frogmorton while they still have two or so hours of daylight, even if that is a gentler, cooler light, starting to gain a purple and orange tint of approaching sunset. The refreshing breeze and easier light does nothing to calm Thorin’s rising temper, unfortunately, as they receive the same reactions in true Shire territory as they had in Buckland. Which made sense with the riverside country, given some thought: simply because they were neighboring lands did not mean that The Shire had the obligation to include Buckland in their war plans, even if still was far from the optimal, moral thing to do. But now that they are amongst the easy-going, sheltered hobbits of the fair country, Thorin was genuinely convinced that their government had been just as irresponsible with them as they had been with their neighbors, more so, even.
Did these folks have no concept of what a war entailed, or were their plans far more sinister than the dwarves could guess or imagine?
Only two things were certain: Thorin, and the rest of Erebor by extension, would never trust Mithrandir’s judgment again, and the folk responsible for this vile situation would meet a most gruesome end courtesy of his ire, which increased more and more as they finally approached the home of Frogmorton’s Mayor, a squat brick building with too many windows for his comfort that also doubled as the hobbit’s office. And it must be through one of said windows that the seemingly affable saw them come, for he steps out of his door with a warm smile and a welcoming gesture while the group is still several meters away, heavily trudging along the main street under the eyes of all other hobbits present in the immediate area, a few more joining their families, friends and neighbors in a horrid, nightmarish merry gathering.
This time, Thorin does not dare face his cousin, or anybody else in the tensely silent group, not that he believes he could, his eyes fixed on the esteemed hobbit meeting them halfway.
“My good Lord Thorin, Your Highness,” Master Bryce greets him much like he had previously done, as if he could not quite decide which titles to use in what order yet did not find it tedious to use several together. It was as oddly charming as the rest of the halfling was. “We weren’t expecting you back here so soon, but you are very much welcome nonetheless!”
Are we , Thorin wonders, alarm, shock and anger mixing unpleasantly within him.
“Master Bryce,” Thorin, who had etiquette lessons as a young child even before he could properly read, barely manages to salute back with a jerky nod, not that the sunny gentle hobbit seems to notice anything amiss.
“Do tell me, to what do we owe the pleasure? Hopefully nothing bad, we’d hate for any tragedies to befall such wonderful folks as yourselves!”
He understands, knows that this is neither the place or the standard for a formal acceptance, but Thorin is too wrong footed and dazed, and nothing in this situation has been regular, or right, as it seems, and not even Balin seems to truly know what to do, uncharacteristically tense beside him.
“We have come to formally accept your declared intent to war against the Kingdom of Erebor,” Thorin replies, detached but clear.
It does not escape him the way their two guides from Buckland - who had led their ponies to the side - tense at the words, sighing with heavy disappointment if without any surprise, although most of his attention still remains on Master Bryce, who wears an expression of innocent, near comical dumbfoundment. Thorin wants to shake or shout at him, he is not quite sure which.
A sound breaks the silence before Thorin can decide on either or perhaps make an attempt at something more sensible instead, a sound that chills the blood in his veins: the twinkling, melodious laughter of a golden-haired hobbit lass who bends forwards at the waist with the hilarity seizing her. It is the breaking of the dam, as not two heartbeats later every hobbit old enough to understand what Thorin has just said - and some of the younger ones who are clearly only following the adults’ lead - is laughing with abandon, crying and wheezing from it, or exchanging riotous commentary with their friends. The only ones who do not join in on the impromptu festivities are Master Brandybuck and Master Burrows, the first of which only shaking his head at the crowd with patent contempt while his younger companion watches on.
This is more or less the moment when Thorin starts praying to Mahal.
“Oh, dear,” Master Bryce huffs, simultaneously trying to straighten up, wipe the few stray tears that have escaped him and regain his breath, and failing equally at all. “Didn’t think you lot would be such jesters, my Lord, apologies. War! Oh, sweet Eru, not even the littlest Tooks could come up with something like this.”
Thorin and the rest of the dwarves remain deadly silent and still on top of their shuffling and huffing mounts, wide-eyed with something that is not quite abject horror, but is not all that far from it, either. Not a minute too soon, Master Brandybuck dismounts from his own pony, hands over the reins to Master Burrows before walking up to them and unceremoniously yet still somewhat dignified taking a hold of the Mayor’s arms and guiding him back into the house, suggestively away from the crowd that has begun to disperse, many of the gentle folk likely heading back home or to the nearby tavern to get a nice, warm meal and spread the news about dwarven humor amongst those who missed the spectacle. The dwarves themselves remain rooted to the stop, incredibly tense despite Master Burrows best attempts to reassure them.
It is as if they can finally breathe again when the Mayor comes out of his home once more, this time accompanied by Master Brandybuck and with a far more suitably serious expression on his face, even if it is decidedly not quite severe yet in Thorin’s opinion.
“And I am telling you , Orgulas, that this must all be either a gross misunderstanding or a prank gone too far! It’s all a matter of which is it and who the responsibles may be, although I would bet some good money on some precocious young Tooks being behind all of this,” Master Bryce comes to rejoin them, hissing at his fellow hobbit all the way until he reaches Thorin anew, this time taking a more considering look at Thorin’s and Balin’s more formal attire as well as the reglementary armor on the rest of the dwarves, the pinkish color draining from his face. Still, he forges on with exemplary determination. “Your Highness, my apologies for my reaction but Master Brandybuck has seen fit to enlighten me about the situation. We do not find ourselves involved in affairs such as these often, as you may have guessed, but that is merely an excuse, and a frankly poor one at that. I do believe this is a genuine misunderstanding of some sort, but that is besides the point: what precisely do you need of me, my good Lord?”
Thorin does not need to think on the matter, at the very least: “I believe it would be best if you guided us to The Thain, immediately, if that is possible.”
“It will be quickly arranged. In the meantime, you may want to let your mounts get some rest, surely.”
They do, and so they follow a young page towards a nearby rest stop where they can dismount and let the animals pace and drink from a fountain set for them. No council is held, not even in Khuzdul, but the looks and gestures Balin sends his way reflect his own thoughts: this situation has unequivocally gone from irregular to bizarre, and it was bound to get worse before there was any chance of it getting better.
The journey further West renews shortly after, this time with Master Bryce and one of his own boulders leading the group while their Bucklander guides guard the back, the four of them setting a livelier pace than the one they had been keeping until then, admittedly more manageable for their beasts now that the Sun is setting. This time, they only stop briefly to light a few torches as they hit a more densely forested area, where the clear light of the stars and the large, round moon cannot reach them.
Even with the picking of speed, it must be late at night by the time they reach Tuckborough, late enough for most upstanding hobbits to be fast asleep in their beds, and any others on their way to do the same. And yet, Master Bryce steadfastly leads them all the way to the large, round, green door of the Great Smials, going as far as to swiftly dismount and knock on the painted wood in advance while Thorin and Balin get off their rams and step forwards themselves.
Master Bryce remains by their side, awkward yet decided. “Should I introduce you or will you do so yourselves?”
Thorin mulls on it for a moment: on one hand he only needs to introduce himself to formally accept the declaration of war, which his words in Frogmorton most certainly were not, and on the other, the poor Mayor could probably use something to focus on before he breaks down under the anxiety and uncertainty.
“You may introduce us, but you cannot declare our intentions for us, other than our need to meet The Thain in person and with haste,” he replies, just before a young hobbit, one of Master Gerontius’ and Lady Adamanta’s daughters he recognizes by face if not by name, answers, still in her day clothes and clearly up late for some reason, another of her kin popping his head out a doorway with a plate and a cloth in his hands further in.
The lass listens to Master Bryce and for a moment immediately after it almost looks like she will send them back to where they came from, tell them to come back at a proper hour when the Sun’s out, ask them if this was some poorly thought out prank, only her expression is leaning towards irritation rather than the amusement they had been met with earlier.
“Miss, please,” Master Bryce pleads with earnest severity, however.
After further, relentless insistence the lass finally relinquishes, only putting her foot down on the two soldiers she allows to enter the house instead of the traditional four, Thorin acquiescing in the hopes it will help smooth things even just a tad and taking comfort in the added presence of Master Bryce and Master Brandybuck.
And so she leads them down corridors and beyond doors, following the same path towards the large reading room they had first been hosted in the previous year, this time much darker, veiled by night and the very few candles that remain lit at the hour. The lass only stops to tell her companion - her brother Isengar, Thorin realizes when they are closer - to get their father and mother, maybe even a few others too, he cannot quite catch everything they whisper to each other and some of it may not even be in Westron.
The hobbit lass has them seated, lights up all the candles in the room, and is questioning them if they want anything to drink or eat, still suspicious yet keeping to the usual manners reserved for guests, when The Thain of The Shire finally steps into the room, closely followed by his wife and a pair of his sons, only one of the later haphazardly dressed in his day clothes while all the others are as proper and prim as they can possibly be in their nightgowns, which is surprisingly quite a lot, Thorin thinks, with their long, impressively crafted robes and their noticeably combed back hair, Lady Adamanta having deftly pinned her silvery curls away from her face.
“Your Highness, Prince Thorin,” the new appearances bow lightly in their usual manner at Master Gerontius’ clear greeting, his eyes expressing the same concern and suspicion as his serviceable daughter. “And Master Balin, too, good evening to you both! Well, this is a surprise, we were not expecting either of you to come back this soon.”
“Likewise,” Thorin replies, the steadiness of his voice and gesture bellying his inner weariness. “And yet, here we are.”
“Indeed,” Master Gerontius agrees with a sudden sharpening of his posture and of his eyes. He quickly shepherds his kin, sending one of his sons - the one wearing nightclothes - to the kitchens to make with food and drinks, and pointing the others, even his daughter, to settle in the seats arranged in front of the dwarves and their two hobbit companions, where Lady Adamanta is already poised and measuring them with a clever eye like the one of a raven.
“Now, let’s get straight into it: what seems to be the matter, Master Thorin?” The Thain begins once he himself is seated right at the middle of his group, yet another two members of his family walking in in the meantime and quickly taking a seat after a quick glance.
Thorin makes with the missive, pulling it out of the internal breast pocket of his jacket, and shows it to all present, most eyes diverting to it save for those of the older couple, who keep their undivided attention on him.
“I, Prince Thorin of Erebor, son of King Thráin, second of his name, have come to The Shire, to the presence of Thain Gerontius Took, to formally accept this country’s declared intention of war as contained within this letter.”
The words taste like ash as he speaks them into the world, and by the time he has finished his part he can hear the thunder of his fast beating heart like a drum in his ears. The hobbits simply stare at him, faces blank with the most complete shock.
Eventually, one of the younger attendees breaks into a short bark of laughter, breaking the spell. This time, Thorin is somewhat relieved to note the sound has none of the ecstatic joy of the folks at Frogmorton, but rather seems to be infused with something akin to hysteria. And if nothing else, at least the shrill noise spurs them into action.
Master Gerontius points towards the missive with a slightly shaky finger and asks: “That’s meant to be our so-called declaration of war, yes? Mind if I take a look at it? Because this is the first time I am hearing of such a nonsensical thing.”
Thorin lowers his arm holding the letter and rests it on his upper leg, the declaration still there for everyone to see - and see they do, as if caught in a trance by it - but without the risk of his muscles numbing with the raised position if he were to keep it for long enough. And this looks like it will be a long affair.
“I am afraid I cannot do so, not until the sender has confirmed the veracity of it, at the very least,” Thorin informs them of the dwarven tradition.
“Well, may I at least know who that sender was?”
“One Bilbo Baggins of Bag End, I believe he is a grandson of yours.”
If the hobbits were shocked before, they are positively confounded now, looking at Thorin as if he had started speaking orcish instead of common, amongst other equally disconcerting things.
“Hogwash,” one of them says, the same who had barked with hysterical laughter before, and he looks positively offended. At the implication that this Master Baggins would do such a thing, perhaps?
Master Gerontius shoots his young relative a sharp look of reproach. “Falco, I know you’re only visiting but go fetch Isengrim and Isembold, take some ponies, and go to Hobbiton to get Bilbo. Drag him here if you have to.”
The poor lad, Falco, looks bewildered, likely at the idea of having to drag one of his fellows, but stands up and goes to do as he is told, only stopping halfway towards the door to ask: “And Auntie Donna too?”
Lady Adamanta snorts delicately at that. “If you think you could keep her from following after her dear son’s been accused of such tomfoolery, you have another thought coming.”
The lad pales further, nods jerkily and scampers away. In his wake, Master Gerontius turns towards his daughter, the very same one who had greeted them at the door, whose name Thorin still does not know.
“Sweetheart, go wake all the lads of age and tell them to gather the nearby Shirriffs and family and clan heads, and to bring them here in the meantime, yes? There’s no need to hurry, so long as we’ve got some of them present before dawn.”
Off goes the lass too, who does not bother hiding the furious glare she shoots at them as she steps out. For a deafeningly quiet moment after that, Master Gerontius and Lady Adamanta look at each other with emotions unfathomable for them.
It is the Lady of the house who turns to address them once more. “Do you need to rest? We have plenty of guest rooms to offer you and all your people outside as well, and we don’t expect Falco to return with Bilbo until dawn, at the earliest.”
Thorin presents her with a grateful smile, but otherwise declines the generous offer. “It is not our custom to accept such services from our hosts in these situations, even accepting your food is uncommon for us, and we only do so now out of deference to you.”
Lady Adamanta nods at him, not quite appeased it would seem, but understanding, and truly that is all he could possibly ask of her, or any other hobbit, and her husband remains just as steadfast beside her as the night progresses relentlessly onwards. He takes a moment to send word of the situation to those waiting on him, but other than that, he stays where he has been seated in the reading room, his back to the wall and his eyes patiently measuring any and all new arrivals as they come in.
And come in they do, first with a trickle, maybe two or three bleary eyed hobbits per hour bumbling in and wondering what on everything that was good was the matter, then with a creek, a river, a torrent, more and more halflings of varied stature, shape and status pouring in as the break of dawn approaches, the patches of sky he can catch glimpses of between the curtains across the room from him gaining a gray and periwinkle tinge to them. He remains steadfast and stoic through the long night with the help of training, which does make him wonder how the hobbits seem to fare about as well as they do. Stubbornness and anxiety, perhaps, with a helping of good food, hot beverages and no small amount of company. The older fellows, amongst them Master Gerontius and Lady Adamanta, do take short leaves to be better rested come the main event , as the gentle folks have taken to call this entire situation in general, and whatever awaits for them at the appearance of Bilbo Baggins in specific. A peaceful resolution, Thorin hopes despite any world weariness.
As the Sun peeks over the side of the world and starts its slow crawl across the skies, the reading room, as large as it is, starts to fill until it is fit to burst both with Tooks of all ages and figureheads from The Shire. Even Gandalf makes an appearance, not long before noon, announcing his arrival with a frantic ruckus that grows louder and louder as he gets closer and closer to them, many of the halflings eyeing the door with trepidation, bracing for whatever new unsavory surprise is headed their way, until the wizard bursts in, a confusing, shapeless, liquid entity made up of dirtied grays and breathing heavily at first glance, the twinkling of wide, stormy eyes the first sign that this may be a much more earthly kind of apparition, for a somewhat free usage of the word earthly . He makes his way to the four dwarves, mostly left alone in their place by the wall, as soon as he catches sight of them.
“What is the meaning of this?” Gandalf demands, wild eyed, and Thorin believes that the gray wizard would go so far as shout it with the intensity of thunder and cave-ins even in the cramped room, if he were not attempting to yet regain his breath.
Thorin remains impassive before the old, powerful being if only thanks to sheer willpower and the stubborn conviction that he is doing this the proper way, regardless of the outcome.
“We are here simply to answer a declaration of war emitted from this country, by a hobbit named Bilbo Baggins.”
A deadly hush befalls the room as the attendees watch them intently, and if Thorin thought the Tooks had seemed thoroughly incredulous in the face of his words last night, he is not quite sure how to qualify Gandalf’s reaction now.
“Nonsense!” The wizard, bending uncomfortably due to the too-low ceiling that is perfect for hobbits and dwarves alike, proclaims with angry certitude. “Is that the declaration? Let me see it.”
Thorin’s hold on the missive tightens, eyeing Gandalf with icy blues. “You know the ways of my people, you know I cannot -”
He first hears Bilbo Baggins before he lays eyes on him.
Another commotion comes from outside the room, making its way towards them from the front of the smial at breakneck speed, several voices shouting at and on top of each other, a pair he recognizes, the rest unfamiliar, one of the later in particular seemingly leading them all, stronger and clearer. Gandalf trips on his own words, something he cannot say he ever thought possible, but Thorin barely pays it any mind, standing up in preparation to this new hardship, tensing further when he notes the way most of the Tooks along with a few others grimace and attempt to discreetly move to the end of the room opposite to the door. The voice and loud footsteps get closer and closer, damnably so, and Thorin can feel the rush before a fight coursing through him, making his heart beat harshly, until…
The door opens with a quick, strong swing, almost hitting one of the hobbits standing near it if the lad’s reflexes were any slower, and yet the voice is faster: “Alright, I’m here. What on Eru’s name is the matter?”
Thorin supposes the voice would be even more pleasant without its current frantic, breathless quality, yet he is stunned silent regardless: standing at the door frame, leaning on it and on the jamb, breathing heavily and haphazardly dressed in whites, tans and maroons, hair a halo of wild dark golden curls, and eyes wide and surprisingly difficult to make out, other than of an imprecise light color, Bilbo Baggins looks nothing like what Thorin had envisioned in the time since he had received the gentle hobbit’s missive.
“Bilbo!” Gandalf shouts gravelly next to Thorin, from where he is still bending and crouching awkwardly, making half the room jump in near unison, Thorin and Bilbo included. “Come here, my boy, so we can sort this nonsense out.”
The halfling looks at Gandalf, at a loss and likely wondering what is the wizard even doing there to begin with, just as Thorin does, then the crystalline eyes slip off of their meddlesome mediator, landing unceremoniously on Thorin himself. It may just be the blow of the revelatory-like first encounter, but surely Bilbo should react more outwardly to their presence rather than a slight widening of somewhat surprised eyes - blue and gold and brown, he notes as the hobbit walks up to them and stops at arm’s length from the Prince, bejeweled orbs dancing and hopping between the faces of the outsiders.
“Falco said something about a declaration of war,” Master Baggins mentions, cautious, addressing Gandalf while trying to keep an eye on all of the dwarves at the same time. “But surely, that can’t be true?”
“Master Bilbo Baggins, is it?” Thorin interrupts not unkindly, suppressing a shiver when the precious stone eyes smoothly divert towards him, dedicating him their complete, unwavering attention.
“Who asks?” The hobbit’s voice takes a slightly rougher, more demanding tone, and yet the eyes remain mostly unchanged, clear and assessing.
Even if he were as anxious or afraid as some of his fellows, he probably considers himself more than secure enough in his land, surrounded by his people. Thorin can only aspire not to have to prove the gentle creature wrong.
“I am Prince Thorin of Erebor,” Master Baggins’ eyes let some more emotion show through at that, hints of surprise and, maybe, concern. “I have come to answer a declaration of war in your name, sent to me sometime in late Autumn or early Winter of last year in accordance with our calendar.” He procures the missive in question, offering it with his left hand only barely stretched out in the space between them and adds: “I now need you to confirm the authorship, contents and intentions of this missive before we can move forwards.”
Master Baggins looks at the missive, then at Thorin and back at the missive, his expression inscrutable save for a few lines and tensed muscles, the meaning of which he cannot decipher, he could only decipher with any semblance of certainty after half a lifetime spent studying the gently sun kissed face, perhaps.
“ Move forwards , to what?” The hobbit asks with a whisper even Thorin, immediately before him, has trouble discerning.
“Conversations, first and foremost, and hopefully last as well,” he chooses to reply with honesty.
Master Baggins accepts the letter with a slow, shaky hand, murmuring something under his breath that may or may not be a complaint about not understanding any one damned thing. He then takes a fortifying breath and unspools the item, starting to read it silently as Thorin gives him space and the gentle folks filling the room begin chattering among each other, the lull of their voices lowering and rising by turns like the tide.
Despite the general disorder starting to gain strength all around them, and Gandalf’s palpable impatience, Thorin’s full attention lingers persistently on the apparition in front of him, on the bright eyes skimming over the damning words. Within the recesses of his mind, he tries to pinpoint the bewitching composition of the brisk irises: perhaps that of a lapis lazuli with brown and gold veins, although the shades and values of the colors do not quite match. He is so fully engrossed in his study that he immediately notices the barest change of demeanor and disposition in that gaze, fixed as it is on the letter.
Master Baggins makes a small sound of confusion, a frown taking over the lines of his forehead and eyes, and he reads through the missive once, twice more.
“Well, what is it then, Bilbo?” Gandalf asks inattentively, trying to make himself comfortable in a chair that could not possibly offer him such luxuries.
Not that Thorin sees him at it, a most amusing sight for sure, more preoccupied with the hobbit at the moment. The hobbit, and the increasingly widening of his enchanting eyes, and the hint of pink blush painting his cheeks and the bridge of his nose, the tips of his elven-like ears, the very small and very concerning sound coming from deep within his throat and chest, which Thorin would wager on it escalating to a proper screech if Master Baggins were to let it out onto the world.
“Bilbo, dear, what is it?” Asks a hobbit lady hovering nearby, one who Thorin believes to be another of Master Gerontius’ daughters, and therefore one of Bilbo’s aunts.
The halfling in question does not answer right away, quickly diverting his eyes from the letter in his hands to shoot a glance that bodes nothing good his way instead. Thorin has the urge to demand something, anything from him, but his mouth refuses to cooperate as if spellbound. Master Baggins, ignorant of the turmoil within Thorin and of the effect of his iridescent eyes on the dwarf both, repeats the motion of turning his gaze from the missive to the Prince and back again a few more times, each iteration growing more agitated and, oddly enough, embarrassed, if the scarlet shade his countenance takes is any indication. Surely it looks nothing like anger.
“Well,” Master Baggins begins with a thin, wavering voice. “I can say that this is my name in the place of the emitter, and that this does appear to be my hair that’s been paired with the letter. However,” and his voice breaks with that single word, seemingly on the edge of hysterics. “While similar, this is not my handwriting, the ns and ts are lacking their tails, for instance, and the punctuation and accentuation is too uniform, mine is a lot less neat, if I do say so myself.”
Thorin frowns, taken aback at the enumeration of the differences and the seeming amount of possible variations in writing, considering he is used to the guided, dogmatic usage of runes, and the unnaturally uniform writing of elves. He supposes that at least in this case the hobbits are more alike men, Thorin’s mind reminiscing on the many dissimilarities that make Bard’s writing almost entirely unlike Lord Habard’s.
“Also, ah, Your Highness,” Master Baggins regains his attention disconcertingly easy, his expression twisted by a grimace denoting too many emotions for Thorin to properly peruse and catalog. “I am so terribly sorry for my bluntness, but there’s hardly any easier or less mortifying manner in which to say what I’m about to say: this is not a declaration of war, this is a courtship proposal .”
Thorin’s mind blanks so thoroughly he does not register the uproar that follows for several long minutes, all he can still process is the vision of the equally pained and defeated wince the gentle hobbit’s face morphs into as he seemingly tries to shrink himself into non-existence.
III
Bilbo feels like dying of shame.
He has never heard or read any stories of hobbits dying of mortification, which seems rather peculiar to him given the host of tales about them dropping like pet bunnies due to the most varied, unbelievable reasons, chief among them fright and heartbreak.
Well, the chances of a war that would most certainly end poorly for them - since these are no feral wolves or disorganized orcs - have thankfully plummeted, so there is no reason to be afraid, and Bilbo is not heartbroken, not at all, truly, it is just…
He just wishes the ground below him would open up like the maw of a massive, ancient beast and devour him whole, not a trace of him left. Yes, his dear mother would miss him, sure as the Sun rises from the East, but at least she would not be witnessing his younger cousins teasing him relentlessly, even crudely at times.
“Oh, don’t you worry about that, my boy. Your father and I had it far worse when he started courting me, maybe precisely because it was a proper, if a bit rocky, courtship, not, well, you know, no case in beating the pony while it’s down,” his mother tries to comfort him with a nice cup of chamomile and honey, but he knows that mischievous smile far too well for any of it to help settle his poor nerves and heart.
“I love you, mother, I truly do, but please ,” Bilbo does not whine, but only because he supposes he ought to hold on to the last shreds of his dignity in any way he can.
Belladonna Baggins, nee Took, simply snickers over the rim of her cup before taking a perfectly mannered sip from her own spiced tea. Bilbo is starting to believe perhaps something strong like that would better help him get back on his feet instead, but at least the situation is making her laugh, a sound he has been hearing less and less since his father’s passing. He takes a sip of his own drink and tries to comfort himself with the thought; there is hardly much more to take some of that from, he reckons.
For a good few minutes after unthinkingly stating what exactly the clear misunderstanding between them and the dwarves was where almost everybody on the Took side of his family could bear witness to it, and then tell the few relatives who had unfortunately missed the show, and anybody else willing to listen in Tuckborough and miles around, not to mention all the clan heads and Shirriffs that had also been present, and Master Brandybuck, and Master Burrows, and…
In fact, Bilbo was certain mortification was not the right word for the sentiment that had flooded through him then. It was not strong enough, not visceral enough. At that moment, with the cacophony of shouting, laughing and crying hobbits, as well as a pair of the dwarves demanding he further explained himself, the storm of noise and faces surrounding him, enveloping him, pushing against him like something straight out of his worst nightmares, he had wanted for it all to cease at once, please and thank you. However, in the light of the blank, pale as death face of Prince Thorin, who had come all the way from his faraway home in Erebor, had been two months at minimum on the road - and that only when there was a road -, likely believing that he was on his way to glorious, rewarding battle to be met with deception, disappointment and humiliation, Bilbo had, perhaps understandably so, shut down for a minute or two, or ten or twenty, willing himself to pop and become nothing but a flicker of dust, and drift away in the breeze, never to be perceived again.
Eventually, and with the sensible voices of his mother, his grandparents, and Gandalf, the relative sense of barely-but-not-quite-calm that was characteristic of large hobbit gatherings of all kinds could be restored, Bilbo calmed down and took a heavy seat on one of the nicer armchairs in the room, and the Prince regained some color, stopped looking like he was going to drop dead any second, and also sat, a little worse for wear and appearing as if he was coming out of a daze. Bilbo could relate to that, but even if he could find the energy and gumption to say as much to the dwarf, he doubted he would be well received or reciprocated, so he had kept his mouth shut about it.
“Very well,” spoke the white-haired dwarf that Bilbo recognized from the Prince’s prior visit, the one his grandmother had called Master Balin.
And how had he not realized that it was Prince Thorin standing before him earlier, he could only rationalize was due to his frantic, tired mind not been all there after being harshly woken up in the middle of the night and perilously riding a pony in the confusing dark to reach Tuckborough as quickly as possible.
“Now that we’ve all calmed down, could someone, please, explain to me, to us , what does any of this mean?” Master Balin had emphasized by pulling Bilbo’s hand up, the one still gripping the letter, and giving it a good shake to make his point even clearer.
Bilbo had winced, but otherwise done nothing to stop the dwarf, simply kept quiet, hoping someone else would step up for it, then sighed heavily and attempted to take his own out of the fire when it became obvious nobody was going to do so for him, not even his relatives, not even for a war. So, he steeled himself and did his best to ignore the Prince’s persistent, intense stare, boring holes into him.
Well, at least the dwarf had not shouted at him or attempted to murder him, small blessings*.
“I cannot make out what exactly in this letter made you or any of your people see it as a declaration of war, and I would like an explanation for that myself, but for us hobbits, this is very much a written courting proposal,” he had tried his best to remain cool-headed and matter of fact about the whole affair, but dear Eru, had it been difficult, especially at the very beginning. “You see, we have a few traditions when it comes to those matters, none of them are very strict or dogmatic, but it usually involves a gift from the proponent to their intended: flowers, more often than not, although a lock of hair tied with a silk ribbon is a close second favorite, I suppose. They are meant to be given in person, but if the intended lives a bit farther away - say, they live in Buckland while the proponent lives here or further West than here -, it can be sent through a courier or a messenger pigeon. The writing is fairly ambiguous, but still well within norm as far as I know.”
In all honesty, it is not as if he has ever proposed a courtship, and he very quickly, very awkwardly rejected the only one he has ever been in the receiving end of, he did not even touch that poor lass’ gift, at that.
Master Balin had looked at him keenly then, as if he had been trying to catch him in a lie, perhaps to spare them from a conflict, which, fine, that may seem like too much for him, but surely that was only because he had grown up surrounded by traditions like this, had known about this particular custom since he was a wee lad because it was a story his father had loved to tell him, thought it was funny even when Bilbo himself thought his mother’s original rejection had made Bungo look a tad pathetic, not that he ever said as much, that was a thought he was planning to take to his grave, thank you very much.
After seemingly being appeased by Bilbo’s nervous steadiness, Master Balin had shot a look at Gandalf, which Bilbo had not being able to catch, staring at the back of the dwarf’s head instead, but he had seen the nod his mother’s friend had replied with, easing the tension within him. He may have made himself - and whoever sent the letter - look absolutely ridiculous in the eyes of the dwarves, and the butt of the joke to everyone else, but at least the dwarves could see the true meaning behind the letter now, and they had Gandalf there to confirm it to them.
Master Balin turned back towards him, looking calmer even if he had still been frowning. “And you say you didn’t even write it?”
Bilbo nodded furiously at that. “Like I said, the handwriting is very similar, a very good imitation, but some of my letters have a short tail at the end and my symbols are not this neat, not yet at least. And I could hardly say that getting a lock of my hair without my knowing is an impossible task, or even all that difficult: quite a few different people have cut it for me, and a lot of people could have gotten a lock while I was sleeping, for instance.” He grimaces once more when a new thought occurs to him, one he doubts the dwarves will care much for: “And I can see how one of us may find this to be nothing but a funny, harmless prank, even if one that would require more time and effort than most. We do not have royalty or anything comparable to that, we are all at more or less the same level here, and even those that are held at a higher regard, like my grandfather, participate willingly, if not eagerly, in things like pranks and games all the time.” Not to mention Bilbo’s persistent singleness and general uninterest was something a lot of people were aware of and teased him for, not that the dwarves needed to know that.
Master Balin had still looked troubled, and the armored warriors had murderous intent clearly written across their faces, but at least Prince Thorin had seemed more at ease, relieved even, albeit exhausted, and, just as importantly, had stopped staring at Bilbo with his piercing blue eyes by then.
Bilbo had asked Master Balin then: “Whatever made you think this was a war declaration ?”
And he had listened - with a mounting horror that had certainly been felt across the room - as the Master Dwarf had explained how hair was held in very high regard in their culture, and that sending a lock of it to someone of the royal family or else the court was a symbol of opposition and conflict. Bilbo had wanted to find the joker then and shake them, scream at them even.
“But it is quite interesting, is it not? Maybe even funny, in retrospect,” Gandalf comments from his mother’s other side, where he is folded onto a too small chair and enveloped by a thick cloud of tobacco smoke. “Such similar traditions in both cultures, and they mean entirely opposite matters for each.”
Bilbo shoots him a quick, secretive glare but remains quiet, holds his tongue back out of respect to the wizard - and fear, respect and fear, he has no compunction admitting as much. Gandalf has a reputation for being quite intimidating when angered or offended.
“I can understand the scholarly interest, but I fail to see the cause for amusement in the situation,” Prince Thorin, who had followed them to the drawing room while the debacle continued elsewhere, did not share the same scruples and anxieties, it seemed.
Gandalf snorts, both derisive and entertained. “You would. You are too serious, and embarrassed, not that it is your fault, of course, O Crown Prince Under The Mountain, but I am confident Frerin and Bard would see it too.” The Prince - and oh dear Eru, Bilbo cannot stop thinking about that, what a mess - stops the writing of his letter to grimace, with his full body, like a shudder, and Gandalf outright laughs this time. “Oh yes, as much as I doubt that you could, don’t even try to hide it from them, because surely Balin will be intervening then, and that’s not something you’d like, now would you?”
Prince Thorin shoots daggers at the wizard with a glare that would have most hobbits petrified. It certainly roots Bilbo to his spot, never mind how it is not aimed at him.
“What are you even doing here, Mithrandir? Even if either Frerin or Bard had decided to intervene through you, I doubt they could get a hold of you in time.”
Bilbo takes note of that, having been wondering the same since he first stepped into his grandparents’ reading room and found the wizard in there amongst all the littler people, sticking out like a fox in the henhouse.
“I have my ways, Thorin Oakenshield, and you need not know them,” Gandalf drawls with a mysterious air about him.
The Prince scowls and grunts at him before returning to his letter, only adding a clipped: “Bloody elves, cannot keep their noses out of other people’s business.”
Prince Thorin remains mostly quiet after that brief exchange, much like he had done earlier, in the reading room. So far, he has only spoken to Bilbo directly when introducing himself and guiding him through the matter of the letter. And Bilbo is fine with that, more than, even, he believes he could live the rest of his life without hearing another word from the dwarven royal, or, likewise, without himself saying another word to the Prince; he may not live this down with his fellow hobbits, but surely he could grow used to that, in time, while he could not say the same if it came to facing the other half involved in this disaster, not even once again, no even sixty years from now.
And yet, he must, at least once more, one final word before they part ways again, likely never to meet again…
It is agreed by his grandfather and all the other important folks present at the Great Smials that day that the dwarves - all of them - will be hosted by the families of the West Farthing, as well as the South and North if necessary, during the following couple of days. Apparently, Prince Thorin and Master Balin make a valiant attempt to decline the offer and go back to Erebor immediately, not that he blames them any, but Bilbo knows just how stubborn his grandparents, and a few of the other family heads there with them, are, so truly, it was a lost battle from the very moment they decided to fight it.
Allegedly, of course, since Bilbo has no clue as to what transpires behind closed doors when his companions are called in and he is sequestered by a Shirriff, a Master Underhill tasked with figuring just exactly what happened. The very first thing he asks is for Bilbo to write something, anything, on a piece of paper, to compare the handwriting. Clever, Bilbo supposes, although then again, he is not a Shirriff, so who knows.
“They look remarkably similar, I must admit,” Master Underhill says when he gets to examine the writings and for a brief moment Bilbo feels faint, the mortification returning strong and this time paired up with dread at the thought of not being believed. Except the Shirriff then adds: “But I can also see what you meant about the little differences. I could see a smitten lad trying their best to remedy your issue with the punctuation symbols for this kind of letter, Eru knows I did, but then again it wouldn’t make any sense to forgo the little tails too, not when they add some charm to the whole thing.”
Bilbo exhales, long and loud, with relief and Master Underhill gives him a sympathetic smile.
“Not to mention, I asked a couple of your relatives, just so I could have something more to compare, for thoroughness’ sake, and they mentioned that not only did you never speak of him in the last year, but they were certain you never even met the Prince fellow, and that you’re quite the wordy fellow in your letters, and I don’t suppose you would be very happy with sending this note to the object of your affections if that’s the case, yes?”
“I rather think so, yes,” Bilbo replies with a grimace, forgoing to add only if I were rendered utterly speechless by them , surely that would not help his case.
“Very well, then,” the Shirriff continues, carefully folding both pieces of paper and tucking them into a pocket for safekeeping. “I genuinely don’t believe you had anything to do with this, so don’t you worry about it, but I do need to ask you a few questions.”
I do, and will, worry about it , Bilbo thinks, for as long as his family decides to hang it over his head, at least, likely for the rest of his life, but otherwise he gestures for the older hobbit to carry on. Mostly it is confirmation of what he had said earlier in the reading room and furthermore tangential information. Master Underhill leaves him soon enough.
Bilbo almost wishes the Shirriff would come back, if only so he would not be left alone with nothing but his thoughts.
At the very least, he is much calmer now that it seems very unlikely any of this will turn back around against him - in any other way but mockery - and that he has gone through everything a second, had the opportunity to rationalize through it and let it out mostly on his own terms. Mind you, he still felt deeply embarrassed and like he would rather have the chance to shake and shout at whoever had been behind this. Oh Eru, what a mess .
And what were they even thinking? Of course, he had told the dwarves that whoever had done this had likely only thought of it as a harmless prank, and that still stood, especially given how some of his closer relatives were already starting to tease him about his honest lack of interest in things such as marriage, all very sweet and friendly, truly. But he could not find it in himself to believe any of them would be the culprit, precisely because of how, say, kind they were about it: they have all seemed very accepting, if not outright uninterested, never even a peep about him changing his mind when he met the right lass or got older and decided to have children And it could not have possibly been any of his Baggins relatives, most of them would first faint at the impropriety of it all.
He supposes it does not matter, or rather, it did not matter to whoever did it, so long as the prank was made, and Bilbo was simply dragged into it because he was unmarried and had no prospects, and nothing more.
The rest of the day passes by in the blink of an eye, likely because he is tired from having his sleep cut off and everything that came after that. As sunset comes and goes, and after helping settle the dwarves just so he has something productive to do, his limbs start feeling heavier and heavier, and his mind slower and slower; by the time supper rolls around, he is falling asleep more than he is eating, even through the ruckus of a large hobbit meal, several generations and a handful of dwarves prodigiously crammed into a single dinning room, manageable only thanks to the very nature of his grandfather’s Great Smials.
In a brief moment of wakefulness, Bilbo finds that while Prince Thorin and Master Balin seem more or less unfazed by the mayhem, most of the others of their group watch on with something not unlike fascination, with the occasional hint of trepidation, none of it unwarranted in his humble opinion, and holding onto the slightly revitalizing amusement is all he can do to quickly get through his food before taking his leave in favor of the room he is to share with one of his cousins for the night.
The fact that he does as much just as Prince Thorin chooses to retire as well is purely coincidental, truly, he does not even notice the dwarf, imposing and impressive as he is, standing up or announcing his intention or any such, busy as he is trying to take his plates and cutlery to the kitchens without falling face first while at it. Despite the odds stacked against him, Bilbo manages, only for then to nearly trip on his own two hairy feet when he turns around and finds himself face to face with the one and only Crown Prince of Erebor.
Prince Thorin extends his free hand towards Bilbo with the clear intention to help him or at least stop him from genuinely falling, but when the hobbit regains his footing quickly, the appendage simply hangs there between them, oddly dejected.
“ I’m sorry ,” the two of them say in unison, the Prince somewhat crestfallen, Bilbo red-faced.
An awkward silence envelops them like an itchy cocoon then, neither of them entirely sure what to say, or even if they should speak at all. Bilbo watches, equally fascinated and amused, as the Prince gathers himself, straightens up before taking the lead.
“I apologize, I did not mean to startle you with my presence.”
Bilbo wants to grin at this majestic Crown Prince of a grand dwarven kingdom, with his adorned and formal vestments he is yet to change out of, only his crown missing, even if it is only missing from his head, Bilbo notes, the intricately worked metal hanging off a hook on his belt, a picture of old, proud royalty, except for how he has been reduced to such a cautious creature, here in his grandparents’ kitchens. His eyes are very much blue, Bilbo thinks, and chooses to spare them both with a sympathetic smile.
“There’s nothing for you to apologize about, truly, I’m simply feather-brained, that’s all,” Bilbo thinks to reply before the silence stretches for too long once more. “It sure has been a day.”
Prince Thorin eyes consideringly. “ Feather-brained ?”
“Oh! You don’t have that expression?” The Prince shakes his head, his clear eyes remaining on Bilbo, insistent. He is still carrying his plates in one hand and the gentle hobbit starts feeling warm under the collar with self-consciousness. “It means to be absent-minded, careless, uh, distracted, the likes.”
“Oh, scatter-brained,” Prince Thorin’s expression morphs into a light frown, and he finally moves to deposit his items on the counter behind Bilbo, making quick work of stacking their plates together. “I’d never heard it said like that.”
“Well, I suppose it goes to further show the little differences between our cultures, yes?” Bilbo offers lightly, for all that he wants nothing more than to bolt, and leave the kitchens - and the Prince - behind in favor of his cousin’s room, where he can keep apart from the dwarf if only thanks to a wooden door, albeit a sturdy wooden door with a lock.
“I do suppose you are correct,” Prince Thorin turns to eye him furthermore, considering. “It’s a very whimsical expression, it seems to me.”
Bilbo is left stumped and speechless. Is the dwarf mocking him? Somehow he doubts that is the case, but he is starting to find it difficult to read the Prince whenever he is not candid, intentionally or not.
“Thank you,” Bilbo accomplishes not to make it sound like a question, only the barest hint of uncertainty showing through, and he does not believe his conversational partner will catch onto it. At least he hopes as much.
Prince Thorin nods placidly at him, which he guesses is as good a sign as any, and turns around to leave the room. Bilbo, understandably so, panics, just a little.
“Wait!” It comes out louder and far more commanding than Bilbo intends, and when the Prince turns back around towards him he does so with a somewhat sardonic raise of an eyebrow that seems to question him just who does he think he is, speaking to royalty like that. Again, dying of mortification is probably not entirely out of the question.
If a Prince can be meek, then Bilbo may as well try his hand at a measure of fortitude.
“I ought to apologize as well.”
Prince Thorin frowns and questions: “For what?”
Bilbo wants to ask him if perhaps he is the one who has been feather-brained all day long, vexed at this dwarf’s cluelessness making things more difficult and excruciating for him.
“Everything, give or take. You were probably hoping for some grand battle and an honorable conquest, and it all turned out to be a misunderstanding and a joke, at our expense, too. It’s just so much wasted time, and resources, and energy, and it was all for nothing.” Bilbo inhales deeply, meets Prince Thorin head on, and reiterates: “I’m sorry, Your Highness.”
The dwarf watches him with keen blue eyes, his face a blank, unknowable book cover, but this time Bilbo stands his ground. Curse his Tookish candidness, perhaps, he still believes this is the least Prince Thorin deserves.
“Well, you said so yourself: we’re both laughingstock here, there’s nothing for you to apologize over.”
He then walks out in a flutter of lush black hair and gold stitched black fabrics, the thump of his crown against his hip and thigh branding itself in Bilbo’s mind, and the hobbit can breathe easily once more. Never mind how it does not truly feel like all has ended well, only that he has apologized for the wrong slight.
Despite all signs and odds betting on the contrary after his conversation - if it could truly be called as much -, Bilbo sleeps like a babe, like the dead even, that night, everything catching up to him in one devastating blow as soon as he is lying horizontally on the bed, soft like clouds ought to be. When he is woken up by his cousin the following morning, Bilbo does not even want to leave the bed, much less the room. For what? To walk into Prince Thorin as he turns any one of the multitude of corners and doorways? No, thank you.
Although…
The following morning is much like any other morning at his grandparents’, other than his cousin - a very no-nonsense fellow, especially for a younger Took - more or less tossing him out of bed when he starts getting too stubborn about getting up. There are the familiar, comfortable sensations, the scents of warm breakfast and freshly cut flowers, the brightly sunlit front rooms and hallways.Three of his relatives are busy in the kitchens when he pops in, his Uncle Isengrim in the lead, which is just as well because it most certainly means lavender shortbread biscuits are in order, doubly so with their visitors.
That is about the time he remembers just who those visitors are, but truly, there is hardly anything to do about that, and the day has already started so nicely, it would be a right shame if he let it ruin his mood. So, he braces himself for it and takes it head on, helping his Aunt Mirabella carry food and kettles to the dining room, where a lively group is already seated down, eating and conversing amongst each other, a few of the dwarves staying with them included. Bilbo does not see Prince Thorin at first glance, and after a while he gathers that the royal had already eaten and briefly taken off with Master Bryce to meet with a few of his fellows waiting in Frogmorton.
And that is a good thing too, for Bilbo was about going mad with the thought of coming face to face with the Crown Prince again before leaving on his way back home with his mother closer to noon, the shame still very much present as he knows it will be for a long time coming.
“But are you sure you want to?” His mother asks him shortly after a very concurred second breakfast, their meal schedule the one thing any of the dwarves they have met so far seems genuinely keen on.
Bilbo blinks owlishly at his mother, leaving his pen on its holder for the time being. “What do you mean?”
Belladonna Baggins stares at him through a faint curtain of smoke. He does not know where she got the tobacco and pipe from, since hers were left behind in Bag End, but he is willing to bet on Gandalf or his grandfather. Now it is only a matter of time before she starts having coughing fits, wonderful.
“I mean, are you sure you want to go back home?” Bilbo keeps looking at her, utterly confused, until she adds with a sigh: “Do you want to return back home, or do you want to go?
Bilbo frowns. “Go where ?”
His mother sighs heavier, louder. “To Erebor , boy, where on Arda else?”
For a brief moment, Bilbo remains oblivious, his mind unable to capture and process what his mother has just said. Then his eyes widen as understanding dawns on him.
“Whatever made you think I would want to go to Erebor, mother? Don’t you believe me when I say I had nothing to do with any of this?”
“Don’t be dramatic, of course I believe you,” his mother rolls her eyes at him, as if he did not get his dramatic streak from her. “You would never do something like this, not ever for a princeling, not even for this princeling.”
“Please, don’t insult a royal who’s staying under the very same roof as us,” he despairs.
“He went out to Frogmorton earlier, didn’t he?”
“You know what I mean.”
“And you know what I mean,” Belladonna retorts immediately. “Of course, you had nothing to do with this situation, didn’t even touch that letter, much less write it, and you probably haven’t even thought about His Royal Highness since we were all under this very same roof the year prior, but that doesn’t mean you haven’t thought about Erebor, and everything that lays between here and there, now, have you?”
Bilbo blushes.
“Whatever it is that you’re thinking, or believing…”
“I think that you’ve spent a lot of time sighing and longing and frowning this past year, looking eastward, and I believe that it’s not over any Frogmorton or Buckland lass, nor over any dwarf princes. I think that you’ve been doing much of what I sometimes do before I cave in and go for a little walk.”
His mouth dries suddenly. “Mother, I can’t .”
The older hobbit looks at him with a confident smile and asks: “Why is that?”
And is not that the crux of the matter?
*
His first instinct is to say no, to send the hobbit back home and to his mother, derisively too if that is what it takes. Truthfully, what do they have to gain from Master Baggins joining them on their journey back to Erebor? Conversely, what would Master Baggins gain from it? Yes, they have the numbers to fend off any threat short of a full-fledged, well-organized army of elves or men, which they do not expect to come across, and the hobbits of The Shire have provided them with all the supplies they could possibly need in their travels, and then some, so it is hardly skin off their backs if someone wishes to join them, after all, they have already agreed that Gandalf would accompany them all the way to Erebor to help them untangle this mess, and in theory - Thorin can admit this much -, having an actual hobbit there to explain matters could be of help.
Thorin simply has a moment of panic when he immediately realizes having Master Baggins return with them, as a guest of honor, would only make things worse for him, where Bard, Frerin and Dís are concerned. Even Dwalin may be a hassle, if he takes to mocking rather than derisive indifference.
Balin sends him a true and tired look, the closest thing to a glare the older dwarf has ever given to anybody other than an orc or a goblin, and Gandalf calls him an insensate under his breath. Thorin caves, because he is not beyond reason, or at least tries not to be, and he will hardly stave off the mockery from his friends and family simply by not bringing the hobbit along…
And because maybe, just maybe, those gemstone eyes will haunt him regardless.
