Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2023-07-06
Words:
2,451
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
95
Hits:
0

Re-Re-Re-Re-Rejection

Summary:

King Thorin keeps getting killed, though by the grace of Mahal, he keeps being sent back to the mountain. After the fourth time this happens, his husband, Bilbo, starts getting suspicious.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

It is a well-known fact throughout Arda that some of the Valar’s children receive the gift of longer lifespans. Men lived an average of 163 years, dwarves 202 years, and hobbits 97 years.* Elves, were not considered part of that tally. They were magical creatures, like Ents and Wizards who experienced extremely prolonged existences.

There were exceptions in this study. In particular, one dwarf by the name of Thorin Oakenshield, Son of Thror, Son of Thrain, King Under the Mountain. He had already lived nearly 300 years when he met and married Bilbo Baggins, a Hobbit of the Shire. But after 30 years of blissful companionship, the Hobbit began asking questions.

Gandalf the Grey, Bilbo's friend and wizard had no answers. Each time Thorin Oakenshield died, the dwarf would reappear in Erebor in perfect health. The first time, he appeared after four days. The second, third, and fourth times he died, he returned in less than 24 hours.

Bilbo didn’t wish to be mistaken about his curiosity. He was happy Thorin returned to him time and again. He loved him more than anything. Only, he began to wonder if there were perhaps problems within the Hallways of Mandos, in the out-of-reach places where the dwarves met their maker and were reunited with their forefathers.

Even Thorin himself did not understand. He recalled having died, but he could never remember anything after that.

Each time that he did die, Erebor’s occupants would participate in a cycle of mourning that generally lasted four weeks. Everybody wore black and an elaborate burial ritual was performed. Admittedly, the second and third occasions were far less formal and by the fourth, no one even bothered to come. There were few tears by the fourth event, and no one changed their clothes to frocks of black that represented their mourning state.

That bothered Bilbo at first, but he couldn’t blame anyone for their lack of concern after Thorin had come back so many times. What continued to bother Bilbo was that Thorin was reckless. He disregarded his own safety and continued to risk his life.

Thorin had the tendency to run headfirst into danger without considering the risks. He’d done so since Bilbo had first known him. In the beginning, the hobbit thought he was incredibly brave. Later? He was beginning to think it wasn't bravery as much as a willful stubbornness and belief that nothing bad could possibly happen to him. Thorin apparently believed his bones were made of mithril, and even after four tragic events, he wasn’t learning his lesson.

Bilbo was longsuffering. It was a gift from the creator Yavanna, herself. She was the one who made him this way, and most likely for the sole purpose of putting up with such a reckless, audacious dwarf. There had been a reason Thorin had still been single at the ripe old age of 300, and there were many times the other dwarves had teased Bilbo that only a hobbit had the patience required to put up with him.

Thorin’s sister, Dis, agreed. She’d had her fill of her brother by that time and was proud when Bilbo had taken him off her hands. Or so she’d loudly announced on their wedding day.

Still, Bilbo was curious about the repetitive miraculous occurrences, and one day, he journeyed to Rivendell to meet with Lord Elrond to ask for his advice.

At first, the Elf seemed hesitant, stating that whatever decisions the Valar made should not be interfered with or questioned. Bilbo had one thing to say to that.

“So, every time Thorin dies, he’s going to return to rule the mountain? Will there never be another King? Will Thranduil never have an ally who he can actually get along with? What about Fili? Or Fili’s future offspring? What about me? After I die, is Thorin going to keep on living? How fair is that? Lord Elrond,” the hobbit said with a sigh. “I just want to know. I want to know the reason, and if there is one, how can I fix that? It’s not natural and in the long run, won’t amount to any good. Surely, you can see that.”

The Elf pondered for a moment and then placed a comforting hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.

“My friend, I see your point and I will grant the Dȏlen Cuĭn, the Secret Passage of the Living. You may visit Valinor for a moment, but not interact. You will not be seen, only see. Do you understand?”

“Yes!” Bilbo replied enthusiastically as he was given a vial filled with a bright green liquid.

“The next time Thorin Oakenshield loses his life," the elven lord explained, "drink this potion. It will last for one hour and then you will return to Erebor.”

“One hour,” Bilbo repeated. “Got it. Anything else I should be aware of?”

Elrond nodded and stared at the Hobbit seriously. “While you’re there, stay out of the way and you’ll be fine.”

“Stay…wait,” Bilbo replied, becoming confused. “I thought you said I’d be invisible?”

“Yes.”

“But then…”

“You have what you came for, Bilbo Baggins, have you not?”

Of course. How rude of him. He was taking up this important Elf’s time – even though he’d already been alive for thousands of years. Didn’t he have all the time in the world?

Instead of rolling his eyes like he wished to do, Bilbo smiled and left Rivendell in the royal carriage his husband had provided for him.

The next time Thorin was killed by a pack of orcs who ambushed him during a trip to the Iron Hills, (despite Bilbo insisting that he at least take a small army to accompany him), Bilbo was ready. He once again said goodbye to his husband, told him he loved him deeply, waited until Oin had announced his passing, and then slipped away to drink the potion.

He felt lightheaded at first, a little bit nauseous, and then very similar to how he felt whenever he put on his golden ring (minus the evil chatter in his head telling him to kill everyone he saw including himself). When he opened his eyes, instead of the swirling shadows of gray the ring kept everything shrouded in, Bilbo saw beautiful colors, majestic mountains, rolling green hills, and bountiful pastures. There were ivory castles atop cliffs, waterfalls with iridescent rainbows arcing out from them, and the most lovely and fragrant trees he had ever seen.

And the flowers! Bilbo had never seen such magnificent blooms in such bright colors in his life!

This must be Yavanna’s Garden, he thought to himself, and would gladly stay here for hours were it not for the shrieking and booming voices he heard coming from a crystal gazebo not very far from where he stood.

Bilbo snuck toward it, even though he was invisible. He recalled Lord Elrond’s words to stay clear of the Valar, for indeed that was whose voices he was hearing. It just so happened that the being they were arguing about was none other than his husband, Thorin Oakenshield.

“What is wrong with this dwarf of yours? Why does he continually put his life at risk? Is he honestly that stupid or just the biggest klutz to live inside the Lonely Mountain?”

“My dear,” the deep voice of Mahal replied. “I designed my children from stone. They are tough and as longlasting as granite. They create marvelous things with their hands, beautiful, magnificent items that…”

“Well, this one’s head is full of rocks!” the female, whom Bilbo assumed was Yavanna, replied with growing aggravation. “He just died not a passing ago and look! Here he comes again!”

Indeed, as Bilbo watched, he saw Thorin strutting toward the roofed platform, a thunderous frown on his face and his hands outstretched in a greeting of frustration.

“I would’ve thought the malevolence in Arda would’ve been eliminated by now,” the dwarf was saying. “What good is a God or Goddess who cannot disperse the evil that thrives in Middle Earth? Do you even know the whereabouts of the one you call Mairon? The one who will bring destruction to both men and dwarves alike? The one who will drive out the Elves from Middle Earth and leave everyone to their own devices? Just how long will you allow this Evil One of the Maiȃ to threaten your creations? Can you not do something to stop him? I have encountered every known type of monster of his imaginings during my lifetime and have slayed them all. True, I paid for such a service with my life – many times, but surely, the two of you can figure out some way to protect my people!”

Things were starting to become quite clear to Bilbo.

The Green Lady bent over at her waist to lean down very close to the much smaller dwarf, her eyes narrowing with frustration.

“Just as last time, I will ask you, Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, what would you have us do?”

Bilbo recognized his expression. Thorin wasn’t happy. In fact, he was getting very close to losing his temper. If Bilbo could, he would step up and calm him down the way he always did, with gentle, softly spoken words, a soothing touch, and a smile. Any of those things always did the dwarf wonders. Bilbo didn’t think he was going to receive any such kindness here.

“And just like last time,” Thorin said through a tight jaw and gritted teeth, “I will tell you that it is not my place to tell a God or Goddess what they should do! You should be able to figure that out for yourselves!”

“Oh, of course not!” Yavanna screeched, standing upright again, her arms flinging out in exasperation. “You won’t give us any ideas, but you don’t have a problem standing here accusing us of doing nothing! Just who do you think you are anyway?”

“My dear,” Mahal finally spoke up. “He is Arisiualkhudid-azân.”

Yavanna’s green eyes rolled skyward. “Don’t give me that rubbish. Spark of light indeed. He’s a spark all right, but a dim one! In fact, I’ve never seen a light so dim in my entire existence! I’m amazed the dwarves have lasted as long as they have with the likes of him ruling over them!”

Bilbo didn’t appreciate Yavanna’s words or her tone and despite Lord Elrond’s instructions, he stepped out to shout at her.

“I beg your pardon! That’s my husband you’re talking about! How dare you speak of him in such a way! He gave his life to recover his homeland! He faced and survived many dangers no thanks to either of you! He fought hard and lost his life to return to the dwarves what rightfully belonged to them!”

Yavanna slowly turned her head in his direction and Bilbo immediately shut up.

“Oh crap,” he said under his breath.

With a subtle flick of her hand, a green wave of light swept over him, and then three sets of eyes were glaring at him. Apparently, he wasn’t invisible anymore.

“Bilbo? What are you doing here? Did you die? How did you die? Why are you here?”

Thorin frantically ran over to him and started checking his husband for injuries, which was ridiculous, of course, because everyone knew after death you received a new and perfect body. In fact, Thorin hadn’t looked so magnificent in ages.

“Darling, it’s all right,” Bilbo told him, suddenly overcome with admiration. “I’m just visiting, thanks to Lord Elrond, because I wanted to see what the problem is – why you keep getting sent back to Erebor. And now I do!”

He boldly glared at the two Valar still staring at them. “You have no right to say such things about my beloved!” he scolded them sharply. “Take them back!” he demanded with a stomp of his large hobbit foot. “Take those words back right now! And apologize at once! Bad form and bad manners!” He added a wagging finger for good measure. “A Goddess should know better! You are speaking to a King!”

Bilbo nervously closed his mouth. He’d said too much, as he often did whenever he was taking up for Thorin.

Surely, he was about to be cast out of Valinor, but Yavanna looked so shocked at his outburst, that she stuttered a little bit.

“I’m…You…My apologies, Master Baggins. Indeed, I didn’t mean to offend you. Either of you. Allow me to personally return you both where you belong – with my blessings.”

Bilbo jutted out his chin confidently while Thorin grabbed his arm and stepped behind him. For his own safety? Bilbo wasn’t sure. “Yes, well,” he replied with as strong a voice as he could muster. “That would be fine. Thank you.”

And with a snap of her fingers, the two visitors were gone.

The Goddess of Nature turned to her husband, the shock on her face melting away to stupefied annoyance. “Did I seriously just apologize to one of my own creations? What evil has come to Valinor? What power do these two have over us that they think they can come and go as they please?”

“I have nothing to do with Hobbits, dear,” Mahal informed his wife. “They were all your doing.”

“No kidding,” she answered sarcastically. “Have you ever seen or heard the like of those two? And Lord Elrond is involved now as well? What are we to do about that? Does he truly believe it’s acceptable to use the sacred Dȏlen Cuĭn to send a living soul to Valinor? It has never been done!”

Mahal gazed at his normally loving wife and smiled.

“What? Why are you smiling like that? This is a serious matter! We must do something about it at once! Thorin Oakenshield was bad enough to have in Valinor and I couldn’t help but send him back. Let his own kind suffer with his arrogance and critical nature instead of us! But now his husband is going to come here and defend him? And he’s even worse than the dwarf!”

“Then perhaps we should teach Lord Elrond a lesson,” Mahal purred to his wife before drawing her into his arms.

“You have foreseen what I have then,” Yavanna relaxed into the embrace. “That at the end of the Age, Elrond will sail into The Undying Lands.”

“Yes,” Mahal agreed with his wife, placing a tender kiss on her temple. “And we will make sure that a certain dwarf and his hobbit partner are on board that ship.”

Yavanna laughed and caressed her husband’s beard. “For someone who created a race whose heads are full of rocks, you, my dear, are a genius.”

 

__~*~__

 

*"Middle-Earth in Numbers - LotrProject" (Standard deviation)

Notes:

This one-shot was the result of a Bagginshield Book Club Discord discussion two nights ago that got a little silly and carried away. All for fun!