Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2023-06-22
Words:
1,970
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
249
Hits:
0

Remembrance

Summary:

Bilbo visits Erebor after 30 long years. While there, he visits Thorin's tomb and speaks to his grave.

Based on a stunning piece of art by the wonderful Mr. Kida.

Notes:

This is very sad. It's a story of grief, loss, and morning.

Please check out Mr. Kida, whose art is featured in this fic. You can find them
Here

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

It was his right as a member of the company to be here for this day. This was the thirtieth anniversary of the Battle of the Five Armies. Marking it a day of observance was Dain’s first official act as king. He remembered standing before the throne as Dain thanked him for his service all those years ago. He could hardly remember the words Dain used now. It had been so soon after the battle that he hadn't even been able to rid his clothes of Thorin’s blood. The world was a wash of color, and the waking world had been reduced to resembling that of the one inside his ring. Bilbo hadn't been back to the Lonely Mountain since his grand adventure. He had visited the elves in Rivendell many times and even camped on the edge of the old forest, but he had not passed over the Misty’s in thirty long years. That was until very recently. 

A raven perched itself on his garden gate and told him he would have visitors on the morrow. This did not phase him. He was used to visitors that announced themselves with talking ravens. It was a small contributing factor to his new regard in Hobbiton as Mad Bilbo Baggins. Tomorrow came and brought with it Ori, Gloin, and Bofur. The visitors were no surprise to him, as the raven had not been. He had decided in the previous year's winter that it was time to see the Lonely Mountain again. When he wrote to his friends about his plans, they refused to let him travel alone, and he was glad about that.

So now he stood in front of the gates he had last seen ruined. They were a ruin no longer. The mastery of the dwarves could be seen in every detail. A familiar face greeted him at the gate. 

“It’s good to have you here again, laddie. I hope the trip was swift and had fewer trials than last time.” Balin gave him a big hug and a proper dwarven head knock, although not so proper that it split his skull. 

“The trip was as fair as it could be on old bones. You still look as I remember you, although you’ve grown your beard near to your knees!” 

“Aye, keen eyes as always. Though you flatter me with talk of age when you certainly don’t look yours. How long was it that Hobbits lived?” Balin asked in jest but not rhetorically. 

“Short enough that I am considered an old man but long enough to have some years left in me. Though the cold and wind is doing little for my bones,” Bilbo replied. Balin hastened them inside. It was not the first step inside that was the hardest. It was every step after it. Dain had done a good job as king. Erebor was beautiful and prosperous. Once again, the bastion of hope for a people long void of an ancestral home. Do you see all of this, Thorin? Your kin are thriving because of you. You would be so proud.       

He met the rest of the company, and they greeted him with enthusiasm and love. He had missed them dearly. They picked up right where they left off, and soon Bilbo was inundated with stories of his friends' lives that did not belong in a letter. These stories could only be best told by the warmth of a fire and in the company of others. Eventually, the evening turned to night, and the company parted with talk of meeting the following afternoon or sooner. Bilbo had one place he wanted to visit before the night ended. He made his way to the gate again and climbed the ramparts to look out across the land. The desolation was gone, and the Green Lady had touched this land again. He stood in the same spot he had as a younger man and closed his eyes. He opened them only when he heard footsteps.

“Master Burglar-” 

“It’s been thirty years, Dwalin. Just call me Bilbo.” He opened his eyes to see the old warrior standing atop the staircase. Dwalin chuckled, but it was half-hearted. “You didn’t change it. I thought you would have. I saw you build this in a day, after all.” 

“No. It had too much attached to it, good and bad. Does it not frighten you to be up here after what happened?” Dwalin asked.

“No. Not after so long. It’s the curse of the survivors to look back upon painful memories. I will not cherry-pick how I remember him; I only wish that I had more of him to remember."

“I never got to say I was sorry to you after the battle.” Dwalin’s voice sounded cracked. “I have replayed the battle on Raven Hill so many times. If I had been there in time, I might have-.” Bilbo stopped him.

 “And if I had not been hit by a rock and knocked out, then I might be able to wake up every morning and see his face by mine. The fault is not with you. It never has been. And if you have spent these years thinking I in some way blame you for what happened, then you can be free of those suspicions now.” There were no more words needed after that. They stood side by side on the battlements holding a vigil of their own before eventually retiring for the night.

It was his right as a member of the company to be here for this day. Yet he shared it with no one. He did not visit the company, nor accept the invitation for lunch that Dain extended to him, nor did he see the statue Bifur made to stand as the sentinel to Thorin’s tomb. It was late into the afternoon when a knock that did not wait for him to answer sounded at his door. 

“Do you not want to see him?” Dwalin asked 

“I can not be there as others remember him for something he was not to me. It hurts too much.”   

“Come, Bilbo; it’s been too long since you’ve visited.” Dwalin led him down the empty hall to the chamber of remembrance. They passed a guard who nodded at Dwalin and stood to block any others who would follow. They soon arrived at the sturdy doors that marked the entrance to the tomb of the great kings. “You will have solitude for as long as you wish it. I will be just outside.” 

The room was well-lit for a dwarf but still dim to his eyes. That did not stop him from seeing clearly what was intended for him to see. Thorin’s tomb sat large in the room, crafted from a sturdy dark rock. Runes spread along its sides, telling the story of his heroism, or so he was told. On either side, tokens of appreciation were stacked high. They were well-crafted goods from every possible guild. But the grandest token of them all was straight ahead. Standing at the head of the tomb, in stark contrast to the darkness of the room, was the marble likeness of his heart's desire. The tears came from him immediately, but there were no great sobs to accompany them, just the consistency of a three-decade-long heartbreak. To reach the statue, he would have to step onto the tomb. Later he would worry if Dwarves considered that a taboo, but right now was his time, and he wanted to be as close to Thorin as he could. His grief carried his feet. 

He stood on his knees and brought his hand up to the chiseled face as strong and handsome in memorium as it was in life. Bifur had done his likeness great justice. He ran his hand over the carved hair and high cheekbones of his beloved. His fingers glided over the broody eyebrow ridge and down that sharp nose. 

“It’s been too long. Thirty years, and I haven't moved on from you. I can’t, and I never will. You left a mark on me. I lived fifty years without knowing you, and by fifty-one, you made me forget how to live without you. It’s taken me decades to learn how, and I’m still not any good at it. The moment you showed up late to my front door, I was doomed, but not by a dragon.” 

His fingers continued trailing the cut of his cheekbone and the shape of his jaw. The stone was cold and lifeless to the touch. Nothing like the dwarf it resembled. Thorin had always been warm, overly so, like sitting close to a furnace that didn't burn you. No fire would ever warm him so deeply again. How could it? It was like trading a roaring hearth for a single match. 

“I wonder about the life I could have had with you. Going back to The Shire has been a dull affair. It doesn't feel like I was ever meant to return. But I did as you asked. I planted my flowers, I watched them grow. I have a whole patch of forget-me-nots just for you.” Bilbo sighed and rested his head on the statue's chest. “I’m getting old, my love. Time has been kind to my features but long on my soul. I am old for a hobbit though I’m sure you would laugh at my version of old age. I’m still half the age you were when you… when you…” Ah, so he still had sobs in him after all. The marble darkened where his tears fell, and his wails echoed in the empty chamber until there were no more left in him. 

Sorrow

He looked back at the statue's face and into those white, unseeing eyes. He could so clearly remember the blue that belonged there. He might never see such a devastatingly beautiful blue again. Finally, his fingers traced Thorin’s lips. He never got to learn what they tasted like. What they felt like against his.

How Thorin might have responded, how he might have gathered him in those impossibly strong arms and never let him leave. It was one of his biggest regrets. He ached to know, so foolishly, and desperately, he kissed the stone mouth. He knew the outcome would be painful and unfulfilling, yet he did it all the same. It would be his only chance to kiss his lips, even just the statue of him. He would never return to Erebor after this. He knew that. 

He hung his head in shame and sorrow. He cursed himself for falling in love with a memory. Memories of a person he never truly had and would never truly hold. And it hurt. Worse than a blade, worse than the greatest illness. Worse than even his parents' deaths. At least with them, he had memories of a life lived, not a life that could be. He was robbed of this future, and he cursed the Valar’s name. Aulë, Yavanna, and even Ilúvatar himself for singing his pain into existence. His life seemed to drag on, not even giving him the grace of aging properly.

He wondered if this was punishment for some unknown slight, for he could no longer remember the shape of his mother's face without the aid of pictures, but time had not marred his image of Thorin in the slightest. He could remember his face, his laugh, his voice, his smell in excruciating detail. It haunted him, keeping him tethered to this place and to his best and worst memories. The night drew on, and Bilbo's tears dried up. He continued to marvel at Thorin’s face until his ability to fight the pull of sleep failed him.   

That is where Dwalin found him the next morning. Slumped against the statue of Thorin. Asleep on his tomb. 

Notes:

Thank you for reading I hope you didn't need too many tissues. Kudos and comments are always welcome. Feel free to come say hi on
Tumblr

If you are curious, Bilbo is 81 years old in this story. He adopts Frodo when he is 99 years old.