Chapter Text
Silly, silly… Bilbo tells himself even as he buttons his best waistcoat and folds his shirt collar neatly over it. What are you even thinking, you fool of a Baggins? his mind carries on even as he glances in the bedroom mirror and fluffs his curls. Utterly pointless, utterly foolish, utterly- oh!
At the last minute, he spots a certain item on his bureau. A brooch, rectangular in shape, formed of a piece of green stone with a slender vein of gold lacing through it like a lightning bolt caught mid-strike. It’s set in a silver frame marked with a geometric pattern that unmistakably declares it a dwarven craft. It’s the only one Bilbo has ever seen in the Shire, because of course no hobbit would venture far enough to come across its like. No hobbit but one. In this moment, it seems to be the perfect way to impress his guest.
Well, not a guest, technically-speaking. Mister Oakenshield was summoned to work, addressing a damaged door knob. Hamfast remarked how lucky Bilbo was that the itinerant blacksmith happened to have returned to Hobbiton only the day before, and could surely make a home visit. And Bilbo did feel lucky, that he would have a chance to spend some time with Mister Oakenshield. To not be just another hobbit seeking his skills. If only for a little while.
And, for this little while, he wants to look his best, which certainly involves pinning the dwarven brooch to his waistcoat and striding out just as the doorbell rings.
Yesterday, when he summoned up his courage to approach the market forge and make his request for the repair visit with a modicum of stammering, Mister Oakenshield simply looked at him with pure neutrality that still did little to detract from the loveliness of his eyes. He’s met with that same neutrality as he pulls the door open from its edge and smiles brightly.
“Good day, Mister Oakenshield, thank you very much for coming.”
“Good day, Mister Baggins. This is the broken knob?”
Don’t be disappointed, you know dwarves aren’t much for chit-chat, he commands himself, and nods down at the bent mechanism in the door. “That’s the one. Pure accident, of course. Fumbled delivery of a rather large cheese wheel. I do hope it won’t be too much trouble to fix. Do you think…?”
Bilbo glances up from the knob to see Mister Oakenshield is not assessing its state. And his gaze is no longer neutral. His eyes are rounded and firmly fixed on the brooch, causing Bilbo’s stomach to flip and his heart to skip.
“Oh, um, this is a very nice piece, isn’t it? My mo-”
“I must work. One silver for the repair, agreed?” The words shoot from Mister Oakenshield’s mouth like arrows and he doesn’t wait for an answer, simply drops the leather sack of tools hanging from one broad shoulder and hunches over the knob.
“A-agreed,” Bilbo echoes weakly, and scurries off, looking for a place to hide and figure out what went so terribly wrong.
He ends up back in his bedroom, where he unpins the brooch and returns it to its place on his bureau. He looks at it, mind wandering over the multitude of emotions and memories bound to it, hating the new additions of stinging shame and the image of Mister Oakenshield’s hardened expression.
Well, in any case, even if Mister Oakenshield is not technically a guest, even if he has been quite rude for no reason, Bilbo must complete his duties as a good host. He pads to the kitchen, glancing in the dwarf’s direction only once on his way and receiving no attention whatsoever. He makes up a tray with two rosemary scones that aren’t even slightly stale and tea that is perfectly steeped. This he carries to the door, where he clears his throat with a gentle cough and says-
“I am finished.”
Bilbo startles back a half-step. “Oh! You- oh. That was very quick.”
That gaze, no longer neutral, now truly sharpened with anger, pierces Bilbo. “You may inspect my work,” Mister Oakenshield all but growls, before bending down to grab the strap of his tool sack and return it to his shoulder.
Bilbo swallows against a dry throat, but a flicker of either Took-ish courage or Baggins-ish pride has him setting the tray down on the nearest table and returning to give the knob an experimental twist. It functions as if a hefty wheel of sharp cheddar never touched it. “Right then. Indeed you are finished. I’ll fetch your silver.”
He gets the coin from a purse in his office and holds it out to Mister Oakenshield. Who does not take it.
“I… I apologize for altering out agreement,” he says, his voice straining for civility, “However, I would take the brooch as payment, rather than your silver.”
Bilbo gapes for a moment before his mouth snaps shut and he pertly replies, “The brooch is not for sale.”
The sharp anger returns to Mister Oakenshield’s gaze. “I will have the brooch.”
“You will not. It’s been in my family for years, and there it will remain.”
The anger blossoms into black fury on the dwarf’s face as he shouts, “It is not yours!”
“Yes it is!” Bilbo hears himself shout right back as his own anger suddenly boils over. “Lawfully purchased and therefore mine. Here is your silver as agreed. Good day, Mister Oakenshield.”
He snatches up the dwarf’s hand and presses the coin into it, only to have it hurled past his head into the recesses of Bag End just as quickly. Now he gapes in shock tinged with fear. Mister Oakenshield is particularly tall and broad for his kind. There won’t be much at all Bilbo can do if he decides to put that fact to use. He’s already glaring deeply and blowing harsh breaths through his nose like an enraged bull. “I will have what I am owed. That brooch is not yours.”
With panic tingling in his limbs, Bilbo still manages to stand his ground. “I agreed to pay you in silver, and that is what you will have. I owe you nothing further and there is nothing in this smial that you may claim. Be on your way before you make even more of a spectacle of yourself.” Bilbo looks over Mister Oakenshield’s heaving shoulders at the few hobbits who have paused in Bagshot Row to observe their disagreement. “Good day, Mistress Grubb!” he calls to the nearest one, “Lovely weather, isn’t it?”
“Oh yes, Mister Baggins, quite fine,” she replies, her light words undercut by a wary tone.
Mister Oakenshield stiffens and shrinks, and pulls a mask of the previous neutrality over his face. In a voice like the grinding of great stones beneath the earth, he murmurs, “I will have what I am owed.” Then he turns on a heel and marches off, stomping on the poor road like it did him some great wrong.
No wrong of any kind was done, however. Bilbo is quite sure of this. No wrong at all.
