Chapter Text
After the scene in the market, Bilbo sits in his armchair for a long time, staring into his empty hearth. He’s never treated anyone like that in his life. Never lorded his status over someone who has none of his own. Bungo would be ashamed. Belladonna doubly so. Triply. Quadruply. He’s stained his honor as surely as if he had in truth not paid Mister Oakenshield for his service. But still, he did pay. Fifty silver coins shining in the dirt. It is done. The consequences will be what they will be.
He keeps to himself as much as possible for the next few days. Even ducks past windows so he doesn’t make any accidental eye-contact with Hamfast in the garden. Loses himself in the histories of legendary places and magical times, far from the foolish little catastrophes of normal life. He keeps the brooch on his bureau, more as a reminder of his failure than the bittersweet remembrance it used to be. The coins are not returned, which lets him think perhaps he has finally earned a reprieve from Mister Oakenshield’s ire.
Then one night a noise almost, but not quite, wakes him from his slumber. He snuffles and rolls over, burrowing into his warm blankets. He’s on the verge of sinking back into the depths of sleep when another soft noise makes his ear twitch. It crosses his mostly dreaming mind to investigate, but then Bag End is over half a century old. Mysterious creaks and pops and the like are a regular occurrence Bilbo has learned to live with, since it is only him here. What is not so regular is his bedroom door easing open with the tiniest of squeaks, nor the shuffling of feet on the polished floor.
Bilbo has never been more awake. His entire body from curl to toenail is frozen in terror. The intruder moves around his bed, and he has the wild thought of leaping up and sprinting through the door and away to safety. If the intruder is who he suspects, there’s a decent chance he can move faster. But decent has never felt farther from certain.
The shuffling steps move to the bureau and, despite all logic down to and including base survival instinct, outrage breaks through Bilbo’s terror. He bolts upright and shouts at the hulking shadow in his room, “So you mean to burgle me?!”
The shadow whips around and Bilbo glimpses the slight yellow-green shine of dwarven eyes before he’s out of bed and running, brain moving just as fast through possible weapon choices when it lands on the fireplace poker, directing his feet to the den. He grabs it and spins around in seconds, racing back to see Mister Oakenshield barreling out of the bedroom and over to a broken window in the parlor. Bilbo runs ahead and lunges between it and him, poker held at the ready as if it was Orcrist itself.
“Now you listen!” he roars, “You are not leaving with that brooch. It is mine. My mother gave it to me, before she died!”
He fully expects to be swatted out of the way like a pesky fly. Probably he deserves it for this foolhardy display of bravado alone. And yet, Mister Oakenshield instead stares for a silent moment, then stands up straight and tall and roars right back, “My mother made it, before she died!”
Nothing short of a personal visitation by Eru could have given Bilbo a greater shock. The poker drifts in his weakening grip until it only pokes the floor. He straightens as well, his shoulders going slack as he recalls his every interaction with Mister Oakenshield since that first repair. He could almost laugh. Or weep. Instead, he says, “Right. Well. Why didn’t you say so?”
This seems to throw the dwarf, who eventually replies, “It is not for you to know. It is my family’s business, as the brooch is my family’s heirloom.”
“Yes, but it’s my family’s heirloom too. So, now… Now you can run off with it, and I can call the shiriffs who will call the bounders, and it will all be one big, silly, stupid mess. Or… you can sit down, have some tea, and tell me about our heirloom. What do you say?”
Please, please don’t make me have to decide whether or not to really call the shiriffs, Bilbo silently begs. It feels like an age passes before Mister Oakenshield finally softens his stance. “Fine. I… I will tell you.”
Bilbo blows out a heavy sigh of relief, the poker dropping from his hand with a dull clank. “Yes. Good. This way, please.”
He settles Mister Oakenshield at the kitchen table, and goes about lighting candles and stirring the mostly dead coals enough to heat a kettle of water. That done, he goes back to his bedroom and ties his patchwork house robe over his nightshirt. Pausing there in the dark, he takes a moment to breathe, and make a new vow to the memory of his parents, “I’m going to set things right. I promise.”
