Actions

Work Header

Never Tear Us Apart

Summary:

After the Battle of Five Armies, Thorin asks Mahal for a second chance at life, with the promise that if he and his nephews return he’ll right all the wrongs he committed. Mahal grants his request under one condition...

Chapter Text

The battle is over. The sky clears, the forces of evil retreat. Eagles fly home, Elves return to their forest, and the Dwarves kneel on the ice, beyond sorrow and grief.

Their king is dead. He has already reached Mahal’s Halls.

The day began with one, two, three mistakes. He almost killed someone he loved more than life, chose avoidable war over peace, left his cousin to fight alone.

It ended as he led Fíli and Kíli, the light of his eyes, into a death trap. The day, and Thorin’s life, ended then.

Fíli and Kíli stand at the door to the Halls; they arrived before him. Thorin would speak to them, if he knew words that could...

There are none. Action is the only thing Thorin knows: to move forward, even when you’ve committed a wrong. To have the courage to act.

So he acts. It starts with a promise, to ask Mahal to undo this somehow, to change the course of events, because this is wrong. Stay here, he commands, and enters alone.

 

“Please, let them go back. Let them live their youth, see the Mountain restored. Allow Fíli to rule in my stead, and Kíli to enjoy romance with the she-elf.”

“And you?” asks Mahal curiously, his eyes scrutinizing Thorin up and down, as if suspecting him of a hidden plan.

“I will toil endless hours in these Halls. I will be your slave.”

“Ah. But you also wanted to live, did you not?”

He avoids the answer. What he wished, if anything, for himself. So many years have passed since he last wanted to live. Yet recently, it seems, he had tried.

“If I could go back, it would be for one thing: to serve my kingdom day and night. To make amends with those that I’ve wronged. I promise you this.”

Mahal waves him away. “Your cousin Dáin can do all of that, you know. On the other hand...” This could be fun, Thorin reads on his Maker’s face. He waits, not daring to say any more.

“My child, I could be wrong, but I got the impression it was not just Kili who formed a special attachment in this quest.”

“That is of little matter.”

“Indeed? Then this should be easy for you. Here is what I propose: I will let all three of you go back. You will be king, and do what you deem to be right, under one condition: that you forget that you ever loved.”

“I...” Wait. How can one...

“I can make it happen. You’ll still remember the person you loved and everything you knew about them, except for those memories connected with love. The moment you knew you’d fallen for them. If you confessed or expressed your feelings in some way. If you kissed... though it’s not looking like you got that far. All that will be forgotten, as will any times you thought of this person with love.”

Mahal searches Thorin deeply, questioningly, and Thorin searches back in return.

“Why? Why would you have me forget?”

“So you can fulfill the promise you have made just now: to do the right thing.”

“And I can’t keep my promise and love at the same time?”

“You haven’t shown great skill at multitasking as of late, Thorin, son of Thrain. One might say you got distracted by love. Perhaps with fewer things to keep track of, you’ll be able to focus better.”

Feelings can come back, can they not? Maybe they don’t depend on memories in the first place. If the one he loves is still present in his life, Thorin will fall in love again. Such it is that he reasons, quickly, without second guessing. It’s a small price to pay for Fíli and Kíli’s life; for hoping to redeem his own honor.

“I accept. Thank you.”

To the left of the great entrance there is a rectangular pool surrounded by three walls adorned with glittering gems in green, red and blue, reflecting in the clear sparkling water. There Mahal leads him, and Thorin finds it strange his Maker should have gone to such lengths to cleanse one’s memory of love, but, he supposes, Mahal has seen a lot in his life.

Before saying goodbye, he briefly revisits. The moment he knew he was in love. The first time he tried to express it. The last. Few such memories were created. Maybe they will come back, maybe someone will remind him of them. The rest of his treasury of love are just thoughts - what he wished or planned, how he viewed this person in the privacy of his mind. All such thoughts will be gone, but Thorin is not too concerned: with one look at him it will all come back, he is sure.

...and as he bathes in the pool of forgetness, for each memory he loses contact with a crack is made in the walls and a gem turns to grey as it falls, losing its shine until it dissolves in the water. At the end, no gems are left in the walls. How many were there? Hundreds, at least. He wonders what they were for, what happened to them.

“Take your nephews and go now, my child. You won’t remember our conversation, save for the promise you’ve made. Go, and do the right thing.”

 

The joy of the Dwarves in the Mountain at the sons of Durin’s return is immense. One by one, they embrace their king and his heirs, marveling that no one seems hurt.

Bilbo comes too, greets them with a happy, if hesitant look. Thorin hugs him solidly, fondly; apologizes again for his conduct, rescinds his order of banishment, reassures Bilbo he’s welcome to stay. Bilbo appears to want to say something, too; but before he gets a chance Thorin’s eyes fall upon the V of his coat, where a bright garment emerges, of unbelievable worth.

“How did you come by that?...”

“What?” Bilbo asks in confusion, looking around himself.

“The armor you are wearing. Did someone give it to you?”

It’s unexpected, that is all; that Bilbo should have come across such a precious thing. Thorin is curious. Well, maybe more. He wonders who has claimed Bilbo so boldly, so quickly, while he was out cold. He asks casually, nicely, careful to keep in check any hint of greed. There is none: the only hint is of a strange feeling, jealousy unforeseen.

Bilbo laughs nervously; tries to, more like.

“Did someone give it to me? You could say that. But...” he proceeds to remove his coat, “I’m happy to return it. The battle is over now, so. I can’t imagine I’m going to need it.” He takes the mithril off, and Thorin’s thoughts change: it’s good someone took care to protect him in war.

“You are entitled to one fourteenth of the treasure. And I hardly need add that, for your brave deeds, you can pick anything out of the hoard. If this is what you want, it is yours.”

“It is not. In fact, given some of my deeds, it is appropriate to return it,” says Bilbo, pressing the mithril into Thorin’s hands with no second thought, though a wave of indecision swirls around his lips, not for what he should do, but for what he should say.

“I am glad to see you well, Thorin. I don’t believe I will need any other reward,” Bilbo says with a quiet resolve, and departs. And Thorin’s mind never strays too far from him: how beautiful he looked in that armor. He wishes he could have admired him a while longer.

“Put this back in the armory, Dwalin.” He turns to the Company, only to see them regard Thorin with jaws dropped in shock. “What?”

 

There is some confusion among the dwarves as to what actually passed. It’s not clear if Thorin asked for the mithril back, or Bilbo rejected his gift. Dwalin says, if Thorin did ask for it back, he was within his rights to do so. Hopefully this marks the end of heartbreak at the hobbit’s hand, heartbreak he could observe while Bilbo betrayed his friend and then stood there to witness his public humiliation from a few feet away.

“I think you’re being a bit hard on Bilbo, brother,” observes Balin.

“Then you tell me: where is his affection for Thorin?”

“I thought I saw it in his tears. After the battle.”

“You’d have to be made of stone not to cry...” scoffs Dwalin. Balin chuckles. “Ah, forget it. You just wait and see. The hobbit will leave come Spring, and in time Thorin will be nothing more to him than a good tale to tell.”

 

Fíli and Kíli opt for the theory that Bilbo returned the gift. Whether he did out of remorse, or rejecting something grand like a courting attempt, they don’t know; nor will they prod their Uncle for answers. Everyone decides to be grateful Thorin is alive and of sound mind now, and will not interfere with his peace.

 

Thus life continues on, with the king taking his rightful place on the throne and beginning rebuilding his home, working to strengthen alliances, welcome new dwarves into Erebor, pouring endless hours into making it livable once again. He spares no effort; he forgets himself.

There’s something crushing about Thorin’s attitude after his miraculous return, Bilbo thinks. Everything is so all right with him: no more impulses towards anger, every action, every word carefully said, with an eye for good, for doing good and staying good and never falling down again. He never seems to need anything; and that, more than anything else, makes Bilbo feel out of place.

Sometimes, late in the evenings, the Company retreat to a small hall, where they drink by the fireplace and tell stories. Often times, like tonight, Kíli talks of the elf Tauriel. She has gone home for now; he is growing impatient. He’s never written a love letter in his life, but thinks that will help speed her return.

“You appear to be skilled with words, Bilbo. Might you help me with writing this letter?” he asks. Fíli is there, and Thorin too, pouring over a new treaty Thranduil has sent him, to be signed in the morning.

“I’m... not sure,” answers Bilbo with that hint of sadness Thorin has noticed lately, on the rare moments when their eyes meet. Bilbo usually tries to look cheerful, but there’s more, something unsaid, unresolved. “I may be good with words, but I seem to fail at love. Nevertheless, I can try to help.” And Thorin cannot help overhear a few lines Bilbo offers, with no preparation, out of the blue.

Dearest Tauriel,

Why have you not come back to me? Every day I await your return... Has King Thranduil forbidden you from leaving the Woodland Realm? You must find a way of seeing me again. My life didn’t begin until I saw your face... My one waking thought is of being with you...

Kíli is all delight.

“That’s gold, Bilbo! Wow! And you say you are not skilled at love?”

Thorin’s heart skips a beat. This does not sound like someone who’s just helping out a friend. Bilbo must be in love. A person in this Mountain, someone he met on the road... Keep it together. Thranduil will be here tomorrow. Oh, Mahal, don’t let it be Thranduil.

Thorin needs to focus if he’s to fulfill the promise he made. Yet he can’t help gaze at Bilbo some more, and wonder who this “gold” is really for, who may have stirred such passion in his heart.

 

The next day, Thranduil is led to the Throne Room. Thorin bows to him graciously and offers the gems of Lasgalen, with no mention of payment. After the Elvenking’s eyes bathe sufficiently in their magical glow, they finally take in his surroundings: his host before him, some of the Company’s dwarves, the brave Halfling... the throne, and the King’s Jewel above it.

“The Heart of the Mountain,” Thranduil remarks, quite mesmerized by its beauty. “Not long ago I’ve heard it called by a different name. While I had my doubts at the time, I believe it finally to be true, and let me say, it looks gorgeous above Your Majesty’s throne. Your heart. It does suit you well.”

“I thank you, but wish to make a correction: the Arkenstone has never held my heart,” says Thorin, and his eyes search every member of his audience. He wants everybody to know this. If there was any doubt - that he is here to make things right, to give all of himself, even to set this elf straight if he has to.

“I never wanted it for myself. A symbol that would help unite the seven armies of the Dwarves, that’s all it was to me. As a symbol it stands now, beautiful indeed, but it has no power over me.”

The Company beam at him proudly. Only one has tears in his eyes. “Excuse me,” Bilbo whispers faintly, and tears himself away from the small crowd, fleeing down the hall.

“Balin, Dori... show our honored guest around,” orders Thorin. “There is much that I wish him to see. I will be back.”

 

Bilbo is on the ramparts, sobbing.

“Master Baggins... What is the matter?”

Bilbo cannot speak, and Thorin moves closer, yet maintaining an appropriate distance.

“Will you not trust me enough to tell me what distresses you? If it’s anything in my power to resolve...”

“I hurt you,” Bilbo lets out in anguish. “I hurt you more than I could have imagined.”

“When did you hurt me?”

“Here. Here on this wall, when I told you I gave away the stone - your Heart, I called it, and... and now you’re standing here, healed, and good, and... well, more than good. Kingly, handsome as always, majestic... it’s wonderful to see. And it turns out I was far more wrong than I thought. When I predicted you’d give anything in return for your heart.”

“Please,” Thorin pleads uncertainly. “You don’t need...”

“I don’t know how to undo what I did. At the time, if it had helped prevent a senseless war, my deed would have seemed justified. But it helped with nothing. A battle still occurred, and at the end there were more casualties than I could endure to see in a hundred lifetimes. So what did I achieve? Only this: I hurt you.”

“If it is any consolation, I don’t remember being hurt.”

“You don’t?”

“No. But if I was hurt, I deserved it,” says Thorin, suddenly overcome with a feeling of warmth. “Master Baggins... I would not have you spend valuable time sweating over this. I would have you feel joy in the renewal around you. This Mountain, pulsing with life once again. The sun stretching over the horizon. The days growing longer. Do you not rejoice in the coming of Spring?”

“You called me Bilbo before.”

Thorin is silent. Trying to comprehend something as if in darkness, without a map, frustrated to have lost his way. Please, forget these dark thoughts, he wanted to say, yet he tries to remember as he leans on the wall. Why is it he can’t recall calling him by this name.

“Thorin?”

Bilbo stands next to him, close this time, too close for his own comfort yet doesn’t seem to care.

“I never know how to tell you this. So much time has passed, that perhaps it is meaningless now, but I wanted to tell you, on that day, when I saw you react. I regret the way I handled the Arkenstone. I know very well that through my actions I lost something that would have been of greatest value to me. There are no words for how much I regret that part. But even more I regret hurting you.”

“Are you saying... you wanted that mithril coat after all? If you want it, it’s yours,” says Thorin, whose understanding of “of greatest value” must differ a great deal from the Halfling’s; how else can he explain the are you stupid look levelled at him right now.

“The mithril? No. I told you, it’s not that. I don’t know how to describe what I lost, but it has to do with you.”

Thorin is always busy: Bilbo gets more and more that impression. Part of why continuing this discussion is a serious blunder is imposing on his expensive time. That is why Bilbo would like to run, if he could.

Strong hands grasp his shoulders firmly, yet ever so gently, as if Thorin is scared of his own design.

“Master Baggins. Bilbo.”

Bilbo closes his eyes in elation that tastes like fear, but even the fear tastes good, for it’s filled with memory and hopeful anticipation.

“Whatever it is you’ve lost... I want to know. When you find a way to express it, please share it with me.”

"All right." Bilbo looks in the distance, as if finally touched by a vision of Spring.

“I will be going home soon.” He mutters it mostly to himself, as an afterthought, perhaps wondering how much it truly matters, to reveal what he’s lost, when his time here is at an end.

Yet Thorin heard, and when he heard he felt a pain in his chest sharper than any blade.

“Your happiness is most important to me. If what you’ve lost is in my power to return, I will give it to you.”

This is not how Thorin meant to finish his request. In a reassurring, steady tone, not with voice cracking and feeling like he had to grasp the wall for control.

He was hurt, wasn’t he? Weeks ago, on this wall...

Does it matter?...

Bilbo was leaving then, too.

It hurts, and Thorin doesn’t know why.

 

He returns to the Throne Room, now devoid of company, takes off his black cloak and spreads it over the throne like a curtain. Then Thorin removes his crown and places it on the cloak. And he stares at these three, the throne, the Arkenstone and the crown - his, his and his - and three times do they magnify the emptiness in his heart. They are all that he ever wanted, yet they are not good enough. Not nearly enough to make Bilbo stay.

 

Chapter Text

Ever since Bilbo said I will go soon, something completely foreign has taken over the king. He would call it discomfort, for lack of a better word. It is worst in the evenings, when the Company gather around the fireplace and Bilbo talks about home.

Tonight, however, their conversations turn to what’s new: Tauriel is here. She got Thranduil’s blessing to leave and has been in Erebor for three days. Kíli barely manages to keep his hands off her, which to Thorin feels like a punch in the gut, that has nothing to do with her being an elf.

Mercifully, the love birds are behaving tonight: there are dwarves nearby, all pleased with the wine Tauriel brought from the Woodland Realm. On second thought, maybe she shouldn’t have, given the bluntness the Company sport after a few drinks.

Was it his looks or his personality? the dwarves wonder as they behold the unlikely pair before them. What is it about Kíli that the fair elf maid fell for so fast? They would ask but no one dares to, except Fíli, of course.

“So let me get this straight. You met my brother in the forest while fighting spiders. You two spent, maybe a minute together before we were all captured? Then you spoke again while he was behind bars and you on guard duty, for, like, what? Ten minutes?”

“Hold on,” says Kíli with a big grin. “You forget the moment she put me in prison.”

“Right, right. Of course. I’m sure you alluding to the contents of your trousers was a key moment that will pass into legends. So, Mistress Tauriel, on the basis of twelve minutes combined, you fell in love with this dude?”

“It wasn’t just those times. If you recall, I also treated his wound in Bard’s house in Laketown. And of course, in the battle...” She bows her head in a mix of sadness, and pride at the way Kíli acted.

“Still. You two didn’t exactly know each other, and these always-on-the-run circumstances... it boggles the mind,” says Dwalin.

Several dwarves jump in: it’s obvious why Kíli fell for her; that’s not the question here.

“What made me fall in love...” Tauriel lifts her eyes nostalgically as if toward a memory, yet it’s not one event or another but the time in between, the absence of Kíli as much as his ever short presence. “It wasn’t how many minutes we had with each other, but how he made use of them. When Kíli approached me and spoke, so directly, decidedly... some things were made clear. His courage, a force able to conquer everything in its path and reckon with the harshest of evil. I saw his faith in our bond, even as it was being formed: he was not afraid to share that with me.”

Kíli blushes. Some dwarves go “oooo”, others listen in awe.

“It is indeed rare to try to woo someone from behind bars,” says Fíli. “We could all stand to learn from your skills, brother; some of us perhaps more than others.” He and Kíli exchange an amused look, as if it’s a private joke between them; Thorin wonders loosely if other Company members were swooning over elves while in Mirkwood.

“Here’s to you then, Kíli, for being bold enough to secure this relationship.” Nori gallantly raises his tankard. The others follow, Bilbo does the same. From across the table Thorin watches him intently. Bilbo appears in low spirits tonight, but he sure seems to enjoy the wine.

“Oh well. I had a bit of help along the way.” Kíli winks, shifting his gaze in Bilbo’s direction.

The letter Kíli wrote with Bilbo’s help must have sealed the deal with the elf maid. Thorin thinks, maybe Bilbo once sent such a letter. Maybe the person that inspired him to write such powerful words is in the Shire, waiting.

Bilbo raises his head from the tankard he’s been quite busy with: he’s on his second refill.

“So if I may ask, Lady Tauriel... if Kíli had not spoken to you the way he did... all else being equal, would you still be dating him?”

Tauriel laughs. “If he hadn’t made the first move? or should I say moves... I don’t see how we would be together. I’m not exactly used to initiating courtship, and have never contemplated dating a dwarf in my life!”

“But you would still have fallen for me, right?” asks Kíli, looking menacing, if jokingly so.

“Absolutely. It would just be a sad case of pining from a distance, I’m afraid.” The dwarves join in her laughter: how unproductive, what a waste of time that would be.

“So, Bilbo, you’re still leaving next week?” asks Balin, looking to change the subject.

“I am.”

“Bofur and Dwalin will accompany you to Mirkwood. From there, King Thranduil will send his escorts with you.”

“That sounds great. Excellent.”

“A pity, though, that you cannot stay longer. But, a plan is a plan. You made it clear how much you miss home.”

“Right. I... If you would excuse me,” Bilbo says, rising from his seat in a slow, unsteady motion. “The hour is late, and I’m awfully tired. Good night, everyone.” He thanks Tauriel for the wine and leaves the hall.

“He doesn’t seem as excited as one would expect,” observes Bifur.

“That’s an understatement. He was terribly out of his comfort zone this evening,” says Bofur.

“Maybe he just hates separations,” says Bombur.

Thorin can take no more. “I have to go as well. Left some work unfinished. I’ll see you all in the morning.“

He makes for the exit and calls for the hobbit, who is far down the hallway by now.

“Master Baggins. Please, allow me to walk you to your room.”

“Oh. No, no. There’s no need.”

“You don’t seem well.”

“I am. Perfectly well.” There’s struggle in Bilbo’s voice. “I suppose we can walk for a bit.”

Thorin follows his lead, to pleasantly discover Bilbo prefers a longer route to his room, and even shows a mild interest in conversation.

“Kíli and Tauriel seem to have something special. I can see where she’s coming from. Courage and this mad-driving selflessness... seem to run in the Durin line.”

“I wish I could have half of his courage,” Thorin murmurs. The kind of courage it would take to ask Bilbo Is there someone waiting for you at home, or have you met someone while in Erebor, if it runs in the Durin line, it most certainly skipped a generation.

“All this talk of Mirkwood made me a bit nostalgic,” confesses Bilbo. “I remember our stay there. How I searched for you all, and how lucky I got thanks to Thranduil’s wine. That day was surreal.”

Thorin is listening a little too avidly, taking in all the details. By now he can tell there are gaps in his memory, not just when it comes to Mirkwood: hopefully Bilbo won’t notice.

“Thorin. Can I ask you something?”

“Of course. Anything.”

“Do you remember the moment I rescued you from that prison?”

“I... Yes. Sort of.”

Thorin knows that Bilbo rescued him. He doesn’t remember the moment itself: it’s as if someone reported this to him, though he can’t remember that reporting act, either.

“When I unlocked your door... there was this look in your eyes. Like you knew I would come, yet you couldn’t believe it.”

How is it possible to forget something like this?...

“And I wanted... I wanted so badly to say something.”

How to pretend to agree with an unknown, when on his side there’s a hole in the truth.

He would love to agree, if only he could know the truth, too.

“But I was held back,” Bilbo goes on. “We were in absolute hurry. Then at the Hidden Door, I wanted to say something once more. When you sent me into the Mountain alone and I feared I may never return, and again when you came for me and I wanted to live more than anything. When we said farewell: especially then. But there was never time. Yet as it turns out I could have made good use of time.”

By now Thorin can grasp Bilbo is going somewhere with this, just not toward refreshing his memory, but adding to things that make him feel lost. Vaguely Thorin discerns “good use of time” may apply to Kíli per the talk they have witnessed. What could this have to do with Bilbo, who must be so home sick that just earlier he was drowning his sorrows in wine?

“The moments you speak of... I don’t remember them quite in the same way you do. I am sorry.”

Better than to say I don’t remember you in them at all.

“It’s no problem. Please don’t look so down on yourself.”

“I forgot some things that involve you,” Thorin admits with great pain. “That’s a serious failure on my part.”

“It is not,” says Bilbo, too kindly for what Thorin deserves. “Really, it’s not a big deal.”

“I made a promise I would do the right thing. It pains me to see I cannot, in such an important matter.”

“I don’t need “the right thing” from you, Thorin,” Bilbo frowns. “I guess I’m wondering why you seem to have forgotten, or blocked, so many memories of me.”

“I certainly did not block them.”

They have reached Bilbo’s door for a while now, and Thorin prays Bilbo forgot they’re standing in front of it; or perhaps he does not want to go in.

“It’s because I hurt you, isn’t it?”

Thorin brings his hand to Bilbo’s lips and silences him softly, the word stop barely registering amid his emotion.

“I will not hear any more about you hurting me.”

“All right.”

“Bilbo... I don’t know what happened to me when I was brought back to Middle Earth. Lord Mahal granted me another chance at life, but some things may have been lost. I am sure I have many lapses in memory. Many faults.”

“No, I truly believe this is your only fault,” says Bilbo, who hasn’t heard a single soul complain Thorin forgot anything or did anything wrong. On the contrary, everyone raves about the king’s stellar performance in all aspects of ruling, finding no flaw in him.

“I want to remember,” Thorin whispers through the frustration, the anger at his situation and the hope Bilbo’s words gave him just now, hope he has no idea what to do with or what it is for.

He says it as if he welcomes Bilbo’s help

 

except there is nothing precisely that Bilbo would point to as the memory, the proof that they had something that no other two souls can have, a bond so deep that for all the lack of faith or courage and for all that it strayed under duress from the start, and in the end didn’t move mountains or manage to stave off evil it would have been unbreakable, beautiful, pure. Bilbo knows, it’s possible it’s all in his mind, he idealized the smallest gesture from Thorin and now thanks to Thranduil’s wine he’s about to do it again

The thought is tempting, to make up something, to stir in Thorin that which wasn’t there before, to say you loved me and hope it was true, once, before Thorin forgot it

and as his mind begins to delve deeply into the possibility Bilbo feels himself moving closer. His hand reaches for Thorin’s and presses it against his own lips, then brings it to his chest; he rests his hand and all his feeling there. His fingers reach upward and stroke Thorin’s hair almost motionlessly, too aware they’re touching something forbidden, not because this is normally reserved for courting but simply because that hair is Thorin’s and therefore intangible; the movement ceases soon. Seconds pass, and the possibility grows in Bilbo’s mind. He could create something now and place it in the past

pretend it happened - no, not pretend, that’s not

He brings their lips close, so close until it’s impossible to deny he is kissing Thorin, almost imperceptibly, as a continuation of a dream. He is in it, in the fantasy he is trying to conjure as a stand-in for a memory that would do: yes, he will stay here and force Thorin to admit, to remember, for even as they’ve never done this before Bilbo thought about it, at times he was sure Thorin wanted it... And through the kiss they feel each other’s absence, their presence likewise in each other’s lives; what was lost flickers fleetingly in the darkness of Thorin’s mind, and Bilbo longs to have him back

and then Thorin asks something that is so unlike him.

“You and I... tell me... were you and I lovers?”

Maybe there was a hint of hope, or fear, in the way Thorin asked. The kiss is consumed, like a snowflake that went up in flames; Bilbo wonders if it was real.

“N... no,” he says nervously, terrified. “I... I-m sorry if I gave you that impression.”

Thorin’s arms enclose him in a gentle, if restrained hug and places a kiss on Bilbo’s curls, chaste, full of adoration, yet nowhere near the intensity of what just passed between them; they are together, still.

“I want to remember,” Thorin says one last time. He releases Bilbo from his arms and leaves, and Bilbo feels the floor open beneath. That’s what you get for pushing him too far. You willingly misled him, he chastizes himself. Still, he can’t bring himself to regret it. Thorin looked stunned: his face acquired a beautiful, new expression that didn’t fade after Bilbo’s answer.

 

Bilbo’s last week passes uneventfully. He packs, spends lots of time with each friend, writes to Bard and Thranduil, announcing he’ll visit them on his way. And it comes, the evening before he’s scheduled to leave for the Shire. The last, that he saved for the king.

They sit in Bilbo’s room. The hobbit reminisces about their adventure again: nothing serious, just going over moments, no longer putting Thorin on the spot. It’s fitting, Bilbo says, that we should recall what brought all of us together. Thorin stares at him openly, studying, taking in every feature, while thinking deeply of Mirkwood, the Hidden Door, the time when Bilbo was sent to face Smaug and when he returned. All nothing but abstract thoughts, but he’ll fit Bilbo’s image in this frame, and hope with time memories will be restored.

Ravenhill... Bilbo was there, because Bilbo said so. It’s not enough to make it come back, but

Without this memory I cannot be whole

Can I have it back, just this one? he silently asks Mahal. If there is an answer, it is equally silent. He could ask Bilbo to remind him of it, their farewell, and share with Thorin what he wanted to say. He could ask Bilbo again if he’s found what he lost. But this is fine, too, to sit here admiring him: more than fine. For something new is happening as Thorin watches him, wishing to be nowhere else and realizing it’s no longer the discomfort of Bilbo leaving - this week Thorin felt it more than ever, for he rarely saw him... Bilbo didn’t have time, and Thorin tried to hide away his feelings, too afraid to face their power, to confront that new reality that started the moment they kissed; he’s never felt more awake. Thorin ruined it, but the memory stays, and that is more than enough.

Bilbo... He wants him close, woven into the fabric of his soul. He wishes he could leave Erebor, the throne and the Arkenstone and everything else Thorin fought for, and follow him anywhere he’ll go.

Not the right thing. Not what he promised at the crossing between worlds. Thorin is needed here, to work endlessly for the good of his kingdom: the purpose of his return.

It’s all right. Bilbo will go home, and Thorin will return to being king and not having time for anything.

It helps, though. To be here, to experience this. To begin to know, despite the mystery of the past, one feeling clearly, one thing. Thorin is falling in love. He lets himself surrender to that feeling, immersed in the warmth of Bilbo’s presence as Bilbo continues to tell him favorite parts of the quest, lightly and casually and not alluding to anything them. And Thorin drowns deeply in that new feeling, love, until he can see the bottom: a glittering pool with gems that start to float as he sinks even deeper.

The moment of falling in love... He has arrived, he is in it now. So much so it takes courage to hold that feeling together, deeply into his soul, and hold himself steady, for fear he is too fragile to bear it. Courage to witness a bond being formed and to look for a way to voice it; to share his faith in it with one who may not return it. Courage to wonder if it would be right to ask Bilbo to stay.

Thorin lacks all this courage, of course. But it matters not. If by any chance it happened before, the moment when he knew he was in love, and someone took that memory away, he’ll take this one now. This one, this reality here, this love he holds now, Thorin will never forget.

 

Chapter Text

It is late evening. Thorin left Bilbo to rest before his journey home. Thorin should, too: not that rest is anywhere on his mind.

He’d prefer to bask in this feeling, try to uncover more, leave no stone unturned. There promises to be more: every time he delves into it, this feeling grows, radiates in myriad new ways, magnified in its wondrous splendor.

I love you. Can he go back and tell him this now, after they’ve said good night? He certainly could, but it’s not Thorin’s style. And Bilbo managed to hide behind a veil of politeness, and render them friends - good, solid, singular, one might say - but still: friends.

His style has yet to reveal itself: for Thorin has never courted or loved before. But there is little a soul can do between now and tomorrow at noon, when Bilbo is planning to leave. There is no time to craft that special gift Bilbo could take with him. Of course, Thorin could ransack the treasury for the shiniest gem, or give him the Arkenstone, even if it meant splitting Erebor’s image in two. He would, if not for the fact that Bilbo deserves more than a last minute hack.

To tell the truth: it’s not just that Thorin has never loved, or courted before. He’s also not used to being in a rush. No, even with a battle at his door he did not give in to pressure imposed by lack of time.

Did he?...

No. With everything, Thorin takes his time. And love by dwarf standards involves a certain kind of patience; a slow, steady process, in which time plays a role. Running back to the beloved’s bedroom to beg Please don’t go is not anywhere near what besotted dwarves do.

What this besotted dwarf does is reflect, put pieces back together. Because this love traces back to a place he still can’t identify.

Was it love then, already, when he came back from Mahal’s Halls? His eyes descended upon the silver steel Bilbo wore, deeming the sight arresting, irresistible, reminiscent of a pool of gems that glittered with an otherworldly glow...

...against a background Thorin still can’t remember.

Was it something like love at first sight, in his given new life.

How did you come by that?...

I am glad to see you well, Thorin. I don’t believe I will need any other reward.

He is in the armory now. Retraces steps - his? Dwalin’s? Dwalin placed back the silver steel there, that day, when Thorin returned from the dead. That was hasty, he’s thought ever since. Thorin takes it; sleeps with it, if holding it close and whispering endearments in the night can be sleep.

You and I... tell me... were you and I lovers?

The answer was no, but that kiss held a promise.

If Thorin could do it again, he would not use any words. He would deepen the kiss, slowly and steadily, fearless, without caring how they got here. His mouth would taste him in one hundred ways, never stopping until he’s satisfied. Then his lips would surround Bilbo’s neck while Thorin would gently push the two of them in, toward the nearest wall. And when every kiss has left a bruise Thorin’s hand would leave Bilbo’s skin and reach for the door handle, open the door, and possibly say something this time. I want you. In Bilbo’s room time would stand still, and he’d know how to love him, even if he didn’t know love before.

He pours this fantasy onto the shirt, pressed tightly on Thorin’s chest, and he is lost to beauty and power while the armor is being remade, crafted into a new garment of even more beauty and power. No blade can pierce it, except this, Thorin’s love mingled with a strange, deep desire that drifts between the silver steel links, seeking the One it is destined for. His desire, what could have been flows in it, imprinting into the mithril while Thorin has Bilbo moan in wild pleasure in darkness; it’s still night, and they’re still in his mind.

 

...Outside, somehow the hours passed, darkness turned into dawn, and birds flew back to the Mountain, bringing a warm wind of Spring. Outside, it is noon, now. Tauriel and the Company gathered to say goodbye; they all say it, except Bofur and Dwalin, who stand aside with ponies, weapons and food, ready to escort Bilbo away from Erebor.

Thorin approaches him last, the steel armor packed in a blue cloth tied with silvery strings, and speaks softly, secretly.

“Bilbo... I am sorry you had to part with this. I’ve realized since, that it was meant to be yours.”

“The mithril?”

Bilbo pauses, searches the unseen with his eyes.

“Why are you giving me this?”

“It is a gift. A token of our friendship.”

Bilbo chuckles. “That’s what you said the first time.”

and there, Thorin’s mouth opens in some sort of surprise, I gave it to you? thankfully registering before he could say it out loud. There’s no need to ask: the look on Bilbo’s face says it all. Yet Bilbo’s reaction is not far from his: he wanted to speak, then he stopped himself, too.

“All right. Thank you.” Bilbo braves the awkwardness, puts the gift in his backpack without opening it. Wearing protection on a long trip is overrated, or he’s just gracious enough to save Thorin the embarrassment of having Erebor watch him regift something he de-gifted before.

“I have something for you, too.” Bilbo pulls out a small wooden box, red as the oak leaves in Mirkwood and as the sun setting on the Hidden Door, yet has Shire written all over it: a bit of his home.

“What I lost... I’ve figured it out. The answer... is here.” Bilbo’s eyes face the ground; he doesn’t dare meet Thorin’s eyes.

He hands Thorin the box.

“Please, don’t open it now. Later. After I’m gone.”

The secrecy extends to Bilbo’s nervousness; Thorin would give anything, now, to decipher it. But if he were to guess, Bilbo is being shy, not afraid. Definitely not afraid.

“Thank you. I will.”

And here, here Thorin contemplates saying something, and of course it would be the wrong thing, for he is not good with words; that is why he prefers silence, a lot.

I remember now.

What?

Being hurt, that day on the wall. Not for the Arkenstone, but for ordering you to go. You did not cause it - I hurt myself. It hurts in the exact same way now, as you’re leaving.

Then Bilbo would say, I don’t want to hurt you again, or even I’m sorry for leaving. I’m sure I deserve it, would come the reply, and Thorin would hate himself for its righteousness.

Who is he? All the right things, ever since he returned... every day Thorin tries his hardest to do those. Yet something is missing: the person who could ask him to stay, especially now, when Bilbo eyes him curiously, thoughtfully, almost daring him to. But that wouldn’t be right. Bilbo has family, friends. A life. A home he missed terribly during the quest; Thorin remembers that much.

And yet Bilbo leaving feels wrong. A promise is a promise, though: Thorin paid for his life with it. To own the barrier Mahal asked him to hold. He’ll do it, even as here and now blur the edges of right and wrong.

“I wish you all the joy in the world,” Thorin says as he pulls Bilbo close, and hopes his arms, his chest, his hands can say it, because love is not just something in his mind; not something to express in words, all the time. Love penetrates the innermost layers of his being where the fire burns secretly, low, matching the passing of time in a slow, heady rhythm, and shaping his heart into a place where someone, one day, can be home. A place where somebody lives, now.

Bilbo cries in his arms. “I will miss you.”

I don’t want to miss you. I want you forever, like this, in my arms.

What is right is here, in this embrace, strong and unyielding, yet not strong enough to never tear them apart. Thorin does not have permission to decide on what’s right.

“Have a safe journey, Bilbo.”

And it ends: or begins, rather. With every step Bilbo takes away from him, something is happening. The workings of Thorin’s mind less than excellent, true, but his body has a mind of its own, that feels the separation as much as it felt Bilbo’s banishment months ago: a hole opened up in his heart, ravaging the beginnings of home. It was mended when he returned from the Halls. It is breaking now.

He lets Bilbo go.

 

Thorin waits until evening sets, work day over, schedules and paperwork left behind as he retreats to his rooms; knows not what he’s afraid of, but afraid he is, like he’s never been in his life.

In his darkest dreams, someone trapped his memories in a box. They concern the most precious person in the world. They speak of a bond, something that should have been clear and pure. Thorin longs for them.

This is absolution: miraculously, the box ended up with Bilbo, his rescuer, always. Bilbo kept those memories for him; now he’s about to reveal them.

And yet, Bilbo lost something, too.

I don’t know how to describe what I lost, but it has to do with you.

Thorin wanted to know. Thorin wished he could find it for him. Then today, Bilbo gave it to him.

I’ve figured out what I lost. It’s... in here.

Maybe he needs to atone for something, too off-putting to bring it up. A memory he should own, to make up for.

After enough brooding he gets over himself. The box is opened. It appears to contain one small object wrapped in a small sheet of paper. Thorin removes the wrapping and beholds the item: a tiny acorn that perfectly complements Bilbo’s box, his Shire, his home.

Thorin doesn’t remember this acorn.

He can’t help but smile, though. If he thought about clear and pure, this is it: how their bond must have been.

There is more. Thorin’s gaze falls on the paper the acorn was kept in. It contains writing. It is a note. Mahal. A note from Bilbo, to him.

Where is he? Good, he’s in his private rooms, where no one can see the King Under the Mountain shaking like a leaf as he brings the writing closer and reads.

I didn’t know how to tell you.

I still don’t. How to tell you what I’ve lost, what I miss and will miss no matter how close or how far. I hid how I feel in a box; I would leave you with it, helpless against an unknown device that keeps knocking down all those things that we were. If it took everything from us except one, there is one memory I would keep. The way you looked at me when you saw this, this acorn. I don’t know if you remember it. I do, and how beautiful you looked then, to me. Take it, Thorin Oakenshield, and if it means nothing, forget me; for I seem to remember too much.

Thorin doesn’t wait for his mind to click; it may never. Except the urgency of love is made clear. He scans the room for his sword and coat; by the way, now it’s time to put that war ram Dain gave him to use. He tucks the note in his coat; the acorn never leaves his hand. He’ll have time to figure out if it means anything.

Right. He may be the first dwarf who rode dramatically in the dark to catch up with love. But then again, this. is. no. ordinary. love.

 

...Bilbo is sleeping under the stars, in Dale.

He reached Bard’s new house, was invited in, dined. Conversation flowed, then both he and the dwarves were offered rooms to sleep in. Bofur and Dwalin left it up to him. Bilbo chose to camp outside for the night, glad to catch a glimpse of Spring while still near the Mountain. The air is warm and filled with promise and hope.

Bofur and Dwalin will take turns keeping watch; for now, they are both awake, eager to pass some remarks.

“What do you make of this dude? He sure was a mess earlier.”

“I know, right? Have you noticed he’s wearing mithril? He wasn’t when we left.”

“Aye. The armor wasn’t even his anymore. Thorin asked me to put it back whence it came.”

“Better not ask how Bilbo got hold of it. We’ll assume he didn’t steal it, and leave it at that.”

They laugh.

“And another thing,” Bofur says. “For all the halfling cried a river today, he doesn’t appear sad anymore. Any thoughts on that?”

“Maybe he really wanted to get out of here. Or maybe his happiness bears relation to the armor. It’s no cheap trinket, you know? He could buy the whole Shire with it.”

“Or maybe it’s that Thorin gave it to him - again.”

“That would be hilarious, if he did.”

“A last minute hack to right all the wrongs he committed. Nicely done, Thorin.”

There’s more to wonder about. There’s a new air about Bilbo, they noticed when he prepared for sleep: a hint of freedom, almost a kingly bearing as he spread his bedroll and stretched over the cool earth. What that’s about, they totally know not. Nor do they know that today, Bilbo won an important fight. The enemy, who looked suspiciously like himself, he struggled all night to overcome; and in the aftermath he found something he’d lost. He would call it courage; for one day, it sufficed: he revealed a piece of his heart.

That could account for his blissful smile as Bilbo sleeps under the stars, in Dale; that, or he’s dreaming pleasurable dreams.

 

Chapter 4

Notes:

Thank you so much for reading, and many thanks to all who left kudos, comments, bookmarked or subscribed to this work! I loved writing this story and sharing it with you ❤️

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Farewell, Master Burglar. Go back to your books, and your armchair. You did what only a true friend would do. I was too blind to see it. Forgive me...

This memory hangs, suspended in empty space, among courage and wisdom and I am glad to have shared in your perils, in a place Thorin can’t reach anymore.

Yet he is learning courage. A new form, embodied in the little note and the acorn Bilbo left him, though it didn’t bring anything back except It’s a poor prize to take back to the Shire. He’s never felt so sad as in that moment. Why? Perhaps at the realization that Bilbo had something Thorin would never have.

I miss the way you looked at me... Take it, Thorin Oakenshield...

Yet Bilbo didn’t take it to the Shire. Bilbo left it with him.

and if it means nothing, forget me.

He holds on, rides faster in the dark while Thorin’s mind spins, awake now from its drifting. He is lost in this endless searching, as infinite as the stars, where he doesn’t know what the acorn means, and Bilbo said there was never time.

Bilbo’s note... not a direct declaration, but it retained the passion that helped write Kíli’s love letter. Already, then, Thorin wanted: his desire was born, flaming, restless, that Bilbo’s words of longing be for him.

His fingers stroke the acorn, caress it with the passion of last night. The fire still burns. He brings it to his lips, trails it over his chin, his neck, his body, and whispers Take me to him, be my light in this world of darkness. Can this acorn reach Bilbo now as he’s settling somewhere for sleep. Can it close the distance between them. Will Bilbo hear him call his name, will the wind hold the sound as it sways in the air, small in the seed’s tiny home yet immense in the vastness of stars.

I loved you, didn’t I?...

Plant your trees... the wind cries back to him, words Thorin suddenly remembers, that he had said to Bilbo when they parted. Thorin had been content, then: the sadness was gone, or perhaps he didn’t have enough strength to sustain it. The power he still held was given to the only thing that mattered.

I loved you.

 

Later that night, Dwalin’s watch is disturbed.

His king appears out of the blue, riding as he did when determined to take out the pale orc. His eyes pierce the surroundings, and there’s that fierce look, that precision in his movements: someone must have declared war, again.

“Where is Master Baggins?” instead, Thorin asks.

Deflated, Dwalin points to the remains of the campfire they made. Bilbo’s bedroll is not far from it.

The most awkward conversation ensues.

“Before you go there, I must ask what your intentions are.”

“I just want to be near him. I will speak with him when he wakes.”

“Except your order was protect Master Baggins at all costs. He should never leave my or Bofur’s sight, you said.”

“Right. And your point is?”

Dwalin clears his throat. “Well. As you may recall, half way through the quest you developed... that thing. A gleam in your eyes like a terrible need, when you looked at the halfling. You’re sporting the same look tonight. Whatever you’re planning to do, you are going to ask for his consent?”

“Half way through the quest, did you say?”

“Aye. There were times I thought you were going to devour him right then and there. So you see, one must secure Master Baggins’ protection.”

“That’s a good goal,” Thorin murmurs absent-mindedly, his eyes still searching for the coveted spot. “Thank you, Dwalin. Now, in the interest of privacy, I hereby order you to change your watch post.”

Dwalin sighs and walks over, turning his back to the campfire. “Fine,” though Thorin has not addressed the consent part.

 

Bilbo is asleep. He is lying down, face up, his body spread on the raw soil, his bedroll forgotten. A smile on his face, carefree and content and... something else. He’s having a perfect dream.

A blanket lies next to him: he must have pushed it aside during sleep. Thorin rushes to cover him; his gaze is caught by something soft glimmering above Bilbo’s coat.

The mithril last night he so intimately possessed... Can Bilbo feel the love he poured into it. Can he feel Thorin is here; that he came for him.

His eyes wander all over Bilbo’s body. Touching him - what it would be like - just a flicker, to rest a hand on his shoulder, or Bilbo’s hair... can he touch Bilbo’s hair. Thorin settles on parting his coat, revealing the soft, delicate armor, beautiful in the moonlight, spread out on him like a rayment of stars. His fingers trace the intricate links; under them, there is nothing but skin.

He hasn’t come here to negotiate, or even to ask; he has come here to act. Yet to have this time, where he can almost visualize Bilbo’s dreams, so unhindered, so unexpected... it makes Thorin’s gaze linger longer.

Dwalin is right: he could be slightly confused about what “the right thing” means now.

He brings his forehead close to the mithril mail, and rests it there for a while, barely touching, Thorin’s hair spread all over it. In the starlight steel rings cling onto his hair, and shine like a chain of pearls shot across an ocean. They merge into a dream. His lips caress the silver steel softly, once, twice... Bilbo’s body relaxes into the gentle touch, breathing soft sounds of pleasure. And Thorin resists no longer.

...In Bilbo’s dream, there is a warm wind that rustles through his hair, glides over his neck and the exposed skin above his coat, seeking his favorite places, his innermost secrets; it undoes his belt, parts his coat and invades him with an irresistible warmth. And that wind is now hair, dark velvety hair that flows above the silver steel rings and mingles with them, each ring a tiny drop like rain upon the moon, a reflection in an empty pool that slowly fills with water. It’s the first Spring rain, and each drop is a word Bilbo has long wanted to say. How much I love you you don’t know... in my thoughts you alone are... What do I mean to you?... Then he feels lips descend on his shirt, and with them something pours into his skin, invisible, small, like water, warm drops designed to subtly penetrate the armor through a myriad of entry points, each one offering a different sensation, each drop a thrill, a shiver, a world of pleasure from a love still restrained.

This can never be him. Yet in dreams Bilbo has that power, to will Thorin to be here, where Bilbo can touch, cradle his head in his hands... where Bilbo is waiting to give himself to him.

“Thorin...” Bilbo’s voice whispers through his dream. His lips search for that warmth that infused his soul, his body; it penetrates deeper into him. And Bilbo tastes Thorin like in a dream, daring and carefree, and this person he wanted against loss of all hope kisses him back lightly, dizzily, and then unrestrained; as if he will stay, going nowhere.

He wakes to holding in his hands this beauty immense, that has a name, can only have one name. Thorin above him, his hair falling on Bilbo’s ear and shoulder, and

“You’re here. Thorin... Thorin, you’re here.”

Bilbo’s joy cannot be contained. Except he has let Thorin into his dreams: this Thorin, who, who would have known, arrived in Dale in the middle of the night. He would take back his courage, now, if he could. The courage to gift Thorin those foolish farewell things; to fantasize about him.

Yet Thorin’s hand rests on the mithril still, as the hand in the dream did; and Thorin runs his fingers through his hair. Bilbo’s eyes look down, not able to bear to meet his, uncertain; actually, embarrassed an inordinate amount.

“Tell me we have time,” Thorin whispers. And Bilbo feels fingers on his chin lift his head gently, and Thorin kisses him again, for real this time. “Tell me I am not too late.”

Bilbo watches him in disbelief. Thorin holds the most genuine expression, so open and wanting, so full of anticipation and desire. “If you have come here to talk, it may soon be too late,” it occurs to him, and before he realizes he said it out loud Thorin’s lips are on him again.

Bilbo closes his eyes and surrenders. Thorin is still above him, above the water in that brilliant pool that lies beneath the entrance of a cave. Together they dive... New drops of water send shivers through Bilbo’s skin, and he feels invaded with beautiful jewels of red, blue and green that splash against his skin and dissolve into the silver steel rings. Bilbo doesn’t know what they are. Nor that for Thorin, the gems are out of reach: they merge toward the bottom of the pool, seducing him, inviting him to chase them. They rise to the surface, blinding him with their multicolored glow.

He tries to collect them: they deny him, yet all the more unravel before him. Only Bilbo has the power to claim, to command, to release them.

Who am I, Thorin?... Bilbo breathes under him, the one memory Thorin has found a name for. My love, Thorin’s mouth presses heatedly on his lips, his neck, his chest, his everything. You’re my love... They kiss passionately, urgently, intoxicated with each other’s power, an overflow of heat that radiates from their bodies as much as from these words upon their lips. Under the stars they burn, two bright, all-consuming flames that chase, split and merge above the water under the cover of darkness; two souls that hunger for each other wildly, violently, never satisfied.

In a pool enclosed by walls red, blue and green, it was there that I lost you, Thorin voices when they part for an instant to behold this impossible reality. Their gazes devour each other, unsatiated, as their bodies never cease to crave the touch, the closeness. And his One, his heart answers You never lost me... you have lost yourself. I am here, Thorin... my heart, my home.

...They are in Dale again, by the campfire. Bilbo breaks out of Thorin’s grasp and reverses positions, pinning him to the ground.

“I kept everything. Each memory of you and me.” He senses Thorin’s fragileness, his need to be forgiven once again. Only he can return Thorin to himself. “I can tell you everything. From the beginning.” “I would like that,” says Thorin, not clear if he means now or for the rest of their lives. And the first thing Bilbo does is lift his arms in a request, silently asking Thorin to undress him. Thorin heeds slowly and removes his armor, still attending to him with the gentlest kisses, careful as if not to break the fragile treasure hidden underneath. When he is finished, Bilbo holds the mithril between them.

“Tonight I thought of you, and what you have lost. And I... I called upon all the things I remember, to be imprinted here. But... something else was already imprinted. Something I would not want to part with.”

and through the armor’s veil they see each other, know each other, truly, their love complete, absolute, clear and pure. And Bilbo wills his memories to travel through, between them, and penetrate Thorin’s mind. In bits and pieces images come back, fleeting scenes of the sun rise on the Carrock, the moon illumining the Hidden Door, the One who said I’ll vouch for him in Laketown, the voice that broke the spell beneath the Mountain and led Thorin out of his solitude. And when the armor is lifted the images fade, yet his love for Bilbo lives and will live again, and in this starlight new memories will be made.

Thorin is changed. It’s not memory, but a visceral longing that has been locked behind the veil of forgetness: it comes back to him in waves, overtaking. I want you. The watching from afar, the want, the fear and longing. The greedy, insatiable need, always pushed aside for the Quest’s sake. Tonight he may slightly give in; but in his mind, Thorin fell long ago. He hears Dwalin’s warning, fears his promise to Mahal will be undone by this desire that consumes him whole. He will not wait. He will not ask for consent. He will take what is his, possess, claim the halfling for his own.

He commands, resolute and fearless, everything he has waited for, this impossible treasure that offers itself to him, so bright, vivid and real and long overdue. He wants it with his whole being. He demands it. He wants to feel the answer in the way Bilbo’s body responds, arches to align with his at every touch; to feel Bilbo’s surrender. To taste this beautiful body magnetized to him, draw out his need and hear him scream in pleasure. To lead him there, where no one else has known love, and to reinvent love every time after. To need to hear Yours, again, Thorin, I am yours, and know no one and nothing can ever tear them apart. To abandon himself for the first time, and cleave to this being that is no longer Bilbo, or him: whole, for the first time.

 

...On the cool earth Bilbo’s body lies, trembling, drifting between pleasure and a state of perfect peace. His lips move imperceptibly, in an attempt to speak. Perhaps he means to ensure he did not dream this, what just happened, though the world lost its weight, its shape, its color for a while.

He wonders if he could fall asleep like this; if he could trust this was more than a dream.

Then Thorin speaks: he asks something completely unlike him.

“Would you like to continue here? Or in Erebor?”

Bilbo finds he can talk easily now. “Excuse me. I would think the proper way to phrase that is Would you like to do this again.”

Thorin pierces him with all-knowing eyes, uncompromising.

“I recall you saying, I don’t need “the right thing” from you, Thorin. Are you telling me you want the proper way?”

Bilbo regards him in surprise, part amusement and part admiration. It’s too soon to tease him, but You have a good memory does cross his mind.

“All right then. Yes, I would like to continue. In Erebor, preferably.” His hands stroke Thorin’s hair adoringly, like an absolution.

 

It is the morning after.

Thorin has done the first not-exactly-right-thing since he returned from Mahal’s halls. He slept in; did not show up for today’s first business meeting.

Good news? He is in Erebor. He arrived at dawn, bringing Bilbo with him. In the king’s quarters they fell asleep, whispering soft endearments in each other’s arms.

Bilbo is still in bed. Thorin is dressed for court, but it’s not clear if he’s intent on leaving: for now he lingers by Bilbo’s side. He takes his love’s hands in his, and Bilbo braces himself for the moment of truth.

“When I went to the Halls of my Fathers, I asked my Maker to let Fíli and Kíli live. And he did. In exchange for it, and for my life, I promised him I would do the right thing. I would treat my life as a chance to pay for my sins. Bilbo... I wanted to live so I can do the right thing.”

“I think you’ve done that a hundred times now.”

“I need to keep doing it. Every day, until the end.”

It sounds like an apology, or it could be a question. Bilbo won’t risk reading into it.

“I love you. I have always, even as memories left me. I will always love you.”

Bilbo curls his head on Thorin’s chest, overwhelmed and relieved. He likes this morning-after Thorin very much.

“And I want... I want to be with you so much that I would give this all up, my kingdom, my crown, to follow you to your beloved home, if it weren’t for the promise I made.”

Maybe there isn’t a question. Bilbo breaks from their embrace to study him, absorb every word if there should be any more. Thorin appears to falter, but not for long. From his Durin blue tunic he produces a tiny object, a seed that is now worth the entire price of the Shire; he places it in Bilbo’s hand.

“This was yours once. I’ve wondered if you still wish to plant it.”

Ah, yes. There is a question. It’s not Bilbo’s imagination. Thorin actually found a way to ask.

“I do wish it. I’m going to plant it in my garden. In Erebor.”

Thorin envelops him with the warmest gaze, and in an instant his lips are on Bilbo’s hand, burning. There Thorin rests his head for a long time, and cries for the first time in his new life.

“I love you, Thorin. With all that you are. The promise you made... I might have resented it at first, but now I can’t imagine you without it. And I would love to help you fulfill it.”

Thorin regards him intently, as if set on handling unfinished business. Silently asks, in a way only Thorin knows how; in a way only Bilbo can answer.

“More than the Shire, I love you.” Though Bilbo can’t imagine it’s important, not as much as a king being in touch with his feelings: the most handsome and selfless king Arda has seen.

“I want to stay with you.”

But it turns out his words are important: at least enough to make Thorin miss his second meeting.

 

...A deal is a deal.

Thorin never remembered everything.

Mahal did take pity and gave him back one memory: the farewell on the ice, that Thorin asked for. He rightly guessed Bilbo will never have the heart to tell it.

But there are other things besides the past. There is taking time off to accompany Bilbo to the Shire, because after all Bilbo has to pack a few things before moving across the world. There is reliving the quest in reverse, and pausing over each moment together, until Thorin can say he’s lived it at least once. New memories, on the way back to Erebor.

There is the book Bilbo will write, with all of this and more things that happened. There is their wedding, their first night, all the nights that followed, and the love ever after. A love that Mahal turns to, curious to check in on sometimes: without fail, he marvels. If there was a time he feared the halfling merely stole Thorin’s heart; if he tried to test that heart, to see if it would break, and who could fix it; if he doubted a hobbit can love as completely as can a dwarf: let it be known there is no more fear, no more doubt. Just amazement, a trace of guilt Mahal can’t shake off, and the admission he was doubly wrong. Thorin’s love never died, will not die. It endures, forever nourished by the mere existence of his One, who never ceased to love him in return.

 

Notes:

I wanted to write a short story about lost memories, a topic very profound and inspiring to me! I hope you enjoyed it. For a more in-depth treatment of this topic, feel free to check out my story "An Eternity Of Love".