Chapter Text
The battle is over. The sky clears, the forces of evil retreat. Eagles fly home, Elves return to their forest, and the Dwarves kneel on the ice, beyond sorrow and grief.
Their king is dead. He has already reached Mahal’s Halls.
The day began with one, two, three mistakes. He almost killed someone he loved more than life, chose avoidable war over peace, left his cousin to fight alone.
It ended as he led Fíli and Kíli, the light of his eyes, into a death trap. The day, and Thorin’s life, ended then.
Fíli and Kíli stand at the door to the Halls; they arrived before him. Thorin would speak to them, if he knew words that could...
There are none. Action is the only thing Thorin knows: to move forward, even when you’ve committed a wrong. To have the courage to act.
So he acts. It starts with a promise, to ask Mahal to undo this somehow, to change the course of events, because this is wrong. Stay here, he commands, and enters alone.
“Please, let them go back. Let them live their youth, see the Mountain restored. Allow Fíli to rule in my stead, and Kíli to enjoy romance with the she-elf.”
“And you?” asks Mahal curiously, his eyes scrutinizing Thorin up and down, as if suspecting him of a hidden plan.
“I will toil endless hours in these Halls. I will be your slave.”
“Ah. But you also wanted to live, did you not?”
He avoids the answer. What he wished, if anything, for himself. So many years have passed since he last wanted to live. Yet recently, it seems, he had tried.
“If I could go back, it would be for one thing: to serve my kingdom day and night. To make amends with those that I’ve wronged. I promise you this.”
Mahal waves him away. “Your cousin Dáin can do all of that, you know. On the other hand...” This could be fun, Thorin reads on his Maker’s face. He waits, not daring to say any more.
“My child, I could be wrong, but I got the impression it was not just Kili who formed a special attachment in this quest.”
“That is of little matter.”
“Indeed? Then this should be easy for you. Here is what I propose: I will let all three of you go back. You will be king, and do what you deem to be right, under one condition: that you forget that you ever loved.”
“I...” Wait. How can one...
“I can make it happen. You’ll still remember the person you loved and everything you knew about them, except for those memories connected with love. The moment you knew you’d fallen for them. If you confessed or expressed your feelings in some way. If you kissed... though it’s not looking like you got that far. All that will be forgotten, as will any times you thought of this person with love.”
Mahal searches Thorin deeply, questioningly, and Thorin searches back in return.
“Why? Why would you have me forget?”
“So you can fulfill the promise you have made just now: to do the right thing.”
“And I can’t keep my promise and love at the same time?”
“You haven’t shown great skill at multitasking as of late, Thorin, son of Thrain. One might say you got distracted by love. Perhaps with fewer things to keep track of, you’ll be able to focus better.”
Feelings can come back, can they not? Maybe they don’t depend on memories in the first place. If the one he loves is still present in his life, Thorin will fall in love again. Such it is that he reasons, quickly, without second guessing. It’s a small price to pay for Fíli and Kíli’s life; for hoping to redeem his own honor.
“I accept. Thank you.”
To the left of the great entrance there is a rectangular pool surrounded by three walls adorned with glittering gems in green, red and blue, reflecting in the clear sparkling water. There Mahal leads him, and Thorin finds it strange his Maker should have gone to such lengths to cleanse one’s memory of love, but, he supposes, Mahal has seen a lot in his life.
Before saying goodbye, he briefly revisits. The moment he knew he was in love. The first time he tried to express it. The last. Few such memories were created. Maybe they will come back, maybe someone will remind him of them. The rest of his treasury of love are just thoughts - what he wished or planned, how he viewed this person in the privacy of his mind. All such thoughts will be gone, but Thorin is not too concerned: with one look at him it will all come back, he is sure.
...and as he bathes in the pool of forgetness, for each memory he loses contact with a crack is made in the walls and a gem turns to grey as it falls, losing its shine until it dissolves in the water. At the end, no gems are left in the walls. How many were there? Hundreds, at least. He wonders what they were for, what happened to them.
“Take your nephews and go now, my child. You won’t remember our conversation, save for the promise you’ve made. Go, and do the right thing.”
The joy of the Dwarves in the Mountain at the sons of Durin’s return is immense. One by one, they embrace their king and his heirs, marveling that no one seems hurt.
Bilbo comes too, greets them with a happy, if hesitant look. Thorin hugs him solidly, fondly; apologizes again for his conduct, rescinds his order of banishment, reassures Bilbo he’s welcome to stay. Bilbo appears to want to say something, too; but before he gets a chance Thorin’s eyes fall upon the V of his coat, where a bright garment emerges, of unbelievable worth.
“How did you come by that?...”
“What?” Bilbo asks in confusion, looking around himself.
“The armor you are wearing. Did someone give it to you?”
It’s unexpected, that is all; that Bilbo should have come across such a precious thing. Thorin is curious. Well, maybe more. He wonders who has claimed Bilbo so boldly, so quickly, while he was out cold. He asks casually, nicely, careful to keep in check any hint of greed. There is none: the only hint is of a strange feeling, jealousy unforeseen.
Bilbo laughs nervously; tries to, more like.
“Did someone give it to me? You could say that. But...” he proceeds to remove his coat, “I’m happy to return it. The battle is over now, so. I can’t imagine I’m going to need it.” He takes the mithril off, and Thorin’s thoughts change: it’s good someone took care to protect him in war.
“You are entitled to one fourteenth of the treasure. And I hardly need add that, for your brave deeds, you can pick anything out of the hoard. If this is what you want, it is yours.”
“It is not. In fact, given some of my deeds, it is appropriate to return it,” says Bilbo, pressing the mithril into Thorin’s hands with no second thought, though a wave of indecision swirls around his lips, not for what he should do, but for what he should say.
“I am glad to see you well, Thorin. I don’t believe I will need any other reward,” Bilbo says with a quiet resolve, and departs. And Thorin’s mind never strays too far from him: how beautiful he looked in that armor. He wishes he could have admired him a while longer.
“Put this back in the armory, Dwalin.” He turns to the Company, only to see them regard Thorin with jaws dropped in shock. “What?”
There is some confusion among the dwarves as to what actually passed. It’s not clear if Thorin asked for the mithril back, or Bilbo rejected his gift. Dwalin says, if Thorin did ask for it back, he was within his rights to do so. Hopefully this marks the end of heartbreak at the hobbit’s hand, heartbreak he could observe while Bilbo betrayed his friend and then stood there to witness his public humiliation from a few feet away.
“I think you’re being a bit hard on Bilbo, brother,” observes Balin.
“Then you tell me: where is his affection for Thorin?”
“I thought I saw it in his tears. After the battle.”
“You’d have to be made of stone not to cry...” scoffs Dwalin. Balin chuckles. “Ah, forget it. You just wait and see. The hobbit will leave come Spring, and in time Thorin will be nothing more to him than a good tale to tell.”
Fíli and Kíli opt for the theory that Bilbo returned the gift. Whether he did out of remorse, or rejecting something grand like a courting attempt, they don’t know; nor will they prod their Uncle for answers. Everyone decides to be grateful Thorin is alive and of sound mind now, and will not interfere with his peace.
Thus life continues on, with the king taking his rightful place on the throne and beginning rebuilding his home, working to strengthen alliances, welcome new dwarves into Erebor, pouring endless hours into making it livable once again. He spares no effort; he forgets himself.
There’s something crushing about Thorin’s attitude after his miraculous return, Bilbo thinks. Everything is so all right with him: no more impulses towards anger, every action, every word carefully said, with an eye for good, for doing good and staying good and never falling down again. He never seems to need anything; and that, more than anything else, makes Bilbo feel out of place.
Sometimes, late in the evenings, the Company retreat to a small hall, where they drink by the fireplace and tell stories. Often times, like tonight, Kíli talks of the elf Tauriel. She has gone home for now; he is growing impatient. He’s never written a love letter in his life, but thinks that will help speed her return.
“You appear to be skilled with words, Bilbo. Might you help me with writing this letter?” he asks. Fíli is there, and Thorin too, pouring over a new treaty Thranduil has sent him, to be signed in the morning.
“I’m... not sure,” answers Bilbo with that hint of sadness Thorin has noticed lately, on the rare moments when their eyes meet. Bilbo usually tries to look cheerful, but there’s more, something unsaid, unresolved. “I may be good with words, but I seem to fail at love. Nevertheless, I can try to help.” And Thorin cannot help overhear a few lines Bilbo offers, with no preparation, out of the blue.
Dearest Tauriel,
Why have you not come back to me? Every day I await your return... Has King Thranduil forbidden you from leaving the Woodland Realm? You must find a way of seeing me again. My life didn’t begin until I saw your face... My one waking thought is of being with you...
Kíli is all delight.
“That’s gold, Bilbo! Wow! And you say you are not skilled at love?”
Thorin’s heart skips a beat. This does not sound like someone who’s just helping out a friend. Bilbo must be in love. A person in this Mountain, someone he met on the road... Keep it together. Thranduil will be here tomorrow. Oh, Mahal, don’t let it be Thranduil.
Thorin needs to focus if he’s to fulfill the promise he made. Yet he can’t help gaze at Bilbo some more, and wonder who this “gold” is really for, who may have stirred such passion in his heart.
The next day, Thranduil is led to the Throne Room. Thorin bows to him graciously and offers the gems of Lasgalen, with no mention of payment. After the Elvenking’s eyes bathe sufficiently in their magical glow, they finally take in his surroundings: his host before him, some of the Company’s dwarves, the brave Halfling... the throne, and the King’s Jewel above it.
“The Heart of the Mountain,” Thranduil remarks, quite mesmerized by its beauty. “Not long ago I’ve heard it called by a different name. While I had my doubts at the time, I believe it finally to be true, and let me say, it looks gorgeous above Your Majesty’s throne. Your heart. It does suit you well.”
“I thank you, but wish to make a correction: the Arkenstone has never held my heart,” says Thorin, and his eyes search every member of his audience. He wants everybody to know this. If there was any doubt - that he is here to make things right, to give all of himself, even to set this elf straight if he has to.
“I never wanted it for myself. A symbol that would help unite the seven armies of the Dwarves, that’s all it was to me. As a symbol it stands now, beautiful indeed, but it has no power over me.”
The Company beam at him proudly. Only one has tears in his eyes. “Excuse me,” Bilbo whispers faintly, and tears himself away from the small crowd, fleeing down the hall.
“Balin, Dori... show our honored guest around,” orders Thorin. “There is much that I wish him to see. I will be back.”
Bilbo is on the ramparts, sobbing.
“Master Baggins... What is the matter?”
Bilbo cannot speak, and Thorin moves closer, yet maintaining an appropriate distance.
“Will you not trust me enough to tell me what distresses you? If it’s anything in my power to resolve...”
“I hurt you,” Bilbo lets out in anguish. “I hurt you more than I could have imagined.”
“When did you hurt me?”
“Here. Here on this wall, when I told you I gave away the stone - your Heart, I called it, and... and now you’re standing here, healed, and good, and... well, more than good. Kingly, handsome as always, majestic... it’s wonderful to see. And it turns out I was far more wrong than I thought. When I predicted you’d give anything in return for your heart.”
“Please,” Thorin pleads uncertainly. “You don’t need...”
“I don’t know how to undo what I did. At the time, if it had helped prevent a senseless war, my deed would have seemed justified. But it helped with nothing. A battle still occurred, and at the end there were more casualties than I could endure to see in a hundred lifetimes. So what did I achieve? Only this: I hurt you.”
“If it is any consolation, I don’t remember being hurt.”
“You don’t?”
“No. But if I was hurt, I deserved it,” says Thorin, suddenly overcome with a feeling of warmth. “Master Baggins... I would not have you spend valuable time sweating over this. I would have you feel joy in the renewal around you. This Mountain, pulsing with life once again. The sun stretching over the horizon. The days growing longer. Do you not rejoice in the coming of Spring?”
“You called me Bilbo before.”
Thorin is silent. Trying to comprehend something as if in darkness, without a map, frustrated to have lost his way. Please, forget these dark thoughts, he wanted to say, yet he tries to remember as he leans on the wall. Why is it he can’t recall calling him by this name.
“Thorin?”
Bilbo stands next to him, close this time, too close for his own comfort yet doesn’t seem to care.
“I never know how to tell you this. So much time has passed, that perhaps it is meaningless now, but I wanted to tell you, on that day, when I saw you react. I regret the way I handled the Arkenstone. I know very well that through my actions I lost something that would have been of greatest value to me. There are no words for how much I regret that part. But even more I regret hurting you.”
“Are you saying... you wanted that mithril coat after all? If you want it, it’s yours,” says Thorin, whose understanding of “of greatest value” must differ a great deal from the Halfling’s; how else can he explain the are you stupid look levelled at him right now.
“The mithril? No. I told you, it’s not that. I don’t know how to describe what I lost, but it has to do with you.”
Thorin is always busy: Bilbo gets more and more that impression. Part of why continuing this discussion is a serious blunder is imposing on his expensive time. That is why Bilbo would like to run, if he could.
Strong hands grasp his shoulders firmly, yet ever so gently, as if Thorin is scared of his own design.
“Master Baggins. Bilbo.”
Bilbo closes his eyes in elation that tastes like fear, but even the fear tastes good, for it’s filled with memory and hopeful anticipation.
“Whatever it is you’ve lost... I want to know. When you find a way to express it, please share it with me.”
"All right." Bilbo looks in the distance, as if finally touched by a vision of Spring.
“I will be going home soon.” He mutters it mostly to himself, as an afterthought, perhaps wondering how much it truly matters, to reveal what he’s lost, when his time here is at an end.
Yet Thorin heard, and when he heard he felt a pain in his chest sharper than any blade.
“Your happiness is most important to me. If what you’ve lost is in my power to return, I will give it to you.”
This is not how Thorin meant to finish his request. In a reassurring, steady tone, not with voice cracking and feeling like he had to grasp the wall for control.
He was hurt, wasn’t he? Weeks ago, on this wall...
Does it matter?...
Bilbo was leaving then, too.
It hurts, and Thorin doesn’t know why.
He returns to the Throne Room, now devoid of company, takes off his black cloak and spreads it over the throne like a curtain. Then Thorin removes his crown and places it on the cloak. And he stares at these three, the throne, the Arkenstone and the crown - his, his and his - and three times do they magnify the emptiness in his heart. They are all that he ever wanted, yet they are not good enough. Not nearly enough to make Bilbo stay.
